{"count":1963,"results":[{"id":"49b9f0a8-299b-49bd-961c-d39ccd56be25","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-28T03:33:22","year":2015,"place":"ar","dataset":"postcodes","exists":"Unsure","digital":"Unsure","public":"Unsure","online":"Unsure","free":"Unsure","machinereadable":"Unsure","bulk":"Unsure","openlicense":"Unsure","uptodate":"Unsure","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Post code search service does not comply with 2015 index requirements. ","details":"Argentina has an up to date zipcodes dataset on this website: \r\nhttps://www.correoargentino.com.ar/formularios/cpa\r\n\r\nHowever, it does not contain the relevant Geodata, and it is in a separate dataset. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Yamila García","reviewer":"Codrina Maria Ilie","score":0},{"id":"286cd52d-0148-4b87-ac55-22a7eaf196e7","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-29T00:04:55","year":2015,"place":"pa","dataset":"water","exists":"Unsure","digital":"Unsure","public":"Unsure","online":"Unsure","free":"Unsure","machinereadable":"Unsure","bulk":"Unsure","openlicense":"Unsure","uptodate":"Unsure","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Approving submission, couldn't find data on water quality.","details":"","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"HAMZAH HAJI","reviewer":"Nisha Thompson","score":0},{"id":"88754a39-5310-4670-98a4-ef3e4df1fc40","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-08-02T12:31:30","year":2015,"place":"uz","dataset":"statistics","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"https://www.stat.uz/en/","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"The State Committee for the Republic of Uzbekistan on Statistics","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Data are available but not regularly updated and not open.","details":"[GDP][1] up to 2015\r\n\r\n[Unemployment][2] for 2012.\r\n\r\n[Population][3] up to 2014. \r\n\r\n\r\n [1]: https://1.%20https://www.stat.uz/en/88-interaktivnye-uslugi/773-macroeconomic-indicators-of-the-republic-of-uzbekistan\r\n [2]: https://gender.stat.uz/en/main-indicators/labor/economically-active-population/171-female-to-male-ratio-of-total-employment-in-the-formal-sector-of-the-economy-in-2012\r\n [3]: https://www.stat.uz/en/statinfo/demograficheskie-dannye","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Diyora Kabulova","reviewer":"Zach Christensen","score":35},{"id":"6852bbc4-7fa6-4e6c-93e8-087f36726778","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-19T00:55:54","year":2015,"place":"mx","dataset":"statistics","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www3.inegi.org.mx/sistemas/productos/default.aspx?c=265&s=inegi&upc=702825046385&pf=Prod&ef=&f=2&cl=0&tg=8&pg=0","format":" CSV, PDF, XLSX","licenseurl":"https://www.inegi.org.mx/terminos/terminos_info.aspx","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Instituto Nacional de Estadistica y geografia - INEGI","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Data available in multiple formats and licensed to be open.","details":"Data is accessible in a wide variety of formats and can be downloaded in bulk. \r\n\r\nRight now the terms of use clearly state that the only requirement is the source attribution.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"Enrique Zapata","reviewer":"Zach Christensen","score":100},{"id":"7b8acd9b-7321-451e-89b6-96c6cfe646e1","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-01T15:51:44","year":2015,"place":"gt","dataset":"budget","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.minfin.gob.gt/index.php/proyecto-de-presupuesto","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Proyecto de Presupuesto General de Ingresos y Egresos del Estado","publisher":"Ministerio de Finanzas Públicas","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"I could not find a license, therefore, i have changed the license section to NO. ","details":"PDFs available\r\n\r\nThe actual link to the 2016 budget proyect is: \r\n https://www.minfin.gob.gt/archivos/proypre2016/inicio.htm\r\nThe form didn´t accept it. The link on the form takes you to the place were all the proyects for past years included the one for 2016, are listed. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Iscelle Marsicovetere","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":45},{"id":"423e3630-9ef3-4e53-acee-9fdc3848a5c8","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-01T16:45:54","year":2015,"place":"mx","dataset":"emissions","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://sinaica.ine.gob.mx/","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"checked","details":"Information can be accessed in different portals. Most information can is gathered int the National Institute of Ecology (https://sinaica.ine.gob.mx) though machine readable files commonly do not follow a database layout. Data is clustered at a state level and divided in different time-lapse data clusters. Most files are accessible in: https://www.inecc.gob.mx/calaire-presentacion/546-calaire-indicadores The Ministry of Environment's porta contains similar information:\r\nhttps://app1.semarnat.gob.mx/dgeia/clave_2010/clave/indicadores/ibi_apps/ind_clave_05.html\r\nhttps://app1.semarnat.gob.mx/dgeia/clave_2010/clave/indicadores/ibi_apps/ind_clave_06.html\r\nhttps://app1.semarnat.gob.mx/dgeia/clave_2010/clave/indicadores/ibi_apps/ind_clave_08.html Also, data is also identified under research center's web sites, such as Mexico's National Autonomous University: https://www.atmosfera.unam.mx/procca/Ozono.php Furthermore, SEMARNAT's Pollution Transfer and Emissions registry (RETC) contains a national database of air, water, ground and underground contains record of pollution sources and environmental assessments. RETC's landing page can be accesed here: https://www.semarnat.gob.mx/temas/gestionambiental/calidaddelaire/Paginas/retc.aspx and data (not in bulk) accessed here: https://app1.semarnat.gob.mx/retc/retc/index.php No license information found, which means it's not an open license. \r\n\r\nFound bulk data for air measurements here but it's not timely (until end of 2008): https://www2.inecc.gob.mx/dgicurg/calaire/tend/horarias/concentra.php\r\n\r\n------\r\nFor 2014's review, it was noted that the main data has not been updated since September 6th 2013 16:17hrs. \r\nINECC's web site (https://www.inecc.gob.mx/acerca/831-pol-privacidad) does not use an open license. Under it's privacy statement, it indicates \"Some rights reserved\" and in the policy legend does not explain the terms and conditions for the use of the data besides explicitly prohibiting parcial or total reuse of content for commercial purposes: \"Queda estrictamente prohibido la reproducción total o parcial con fines comerciales de los datos, gráficos e información contenidos en esta página, por cualquier medio y de cualquier forma salvo para fines bibliográficos que reconozcan al autor de los documentos publicados en este sitio.\"\r\n\r\nFor 2015: There is no air quality data to other regions beside Mexico City. The information in the portal above does not contain the relevant pollutants. Therefore, I indicated the data as does not exist. \r\nThe link to Mexico City air quality data - https://www.aire.df.gob.mx/default.php\r\n\r\n\r\nadd by yaron \r\nthe data provided on a timely and up to date basis \r\nits can been seem here-i didnt find the page That the information is taken [link][1]\r\nalso the site list Mexico is a Country with online data \r\n[link][2]\r\n\r\n\r\n [1]: https://aqicn.org/city/mexico/nuevo-leon/garcia/\r\n [2]: https://aqicn.org/sources/","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Mor Rubinstein","reviewer":"yar michl","score":45},{"id":"e5d42d97-76d9-4785-8db1-a281f29e775a","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-10-30T02:25:37","year":2014,"place":"co","dataset":"timetables","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://datosabiertoscolombia.cloudapp.net/frm/catalogo/frmCatalogo.aspx?dsId=20771","format":"EXCEL, TEXTO","licenseurl":"https://datosabiertoscolombia.cloudapp.net/frm/buscador/frmBusquedaAvanzada.aspx?bs=BARRANQUILLA","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"TRANSMETRO \tcomunicaciones@transmetro.gov.co","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Information only for Barranquilla, not on a national level. ","details":"Es importante aclarar que se sugiere suministrar esta información de\ncarácter regional teniendo en cuenta que la información de Transporte no está centralizada ya que es potestad de las entidades que administran los sistemas y las entidades territoriales definir los horarios","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"Gomezina L","reviewer":"Oscar Montiel","score":100},{"id":"7c267826-a5e5-477e-a216-57e9bdcf1630","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-11-09T15:37:18","year":2015,"place":"mx","dataset":"water","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Unsure","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Unsure","url":"https://www.agua.org.mx/index.php/biblioteca-tematica/usos-del-agua/uso-domestico-del-agua-urbano-y-rural/1280-metodos-de-purificacion-de-agua?start=10","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Water Quality Indicators","publisher":"National Water Commission","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"After searching several of the water related portals of which there are many with a diverse amount of information, there is no downloadable dataset with all the parameters. ","details":"There are several websites that have references to water quality data. \r\n\r\nThere are several more updated reports that have water quality assessments of various water body sources. \r\n\r\nhttps://www.conagua.gob.mx/CONAGUA07/Publicaciones/Publicaciones/EAM2014.pdf\r\n\r\nThere is also the water data portal:\r\nhttps://201.116.60.25/sina/Default5.aspx?tab=2\r\n\r\nAnd also water documents library:\r\nhttps://www.agua.org.mx/index.php/biblioteca-tematica/usos-del-agua/uso-domestico-del-agua-urbano-y-rural/1280-metodos-de-purificacion-de-agua?start=10\r\n\r\nHowever, I can't find any downloadable dataset of the parameters. \r\n","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Ricardo Pizzuto","reviewer":"Nisha Thompson","score":20},{"id":"b62277ef-f40e-41e9-a975-f5d1c05a06c2","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-27T02:41:31","year":2015,"place":"cr","dataset":"map","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Unsure","online":"Yes","free":"Unsure","machinereadable":"Unsure","bulk":"Unsure","openlicense":"Unsure","uptodate":"Unsure","url":"https://www.snitcr.go.cr/visor/?lang=en","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Registro Nacional","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"There is an online viewer, but I can't even find a save as PDF option, it is not clear if one can get the actual data and re-use it, so everything but the existance of digital data online is unsure in my opinion. The data from the National University apears to be only in JPG files.","details":"This is the map available by the National Register System. However, there is a different dataset from the National University, available in open source in the link: https://www.mapoteca.geo.una.ac.cr/index.php/home.html ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Alejandro Sanabria","reviewer":"Gil Zaretzer","score":15},{"id":"c9d94e1c-0ff3-47e7-af5f-8c2ebc45ba3a","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-10-13T18:22:43","year":2014,"place":"cl","dataset":"timetables","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://datos.gob.cl/datasets/ver/1587","format":"GTSF","licenseurl":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/cl/","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"GTSF Transantiago feed: Transantiago operation Programme, in General Transit Feed Specification (GTSF) format, which includes daily information and services about location, stations, frequency and travel times for buses and subway.","publisher":"Undersecretary of Transportation. Contact: gtfsbeta@transantiago.cl","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Accepted with revisions.","details":"This data set only considers the transport system information of Santiago de Chile.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Daniela Tejada","score":100},{"id":"618df12a-0ef7-4a28-be84-93fc0bc31684","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-08-27T15:04:41","year":2015,"place":"cl","dataset":"emissions","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.mma.gob.cl/retc/1279/channel.html","format":"XLS,CSV","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"National Information System on Air Quality","publisher":"Ministry of Environment","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"checked","details":"all type of Pollutant is been monitoring except of VOCs","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Diego Ignacio","reviewer":"yar michl","score":70},{"id":"c1c12d2a-8a97-4dbb-a634-5f99d26757aa","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-27T01:11:38","year":2015,"place":"cr","dataset":"elections","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://tse.go.cr/zip/elecciones/eleccionescifras.zip","format":"Excel, PDF","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Elecciones en cifras 1953 - 2014","publisher":"Tribunal Supremo de Elecciones","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The submission does not meet the definition. As the submission says, data is available at higher levels of aggregation (in fact, for municipalities of up to 40.000 people).","details":"Results are disaggregated only at the national level and for provinces, not for smaller areas like cantons or districts. No license found on site.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"camila salazar","reviewer":"Kamil Gregor","score":70},{"id":"fa2b525c-87f5-4ede-adbd-8bcff571b86e","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-17T08:29:04","year":2015,"place":"cz","dataset":"companies","exists":"Yes","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Ministry of Justice","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"It is not possible to browse through the database or access data without providing a search term, therefore the registry does not qualify for most of the criteria.","details":"The data is available via a register - you can browse one company at a time and then download each listing as pdf. It is not possible to view company data unless a search term is inputted. \r\n\r\nLast year, there was an option to download machine readable data (XML) but last update is more than a year old. 2015 data are therefore available only via the search interface.\r\n\r\nAlso, the licence restricts commercial use https://or.justice.cz/ias/ui/download/licence_pro_pouzivani_zverejnenych_dat.pdf","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Michaela Rybičková","reviewer":"Rebecca Sentance","score":15},{"id":"880c7ec8-e5e8-48f3-be5c-6e368e879565","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-08-27T13:33:55","year":2015,"place":"cl","dataset":"elections","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.servel.cl/ss/site/resultadoselectorales.html","format":"Excel","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Historic Election Results: Includes Presidential, Senators, Deputies, and others from 1989 to 2013.","publisher":"Electoral Service - SERVEL","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The submission is correct.","details":"It doesn't have information about license or term of use. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Ahumada Abrigouis Alberto L","reviewer":"Kamil Gregor","score":70},{"id":"7ced0e66-f996-41d4-9882-d5b70231d1f5","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-16T14:08:32","year":2015,"place":"gt","dataset":"procurement","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.guatecompras.gt/","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Guatecompras","publisher":"Ministerio de Finanzas Públicas","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Could not replicate the bulk download. ","details":"guatecompras.gt operado por el Ministerio de Finanzas Públicas ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Joel Peñate","reviewer":"Georg Neumann","score":45},{"id":"646e1344-93dd-493d-90cf-94140d9f26e9","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-27T03:08:36","year":2015,"place":"cr","dataset":"health","exists":"Unsure","digital":"Unsure","public":"Unsure","online":"Unsure","free":"Unsure","machinereadable":"Unsure","bulk":"Unsure","openlicense":"Unsure","uptodate":"Unsure","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"This entry is uncomplete. Not information about the dataset, or link to check was found. ","details":"","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Alejandro Sanabria","reviewer":"Iris Palma","score":0},{"id":"20150c0e-9a00-48da-95eb-9275f33b4947","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-28T23:59:05","year":2015,"place":"pa","dataset":"statistics","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"https://www.contraloria.gob.pa/inec/","format":"PDF, XLS","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Panama Instituto Nacional de Estadistica y Censo (INEC)","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Data available but not regularly or with open license. ","details":"[GDP][1] data\r\n\r\n[Unemployment][2] data (up to 2014)\r\n\r\n[Population][3] data\r\n\r\n\r\n [1]: https://www.contraloria.gob.pa/inec/publicaciones/Publicaciones.aspx?ID_SUBCATEGORIA=26&ID_PUBLICACION=698&ID_IDIOMA=1\r\n [2]: https://www.contraloria.gob.pa/inec/Publicaciones/Publicaciones.aspx?ID_SUBCATEGORIA=38&ID_PUBLICACION=652&ID_IDIOMA=1&ID_CATEGORIA=5\r\n [3]: https://www.contraloria.gob.pa/inec/Publicaciones/subcategoria.aspx?ID_CATEGORIA=3&ID_SUBCATEGORIA=10&ID_IDIOMA=1","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"HAMZAH HAJI","reviewer":"Zach Christensen","score":50},{"id":"daeda51c-ba82-4ed8-b6c4-fad9243e282a","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-27T21:20:48","year":2015,"place":"uy","dataset":"statistics","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"No","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://catalogodatos.gub.uy/organization/ine","format":"CSV, TSV, XLS, DAT, dBase, PDF","licenseurl":"https://datos.gub.uy/wps/wcm/connect/856cc1804db0463baa8bea01b72d8394/terminos-catalogodatos.pdf?MOD=AJPERES&ContentCache=NONE&CACHEID=856cc1804db0463baa8bea01b72d8394","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Instituto Nacional de Estadistica (INE)","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Difficult to find current data that is not in PDF. ","details":"Plenty more information available at:\r\n- https://www.agev.opp.gub.uy/observatorio/servlet/mainindicadoresap?41018,41018\r\n- https://www.ine.gub.uy\r\n-[National Accounts][1] info up to 2014.\r\nSome 2015 Unemployment data available [here][2] in PDF format. \r\nFigures for GDP, Unemployment, Population for 2014 available in PDF [here][3]. \r\n\r\n\r\n [1]: https://www.ine.gub.uy/web/guest/cuentas-nacionales\r\n [2]: https://www.ine.gub.uy/documents/10181/30865/ECH+Empleo+Agosto+2015/f04ef8ae-da25-42cf-a49b-d4d0731439bb\r\n [3]: https://www.ine.gub.uy/documents/10181/39317/Uruguay_en_cifras_2014.pdf/aac28208-4670-4e96-b8c1-b2abb93b5b13","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"Daniel Carranza","reviewer":"Zach Christensen","score":90},{"id":"9a013c25-c2a2-49c3-b9e2-5a96704fa324","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-01T16:52:19","year":2015,"place":"dk","dataset":"postcodes","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://dawa.aws.dk/postnummerdok","format":"json, csv, xml, geojson","licenseurl":"https://dawa.aws.dk/om#vilkaar","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Ministeriet for By- Bolig og Landdistrikter","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"OK!","details":"First link provided contains maps of postal areas\r\nPostal codes can also be found at: https://www.postdanmark.dk/da/Privat/Kundeservice/postnummerkort/Sider/home.aspx QA question: Please explain how to obtain the data required for this item of the census according to the definition above. The file at www.postdanmark.dk contains postcodes and town/commune names, without geolocations in lat/long or equivalent. The link is to an inventory of maps, in shape files: how would these be used to obtain a table of postcodes and their lat/long please? Answer: The postcode information is available in multiple formats for different purposes. For polygons on maps (incl. lat/long), see here https://www.gst.dk/Emner/Frie_data/Hvilke+data+er+omfattet/Hvilke+data+er+frie/Landinddelinger/DAGI/DAGI-download.htm and here https://www.adresse-info.dk/Default.aspx?tabid=220 (text in Danish, maps in shape, mapinfo and geomedia). There's also a webservice from which you can enter an address and obtain the postcode. I'm not an expert in geodata myself so in order to answer the postcode-related questions at the Census I had help from https://twitter.com/neogeografen (who might be more helpful in order to explain how to find the data of your need). Thanks to Andrew Stott and Neografen for help on this\r\n\r\n-- \r\n\r\nProvided name and link for correct official API-provider of zipcodes and other various address endpoints.\r\n\r\nUpdate 2015: No changes from 2014. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"Mor Rubinstein","reviewer":"Codrina Maria Ilie","score":100},{"id":"bf58c583-e115-4a81-99bb-6cb9d8f3ec57","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-11-13T06:55:32","year":2015,"place":"mx","dataset":"spending","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"lorena_rivero@hacienda.gob.mx","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The review added the government's comment on this data. The review team would like to add that we use secondary data in order to assess our data. This secondary data actually made the criteria more accurate and brought the score of more countries up. For other comments, see our insights page. ","details":"https://www.transparenciapresupuestaria.gob.mx is a very nice website detailing government spending. However it does not include transactional data but only indicates that the data exists and is digital.\r\n\r\n\r\nComments to the reviewer and OD Index: \r\nNeither the International Monetary Funds’ (IMF) Fiscal Transparency Code of 2014 nor the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development’s (OECD) Council on Budgetary Governance Recommendations of 2015 make reference to transactional information (including individual transaction records) as a relevant aggregate but, in terms of openness, stress particularly on coverage, comparability, fullness and relevance, establishing clear and homogenous expenditures classifications. \r\n\r\nTherefore, it is important to mention that the Open Budget Survey, conducted by the International Budget Partnership does not contemplate transactional information as part of the neither the survey. Nevertheless, it does include the transparency of disaggregated information by line item according to the established recognized classifications.\r\n\r\nIn accordance to the above-mentioned and globally recognized best practices on fiscal transparency, the Mexican fiscal transparency portal: www.transparenciapresupuestaria.gob.mx does provide for substantial and open spending information, as acknowledged by the International Budget Partnership in their Open Budget Index score for 2015 in open formats.\r\n\r\nFinally, it is noteworthy that 2014 and 2015 index, according to the website, has the same parameters of evaluating this variable, nonetheless the evaluation with same (and even more) information published from year to year has brought the assessment down. Therefore, for it to be a comparable and functional index, it should disclose the methodology changes that generate this downgrade. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Enrique Zapata","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":10},{"id":"76279435-fcb5-4959-9e7a-294976919630","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-15T18:26:52","year":2015,"place":"mx","dataset":"weather","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.smn.cna.gob.mx","format":"","licenseurl":"https://datos.gob.mx/terminos-y-condiciones/","officialtitle":"In the main page of SMN you can find the link for weather forecasts by city in different time frames. 10 year historic series of temperature and precipitation can be found under the section of 'Climatology'.","publisher":"Servicio Meteorológico Nacional","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 4 days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.","details":"","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Ricardo Pizzuto","reviewer":"Neal Bastek","score":85},{"id":"dd954e80-962d-4a7c-9067-40fc475f0677","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-27T20:01:17","year":2015,"place":"lv","dataset":"spending","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Submission is correct.","details":"The Treasury has detailed up-to-date spending information, but this information is not available online. \r\n\r\nThere is a service *\"Valsts budžeta iestāžu izdevumi\"*: https://www.kase.gov.lv/?module=maks&object_id=7446 that claims to provide daily expenditure information but it does not return any data.\r\n\r\nThe service at www.kase.gov.lv only has old (most recent: 2013) non-machine-readable PDF data behind a JS form and captcha and provides aggregated data, not transactional.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Uldis Bojars","reviewer":"Tryggvi Björgvinsson","score":10},{"id":"cd50d1be-01e1-436c-bd06-376cb2ac3360","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-28T17:33:02","year":2015,"place":"lv","dataset":"postcodes","exists":"No","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"ok","details":"Data matching the listed criteria does not exist.\r\n\r\nLatvia Post has a related dataset: [ZIP-code index page][1] (\"Pasta indeksu grāmata\") containing a number of XLS files in unstructured / semi-structured form. \r\n\r\nIt shows the mapping between locations (towns, street addresses, etc.) and relevant ZIP-codes but does not contain geo-coordinates nor is there another service where one could resolve ZIP-codes to geo-coordinates.\r\n\r\n [1]: https://www.pasts.lv/lv/uznemumiem/noderigi/pasta_indeksu_gramata/","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Uldis Bojars","reviewer":"Codrina Maria Ilie","score":0},{"id":"292618c5-5e10-4682-95ac-6a87d86d78d9","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-28T17:26:32","year":2015,"place":"lv","dataset":"map","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"No","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Unsure","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Unsure","url":"https://kartes.lgia.gov.lv/karte/","format":"DGN, ESRI ArcGIS","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Latvian Geospatial Information Agency","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Data is digital, public, but is not free to download, it is online, machine readable if you pay, I marked unsure for bulk because I cannot varify what you get for paying, it is not open to use and unclear as to updates.","details":"Unsure how to answer the \"Available for free\" and \"Machine-readable\" criteria:\r\n\r\n - there is an online version https://kartes.lgia.gov.lv/karte/ which is free but not machine-readable (it's an online map)\r\n - detailed machine-readable versions are also available (as OGC WMS, OGC WFS services, etc.) but it is a paid service and it is not clear how to get access to them. here's the official publication with a list of fees: https://likumi.lv/doc.php?id=258991\r\n\r\nLatvian Geospatial Information Agency: https://www.lgia.gov.lv/en/Par%20mums.aspx\r\n\r\nMap services available: https://map.lgia.gov.lv/index.php?lang=2&cPath=4\r\n\r\nSee also:\r\n\r\n - The State of Open Data in Latvia: 2014. Baltic J. Modern Computing, Vol. 2 (2014), No. 3, 160-170 - https://arxiv.org/abs/1406.5052\r\n\r\nData did not change from 2014\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Mor Rubinstein","reviewer":"Gil Zaretzer","score":35},{"id":"c3184f2f-9ada-4eeb-a157-bed7d9c799b2","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-27T20:30:57","year":2015,"place":"lv","dataset":"statistics","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.csb.gov.lv/en/dati/data-23959.html","format":"CSV, XLSX, PX-Axis","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Central Statistical Bureau","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Current data available but not open.","details":"[Unemployment][1]\r\n\r\n[GDP][2]\r\n\r\n[population][3]\r\n\r\n\r\n [1]: https://www.csb.gov.lv/en/statistikas-temas/employment-and-unemployment-key-indicators-30679.html\r\n [2]: https://www.csb.gov.lv/en/statistikas-temas/gross-domestic-product-key-indicators-30517.html\r\n [3]: https://www.csb.gov.lv/en/statistikas-temas/population-key-indicators-30624.html","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Uldis Bojars","reviewer":"Zach Christensen","score":70},{"id":"f2397544-9735-4283-9f0b-58f572520283","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-27T09:06:45","year":2015,"place":"lv","dataset":"companies","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://dati.ur.gov.lv/register/","format":"CSV files + a TXT describing CSV file structure; XLSX files","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Republic of Latvia Company Register","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Added title and more specific URL. Looks good :)","details":"Enterprise register's data is published in a structured form and updated daily. Benefits from timely updates: organisations requiring Enterprise register statistics can just grab the file instead of filing official requests, thus saving time and effort.\r\n\r\nFiles include basic information about enterprises but lack more detailed information. Enterprise register sells access to detailed information to commercial companies for a considerable fee (in tens of thousands EUR) which can resell this information to everyone else.\r\n\r\nThis is one of the best open data examples in Latvia, but it is difficult to find - you have to know the URL of the open data server or the path to take through register's website in order to find a link to the open data server.\r\n\r\nUpdate 2015: situation has not changed since 2014 and the answers are the same (URL valid, dataset updated regularly).","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Uldis Bojars","reviewer":"Rebecca Sentance","score":70},{"id":"9b99411b-d032-465c-b62d-af8e905631b3","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-27T20:13:09","year":2015,"place":"lv","dataset":"elections","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.cvk.lv/pub/public/","format":"XML","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Centrālā vēlēšanu komisija","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The data is available in bulk. The XML files contain the full results.","details":"The [Central Election Commission][1] publishes election results (for both general and EP elections). Each election instance, however, has its own web page and there is no central starting point where you could find all results together.\r\n\r\nI was not sure if the dataset qualifies as machine-readable -- the situation varies in every case with most results available as HTML tables located on multiple web pages:\r\n\r\n - 12th Saeima election (the most recent general election) results are published as XML: https://sv2014.cvk.lv/index_rez.html\r\n - 2014 European Parliament election results are published as HTML tables only: https://ep2014.cvk.lv/index_rez.html\r\n - 11th Saeima election results are published are published as HTML tables only: https://www.cvk.lv/cgi-bin/wdbcgiw/base/Saeima11.GalRez_s11\r\n - the formats of earlier election results vary, but are either HTML tables (semi-machine-readable) or not machine-readable\r\n\r\nSee also:\r\n\r\n - The State of Open Data in Latvia: 2014. Baltic J. Modern Computing, Vol. 2 (2014), No. 3, 160-170 - https://arxiv.org/abs/1406.5052\r\n\r\n [1]: https://cvk.lv \"Central Election Commission\"\r\n\r\nUpdate (2015): the situation is the same as in 2014. There have been no new election since then.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Uldis Bojars","reviewer":"Kamil Gregor","score":70},{"id":"6fd1e565-13bb-443a-afe0-1d968e1b37fc","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-27T20:07:35","year":2015,"place":"lv","dataset":"budget","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.fm.gov.lv/lv/sadalas/valsts_budzets/2015__gada_budzets_/","format":"XLS","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"LR Finanšu ministrija","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"I have reviewed the submission and it is correct. ","details":"The state budget for recent years is published as semi-structured XLS files (cell text indentation level shows budget entry hierarchy, not entirely machine-readable): https://www.fm.gov.lv/files/valstsbudzets/2014/4piel_2014_budzets_131113.xls\r\n\r\nURL for state budget 2014: https://www.fm.gov.lv/lv/sadalas/valsts_budzets/2014__gada_budzets/\r\n\r\n - see \"4.pielikums\" for the main budget and \"5.pielikums\" for the special / social insurance fund budget\r\n\r\nThe archive of state budget data for previous years (year 2013 shown by default, see the sidebar for earlier years): https://www.fm.gov.lv/lv/sadalas/valsts_budzets/valsts_budzeta_likums_arhivs/2013_gads/ \r\n\r\nUpdate (2015): situation is the same as in 2014. Updated the dataset URL field to the current year (state budget 2015). \r\n\r\nSee also:\r\n\r\n - The State of Open Data in Latvia: 2014. Baltic J. Modern Computing, Vol. 2 (2014), No. 3, 160-170 - https://arxiv.org/abs/1406.5052\r\n\r\n","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Uldis Bojars","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":70},{"id":"6a8251cc-1096-4e06-a1d6-e6022fb803e5","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-27T20:17:38","year":2015,"place":"lv","dataset":"timetables","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.pv.lv/lv/vilcienu_saraksts","format":"XLS","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"JSC “Pasažieru vilciens” (“Passenger train”)","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Good submission","details":"This entry is about public train transport in Latvia. The bus transport is operated at a municipal level.\r\n\r\nLive train schedules, including pricing information, are published at https://www.pv.lv/lv/vilcienu_saraksts\r\n\r\nThere is also an XLS version available that contains all the schedules together and is reasonably up-to-date (last updates: 2015-Sep-01):\r\nhttps://www.pv.lv/lv/kopejais_iekszemes_vilcienu_kustibas_saraksts/ \r\n\r\nBoth versions should be up-to-date but the live version may also contain information about unscheduled changes.\r\n\r\nSee also:\r\n\r\n - The State of Open Data in Latvia: 2014. Baltic J. Modern Computing, Vol. 2 (2014), No. 3, 160-170 - https://arxiv.org/abs/1406.5052\r\n\r\nUpdate (2015: the situation is the same as reported in 2014.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Uldis Bojars","reviewer":"Pieter Colpaert","score":70},{"id":"24dbb4f4-a57e-47c2-8b3d-91cc349b3bf0","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-14T20:26:41","year":2015,"place":"co","dataset":"postcodes","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://datos.gov.co/frm/catalogo/frmCatalogo.aspx?dsId=63472","format":".xls, .txt","licenseurl":"https://datos.gov.co/frm/Acerca/frmAcercaDe.aspx","officialtitle":"Códigos Postales Colombia","publisher":"Ministerio de Tecnologías de la Información y las Comunicaciones, Contacto Yesika Padilla-Subdirección de Asuntos Postales Correo: ypadilla@mintic.gov.co","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"ok!","details":"El código postal es un esquema que asigna a distintas zonas o lugares de un país un código, que junto con la dirección sirven para facilitar y mecanizar el encaminamiento de un objeto postal (una pieza de correo como una carta, un sobre, un paquete o cualquier elemento que necesite ser llevado a un lugar).\r\n\r\nNo reemplaza la dirección, sino que la complementa para facilitar la entrega de un envío.\r\n\r\nPara mayor información consultar en:\r\nhttps://www.codigopostal.gov.co/\r\n\r\n","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"Juan Felipe Devia Rodriguez","reviewer":"Codrina Maria Ilie","score":100},{"id":"dc6ca9db-3fe3-4aa6-bfe2-ba5007bc9ab9","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-07T15:42:29","year":2015,"place":"ie","dataset":"companies","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"No","online":"Yes","free":"No","machinereadable":"Unsure","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.cro.ie/en-ie/Services/Access-to-CRO-Data","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Company Data","publisher":"Companies Registration Office (CRO)","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Made some small tweaks - I determined that the data is not publicly accessible if it needs to be paid for and then requires login details to access. Agree with all other fields :)","details":"This remains unchanged from last year.\r\n\r\nDetails about **Accessing CRO Data** are explained here: https://www.cro.ie/en-ie/Services/Access-to-CRO-Data \r\n\r\nData available **via free API** for which signup is required at https://services.cro.ie/overview.aspx.\r\n\r\n**Bulk data are available for an annual fee:** \"The CRO supplies, under licence, data in bulk format for high volume users of our data. The data concerned is company information in respect of all companies on the register. It is in a specified format which may be updated to take account of changes in filing requirements. Daily updates of the data may be downloaded via the internet - a password is assigned to a Licensee to facilitate this. The fee for the daily data update service has been fixed by the Minister at **€31,000 per annum**.\"\r\n\r\nThe database can also be searched free of charge at https://search.cro.ie/company/.\r\n\r\n","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Rebecca Sentance","score":35},{"id":"c8ddb9ee-28a1-474f-8316-ef89a4468ab4","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-19T08:35:04","year":2015,"place":"in","dataset":"water","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"https://data.gov.in/catalog/water-quality-affected-habitations","format":"CSV, Excel","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Water Quality Monitoring","publisher":"Ministry of Drinking Water and Sanitation","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"While several places have water quality at a central level available online, it is not available in open license or in a bulk format. ","details":"OGD India gives an exhaustive amount of data with regard to Water Quality. The data is in open format and machine readable, Bulk download facility is available on Data Portal India. Data published on data Portal are Open and comes under the policy NDSAP and it's totally open.\r\nData for water quality is also available on CPCB database https://cpcbedb.nic.in/","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Shubhadip Biswas","reviewer":"Nisha Thompson","score":50},{"id":"230f45ab-01ff-4eaf-b22f-c2a61b5ab5e3","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-19T19:16:09","year":2015,"place":"co","dataset":"statistics","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.dane.gov.co/index.php/poblacion-y-demografia/censos","format":"Excel, PDF","licenseurl":"https://www.dane.gov.co/index.php/terminos-de-uso","officialtitle":"Cuentas Económicas Nacionales Trimestrales - PIB Oferta y Demanda, Estadísticas por Tema: IPC, Mercado Laboral, Demografía y Población","publisher":"Departamento Administrativo Nacional de Estadística-DANE, Ligia Galvis Amaya, correo: osistemas@dane.gov.co ","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Data are up to data and open.","details":"Se presentan como soporte 4 links donde se pueden consultar la información solicitada:\r\n\r\nIPC - https://www.dane.gov.co/index.php/indices-de-precios-y-costos/indice-de-precios-al-consumidor-ipc\r\n\r\nPIB - https://www.dane.gov.co/index.php/cuentas-economicas/cuentas-trimestrales\r\n\r\nMERCADO LABORAL - https://www.dane.gov.co/index.php/estadisticas-por-tema/mercado-laboral\r\n\r\nDemografia y población - https://www.dane.gov.co/index.php/poblacion-y-demografia/censos\r\n\r\nIPC - El IPC es un indicador que mide la variación de precios de una canasta de bienes y servicios representativos del consumo de los hogares del país. Los resultados son analizados por grupos, subgrupos y clases de gastos, gastos básicos y niveles de ingreso.Se publican cuadros en excel con información más desagregadas (por subgrupos), para el total nacional, por ciudades y niveles de ingresos. Se registran las variaciones mensuales, año corrido y para los últimos 12 meses. Se puede acceder a los documentos y a la información de la investigación que se encuentra en tablas de Excel o por medio de consultas dinámicas, que permiten que el usuario obtenga la información de acuerdo con sus necesidades.\r\n\r\nPIB - constituyen una síntesis de la información de coyuntura que tiene como finalidad presentar oportunamente con periodicidad trimestral la situación económica del país, en coherencia con las Cuentas Nacionales anuales. Se publican anexos estadísticos e históricos en excel con resultados de Valor agregado total y por ramas de actividad, Consumo final de los hogares total y por grado de durabilidad, Consumo final total y por categorías económicas, Formación bruta de capital fijo total y por clase de productos, Exportaciones totales y por grupos de productos, Importaciones totales y por grupos de productos, Producto Interno Bruto PIB Total.\r\n\r\nMERCADO LABORAL - Los indicadores de mercado laboral indagan sobre las condiciones de empleo de los colombianos y dan a conocer aspectos como si trabajan o no, en qué rama de actividad se desempeñan, cómo se comporta el mercado laboral para grupos poblacionales específicos como mujeres y jóvenes, cuál es la remuneración que reciben, cómo es la afiliación a seguridad social, entre otros aspectos; la cobertura de estas investigaciones es nacional y se realizan informes departamentales y regionales. Se presentan anexos e indicadores históricos en excel con las principales variables de mercado laboral para el Total nacional y 13 áreas.\r\n\r\nDEMOGRAFÍA Y POBLACIÓN - Información de la población colombiana y sus proyecciones en el tiempo, junto con estadísticas vitales como nacimientos y defunciones, además de resultados sobre las migraciones tanto nacionales internas como internacionales. Se tiene también indicadores sobre grupos étnicos colombianos. Se publican anexos en excel con información de variables demográfica y se cuenta sistemas de consulta dinámicos y estáticos para el censo General . Los primeros, permiten hacer cruces de información de todas las variables que indagó el ejercicio censal; los segundos presentan en mapas información particular consultada durante el operativo.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"Juan Felipe Devia Rodriguez","reviewer":"Zach Christensen","score":100},{"id":"3d4e3a9c-a891-4d49-8a6a-5ce944707804","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-27T23:35:33","year":2015,"place":"ec","dataset":"elections","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://resultados.cne.gob.ec/","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Consejo Nacional Electoral","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The submission is correct.","details":"Election results are published on this website, with a copyright notice in the footer.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Eduardo Bejar","reviewer":"Kamil Gregor","score":45},{"id":"ff8b854c-3552-46f9-b6d6-8b05059f5dec","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-21T18:58:18","year":2015,"place":"us","dataset":"weather","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Unsure","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://graphical.weather.gov/xml/","format":"XML","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (which includes the National Weather Service and the National Centers for Environmental Information)","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"I updated this submission with the forecast data in addition to the historical/climate data. We accept this submission because it meets our criteria of 5 days of precipitation, temperature and wind forecast.","details":"Forecast data is available at the link above.\r\n\r\nHistorical/climate data is available here: https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/cdo-web/datasets\r\n\r\nThere are some online and some offline data. The ones that are offline need to be ordered by mailing NCEI. All that is online can be downloaded for free but what is offline needs to be ordered and “[most offline services require an additional charge][1].\" Also in order to “certify” data records in the case that they are used in court, there might be further costs.\r\n\r\nUnsure if most of it is online but there definitely exists offline data. Here are places to look for online data: a. [Dataset Gallery of NOAA][2]; b. [Quick links][3] to many of NCEI’s datasets on weather/climate; c. [Operational Climate Data Records][4]; d. [Climate Data: Dataset Discovery][5]\r\n\r\nYes, openly licensed because it goes with the [World Meteorological Organization Resolution][6], which means non-US info cannot be used for commercial use; international data can be used within the US or for noncommercial international uses without any restrictions.\r\n\r\n\r\n [1]: https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/customer-support\r\n [2]: https://www.climate.gov/maps-data/datasets/coverage/us\r\n [3]: https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/data-access/quick-links\r\n [4]: https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/cdr/operationalcdrs.html\r\n [5]: https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/cdo-web/datasets\r\n [6]: https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/customer-support","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Neal Bastek","score":70},{"id":"66ace388-a835-4dde-a8e3-9794acc9446c","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-28T00:24:43","year":2015,"place":"ar","dataset":"budget","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.mecon.gov.ar/onp/html/consolidado/2015/Pcspn15.pdf","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Ministry of Economy, Finance Secretary","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Data for 2015 is only in machine readable format. Changed data to not machine readable. ","details":"The budget details are on the website of the National Budget Office which depends on the Ministry of Economy. The paper this year (2011- 2014) is published as disaggregated data. \r\n\r\n\r\nThe data for 2015 is only available in a PDF format. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Yamila García","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":55},{"id":"c2d84893-0a13-4802-a0e9-99d61dc3adbf","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-28T02:43:45","year":2015,"place":"ar","dataset":"legislation","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.hcdn.gov.ar/","format":"","licenseurl":"https://www.hcdn.gov.ar/","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Honorable Cámara de Diputados de la Nación Argentina","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The submission is correct.","details":"The website for the National Congress contains up-to-date information about all legislative activity in different formats and different sections.\r\n\r\nA local citizen initiative Congreso Interactivo is publishing a machine readable dataset:\r\nhttps://www.congresointeractivo.org/dataset-todas-las-votaciones-del-congreso-2001-2013/\r\n\r\nAnd an API:\r\nhttps://billit.congresointeractivo.org\r\n","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Kamil Gregor","score":75},{"id":"c57f5623-77a7-4fcd-a2e7-8a79299aef2d","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-11-23T19:48:08","year":2015,"place":"nl","dataset":"water","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"No","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://live.waterbase.nl","format":"excel","licenseurl":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/deed.nl","officialtitle":"Waterkwaliteit - Chemisch - Rijkswaterstaat, Unie van Waterschappen","publisher":"Rijkswaterstaat, Unie van Waterschappen","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Link to data had to updated to download tool, not a bulk download dataset","details":"QA - review - the license is cc-by 4, as this datasets was found in the CKAN portal, where all datasets share the same license. Data was also timely and was updated to the week of the review. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"Nisha Thompson","reviewer":"Nisha Thompson","score":90},{"id":"99077c5e-2282-424b-bb84-da9c9bb5b9f9","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-28T20:14:53","year":2015,"place":"mx","dataset":"budget","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.transparenciapresupuestaria.gob.mx/","format":"CSV","licenseurl":"https://www.transparenciapresupuestaria.gob.mx/es/PTP/Terminos_y_Condiciones","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Ministry of Finance","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"I have reviewed the data and it is correct. Submission accepted. ","details":"No change from 2014. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":100},{"id":"d4e31a47-58ca-4d54-9cfe-908620a03904","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-02T20:55:59","year":2015,"place":"sn","dataset":"statistics","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"https://www.ansd.sn","format":"PDF","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"General statistics","publisher":"National Agency of Statistics and Demography","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Data for population not current, no open license. ","details":"The data is accessible here. Population figures last updated for 2013.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Zach Christensen","score":45},{"id":"421c0deb-7054-47e8-994e-5cf9d34ec366","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-11-06T15:02:05","year":2014,"place":"sn","dataset":"timetables","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"No","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Unsure","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Check the original submitter. Data is not available on the site. I changed accordingly. ","details":" According to Genova, no change from 2013. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Mor Rubinstein","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":30},{"id":"09518896-b5d9-4dc1-b348-75117a165146","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-28T00:56:37","year":2015,"place":"ar","dataset":"elections","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://elecciones.gob.ar/articulo_sub_sub.php?secc=2&sub_secc=9&sub_sub_secc=69","format":"CSV","licenseurl":"https://datospublicos.gob.ar/data/organization/e0ddc4f9-6d3b-4c94-ba22-b16f52ab5eed?license_id=odc-odbl&_license_id_limit=0","officialtitle":"","publisher":"National Electoral Management","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The submission is correct.","details":"This data is well structured and easy to access. That Were data sets are cleaned and sorted. The last update of the PASO elections are in 2015, the datasets is in csv format.\r\nAre the results of the elections of 2001 - 2011 in PDF format.\r\nhttps://elecciones.gob.ar/articulo_sub_sub.php?secc=2&sub_secc=9&sub_sub_secc=9","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"Yamila García","reviewer":"Kamil Gregor","score":100},{"id":"a3374832-41f2-437e-8b0c-ff6b2ba94144","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-11-23T16:45:17","year":2015,"place":"bj","dataset":"procurement","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"https://www.marches-publics.bj/index.php?option=com_appeloffres&task=list1&Itemid=69","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Avis d'attribution de marchés publics","publisher":"Direction Nationale du Contrôle des Marchés Publics","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Changed according to the thematic reviewer second review. ","details":"The procurement tenders are published on the website of the general direction of procurement. All data about the tenders are publicly available, but the data are not machine readable and not up to date. Bulk downloads are not sufficiently frequent. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Georg Neumann","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":35},{"id":"b143f98c-375c-43ac-bee8-11c6f28993f3","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-27T08:18:46","year":2015,"place":"bo","dataset":"weather","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.senamhi.gob.bo/sismet/index.php","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"SisMet","publisher":"Servicio Nacional de Meteorología e Hidrología","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"I have checked the data and it is correct. Changed license from unsure to no. ","details":"The SENAMHI offers a weather forecast of temperature, wind precipitation for 4 days (today + 3 days). It is non machine readable format. \r\nData is © Copyright 2010 SENAMHI and therefore is not openly licensed. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Mariana Leyton","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":45},{"id":"37b4bc81-7f3f-4e9d-8e09-5fe776c72754","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-10-30T23:33:07","year":2014,"place":"es","dataset":"timetables","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://renfe.es","format":"","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"RENFE","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Added bus information. ","details":"No related information found in both the Ministerio de Fomento[1] or the Spanish OpenData Portal[2]. The timetables for national-level trains are available at renfe.es site. \nBus data can be found here - https://www.alsa.es/en/\n\n[1] https://www.fomento.gob.es\n\n[2] https://datos.gob.es","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"José Félix Ontañón","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":45},{"id":"38237c21-b6ff-478c-8355-b8b9fa52a743","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-26T23:54:05","year":2015,"place":"bo","dataset":"companies","exists":"Unsure","digital":"Unsure","public":"Unsure","online":"Unsure","free":"Unsure","machinereadable":"Unsure","bulk":"Unsure","openlicense":"Unsure","uptodate":"Unsure","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"We could not find the data","details":"","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Mor Rubinstein","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":0},{"id":"f13c00e8-cff0-42ef-8757-afb5f643162d","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-11T14:13:02","year":2015,"place":"tr","dataset":"elections","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.ysk.gov.tr/ysk/faces/Anasayfa?_adf.ctrl-state=16l17042qv_85&wcnav.model=YSKUstMenu&_afrLoop=20006272935868012","format":"Excel, PDF, CSV","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Supreme Electoral Council of Turkey","publisher":"Supreme Electoral Council of Turkey","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The submission is correct.","details":"https://www.ysk.gov.tr/ysk/faces/HaberDetay?training_id=YSKPWCN1_4444005790&_afrLoop=2365240657220670&_afrWindowMode=0&_afrWindowId=12zs3opp84_37#%40%3F_afrWindowId%3D12zs3opp84_37%26_afrLoop%3D2365240657220670%26training_id%3DYSKPWCN1_4444005790%26_afrWindowMode%3D0%26_adf.ctrl-state%3D12zs3opp84_49\r\n\r\nQA review- Changed the license to not open. Do not license in [this link] does not mention data, but mentions information about the elections process.[1] \r\n\r\n\r\n [1]: https://www.ysk.gov.tr/ysk/faces/YSKGorevVeYetkileri?_adf.ctrl-state=12zs3opp84_89&wcnav.model=footerMaviTasarim&_afrLoop=2365433288610675","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Mor Rubinstein","reviewer":"Kamil Gregor","score":70},{"id":"f722a31a-ba47-4164-831f-2ef7b1906a86","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-01T17:03:18","year":2015,"place":"gt","dataset":"statistics","exists":"No","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Data largely unavailable.","details":"In https://www.ine.gob.gt/index.php/estadisticas/2013-10-30-16-43-37 \r\nypu can find the datasets avalaible in excel format. However there are not datasets with the criteria enlisted above (GDP or Population but some 2014 data for unemployment)","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Iscelle Marsicovetere","reviewer":"Zach Christensen","score":0},{"id":"b6e90771-6d69-4109-8b11-351e7c9dae27","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-03T02:15:03","year":2015,"place":"mx","dataset":"companies","exists":"Yes","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"Unsure","uptodate":"Unsure","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Mexican Business Information System (Sistema de Información Empresarial Mexicano)","publisher":"Ministry of Economy (Secretaría de Economía)","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"It is not possible to browse through the database or access data without providing a search term, therefore the registry does not qualify for most of the criteria.","details":"Despite the fact that data is available under the Treasury and Economic Ministry, there is no public database available to the public. Some query mechanisms exist in order to find basic company information based on the name of the company or their tax id. It is also possible to download generated search results in .XLS format.\r\n\r\nNo change from 2014. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Haydeé Quijano","reviewer":"Rebecca Sentance","score":5},{"id":"4b8649eb-6347-414c-9c43-69cf018944ea","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-11-10T19:14:03","year":2015,"place":"mx","dataset":"legislation","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.diputados.gob.mx/LeyesBiblio/index.htm","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Laws, regulations, official normativity and its amendments, updated daily","publisher":"Cámara de Diputados y Diario Oficial de la Federación","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Data exist. Therefore, we approve this submission. ","details":"Both Legislative Chambers, Diputados (https://www.diputados.gob.mx) and the Senate (https://www.senado.gob.mx) don't have machine readable and bulk data. Nonetheless, outside websites have built APIs and other scrapping-based information flows in order to gather and publish information in sites such as www.curul501.org and apps such as https://itunes.apple.com/mx/app/id625548107?mt=8. Other internal data standards, such as law taxonomy are either not public or don't exist.\r\nNo license could be found which makes the data not open. \r\n\r\nNo change from 2013. \r\n\r\nActualización 2015: El estado de los datos no ha cambiado, la información solicitada en los criterios no existe y no hay una licencia clara para el uso de los datos. \r\n\r\nComment to the 2015 update: \r\nLegislation data in Mexico do exist, is publicly available, for free, available online, on a timely basis and in digital forms.\r\n\r\nDatasets can be found in the following two sites: \r\n•\tChamber of Representatives: https://www.diputados.gob.mx/LeyesBiblio/index.htm\r\n•\tOfficial Gazette: https://www.dof.gob.mx/# \r\n\r\nData in this sites is updated at a dainly basis, and specificially the Official Gazette, is by law, updated daily to show any amendment, change or publication of new or existing laws, regulations, and normativity in Mexico.\r\n","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Enrique Zapata","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":45},{"id":"ce581e7e-f2a8-414a-9a9d-8b7437894dca","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-02T12:21:01","year":2015,"place":"iq","dataset":"statistics","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"https://cosit.gov.iq/","format":"XLS, PDF","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Central Statistical Organization of Iraq","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Some data available in fairly open format.","details":"[Unemployment][1] for 2008.\r\n\r\n[Population][2] for 2010. \r\n\r\n[GDP][3] up to 2014.\r\n\r\n\r\n [1]: https://cosit.gov.iq/en/population-manpower-staatistics/manpower\r\n [2]: https://cosit.gov.iq/en/population-manpower-staatistics/life\r\n [3]: https://cosit.gov.iq/en/national-accounts-statistics/national-income-reports","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Sadeek Hasna","reviewer":"Zach Christensen","score":50},{"id":"6852c79c-7a68-44e7-8f83-a001bf7af90e","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-10-29T12:52:28","year":2014,"place":"bd","dataset":"map","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"https://www.sob.gov.bd/mapcate.php","format":"","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Survey of Bangladesh","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"updated data.","details":" updated new data","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Nasir Khan","score":35},{"id":"4377472c-8ec9-4bb3-84ce-8868d665e24b","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-17T12:30:26","year":2015,"place":"ec","dataset":"budget","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"https://www.finanzas.gob.ec/informacion-presupuestaria/","format":"HTML, PDF, CSV, XML, Excel","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Ministerio de Finanzas ","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"There is an historical data, not current data. Changed timely to NO","details":"The consolidated budget for 2014 is available online, but not its detailed version and execution.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":60},{"id":"3df54c70-2bfb-4829-b9be-15f5d0f17b18","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-19T15:10:37","year":2015,"place":"co","dataset":"elections","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://datos.gov.co/frm/catalogo/frmCatalogo.aspx?dsId=63550","format":"CSV","licenseurl":"https://datos.gov.co/frm/Desarrolladores/frmTerminosCondiciones.aspx","officialtitle":"Datos abiertos elecciones 2014","publisher":"Registraduría Nacional del Estado Civil, Contacto: Edwin Gonzalez Caldas-Jefe oficina de comunicaciones y prensa, Correo: egonzalezcaldas@gmail.com ","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The submission is correct.","details":"Además, en el portal principal de la Registraduria Nacional del Estado Civil, está publicada la información con los resultados de la Presidencia y Congreso del último periodo de elecciones en Colombia. En el siguiente link puede encontrar la información:\r\n\r\nhttps://www.registraduria.gov.co/-Historico-de-Resultados-.html\r\n\r\nPor otra parte, se publica información de resultados electorales en la plataforma de la Misión de Observación Electoral –MOE: https://www.datoselectorales.org/#, ver sección \"Resultados electorales\". \r\n\r\nCon el fin de aclarar, la MOE es una plataforma de organizaciones de la sociedad civil, independiente del gobierno, de los partidos políticos y de intereses privados, que promueve la realización del derecho que tiene todo ciudadano a participar en la conformación, ejercicio y control del poder político.\r\n","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"Juan Felipe Devia Rodriguez","reviewer":"Kamil Gregor","score":100},{"id":"5ce9086f-4303-4885-9f8a-cdbd8e18feea","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-12T10:39:01","year":2015,"place":"ir","dataset":"elections","exists":"No","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The submission is correct.","details":"We checked the Guardian Council's website (https://www.shora-gc.ir/Portal/Home/), it is who approves or disapproves parliamentary or presidential elections candidates. It has a section for elections on the website, but only containing election laws and another elections news section, mainly about the council's activities. \r\n\r\nCurrently, Electoral Commission announces the results after the Ministry of Interior confirmation. We checked the site for the Ministry of Interior, the page for the presidential elections results (https://result-p.moi.ir/Portal/Home/default.aspx) seems to be down. Wikipedia article about 2013 elections in Iran cited the Ministry of Interior as their source, but didn't specify a link. We couldn't find any web presence for the Electoral Commission. \r\n\r\nThis link from MOI should also provide the elections results data (https://www.moi.ir/portal/home/default.aspx?categoryid=c2cf29ae-2e8e-4319-a926-1e311d44c6d1), but links there are not working, and gave us errors when we tried to access the presidential or parliament elections results. Only one of the few links that worked for one past election, gave us data in the following format (https://www.moi.ir/portal/Home/Default.aspx?CategoryID=a49af0c2-962d-4896-9dab-994263db42f4 - https://www.moi.ir/portal/File/ShowFile.aspx?ID=7201aaf9-13af-48a0-902b-513b34e9134d), which doesn't seem to meet the standards ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Tarek Amr","reviewer":"Kamil Gregor","score":0},{"id":"ac2afc05-b58d-432c-8f07-1ed257bfb9fb","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-18T10:49:15","year":2015,"place":"in","dataset":"procurement","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://eprocure.gov.in/cppp/tendersearch","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Central Public Procurement Portal - The Central Public Procurement Portal of Government of India facilitates all the Central Government Organizations to publish their Tender Enquiries, Corrigendum and Award of Contract details. The system also enables the users to migrate to total electronic procurement mode. The primary objective of this portal is to provide a single point access to the information on procurements made across various Central Government Organizations.","publisher":"Department of Expenditure, Ministry of Finance","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Submission correct. There is no specific mention of an open license, set to no. ","details":"The Government of India has online portal for procurement and issuing of tenders where one can easily browse through data and access information regarding them. https://eprocure.gov.in/cppp/tendersearch is the main site catering to this need.\r\n\r\nThe Central Public Procurement Portal of Government of India facilitates all the Central Government Organizations to publish their Tender Enquiries, Corrigendum and Award of Contract details. The system also enables the users to migrate to total electronic procurement mode. The primary objective of this portal is to provide a single point access to the information on procurements made across various Central Government Organizations.\r\n","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Akhilesh Srivastava","reviewer":"Georg Neumann","score":45},{"id":"843c1767-b32e-4379-8ef9-617c9555a229","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-08T17:29:23","year":2015,"place":"ae","dataset":"spending","exists":"No","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Submission fixed.\r\n\r\nSubmission was correct but moved answer from unknown to no.","details":"UAE does not seem to maintain a database that covers individual records of transactions. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Riyadh Al-Balushi","reviewer":"Tryggvi Björgvinsson","score":0},{"id":"5a44e4da-03f8-4368-898f-2b7b58954bb5","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-16T05:20:29","year":2015,"place":"ir","dataset":"postcodes","exists":"No","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"ok","details":"Iran has 10 digits postal codes for each and every place (see here https://www.post.ir/DesktopModules/Articles/ArticlesView.aspx?TabID=1&Site=postportal&Lang=en-US&ItemID=10337&mid=10768 and here https://www.postcode.post.ir/_Geography/Documents/postal%20code.%20PDF.pdf)\r\n\r\nHere (https://eservice.postcode.post.ir/) you can search for codes by entering the full address. However, we could not find a database of postal codes and corresponding address. No coordinates are shown in all cases.\r\n","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Tarek Amr","reviewer":"Codrina Maria Ilie","score":0},{"id":"92c2679e-2b90-4c82-961b-30973406dbad","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-10-27T19:07:40","year":2014,"place":"cy","dataset":"budget","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"Unsure","openlicense":"Unsure","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.mof.gov.cy/mof/mof.nsf/page15_gr/page15_gr?OpenDocument","format":"","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Ministry of Economy","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"duplication","details":"Later data is more complete, but is only available in PDF so not easy to machine read. More information available in Greek than in English or Turkish.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Andreas P","score":45},{"id":"59758932-e290-4fc2-86cb-32eef355150c","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-11-03T10:32:48","year":2014,"place":"cy","dataset":"spending","exists":"No","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"https://www.mof.gov.cy","format":"","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Could not be found, again.","details":" Cannot be found on government websites. If anyone finds something, please submit! ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Andreas P","score":0},{"id":"b3a10777-158b-49b4-a550-1b98c5b2e858","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-10-27T19:20:46","year":2014,"place":"cy","dataset":"companies","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"Unsure","uptodate":"Unsure","url":"https://efiling.drcor.mcit.gov.cy/DrcorPublic/SearchForm.aspx?sc=0&lang=EN","format":"","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Definite improvement from last year, but still more could be done.","details":"It appears you can search the database for specific companies but it is not possible to get the whole dataset. Significant improvement on last year due to updated website.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Andreas P","score":35},{"id":"cdc8fcce-78d2-4981-bd44-2f13ffddce71","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-17T15:15:00","year":2015,"place":"ir","dataset":"water","exists":"Yes","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"Unsure","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Water Quality","publisher":"Local municipalities","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"They do test water at the local municipal level:\r\nhttps://www.tpww.ir/fa/album/211/Water-Wastewater-Quality-Control-Dept-labarotories\r\n\r\nUnclear if there is a national monitoring body requiring reporting or aggregating of data. ","details":"We were not able to find this data on the website for the Department of Environment, https://www.doe.ir/","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Tarek Amr","reviewer":"Nisha Thompson","score":5},{"id":"04987724-5107-4b47-bae5-62feaaf7d72d","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-28T15:51:51","year":2015,"place":"in","dataset":"postcodes","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://data.gov.in/catalog/all-india-pincode-directory#web_catalog_tabs_block_10","format":"CSV","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"India Post - For more than 150 years, the Department of Posts (DoP) has been the backbone of the country’s communication and has played a crucial role in the country’s socio-economic development. It touches the lives of Indian citizens in many ways: delivering mails, accepting deposits under Small Savings Schemes, providing life insurance cover under Postal Life Insurance (PLI) and Rural Postal Life Insurance (RPLI) and providing retail services like bill collection, sale of forms, etc. The DoP also acts as an agent for Government of India in discharging other services for citizens such as Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (MGNREGS) wage disbursement and old age pension payments With 1, 55,015 Post Offices, the DoP has the most widely distributed postal network in the world.","publisher":"India Post, Ministry of Communication & Informataion Technology, Government of India","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"License is not Open - https://data.gov.in/sites/default/files/NDSAP.pdf","details":"The dataset (All India Pincode directory with contact details along with Latitude and longitude) is available in CSV format at https://data.gov.in/dataset/all-india-pincode-directory. The information available on OGD India and is completely open for reuse and further studies and research. Many Applications have also been developed using this data. The data is also available at https://www.indiapost.gov.in/pin/. The data consists of pincodes along with post office information like address and postal code. The data can also be searched by location or pincode on https://www.indiapost.gov.in/.\r\n\r\nThe license does not allow commercial use, it is not open. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":70},{"id":"9fd331f0-f1a5-44b4-b917-fc44fdf3d139","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-21T08:08:35","year":2015,"place":"cy","dataset":"weather","exists":"No","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Submission is valid. \r\nThank you for your submission to the 2015 Global Open Data Census. ","details":"The data is not updated and is presented in a completely non-reusable way.\r\nhttps://www.moa.gov.cy/moa/ms/ms.nsf/DMLindex_en/DMLindex_en?opendocument","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Andreas P","reviewer":"Stephen Gates","score":0},{"id":"821d8e5d-ba28-4a74-94e9-9df6adf8bee7","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-11-03T10:33:21","year":2014,"place":"cy","dataset":"emissions","exists":"No","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Agree","details":"Could not find data on government websites https://www.moa.gov.cy ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Andreas P","score":0},{"id":"f5716be5-6352-41d2-8e41-769e46475d36","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-11-03T10:30:24","year":2014,"place":"cy","dataset":"map","exists":"No","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The data does not exist. Same as last year with old tourist maps.","details":"","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Andreas P","score":0},{"id":"6d996e18-2768-4dd7-9da8-c84be0b53a75","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-12-31T20:00:07","year":2014,"place":"cy","dataset":"elections","exists":"No","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"https://wtv.elections.moi.gov.cy/","format":".txt","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"","details":"No information appears to be available on the results of elections in Cyprus. There is information available about how to vote and more technical aspects, but not the results. Broken links exist for the latest Presidential election.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"anonymous","score":0},{"id":"382d8e57-256a-49f0-ad64-3ca3424c5088","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-10-27T19:28:06","year":2014,"place":"cy","dataset":"statistics","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Unsure","bulk":"No","openlicense":"Unsure","uptodate":"Unsure","url":"https://www.cystat.gov.cy/","format":".xls .pdf","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Lots of statistics available, could be kept more up-to-date possibly/ more open formats.","details":"You can view the data without paying, but there are charges for some datasets and reports. Data is mixed, between percentages and whole numbers. Some data is machine-readable, some is not. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Andreas P","score":35},{"id":"f596eded-6439-4637-ac1f-29916ca903a5","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-08T10:41:25","year":2015,"place":"es","dataset":"statistics","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"No","openlicense":"Unsure","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.ine.es","format":"CSV","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"PIB. Tasa de Paro. Población residente en España.","publisher":"Instituto Nacional de Estadística","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Updated data but not openly licensed.","details":"Below the direct link to the three dataset to match the evaluation criteria:\r\n\r\n* [GDP for the whole country][1], updated quarterly.\r\n* [Unemployment statistics][2], updated quarterly not monthly.\r\n* [Population][3] updated at once a year.\r\n\r\nThe Unemployment Statistics aren't updated monthly but quarterly.\r\n\r\n\r\n [1]: https://www.ine.es/jaxi/menu.do?type=pcaxis&path=%2Ft35%2Fp009&file=inebase&L=0\r\n [2]: https://www.ine.es/dyngs/INEbase/es/operacion.htm?c=Estadistica_C&cid=1254736176918&menu=ultiDatos&idp=1254735976595\r\n\r\nLicense is unclear - \"Denaturalising the sense of the information is expressly prohibited\" \r\nhttps://www.ine.es/ss/Satellite?c=Page&p=1254735849170&pagename=Ayuda%2FINELayout&cid=1254735849170&L=1#\r\n [3]: https://www.ine.es/inebaseDYN/cp30321/cp_inicio.htm","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Mor Rubinstein","reviewer":"Zach Christensen","score":60},{"id":"49b64db9-71f5-47b1-aca2-819a80ce4a83","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-25T08:06:15","year":2015,"place":"za","dataset":"map","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Unsure","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"1:250 000 Topo-Cadastral maps","publisher":"National Geo-spatial Information, a component of the Dept of Rural Development and Land Reform","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"I have reviewed the data and it seems correct.","details":"National Geo-spatial Information (NGI), a component of Department of Rural Development and Land Reform (DRDLR) commenced with the establishment of an integrated survey system and provision of extensive mapping coverage of the country. NGI is also known as South Africa's national mapping organisation.\r\n","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Greg Kempe","reviewer":"Gil Zaretzer","score":10},{"id":"55307f8d-fff9-47cc-9a14-afc070ba7fdd","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-12-16T10:17:12","year":2015,"place":"sk","dataset":"postcodes","exists":"No","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Review is ok ","details":"Slovak Republic is a small country, so there is only about 10^4 different postcodes altogether. List of those can be obtained from Slovak Post Office at https://www.posta.sk/stranky/postove-smerovacie-cisla . License is not clearly stated and there is Copyright notice at the page providing the download so \"no\" is filled.\r\n\r\nLatitude and longitude information is not provided in the data source but other data source (https://zbgis.skgeodesy.sk/tkgis/default.aspx - intended for users, no API) can be used to locate towns (but not streets). Thus the data is considered as NOT available.\r\n\r\n**Data was submitted by Fair Play Alliance and Jano Suchal**","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":0},{"id":"990bdff8-e833-45f9-b3d0-1d75b2662d85","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-11T14:47:18","year":2015,"place":"mx","dataset":"elections","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"No","openlicense":"Unsure","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://computos2015.ine.mx/Nacional/VotosPorPartido/","format":".csv, .pdf","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Instituto Nacional Electoral","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The bulk download option does not exist.","details":"Database is not on it's most detailed level. Vote counts basis are at a ballot level, not at a vote by vote detail. Not openly licensed because no license can be found, only copyright statement. \r\n\r\n10/01/2014 - No change from 2013 in detail level. Changed web adress. Added XLS. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Mor Rubinstein","reviewer":"Kamil Gregor","score":60},{"id":"f3a55a6f-7ae2-4f98-a6e1-b4fad76c5d1b","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-05T18:15:10","year":2015,"place":"ca","dataset":"budget","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.tbs-sct.gc.ca/ems-sgd/esp-pbc/me-bpd-eng.asp","format":"Excel, PDF, HTML","licenseurl":"https://open.canada.ca/en/open-government-licence-canada","officialtitle":"Government Expenditure Plan and Main Estimates (Parts I and II)","publisher":"Treasury Board of Canada","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Submission is correct. ","details":"The data for the most recent year is updated monthly.\r\nThe annual budget data is avaible back to FY 2009.\r\nThe data is available grouped in three ways (in French and English):\r\n - Statutory forecasts\r\n - Expenditures by Strategic Outcome and Program \r\n - Expenditures by Standard Object \r\nThe data is available in Excel (.xls) formats. (No change from 2014)","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"Mor Rubinstein","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":100},{"id":"4b277939-db55-4e71-bd7c-a41633c4c02f","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-26T21:06:32","year":2015,"place":"cm","dataset":"postcodes","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Data on Administrative Boundaries (Zipcode database not available in Cameroon)","publisher":"Cameroon National Institute of Cartography","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"ok","details":"There is no national zipcode system in use in Cameroon. The Government has a project with the African Development Bank to build such a database for 2015 year.\r\nBut there is data of the national administrative boundaries, produced by the National Institute of Cartography.\r\nThis institute produces even guides for regions, cities and villages. But these guides aren't free of charge.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Charlie Martial NGOUNOU","reviewer":"Idriss TINTO","score":20},{"id":"9e038226-cb75-44b6-8d82-00a70704f579","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-26T20:35:43","year":2015,"place":"cm","dataset":"legislation","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.prc.cm/fr/multimedia/documents","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Cameroon Laws and decrees ","publisher":"Presidency of the Republic","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The data is not available in bulk.","details":"Laws and regulations are published in various websites... \r\n\r\nPrime Minister's Office\r\nhttps://www.spm.gov.cm/fr/documentation/lois.html\r\nVery outdated\r\n\r\nNational Assembly \r\nhttps://www.assnat.cm/index.php/fr/les-lois/les-lois-adoptees\r\nThis is very outdated\r\n\r\nPresidency of the Republic\r\nThis is the most updated as it is easy to see that last laws published are from September. Even last speeches of the President of the Republic is online. That's why I think the last question of this survey deserves a YES.\r\nhttps://www.prc.cm/fr/multimedia/documents\r\n","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Charlie Martial NGOUNOU","reviewer":"Kamil Gregor","score":45},{"id":"0e48699c-f9c3-4e07-8699-8cd9c2e04dc4","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-13T10:25:29","year":2015,"place":"cm","dataset":"statistics","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"https://www.statistics-cameroon.org/manager.php?id=8","format":"CSV, XLS, MDB, DBF, PDF","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Online access to various data, informations and publications published by the National Institute of Statistics of Cameroon","publisher":"Institut National de la Statistique du Comeroun","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Data not timely or openly licensed.","details":"The National Institute of Statistics has some information that is regularly updated like inflation rate, economic growth, GDP and other economics indicators. But population data are not regularly updated (not once a year).\r\nhttps://www.stat.cm/downloads/2015/CNT_INS_Cameroun_T1_2015.pdf\r\n\r\nSee also the data portal [here][1]. \r\n\r\n\r\n [1]: https://cameroon.africadata.org/fr/Reports","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Zach Christensen","score":60},{"id":"ef5a9ade-0607-46ff-8274-514888072c7f","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-13T10:24:37","year":2015,"place":"cm","dataset":"map","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Unsure","free":"No","machinereadable":"Unsure","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Cameroon National Map (Administrative Map - Topographic Map - Road Map)","publisher":"National Institute of Cartography","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Everything seems correct, only that I didn't find anything to suggest they offer online, and machine readable files, they offer hardcopys, so I'm changing these two answers to unsure.","details":"The most complete, detailed and up-to-date maps in Cameroon have to be found at the National Institute of Cartography. \r\n\r\nIt is a public body in charge of conception and construction of map, either administrative map, road map, topographic map or geodesic map. It is also in charge of handling the production specific map according to anyone purpose or goal. It may be a map or a monograph for a specific locality, for a council, etc. with any type of information one might need.\r\n\r\nBut the problem is that they charge a fee for accessing maps. All their maps are up-to-date.\r\n\r\nwww.inc-cameroun.cm/","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Gil Zaretzer","score":35},{"id":"673cb379-dabc-424a-bc37-971a64ec7ccb","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-13T10:24:13","year":2015,"place":"cm","dataset":"companies","exists":"Unsure","digital":"Unsure","public":"Unsure","online":"Unsure","free":"Unsure","machinereadable":"Unsure","bulk":"Unsure","openlicense":"Unsure","uptodate":"Unsure","url":"https://www.statistics-cameroon.org/news.php?id=136","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The information available on Cameroon companies is very piecemeal and spread out, therefore it is hard to know which is the most authoritative dataset or which to fill out the criteria for. (The link given in the submission was broken and also appeared to be for 2012). But the details provide a lot of information which is useful on its own.","details":"At the Cameroon National Institute of Statistics, this information is organized for investors and this might explain why it is so incomplete. It concerns only companies having a turnover over 100 millions per year (Official source)\r\nSource : https://www.stat.cm/downloads/liste_entreprise_2012_fr.pdf\r\n\r\nMining companies are to be found elsewhere, especially in the EITI-Cameroon website (Official source).\r\nSource : https://www.eiticameroon.org/index.php/les-industries-extractives/les-societes-minieres\r\n\r\nOil companies are to be found in another link in the same EITI-Cameroon website (Official source)\r\nhttps://www.eiticameroon.org/index.php/fr/les-industries-extractives/les-societes-petrolieres\r\n\r\nThe Chamber for commerce, industry, mining and craft (CCIMA) is responsible for the collection and diffusion of information on companies in Cameroon (1). \r\nThe eRegulation service maintained by the Ministry of SMEs, Solidarity Economy and Crafts (MINPMEESA) offers information for registration for specific councils but there is no centralized process yet (2). \r\nA project on the creation of a central database was mentioned in a 2009 report but there is no evidence such an exhaustive register is operational (3). \r\nFinally, the Statistics Institute conducted a Census of Companies in 2009 but it does not provide the list of the companies, the results provided are only about statistics on these companies (4).\r\n\r\n(1) CCIMA, https://www.ccima.net/present_fr.php Accessed on 2014-07-03 (Official source)\r\n(2) Cameroon eRegulations, https://cameroun.eregulations.org/ Accessed on 2014-07-03 (Official source)\r\n(3) Observatoire Economique et Statistique d'Afrique Subsaharienne, Atelier sur le traitement des statistiques d'entreprises, February 2009, https://www.afristat.org/contenu/doc_travail_experts/Com_Repertoire-Final_publication.pdf Accessed on 2014-07-03\r\n(4) INS Cameroun, Recensement Général des Entreprises (RGE2009),https://www.statistics-cameroon.org/news.php?id=78 Accessed on 2014-09-09\" (Official source)\r\n\r\nStatus:\r\n\"There are some lists of companies that are shared but these lists are not complete at all. The Chamber for commerce, industry, mining and craft (CCIMA) maintains a database on industrial companies in the country. The database only have 63 companies registered though, on a voluntary basis. It is possible to export the data in Excel file (1). The CCIMA also provides another listing on its website (1) but there are less than 400 companies available and there is no possibility to export the data easily.\r\n\r\n(1) Base de données sur les entreprises industrielles du Cameroun (CCIMA), https://www.pointsbiz.com/projets/ccima4/entrepriselist.php \r\n(2) CCIMA, Annuaire des entreprises du Cameroun, https://www.ccima.net/annuaire_fr.php\r\n","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Rebecca Sentance","score":0},{"id":"e2550f93-0990-4b75-a354-ef429b83ee3c","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-13T10:23:38","year":2015,"place":"cm","dataset":"elections","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"https://www.elecam.cm/uploads/media/RAPPORT_LEGISLATIVES_MUNICIPALES_2013_Fr.pdf","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Rapport des élections législatives et municipales de 2013","publisher":"Elections Cameroon","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The submission does not meet the definition. Report in Data location only contains summary results. Also the submission says that data is not available.\r\n","details":"Those data are not available from the 2 entities in charge of the elections process in Cameroon.\r\n\r\nElections Cameroon https://elecam.cm/\r\n\r\nMinistry of Territorial Administration and Decentralization https://minatd.cm/gov/site/en/","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Kamil Gregor","score":45},{"id":"7075a7f4-cc8e-4f09-ab93-c178f02b8fab","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-13T10:22:57","year":2015,"place":"cm","dataset":"spending","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Data on Government Contracts Executed","publisher":"Ministry of Economy, Planning and Regional Development","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Submission fixed (data is not publicly available)","details":"Government spendings reports are still published at end of the following year pending auditing by the Audit bench of the supreme court and the vote by the legislature.\r\n\r\n2014 budget spending report is not yet available when 2013 spendings report was released in December 2014 (https://www.presidenceducameroun.com/news/?lang=fr&mode=newsdetails&id=3635). This is why we have so many \"No\" in this survey.\r\nTo access the spending data, the requester must write to the minister","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Tryggvi Björgvinsson","score":10},{"id":"62b08d02-38e4-48ca-b77e-63698c4f3992","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-13T10:22:32","year":2015,"place":"cm","dataset":"budget","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.minfi.gov.cm/images/documents/loi%20des%20finances%202015.pdf","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Finance law 2015","publisher":"Ministeres des finances/Direction Générale des Impôts","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"I have review the data and it is correct. ","details":"Cameroon Budget is voted every year as per de law and it is made available to Citizens through several means. Since 2013, Cameroon is moving from line item budget to program budgeting, so the Cameroon budget is presented by program for each ministry.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":55},{"id":"1c04ec79-d570-48aa-ae19-96ed04a866cf","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-26T10:09:42","year":2015,"place":"cm","dataset":"timetables","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.camrail.net/guide_horaires_2014_05_28.pdf","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Horaire de trains de la société Camrail","publisher":"CAMRAIL","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"all is ok","details":"Cameroon has a national airline compagny that covers 5 regions over 10, and extension are underway to other regions. There is some transportation companies, we don't know what kind of agreement they have with the Government. At any case no data are available from both concerning public transsport.\r\n","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Charlie Martial NGOUNOU","reviewer":"Idriss TINTO","score":55},{"id":"051e374a-7266-4582-b135-96bb63cf16d2","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-24T06:00:45","year":2015,"place":"sg","dataset":"spending","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Submission fixed.\r\n\r\nIf aggregated data exists it indicates that transactional data does so as well, just not published.","details":"Whilst budget includes some expenditure information (see e.g. https://data.gov.sg/common/search.aspx?q=budget&page=1) there is no detailed transactional information available as far as we have been able to determine (only aggregated).","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Zhi Yuan Lim","reviewer":"Tryggvi Björgvinsson","score":10},{"id":"f4f24c6c-91fe-4b39-8582-cd0227e8b4fa","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-19T15:09:46","year":2015,"place":"sg","dataset":"budget","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Unsure","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.singaporebudget.gov.sg/budget_2015/RevenueandExpenditure.aspx","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"FY2015_Analysis_of_Revenue_and_Expenditure","publisher":"Ministry of Finance","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Since sub departmental expenditure is only available in PDF, I have marked the machine readable section as unsure. ","details":"Material is not open as terms of use at https://www.mof.gov.sg/budget_2013/terms_of_use.html state \"Except as otherwise provided, the Contents of this Site shall not be reproduced, republished, uploaded, posted, transmitted or otherwise distributed in any way, without the prior permission of MOF. To use any parts of the Contents of this Site, the user must seek permission in writing, stating the Contents for use; intent of use; manner of use; time frame of use and identity of the user. MOF reserves the right to refuse permission without declaring reason(s); and/or if information submitted by user is deemed insufficient.\"\r\n\r\nThe machine readable data is available in really low level. Sub departmental expenditure is available only in PDF.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Zhi Yuan Lim","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":55},{"id":"fd6b751c-b5ea-467a-a751-a52865bdaa4b","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-12T05:16:21","year":2015,"place":"sg","dataset":"timetables","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Bus times","publisher":"Land Transport Authority","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Data is available, but you need jump through a request hoop","details":"The data is accessible via another gov-portal, Land Transport Authority: https://www.mytransport.sg/content/mytransport/home/dataMall.html. Review comment: The data are machine readable and available in real-time streaming, but you need to file a request to get them. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Pieter Colpaert","score":10},{"id":"ef1bfa72-3146-49ea-9b69-fff76bc2298a","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-07T15:38:31","year":2015,"place":"pr","dataset":"spending","exists":"No","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Submission is correct. Clarification added.","details":"There is an up to date contract database at the Office of the Comptroller's website and at data.pr.gov, but no detailed records of spending at a detailed transactional level. According to [a note](https://www.hacienda.pr.gov/sites/default/files/msrb-emmacommnotice-auditedfinstat.pdf) around the auditing of the government's fiscal statements the government has failed to produce the data for the last fiscal year. Therefore it seems that the data does not exist.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Mor Rubinstein","reviewer":"Tryggvi Björgvinsson","score":0},{"id":"68073754-0690-4548-a376-f0ea19aa2ca9","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-20T07:49:03","year":2015,"place":"gr","dataset":"emissions","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"https://www.ypeka.gr/Default.aspx?tabid=708&language=en","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Daily Bulletin Atmospheric Pollution","publisher":"ministry of environment & enegry","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"checked","details":"no data for VOCs","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Charalampos Bratsas","reviewer":"yar michl","score":35},{"id":"3f437394-ec51-4061-bb7f-2473e9c1e5b7","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-18T10:32:59","year":2015,"place":"gr","dataset":"map","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"Unsure","bulk":"Unsure","openlicense":"Unsure","uptodate":"Unsure","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"THE HELLENIC MILITARY GEOGRAPHICAL SERVICE (HMGS)","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"I found that the link supplied here at first doesn't qualify as the data we are looking for, but, the THE HELLENIC MILITARY GEOGRAPHICAL SERVICE (HMGS) offers an e-shop for maps and data which seem to cover our needs, since I could not varify the data itself many questions are left unsure, however I am positive the data exists, even digitaly, and open to the public for a price, and some of it is online to view but not to save.\r\nlink to the e-shop: https://web.gys.gr/portal/page?_pageid=33,46034&_dad=portal&_schema=PORTAL\r\nlink to the viewer: https://web.gys.gr/GeoSearch_EN/","details":" ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Charalampos Bratsas","reviewer":"Gil Zaretzer","score":15},{"id":"4c9f8e67-6192-4dae-a5f3-3ce53f1162b0","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-18T12:27:59","year":2015,"place":"gr","dataset":"legislation","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.et.gr/","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"National Printing Office","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The data is not available in bulk.","details":"According to Law 3861/2010, article 7 /τ.Α΄112 -13.7.2010 all laws, Ministerial Decrees, Presidential Decrees and other regulation of Greece become available online for free through the website of the National Printing Office. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Charalampos Bratsas","reviewer":"Kamil Gregor","score":45},{"id":"d3a5e88f-f5e3-4223-87ad-d2e4766897fb","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-22T08:05:45","year":2015,"place":"gr","dataset":"companies","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"Unsure","uptodate":"No","url":"https://www.businessportal.gr/search_name.php","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"General Commercial Register","publisher":"General Secretariat of Commerce, Ministry of Development","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Same rationale used as with China - companies register can be browsed and does contain company details, though the number of search results makes its usefulness very limited in truth.","details":"It is possible to search for company names and details, or to browse the register by inputting a space as the search term, up to a limit of 20 results. The limit to the number of results displayed is a severe logistical limitation to using the database. There are also no address details given for the companies retrieved.\r\n\r\nA more full company register can be found and searched here: https://www.et.gr/index.php/2013-01-28-14-06-23/search-ae-epe-issue-with-publisher-criteria but it still requires inputting a search term with a minimum of 4 characters to access data. It is possible to view company documentation by clicking on the company name, and download it in PDF form.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Charalampos Bratsas","reviewer":"Rebecca Sentance","score":35},{"id":"c9c9a316-5e48-42d6-a200-e1a905712601","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-18T08:59:03","year":2015,"place":"gr","dataset":"water","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Unsure","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"https://www.moh.gov.gr/articles/health/dieythynsh-dhmosias-ygieinhs/ygieinh-periballontos/prostasia-poiothtas-ydatwn/prostasia-neroy-anthrwpinhs-katanalwshs/1317-ekthesh-trietias-2008-2010-gia-thn-poiothta-toy-posimoy-neroy-se-perioxes-poy-eksyphretoyn-perissoteroys-apo-5000-katoikoys-symfwna-me-stoixeia-twn-ypeythynwn-ydreyshs-o-t-a-d-e-y-a-k-lp","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Water Quality Protection, Human Consumption","publisher":"Ministry of Public Health","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The submitter's links didn't point to water quality data that matched the parameters. While Greece's water supply and quality is management by decentralized municipal companies, it is reported to the Ministry of Health and then reported to the EU> ","details":"For Bathing Water\r\nUntil 2013 the data published on the website geodata.gov.gr\r\nhttps://geodata.gov.gr/geodata/index.php?option=com_sobi2&sobi2Task=sobi2Details&catid=30&sobi2Id=237&Itemid=\r\n\r\nAlso there are some data for 2014 but not public available in \r\nhttps://cdr.eionet.europa.eu/gr/eu/nbwd/envvjao5w/
\r\nFor Drinking Water\r\nThere are some data for 2013 in\r\nhttps://cdr.eionet.europa.eu/gr/eu/dwd/","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Charalampos Bratsas","reviewer":"Nisha Thompson","score":20},{"id":"946d2a5d-3846-4e22-888a-b81da4935654","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-17T09:37:52","year":2015,"place":"gr","dataset":"land","exists":"Yes","digital":"Unsure","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"Unsure","bulk":"Unsure","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Unsure","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"What is the Cadastre? It is a complete registration of all real properties and the (registrable) rights these bear across Greece; the aim of the Cadastre is to protect and consolidate these rights. The cadastre does not involve any tax inspection sense.","publisher":"National cadastre & mapping agency SA","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The provided link https://www.ktimatologio.gr/sites/en/Pages/Default.aspx does not lead to the actual cadastral data, nor a view / discover service of a geoportal. ","details":"The NATIONAL CADASTRE & MAPPING AGENCY S.A. company is a Legal Entity of Private Law and its mission is the study, development and operation of the Hellenic Cadastre.\r\n\r\nThe company was founded with a joint decision of the Minister of Economy and Finance and the Minister of Environment, Physical Planning and Public Works (Decision 81706/6085/6-10-1995/Government Gazette 872Β/19-10-1995). NCMA S.A. operates according to the rules of private finance and the provisions of article 5 of Law 2229/1994, of the coded Law 2190/1920, of Law 2308/1995 and Law Ν.2664/1998, as these stand today. Furthermore, the company does not fall under the class of organizations and businesses of the broader state sector; regulations that concern companies directly or indirectly owned by the State do not apply to NCMA S.A.\r\n\r\nThe sole shareholder of the company is the Ministry of Environment, Energy and Climate Change.\r\n","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Isidoros Passas","reviewer":"Codrina Maria Ilie","score":5},{"id":"4d1cc9aa-601c-4380-97b3-11d4b08e3835","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-18T12:27:01","year":2015,"place":"gr","dataset":"statistics","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"https://www.statistics.gr/portal/page/portal/ESYE","format":"Excel, CSV, PDF","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"The Hellenic Statistical Authority collects data which concern population, employment and unemployment, tourism and the economy, industry, as well as data concerning health and social insurance, education and others","publisher":"Hellenic Statistical Authority, ELSTAT (Greek: ΕΛ.ΣΤΑΤ)","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Data on population are not current or openly licensed.","details":"","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Charalampos Bratsas","reviewer":"Zach Christensen","score":60},{"id":"9558e67a-fb85-4783-ab55-fb2ef7b8a88e","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-20T08:09:04","year":2015,"place":"gr","dataset":"weather","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.hnms.gr/","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Hellenic National Meterological Service","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 3 days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.","details":"","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Charalampos Bratsas","reviewer":"Neal Bastek","score":45},{"id":"9452a489-d45a-4ae7-89af-ca136d4222c6","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-17T11:50:43","year":2015,"place":"gr","dataset":"spending","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://opendata.diavgeia.gov.gr","format":"API, json","licenseurl":"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Ministry of Administrative Reform and e-Governance","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Submission is correct","details":"Expenses are published as part of the “Clarity” program of Law 3861/2010, which introduced for the first time in Greece the obligation to publish all the decisions of government and all administrative entities on the Internet. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"Sotiris Karampatakis","reviewer":"Tryggvi Björgvinsson","score":100},{"id":"c17cd562-fff0-49bd-b68e-b7c3d88a411e","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-18T08:12:03","year":2015,"place":"gr","dataset":"procurement","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.eprocurement.gov.gr/actSearch/faces/active_search_main.jspx","format":"Excel","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Title: e - procurement Description: The innovation of the e - procurement platform that has been developed for public authorities in Greece by the General Secretariat of Commerce. This platform will be used in all the sstages of a public procurement procedure, increasing transparency and accelerating public procurement procedures.","publisher":"General Secretariat of Commerce","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Submission correct.","details":"","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Charalampos Bratsas","reviewer":"Georg Neumann","score":70},{"id":"40e038c4-0c55-4911-ac20-ef28463c89d0","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-17T11:56:29","year":2015,"place":"gr","dataset":"elections","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://ekloges.ypes.gr/","format":"HTML ","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Ministry of Interior","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The submission does not meet the definition. Data is available for municipalities, aggregating the votes of up to 400.000 people.","details":"Regarding the election results in Greece the following are valid: available data are not machine readable; not in bulk\r\nand without any license or terms of use. The data are available through a website of a private ICT enterprise.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Sotiris Karampatakis","reviewer":"Kamil Gregor","score":45},{"id":"ab7fa815-6d00-4c79-bac4-dd5587506f74","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-12T15:49:45","year":2015,"place":"gr","dataset":"budget","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"https://www.minfin.gr/?q=el/content/%CE%BA%CF%81%CE%B1%CF%84%CE%B9%CE%BA%CF%8C%CF%82-%CF%80%CF%81%CE%BF%CF%8B%CF%80%CE%BF%CE%BB%CE%BF%CE%B3%CE%B9%CF%83%CE%BC%CF%8C%CF%82-2015","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Greek Goverment Budget","publisher":"Hellenic Parliament","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"I have checked the data and it is correct. ","details":"The General Accounting Office is responsible for the dissemination and publicity of the Annual Budget. Unfortunately, the General Accounting office has chosen to publish the related data in formats, which essentially prevents further use of this information by the public. The annual budget is published as unstructured PDF documents, while the internal breakdown formations change almost every year. This makes comparisons of actual spending with the budget , particularly difficult. Some experimental projects have been made using data scraping techniques , however, for a reliable and efficient solution the General Accounting Office should re-evaluate the data publishing policies applied. \r\n\r\nQA note: Changed to data is not opened. Copyright - Treasury © 2014 ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Mor Rubinstein","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":35},{"id":"e5525d67-f34f-4138-aea9-f324378be674","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-28T05:38:03","year":2015,"place":"ua","dataset":"spending","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://spending.gov.ua/","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Government Spending in Ukraine","publisher":"Ministry of Finance","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Submission is correct","details":"Ministry of Finance has launched the transparency project named eData which is primarily focused on publishing transactions of the National Treasury.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Tryggvi Björgvinsson","score":45},{"id":"cf5a9f95-4f2a-43d6-a1fd-8a28e6ae27de","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-19T16:25:31","year":2015,"place":"id","dataset":"companies","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://data.go.id/dataset/direktori-perusahaan-industri-indonesia","format":"CSV","licenseurl":"https://data.go.id/persyaratan-penggunaan.html","officialtitle":"Directory of Industrial Companies in Indonesia - A downloadable dataset of Indonesian companies","publisher":"Indonesian Ministry of Industry","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Ticks all the boxes! Well done, Indonesia! ;)","details":"This dataset gives a more extensive list of limited companies which includes both state-owned as well as private enterprises, and across sectors.\r\n\r\nThe dataset consists of company names, address and locations, and the type of industry. It can be downloaded as a single CSV file to the user's computer without restrictions, and is openly licensed. \r\n","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"Yefta Sutanto","reviewer":"Rebecca Sentance","score":100},{"id":"eba81cae-a480-46ce-8d62-a1e96604ac66","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-17T12:42:02","year":2015,"place":"bg","dataset":"companies","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"No","online":"Yes","free":"No","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.brra.bg/","format":"XML, WSDL","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Агенция по вписванията (Registration Agency, under the auspices of the Ministry of Justice)","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"I have marked the dataset as not publicly available based on the restrictions to obtaining it. ","details":"The company database can be searched online, but queries are restricted to single entities and captcha. Obtaining the full database costs about 50 EUR. There are still some legal aspects of the bulk download (mostly relating to personal data protection) that are still unclear. Therefore the bulk download and subscription for new users is in effect blocked by the personal data protection agency.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Boyan Yurukov","reviewer":"Rebecca Sentance","score":50},{"id":"229d1843-6be5-4518-86a1-eadd60217202","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-27T21:27:58","year":2015,"place":"bg","dataset":"spending","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://opendata.government.bg/dataset/plashtaniya-v-sebra-i-drugi-plashtania-v-bnb","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Submission fixed.\r\n\r\nCSV format is used but not machine readable. License not specified.","details":"Bugdet payments and spending reports are available on daily basis. File type is CSV but it is constructed in a non-machine readable way. License is not specified but the data is made available on an open data platform (still does not count).","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Boyan Yurukov","reviewer":"Tryggvi Björgvinsson","score":55},{"id":"01cf6360-29de-4cbd-96a3-8c04d8f52f70","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-27T15:27:11","year":2015,"place":"bg","dataset":"procurement","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.aop.bg/","format":"CSV","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Агенция по обществените поръчки/Public Procurement Agency","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"","details":"All documents are available on the website of the agency. They are in somewhat structured form, but are not machine readable. There's no formal schema or definition. Their own dataset has been extended multiple times, so even internally it's hard to figure out a standartised form and values for the data. A [bulk download][1] is avialable via the open data portal of the government.\r\n\r\n\r\n [1]: https://opendata.government.bg/dataset/nhqpopmaunr-3a-ckjiiohehn-dorobopn-njin-pe3yjitatn-ot-npobedehn-kohkypcn-3a-npoekt","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Georg Neumann","reviewer":"Georg Neumann","score":70},{"id":"3d61d721-b039-4e9f-8ae0-5dcca4a4c266","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-27T21:32:20","year":2015,"place":"bg","dataset":"emissions","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://pdbase.government.bg/forms/public_eprtr.jsp","format":"RDF","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"егистър на лицата, притежаващи документи за извършване на дейности с отпадъци","publisher":"Изпълнителна агенция по околната среда и водите","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Changed from unsure to no. \t\r\nCopyright © 2011 Executive Environment Agency (EEA)","details":"The data is available as part of an online registry. It includes information on the industrial/agricultural installations that emit pollution and the pollution generated from each one. The data is submitted to the EEA and can be downloaded as part of the full RDF dataset:\r\nhttps://prtr.ec.europa.eu/pgDownloadDataSet.aspx \r\n\r\n \t\r\nQA reviewer: Copyright © 2011 Executive Environment Agency (EEA)","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Boyan Yurukov","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":70},{"id":"df3077e8-d97d-402b-92c9-3150df13a905","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-27T21:41:04","year":2015,"place":"bg","dataset":"elections","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.cik.bg/","format":"CSV","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The submission is correct.","details":"The data is updated almost in real time as the election results are processed.\r\n\r\nIt is not available in bulk, but the information is in easily scrap-able htmls and sometimes available for download as CSV files.\r\n\r\nThe data was considered non-open as, although the Commission is working towards increasing the amount of machine-readable formats and the respect of interoperability, it does not clearly state what the reuse, modification and distribution conditions are (see here: https://results.cik.bg/pi2014/csv.html).","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Boyan Yurukov","reviewer":"Kamil Gregor","score":70},{"id":"e50149e5-fde7-4957-9677-27b8a30945b0","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-27T21:40:51","year":2015,"place":"bg","dataset":"budget","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.minfin.bg/bg/page/4","format":"Excel","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Ministry of Finance","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Changed data to bulk. Data was up to date, and I changed the timely question to 'YES'. ","details":"The Budget law is promulgated in the State gazette, so it is in the public domain. The PDF is also published on the Ministry of Finances website (see here for 2015: https://www.minfin.bg/bg/page/851).\r\n\r\nThe consolidated budget framework is published on the Finances ministry website, usually as an Excel generated PDF. The available Excel sheets for 2015 are different amendments but their aim is unclear.\r\n\r\nData has been considered unavailable in bulk because each file, be it in machine-readable format or no, has to be downloaded individually. Also, the data has been considered available for free as anyone can access the files and download them from the Ministry's website.\r\n\r\nReviewer's note - Although each excel file needs to be downloaded individually,it is all in one webpage, and we consider that as bulk. For the future, it would be better if all the data was in one spreadsheet. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Boyan Yurukov","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":70},{"id":"ffaf697b-6ad6-4fd1-81f4-c5491c6c63ca","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-11-23T19:59:11","year":2015,"place":"bg","dataset":"water","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"No","url":"https://opendata.government.bg/dataset/danni-ot-edinnata-informatsionna-sistema-voda","format":"CSV","licenseurl":"https://www.opendefinition.org/licenses/cc-zero","officialtitle":"Data on water pollution","publisher":"Министерство на околната среда и водите | Ministry of the environment and water","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Data wasn't updated in a timely way.","details":"The data is published regularly on the Bulgarian government opendata portal.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"Nisha Thompson","reviewer":"Nisha Thompson","score":90},{"id":"d40e3dd4-6cd6-4594-a9ba-82ee4518a696","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-08-30T19:03:42","year":2015,"place":"eg","dataset":"weather","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"https://ema.gov.eg/pdf/4df.png","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Weather / Four Days Forecast","publisher":"Egyptian Meteorological Authority (EMA, https://ema.gov.eg/) ","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 4 days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.","details":"The Egyptian Meteorological Authority publishes temperature readings for Egypt main cities. [https://ema.gov.eg/] It also published forecasts of temperature, humidity and wind speed for the upcoming 4 (not 5) days. [https://ema.gov.eg/pdf/4df.png]\r\n\r\nThey do not publish precipitation on the same website, but humidity instead, which I think is fine as rain is rare in most of Egypt, and precipitation is not really useful to citizens most of the time. Nevertheless, the precipitation forecast can be found on NWP website which belongs to the same authority. [https://nwp.gov.eg/index.php/wrf/preciptation]\r\n\r\nHistorical Data was not found on the website, however, it temperature, humidity and windspeed charts are found as part of the Pollution Reports published by NWP. [https://nwp.gov.eg/index.php/reports-enviromental]. It worth mentioning that this data is not available in reports since October 2014, thus we marked the dataset as not provided on a timely and up to date basis. \r\n","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Neal Bastek","score":35},{"id":"255402e9-deaa-44f1-8524-bb87f02a208e","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-14T15:34:12","year":2015,"place":"co","dataset":"budget","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.dnp.gov.co/programas/inversiones-y-finanzas-publicas/Datos-y-Estadisticas/Paginas/presupuesto-de-inversi%C3%B3n.aspx","format":"Excel","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Presupuesto de Inversión: Contiene el detalle del proyecto del presupuesto de Inversión presentado para aprobación del Congreso, el seguimiento a la Inversión y la Evolución histórica de la misma.","publisher":"Departamento Nacional de Planeación, Manuel Fernando Castro, Subdirector Territorial y de Inversión Pública, mfcastro@dnp.gov.co","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"There is no license on this data, the linked licensed was about privacy policy. Marked license as not open. ","details":"The link to license does not mention any rights to private or public use, it is just a privacy policy - https://www.dnp.gov.co/Paginas/Pol%C3%ADtica-de-privacidad.aspx","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Juan Felipe Devia Rodriguez","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":70},{"id":"e0ae37c4-c539-48cd-b3e4-7da7c183bd5a","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-18T13:56:00","year":2015,"place":"ro","dataset":"elections","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.roaep.ro/istoric/","format":"XLS","licenseurl":"https://data.gov.ro/base/images/logoinst/OGL-ROU-1.0.pdf","officialtitle":"Election results","publisher":"Permanent Electoral Authority","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The submission is correct.","details":"The Romanian Permanent Electoral Authority set up a portal where the results of the elections can be retrieved in XLS format. Usually, the results are published immediately after their validation by the Constitutional Court. Only the results of the more recent elections (after 2004) are available in re-usable format. Although the data is not explicitly licensed on their website, the datasets with the most recent elections (2009+) are also available on the Government's Open Data Portal - https://data.gov.ro/organization/autoritatea-electorala-permanenta - thus the positive answer to the specific question.\r\n\r\nThe data can be downloaded for each scrutiny from separate pages. The Authority also set up a page where all data is available, including online viewers, at https://alegeri.roaep.ro/, but it is working intermittently. \r\n\r\n","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"Ovidiu Voicu","reviewer":"Kamil Gregor","score":100},{"id":"f6ac4282-9f85-4ec9-9755-f1f6e41de391","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-11-28T04:32:10","year":2014,"place":"ro","dataset":"timetables","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://data.gov.ro/dataset/mers-tren-sntfc-cfr-calatori-s-a","format":"XML","licenseurl":"https://data.gov.ro/base/images/logoinst/OGL-ROU-1.0.pdf","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"Railway passenger operator SNTFC ","publisher":"S.C. Informatica Feroviara S.A. (data.gov.ro)","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"I have reviewed this entry, I accept the content, I have added descriptive text from the publisher's website translated with the use of Google Translate.","details":"The information refers only to national railway system (public company). There is no national bus company. The data was published recently on the government's open data portal data.gov.ro.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"Tracey P. Lauriault","reviewer":"Tracey P. Lauriault","score":100},{"id":"d3aa7076-4c2f-4bfd-8986-50fbdf58e6af","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-21T02:41:29","year":2015,"place":"hk","dataset":"postcodes","exists":"Unsure","digital":"Unsure","public":"Unsure","online":"Unsure","free":"Unsure","machinereadable":"Unsure","bulk":"Unsure","openlicense":"Unsure","uptodate":"Unsure","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"ok","details":"postcodes/zipcodes not used so this dataset does not apply. \r\nhttps://futurehandling.com/2012/11/12/why-doesnt-hong-kong-have-postal-codes/ \r\nThis category discriminates on all the countries and territories that do not have postcodes (>60 https://gist.github.com/kennwilson/3902548). China uses one postcode for all of Hong Kong (999077) so sent a FOI request to see if that was listed anywhere on a HKgov website and if could be used as a postcode for HK. This was the response\r\nhttps://accessinfo.hk/en/request/postal_code_information_for_hong\r\n\r\nThey said to use this page:\r\nSee also: https://www.hongkongpost.hk/eng/postage/info/index.htm#addressing\r\n\r\nReview - did not identified any official admin boundaries. Not endorsed admin boundaries are available here https://www.gadm.org/download. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"S.C. Edmunds","reviewer":"Codrina Maria Ilie","score":0},{"id":"ee6d3f49-d406-4f48-b74a-cb9d29b3332b","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-23T08:03:28","year":2015,"place":"hk","dataset":"land","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Unsure","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Digital land boundary map","publisher":"Survey and mapping office (SMO) ","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"ok","details":"The Lands Department in Hong Kong is very proprietary of its data. Several FOI requests to other departments (accessinfo.hk) have shown that the Lands Department's strong licensing prevents release of all manner of data.\r\n\r\nBoundary information does appear to be recorded and stored in digital format, but not free to access: https://www.landsd.gov.hk/mapping/en/digital_map/mapprod.htm\r\n\r\nIt is possible for citizens to search a database for details pertaining to very specific plots of land (building number is needed using the 'street search' facility), but this is limited - not finding my entire office block and not providing any information other than the building name for the block of flats I live in. Search facility is here: https://www2.iris.gov.hk/eservices/searchlandregister/search.jsp ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Rob Davidson","reviewer":"Codrina Maria Ilie","score":10},{"id":"58982c76-7433-4211-84b0-e5822ac39020","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-16T06:10:21","year":2015,"place":"hk","dataset":"companies","exists":"Yes","digital":"Unsure","public":"No","online":"Unsure","free":"No","machinereadable":"Unsure","bulk":"Unsure","openlicense":"Unsure","uptodate":"Yes","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Cyber Search Centre of the Companies Register","publisher":"Companies Registry, crenq@cr.gov.hk","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Changed most criteria to \"unsure\" as it is not possible to know without paying charges.","details":"It is not possible to search the registry or view any company data without paying a fee. Details of the fees are made available at: https://www.icris.cr.gov.hk/csci/chargeRate.do","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Rob Davidson","reviewer":"Rebecca Sentance","score":15},{"id":"a3a07aa7-69b2-4a7b-ae97-cce1027bb044","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-21T02:51:14","year":2015,"place":"hk","dataset":"water","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"https://www.wsd.gov.hk/en/water_resources/water_quality/water_quality_monitoring_data/index.html","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Water Quality Monitoring Data ","publisher":"Water Supplies Department","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Approving this submission, reports contain the parameters. ","details":"Only have yearly pdfs and nothing in data.gov.hk from this department yet. These are the 2014-2015 files:\r\n\r\nhttps://www.wsd.gov.hk/filemanager/en/content_135/drinking_a-e.pdf\r\nhttps://www.wsd.gov.hk/filemanager/en/content_135/drinking_b-e.pdf","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"S.C. Edmunds","reviewer":"Nisha Thompson","score":35},{"id":"cb661934-97cf-4bce-ab4e-017c7d03ea7c","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-23T04:01:21","year":2015,"place":"hk","dataset":"legislation","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.legislation.gov.hk/blis/eng/index.html","format":"HTML; PDF","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Department of Justice","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The submission is correct.","details":" In this case, the questions about 'available in bulk' and 'open licensing' are very pertinent. As per the terms of use (https://www.legislation.gov.hk/blis/eng/cr.html ), \"downloading a large amount of Legislation from BLIS by program in one go\" is not allowed. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Rob Davidson","reviewer":"Kamil Gregor","score":45},{"id":"098a5b6f-38ca-4f9b-95be-5ba56f87e30f","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-23T07:01:13","year":2015,"place":"hk","dataset":"procurement","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.fstb.gov.hk/tb/en/tender-notices.htm","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"The Treasury Branch. Financial Services and the Treasury Bureau","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Submission updated with award information. ","details":"The award information is available at https://www.gldetb.gov.hk/\r\n","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Rob Davidson","reviewer":"Georg Neumann","score":45},{"id":"cda1a98f-54c8-4152-b9c5-7ff7e2990017","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-23T03:09:54","year":2015,"place":"hk","dataset":"map","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Unsure","url":"https://www.landsd.gov.hk/mapping/en/download/openmaps.htm","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Digital Topographic Map (B100k-OM)","publisher":"Survey and Mapping Office , Lands Department","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The data is digital, public, free, online, and available in bulk, however, it is not machine readable, or openly licensed, and it is unclear as to updates. ","details":"**Digital Topographic Map (B100k-OM)**\r\nThe B100k-OM is a topographic map of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region. It shows the key geographical features and is suitable for map applications in 1:100 000 scale. The image for download is geo-referenced to the local coordinate system in Hong Kong 1980 Grid. \r\n\r\n**Digital Orthophoto Map (DOPM100-L0-OM)**\r\nThe DOPM100-L0-OM is an orthophoto map of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region. It is mosaicked from geometrically rectified aerial photographs and constructed for measurement accurate to 1:100 000 scale. The image for download is geo-referenced to the local coordinate system in Hong Kong 1980 Grid. (Remark: The area beyond the Hong Kong territory is produced from Landsat-7 satellite image.)","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Rob Davidson","reviewer":"Gil Zaretzer","score":45},{"id":"377f29d9-838d-4fd4-be02-cbe58235339a","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-23T04:06:08","year":2015,"place":"hk","dataset":"emissions","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://epic.epd.gov.hk/EPICDI/air/station/?lang=en","format":"CSV","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Inquire and Download Air Quality Monitoring Data","publisher":"Environment Protection Bureau","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"checked\r\n","details":"This year I've updated the 'available in bulk' to 'no' because the web form requires a minimum of 300 submissions to extract all the data - as per this ongoing FOI request: https://accessinfo.hk/en/request/collated_air_quality_data\r\n\r\nNB: the FOI response is currently asking for a large sum to provide the data in bulk, but I have not altered the 'available for free' setting from 'yes' because in theory, the data is available for free if you are willing to use the web form sufficient times.\r\n\r\nAir quality Index data (which is based upon the raw data from air quality monitoring network) is available at: \r\nhttps://www.aqhi.gov.hk/epd/ddata/html/out/24aqhi_Eng.xml\r\n\r\nall Pollution are measured except for VOCs","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Rob Davidson","reviewer":"yar michl","score":60},{"id":"396137b7-e916-46ae-a9ac-ab1bfdd36719","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-21T02:59:32","year":2015,"place":"hk","dataset":"weather","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Unsure","url":"https://www.hko.gov.hk/cis/climat_e.htm","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Climatological Database access via the Climatological Information Services page","publisher":"Hong Kong Observatory","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 5+ days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.","details":"RSS data via https://data.gov.hk/en-data/provider/hk-hko and database of historical data here? https://www.hko.gov.hk/cis/climat_e.htm","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"S.C. Edmunds","reviewer":"Neal Bastek","score":35},{"id":"c798ced2-11e5-401d-a7da-f79936ebbadf","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-16T05:59:44","year":2015,"place":"hk","dataset":"elections","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.elections.gov.hk/legco2012/eng/rs_gc.html","format":"HTML, XLS","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Election results (LegCo 2012)","publisher":"Registration and electoral office, Chief electoral officer, reoenq@reo.gov.hk","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The data is available in machine available format in bulk. Detailed data is available in XLS for \"counting stations\" at https://www.elections.gov.hk/legco2012/eng/result/rs_ds.html.","details":"Election results are available for LegCo under the 3 headings of:\r\nGeographical constituencies, District/Functional constituencies and Functional constituencies. \r\nResults are displayed in HTML tables, separated over many pages, one for each constituency. \r\nOddly, results seem to be given as total number of votes received for a block of candidates and then indication of which single candidate from that block was elected - rather than breakdown of votes per candidate. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Rob Davidson","reviewer":"Kamil Gregor","score":70},{"id":"2d9f500f-6b9d-4f03-ad1a-e440c29981d3","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-23T03:34:28","year":2015,"place":"hk","dataset":"statistics","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.censtatd.gov.hk/hkstat/sub/bbs.jsp","format":"XLS, PDF, HTML","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Census and Statistics Department","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Data available but no open license.","details":"\r\n\r\n[Unemployment][1] data\r\n\r\n[GDP][2] data\r\n\r\n[Population][3] data\r\n\r\n\r\n [1]: https://www.censtatd.gov.hk/hkstat/sub/sp200.jsp?tableID=006&ID=0&productType=8\r\n [2]: https://www.censtatd.gov.hk/hkstat/sub/sp250.jsp?tableID=030&ID=0&productType=8\r\n [3]: https://www.censtatd.gov.hk/hkstat/sub/sp150.jsp?tableID=001&ID=0&productType=8","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Rob Davidson","reviewer":"Zach Christensen","score":70},{"id":"6d99a6c2-cb67-4f18-8f18-3f4674d7ee6f","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-23T10:48:27","year":2015,"place":"in","dataset":"weather","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://202.54.31.7/citywx/localwx.php","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Weather Forecast - India Meteorological Department (IMD) is the National Meteorological Service of the country and the principal government agency in all matters relating to meteorology, seismology and allied subjects. It takes meteorological observations and provides current and forecast meteorological information for optimum operation of weather-sensitive activities like agriculture, irrigation, shipping, aviation, offshore oil explorations, etc.","publisher":"Indian Meteorological Department","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"I changed the license entry from 'unsure' to 'no' because commercial use is not allowed (https://www.imd.gov.in/doc/nccraindata.pdf), but otherwise this submission is accepted as is.","details":"The observational data recorded at various types of surface and upper air observatories, are scrutinised and archived at the National Data Centre, Pune. It has approximately 8 billion characters of data storage which includes ship data and rainfall data of State raingauges spanning over a century. The statistics thus compiled are periodically revised and updated. The archives form the basis for computation of means, normals, frequencies and other derived parameters, for their analysis and interpretation, and for the preparation of district and state climate summaries and atlases. It makes weather forcast for the country and upto the level of cities (https://202.54.31.7/citywx/localwx.php and https://www.indiaweather.gov.in/ - National Weather section) .","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Neal Bastek","score":45},{"id":"4446f4cd-1e5c-49e6-b1cf-15bacf0d2a95","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-18T11:27:37","year":2015,"place":"in","dataset":"spending","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Controller General of Accounts - Controller General of Accounts is the principal Accounts Adviser to the Government of India and is responsible for establishing and maintaining a technically sound management accounting system. He prepares a critical analysis of expenditures, revenues, borrowings and the deficit for the Finance Minister every month. He also prepares annual Appropriation Accounts (Civil) and Union Finance Accounts for presentation to the parliament.","publisher":"Controller General of Accounts, Ministry of Finance, Government of India","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Submission fixed","details":"National expenditure data is available on the website of Controller General of Accounts, Ministry of Finance at https://cga.nic.in/Forms/Accountingproc.aspx and appropritaion account tab contains ministry and department wise Expenditure data at https://cga.nic.in/forms/List.aspx?Lid=3310&id=36 . The data available on the Controller General of Accounts Website is up to date and totally free for public.\r\nThe OGD India also provides important datasets on government spending and outlays which is totally in the machine readable format. The data available on the Data portal is open for reuse and further study. \r\nData is also available on the Ministry of Finance website \"https://www.finmin.nic.in/the_ministry/dept_expenditure/cca/cca_exp_stat.asp\".\r\n\r\nAll this data is unfortunately aggregated but it does indicated that the data exists and is digital.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Akhilesh Srivastava","reviewer":"Tryggvi Björgvinsson","score":10},{"id":"9eafd848-3c22-4c85-ad2d-cbbc451f46fb","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-18T10:36:04","year":2015,"place":"in","dataset":"land","exists":"Yes","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"Unsure","uptodate":"Yes","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Land Ownership - The National Land Records Modernization Programme (NLRMP) was launched by Government of India in August 2008, aimed to modernize management of land records, land ownership etc through the States which have jurisdiction over landownership.","publisher":"Various State Governments' Revenue or Land Resources Departments","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"We have been unable to find references related to the geometry of the land parcels. Each state offers a search service with the result in the shape of a form, without any geodata. Thus, the data submitted does not comply with the requirements of the 2015 index. ","details":"Land registration is a State Subject according to Constitution of India. However, under e-Governance initiative, the Central government has put in lot of resources to ensure that all land records are computerized at state level, which are in advanced stages of implementation. Links to the landrecords system/websites of the states in India are as under: \r\nGoa: https://dslr.goa.nic.in/f114new.aspx\r\nOdisha : https://bhulekh.ori.nic.in/\r\nUttrakhand : https://devbhoomi.uk.gov.in/\r\nUttar Pradesh : bhulekh.up.nic.in\r\nMadhya Pradesh : https://landrecords.mp.gov.in/newweb/index.html\r\nGujarat : https://anyror.gujarat.gov.in/\r\nRajasthan : https://apnakhata.raj.nic.in/\r\nTamil Nadu : https://edistrict.tn.gov.in/eservicesnew/index.html\r\nKarnataka : https://bhoomi.karnataka.gov.in","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Akhilesh Srivastava","reviewer":"Codrina Maria Ilie","score":15},{"id":"514b71a8-a0a5-4af0-8abb-ddb60c633267","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-10-30T08:45:26","year":2014,"place":"in","dataset":"timetables","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://data.gov.in/catalogs#path=ministry_department/ministry-road-transport-and-highways","format":"","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Changed the source of the license. ","details":"While timetables for trains are commonly available, for other modes of transport we could do with more easily available information. The data provided is public, still there is a \"captcha code\" facility which mandates human intervention in the search process. Due the heavy web traffic these websites are slow functioning. Marked as \"no bulk download\" / \"not easily machine readable\" due to capcha Real time train data is easier to find than timetable data. Cannot find open licence. https://enquiry.indianrail.gov.in/ntes/ -- real time train information\nhttps://www.irctc.co.in/ - some train information \n\nPlease note that erail.in is not an official government source. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"SUSISahoo KUMAR L","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":45},{"id":"ea4bcdf7-8f30-4ec9-ba85-d58f6e7ae3ca","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-18T10:27:16","year":2015,"place":"in","dataset":"legislation","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Unsure","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://indiacode.nic.in/","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Legislation of India - All legislation /Acts are made by Parliament of India. India Code Information System contains all Central Acts of Parliament right from 1836 onwards. The Parliament of India comprises of Rajya Sabha & Lok Sabha, the upper house and lower house. The Lok Sabha secretariat and the Rajya Sabha secretariat publishes all its data starting from its members to the various legislative businesses on their respective websites. All the data published by secretariats have been meticuloustly compiled into a digital package by OGD India. The portal also provides data related to the various state legislative assemblies in India.","publisher":"Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The submission is correct.","details":"All legislation /Acts are made by Parliament of India. India Code Information System contains all Central Acts of Parliament right from 1836 onwards which is available on https://indiacode.nic.in/welcome.htm . The Parliament of India comprises of Rajya Sabha & Lok Sabha, the upper house and lower house. The Lok Sabha secretariat and the Rajya Sabha secretariat publishes all its data starting from its members to the various legislative businesses on their respective websites. All the data published by secretariats have been meticulously compiled into a digital package by OGD India. The portal also provides data related to the various state legislative assemblies in India. The data on India Code Information System is open for public use. The websites of the Rajya Sabha and Lok Sabha clearly mention in their terms and copyright that - \"The material listed may be reproduced without formal permission for the purposes of non-commercial research, private study and for criticism, review and news reporting provided that the material is appropriately attributed.\" Plus OGD India also provides important data related to legislative business which is openly available at https://data.gov.in/catalogs/ministry_department/lok-sabha-secretariat, https://data.gov.in/catalogs/ministry_department/rajya-sabha and https://data.gov.in/catalogs?query=legislation&sort_by=search_api_relevance&sort_order=DESC&items_per_page=20. The data is openly licensed and open for further reuse. Both the Rajya Sabha and Lok Sabha Secretariat update the information regarding the members and legislative business on a timely basis. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Akhilesh Srivastava","reviewer":"Kamil Gregor","score":55},{"id":"04c086a0-5272-48bd-b36f-39ca28db8cae","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-23T07:46:39","year":2015,"place":"in","dataset":"emissions","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://data.gov.in/catalogs?query=air+quality&op=Search&sort_by=search_api_relevance&sort_order=DESC&items_per_page=10","format":"CSV, Excel","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Environmental Information System - Realising the importance of Environmental Information, the Government of India, in December, 1982, established an Environmental Information System (ENVIS) as a plan programme. The focus of ENVIS since inception has been on providing environmental information to decision makers, policy planners, scientists and engineers, research workers, etc. all over the country. Since environment is a broad-ranging, multi-disciplinary subject, a comprehensive information system on environment would necessarlly involve effective participation of concerned institutions/ organisations in the country that are actively engaged in work relating to different subject areas of environment. ENVIS has, therefore, developed itself with a network of such participating institutions/organisations for the programme to be meaningful. ","publisher":"Environmental Information System, Ministry of Environment & Forest, Government of India","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"License - https://data.gov.in/sites/default/files/NDSAP.pdf is not open. Changed the submission. ","details":"OGD India gives an exhaustive amount of data with regard to emission and other related details. The data is in open format and machine readable. Area and pollutant wise air quality can be accesed on Data portal India at https://data.gov.in/catalogs?query=air+quality&op=Search&sort_by=search_api_relevance&sort_order=DESC&items_per_page=10. Real time Ambient Air Quality Data at various locations in the country is available at https://www.cpcb.gov.in/CAAQM/mapPage/frmindiamap.aspx. Data can be easily downloaded in XLS format.\r\ndata for air quality is also available at https://cpcbenvis.nic.in/airpollution/air%20data%202011-2007/AIRTAB.html. \r\nReal time Air Quality data across country is available at https://164.100.43.188/cpcbnew/movie.html and live data of Delhi is also available at https://www.cpcb.gov.in/cpcbpa/index.aspx?state=delhi.\r\n\r\nReviewer's note: the license here - https://data.gov.in/sites/default/files/NDSAP.pdf is not open - does not allow commercial use. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Mor Rubinstein","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":70},{"id":"953e1c47-61bc-4f49-96f7-826449222ad0","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-28T15:47:50","year":2015,"place":"in","dataset":"statistics","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://data.gov.in/catalogs#path=sector/statistics-9382","format":"XLS,CSV","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"National Statistics - The Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation came into existence as an Independent Ministry on 15.10.1999 after the merger of the Department of Statistics and the Department of Programme Implementation. The Ministry has two wings, one relating to Statistics and the other Programme Implementation. The Statistics Wing called the National Statistical Office(NSO) consists of the Central Statistical Office (CSO), the Computer Centre and the National Sample Survey Office (NSSO). The Programme Implementation Wing has three Divisions, namely, (i) Twenty Point Programme (ii) Infrastructure Monitoring and Project Monitoring and (iii) Member of Parliament Local Area Development Scheme. Besides these two wings, there is National Statistical Commission created through a Resolution of Government of India (MOSPI) and one autonomous Institute, viz., Indian Statistical Institute declared as an institute of National importance by an Act of Parliament. ","publisher":"Ministry of Statistics and Program Implementation, Government of India, Office of Registrar General, India","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Approved, license was not open","details":"The OGD India (https://data.gov.in/) provides voluminous amount of national statistics and data in this regard which is absolutely open and machine readable. All the national statistics data are open to public, reusable and freely available in Data Portal India. The Data has been shared under National Data Sharing and Accessibility Policy – 2012 (NDSAP-2012). This was a unique initiative taken by Govt of India to facilitate access to Government of India owned shareable data and information in both human readable and machine readable forms.\r\n\r\nReview note - This license does not considered open - https://data.gov.in/sites/default/files/NDSAP.pdf","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":70},{"id":"26d35674-6984-4a1b-add6-9ae92673fe40","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-16T03:24:54","year":2015,"place":"hk","dataset":"budget","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.budget.gov.hk/2015/eng/estimates1.html","format":"CSV","licenseurl":"https://data.gov.hk/en/terms-and-conditions","officialtitle":"Data related to 2015-16 Estimates of the Government","publisher":"Financial Services and the Treasury Bureau, info@fstb.gov.hk","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"From the website - \"The usage of the datasets is subject to the Terms and Conditions as stipulated under DATA.GOV.HK\". The license on DATA.GOV.UK seems as it comply with Open Data and allow commercial and non-commercial use. ","details":"Hong Kong released its budget plans in CSV format for the first time this year. The full descriptions for spending are still held in PDF format in the 'Budget Speech' documents: https://www.budget.gov.hk/2015/eng/speech.html\r\n\r\nBudget commitments are described in terms of policy areas, but there is a document that links policy area to government departments. The expenditure plans in the CSV format do include a fairly detailed breakdown of 'large' projects that includes past and future expenditure.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"Rob Davidson","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":100},{"id":"75e2a6ad-6a1f-4334-b902-30621a0b315f","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-28T15:49:18","year":2015,"place":"in","dataset":"map","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://data.gov.in/catalog/bhuvan-geoportal-nrscisro#web_catalog_tabs_block_1","format":"WMS","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Bhuvan Geoportal - It allows users to explore a 2D/3D representation of the surface to view India, offering the highest resolution in this region and providing content in four local languages. Apart from visualization Bhuvan provides free satellite data and a products download facility and rich thematic datasets. Bhuvan is using a crowdsourcing approach to enrich its maps and collect point of interest data.","publisher":"National Remote Sensing Centre","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"License is not open","details":"The data is fully available in the OGD India website mentioned above with their links. The information available on OGD India and is completely open for reuse and further studies and research. Maps are available at https://data.gov.in/catalog/bhuvan-geoportal-nrscisro#web_catalog_tabs_block_10. \r\n\r\nBhuvan (https://bhuvan.nrsc.gov.in/data/download/index.php) is the gateway on Indian Earth Observation. It gives an easy way to experience, explore and visualize IRS images over Indian region. Bhuvan platform provides wide ranging information through its interactive maps and a number of products which are available on its site. The data is available for download to every one and the policy clearly states that the data can be distributed and further used for developing applications and research. But data doesn't include administrative boundaries, public equipments, transport systems, etc.\r\n\r\nSurvey of India (https://www.surveyofindia.gov.in/), the National Survey and Mapping Organisation of the country under the Department of Science & Technology, provides varrious types of mapping data. The full list of available mapping products is here: https://www.surveyofindia.gov.in/pages/display/59-publications. \r\n\r\nThe license here - https://data.gov.in/sites/default/files/NDSAP.pdf does not considered open","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Mor Rubinstein","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":70},{"id":"49420560-7957-44b2-8516-625065095387","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-28T15:50:19","year":2015,"place":"in","dataset":"companies","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://data.gov.in/catalog/company-master-data","format":"CSV","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Company Register - The Ministry of Corporate Affairs is charged with administering the Companies Act of India 1956 and 2013, registration of companies and other issues pertaining to the private sector in India. It is the nodal agency for data pertaining to companies and corporate entities. ","publisher":"Ministry of Corporate Affairs, Government of India","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"License is not open","details":"Master data of all the companies registered is available on OGD India, which is easily downloadable and available in bulk. Most importantly it is machine readable. The information available on OGD India and is completely open for reuse and further studies and research. It is updated on an annual basis for each financial year.\r\n\r\nData is also available on Ministry of Corporate affairs website:\r\n1. Company Master Data (https://www.mca.gov.in/MinistryV2/masterdatareport.html)\r\n\r\n2. Total Companies Registered-Year wise and State wise:\r\nList of Companies registered or incorporated during the year (year wise from 1857 till date) :https://www.mca.gov.in/MinistryV2/CompStat_IFCompLLP.html\r\nList of Companies Registered or incorporated - statewise (Registration from 1857 till date): \r\nhttps://www.mca.gov.in/MinistryV2/CompStat_IFCompLLP.html\r\n3. Companies Incorporated or Closed during the month:\r\nMonth wise Master details of Companies/LLPs Registered (From Nov 2013 to Nov 2014): https://www.mca.gov.in/MinistryV2/eir.html and https://www.mca.gov.in/MinistryV2/eir_Archive.html\r\nThis particular data includes information of Indian companies registered,Foreign companies registered and LLP registered.\r\n\r\nThe license is not considered open - https://data.gov.in/sites/default/files/NDSAP.pdf","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":70},{"id":"8eabafcc-1c6f-4b44-82b3-5dfabfe43ebb","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-18T11:33:56","year":2015,"place":"in","dataset":"elections","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Unsure","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://eci.nic.in/eci_main1/ElectionStatistics.aspx","format":"Excel, PDF","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Election Commission of India -The Election Commision of India is an autonomous constitional body in India which is tasked with the duty to administer all electoral process within Republic of India. Starting from declaration of elections to conducting them and coming out with results. India being the largest democracy in the world, a mindboggling levels of numbers are associated with the conduct of the elections which can be constituted as data. The Election Commision of India is the sole publisher of data related to elections. ","publisher":"Election Commission of India","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The submission does not meet the definition - they are available at constituency level, aggregating votes of up to 3 million people. Polling station data is available at https://eci.nic.in/eci_main1/LinktoForm20.aspx in various formats.","details":"Data of Election result is available at https://eci.nic.in/eci_main1/ElectionStatistics.aspx; Detailed Results of latest elections are available in xls format i.e https://eci.nic.in/eci_main/StatisticalReports/candidatewise/LS-2014_ElectionResult.xlsx and https://eci.nic.in/eci_main1/GE2014/Party_Contested_GE_2014.xlsx\r\nReal time Election Result is available also when actual election is going on and can be accessed through https://eciresults.nic.in/. API is also available for real time election result. Many web/mobile app has been developed using the API of https://eciresults.nic.in/.\r\nData related to elections is also available on Data Portal.\r\nDetails include-\r\n* List of Participating Political Parties\r\n* List of Successful Candidates\r\n* Performance of Political Parties\r\n* Candidate Data Summary\r\n* Electors Data Summary\r\n* Women Candidates\r\n* Constituency Data Summary\r\n* Detailed Results\r\nData available on OGD India is completely free and open for reuse and further studies and research.\r\n","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Akhilesh Srivastava","reviewer":"Kamil Gregor","score":70},{"id":"59c18c8f-41de-413c-ba25-77a1aa96d63f","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-18T08:10:20","year":2015,"place":"in","dataset":"budget","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://indiabudget.nic.in/ebmain.asp","format":"CSV, Excel","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Union Budget of India - The Union Budget of India also known as Annual Financial Statement in Article 112 of the Constitution of Indiais presented each year in the month of February by the Finance Minister of India, in the Indian Parliament. This budget encompasses all the departments of the Government and the various important governance initiatives that are to be undertaken. ","publisher":"Ministry of Finance, Government of India","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Terms of use here does not mention the data can be re-used for any porpuse. - https://indiabudget.nic.in/terms.asp","details":"The data is available in the OGD India (https://data.gov.in) website mentioned above with their links. The data is available in machine readable formats. The data portal provides important data pertaining to various aspects of the budget from 2011-12 to 2015-16 in machine readable excel format.\r\n\r\nThe Ministry of Finance website https://indiabudget.nic.in/index.asp on Union Budget provides up to date information about the budget (In XLS and PDF Format). The information available on OGD India is completely open for reuse and further studies and research. Same is the case with the data available on the budget website.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Akhilesh Srivastava","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":70},{"id":"f3ebdd43-b993-4b19-ad7f-20dd824b69bc","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-10-31T21:35:43","year":2014,"place":"hk","dataset":"timetables","exists":"No","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"This is very tricky in HK. As the dataset actually asks about *national-level* transportation services. I do not think HK has any kind of service there. Regarding timetable itself (for city-level transportation service), the data should exist based upon my personal experience, but no idea where is the digital one.","details":"","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"FENG GAO","score":0},{"id":"4e9f566a-f4c0-436b-b1bd-2b1fb1e4f843","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-11-10T01:26:19","year":2015,"place":"tw","dataset":"land","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"Unsure","bulk":"Unsure","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Unsure","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"The Department of Land Administration, Ministry of the Interior /czester@land.moi.gov.tw","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"https://easymap.land.moi.gov.tw/ is an interface to the java-applet powered map that people can query and buy electronic copies of land information.","details":"","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Czester Chen","reviewer":"Codrina Maria Ilie","score":10},{"id":"34faed5c-db54-4805-b78a-31122d1f0a7d","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-28T06:09:56","year":2015,"place":"ua","dataset":"companies","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"No","online":"Yes","free":"No","machinereadable":"Unsure","bulk":"Unsure","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://usr.minjust.gov.ua/paidextract","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Unified State Register of Legal Entities and Individual Entrepreneurs","publisher":"Ministry of Justice of Ukraine","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Data is now held by the Ministry of Justice - updated publisher and description. Filled out criteria according to paid data. It is online because the paid data can be obtained via a web portal, but what form the data is in is unknown (presumably digital, unsure if machine readable).","details":"The register can be searched for free using keywords, although a CAPTCHA must also be entered for every individual search. To make a search in the registry, visit: https://usr.minjust.gov.ua/ua/freesearch\r\n\r\nAll other data must be purchased, though it is unclear whether or not this is bulk data or what format it is available in.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Rebecca Sentance","score":25},{"id":"d69c2a54-c738-4b9c-9892-5257df8bc5ff","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-02T05:42:12","year":2015,"place":"ml","dataset":"map","exists":"No","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Seems correct.","details":"The National Geographical Institute (IGM) have started with the support of EU funds in year 2013 to realise a map of the country at the scale of 1/200 000","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Gil Zaretzer","score":0},{"id":"2e084e12-35af-48a3-9ab1-42efbfc07f23","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-13T09:22:42","year":2015,"place":"ir","dataset":"statistics","exists":"No","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Some data but not recent and not open. ","details":"The statistical data is available via Management and Planning Organization (Statistical Centre of Iran / https://www.amar.org.ir)\r\n \r\nHere you can find the population (https://www.amar.org.ir/Default.aspx?tabid=500), last updated on 2011. \r\n\r\nUnemployment here (https://www.amar.org.ir/Default.aspx?tabid=498), link not working.\t\r\n\r\nGDP here (https://www.amar.org.ir/Default.aspx?tabid=499), last updated 2011.\r\n","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Tarek Amr","reviewer":"Zach Christensen","score":0},{"id":"c1097e43-020b-449d-93a9-b57140297774","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-03T08:25:49","year":2015,"place":"im","dataset":"legislation","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"No","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"https://www.gov.im/about-this-site/open-government-licence/","officialtitle":"primary legislation","publisher":"HM Attorney General chambers","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The submission seems to be correct.","details":"All primary legislation is uploaded by the HM Attorney General's department (cloud hosted open source system as per Jersey) and all secondary legislation is uploaded by the IT department at the Isle of Man Parliament (cloud hosted Microsoft Sharepoint). All \"live\" primary legislation is available free online. All secondary legislation from 2000 is available free online and all earlier secondary legislation is available free by email (typically same day) -- all earlier secondary legislation will be uploaded in due course.\r\n\r\nSince some of the legislation is not available online, we are marking it as 'unsure'.\r\nBulk download of all legislations is not present. \r\n","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Kamil Gregor","score":70},{"id":"56c23a1b-db9e-4bbe-b3c5-97ebc70563b9","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-11-09T22:41:41","year":2015,"place":"tw","dataset":"spending","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"中央政府總結算","publisher":"Directorate General of Budget, Accounting and Statistics, Executive Yuan, R.O.C.","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Data is not in transactional level","details":"https://www.dgbas.gov.tw/public/Attachment/4828914358VPAUQXD.xls shows the aggregated data which indicates the transactional data exists and is digital.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Mor Rubinstein","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":10},{"id":"a14e1452-9d3a-47e9-8086-8953d065e2e6","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-14T17:18:37","year":2015,"place":"fr","dataset":"water","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"No","url":"https://www.sante.gouv.fr/qualite-de-l-eau-potable","format":"","licenseurl":"https://wiki.data.gouv.fr/images/9/9d/Licence_Ouverte.pdf","officialtitle":"Qualité de l'eau potable ","publisher":"Ministère des affaires sociales, de la santé et des droits de femmes & Ministère de l'Écologie, du Développement durable et de l'Énergie","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The government does provide this data on the web. It does specify when it was collected \"Date du prélèvement\" seems to be every few months, with every area on a different timeline. I couldn't find downloaded bulk data anywhere but they have it in a digital format.","details":"This data is on drinking water and is updated on a daily/weekly basis. \r\n\r\nDetailed data on water sources are also available on:\r\n- www.eaufrance.fr: documentation and surface water\r\n- www.ades.eaufrance.fr: on groundwater data \r\n","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Claire-Marie Foulquier-Gazagnes","reviewer":"Nisha Thompson","score":65},{"id":"5d8428a9-0aca-4b54-84a2-e2cd57deebe1","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-12-05T19:51:54","year":2014,"place":"mx","dataset":"timetables","exists":"No","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"","details":"National ministry of transport: https://www.sct.gob.mx/ \n\nData exists on municipal level. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Enrique Zapata","reviewer":"Enrique Zapata","score":0},{"id":"ceeee6a0-b51e-4ad6-b3ee-8681fdc2b279","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-19T11:26:11","year":2015,"place":"ch","dataset":"map","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"No","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.swisstopo.admin.ch/internet/swisstopo/en/home/products/freeproducts.html","format":"WMS, WMTS, SHP, PDF","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Swiss Raster Map","publisher":"Federal Office of Topography swisstopo","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"I found that one must register in order to download even the free content, thus it is not public. The terms and conditions one approves when downloading clearly state that this is not free for commercial use.","details":"A raster map with the scale 1:1.000.000 as well as several vector and geology datasets are provided for free. Additional data is sold via the [online shop](https://www.toposhop.admin.ch/de/shop/index). An [interactive map viewer](https://map.geo.admin.ch/) with all available layers and visualization of changes over time is available here. A catalogue of all [existing geospatial data](https://www.geocat.ch/) is available on a specific data catalogue for geo-data with detailed meta-descriptions and detailed information on updates to topographical maps. Several geographic data sets will also be available on the Swiss [Open Government Data Portal](https://opendata.admin.ch/en/dataset?groups=raum-und-umwelt&_organization_limit=0).","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Oleg Lavrovsky","reviewer":"Gil Zaretzer","score":65},{"id":"4d0bc5ee-c800-4d5c-a8d8-d00c184391a4","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-21T18:15:54","year":2015,"place":"gt","dataset":"elections","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Unsure","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://resultados2015.tse.org.gt/resultados-2015/","format":"Excel","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Tribunal Supremo Electoral - https://www.tse.org.gt/","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The submission is correct.","details":"The Supreme Electoral Court (TSE) is the highest authority in electoral matters. Elections are intended to elect the President and Vice-President, Members of Congress, Municipal Corporations throughout the Republic, deputies to the Central American Parliament and alternates. The Guatemala Electoral Commission publishes an authoritative collection of electoral results. The Electoral Commission makes the bulk data available for download in PDF and Excel spreadsheet formats. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Julio Herrera","reviewer":"Kamil Gregor","score":70},{"id":"01a4f062-0832-472f-8c61-edf0e5f81a12","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-28T07:52:58","year":2015,"place":"mm","dataset":"elections","exists":"No","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The submission is correct.","details":"No evidence showing from the President's Officer website that the data is exist. https://www.myanmarpresidentoffice.info/en/ and the dedicated webpage for the cabinet ministries is empty https://www.myanmarpresidentoffice.info/en/?q=cabinet/ministries so no way to find out who are the responsible minister involve. I have found a 3rd party website https://www.ourweb.info/01/directory/myanmar/005/ that provide a list of ministries official websites but some of these websites are not found.\r\n\r\n![enter image description here][1]\r\n\r\n\r\n [1]: https://s9.postimg.org/92ckd9e5b/Screen_Shot_2015_09_28_at_3_51_24_PM.png","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Kamil Gregor","score":0},{"id":"58474b4d-4c39-4856-ab68-e5343524d8a5","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-28T08:01:22","year":2015,"place":"mm","dataset":"statistics","exists":"No","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"No official sources found.","details":"No evidence showing from the President's Officer website that the data exist. https://www.myanmarpresidentoffice.info/en/ and the dedicated webpage for the central statistical organization does not work. https://costat.gov.mm","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Zach Christensen","score":0},{"id":"919be4be-8874-4d98-89a3-06e2ed64e978","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-01T14:42:00","year":2015,"place":"ca","dataset":"spending","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Submission is correct.\r\n\r\nAll suggestions in comments are aggregated expenditure or procurement data.","details":"The Government of Canada released a pilot sample dataset matching the criteria for this category for the fiscal year 2013-2014, which has since been discontinued: https://data.gc.ca/data/en/dataset/2eed2fba-1626-4d2e-a511-389cc6b51ddf . The Government of Canada also has a tool for searching expenditure data, but data availability varies by ministry and department. Data is not month to month - it is aggregated by fiscal year - and it is not very detailed. Data cannot be downloaded. https://www.tbs-sct.gc.ca/ems-sgd/edb-bdd/index-eng.html\r\n\r\n(No change since 2014)","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Neal Bastek","reviewer":"Tryggvi Björgvinsson","score":10},{"id":"68b9e75e-4d17-4300-ac47-a65631fe6f9f","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-11-03T14:39:30","year":2015,"place":"tw","dataset":"procurement","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://data.gov.tw/node/7264","format":"XML","licenseurl":"https://data.gov.tw/license","officialtitle":"Awarding for Government Procurement","publisher":"Public Construction Commission Executive Yuan","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Submission correct. ","details":"Active tenders are searchable. Full data is available through the Open Data portal.\r\n\r\n - Zh-TW website: [Link here][1]\r\n - English website: [Link here][2]\r\n\r\n\r\n [1]: https://web.pcc.gov.tw/tps/pss/tender.do?method=goSearch&searchMode=common&searchType=basic\r\n [2]: https://web.pcc.gov.tw/tps/pss/tender.do?method=goNews","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"lycurgus kk","reviewer":"Georg Neumann","score":100},{"id":"740aea09-72f9-435d-a775-a43735be3fda","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-11-03T15:19:04","year":2015,"place":"tw","dataset":"water","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"No","url":"https://data.gov.tw/node/6308","format":"CSV","licenseurl":"https://data.gov.tw/license","officialtitle":"This data set is mainly to provide Taiwan with the water company for each water purification plant water quality information.","publisher":"Taiwan Water Supply Corp","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Data is in bulk, however, results are published once a month, and not on a weekly basis. ","details":"The item above is about the water quality of reservoirs in different place. The data is about the name of different reservoirs, townships, layer and depth of sample, and details.\r\nThe data update every month and can be download easily in single file.\r\n\r\n","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":90},{"id":"00f51f91-51b1-4cf0-a7ad-fe3c3cbc9602","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-11-19T14:22:31","year":2014,"place":"si","dataset":"postcodes","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"No","online":"No","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The data should have postcodes/zipcodes *and* the corresponding geospatial locations. At the moment Slovenia has a postcode data and a separate geospatial locations dataset, but not one dataset that contain the both. Therefore, I changed the review accordingly. ","details":"Data is available from Post of Slovenia, but is hidden in HTML format, not available in bulk and additional skills are needed to extract it. Geodetska uprava (Slovenian equivalent of UK Ordnance survey) resells bulk data with additional GIS information. \n\nFor a simpler postname<->postnumber mapping, see this HTML table:\nhttps://www.posta.si/postne-stevilke-doma","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Marieke Guy","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":45},{"id":"a8d7b9c1-263d-4753-afbe-304d834e3de5","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-12-01T09:26:18","year":2014,"place":"si","dataset":"map","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"","format":"TIFF, SHP, CSV","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"National Topographic Maps","publisher":"Prostor","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Expert review: Criteria were not compliant with neither comment nor reality on the website.","details":"Geodetska uprava (Slovenian equivalent of UK Ordnance survey) takes care of maps and resells them. Bulk data is available against payment. Licensing and reuse is non-free and limited. An 1:1.000.000 topographic raster map is free of charge and free for reuse, if a source is mentioned:\nhttps://www.e-prostor.gov.si/?id=415\nThe list of all available maps can be found here: https://www.e-prostor.gov.si/si/dostop_do_podatkov/dostop_do_podatkov/\n\n1:25.000 topographic maps are available for online use (but not download) through various free web viewers like the Atlas of environment and Geopedia.si .\n\nSome other minor layers are also available free of charge (like the borders), especially environmental data at https://gis.arso.gov.si/wfs_web .","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Daniela Mattern","reviewer":"Daniela Mattern","score":40},{"id":"884e6ca0-122a-4a7d-9ef5-0f2e46cd3ee7","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-11-23T10:52:54","year":2014,"place":"si","dataset":"companies","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.ajpes.si/Registri/Poslovni_register/Splosno","format":"","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Corrected the old review and added that the data is available to the public. ","details":"Only individual records can be used freely; bulk data is limited by a statement \"Users can get only minor parts of the databases (qualitatively and / or quantitatively) and to the extent provided in the context of available web applications. All other forms of retransmission or enabling the use of third parties (eg, publication of the third-party server or user, reproduction in other documents, etc.). Expressly prohibited. This prohibition applies to all forms of use that goes beyond their own use. In particular, the following practices are prohibited: the use of substantial parts (qualitatively and / or quantitatively) databases (eg reproduction structure databases, parts of the structure of databases, creation of public and private databases, etc..) ...\" (see https://www.ajpes.si/Pogoji_uporabe) Bulk extracts are charged for - see https://www.ajpes.si/Registri/Poslovni_register/Ponovna_uporaba/Nadomestila for a scale of charges) ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Mor Rubinstein","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":30},{"id":"55f6e8b5-e011-4736-a570-867712ecad16","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-11-19T14:05:28","year":2014,"place":"si","dataset":"elections","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.dvk-rs.si/","format":"PDF","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"License is not open under the definition of the 'open definition'. Therefore, it is not open and was changed. ","details":"The site gives results for instance for the 2012 presidential election down to polling station level. However only PDF format is offered on the website at https://www.dvk-rs.si/index.php/si/strani/volisca-za-volitve-predsednika-rs-2012 The disclaimer on https://www.dvk-rs.si/index.php/si/pravno-obvestilo asserts that under Slovenian Law these results are not subject to Copyright and so can be reused freely. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Marieke Guy","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":55},{"id":"8bb70ea5-5226-4308-a77f-2c889e436ff0","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-11-19T14:20:56","year":2014,"place":"si","dataset":"legislation","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.pisrs.si/Pis.web/","format":"HTML, PDF","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"PIS","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Data is accurate and approved.","details":"Update to previous site :\n\n\"We hereby inform you that the contents of the website zakonodaja.gov.si 15 April 2014, became an integral part of the revised Site Legal Information System of the Republic of Slovenia ( PIS ) . ISP offers free access to legislative and other public documents of state bodies and statutory authorities in the Republic of Slovenia and the documents issued by the institutions of the European Union and the Council of Europe\"\n\nThe previous site eventually points to the Slovenian Official Gazette as at (for example) https://www.uradni-list.si/1/objava.jsp?urlid=200670&stevilka=2999 . This is in HTML and there is no download facility. The licensing conditions at https://www.uradni-list.si/0/legal include (article 14, Google Translate) \"All rights to the home page and all subpages Site-official list.si reserved. The information and materials on this website are protected by intellectual property rights upravljavca.Informacije and materials displayed on the Site may be downloaded for your personal use, however, do not change copyright and other notices relating to intellectual property rights or other rights notices. It is permitted to download and print information and materials for viewing and reading for non-commercial purposes. Any other copying, distribution, reproduction, modification information and materials on this site or send them by mail or distribute in any other way without prior written permission is prohibited. It is also prohibited to use any element of own-list.si for any purpose other than personal, non-commercial use. Restrictions on use of materials not subject to the Official Journal of the Republic of Slovenia, and it posted content.\" Therefore this site is not Open, not machine readable and no bulk downloadable.\n
\nThe legal registry at https://pisrs.si is newer and most of the sites at the original url redirect there. However, it is mostly a usability enhancement. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Marieke Guy","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":45},{"id":"423c1edc-ee79-428d-9ceb-c2fa8f270749","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-11-29T23:00:08","year":2014,"place":"si","dataset":"spending","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://supervizor.kpk-rs.si/","format":"JSON, JSONP, XML, XLS","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"The Commission for the Prevention of Corruption of the Republic of Slovenia","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Duplicate submission","details":"The first page is not a notice of (un)availability, rather an introductory message. Data is available in a form of a web application, where you are supposed to choose a public body and/or private company doing business with government. Examples:\nhttps://supervizor.kpk-rs.si/organ/16110/ gives a graph and list of all expenses by Ministry of finances. https://supervizor.kpk-rs.si/podj/25028022/ gives all income for Post of Slovenia received from public bodies. Companies also have listed owners, supervisors and directors. You can combine bodies and companies, eg. https://supervizor.kpk-rs.si/organ/12157/podj/25028022/ lists all expenditure from Information comissioner's office given to Post of Slovenia. Bulk data is available at:\nhttps://supervizor.kpk-rs.si/podatki/\nAll transactions above 2000€ are noted and dated (starting from 2003) with a summary log for the rest. There is an API available and official interface provided, which can list all the transactions, not limited to the abovementioned sum:\nhttps://github.com/Supervizor/supervizor-api\n\nThere is also a 3rd-party scrapper available here: https://github.com/dataoko/slobiro/tree/master/superviz2\n\n\nAdditionally , there's detailed monthly and yearly documentation of the balance of public finances at (PDF, XLS):\nhttps://www.mf.gov.si/si/delovna_podrocja/tekoca_gibanja_v_javnih_financah/bilten_jav nih_financ/","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Tryggvi Björgvinsson","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":70},{"id":"073cf752-e0b7-475c-bc8c-152cd5e095c8","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-11-03T15:04:02","year":2015,"place":"tw","dataset":"weather","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"No","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://data.gov.tw/node/9219","format":"XML","licenseurl":"https://data.gov.tw/license","officialtitle":"It provides 7 days forecast of temperature, county names, time, and weather conditions.","publisher":"Central Weather Bureau","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Data exist in XMl, but not in bulk, wind is in a different dataset. ","details":"The PDF is Chinese-English vocabulary form not about the data, but you can find the 7 days forecast data in XML file.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"lycurgus kk","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":90},{"id":"4aca18d1-cbd2-4724-9f17-14bee07ca89b","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-08-29T14:15:11","year":2015,"place":"tw","dataset":"emissions","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://opendata.epa.gov.tw/Data/Contents/AQX/","format":"XML, CSV, JSON","licenseurl":"https://data.gov.tw/opendata/principle","officialtitle":"County, PSI, Major Pollutant, SO2. CO, O3, PM10, PM2.5, Wind Speed, Wind Direct, Publilsh Time","publisher":"Environment Protection Agency","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"checked ","details":"","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"Ying Chu Chen","reviewer":"yar michl","score":100},{"id":"d6820909-b64d-4388-b489-86136acc082d","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-11-09T01:31:17","year":2015,"place":"tw","dataset":"postcodes","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Zip Code and Administrative boundaries","publisher":"Ministry of Transportation and Communications and Ministry of the Interior","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Data for postcodes exist, but does not meet the criteria of geo location. National boundaries are not applicable since there is a postcode system.","details":"1. The Zip Code [above][1]. is in Zh-TW and can be open by unzip tools, and also provide the English post code search interface [here][3].\r\n2. The Administrative boundaries [above][2]. can be open by GIS tools, and also provide the English administrative boundaries search interface [here][4] \r\n\r\n [1]:https://data.gov.tw/node/5948\r\n [2]:https://data.gov.tw/node/7442\r\n [3]: https://www.post.gov.tw/post/internet/U_english/index.jsp?ID=240205\r\n [4]:https://taiwanarmap.moi.gov.tw/moiupe/run.htm","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"lycurgus kk","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":10},{"id":"e4a55d0e-35c9-47c2-91b4-751fb9f6dcb7","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-11-03T14:55:15","year":2015,"place":"tw","dataset":"legislation","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://law.moj.gov.tw/PublicData/GetFile.ashx?DType=XML&AuData=CF","format":"XML","licenseurl":"https://data.gov.tw/license","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Ministry of Justice","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Data is available in bulk and openly licensed. ","details":"It's a website above is belong to Ministry of Justice, and use to search the laws, date, legislative process.\r\n\r\n - English website: [Link][1]\r\n\r\nSome legislative records belong to Legislative Yuan. and the gazette of the Legislative Yuan is here [Link][2], but in all in zh-TW PDF files.\r\n\r\n\r\n [1]: https://law.moj.gov.tw/ENG/index.aspx\r\n [2]: https://lci.ly.gov.tw/LyLCEW/lcivComm.action#pageName_searchResult=1","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":100},{"id":"c4621a82-bf4a-410e-8e50-5975e8df5ac6","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-11-04T08:03:15","year":2015,"place":"tw","dataset":"statistics","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://data.gov.tw/node/6803","format":"XML","licenseurl":"https://data.gov.tw/license","officialtitle":"GDP依支出分(對經濟成長貢獻)","publisher":"Directorate General of Budget, Accounting and Statistics (DGBAS) ","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Data are openly available and regularly updated. ","details":"Data are openly licensed, current, and available in open formats. \r\n\r\nhttps://data.gov.tw/node/6637\r\nhttps://data.gov.tw/node/18681\r\n\r\n","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"TH Schee","reviewer":"Zach Christensen","score":100},{"id":"2bdd5d41-0556-4d98-9094-11c8d63957c7","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-11-03T14:58:56","year":2015,"place":"tw","dataset":"map","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://data.gov.tw/node/9363","format":"WMS","licenseurl":"https://data.gov.tw/license","officialtitle":"通用版電子地圖(WMS)","publisher":"內政部","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"I reviewed this again, since registration is free it is publicly available","details":"The original website (https://emap.nlsc.gov.tw/gis/ ) is a mapping service online, you have to register to use more function.\r\n\r\nIn 2014, The Ministry of Interior has built their open data platform (only in Traditional Chinese), https://data.moi.gov.tw/MoiOD/default/Index.aspx in June. They provide the map web service to download to use.\r\n\r\nThey also provide the data to https://data.gov.tw , people also can download the data in https://data.gov.tw/node/9363 .\r\n\r\nThe Principles of Use are compliant with the open definition.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"lycurgus kk","reviewer":"Gil Zaretzer","score":100},{"id":"6a9d00e2-0d4a-45dd-a108-a8e94f0f7d5e","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-08-29T12:58:06","year":2015,"place":"tw","dataset":"companies","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://data.gcis.nat.gov.tw/od/detail?oid=AD28285B-7B0E-4241-9F58-F2F0F289333E","format":"CSV","licenseurl":"https://data.gov.tw/license","officialtitle":"Name of company, address, unique identifier of the company, the owner, capital, approved date, registration department","publisher":" The Department of Commerce, Ministry of Economic Affairs (data.gcis@gmail.com)","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Have added some details in details field. All else fine.","details":"Company data is updated month by month. NB, some users may have trouble viewing Taiwanese characters when opening CSV file in Excel.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"Ying Chu Chen","reviewer":"Rebecca Sentance","score":100},{"id":"0c781dc7-de6c-4ba7-86ca-0f549fc85d31","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-08-29T13:14:23","year":2015,"place":"tw","dataset":"elections","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://data.gov.tw/node/13119","format":"CSV","licenseurl":"https://data.gov.tw/license","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Central Election Commission","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The submission is correct.","details":"","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"Ying Chu Chen","reviewer":"Kamil Gregor","score":100},{"id":"9b08a9e3-2c13-4758-a7a1-f1898f621634","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-08-28T10:26:06","year":2015,"place":"tw","dataset":"budget","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://data.gov.tw/node/11851","format":"XML","licenseurl":"https://data.gov.tw/license","officialtitle":"","publisher":"The Directorate General of Budget, Accounting and Statistics (DGBAS) of Executive Yuan","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"I have checked the data and it is correct. ","details":"They also provide brief presentation on analysis of annual revenue and Expenditure in English, PDF format.\r\nCentral Government General Budget, Ficscal Year 2015: [Link][1]\r\n(All in PDF.)\r\n\r\n [1]: https://eng.dgbas.gov.tw/ct.asp?xItem=37838&CtNode=6173&mp=2","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"Ying Chu Chen","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":100},{"id":"c37796b1-e8c2-4a2d-bbdd-f16469668700","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-11-04T02:38:46","year":2014,"place":"tw","dataset":"timetables","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://data.gov.tw/node/6138","format":"XML","licenseurl":"https://data.gov.tw/?q=principle","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":" Ministry of Transportation and Communication","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The data is provided by Ministry of Transportation and Communication but from different department, and the open data platform is built by Taiwan gov. so, I think those data sets are eligible.","details":"There is no national central public transport data catalog. Taiwan Railway, Taiwan High Speed Rail and etc., all timetables are in different websites. No changes in 2014.\n\nPeople can download different timetables they need in https://data.gov.tw.\n\n 1. Domestic Airline timetable in CSV format: https://data.gov.tw/node/6066\n 2. Bus timetable in CSV format: https://data.gov.tw/node/6052\n 3. Railway in XML format: https://data.gov.tw/node/6138\n 4. High Speed Railway in CSV format: https://data.gov.tw/node/7080\n\nThey are all provided by Ministry of Transportation and Communication but from different department.\n\nAnd the open data platform is built by Taiwan gov. so, I think those data sets are eligible.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"TH Schee","reviewer":"Ying Chu Chen","score":100},{"id":"5fa79697-8379-4f68-8327-1e3971cb9fcd","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-11-19T14:59:47","year":2014,"place":"si","dataset":"emissions","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Unsure","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://okolje.arso.gov.si/onesnazevanje_zraka/reporting#Nacionalne%20emisije%20onesna%C5%BEeval%20zraka","format":"XLS, XML","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":" \tAGENCIJA REPUBLIKE SLOVENIJE ZA OKOLJE","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Data is accurate and approved. ","details":"The main site is an overview with a set of links mostly pointing to official data submitted to EIONET, for example:\nhttps://cdr.eionet.europa.eu/si/eu/colqba8sg/nec/columnelg/envungf9g\nhttps://cdr.eionet.europa.eu/si/eu/colqba8sg/ghgmm \n
\nThere is also this official listing, which is much more user friendly and oriented more to the layman than the data scientist. However it's update times are staggering and it's only available in Slovenian.\nhttps://kazalci.arso.gov.si/?data=group&group_id=16 ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Marieke Guy","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":70},{"id":"a4d45da4-415e-44bb-8a38-df6bdca8a27c","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-11-19T14:15:31","year":2014,"place":"si","dataset":"statistics","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://pxweb.stat.si/pxweb/dialog/statfile1.asp","format":"XLS, PX, ","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Statistical office of the Republic of Slovenia surs.si-stat@gov.si","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Changed the license from Open to Not Open. ","details":"Registration needed to access data. The home page states \"Use and publication of data is allowed provided the source is acknowledged.\"","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Marieke Guy","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":70},{"id":"230a407c-12f0-4076-a822-7cecda48f6bd","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-11-19T14:00:00","year":2014,"place":"si","dataset":"budget","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.mf.gov.si/si/delovna_podrocja/proracun/sprejeti_proracun/","format":"CSV","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"On the footer of the website it is mention the follows: \"© 2014 Ministry of Finance. All rights reserved!\" Therefore, I changed the license to \"not open\"","details":"Each of the budget revisions are published as an Act and therefore available freely. Click on the links in the content of the page, to get to a page about each revision of a yearly budget. There, the first two links will be the budget in PDF and CSV format. Since 2013 the budget is also provided in CSV. Older PDF and CSV files, general part only (\"splošni del\"), are provided via a third party, on github:\nhttps://github.com/zejn/prrorracun/tree/master/final/splosni ----\n","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Marieke Guy","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":70},{"id":"3f74e6f5-a265-4833-a3ba-64d114505f69","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-11-19T12:53:22","year":2014,"place":"si","dataset":"timetables","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.ap-ljubljana.si/ https://www.slo-zeleznice.si/en/passengers/slovenia","format":"HTML, XML","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Bustrack.com is not an official government resource, and therefore is not relevant for this survey. At the time of the review the official transport website of the Slovenian government - https://www.jpp.si was under construction and there was no XML dump available. Therefore, I changed the data to non machine readable. \nIn addition, all the other official but and train sites are licensed in a private copyright. Therefore, the data is not open licensed. ","details":"There are several time tables and web sites available. For long-distance buses in Slovenia, there's a from-to query interface at https://www.ap-ljubljana.si/ . Timetables for railways are available at Slovenian Railways home page, https://www.slo-zeleznice.si/sl/potniki/slovenija/vozni-redi - available are both as a from-to query and based on route (\"Vozni redi po relacijah\"). There's also an XML dump of bus routes, stations and arrivals available at https://www.jpp.si/Pregled/Register.jsp (but none for trains). Timetables for city bus routes in Ljubljana are available at https://www.lpp.si/javni-prevoz/vozni-redi-mestni-potniski-promet/vozni-redi-redni . There is also a query-style web service, displaying arrival time for city buses in Ljubljana https://bus.talktrack.com/","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Marieke Guy","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":45},{"id":"1ff89a0b-c26c-4a3b-93ab-65db3d2c57d0","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-11-07T17:43:56","year":2014,"place":"hr","dataset":"postcodes","exists":"No","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"This entry is accepted with minor clerification in the comments section.","details":"To our knowledge (and available research), there is no official source linking geospatial data to postcodes in Croatia.\n\nHowever, the database of postcodes in Croatia (without corresponding locations) is available at:\nhttps://www.posta.hr/postanski-brojevi-i-uredi","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Drazen Hoffmann","reviewer":"Stevan Gostojić","score":0},{"id":"7317967c-9e54-4292-9e49-60f71de90a3d","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-11-30T22:32:03","year":2014,"place":"hr","dataset":"spending","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"After expert review we changed the data from not existed to exist but not available to the public, that is since there is aggregated data which is composed out of transactions. ","details":" Records of Government spending are only available on semi-annual basis in the form of the State Budget Execution Report, datasets available in three different types of classification as Ms Excel documents: e.g. economical classification dataset https://www.mfin.hr/adminmax/docs/Izvrsenje%20po%20razdjelima,%20glavama%20i%20ekonomskoj%20klasifikaciji.xls","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Tryggvi Björgvinsson","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":10},{"id":"138ba798-b0b6-4b40-aa9b-3d9b7f3799d5","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-11-07T18:05:12","year":2014,"place":"hr","dataset":"emissions","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://zrak.mzoip.hr","format":"html","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Meteorological and Hydrographical Service; State Network for Permanent Air Quality Measurement","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The entry is accepted without any modifications.","details":"This database differs from the one reported upon in 2013, since it contains aggregate nationwide data, as opposed to single pollutant sources (e.g., this database provides information on aggregate emissions in the city of Rijeka, instead of those by different companies nationwide). In addition, this database is updated on a daily basis, whereas the one reported upon in 2013 reports on an annual basis and does not currently (November 7 2014) contain data for 2014.\n\nData is copyrighted by the Ministry of Environment and Nature Protection.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Drazen Hoffmann","reviewer":"Stevan Gostojić","score":45},{"id":"7c5b2ac8-00a5-41ba-b296-c2b74f998b83","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-11-07T16:59:20","year":2014,"place":"hr","dataset":"legislation","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://narodne-novine.nn.hr/default.aspx","format":"html","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Narodne novine, public company, which was registered as a joint-stock company with a 100% ownership by the Republic of Croatia","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"This entry is accepted without corrections.","details":"No consolidated texts of the laws. Some consolidated and purified texts are available on unofficial site zakon.hr. \n\nIn the terms of use of the website of the Narodne novine company it is stated that datasets are copyrighted by the Narodne novine and may be used only under the conditions prescribed by law. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Drazen Hoffmann","reviewer":"Stevan Gostojić","score":45},{"id":"3050a8ee-dcf1-4ac8-a94a-1d5a51ca9b53","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-11-07T17:29:31","year":2014,"place":"hr","dataset":"statistics","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.dzs.hr/","format":"pdf","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Central Bureau of Statistics","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"This entry is accepted without any modifications. Since census data is available in a machine-readable format, the \"Is the data machine readable?\" should maybe be changed to \"Yes\".","details":"Regarding up-to date status of data, the documents are available, but some are very slow processed. It is currently (as of November 2014.) unclear whether the data from the 2011 census is fully published.\n\nCensus data is available in a machine-readable format (MS Excel), but most periodical publications are not (available only in PDF or HTML).\n\nReproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium of any of CBS publications without acknowledging the Croatian Bureau of Statistics as the source is prohibited.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Drazen Hoffmann","reviewer":"Stevan Gostojić","score":45},{"id":"c32c0189-3ed5-42be-89de-941f1dc1bd82","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-11-07T17:14:01","year":2014,"place":"hr","dataset":"map","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://geoportal.dgu.hr/viewer/","format":"","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"State Geodetic Directorate","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The entry is accepted without any modifications.","details":"The State Geodetic Directorate reserves the right to set and change the terms of use of the datasets. Any alterations, making copies of and distributing the data is forbidden.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Drazen Hoffmann","reviewer":"Stevan Gostojić","score":45},{"id":"3d1f5e0d-8a5b-441a-9411-f5a260c94426","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-11-07T16:38:55","year":2014,"place":"hr","dataset":"companies","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://sudreg.pravosudje.hr","format":"","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Commercial court ","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"This entry is accepted with correction of the \"Openly licensed?\" category.","details":"Since there is no visible license on the website, we have selected \"No\" for the \"Openly licensed?\" category.\n\nDatasets are provided on a timely and up to date basis according to deadlines regulated by the Act on the Court register. In practice this means that the register is updated whenever company registration procedures are completed.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Drazen Hoffmann","reviewer":"Stevan Gostojić","score":45},{"id":"ec8b415d-7009-438e-8b3c-a7cf5d2c64a3","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-11-07T16:08:59","year":2014,"place":"hr","dataset":"elections","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.izbori.hr/izbori/ws.nsf/site.xsp?documentId=A758299505B80F02C1257C8400606C3B","format":"","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"State Election Commission","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"This entry is accepted with changes to \"Openly licensed?\" category (it is changed from \"Unsure\" to \"No\" according to the global open data index guideliness)","details":"Since there is no visible license on the website of the State Election Commission, we have selected \"No\" category. \n\n","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Drazen Hoffmann","reviewer":"Stevan Gostojić","score":45},{"id":"24cfaf8c-9b34-435e-b12c-72c5696d1b6d","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-02-25T12:23:19","year":2014,"place":"hr","dataset":"timetables","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.hzpp.hr/lgs.axd?t=16&id=10729","format":"PDF","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"Vozni red","publisher":"HŽ Putnički prijevoz","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"This entry is accepted. Data publisher and dataset title are added.","details":"Vozni red 2013/2014. - vlakovi u unutarnjem i međunarodnom prometu \n\nTimetables can also be searched online at: \nhttps://www.hzpp.hr/voznired\n\nThere is no national level service operated or regulated by the government for the bus transport.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Miroslav Schlossberg","reviewer":"Stevan Gostojić","score":55},{"id":"3aa2a0c9-eda0-45e7-9c5d-42eef1855b54","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-11-07T15:33:58","year":2014,"place":"hr","dataset":"budget","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.mfin.hr/hr/drzavni-proracun-2014-godina; https://www.mfin.hr/adminmax/docs/Posebni%20dio%20Dr%C5%BEavnog%20prora%C4%8Duna%20RH%20za%202014..xls,","format":"xls, pdf","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"State Treasury Department within the Ministry of Finance","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"This entry is accepted.","details":"Older budget records are available in non-machine readable format only.\n\nSince in the impressum of the website of the Ministry of Finance it is not clearly stated whether data is licensed by the Government of Croatia, we have selected \"No\" category. \n\nWe have selected \"Yes\" under the \"available in bulk\" category since the whole budget for 2014 is available for download in a consolidated file. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Drazen Hoffmann","reviewer":"Stevan Gostojić","score":70},{"id":"849d27bd-435a-42c0-960e-ff3331744ca2","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-28T14:18:49","year":2015,"place":"py","dataset":"postcodes","exists":"Unsure","digital":"Unsure","public":"Unsure","online":"Unsure","free":"Unsure","machinereadable":"Unsure","bulk":"Unsure","openlicense":"Unsure","uptodate":"Unsure","url":"","format":"PDF","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The data is not geocoded. Due to the level of aggregation for Asuncion, geo-referencing the information is not a simple task. For the rest of the country, I was unable to find official admin boundaries that would allow an attribute join. ","details":"Link to download de data set: (2 parts)\r\n\r\nAsuncion (Capital):\r\nhttps://www.correoparaguayo.gov.py/documents/10179/11670/Codigo+Capital/0f517dcf-f167-4ace-aea1-b631343580c0\r\n\r\nRest of the country:\r\nhttps://www.correoparaguayo.gov.py/documents/10179/11670/Codigo+Localidades/dc3c3b3f-580e-455b-b458-f55da409d309\r\n\r\nThe data is complete in the sense that it contains the list of zip codes for the country. Howerver, there is no coordinates or georeferenced data related to each zip code and therefore is does no comply with the definition of the location dataset (ZIP+GEO)\r\n\r\nThe list of zipcodes is available in PDF.\r\n\r\n\r\nDIRECCION NACIONAL DE CORREOS DEL PARAGUAY (DINACOPA)\r\nAddress: 25 de Mayo esq. Yegros\r\nPhone: (595 21) 498-112/16\r\nZIP CODE 1301\r\n\r\nOpen data law 5189:\r\nhttps://www.correoparaguayo.gov.py/web/guest/transparencia-ley-5.189","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Juan Pane","reviewer":"Codrina Maria Ilie","score":0},{"id":"d644e03c-481f-4dae-9d7b-7538cafa4770","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-08T07:57:14","year":2015,"place":"cn","dataset":"emissions","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://106.37.208.233:20035","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"National-wide Air pollutant emission","publisher":"China National Environment Monitoring Center","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"checked\r\n","details":"The China National Environment Monitoring Center is responsible for gathering and publishing the national-wide air pollutant emission data. Currently All major cities have own monitoring sites and the data are collected and published by the center. Data collected include:\r\n\r\nParticulate matter (PM) Levels\r\nSulphur oxides (SOx)\r\nNitrogen oxides (NOx)\r\nCarbon monoxide (CO)\r\n\r\nThe data is updated several times per day. No VOC data is available though. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"OKFN CN","reviewer":"yar michl","score":45},{"id":"9186ac87-f01b-4832-99c1-2ca1436db553","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-08-31T04:17:20","year":2015,"place":"au","dataset":"land","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"","format":"shapefiles, tab","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"ok","details":"Data aggregated by [PSMA](https://www.psma.com.au/) on behalf of the state, territory and Australian governments. PSMA sells the data through a number of [resellers](https://www.psma.com.au/data-access/find-a-reseller/).\r\n\r\nData is released quarterly. [Metadata](https://www.psma.com.au/cadlite-metadata-statement) and \r\n[specifications](https://www.psma.com.au/psma/wp-content/uploads/CadLiteProductDescription.pdf) are available.\r\n\r\nFormats of data vary by reseller. Formats other than those listed may be available.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Stephen Gates","reviewer":"Codrina Maria Ilie","score":35},{"id":"f16c9d6c-c547-40a6-817d-c1d825189d16","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-05T09:06:38","year":2015,"place":"fi","dataset":"companies","exists":"Yes","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Unsure","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"BIS Search","publisher":"Finnish Patent and Registration Office and the Tax Administration","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Could not find any evidence of data as detailed by submitter.","details":"The business information system has a limited companies search feature, which can be found here: https://www.ytj.fi/english/yrityshaku.aspx?path=1704;1736;2052&kielikoodi=3\r\n\r\nHowever, I have not been able to find evidence of the data (Data from the Finnish Trade Register's public notices and Data from Finnish Business Information System, in .JSON format) as specified by the submitter.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Jaakko Korhonen","reviewer":"Rebecca Sentance","score":5},{"id":"470e361a-b24c-490a-909d-288ed39613f8","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-25T13:33:31","year":2015,"place":"rs","dataset":"procurement","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://portal.ujn.gov.rs","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Portal javnih nabavki","publisher":"Uprava za javne nabavke","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Submission correct.","details":"","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Stevan Gostojić","reviewer":"Georg Neumann","score":45},{"id":"623891fe-afcc-49ac-9583-33f4933b84dc","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-22T16:08:32","year":2015,"place":"ru","dataset":"postcodes","exists":"No","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"https://www.russianpost.ru/rp/servise/ru/home/postuslug/searchops1#resultancor","format":"HTML, DBF, XML","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"If the data has no geospatial info than it does not comply with the 2015 index requirements. Additionally, a post code search service will also not comply with the 2015 index requirements. ","details":"A database of postcodes/zipcodes and a corresponding geospatial locations in terms of a latitude and a longitude (or similar co-ordinates in an openly published national co-ordinate system) DOES NOT EXIST You can only get a list of postcodes, no geospatial information. At the same time we now that by url https://www.russianpost.ru/rp/servise/ru/home/postuslug/searchops1#resultancor we could find a web form using that we could find postcode by address.\r\nSo we know that address data exists but it is not publicly available \r\n\r\nComment: No changes since 2013 year\r\nComment: No changes since 2014 year","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Ivan Begtin","reviewer":"Codrina Maria Ilie","score":0},{"id":"54110be3-ffba-4e3e-9d2c-2ccba1eb2141","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-22T16:03:48","year":2015,"place":"ru","dataset":"budget","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Russian federal budget datasets (reports, proposed budget and dictionaries)","publisher":"Ministry of Finances of Russian Federation","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The site https://budget.gov.ru/data/opendata does not exist anymore and I could not find other source. I have changed the submission accordingly. \r\n","details":"Brief Description: Russian budget data is one of most open data but a bit dispersed over a few government websites. Well prepared machine readable data available on new government webisite Budget.gov.ru right here - https://budget.gov.ru/data/opendata\r\nThis data is XML data dumped from government database as XML dumps with XSD (XML schemas) provided. Budget.gov.ru is beta-stage portal for now (November 2014) and this data is not up to date . Up to date data published as XLS on websites of Federal Treasury (https://roskazna.ru) and Ministry of Finances (https://minfin.ru) I suggest to accept this data XML but not to accept it as timely updated for now. Step by step explanation\r\n1. Does the data exist? Yes, national level budget data available at - https://budget.gov.ru/data/opendata 2. Is data in digital form? Yes, data available via website and has digital form. 3. Publicly available? Yes, this data is publicly available. We don't need FOI request to get it. 4. Is the data available for free? Yes, this data is available for free. No payment is required. 5. Is the data available online? Yes. Data available at https://budget.gov.ru/data/opendata 6. Is the data machine readable? Yes, this data provided as XML files 7. Available in bulk? Mostly yes, you need to download a few XML files 8. Openly licensed? No, this data is not formally under open license from OpenDefinition.org 9. Is the data provided on a timely and up to date basis?\r\nYes, data updated monthly\r\n\r\nComment: Nothing changed since 2014 year\r\n\r\nReviewer's comment - the data is no longer available in 2015. I have changed the data accordingly. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Ivan Begtin","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":10},{"id":"f7a648a2-52a3-4d8f-917a-1bd0da4b1cf5","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-25T13:25:17","year":2015,"place":"ru","dataset":"spending","exists":"No","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Submission correct","details":"According to IBP's [Open Budget Survey](https://survey.internationalbudget.org) the Russian Federation publishes the year end report. However the [Open Budget Library](https://openbudgetlibrary.org) contains a 2012 year end report which is more than 2 fiscal periods ago so the data does not seem to exist.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Tryggvi Björgvinsson","reviewer":"Tryggvi Björgvinsson","score":0},{"id":"2387b64b-9a2f-4865-a572-d4a747d6b07f","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-05T07:44:04","year":2015,"place":"jm","dataset":"land","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.nla.gov.jm/","format":"CSV","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"The National Land Agency (NLA) is an Executive Agency that falls under the Ministry of Water, Land, Environment and Climate Change.","publisher":"National Land Agency","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"ok","details":"Based on data availability, the land ownership is found on the iMap Jamaica website: https://www.nla.gov.jm/map.asp where you search by parcel and search by street address.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Bruce Hoo Fung","reviewer":"Codrina Maria Ilie","score":70},{"id":"355a06be-1b34-43ee-b6c1-ae5f4a0b73c5","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-09T14:17:35","year":2015,"place":"ye","dataset":"procurement","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Unsure","url":"https://htb.gov.ye/project_accepted_sh.php","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Tender Announcements and Tender Awards","publisher":"High Tender Board","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Submission correct.","details":"The High Tender Board ( https://htb.gov.ye/project_accepted_sh.php ) publishes details about tender announcements and awards. The awards page shows the name of the project, the name of the winning company, the value of the contract and other dates. The tender announcement page does not currently have any announcements, it could be possible that there are no open tenders at the moment because of the crisis in Yemen, but it is also possible that the website is just not up to date.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Riyadh Al-Balushi","reviewer":"Georg Neumann","score":35},{"id":"807557e0-5b77-404f-9b66-1869e78845ce","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-12-16T10:15:44","year":2015,"place":"sk","dataset":"water","exists":"Yes","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Unsure","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Sampling and analysis of water for customers","publisher":"Water Research Institute","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Under the Ministry of the Environment water quality for drinking water is being collected by Water Research Institute https://www.vuvh.sk/?lid=4 And environmental water quality is being collected by the Slovak Hydrometeorological Institute (SHMI). https://www.shmu.sk/en/?%20page=1776","details":"**Data was submitted by Fair Play Alliance and Jano Suchal**","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":5},{"id":"edf49441-481d-4ea6-b20c-aeab8765a386","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-12-16T10:13:58","year":2015,"place":"sk","dataset":"spending","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Submission fixed.\r\n\r\nData exists and seems to be digital but not made available publicly.","details":"There is some summary information about spending on monthly basis available at https://www.rozpocet.sk/ and https://www.finance.gov.sk/ (see for example https://www.rozpocet.sk/app/homepage/rozpocetVCislach/monitoringStatnehoRozpoctu/mesacnePlnenie/2014/ and also for example https://www.finance.gov.sk/Default.aspx?CatID=9779) but those do not match the definition used by Census.\r\n\r\nThe data is still relatively recent (a couple of weeks) which indicates digital form of data.\r\n**Data was submitted by Fair Play Alliance and Jano Suchal**\r\n","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":10},{"id":"63bf3d98-7bb4-4457-a9a2-ba75e012fb89","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-12-16T10:13:24","year":2015,"place":"sk","dataset":"companies","exists":"Yes","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Obchodný register SR (Company register of the Slovak Republic)","publisher":"Ministerstvo Spravodlivosti Slovenskej Republiky (Ministry of Justice, SR)","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"It is not possible to browse through the database or access data without providing a search term, therefore the registry does not qualify for most of the criteria.","details":"It is only possible to obtain companies data by searching for a keyword. Company names can be clicked on to view more detailed data, although addresses are not included in the database. https://www.orsr.sk/search_subjekt.asp?lan=en \r\n\r\n**Data was submitted by Fair Play Alliance and Jano Suchal**","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":15},{"id":"4a31a831-5f60-4052-8512-e9b22ab9c7ac","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-12-16T10:11:56","year":2015,"place":"sk","dataset":"weather","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"No","online":"Yes","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.shmu.sk","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Slovak Hydrometeorological Institute; shmu@shmu.sk","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"\r\nChanged 'available online' to a yes based on the link provided in the comments.\r\n\r\nOtherwise, this submission is accepted as the dataset contains 5+ days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.","details":"Most of the data is available online. The only item from the required minimum that is not publicly available is historical data. \r\n\r\nThe data is available at https://www.shmu.sk/ only in web view. It is not available in bulk, it is not machine-readable and it is copyrighted, so it is not openly licensed. The topic of copyright protection of meteorological data was publicly discussed for a short while in the past, but the Hydrometeorological Institute fought for the right to continue producing and publishing the data as copyrighted material.\r\n\r\n**Data was submitted by Fair Play Alliance and Jano Suchal**","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":25},{"id":"19dbe3b0-193f-473d-996c-ac8a99d8d5ae","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-12-16T10:10:54","year":2015,"place":"sk","dataset":"land","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"No","machinereadable":"Unsure","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.katasterportal.sk/kapor/","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Úrad geodézie, kartografie a katastra (https://www.skgeodesy.sk/sk/)","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"When this review was made: \"Cadastral portal is not accessible by reason of data update preparation!","details":"Cadastral data is free for non-commercial usage. Bulk data & commercial usage is only possible after paying fees and under strict licence.\r\n\r\n**Data was submitted by Fair Play Alliance and Jano Suchal**","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":30},{"id":"627c4dda-f04c-470a-9ad4-911090fe22c7","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-12-16T10:02:08","year":2015,"place":"sk","dataset":"procurement","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www2.uvo.gov.sk/evestnik","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Public Procurement Bulletin","publisher":"Office for Public Procurement; info@uvo.gov.sk","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Submission correct.","details":"The data is available since 2009. It is updated daily and is quite detailed. It is not structured, machine-readable, nor published in bulk or licensed under an open license, though. \r\n\r\nThe data can be scraped and is being scraped and re-published in structured format by several NGOs.\r\n\r\nOffice for Public Procurement often changes the structure of the Bulletin, which disables scrapers. A couple of weeks ago the whole Bulletin even moved to a new URL (the original URl was identical tu the current one, except it started with \"www\" not \"www2\"). The change made all links to individual data from the Bulletin non-functional and confused users of the data. It is possible that this is a part of a redesign of the Office website and the Bulletin will be moved back to its original location in time.\r\n\r\n**Data was submitted by Fair Play Alliance and Jano Suchal**","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":45},{"id":"bc3f38d7-b04c-4dfd-a498-abeb06d21c4b","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-12-16T10:01:23","year":2015,"place":"sk","dataset":"emissions","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.shmu.sk/en/?page=991","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Current air quality information","publisher":"Slovak hydrometeorological institute","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"checked i write no licensed by after i read this txt\r\n\r\n© 2015 Slovak hydrometeorological institute All the information, texts and images contained on the https://www.shmu.sk website are intellectual property of the Slovak hydrometeorological institute (SHMÚ) and may be downloaded or copied only for personal use. Appropriate acknowledgement of the SHMÚ is required if material is re-published in any format. SHMÚ disclaims responsibility for quality of meteorological and hydrological information from any other source than SHMÚ.","details":"**Data was submitted by Fair Play Alliance and Jano Suchal**","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":45},{"id":"ec9af61b-fdd1-4b56-a9c8-8b09459fa833","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-12-16T10:00:03","year":2015,"place":"sk","dataset":"legislation","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://jaspi.justice.gov.sk/","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Ministerstvo Spravodlivosti SR (Ministry of Justice of the Slovak Republic); informacie211@justice.sk","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The submission is correct.","details":"Legally binding is only paper version of statute. Data can be easily scraped from web page. There is a copyright notice so \"no\" is filled for open license. \r\n\r\n**Data was submitted by Fair Play Alliance and Jano Suchal**","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Mor Rubinstein","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":45},{"id":"9d98611f-f870-4d12-8f2b-78f8a1a7c498","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-12-16T09:52:53","year":2015,"place":"sk","dataset":"statistics","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://slovak.statistics.sk/","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Statistical office of the Slovak Republic; info@statistics.sk","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The data is regularly updated in html","details":"There is no formal license attached to data, only copyright assertion at the bottom of the page. So at least free access is assumed (sort of improvement over 2013), while openly licensed is filled as \"no\".\r\n\r\nNot all data is consistently availabe this way but at least those few stats mentioned in Census definition are, thus we can fill \"yes\" for \"is it accessible online\" (again, sort of improvement over 2013).\r\n\r\n[Population][1] up to 2014.\r\n\r\n[Unemployment][2] (quarterly up to 2015)\r\n\r\n[GDP][3]\r\n\r\n\r\n [1]: https://statdat.statistics.sk/cognosext/cgi-bin/cognos.cgi?b_action=cognosViewer&ui.action=run&ui.object=storeID(%22i700C5B7ABED1414B8B23B4A69E91D146%22)&ui.name=Population%20(absolute%20data)%20%5Bom0001rs%5D&run.outputFormat=&run.prompt=true&cv.header=false&ui.backURL=%2Fcognosext%2Fcps4%2Fportlets%2Fcommon%2Fclose.html&run.outputLocale=en\r\n [2]: https://statdat.statistics.sk/cognosext/cgi-bin/cognos.cgi?b_action=cognosViewer&ui.action=run&ui.object=storeID(%22iB193D1C87387465B954B10BE9F45111D%22)&ui.name=Employed%20by%20the%20Labour%20Force%20Sample%20Survey%20%5Bpr0002qs%5D&run.outputFormat=&run.prompt=true&cv.header=false&ui.backURL=%2Fcognosext%2Fcps4%2Fportlets%2Fcommon%2Fclose.html&run.outputLocale=en\r\n [3]: https://statdat.statistics.sk/cognosext/cgi-bin/cognos.cgi?b_action=cognosViewer&ui.action=run&ui.object=storeID(%22iA188D5A85FEF4EA9B48BC102C7C66758%22)&ui.name=Quarterly%20GDP%20data%20for%202013%20at%20curent%20prices%20%5Bnu0002qs%5D&run.outputFormat=&run.prompt=true&cv.header=false&ui.backURL=%2Fcognosext%2Fcps4%2Fportlets%2Fcommon%2Fclose.html&run.outputLocale=en\r\n\r\n**Data was submitted by Fair Play Alliance and Jano Suchal**","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":45},{"id":"0aa86b8d-bcea-400e-a665-68fdc0afbe56","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-12-16T09:51:34","year":2015,"place":"sk","dataset":"map","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Unsure","url":"https://zbgis.skgeodesy.sk/tkgis/default.aspx","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Geodetický a kartografický ústav Bratislava","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"My review reached similar conclusions.","details":"Maps are available via interactive portal without means to export data for the general public (other than printing in PDF). Maps are available in resolutions up to 1:2000 .\r\n\r\nThere is a copyright notice at the bottom of the page, apart from that, no other license is available specifically for the data - so \"No\" is indicated as an answer in this regard. \r\n\r\nThe data, though, should be available for download, even in bulk, machine/readable formats, for a fee. We couldn't test this functionality, therefore we couldn't specify the formats of the data and stated \"Unsure\" in the question about machine-readability.\r\n\r\nAccording to our knowledge, the data for the whole of Slovakia is updated approximately once in 3 years. The map seems to be up-to-date at the moment, but no information about last updates is provided, so \"Unsure\" is indicated as an answer for the last question.\r\n\r\n**Data was submitted by Fair Play Alliance and Jano Suchal**","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":45},{"id":"3b0a1f61-0f7e-4458-ac29-1039e83824fd","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-12-16T09:50:22","year":2015,"place":"sk","dataset":"elections","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Unsure","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://volby.statistics.sk/","format":"CSV","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Volby a referendum - Election (national, municipal, EU) and referendum data for all elections since 1990.","publisher":"Statistical Office of the Slovak Republic; info@statistics.sk","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The submission is correct.","details":"All election and refernedum results are available at https://volby.statistics.sk/ The dataset meets all criteria, the only drawback being licensing - as usually in Slovakia, no license is given.\r\n\r\n**Data was submitted by Fair Play Alliance and Jano Suchal**","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":70},{"id":"bc49003c-f10a-4ae0-b136-6d7c85eaa982","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-12-16T09:46:58","year":2015,"place":"sk","dataset":"budget","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.rozpocet.sk/","format":"Excel","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Ministerstvo financií Slovenskej republiky (Ministry of Finance, Slovak Republic); info@mfsr.sk","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"I have checked the data and it is correct.","details":"Data is available in a form of \"interactive portal\". XLS export is available for most data. License is not clearly stated and there is copyright notice in the footer of the web page so \"no\" is filled. \r\n\r\n**Data was submitted by Fair Play Alliance and Jano Suchal**","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":70},{"id":"5f9b30c7-a50f-47cd-be65-6bf2a37d3842","site":"global","timestamp":"2014-10-27T12:24:14","year":2014,"place":"nz","dataset":"postcodes","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"","format":"ESRI Shapefile,MapInfo TAB","licenseurl":"","dateavailable":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Not publically available or online (must email and pay)","details":"Postcode data is managed by NZ Post, a state-owned enterprise, with a commercial model. The Postcode Network File is $400-$2100/year depending on use and the license restricts reuse. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Mark Heseltine","reviewer":"Alex Sadleir","score":45},{"id":"76c56e3b-355e-4e1d-a0e3-00e1445d2249","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-25T16:49:55","year":2015,"place":"be","dataset":"companies","exists":"Yes","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Company register","publisher":"KBO","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"I could not find evidence of the data as described by the submitter, only the free search feature which is very restrictive.","details":"**Reviewer's comment**: It appears that it is only possible to obtain companies data by inputting a search term of 9 or 10 characters into this free search engine: https://kbopub.economie.fgov.be/kbopub/zoeknummerform.html There is no other way to freely browse or obtain the data. I have been unable to find evidence of the data as described by the submitter below.\r\n \r\n\r\n**Submitter's comment:**\r\nThere are three ways to obtain this data. \r\nOne is as an Open Data CSV file that is updated monthly and available for free after registration, in this dataset however you can only see the publicly available information about the companies. \r\nThere is also a daily updated webservice where users pay 50 euro per 2000 queries. \r\nAnd there is a full xml catalogue, daily updated with more up-to-date information on the companies (current and stopped). For this you pay a license of 75000 euro per year.\r\n\r\nAs long as the basic way to obtain data is not open without needing to register, we cannot see this as open data under the open definition as defined on https://opendefinition.org/. \r\n","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"anonymous","reviewer":"Rebecca Sentance","score":15},{"id":"5aed16e1-2a74-4b69-9ecb-9d2bd570f82e","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-08T19:21:45","year":2015,"place":"tn","dataset":"companies","exists":"Unsure","digital":"Unsure","public":"Unsure","online":"Unsure","free":"Unsure","machinereadable":"Unsure","bulk":"Unsure","openlicense":"Unsure","uptodate":"Unsure","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Changed the dataset's existence to \"unsure\" based on the existence of some qualifying data, but not enough to satisfy the requirements of the Index.","details":"We checked in September 8, and it stated last update was in August 31. So it is updated. In the Industrial Business Directory is contains only companies with more than 10 employees. Total registered is 5,636, as for the Directory Service companies the total registered is 3,117. Names of companies and addresses are listed, but no unique identifier seem to exist, only company legal names (Dénomination) and Raison Sociale. We are not sure these are all the companies in Tunisia, especially that it is stated in their FAQ that \"To be included in the directory of industrial companies, which is available free of charge to operating industrial enterprises operating in Tunisia and employing ten people or more, contact the Regional Directorate of the API implementation that covers your region\". Which means only companies who contact them are being listed.\r\n\r\nLast year's comment below:\r\n\r\nNo information about license, therefore the data is considered non-open. \r\nIndustry: https://www.tunisieindustrie.nat.tn/fr/dbi.asp\r\nServices : https://www.tunisieindustrie.nat.tn/fr/dbs.asp ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Tarek Amr","reviewer":"Rebecca Sentance","score":0},{"id":"f68284b6-4096-47ca-a0ea-f8efe15b5024","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-06T11:27:12","year":2015,"place":"nl","dataset":"elections","exists":"No","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"https://www.verkiezingsuitslagen.nl/","format":"CSV","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The submission does not meet the definition. As the submission says, data is only available at the level of municipalities of up to 800.000 people.\r\n","details":"2014 entry: \r\nThe data on elections is not open to the public under EML standard. If this data is open it would enable new applications and insights that have a positive impact on our democracy. At this moment, very little information is available about the elections: On the website of the Election Council the results appear only five weeks after the elections in its database. In this database, only the results on the municipal level is shown, not at the level of polling stations. Although the unofficial results of the local elections were announced one day after the elections (March 20, 2014), one is referred to the websites of local governments for the results. On March 28, 2014 when the last recounts were done, one is still referred to the websites of local governments. On election night, news is followed by calls that are made by news agencies to municipalities. These are not actual open data of the actual results. A misinterpretation of results or an error in the news chain could cause wrong information being spread.\r\n\r\nhttps://openstate.eu/2014/05/elections-data-in-the-netherlands-do-our-votes-count/\r\n\r\nUpdate 2015: Data still not openly available - updated some questions from 'unsure' to 'no' based on what's available via https://www.verkiezingsuitslagen.nl/","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Sander van der Waal","reviewer":"Kamil Gregor","score":0},{"id":"71d8fc6d-0f6b-4468-bfd3-baec3b51b5b0","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-12-08T08:53:41","year":2015,"place":"gb","dataset":"procurement","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"No","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.gov.uk/contracts-finder","format":"XML, CSV","licenseurl":"https://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open-government-licence/version/2/","officialtitle":"Contracts Finder","publisher":"Government Digital Service (Cabinet Office)","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Data is not available in bulk. Data is machine readable and up-to-date. ","details":"In February 2015 the Cabinet Office launched a new version of [Contracts Finder][1] as a beta service. This service provides a search facility for public sector procurement contracts in England. Similar services are available for Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland (though the NI service requires registration).\r\n\r\nCabinet Office has separately made available a [static archive of data from the earlier version of Contracts Finder][2], covering the period from February 2011 to February 2015.\r\n\r\nInformation posted to Contracts Finder (past and present) is generally re-usable under the Open Government Licence but some contract records contain exceptions and are therefore non-open.\r\n\r\n [1]: https://www.gov.uk/contracts-finder\r\n [2]: https://data.gov.uk/data/contracts-finder-archive/","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"Mor Rubinstein","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":90},{"id":"e3720a48-02f9-4fbc-a082-c3ce1720bb5d","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-11-23T21:50:33","year":2015,"place":"co","dataset":"water","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://sig.anla.gov.co:8083/","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Sistema de Información Ambiental Colombiano-SIAC","publisher":"Instituto de Hidrología, Meteorología y Estudios Ambientales-IDEAM, Contacto: Leonardo Cárdenas, jefe de sistemas. Contacto: lcardenas@ideam.gov.co","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The water quality data does exist per resource with the right parameters. However, the system is not easy to use. It does not allow download of the data in bulk of machine readable format, and it is not openly licensed. https://www.siac.gov.co/contenido/contenido.aspx?catID=48&conID=47","details":"Se incluye el visor con el sistema de información ambiental en Colombia-SIAC. En la url https://sig.anla.gov.co:8083/resources/Manuales/InformacionSIAC.pdf podrá encontrar el contenido del SIAC, con datos de calidad del agua.\r\n\r\nPor otra parte, podrá encontrar en las siguientes url más información con el estado del agua en Colombia: \r\n\r\nhttps://www.siac.gov.co/contenido/contenido.aspx?catID=860&conID=1373\r\n\r\nhttps://www.siac.gov.co/contenido/contenido.aspx?catID=815&conID=1374\r\n\r\nhttps://www.siac.gov.co/contenido/contenido.aspx?catID=815&conID=1375\r\n\r\n\r\n\r\n ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Juan Felipe Devia Rodriguez","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":45},{"id":"ca0e0a62-4de9-422e-ac08-885267ec7b0a","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-17T12:54:25","year":2015,"place":"bg","dataset":"postcodes","exists":"Unsure","digital":"Unsure","public":"Unsure","online":"Unsure","free":"Unsure","machinereadable":"Unsure","bulk":"Unsure","openlicense":"Unsure","uptodate":"Unsure","url":"https://inspire.cadastre.bg/index.php","format":"json","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Bulgaria has a post code system https://inspire.cadastre.bg/index.php. Admin boundaries file is only accepted for those countries that don't have a post code system. \r\n\r\n","details":"Administrative boundaries on all levels including land parcels are available freely. This includes landmarks like springs, etc. The property level information exists only for about 30% of the country. \r\n\r\n","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Boyan Yurukov","reviewer":"Codrina Maria Ilie","score":0},{"id":"2b7fa27f-c5af-4656-892f-bcda58f2761d","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-09-24T18:48:20","year":2015,"place":"dk","dataset":"elections","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.statbank.dk/statbank5a/SelectTable/Omrade0.asp?SubjectCode=02&ShowNews=OFF&PLanguage=1","format":"PC-AXIS (*.px), Excel (*.xlsx), Excel (*.xls), DBase (*.dbf), DBase in rows (*.dbf), SAS program (*.sas), Semicolon sep. (*.csv), Tab. sep. (*.csv), Comma sep. (*.csv), Matrix (*.csv), Text with layout (*.txt), Text matrix (*.txt), Time series (*.tsd), Time series batch (*.asb)","licenseurl":"https://www.dst.dk/da/omds/omweb.aspx","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Statistics Denmark","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"The submission is correct.","details":"First data on candidates etc. is available before election. During the election night results are made public with an estimated ten minutes delay, but not on the lowest geographical level. Full results are available when officially checked the day after the election. Historical data and data from other local elections, regional elections and referendums are available in the same manner.","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"Niels Erik Kaaber Rasmussen","reviewer":"Kamil Gregor","score":100},{"id":"538118ac-2a3d-431f-aeff-7f895eacdf5a","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-02T18:36:42","year":2015,"place":"se","dataset":"procurement","exists":"No","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Information about the procurement process is available at https://www.konkurrensverket.se and at https://www.upphandlingsmyndigheten.se since September 1, but I can find information on tenders. ","details":"","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Asmen Gül","reviewer":"Georg Neumann","score":0},{"id":"6ab505fb-0e69-436b-945d-594977a8d2f7","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-10-13T17:16:03","year":2015,"place":"co","dataset":"weather","exists":"No","digital":"No","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"https://www.pronosticosyalertas.gov.co/pronosticos","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Data exist here - https://www.pronosticosyalertas.gov.co/pronosticos but do only contains precipitation and temperature for 3 days, therefore, it does not mean the minimum criteria of weather data. ","details":"Puede consultar más información sobre PRONÓSTICOS Y ALERTAS, dando click en los siguientes temas, ubicados en el portal principal:\r\n \r\nPronósticos\r\nAlertas\r\nImágenes Satelitales\r\nModelos de Pronóstico Meteorológico\r\nInformación diaria de precipitación y temperatura de los principales aeropuertos del país\r\n\r\nPor otra parte, se cuenta también con boletines e informes técnicos, así como de mapas y estimación satelital.\r\n\r\nReviewer's note - Data is only available for three days and does not meet the criteria. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Juan Felipe Devia Rodriguez","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":0},{"id":"4bcd09be-8aca-4829-a826-38d8e9b28e43","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-11-23T13:46:41","year":2015,"place":"no","dataset":"weather","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"Yes","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.met.no/?module=Articles;action=Article.publicShow;ID=620","format":"XML","licenseurl":"https://om.yr.no/info/datapolicy/","officialtitle":"Met.no provides free weather data through APIs and services. Forecasts are also available via yr.no - a joint service with NRK - the norwegian national brodcasting corportation (https://www.nrk.no/)","publisher":"Norwegian Meteorological Institute (met.no)","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Data is available in bulk. Submission accepted. ","details":"Qa review- \r\nThe license indicates that there is data in a machine readable format. I found the data in XML format and changed the submission. \r\n\r\nSubmission 2015-11-23:\r\n- Changed publisher to the meteorological institute, in stead of yr.no, which re-use their data.\r\n- Changed bulk-download from \"Unsure\" to \"Yes\".\r\n- Changed link to data to point to the Norwegian Meteorological Institute's web page about open data. From that page, there's links to api.met.no and yr.no for weather forecasts and to other services for bulk-downloads and historical data.\r\n\r\nSee previous comment for more details:\r\nhttps://global.census.okfn.org/submission/b136b239-d962-437f-9bb9-69de95a2296a#comments","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"Yes","submitter":"Bergheimivar L","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":100},{"id":"3c9f0640-0e5f-4c2c-9136-a5ad182708c7","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-11-25T11:06:23","year":2015,"place":"je","dataset":"procurement","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Data does exist and is in digital form, but the award data is not published. Therefore, it is not publicly available, ","details":"The Jersey government through its Corporate Procurement Services, States of Jersey Treasury Department publishes information about [current tender opportunities][1] worth more than £100,000, including an archive of opportunities, but does not publish information about awarded tenders.\r\n\r\n\r\n [1]: https://www.channelislandtenders.com/procontract/channelislands/supplier.nsf/frm_planner_search_results?OpenForm&contains=&cats=&order_by=DATE&all_opps=&org_id=ALL\r\n\r\nThere is a strict confidentiality policy in place, so one party accessing the tender documents may not share them with another apart from on a need-to-know basis.\r\n\r\nJersey and Guernsey, which are two different jurisdictions but are only 20 miles apart, use a shared service (Channel Island Tenders) for open tendering. Therefore the assessment of JE and GG should be identical. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Mor Rubinstein","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":10},{"id":"25daa150-3a51-4ab0-986b-1aab6ae9a7d1","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-11-25T11:04:43","year":2015,"place":"gg","dataset":"procurement","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Channel Island Tenders","publisher":"Corporate Procurement Services, States of Guernsey Treasury and Resources Department treasury@gov.gg","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Data exist and digital, but award data is not published. Therefore, the reviewer gave points for the existence and digitization of the data only. ","details":"The Guernsey government through its Corporate Procurement Services, States of Guernsey Treasury and Resources Department publishes information about [current tender opportunities][1], but does not provide an archive of opportunities and does not publish information about awarded tenders.\r\n\r\n\r\n [1]: https://www.channelislandtenders.com/procontract/channelislands/supplier.nsf/frm_planner_search_results?OpenForm&contains=&cats=&order_by=DATE&all_opps=&org_id=ALL","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Mor Rubinstein","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":10},{"id":"e0e6e87a-982e-4056-951e-d04c66752cf9","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-11-25T10:49:20","year":2015,"place":"ca","dataset":"elections","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"","publisher":"Elections Canada","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Data is not in poll station level. Change it to exist but not publish. ","details":"2013- 2014 - Elections Canada is the elections authority at a national level. Its terms and conditions prohibit commercial reproduction of materials on its website (https://www.elections.ca/content.aspx?section=ele&document=index&lang=e). However, data.gc.ca publishes many of the same materials under an open license. Elections are also held in the provinces and territories as well as municipalities. Each jurisdiction would need to be contacted to assess the degree of openess. Regarding the conflicting licences we have sent a question to the respective authorities but we have assessed that data is available under an open licence. \r\n\r\nCanada does count and report results in [poll station level][1], but it publish and display the results in an [aggregated district level.][2] \r\nTherefore, the data exists and is digital, it just not publicly available. \r\n\r\n\r\n [1]: https://www.elections.ca/enr/help/help_notices_e.htm#polls\r\n [2]: https://enr.elections.ca/ElectoralDistricts.aspx?lang=e","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Mor Rubinstein","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":20},{"id":"9ea5bcd3-ea50-4c9d-a72d-0832e4bcb2da","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-11-23T16:40:50","year":2015,"place":"ua","dataset":"procurement","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://tender.me.gov.ua/EDZFrontOffice/menu/en/","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Ukrainian Public Procurements","publisher":"Zovnishtorgvydav Ukrainy","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Changed according to the thematic reviewer second review. ","details":"In addition to the website we assessed here, [Prozorro][1], an independent web application that is actively supported and scaled up by the government, is being developed to increase the level of transparency of procurement. Through ProZorro all tender and award data is accessible, machine-readable, & openly licensed.\r\n\r\n\r\n [1]: https://bi.prozorro.org","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Georg Neumann","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":45},{"id":"6f2a143d-a2fe-4bd0-a1a8-27e36c2f2e7e","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-11-23T16:45:49","year":2015,"place":"sn","dataset":"procurement","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"Yes","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://www.marchespublics.sn/index.php?option=com_attribution&task=listeavisattribution&Itemid=203","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Contract awards","publisher":"Central Directorate of Public Procurement","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Changed according to the reviewer second review. See comments above. ","details":"The procurement tenders are made available for public on a dedicated website. User can query and download data for free. Bulk download is only available as PDF. ","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Georg Neumann","reviewer":"Mor Rubinstein","score":45},{"id":"4cd88711-28c1-43a4-ab33-5cb9d9b3c1fa","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-11-25T10:15:02","year":2015,"place":"ca","dataset":"land","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"No","online":"No","free":"No","machinereadable":"No","bulk":"No","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"No","url":"","format":"","licenseurl":"","officialtitle":"Canada Lands Survey System - Digital Cadastral Data","publisher":"GeoGratis - Natural Resources Canada","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"We were not able to identify land parcel information to comply to the index requirements (national coverage, land borders, land size).","details":"Canada as a federation has divisions of powers and distributed responsibility over lands across provinces and territories. Lands is a provincial responsibility however there are federal land responsibilities. Cadastre data are provided for some provinces and territories via GeoGratis. The text below provides additional information and is from the following URL https://clss.nrcan.gc.ca/cadastraldata-donneescadastrales-eng.php\r\n\r\n\"Canada Lands Digital Cadastral Data provides the cadastral parcel framework for specified Canada Lands. This cadastral line and parcel structured vector data is designed and suited for Geographic Information Systems (GIS) application.\r\n\r\nBy using this data, it is important to understand and accept that the data is not to be used for defining boundaries. Administrative decisions should be based on legal documents and legal survey plans.\r\n\r\nThe datasets are updated when new survey plans are recorded in the Canada Lands Survey Records (CLSR). Frequent visits to this site are recommended.\r\n\r\nThe links below will guide you to the FTP locations where you can freely download our cadastral datasets. Please contact the regional representative for questions pertaining to the data.\r\n\r\nCanada Map\r\nAlberta\r\nBritish Columbia\r\nManitoba\r\nNew Brunswick\r\nNewfoundland and Labrador\r\nNorthwest Territories\r\nNova Scotia\r\nNunavut\r\nOntario\r\nPrince Edward Island\r\nQuebec\r\nSaskatchewan\r\nYukon\"","isCurrent":"Yes","isOpen":"No","submitter":"Codrina Maria Ilie","reviewer":"Codrina Maria Ilie","score":10},{"id":"9ecae855-0c36-4969-b85d-80af75dae585","site":"global","timestamp":"2015-11-04T16:56:17","year":2015,"place":"fr","dataset":"postcodes","exists":"Yes","digital":"Yes","public":"No","online":"Yes","free":"Yes","machinereadable":"Yes","bulk":"Yes","openlicense":"No","uptodate":"Yes","url":"https://adresse.data.gouv.fr/download/","format":"CSV","licenseurl":"https://opendatacommons.org/licenses/odbl/1-0/","officialtitle":"BAN National address database (version ODBL)","publisher":"IGN & La Poste & OSM France","reviewed":"Yes","reviewResult":"Yes","reviewComments":"Reviewing the location theme for France was not an easy task due to the intricate situation created by the existence of 2 official datasets, one belonging to the National Post and one created in collaboration with other gov departments and with OpenStreetMap France. One significant difference that we need to point out to is the different licensing of the 2: the dataset build in collaboration with OSM has a ODbL license, and the other one has a specific license. The latter is a restrictive proprietary license (https://adresse.data.gouv.fr/static/pdf/BAN%20Licence%20de%20repartage.pdf). An analysis made by the civil society can be found here (https://www.savoirscom1.info/2015/04/ouverture-de-la-base-dadresses-nationale-ban-la-fete-gachee-par-une-licence-piege/). \r\nIt clearly shows a situation that has the potential to generate a multitude of legal, but not only, issues that could significantly hider the access to the reuse of this information. \r\nThe index has been constructed taking into account the various issues that arise from the mentioned situation, from license, to quality of data, from coverage to the entities and their official role in building this dataset. \r\nWe would also like to mention that we recognize the high quality of the dataset built in collaboration with OpenStreetMap and that we applaud this open-mindedness. However, for this wonderful initiative to be truly productive and without a doubt a pillar in the base data of France, we consider that significant steps must be made in the direction of dissolving this complicated situation. ","details":"NEW COMMENT FROM CMFG (ETALAB) :\r\n\r\nThe national address database (BAN) fulfills the requirements to a larger extent as it gives coordinates for all addresses including their zipcodes. It exists in two versions of the base and the first one is the one that is taken into account in this submission (and not in the previous one). We believe this BAN ODBL version can be accepted as an official source because:\r\n- A link to the ODBL version of the BAN, distributed by OSM France, is provided on an official & governmental website: https://adresse.data.gouv.fr/download/ (second link at the bottom of the page) according to the terms of the official BAN convention signed between IGN, La Poste, Etalab and OSM France https://openstreetmap.fr/f/Convention%20BAN%2015%20avril%202015%20SCAN%20SIGNE.pdf\r\n- the data have the same source than the second version mentionned in the previous comment and is formated at and by Etalab (Prime Minister office for open data and open gov) \r\n\r\nPREVIOUS COMMENT FROM REGARDS CITOYENS : \r\n\r\nThe previously registered \"Base officielle des codes postaux\" by La Poste