"id","site","timestamp","year","place","dataset","exists","digital","public","online","free","machinereadable","bulk","openlicence","uptodate","url","format","licenseurl","dateavailable","officialtitle","publisher","reviewed","reviewResult","reviewComments","details","isCurrent","isOpen","submitter","reviewer","score"
"49b9f0a8-299b-49bd-961c-d39ccd56be25","global","2015-09-28T03:33:22","2015","ar","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Post code search service does not comply with 2015 index requirements. ","Argentina has an up to date zipcodes dataset on this website:
https://www.correoargentino.com.ar/formularios/cpa
However, it does not contain the relevant Geodata, and it is in a separate dataset. ","Yes","No","Yamila García","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"286cd52d-0148-4b87-ac55-22a7eaf196e7","global","2015-09-29T00:04:55","2015","pa","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Approving submission, couldn't find data on water quality.",,"Yes","No","HAMZAH HAJI","Nisha Thompson","0"
"88754a39-5310-4670-98a4-ef3e4df1fc40","global","2015-08-02T12:31:30","2015","uz","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.stat.uz/en/",,,,,"The State Committee for the Republic of Uzbekistan on Statistics","Yes","Yes","Data are available but not regularly updated and not open.","[GDP][1] up to 2015
[Unemployment][2] for 2012.
[Population][3] up to 2014.
[1]: https://1.%20https://www.stat.uz/en/88-interaktivnye-uslugi/773-macroeconomic-indicators-of-the-republic-of-uzbekistan
[2]: https://gender.stat.uz/en/main-indicators/labor/economically-active-population/171-female-to-male-ratio-of-total-employment-in-the-formal-sector-of-the-economy-in-2012
[3]: https://www.stat.uz/en/statinfo/demograficheskie-dannye","Yes","No","Diyora Kabulova","Zach Christensen","35"
"6852bbc4-7fa6-4e6c-93e8-087f36726778","global","2015-09-19T00:55:54","2015","mx","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www3.inegi.org.mx/sistemas/productos/default.aspx?c=265&s=inegi&upc=702825046385&pf=Prod&ef=&f=2&cl=0&tg=8&pg=0"," CSV, PDF, XLSX","https://www.inegi.org.mx/terminos/terminos_info.aspx",,,"Instituto Nacional de Estadistica y geografia - INEGI","Yes","Yes","Data available in multiple formats and licensed to be open.","Data is accessible in a wide variety of formats and can be downloaded in bulk.
Right now the terms of use clearly state that the only requirement is the source attribution.","Yes","Yes","Enrique Zapata","Zach Christensen","100"
"7b8acd9b-7321-451e-89b6-96c6cfe646e1","global","2015-10-01T15:51:44","2015","gt","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.minfin.gob.gt/index.php/proyecto-de-presupuesto",,,,"Proyecto de Presupuesto General de Ingresos y Egresos del Estado","Ministerio de Finanzas Públicas","Yes","Yes","I could not find a license, therefore, i have changed the license section to NO. ","PDFs available
The actual link to the 2016 budget proyect is:
https://www.minfin.gob.gt/archivos/proypre2016/inicio.htm
The form didn´t accept it. The link on the form takes you to the place were all the proyects for past years included the one for 2016, are listed. ","Yes","No","Iscelle Marsicovetere","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"423e3630-9ef3-4e53-acee-9fdc3848a5c8","global","2015-10-01T16:45:54","2015","mx","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://sinaica.ine.gob.mx/",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","Information can be accessed in different portals. Most information can is gathered int the National Institute of Ecology (https://sinaica.ine.gob.mx) though machine readable files commonly do not follow a database layout. Data is clustered at a state level and divided in different time-lapse data clusters. Most files are accessible in: https://www.inecc.gob.mx/calaire-presentacion/546-calaire-indicadores The Ministry of Environment's porta contains similar information:
https://app1.semarnat.gob.mx/dgeia/clave_2010/clave/indicadores/ibi_apps/ind_clave_05.html
https://app1.semarnat.gob.mx/dgeia/clave_2010/clave/indicadores/ibi_apps/ind_clave_06.html
https://app1.semarnat.gob.mx/dgeia/clave_2010/clave/indicadores/ibi_apps/ind_clave_08.html Also, data is also identified under research center's web sites, such as Mexico's National Autonomous University: https://www.atmosfera.unam.mx/procca/Ozono.php Furthermore, SEMARNAT's Pollution Transfer and Emissions registry (RETC) contains a national database of air, water, ground and underground contains record of pollution sources and environmental assessments. RETC's landing page can be accesed here: https://www.semarnat.gob.mx/temas/gestionambiental/calidaddelaire/Paginas/retc.aspx and data (not in bulk) accessed here: https://app1.semarnat.gob.mx/retc/retc/index.php No license information found, which means it's not an open license.
Found bulk data for air measurements here but it's not timely (until end of 2008): https://www2.inecc.gob.mx/dgicurg/calaire/tend/horarias/concentra.php
------
For 2014's review, it was noted that the main data has not been updated since September 6th 2013 16:17hrs.
INECC's web site (https://www.inecc.gob.mx/acerca/831-pol-privacidad) does not use an open license. Under it's privacy statement, it indicates ""Some rights reserved"" and in the policy legend does not explain the terms and conditions for the use of the data besides explicitly prohibiting parcial or total reuse of content for commercial purposes: ""Queda estrictamente prohibido la reproducción total o parcial con fines comerciales de los datos, gráficos e información contenidos en esta página, por cualquier medio y de cualquier forma salvo para fines bibliográficos que reconozcan al autor de los documentos publicados en este sitio.""
For 2015: There is no air quality data to other regions beside Mexico City. The information in the portal above does not contain the relevant pollutants. Therefore, I indicated the data as does not exist.
The link to Mexico City air quality data - https://www.aire.df.gob.mx/default.php
add by yaron
the data provided on a timely and up to date basis
its can been seem here-i didnt find the page That the information is taken [link][1]
also the site list Mexico is a Country with online data
[link][2]
[1]: https://aqicn.org/city/mexico/nuevo-leon/garcia/
[2]: https://aqicn.org/sources/","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","yar michl","45"
"e5d42d97-76d9-4785-8db1-a281f29e775a","global","2014-10-30T02:25:37","2014","co","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://datosabiertoscolombia.cloudapp.net/frm/catalogo/frmCatalogo.aspx?dsId=20771","EXCEL, TEXTO","https://datosabiertoscolombia.cloudapp.net/frm/buscador/frmBusquedaAvanzada.aspx?bs=BARRANQUILLA",,,"TRANSMETRO comunicaciones@transmetro.gov.co","Yes","Yes","Information only for Barranquilla, not on a national level. ","Es importante aclarar que se sugiere suministrar esta información de
carácter regional teniendo en cuenta que la información de Transporte no está centralizada ya que es potestad de las entidades que administran los sistemas y las entidades territoriales definir los horarios","Yes","Yes","Gomezina L","Oscar Montiel","100"
"7c267826-a5e5-477e-a216-57e9bdcf1630","global","2015-11-09T15:37:18","2015","mx","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.agua.org.mx/index.php/biblioteca-tematica/usos-del-agua/uso-domestico-del-agua-urbano-y-rural/1280-metodos-de-purificacion-de-agua?start=10",,,,"Water Quality Indicators","National Water Commission","Yes","Yes","After searching several of the water related portals of which there are many with a diverse amount of information, there is no downloadable dataset with all the parameters. ","There are several websites that have references to water quality data.
There are several more updated reports that have water quality assessments of various water body sources.
https://www.conagua.gob.mx/CONAGUA07/Publicaciones/Publicaciones/EAM2014.pdf
There is also the water data portal:
https://201.116.60.25/sina/Default5.aspx?tab=2
And also water documents library:
https://www.agua.org.mx/index.php/biblioteca-tematica/usos-del-agua/uso-domestico-del-agua-urbano-y-rural/1280-metodos-de-purificacion-de-agua?start=10
However, I can't find any downloadable dataset of the parameters.
","Yes","No","Ricardo Pizzuto","Nisha Thompson","20"
"b62277ef-f40e-41e9-a975-f5d1c05a06c2","global","2015-09-27T02:41:31","2015","cr","map","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://www.snitcr.go.cr/visor/?lang=en",,,,,"Registro Nacional","Yes","Yes","There is an online viewer, but I can't even find a save as PDF option, it is not clear if one can get the actual data and re-use it, so everything but the existance of digital data online is unsure in my opinion. The data from the National University apears to be only in JPG files.","This is the map available by the National Register System. However, there is a different dataset from the National University, available in open source in the link: https://www.mapoteca.geo.una.ac.cr/index.php/home.html ","Yes","No","Alejandro Sanabria","Gil Zaretzer","15"
"c9d94e1c-0ff3-47e7-af5f-8c2ebc45ba3a","global","2014-10-13T18:22:43","2014","cl","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://datos.gob.cl/datasets/ver/1587","GTSF","https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/cl/",,"GTSF Transantiago feed: Transantiago operation Programme, in General Transit Feed Specification (GTSF) format, which includes daily information and services about location, stations, frequency and travel times for buses and subway.","Undersecretary of Transportation. Contact: gtfsbeta@transantiago.cl","Yes","Yes","Accepted with revisions.","This data set only considers the transport system information of Santiago de Chile.","Yes","Yes","anonymous","Daniela Tejada","100"
"618df12a-0ef7-4a28-be84-93fc0bc31684","global","2015-08-27T15:04:41","2015","cl","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.mma.gob.cl/retc/1279/channel.html","XLS,CSV",,,"National Information System on Air Quality","Ministry of Environment","Yes","Yes","checked","all type of Pollutant is been monitoring except of VOCs","Yes","No","Diego Ignacio","yar michl","70"
"c1c12d2a-8a97-4dbb-a634-5f99d26757aa","global","2015-09-27T01:11:38","2015","cr","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://tse.go.cr/zip/elecciones/eleccionescifras.zip","Excel, PDF",,,"Elecciones en cifras 1953 - 2014","Tribunal Supremo de Elecciones","Yes","Yes","The submission does not meet the definition. As the submission says, data is available at higher levels of aggregation (in fact, for municipalities of up to 40.000 people).","Results are disaggregated only at the national level and for provinces, not for smaller areas like cantons or districts. No license found on site.","Yes","No","camila salazar","Kamil Gregor","70"
"fa2b525c-87f5-4ede-adbd-8bcff571b86e","global","2015-09-17T08:29:04","2015","cz","companies","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,,"Ministry of Justice","Yes","Yes","It is not possible to browse through the database or access data without providing a search term, therefore the registry does not qualify for most of the criteria.","The data is available via a register - you can browse one company at a time and then download each listing as pdf. It is not possible to view company data unless a search term is inputted.
Last year, there was an option to download machine readable data (XML) but last update is more than a year old. 2015 data are therefore available only via the search interface.
Also, the licence restricts commercial use https://or.justice.cz/ias/ui/download/licence_pro_pouzivani_zverejnenych_dat.pdf","Yes","No","Michaela Rybičková","Rebecca Sentance","15"
"880c7ec8-e5e8-48f3-be5c-6e368e879565","global","2015-08-27T13:33:55","2015","cl","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.servel.cl/ss/site/resultadoselectorales.html","Excel",,,"Historic Election Results: Includes Presidential, Senators, Deputies, and others from 1989 to 2013.","Electoral Service - SERVEL","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","It doesn't have information about license or term of use. ","Yes","No","Ahumada Abrigouis Alberto L","Kamil Gregor","70"
"7ced0e66-f996-41d4-9882-d5b70231d1f5","global","2015-09-16T14:08:32","2015","gt","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.guatecompras.gt/",,,,"Guatecompras","Ministerio de Finanzas Públicas","Yes","Yes","Could not replicate the bulk download. ","guatecompras.gt operado por el Ministerio de Finanzas Públicas ","Yes","No","Joel Peñate","Georg Neumann","45"
"646e1344-93dd-493d-90cf-94140d9f26e9","global","2015-09-27T03:08:36","2015","cr","health","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","This entry is uncomplete. Not information about the dataset, or link to check was found. ",,"Yes","No","Alejandro Sanabria","Iris Palma","0"
"20150c0e-9a00-48da-95eb-9275f33b4947","global","2015-09-28T23:59:05","2015","pa","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"No","https://www.contraloria.gob.pa/inec/","PDF, XLS",,,,"Panama Instituto Nacional de Estadistica y Censo (INEC)","Yes","Yes","Data available but not regularly or with open license. ","[GDP][1] data
[Unemployment][2] data (up to 2014)
[Population][3] data
[1]: https://www.contraloria.gob.pa/inec/publicaciones/Publicaciones.aspx?ID_SUBCATEGORIA=26&ID_PUBLICACION=698&ID_IDIOMA=1
[2]: https://www.contraloria.gob.pa/inec/Publicaciones/Publicaciones.aspx?ID_SUBCATEGORIA=38&ID_PUBLICACION=652&ID_IDIOMA=1&ID_CATEGORIA=5
[3]: https://www.contraloria.gob.pa/inec/Publicaciones/subcategoria.aspx?ID_CATEGORIA=3&ID_SUBCATEGORIA=10&ID_IDIOMA=1","Yes","No","HAMZAH HAJI","Zach Christensen","50"
"daeda51c-ba82-4ed8-b6c4-fad9243e282a","global","2015-09-27T21:20:48","2015","uy","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://catalogodatos.gub.uy/organization/ine","CSV, TSV, XLS, DAT, dBase, PDF","https://datos.gub.uy/wps/wcm/connect/856cc1804db0463baa8bea01b72d8394/terminos-catalogodatos.pdf?MOD=AJPERES&ContentCache=NONE&CACHEID=856cc1804db0463baa8bea01b72d8394",,,"Instituto Nacional de Estadistica (INE)","Yes","Yes","Difficult to find current data that is not in PDF. ","Plenty more information available at:
- https://www.agev.opp.gub.uy/observatorio/servlet/mainindicadoresap?41018,41018
- https://www.ine.gub.uy
-[National Accounts][1] info up to 2014.
Some 2015 Unemployment data available [here][2] in PDF format.
Figures for GDP, Unemployment, Population for 2014 available in PDF [here][3].
[1]: https://www.ine.gub.uy/web/guest/cuentas-nacionales
[2]: https://www.ine.gub.uy/documents/10181/30865/ECH+Empleo+Agosto+2015/f04ef8ae-da25-42cf-a49b-d4d0731439bb
[3]: https://www.ine.gub.uy/documents/10181/39317/Uruguay_en_cifras_2014.pdf/aac28208-4670-4e96-b8c1-b2abb93b5b13","Yes","Yes","Daniel Carranza","Zach Christensen","90"
"9a013c25-c2a2-49c3-b9e2-5a96704fa324","global","2015-10-01T16:52:19","2015","dk","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://dawa.aws.dk/postnummerdok","json, csv, xml, geojson","https://dawa.aws.dk/om#vilkaar",,,"Ministeriet for By- Bolig og Landdistrikter","Yes","Yes","OK!","First link provided contains maps of postal areas
Postal codes can also be found at: https://www.postdanmark.dk/da/Privat/Kundeservice/postnummerkort/Sider/home.aspx QA question: Please explain how to obtain the data required for this item of the census according to the definition above. The file at www.postdanmark.dk contains postcodes and town/commune names, without geolocations in lat/long or equivalent. The link is to an inventory of maps, in shape files: how would these be used to obtain a table of postcodes and their lat/long please? Answer: The postcode information is available in multiple formats for different purposes. For polygons on maps (incl. lat/long), see here https://www.gst.dk/Emner/Frie_data/Hvilke+data+er+omfattet/Hvilke+data+er+frie/Landinddelinger/DAGI/DAGI-download.htm and here https://www.adresse-info.dk/Default.aspx?tabid=220 (text in Danish, maps in shape, mapinfo and geomedia). There's also a webservice from which you can enter an address and obtain the postcode. I'm not an expert in geodata myself so in order to answer the postcode-related questions at the Census I had help from https://twitter.com/neogeografen (who might be more helpful in order to explain how to find the data of your need). Thanks to Andrew Stott and Neografen for help on this
--
Provided name and link for correct official API-provider of zipcodes and other various address endpoints.
Update 2015: No changes from 2014. ","Yes","Yes","Mor Rubinstein","Codrina Maria Ilie","100"
"bf58c583-e115-4a81-99bb-6cb9d8f3ec57","global","2015-11-13T06:55:32","2015","mx","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,"lorena_rivero@hacienda.gob.mx","Yes","Yes","The review added the government's comment on this data. The review team would like to add that we use secondary data in order to assess our data. This secondary data actually made the criteria more accurate and brought the score of more countries up. For other comments, see our insights page. ","https://www.transparenciapresupuestaria.gob.mx is a very nice website detailing government spending. However it does not include transactional data but only indicates that the data exists and is digital.
Comments to the reviewer and OD Index:
Neither the International Monetary Funds’ (IMF) Fiscal Transparency Code of 2014 nor the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development’s (OECD) Council on Budgetary Governance Recommendations of 2015 make reference to transactional information (including individual transaction records) as a relevant aggregate but, in terms of openness, stress particularly on coverage, comparability, fullness and relevance, establishing clear and homogenous expenditures classifications.
Therefore, it is important to mention that the Open Budget Survey, conducted by the International Budget Partnership does not contemplate transactional information as part of the neither the survey. Nevertheless, it does include the transparency of disaggregated information by line item according to the established recognized classifications.
In accordance to the above-mentioned and globally recognized best practices on fiscal transparency, the Mexican fiscal transparency portal: www.transparenciapresupuestaria.gob.mx does provide for substantial and open spending information, as acknowledged by the International Budget Partnership in their Open Budget Index score for 2015 in open formats.
Finally, it is noteworthy that 2014 and 2015 index, according to the website, has the same parameters of evaluating this variable, nonetheless the evaluation with same (and even more) information published from year to year has brought the assessment down. Therefore, for it to be a comparable and functional index, it should disclose the methodology changes that generate this downgrade. ","Yes","No","Enrique Zapata","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"76279435-fcb5-4959-9e7a-294976919630","global","2015-09-15T18:26:52","2015","mx","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.smn.cna.gob.mx",,"https://datos.gob.mx/terminos-y-condiciones/",,"In the main page of SMN you can find the link for weather forecasts by city in different time frames. 10 year historic series of temperature and precipitation can be found under the section of 'Climatology'.","Servicio Meteorológico Nacional","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 4 days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.",,"Yes","No","Ricardo Pizzuto","Neal Bastek","85"
"dd954e80-962d-4a7c-9067-40fc475f0677","global","2015-09-27T20:01:17","2015","lv","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is correct.","The Treasury has detailed up-to-date spending information, but this information is not available online.
There is a service *""Valsts budžeta iestāžu izdevumi""*: https://www.kase.gov.lv/?module=maks&object_id=7446 that claims to provide daily expenditure information but it does not return any data.
The service at www.kase.gov.lv only has old (most recent: 2013) non-machine-readable PDF data behind a JS form and captcha and provides aggregated data, not transactional.","Yes","No","Uldis Bojars","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"cd50d1be-01e1-436c-bd06-376cb2ac3360","global","2015-09-28T17:33:02","2015","lv","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","Data matching the listed criteria does not exist.
Latvia Post has a related dataset: [ZIP-code index page][1] (""Pasta indeksu grāmata"") containing a number of XLS files in unstructured / semi-structured form.
It shows the mapping between locations (towns, street addresses, etc.) and relevant ZIP-codes but does not contain geo-coordinates nor is there another service where one could resolve ZIP-codes to geo-coordinates.
[1]: https://www.pasts.lv/lv/uznemumiem/noderigi/pasta_indeksu_gramata/","Yes","No","Uldis Bojars","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"292618c5-5e10-4682-95ac-6a87d86d78d9","global","2015-09-28T17:26:32","2015","lv","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://kartes.lgia.gov.lv/karte/","DGN, ESRI ArcGIS",,,,"Latvian Geospatial Information Agency","Yes","Yes","Data is digital, public, but is not free to download, it is online, machine readable if you pay, I marked unsure for bulk because I cannot varify what you get for paying, it is not open to use and unclear as to updates.","Unsure how to answer the ""Available for free"" and ""Machine-readable"" criteria:
- there is an online version https://kartes.lgia.gov.lv/karte/ which is free but not machine-readable (it's an online map)
- detailed machine-readable versions are also available (as OGC WMS, OGC WFS services, etc.) but it is a paid service and it is not clear how to get access to them. here's the official publication with a list of fees: https://likumi.lv/doc.php?id=258991
Latvian Geospatial Information Agency: https://www.lgia.gov.lv/en/Par%20mums.aspx
Map services available: https://map.lgia.gov.lv/index.php?lang=2&cPath=4
See also:
- The State of Open Data in Latvia: 2014. Baltic J. Modern Computing, Vol. 2 (2014), No. 3, 160-170 - https://arxiv.org/abs/1406.5052
Data did not change from 2014
","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Gil Zaretzer","35"
"c3184f2f-9ada-4eeb-a157-bed7d9c799b2","global","2015-09-27T20:30:57","2015","lv","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.csb.gov.lv/en/dati/data-23959.html","CSV, XLSX, PX-Axis",,,,"Central Statistical Bureau","Yes","Yes","Current data available but not open.","[Unemployment][1]
[GDP][2]
[population][3]
[1]: https://www.csb.gov.lv/en/statistikas-temas/employment-and-unemployment-key-indicators-30679.html
[2]: https://www.csb.gov.lv/en/statistikas-temas/gross-domestic-product-key-indicators-30517.html
[3]: https://www.csb.gov.lv/en/statistikas-temas/population-key-indicators-30624.html","Yes","No","Uldis Bojars","Zach Christensen","70"
"f2397544-9735-4283-9f0b-58f572520283","global","2015-09-27T09:06:45","2015","lv","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://dati.ur.gov.lv/register/","CSV files + a TXT describing CSV file structure; XLSX files",,,"Republic of Latvia Company Register",,"Yes","Yes","Added title and more specific URL. Looks good :)","Enterprise register's data is published in a structured form and updated daily. Benefits from timely updates: organisations requiring Enterprise register statistics can just grab the file instead of filing official requests, thus saving time and effort.
Files include basic information about enterprises but lack more detailed information. Enterprise register sells access to detailed information to commercial companies for a considerable fee (in tens of thousands EUR) which can resell this information to everyone else.
This is one of the best open data examples in Latvia, but it is difficult to find - you have to know the URL of the open data server or the path to take through register's website in order to find a link to the open data server.
Update 2015: situation has not changed since 2014 and the answers are the same (URL valid, dataset updated regularly).","Yes","No","Uldis Bojars","Rebecca Sentance","70"
"9b99411b-d032-465c-b62d-af8e905631b3","global","2015-09-27T20:13:09","2015","lv","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.cvk.lv/pub/public/","XML",,,,"Centrālā vēlēšanu komisija","Yes","Yes","The data is available in bulk. The XML files contain the full results.","The [Central Election Commission][1] publishes election results (for both general and EP elections). Each election instance, however, has its own web page and there is no central starting point where you could find all results together.
I was not sure if the dataset qualifies as machine-readable -- the situation varies in every case with most results available as HTML tables located on multiple web pages:
- 12th Saeima election (the most recent general election) results are published as XML: https://sv2014.cvk.lv/index_rez.html
- 2014 European Parliament election results are published as HTML tables only: https://ep2014.cvk.lv/index_rez.html
- 11th Saeima election results are published are published as HTML tables only: https://www.cvk.lv/cgi-bin/wdbcgiw/base/Saeima11.GalRez_s11
- the formats of earlier election results vary, but are either HTML tables (semi-machine-readable) or not machine-readable
See also:
- The State of Open Data in Latvia: 2014. Baltic J. Modern Computing, Vol. 2 (2014), No. 3, 160-170 - https://arxiv.org/abs/1406.5052
[1]: https://cvk.lv ""Central Election Commission""
Update (2015): the situation is the same as in 2014. There have been no new election since then.","Yes","No","Uldis Bojars","Kamil Gregor","70"
"6fd1e565-13bb-443a-afe0-1d968e1b37fc","global","2015-09-27T20:07:35","2015","lv","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.fm.gov.lv/lv/sadalas/valsts_budzets/2015__gada_budzets_/","XLS",,,,"LR Finanšu ministrija","Yes","Yes","I have reviewed the submission and it is correct. ","The state budget for recent years is published as semi-structured XLS files (cell text indentation level shows budget entry hierarchy, not entirely machine-readable): https://www.fm.gov.lv/files/valstsbudzets/2014/4piel_2014_budzets_131113.xls
URL for state budget 2014: https://www.fm.gov.lv/lv/sadalas/valsts_budzets/2014__gada_budzets/
- see ""4.pielikums"" for the main budget and ""5.pielikums"" for the special / social insurance fund budget
The archive of state budget data for previous years (year 2013 shown by default, see the sidebar for earlier years): https://www.fm.gov.lv/lv/sadalas/valsts_budzets/valsts_budzeta_likums_arhivs/2013_gads/
Update (2015): situation is the same as in 2014. Updated the dataset URL field to the current year (state budget 2015).
See also:
- The State of Open Data in Latvia: 2014. Baltic J. Modern Computing, Vol. 2 (2014), No. 3, 160-170 - https://arxiv.org/abs/1406.5052
","Yes","No","Uldis Bojars","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"6a8251cc-1096-4e06-a1d6-e6022fb803e5","global","2015-09-27T20:17:38","2015","lv","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.pv.lv/lv/vilcienu_saraksts","XLS",,,,"JSC “Pasažieru vilciens” (“Passenger train”)","Yes","Yes","Good submission","This entry is about public train transport in Latvia. The bus transport is operated at a municipal level.
Live train schedules, including pricing information, are published at https://www.pv.lv/lv/vilcienu_saraksts
There is also an XLS version available that contains all the schedules together and is reasonably up-to-date (last updates: 2015-Sep-01):
https://www.pv.lv/lv/kopejais_iekszemes_vilcienu_kustibas_saraksts/
Both versions should be up-to-date but the live version may also contain information about unscheduled changes.
See also:
- The State of Open Data in Latvia: 2014. Baltic J. Modern Computing, Vol. 2 (2014), No. 3, 160-170 - https://arxiv.org/abs/1406.5052
Update (2015: the situation is the same as reported in 2014.","Yes","No","Uldis Bojars","Pieter Colpaert","70"
"24dbb4f4-a57e-47c2-8b3d-91cc349b3bf0","global","2015-09-14T20:26:41","2015","co","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://datos.gov.co/frm/catalogo/frmCatalogo.aspx?dsId=63472",".xls, .txt","https://datos.gov.co/frm/Acerca/frmAcercaDe.aspx",,"Códigos Postales Colombia","Ministerio de Tecnologías de la Información y las Comunicaciones, Contacto Yesika Padilla-Subdirección de Asuntos Postales Correo: ypadilla@mintic.gov.co","Yes","Yes","ok!","El código postal es un esquema que asigna a distintas zonas o lugares de un país un código, que junto con la dirección sirven para facilitar y mecanizar el encaminamiento de un objeto postal (una pieza de correo como una carta, un sobre, un paquete o cualquier elemento que necesite ser llevado a un lugar).
No reemplaza la dirección, sino que la complementa para facilitar la entrega de un envío.
Para mayor información consultar en:
https://www.codigopostal.gov.co/
","Yes","Yes","Juan Felipe Devia Rodriguez","Codrina Maria Ilie","100"
"dc6ca9db-3fe3-4aa6-bfe2-ba5007bc9ab9","global","2015-10-07T15:42:29","2015","ie","companies","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","No","Unsure","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.cro.ie/en-ie/Services/Access-to-CRO-Data",,,,"Company Data","Companies Registration Office (CRO)","Yes","Yes","Made some small tweaks - I determined that the data is not publicly accessible if it needs to be paid for and then requires login details to access. Agree with all other fields :)","This remains unchanged from last year.
Details about **Accessing CRO Data** are explained here: https://www.cro.ie/en-ie/Services/Access-to-CRO-Data
Data available **via free API** for which signup is required at https://services.cro.ie/overview.aspx.
**Bulk data are available for an annual fee:** ""The CRO supplies, under licence, data in bulk format for high volume users of our data. The data concerned is company information in respect of all companies on the register. It is in a specified format which may be updated to take account of changes in filing requirements. Daily updates of the data may be downloaded via the internet - a password is assigned to a Licensee to facilitate this. The fee for the daily data update service has been fixed by the Minister at **€31,000 per annum**.""
The database can also be searched free of charge at https://search.cro.ie/company/.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Rebecca Sentance","35"
"c8ddb9ee-28a1-474f-8316-ef89a4468ab4","global","2015-10-19T08:35:04","2015","in","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"No","https://data.gov.in/catalog/water-quality-affected-habitations","CSV, Excel",,,"Water Quality Monitoring","Ministry of Drinking Water and Sanitation","Yes","Yes","While several places have water quality at a central level available online, it is not available in open license or in a bulk format. ","OGD India gives an exhaustive amount of data with regard to Water Quality. The data is in open format and machine readable, Bulk download facility is available on Data Portal India. Data published on data Portal are Open and comes under the policy NDSAP and it's totally open.
Data for water quality is also available on CPCB database https://cpcbedb.nic.in/","Yes","No","Shubhadip Biswas","Nisha Thompson","50"
"230f45ab-01ff-4eaf-b22f-c2a61b5ab5e3","global","2015-10-19T19:16:09","2015","co","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.dane.gov.co/index.php/poblacion-y-demografia/censos","Excel, PDF","https://www.dane.gov.co/index.php/terminos-de-uso",,"Cuentas Económicas Nacionales Trimestrales - PIB Oferta y Demanda, Estadísticas por Tema: IPC, Mercado Laboral, Demografía y Población","Departamento Administrativo Nacional de Estadística-DANE, Ligia Galvis Amaya, correo: osistemas@dane.gov.co ","Yes","Yes","Data are up to data and open.","Se presentan como soporte 4 links donde se pueden consultar la información solicitada:
IPC - https://www.dane.gov.co/index.php/indices-de-precios-y-costos/indice-de-precios-al-consumidor-ipc
PIB - https://www.dane.gov.co/index.php/cuentas-economicas/cuentas-trimestrales
MERCADO LABORAL - https://www.dane.gov.co/index.php/estadisticas-por-tema/mercado-laboral
Demografia y población - https://www.dane.gov.co/index.php/poblacion-y-demografia/censos
IPC - El IPC es un indicador que mide la variación de precios de una canasta de bienes y servicios representativos del consumo de los hogares del país. Los resultados son analizados por grupos, subgrupos y clases de gastos, gastos básicos y niveles de ingreso.Se publican cuadros en excel con información más desagregadas (por subgrupos), para el total nacional, por ciudades y niveles de ingresos. Se registran las variaciones mensuales, año corrido y para los últimos 12 meses. Se puede acceder a los documentos y a la información de la investigación que se encuentra en tablas de Excel o por medio de consultas dinámicas, que permiten que el usuario obtenga la información de acuerdo con sus necesidades.
PIB - constituyen una síntesis de la información de coyuntura que tiene como finalidad presentar oportunamente con periodicidad trimestral la situación económica del país, en coherencia con las Cuentas Nacionales anuales. Se publican anexos estadísticos e históricos en excel con resultados de Valor agregado total y por ramas de actividad, Consumo final de los hogares total y por grado de durabilidad, Consumo final total y por categorías económicas, Formación bruta de capital fijo total y por clase de productos, Exportaciones totales y por grupos de productos, Importaciones totales y por grupos de productos, Producto Interno Bruto PIB Total.
MERCADO LABORAL - Los indicadores de mercado laboral indagan sobre las condiciones de empleo de los colombianos y dan a conocer aspectos como si trabajan o no, en qué rama de actividad se desempeñan, cómo se comporta el mercado laboral para grupos poblacionales específicos como mujeres y jóvenes, cuál es la remuneración que reciben, cómo es la afiliación a seguridad social, entre otros aspectos; la cobertura de estas investigaciones es nacional y se realizan informes departamentales y regionales. Se presentan anexos e indicadores históricos en excel con las principales variables de mercado laboral para el Total nacional y 13 áreas.
DEMOGRAFÍA Y POBLACIÓN - Información de la población colombiana y sus proyecciones en el tiempo, junto con estadísticas vitales como nacimientos y defunciones, además de resultados sobre las migraciones tanto nacionales internas como internacionales. Se tiene también indicadores sobre grupos étnicos colombianos. Se publican anexos en excel con información de variables demográfica y se cuenta sistemas de consulta dinámicos y estáticos para el censo General . Los primeros, permiten hacer cruces de información de todas las variables que indagó el ejercicio censal; los segundos presentan en mapas información particular consultada durante el operativo.","Yes","Yes","Juan Felipe Devia Rodriguez","Zach Christensen","100"
"3d4e3a9c-a891-4d49-8a6a-5ce944707804","global","2015-09-27T23:35:33","2015","ec","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://resultados.cne.gob.ec/",,,,,"Consejo Nacional Electoral","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Election results are published on this website, with a copyright notice in the footer.","Yes","No","Eduardo Bejar","Kamil Gregor","45"
"ff8b854c-3552-46f9-b6d6-8b05059f5dec","global","2015-09-21T18:58:18","2015","us","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://graphical.weather.gov/xml/","XML",,,,"National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (which includes the National Weather Service and the National Centers for Environmental Information)","Yes","Yes","I updated this submission with the forecast data in addition to the historical/climate data. We accept this submission because it meets our criteria of 5 days of precipitation, temperature and wind forecast.","Forecast data is available at the link above.
Historical/climate data is available here: https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/cdo-web/datasets
There are some online and some offline data. The ones that are offline need to be ordered by mailing NCEI. All that is online can be downloaded for free but what is offline needs to be ordered and “[most offline services require an additional charge][1]."" Also in order to “certify” data records in the case that they are used in court, there might be further costs.
Unsure if most of it is online but there definitely exists offline data. Here are places to look for online data: a. [Dataset Gallery of NOAA][2]; b. [Quick links][3] to many of NCEI’s datasets on weather/climate; c. [Operational Climate Data Records][4]; d. [Climate Data: Dataset Discovery][5]
Yes, openly licensed because it goes with the [World Meteorological Organization Resolution][6], which means non-US info cannot be used for commercial use; international data can be used within the US or for noncommercial international uses without any restrictions.
[1]: https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/customer-support
[2]: https://www.climate.gov/maps-data/datasets/coverage/us
[3]: https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/data-access/quick-links
[4]: https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/cdr/operationalcdrs.html
[5]: https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/cdo-web/datasets
[6]: https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/customer-support","Yes","No","anonymous","Neal Bastek","70"
"66ace388-a835-4dde-a8e3-9794acc9446c","global","2015-09-28T00:24:43","2015","ar","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.mecon.gov.ar/onp/html/consolidado/2015/Pcspn15.pdf",,,,,"Ministry of Economy, Finance Secretary","Yes","Yes","Data for 2015 is only in machine readable format. Changed data to not machine readable. ","The budget details are on the website of the National Budget Office which depends on the Ministry of Economy. The paper this year (2011- 2014) is published as disaggregated data.
The data for 2015 is only available in a PDF format. ","Yes","No","Yamila García","Mor Rubinstein","55"
"c2d84893-0a13-4802-a0e9-99d61dc3adbf","global","2015-09-28T02:43:45","2015","ar","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.hcdn.gov.ar/",,"https://www.hcdn.gov.ar/",,,"Honorable Cámara de Diputados de la Nación Argentina","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The website for the National Congress contains up-to-date information about all legislative activity in different formats and different sections.
A local citizen initiative Congreso Interactivo is publishing a machine readable dataset:
https://www.congresointeractivo.org/dataset-todas-las-votaciones-del-congreso-2001-2013/
And an API:
https://billit.congresointeractivo.org
","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","75"
"c57f5623-77a7-4fcd-a2e7-8a79299aef2d","global","2015-11-23T19:48:08","2015","nl","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://live.waterbase.nl","excel","https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/deed.nl",,"Waterkwaliteit - Chemisch - Rijkswaterstaat, Unie van Waterschappen","Rijkswaterstaat, Unie van Waterschappen","Yes","Yes","Link to data had to updated to download tool, not a bulk download dataset","QA - review - the license is cc-by 4, as this datasets was found in the CKAN portal, where all datasets share the same license. Data was also timely and was updated to the week of the review. ","Yes","Yes","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","90"
"99077c5e-2282-424b-bb84-da9c9bb5b9f9","global","2015-09-28T20:14:53","2015","mx","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.transparenciapresupuestaria.gob.mx/","CSV","https://www.transparenciapresupuestaria.gob.mx/es/PTP/Terminos_y_Condiciones",,,"Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","I have reviewed the data and it is correct. Submission accepted. ","No change from 2014. ","Yes","Yes","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"d4e31a47-58ca-4d54-9cfe-908620a03904","global","2015-10-02T20:55:59","2015","sn","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"No","https://www.ansd.sn","PDF",,,"General statistics","National Agency of Statistics and Demography","Yes","Yes","Data for population not current, no open license. ","The data is accessible here. Population figures last updated for 2013.","Yes","No","anonymous","Zach Christensen","45"
"421c0deb-7054-47e8-994e-5cf9d34ec366","global","2014-11-06T15:02:05","2014","sn","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Check the original submitter. Data is not available on the site. I changed accordingly. "," According to Genova, no change from 2013. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","30"
"09518896-b5d9-4dc1-b348-75117a165146","global","2015-09-28T00:56:37","2015","ar","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://elecciones.gob.ar/articulo_sub_sub.php?secc=2&sub_secc=9&sub_sub_secc=69","CSV","https://datospublicos.gob.ar/data/organization/e0ddc4f9-6d3b-4c94-ba22-b16f52ab5eed?license_id=odc-odbl&_license_id_limit=0",,,"National Electoral Management","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","This data is well structured and easy to access. That Were data sets are cleaned and sorted. The last update of the PASO elections are in 2015, the datasets is in csv format.
Are the results of the elections of 2001 - 2011 in PDF format.
https://elecciones.gob.ar/articulo_sub_sub.php?secc=2&sub_secc=9&sub_sub_secc=9","Yes","Yes","Yamila García","Kamil Gregor","100"
"a3374832-41f2-437e-8b0c-ff6b2ba94144","global","2015-11-23T16:45:17","2015","bj","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.marches-publics.bj/index.php?option=com_appeloffres&task=list1&Itemid=69",,,,"Avis d'attribution de marchés publics","Direction Nationale du Contrôle des Marchés Publics","Yes","Yes","Changed according to the thematic reviewer second review. ","The procurement tenders are published on the website of the general direction of procurement. All data about the tenders are publicly available, but the data are not machine readable and not up to date. Bulk downloads are not sufficiently frequent. ","Yes","No","Georg Neumann","Mor Rubinstein","35"
"b143f98c-375c-43ac-bee8-11c6f28993f3","global","2015-09-27T08:18:46","2015","bo","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.senamhi.gob.bo/sismet/index.php",,,,"SisMet","Servicio Nacional de Meteorología e Hidrología","Yes","Yes","I have checked the data and it is correct. Changed license from unsure to no. ","The SENAMHI offers a weather forecast of temperature, wind precipitation for 4 days (today + 3 days). It is non machine readable format.
Data is © Copyright 2010 SENAMHI and therefore is not openly licensed. ","Yes","No","Mariana Leyton","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"37b4bc81-7f3f-4e9d-8e09-5fe776c72754","global","2014-10-30T23:33:07","2014","es","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://renfe.es",,,,,"RENFE","Yes","Yes","Added bus information. ","No related information found in both the Ministerio de Fomento[1] or the Spanish OpenData Portal[2]. The timetables for national-level trains are available at renfe.es site.
Bus data can be found here - https://www.alsa.es/en/
[1] https://www.fomento.gob.es
[2] https://datos.gob.es","Yes","No","José Félix Ontañón","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"38237c21-b6ff-478c-8355-b8b9fa52a743","global","2015-10-26T23:54:05","2015","bo","companies","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","We could not find the data",,"Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"f13c00e8-cff0-42ef-8757-afb5f643162d","global","2015-10-11T14:13:02","2015","tr","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.ysk.gov.tr/ysk/faces/Anasayfa?_adf.ctrl-state=16l17042qv_85&wcnav.model=YSKUstMenu&_afrLoop=20006272935868012","Excel, PDF, CSV",,,"Supreme Electoral Council of Turkey","Supreme Electoral Council of Turkey","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","https://www.ysk.gov.tr/ysk/faces/HaberDetay?training_id=YSKPWCN1_4444005790&_afrLoop=2365240657220670&_afrWindowMode=0&_afrWindowId=12zs3opp84_37#%40%3F_afrWindowId%3D12zs3opp84_37%26_afrLoop%3D2365240657220670%26training_id%3DYSKPWCN1_4444005790%26_afrWindowMode%3D0%26_adf.ctrl-state%3D12zs3opp84_49
QA review- Changed the license to not open. Do not license in [this link] does not mention data, but mentions information about the elections process.[1]
[1]: https://www.ysk.gov.tr/ysk/faces/YSKGorevVeYetkileri?_adf.ctrl-state=12zs3opp84_89&wcnav.model=footerMaviTasarim&_afrLoop=2365433288610675","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Kamil Gregor","70"
"f722a31a-ba47-4164-831f-2ef7b1906a86","global","2015-10-01T17:03:18","2015","gt","statistics","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Data largely unavailable.","In https://www.ine.gob.gt/index.php/estadisticas/2013-10-30-16-43-37
ypu can find the datasets avalaible in excel format. However there are not datasets with the criteria enlisted above (GDP or Population but some 2014 data for unemployment)","Yes","No","Iscelle Marsicovetere","Zach Christensen","0"
"b6e90771-6d69-4109-8b11-351e7c9dae27","global","2015-10-03T02:15:03","2015","mx","companies","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,"Mexican Business Information System (Sistema de Información Empresarial Mexicano)","Ministry of Economy (Secretaría de Economía)","Yes","Yes","It is not possible to browse through the database or access data without providing a search term, therefore the registry does not qualify for most of the criteria.","Despite the fact that data is available under the Treasury and Economic Ministry, there is no public database available to the public. Some query mechanisms exist in order to find basic company information based on the name of the company or their tax id. It is also possible to download generated search results in .XLS format.
No change from 2014. ","Yes","No","Haydeé Quijano","Rebecca Sentance","5"
"4b8649eb-6347-414c-9c43-69cf018944ea","global","2015-11-10T19:14:03","2015","mx","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.diputados.gob.mx/LeyesBiblio/index.htm",,,,"Laws, regulations, official normativity and its amendments, updated daily","Cámara de Diputados y Diario Oficial de la Federación","Yes","Yes","Data exist. Therefore, we approve this submission. ","Both Legislative Chambers, Diputados (https://www.diputados.gob.mx) and the Senate (https://www.senado.gob.mx) don't have machine readable and bulk data. Nonetheless, outside websites have built APIs and other scrapping-based information flows in order to gather and publish information in sites such as www.curul501.org and apps such as https://itunes.apple.com/mx/app/id625548107?mt=8. Other internal data standards, such as law taxonomy are either not public or don't exist.
No license could be found which makes the data not open.
No change from 2013.
Actualización 2015: El estado de los datos no ha cambiado, la información solicitada en los criterios no existe y no hay una licencia clara para el uso de los datos.
Comment to the 2015 update:
Legislation data in Mexico do exist, is publicly available, for free, available online, on a timely basis and in digital forms.
Datasets can be found in the following two sites:
• Chamber of Representatives: https://www.diputados.gob.mx/LeyesBiblio/index.htm
• Official Gazette: https://www.dof.gob.mx/#
Data in this sites is updated at a dainly basis, and specificially the Official Gazette, is by law, updated daily to show any amendment, change or publication of new or existing laws, regulations, and normativity in Mexico.
","Yes","No","Enrique Zapata","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"ce581e7e-f2a8-414a-9a9d-8b7437894dca","global","2015-09-02T12:21:01","2015","iq","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"No","https://cosit.gov.iq/","XLS, PDF",,,,"Central Statistical Organization of Iraq","Yes","Yes","Some data available in fairly open format.","[Unemployment][1] for 2008.
[Population][2] for 2010.
[GDP][3] up to 2014.
[1]: https://cosit.gov.iq/en/population-manpower-staatistics/manpower
[2]: https://cosit.gov.iq/en/population-manpower-staatistics/life
[3]: https://cosit.gov.iq/en/national-accounts-statistics/national-income-reports","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Zach Christensen","50"
"6852c79c-7a68-44e7-8f83-a001bf7af90e","global","2014-10-29T12:52:28","2014","bd","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.sob.gov.bd/mapcate.php",,,,,"Survey of Bangladesh","Yes","Yes","updated data."," updated new data","Yes","No","anonymous","Nasir Khan","35"
"4377472c-8ec9-4bb3-84ce-8868d665e24b","global","2015-10-17T12:30:26","2015","ec","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://www.finanzas.gob.ec/informacion-presupuestaria/","HTML, PDF, CSV, XML, Excel",,,,"Ministerio de Finanzas ","Yes","Yes","There is an historical data, not current data. Changed timely to NO","The consolidated budget for 2014 is available online, but not its detailed version and execution.","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","60"
"3df54c70-2bfb-4829-b9be-15f5d0f17b18","global","2015-10-19T15:10:37","2015","co","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://datos.gov.co/frm/catalogo/frmCatalogo.aspx?dsId=63550","CSV","https://datos.gov.co/frm/Desarrolladores/frmTerminosCondiciones.aspx",,"Datos abiertos elecciones 2014","Registraduría Nacional del Estado Civil, Contacto: Edwin Gonzalez Caldas-Jefe oficina de comunicaciones y prensa, Correo: egonzalezcaldas@gmail.com ","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Además, en el portal principal de la Registraduria Nacional del Estado Civil, está publicada la información con los resultados de la Presidencia y Congreso del último periodo de elecciones en Colombia. En el siguiente link puede encontrar la información:
https://www.registraduria.gov.co/-Historico-de-Resultados-.html
Por otra parte, se publica información de resultados electorales en la plataforma de la Misión de Observación Electoral –MOE: https://www.datoselectorales.org/#, ver sección ""Resultados electorales"".
Con el fin de aclarar, la MOE es una plataforma de organizaciones de la sociedad civil, independiente del gobierno, de los partidos políticos y de intereses privados, que promueve la realización del derecho que tiene todo ciudadano a participar en la conformación, ejercicio y control del poder político.
","Yes","Yes","Juan Felipe Devia Rodriguez","Kamil Gregor","100"
"5ce9086f-4303-4885-9f8a-cdbd8e18feea","global","2015-09-12T10:39:01","2015","ir","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","We checked the Guardian Council's website (https://www.shora-gc.ir/Portal/Home/), it is who approves or disapproves parliamentary or presidential elections candidates. It has a section for elections on the website, but only containing election laws and another elections news section, mainly about the council's activities.
Currently, Electoral Commission announces the results after the Ministry of Interior confirmation. We checked the site for the Ministry of Interior, the page for the presidential elections results (https://result-p.moi.ir/Portal/Home/default.aspx) seems to be down. Wikipedia article about 2013 elections in Iran cited the Ministry of Interior as their source, but didn't specify a link. We couldn't find any web presence for the Electoral Commission.
This link from MOI should also provide the elections results data (https://www.moi.ir/portal/home/default.aspx?categoryid=c2cf29ae-2e8e-4319-a926-1e311d44c6d1), but links there are not working, and gave us errors when we tried to access the presidential or parliament elections results. Only one of the few links that worked for one past election, gave us data in the following format (https://www.moi.ir/portal/Home/Default.aspx?CategoryID=a49af0c2-962d-4896-9dab-994263db42f4 - https://www.moi.ir/portal/File/ShowFile.aspx?ID=7201aaf9-13af-48a0-902b-513b34e9134d), which doesn't seem to meet the standards ","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Kamil Gregor","0"
"ac2afc05-b58d-432c-8f07-1ed257bfb9fb","global","2015-09-18T10:49:15","2015","in","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://eprocure.gov.in/cppp/tendersearch",,,,"Central Public Procurement Portal - The Central Public Procurement Portal of Government of India facilitates all the Central Government Organizations to publish their Tender Enquiries, Corrigendum and Award of Contract details. The system also enables the users to migrate to total electronic procurement mode. The primary objective of this portal is to provide a single point access to the information on procurements made across various Central Government Organizations.","Department of Expenditure, Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","Submission correct. There is no specific mention of an open license, set to no. ","The Government of India has online portal for procurement and issuing of tenders where one can easily browse through data and access information regarding them. https://eprocure.gov.in/cppp/tendersearch is the main site catering to this need.
The Central Public Procurement Portal of Government of India facilitates all the Central Government Organizations to publish their Tender Enquiries, Corrigendum and Award of Contract details. The system also enables the users to migrate to total electronic procurement mode. The primary objective of this portal is to provide a single point access to the information on procurements made across various Central Government Organizations.
","Yes","No","Akhilesh Srivastava","Georg Neumann","45"
"843c1767-b32e-4379-8ef9-617c9555a229","global","2015-09-08T17:29:23","2015","ae","spending","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.
Submission was correct but moved answer from unknown to no.","UAE does not seem to maintain a database that covers individual records of transactions. ","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","0"
"5a44e4da-03f8-4368-898f-2b7b58954bb5","global","2015-09-16T05:20:29","2015","ir","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","Iran has 10 digits postal codes for each and every place (see here https://www.post.ir/DesktopModules/Articles/ArticlesView.aspx?TabID=1&Site=postportal&Lang=en-US&ItemID=10337&mid=10768 and here https://www.postcode.post.ir/_Geography/Documents/postal%20code.%20PDF.pdf)
Here (https://eservice.postcode.post.ir/) you can search for codes by entering the full address. However, we could not find a database of postal codes and corresponding address. No coordinates are shown in all cases.
","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"92c2679e-2b90-4c82-961b-30973406dbad","global","2014-10-27T19:07:40","2014","cy","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Unsure",,"Yes","https://www.mof.gov.cy/mof/mof.nsf/page15_gr/page15_gr?OpenDocument",,,,,"Ministry of Economy","Yes","Yes","duplication","Later data is more complete, but is only available in PDF so not easy to machine read. More information available in Greek than in English or Turkish.","Yes","No","anonymous","Andreas P","45"
"59758932-e290-4fc2-86cb-32eef355150c","global","2014-11-03T10:32:48","2014","cy","spending","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.mof.gov.cy",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Could not be found, again."," Cannot be found on government websites. If anyone finds something, please submit! ","Yes","No","anonymous","Andreas P","0"
"b3a10777-158b-49b4-a550-1b98c5b2e858","global","2014-10-27T19:20:46","2014","cy","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://efiling.drcor.mcit.gov.cy/DrcorPublic/SearchForm.aspx?sc=0&lang=EN",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Definite improvement from last year, but still more could be done.","It appears you can search the database for specific companies but it is not possible to get the whole dataset. Significant improvement on last year due to updated website.","Yes","No","anonymous","Andreas P","35"
"cdc8fcce-78d2-4981-bd44-2f13ffddce71","global","2015-09-17T15:15:00","2015","ir","water","Yes","No","No","No","Unsure","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Water Quality","Local municipalities","Yes","Yes","They do test water at the local municipal level:
https://www.tpww.ir/fa/album/211/Water-Wastewater-Quality-Control-Dept-labarotories
Unclear if there is a national monitoring body requiring reporting or aggregating of data. ","We were not able to find this data on the website for the Department of Environment, https://www.doe.ir/","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Nisha Thompson","5"
"04987724-5107-4b47-bae5-62feaaf7d72d","global","2015-10-28T15:51:51","2015","in","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.gov.in/catalog/all-india-pincode-directory#web_catalog_tabs_block_10","CSV",,,"India Post - For more than 150 years, the Department of Posts (DoP) has been the backbone of the country’s communication and has played a crucial role in the country’s socio-economic development. It touches the lives of Indian citizens in many ways: delivering mails, accepting deposits under Small Savings Schemes, providing life insurance cover under Postal Life Insurance (PLI) and Rural Postal Life Insurance (RPLI) and providing retail services like bill collection, sale of forms, etc. The DoP also acts as an agent for Government of India in discharging other services for citizens such as Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (MGNREGS) wage disbursement and old age pension payments With 1, 55,015 Post Offices, the DoP has the most widely distributed postal network in the world.","India Post, Ministry of Communication & Informataion Technology, Government of India","Yes","Yes","License is not Open - https://data.gov.in/sites/default/files/NDSAP.pdf","The dataset (All India Pincode directory with contact details along with Latitude and longitude) is available in CSV format at https://data.gov.in/dataset/all-india-pincode-directory. The information available on OGD India and is completely open for reuse and further studies and research. Many Applications have also been developed using this data. The data is also available at https://www.indiapost.gov.in/pin/. The data consists of pincodes along with post office information like address and postal code. The data can also be searched by location or pincode on https://www.indiapost.gov.in/.
The license does not allow commercial use, it is not open. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"9fd331f0-f1a5-44b4-b917-fc44fdf3d139","global","2015-09-21T08:08:35","2015","cy","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is valid.
Thank you for your submission to the 2015 Global Open Data Census. ","The data is not updated and is presented in a completely non-reusable way.
https://www.moa.gov.cy/moa/ms/ms.nsf/DMLindex_en/DMLindex_en?opendocument","Yes","No","Andreas P","Stephen Gates","0"
"821d8e5d-ba28-4a74-94e9-9df6adf8bee7","global","2014-11-03T10:33:21","2014","cy","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Agree","Could not find data on government websites https://www.moa.gov.cy ","Yes","No","anonymous","Andreas P","0"
"f5716be5-6352-41d2-8e41-769e46475d36","global","2014-11-03T10:30:24","2014","cy","map","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The data does not exist. Same as last year with old tourist maps.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Andreas P","0"
"6d996e18-2768-4dd7-9da8-c84be0b53a75","global","2014-12-31T20:00:07","2014","cy","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://wtv.elections.moi.gov.cy/",".txt",,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"No information appears to be available on the results of elections in Cyprus. There is information available about how to vote and more technical aspects, but not the results. Broken links exist for the latest Presidential election.","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","0"
"382d8e57-256a-49f0-ad64-3ca3424c5088","global","2014-10-27T19:28:06","2014","cy","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","No",,"Unsure","https://www.cystat.gov.cy/",".xls .pdf",,,,,"Yes","Yes","Lots of statistics available, could be kept more up-to-date possibly/ more open formats.","You can view the data without paying, but there are charges for some datasets and reports. Data is mixed, between percentages and whole numbers. Some data is machine-readable, some is not. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Andreas P","35"
"f596eded-6439-4637-ac1f-29916ca903a5","global","2015-10-08T10:41:25","2015","es","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.ine.es","CSV",,,"PIB. Tasa de Paro. Población residente en España.","Instituto Nacional de Estadística","Yes","Yes","Updated data but not openly licensed.","Below the direct link to the three dataset to match the evaluation criteria:
* [GDP for the whole country][1], updated quarterly.
* [Unemployment statistics][2], updated quarterly not monthly.
* [Population][3] updated at once a year.
The Unemployment Statistics aren't updated monthly but quarterly.
[1]: https://www.ine.es/jaxi/menu.do?type=pcaxis&path=%2Ft35%2Fp009&file=inebase&L=0
[2]: https://www.ine.es/dyngs/INEbase/es/operacion.htm?c=Estadistica_C&cid=1254736176918&menu=ultiDatos&idp=1254735976595
License is unclear - ""Denaturalising the sense of the information is expressly prohibited""
https://www.ine.es/ss/Satellite?c=Page&p=1254735849170&pagename=Ayuda%2FINELayout&cid=1254735849170&L=1#
[3]: https://www.ine.es/inebaseDYN/cp30321/cp_inicio.htm","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Zach Christensen","60"
"49b64db9-71f5-47b1-aca2-819a80ce4a83","global","2015-09-25T08:06:15","2015","za","map","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,"1:250 000 Topo-Cadastral maps","National Geo-spatial Information, a component of the Dept of Rural Development and Land Reform","Yes","Yes","I have reviewed the data and it seems correct.","National Geo-spatial Information (NGI), a component of Department of Rural Development and Land Reform (DRDLR) commenced with the establishment of an integrated survey system and provision of extensive mapping coverage of the country. NGI is also known as South Africa's national mapping organisation.
","Yes","No","Greg Kempe","Gil Zaretzer","10"
"55307f8d-fff9-47cc-9a14-afc070ba7fdd","global","2015-12-16T10:17:12","2015","sk","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Review is ok ","Slovak Republic is a small country, so there is only about 10^4 different postcodes altogether. List of those can be obtained from Slovak Post Office at https://www.posta.sk/stranky/postove-smerovacie-cisla . License is not clearly stated and there is Copyright notice at the page providing the download so ""no"" is filled.
Latitude and longitude information is not provided in the data source but other data source (https://zbgis.skgeodesy.sk/tkgis/default.aspx - intended for users, no API) can be used to locate towns (but not streets). Thus the data is considered as NOT available.
**Data was submitted by Fair Play Alliance and Jano Suchal**","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"990bdff8-e833-45f9-b3d0-1d75b2662d85","global","2015-10-11T14:47:18","2015","mx","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://computos2015.ine.mx/Nacional/VotosPorPartido/",".csv, .pdf",,,,"Instituto Nacional Electoral","Yes","Yes","The bulk download option does not exist.","Database is not on it's most detailed level. Vote counts basis are at a ballot level, not at a vote by vote detail. Not openly licensed because no license can be found, only copyright statement.
10/01/2014 - No change from 2013 in detail level. Changed web adress. Added XLS. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Kamil Gregor","60"
"f3a55a6f-7ae2-4f98-a6e1-b4fad76c5d1b","global","2015-10-05T18:15:10","2015","ca","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.tbs-sct.gc.ca/ems-sgd/esp-pbc/me-bpd-eng.asp","Excel, PDF, HTML","https://open.canada.ca/en/open-government-licence-canada",,"Government Expenditure Plan and Main Estimates (Parts I and II)","Treasury Board of Canada","Yes","Yes","Submission is correct. ","The data for the most recent year is updated monthly.
The annual budget data is avaible back to FY 2009.
The data is available grouped in three ways (in French and English):
- Statutory forecasts
- Expenditures by Strategic Outcome and Program
- Expenditures by Standard Object
The data is available in Excel (.xls) formats. (No change from 2014)","Yes","Yes","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"4b277939-db55-4e71-bd7c-a41633c4c02f","global","2015-09-26T21:06:32","2015","cm","postcodes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Data on Administrative Boundaries (Zipcode database not available in Cameroon)","Cameroon National Institute of Cartography","Yes","Yes","ok","There is no national zipcode system in use in Cameroon. The Government has a project with the African Development Bank to build such a database for 2015 year.
But there is data of the national administrative boundaries, produced by the National Institute of Cartography.
This institute produces even guides for regions, cities and villages. But these guides aren't free of charge.","Yes","No","Charlie Martial NGOUNOU","Idriss TINTO","20"
"9e038226-cb75-44b6-8d82-00a70704f579","global","2015-09-26T20:35:43","2015","cm","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.prc.cm/fr/multimedia/documents",,,,"Cameroon Laws and decrees ","Presidency of the Republic","Yes","Yes","The data is not available in bulk.","Laws and regulations are published in various websites...
Prime Minister's Office
https://www.spm.gov.cm/fr/documentation/lois.html
Very outdated
National Assembly
https://www.assnat.cm/index.php/fr/les-lois/les-lois-adoptees
This is very outdated
Presidency of the Republic
This is the most updated as it is easy to see that last laws published are from September. Even last speeches of the President of the Republic is online. That's why I think the last question of this survey deserves a YES.
https://www.prc.cm/fr/multimedia/documents
","Yes","No","Charlie Martial NGOUNOU","Kamil Gregor","45"
"0e48699c-f9c3-4e07-8699-8cd9c2e04dc4","global","2015-10-13T10:25:29","2015","cm","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://www.statistics-cameroon.org/manager.php?id=8","CSV, XLS, MDB, DBF, PDF",,,"Online access to various data, informations and publications published by the National Institute of Statistics of Cameroon","Institut National de la Statistique du Comeroun","Yes","Yes","Data not timely or openly licensed.","The National Institute of Statistics has some information that is regularly updated like inflation rate, economic growth, GDP and other economics indicators. But population data are not regularly updated (not once a year).
https://www.stat.cm/downloads/2015/CNT_INS_Cameroun_T1_2015.pdf
See also the data portal [here][1].
[1]: https://cameroon.africadata.org/fr/Reports","Yes","No","anonymous","Zach Christensen","60"
"ef5a9ade-0607-46ff-8274-514888072c7f","global","2015-10-13T10:24:37","2015","cm","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","No","Unsure","Yes",,"Yes",,,,,"Cameroon National Map (Administrative Map - Topographic Map - Road Map)","National Institute of Cartography","Yes","Yes","Everything seems correct, only that I didn't find anything to suggest they offer online, and machine readable files, they offer hardcopys, so I'm changing these two answers to unsure.","The most complete, detailed and up-to-date maps in Cameroon have to be found at the National Institute of Cartography.
It is a public body in charge of conception and construction of map, either administrative map, road map, topographic map or geodesic map. It is also in charge of handling the production specific map according to anyone purpose or goal. It may be a map or a monograph for a specific locality, for a council, etc. with any type of information one might need.
But the problem is that they charge a fee for accessing maps. All their maps are up-to-date.
www.inc-cameroun.cm/","Yes","No","anonymous","Gil Zaretzer","35"
"673cb379-dabc-424a-bc37-971a64ec7ccb","global","2015-10-13T10:24:13","2015","cm","companies","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://www.statistics-cameroon.org/news.php?id=136",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The information available on Cameroon companies is very piecemeal and spread out, therefore it is hard to know which is the most authoritative dataset or which to fill out the criteria for. (The link given in the submission was broken and also appeared to be for 2012). But the details provide a lot of information which is useful on its own.","At the Cameroon National Institute of Statistics, this information is organized for investors and this might explain why it is so incomplete. It concerns only companies having a turnover over 100 millions per year (Official source)
Source : https://www.stat.cm/downloads/liste_entreprise_2012_fr.pdf
Mining companies are to be found elsewhere, especially in the EITI-Cameroon website (Official source).
Source : https://www.eiticameroon.org/index.php/les-industries-extractives/les-societes-minieres
Oil companies are to be found in another link in the same EITI-Cameroon website (Official source)
https://www.eiticameroon.org/index.php/fr/les-industries-extractives/les-societes-petrolieres
The Chamber for commerce, industry, mining and craft (CCIMA) is responsible for the collection and diffusion of information on companies in Cameroon (1).
The eRegulation service maintained by the Ministry of SMEs, Solidarity Economy and Crafts (MINPMEESA) offers information for registration for specific councils but there is no centralized process yet (2).
A project on the creation of a central database was mentioned in a 2009 report but there is no evidence such an exhaustive register is operational (3).
Finally, the Statistics Institute conducted a Census of Companies in 2009 but it does not provide the list of the companies, the results provided are only about statistics on these companies (4).
(1) CCIMA, https://www.ccima.net/present_fr.php Accessed on 2014-07-03 (Official source)
(2) Cameroon eRegulations, https://cameroun.eregulations.org/ Accessed on 2014-07-03 (Official source)
(3) Observatoire Economique et Statistique d'Afrique Subsaharienne, Atelier sur le traitement des statistiques d'entreprises, February 2009, https://www.afristat.org/contenu/doc_travail_experts/Com_Repertoire-Final_publication.pdf Accessed on 2014-07-03
(4) INS Cameroun, Recensement Général des Entreprises (RGE2009),https://www.statistics-cameroon.org/news.php?id=78 Accessed on 2014-09-09"" (Official source)
Status:
""There are some lists of companies that are shared but these lists are not complete at all. The Chamber for commerce, industry, mining and craft (CCIMA) maintains a database on industrial companies in the country. The database only have 63 companies registered though, on a voluntary basis. It is possible to export the data in Excel file (1). The CCIMA also provides another listing on its website (1) but there are less than 400 companies available and there is no possibility to export the data easily.
(1) Base de données sur les entreprises industrielles du Cameroun (CCIMA), https://www.pointsbiz.com/projets/ccima4/entrepriselist.php
(2) CCIMA, Annuaire des entreprises du Cameroun, https://www.ccima.net/annuaire_fr.php
","Yes","No","anonymous","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"e2550f93-0990-4b75-a354-ef429b83ee3c","global","2015-10-13T10:23:38","2015","cm","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"No","https://www.elecam.cm/uploads/media/RAPPORT_LEGISLATIVES_MUNICIPALES_2013_Fr.pdf",,,,"Rapport des élections législatives et municipales de 2013","Elections Cameroon","Yes","Yes","The submission does not meet the definition. Report in Data location only contains summary results. Also the submission says that data is not available.
","Those data are not available from the 2 entities in charge of the elections process in Cameroon.
Elections Cameroon https://elecam.cm/
Ministry of Territorial Administration and Decentralization https://minatd.cm/gov/site/en/","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","45"
"7075a7f4-cc8e-4f09-ab93-c178f02b8fab","global","2015-10-13T10:22:57","2015","cm","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Data on Government Contracts Executed","Ministry of Economy, Planning and Regional Development","Yes","Yes","Submission fixed (data is not publicly available)","Government spendings reports are still published at end of the following year pending auditing by the Audit bench of the supreme court and the vote by the legislature.
2014 budget spending report is not yet available when 2013 spendings report was released in December 2014 (https://www.presidenceducameroun.com/news/?lang=fr&mode=newsdetails&id=3635). This is why we have so many ""No"" in this survey.
To access the spending data, the requester must write to the minister","Yes","No","anonymous","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"62b08d02-38e4-48ca-b77e-63698c4f3992","global","2015-10-13T10:22:32","2015","cm","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.minfi.gov.cm/images/documents/loi%20des%20finances%202015.pdf",,,,"Finance law 2015","Ministeres des finances/Direction Générale des Impôts","Yes","Yes","I have review the data and it is correct. ","Cameroon Budget is voted every year as per de law and it is made available to Citizens through several means. Since 2013, Cameroon is moving from line item budget to program budgeting, so the Cameroon budget is presented by program for each ministry.","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","55"
"1c04ec79-d570-48aa-ae19-96ed04a866cf","global","2015-09-26T10:09:42","2015","cm","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.camrail.net/guide_horaires_2014_05_28.pdf",,,,"Horaire de trains de la société Camrail","CAMRAIL","Yes","Yes","all is ok","Cameroon has a national airline compagny that covers 5 regions over 10, and extension are underway to other regions. There is some transportation companies, we don't know what kind of agreement they have with the Government. At any case no data are available from both concerning public transsport.
","Yes","No","Charlie Martial NGOUNOU","Idriss TINTO","55"
"051e374a-7266-4582-b135-96bb63cf16d2","global","2015-09-24T06:00:45","2015","sg","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.
If aggregated data exists it indicates that transactional data does so as well, just not published.","Whilst budget includes some expenditure information (see e.g. https://data.gov.sg/common/search.aspx?q=budget&page=1) there is no detailed transactional information available as far as we have been able to determine (only aggregated).","Yes","No","Zhi Yuan Lim","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"f4f24c6c-91fe-4b39-8582-cd0227e8b4fa","global","2015-09-19T15:09:46","2015","sg","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.singaporebudget.gov.sg/budget_2015/RevenueandExpenditure.aspx",,,,"FY2015_Analysis_of_Revenue_and_Expenditure","Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","Since sub departmental expenditure is only available in PDF, I have marked the machine readable section as unsure. ","Material is not open as terms of use at https://www.mof.gov.sg/budget_2013/terms_of_use.html state ""Except as otherwise provided, the Contents of this Site shall not be reproduced, republished, uploaded, posted, transmitted or otherwise distributed in any way, without the prior permission of MOF. To use any parts of the Contents of this Site, the user must seek permission in writing, stating the Contents for use; intent of use; manner of use; time frame of use and identity of the user. MOF reserves the right to refuse permission without declaring reason(s); and/or if information submitted by user is deemed insufficient.""
The machine readable data is available in really low level. Sub departmental expenditure is available only in PDF.","Yes","No","Zhi Yuan Lim","Mor Rubinstein","55"
"fd6b751c-b5ea-467a-a751-a52865bdaa4b","global","2015-09-12T05:16:21","2015","sg","timetables","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Bus times","Land Transport Authority","Yes","Yes","Data is available, but you need jump through a request hoop","The data is accessible via another gov-portal, Land Transport Authority: https://www.mytransport.sg/content/mytransport/home/dataMall.html. Review comment: The data are machine readable and available in real-time streaming, but you need to file a request to get them. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Pieter Colpaert","10"
"ef1bfa72-3146-49ea-9b69-fff76bc2298a","global","2015-10-07T15:38:31","2015","pr","spending","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is correct. Clarification added.","There is an up to date contract database at the Office of the Comptroller's website and at data.pr.gov, but no detailed records of spending at a detailed transactional level. According to [a note](https://www.hacienda.pr.gov/sites/default/files/msrb-emmacommnotice-auditedfinstat.pdf) around the auditing of the government's fiscal statements the government has failed to produce the data for the last fiscal year. Therefore it seems that the data does not exist.","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","0"
"68073754-0690-4548-a376-f0ea19aa2ca9","global","2015-09-20T07:49:03","2015","gr","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.ypeka.gr/Default.aspx?tabid=708&language=en",,,,"Daily Bulletin Atmospheric Pollution","ministry of environment & enegry","Yes","Yes","checked","no data for VOCs","Yes","No","Charalampos Bratsas","yar michl","35"
"3f437394-ec51-4061-bb7f-2473e9c1e5b7","global","2015-09-18T10:32:59","2015","gr","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,"THE HELLENIC MILITARY GEOGRAPHICAL SERVICE (HMGS)","Yes","Yes","I found that the link supplied here at first doesn't qualify as the data we are looking for, but, the THE HELLENIC MILITARY GEOGRAPHICAL SERVICE (HMGS) offers an e-shop for maps and data which seem to cover our needs, since I could not varify the data itself many questions are left unsure, however I am positive the data exists, even digitaly, and open to the public for a price, and some of it is online to view but not to save.
link to the e-shop: https://web.gys.gr/portal/page?_pageid=33,46034&_dad=portal&_schema=PORTAL
link to the viewer: https://web.gys.gr/GeoSearch_EN/"," ","Yes","No","Charalampos Bratsas","Gil Zaretzer","15"
"4c9f8e67-6192-4dae-a5f3-3ce53f1162b0","global","2015-09-18T12:27:59","2015","gr","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.et.gr/",,,,,"National Printing Office","Yes","Yes","The data is not available in bulk.","According to Law 3861/2010, article 7 /τ.Α΄112 -13.7.2010 all laws, Ministerial Decrees, Presidential Decrees and other regulation of Greece become available online for free through the website of the National Printing Office. ","Yes","No","Charalampos Bratsas","Kamil Gregor","45"
"d3a5e88f-f5e3-4223-87ad-d2e4766897fb","global","2015-09-22T08:05:45","2015","gr","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.businessportal.gr/search_name.php",,,,"General Commercial Register","General Secretariat of Commerce, Ministry of Development","Yes","Yes","Same rationale used as with China - companies register can be browsed and does contain company details, though the number of search results makes its usefulness very limited in truth.","It is possible to search for company names and details, or to browse the register by inputting a space as the search term, up to a limit of 20 results. The limit to the number of results displayed is a severe logistical limitation to using the database. There are also no address details given for the companies retrieved.
A more full company register can be found and searched here: https://www.et.gr/index.php/2013-01-28-14-06-23/search-ae-epe-issue-with-publisher-criteria but it still requires inputting a search term with a minimum of 4 characters to access data. It is possible to view company documentation by clicking on the company name, and download it in PDF form.","Yes","No","Charalampos Bratsas","Rebecca Sentance","35"
"c9c9a316-5e48-42d6-a200-e1a905712601","global","2015-09-18T08:59:03","2015","gr","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","No","No",,"No","https://www.moh.gov.gr/articles/health/dieythynsh-dhmosias-ygieinhs/ygieinh-periballontos/prostasia-poiothtas-ydatwn/prostasia-neroy-anthrwpinhs-katanalwshs/1317-ekthesh-trietias-2008-2010-gia-thn-poiothta-toy-posimoy-neroy-se-perioxes-poy-eksyphretoyn-perissoteroys-apo-5000-katoikoys-symfwna-me-stoixeia-twn-ypeythynwn-ydreyshs-o-t-a-d-e-y-a-k-lp",,,,"Water Quality Protection, Human Consumption","Ministry of Public Health","Yes","Yes","The submitter's links didn't point to water quality data that matched the parameters. While Greece's water supply and quality is management by decentralized municipal companies, it is reported to the Ministry of Health and then reported to the EU> ","For Bathing Water
Until 2013 the data published on the website geodata.gov.gr
https://geodata.gov.gr/geodata/index.php?option=com_sobi2&sobi2Task=sobi2Details&catid=30&sobi2Id=237&Itemid=
Also there are some data for 2014 but not public available in
https://cdr.eionet.europa.eu/gr/eu/nbwd/envvjao5w/
For Drinking Water
There are some data for 2013 in
https://cdr.eionet.europa.eu/gr/eu/dwd/","Yes","No","Charalampos Bratsas","Nisha Thompson","20"
"946d2a5d-3846-4e22-888a-b81da4935654","global","2015-09-17T09:37:52","2015","gr","land","Yes","Unsure","No","No","No","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,"What is the Cadastre? It is a complete registration of all real properties and the (registrable) rights these bear across Greece; the aim of the Cadastre is to protect and consolidate these rights. The cadastre does not involve any tax inspection sense.","National cadastre & mapping agency SA","Yes","Yes","The provided link https://www.ktimatologio.gr/sites/en/Pages/Default.aspx does not lead to the actual cadastral data, nor a view / discover service of a geoportal. ","The NATIONAL CADASTRE & MAPPING AGENCY S.A. company is a Legal Entity of Private Law and its mission is the study, development and operation of the Hellenic Cadastre.
The company was founded with a joint decision of the Minister of Economy and Finance and the Minister of Environment, Physical Planning and Public Works (Decision 81706/6085/6-10-1995/Government Gazette 872Β/19-10-1995). NCMA S.A. operates according to the rules of private finance and the provisions of article 5 of Law 2229/1994, of the coded Law 2190/1920, of Law 2308/1995 and Law Ν.2664/1998, as these stand today. Furthermore, the company does not fall under the class of organizations and businesses of the broader state sector; regulations that concern companies directly or indirectly owned by the State do not apply to NCMA S.A.
The sole shareholder of the company is the Ministry of Environment, Energy and Climate Change.
","Yes","No","Isidoros Passas","Codrina Maria Ilie","5"
"4d1cc9aa-601c-4380-97b3-11d4b08e3835","global","2015-09-18T12:27:01","2015","gr","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://www.statistics.gr/portal/page/portal/ESYE","Excel, CSV, PDF",,,"The Hellenic Statistical Authority collects data which concern population, employment and unemployment, tourism and the economy, industry, as well as data concerning health and social insurance, education and others","Hellenic Statistical Authority, ELSTAT (Greek: ΕΛ.ΣΤΑΤ)","Yes","Yes","Data on population are not current or openly licensed.",,"Yes","No","Charalampos Bratsas","Zach Christensen","60"
"9558e67a-fb85-4783-ab55-fb2ef7b8a88e","global","2015-09-20T08:09:04","2015","gr","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.hnms.gr/",,,,,"Hellenic National Meterological Service","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 3 days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.",,"Yes","No","Charalampos Bratsas","Neal Bastek","45"
"9452a489-d45a-4ae7-89af-ca136d4222c6","global","2015-09-17T11:50:43","2015","gr","spending","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://opendata.diavgeia.gov.gr","API, json","https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/",,,"Ministry of Administrative Reform and e-Governance","Yes","Yes","Submission is correct","Expenses are published as part of the “Clarity” program of Law 3861/2010, which introduced for the first time in Greece the obligation to publish all the decisions of government and all administrative entities on the Internet. ","Yes","Yes","Sotiris Karampatakis","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","100"
"c17cd562-fff0-49bd-b68e-b7c3d88a411e","global","2015-09-18T08:12:03","2015","gr","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.eprocurement.gov.gr/actSearch/faces/active_search_main.jspx","Excel",,,"Title: e - procurement Description: The innovation of the e - procurement platform that has been developed for public authorities in Greece by the General Secretariat of Commerce. This platform will be used in all the sstages of a public procurement procedure, increasing transparency and accelerating public procurement procedures.","General Secretariat of Commerce","Yes","Yes","Submission correct.",,"Yes","No","Charalampos Bratsas","Georg Neumann","70"
"40e038c4-0c55-4911-ac20-ef28463c89d0","global","2015-09-17T11:56:29","2015","gr","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://ekloges.ypes.gr/","HTML ",,,,"Ministry of Interior","Yes","Yes","The submission does not meet the definition. Data is available for municipalities, aggregating the votes of up to 400.000 people.","Regarding the election results in Greece the following are valid: available data are not machine readable; not in bulk
and without any license or terms of use. The data are available through a website of a private ICT enterprise.","Yes","No","Sotiris Karampatakis","Kamil Gregor","45"
"ab7fa815-6d00-4c79-bac4-dd5587506f74","global","2015-10-12T15:49:45","2015","gr","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.minfin.gr/?q=el/content/%CE%BA%CF%81%CE%B1%CF%84%CE%B9%CE%BA%CF%8C%CF%82-%CF%80%CF%81%CE%BF%CF%8B%CF%80%CE%BF%CE%BB%CE%BF%CE%B3%CE%B9%CF%83%CE%BC%CF%8C%CF%82-2015",,,,"Greek Goverment Budget","Hellenic Parliament","Yes","Yes","I have checked the data and it is correct. ","The General Accounting Office is responsible for the dissemination and publicity of the Annual Budget. Unfortunately, the General Accounting office has chosen to publish the related data in formats, which essentially prevents further use of this information by the public. The annual budget is published as unstructured PDF documents, while the internal breakdown formations change almost every year. This makes comparisons of actual spending with the budget , particularly difficult. Some experimental projects have been made using data scraping techniques , however, for a reliable and efficient solution the General Accounting Office should re-evaluate the data publishing policies applied.
QA note: Changed to data is not opened. Copyright - Treasury © 2014 ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","35"
"e5525d67-f34f-4138-aea9-f324378be674","global","2015-09-28T05:38:03","2015","ua","spending","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://spending.gov.ua/",,,,"Government Spending in Ukraine","Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","Submission is correct","Ministry of Finance has launched the transparency project named eData which is primarily focused on publishing transactions of the National Treasury.","Yes","No","anonymous","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","45"
"cf5a9f95-4f2a-43d6-a1fd-8a28e6ae27de","global","2015-09-19T16:25:31","2015","id","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.go.id/dataset/direktori-perusahaan-industri-indonesia","CSV","https://data.go.id/persyaratan-penggunaan.html",,"Directory of Industrial Companies in Indonesia - A downloadable dataset of Indonesian companies","Indonesian Ministry of Industry","Yes","Yes","Ticks all the boxes! Well done, Indonesia! ;)","This dataset gives a more extensive list of limited companies which includes both state-owned as well as private enterprises, and across sectors.
The dataset consists of company names, address and locations, and the type of industry. It can be downloaded as a single CSV file to the user's computer without restrictions, and is openly licensed.
","Yes","Yes","Yefta Sutanto","Rebecca Sentance","100"
"eba81cae-a480-46ce-8d62-a1e96604ac66","global","2015-09-17T12:42:02","2015","bg","companies","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","No","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.brra.bg/","XML, WSDL",,,,"Агенция по вписванията (Registration Agency, under the auspices of the Ministry of Justice)","Yes","Yes","I have marked the dataset as not publicly available based on the restrictions to obtaining it. ","The company database can be searched online, but queries are restricted to single entities and captcha. Obtaining the full database costs about 50 EUR. There are still some legal aspects of the bulk download (mostly relating to personal data protection) that are still unclear. Therefore the bulk download and subscription for new users is in effect blocked by the personal data protection agency.","Yes","No","Boyan Yurukov","Rebecca Sentance","50"
"229d1843-6be5-4518-86a1-eadd60217202","global","2015-09-27T21:27:58","2015","bg","spending","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://opendata.government.bg/dataset/plashtaniya-v-sebra-i-drugi-plashtania-v-bnb",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.
CSV format is used but not machine readable. License not specified.","Bugdet payments and spending reports are available on daily basis. File type is CSV but it is constructed in a non-machine readable way. License is not specified but the data is made available on an open data platform (still does not count).","Yes","No","Boyan Yurukov","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","55"
"01cf6360-29de-4cbd-96a3-8c04d8f52f70","global","2015-10-27T15:27:11","2015","bg","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.aop.bg/","CSV",,,,"Агенция по обществените поръчки/Public Procurement Agency","Yes","Yes",,"All documents are available on the website of the agency. They are in somewhat structured form, but are not machine readable. There's no formal schema or definition. Their own dataset has been extended multiple times, so even internally it's hard to figure out a standartised form and values for the data. A [bulk download][1] is avialable via the open data portal of the government.
[1]: https://opendata.government.bg/dataset/nhqpopmaunr-3a-ckjiiohehn-dorobopn-njin-pe3yjitatn-ot-npobedehn-kohkypcn-3a-npoekt","Yes","No","Georg Neumann","Georg Neumann","70"
"3d61d721-b039-4e9f-8ae0-5dcca4a4c266","global","2015-09-27T21:32:20","2015","bg","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://pdbase.government.bg/forms/public_eprtr.jsp","RDF",,,"егистър на лицата, притежаващи документи за извършване на дейности с отпадъци","Изпълнителна агенция по околната среда и водите","Yes","Yes","Changed from unsure to no.
Copyright © 2011 Executive Environment Agency (EEA)","The data is available as part of an online registry. It includes information on the industrial/agricultural installations that emit pollution and the pollution generated from each one. The data is submitted to the EEA and can be downloaded as part of the full RDF dataset:
https://prtr.ec.europa.eu/pgDownloadDataSet.aspx
QA reviewer: Copyright © 2011 Executive Environment Agency (EEA)","Yes","No","Boyan Yurukov","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"df3077e8-d97d-402b-92c9-3150df13a905","global","2015-09-27T21:41:04","2015","bg","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.cik.bg/","CSV",,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The data is updated almost in real time as the election results are processed.
It is not available in bulk, but the information is in easily scrap-able htmls and sometimes available for download as CSV files.
The data was considered non-open as, although the Commission is working towards increasing the amount of machine-readable formats and the respect of interoperability, it does not clearly state what the reuse, modification and distribution conditions are (see here: https://results.cik.bg/pi2014/csv.html).","Yes","No","Boyan Yurukov","Kamil Gregor","70"
"e50149e5-fde7-4957-9677-27b8a30945b0","global","2015-09-27T21:40:51","2015","bg","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.minfin.bg/bg/page/4","Excel",,,,"Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","Changed data to bulk. Data was up to date, and I changed the timely question to 'YES'. ","The Budget law is promulgated in the State gazette, so it is in the public domain. The PDF is also published on the Ministry of Finances website (see here for 2015: https://www.minfin.bg/bg/page/851).
The consolidated budget framework is published on the Finances ministry website, usually as an Excel generated PDF. The available Excel sheets for 2015 are different amendments but their aim is unclear.
Data has been considered unavailable in bulk because each file, be it in machine-readable format or no, has to be downloaded individually. Also, the data has been considered available for free as anyone can access the files and download them from the Ministry's website.
Reviewer's note - Although each excel file needs to be downloaded individually,it is all in one webpage, and we consider that as bulk. For the future, it would be better if all the data was in one spreadsheet. ","Yes","No","Boyan Yurukov","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"ffaf697b-6ad6-4fd1-81f4-c5491c6c63ca","global","2015-11-23T19:59:11","2015","bg","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://opendata.government.bg/dataset/danni-ot-edinnata-informatsionna-sistema-voda","CSV","https://www.opendefinition.org/licenses/cc-zero",,"Data on water pollution","Министерство на околната среда и водите | Ministry of the environment and water","Yes","Yes","Data wasn't updated in a timely way.","The data is published regularly on the Bulgarian government opendata portal.","Yes","Yes","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","90"
"d40e3dd4-6cd6-4594-a9ba-82ee4518a696","global","2015-08-30T19:03:42","2015","eg","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://ema.gov.eg/pdf/4df.png",,,,"Weather / Four Days Forecast","Egyptian Meteorological Authority (EMA, https://ema.gov.eg/) ","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 4 days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.","The Egyptian Meteorological Authority publishes temperature readings for Egypt main cities. [https://ema.gov.eg/] It also published forecasts of temperature, humidity and wind speed for the upcoming 4 (not 5) days. [https://ema.gov.eg/pdf/4df.png]
They do not publish precipitation on the same website, but humidity instead, which I think is fine as rain is rare in most of Egypt, and precipitation is not really useful to citizens most of the time. Nevertheless, the precipitation forecast can be found on NWP website which belongs to the same authority. [https://nwp.gov.eg/index.php/wrf/preciptation]
Historical Data was not found on the website, however, it temperature, humidity and windspeed charts are found as part of the Pollution Reports published by NWP. [https://nwp.gov.eg/index.php/reports-enviromental]. It worth mentioning that this data is not available in reports since October 2014, thus we marked the dataset as not provided on a timely and up to date basis.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Neal Bastek","35"
"255402e9-deaa-44f1-8524-bb87f02a208e","global","2015-09-14T15:34:12","2015","co","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.dnp.gov.co/programas/inversiones-y-finanzas-publicas/Datos-y-Estadisticas/Paginas/presupuesto-de-inversi%C3%B3n.aspx","Excel",,,"Presupuesto de Inversión: Contiene el detalle del proyecto del presupuesto de Inversión presentado para aprobación del Congreso, el seguimiento a la Inversión y la Evolución histórica de la misma.","Departamento Nacional de Planeación, Manuel Fernando Castro, Subdirector Territorial y de Inversión Pública, mfcastro@dnp.gov.co","Yes","Yes","There is no license on this data, the linked licensed was about privacy policy. Marked license as not open. ","The link to license does not mention any rights to private or public use, it is just a privacy policy - https://www.dnp.gov.co/Paginas/Pol%C3%ADtica-de-privacidad.aspx","Yes","No","Juan Felipe Devia Rodriguez","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"e0ae37c4-c539-48cd-b3e4-7da7c183bd5a","global","2015-09-18T13:56:00","2015","ro","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.roaep.ro/istoric/","XLS","https://data.gov.ro/base/images/logoinst/OGL-ROU-1.0.pdf",,"Election results","Permanent Electoral Authority","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The Romanian Permanent Electoral Authority set up a portal where the results of the elections can be retrieved in XLS format. Usually, the results are published immediately after their validation by the Constitutional Court. Only the results of the more recent elections (after 2004) are available in re-usable format. Although the data is not explicitly licensed on their website, the datasets with the most recent elections (2009+) are also available on the Government's Open Data Portal - https://data.gov.ro/organization/autoritatea-electorala-permanenta - thus the positive answer to the specific question.
The data can be downloaded for each scrutiny from separate pages. The Authority also set up a page where all data is available, including online viewers, at https://alegeri.roaep.ro/, but it is working intermittently.
","Yes","Yes","Ovidiu Voicu","Kamil Gregor","100"
"f6ac4282-9f85-4ec9-9755-f1f6e41de391","global","2014-11-28T04:32:10","2014","ro","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.gov.ro/dataset/mers-tren-sntfc-cfr-calatori-s-a","XML","https://data.gov.ro/base/images/logoinst/OGL-ROU-1.0.pdf",,"Railway passenger operator SNTFC ","S.C. Informatica Feroviara S.A. (data.gov.ro)","Yes","Yes","I have reviewed this entry, I accept the content, I have added descriptive text from the publisher's website translated with the use of Google Translate.","The information refers only to national railway system (public company). There is no national bus company. The data was published recently on the government's open data portal data.gov.ro.","Yes","Yes","Tracey P. Lauriault","Tracey P. Lauriault","100"
"d3aa7076-4c2f-4bfd-8986-50fbdf58e6af","global","2015-09-21T02:41:29","2015","hk","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","postcodes/zipcodes not used so this dataset does not apply.
https://futurehandling.com/2012/11/12/why-doesnt-hong-kong-have-postal-codes/
This category discriminates on all the countries and territories that do not have postcodes (>60 https://gist.github.com/kennwilson/3902548). China uses one postcode for all of Hong Kong (999077) so sent a FOI request to see if that was listed anywhere on a HKgov website and if could be used as a postcode for HK. This was the response
https://accessinfo.hk/en/request/postal_code_information_for_hong
They said to use this page:
See also: https://www.hongkongpost.hk/eng/postage/info/index.htm#addressing
Review - did not identified any official admin boundaries. Not endorsed admin boundaries are available here https://www.gadm.org/download. ","Yes","No","S.C. Edmunds","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"ee6d3f49-d406-4f48-b74a-cb9d29b3332b","global","2015-09-23T08:03:28","2015","hk","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,"Digital land boundary map","Survey and mapping office (SMO) ","Yes","Yes","ok","The Lands Department in Hong Kong is very proprietary of its data. Several FOI requests to other departments (accessinfo.hk) have shown that the Lands Department's strong licensing prevents release of all manner of data.
Boundary information does appear to be recorded and stored in digital format, but not free to access: https://www.landsd.gov.hk/mapping/en/digital_map/mapprod.htm
It is possible for citizens to search a database for details pertaining to very specific plots of land (building number is needed using the 'street search' facility), but this is limited - not finding my entire office block and not providing any information other than the building name for the block of flats I live in. Search facility is here: https://www2.iris.gov.hk/eservices/searchlandregister/search.jsp ","Yes","No","Rob Davidson","Codrina Maria Ilie","10"
"58982c76-7433-4211-84b0-e5822ac39020","global","2015-09-16T06:10:21","2015","hk","companies","Yes","Unsure","No","Unsure","No","Unsure","Unsure",,"Yes",,,,,"Cyber Search Centre of the Companies Register","Companies Registry, crenq@cr.gov.hk","Yes","Yes","Changed most criteria to ""unsure"" as it is not possible to know without paying charges.","It is not possible to search the registry or view any company data without paying a fee. Details of the fees are made available at: https://www.icris.cr.gov.hk/csci/chargeRate.do","Yes","No","Rob Davidson","Rebecca Sentance","15"
"a3a07aa7-69b2-4a7b-ae97-cce1027bb044","global","2015-09-21T02:51:14","2015","hk","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.wsd.gov.hk/en/water_resources/water_quality/water_quality_monitoring_data/index.html",,,,"Water Quality Monitoring Data ","Water Supplies Department","Yes","Yes","Approving this submission, reports contain the parameters. ","Only have yearly pdfs and nothing in data.gov.hk from this department yet. These are the 2014-2015 files:
https://www.wsd.gov.hk/filemanager/en/content_135/drinking_a-e.pdf
https://www.wsd.gov.hk/filemanager/en/content_135/drinking_b-e.pdf","Yes","No","S.C. Edmunds","Nisha Thompson","35"
"cb661934-97cf-4bce-ab4e-017c7d03ea7c","global","2015-09-23T04:01:21","2015","hk","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.legislation.gov.hk/blis/eng/index.html","HTML; PDF",,,,"Department of Justice","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct."," In this case, the questions about 'available in bulk' and 'open licensing' are very pertinent. As per the terms of use (https://www.legislation.gov.hk/blis/eng/cr.html ), ""downloading a large amount of Legislation from BLIS by program in one go"" is not allowed. ","Yes","No","Rob Davidson","Kamil Gregor","45"
"098a5b6f-38ca-4f9b-95be-5ba56f87e30f","global","2015-09-23T07:01:13","2015","hk","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.fstb.gov.hk/tb/en/tender-notices.htm",,,,,"The Treasury Branch. Financial Services and the Treasury Bureau","Yes","Yes","Submission updated with award information. ","The award information is available at https://www.gldetb.gov.hk/
","Yes","No","Rob Davidson","Georg Neumann","45"
"cda1a98f-54c8-4152-b9c5-7ff7e2990017","global","2015-09-23T03:09:54","2015","hk","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Unsure","https://www.landsd.gov.hk/mapping/en/download/openmaps.htm",,,,"Digital Topographic Map (B100k-OM)","Survey and Mapping Office , Lands Department","Yes","Yes","The data is digital, public, free, online, and available in bulk, however, it is not machine readable, or openly licensed, and it is unclear as to updates. ","**Digital Topographic Map (B100k-OM)**
The B100k-OM is a topographic map of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region. It shows the key geographical features and is suitable for map applications in 1:100 000 scale. The image for download is geo-referenced to the local coordinate system in Hong Kong 1980 Grid.
**Digital Orthophoto Map (DOPM100-L0-OM)**
The DOPM100-L0-OM is an orthophoto map of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region. It is mosaicked from geometrically rectified aerial photographs and constructed for measurement accurate to 1:100 000 scale. The image for download is geo-referenced to the local coordinate system in Hong Kong 1980 Grid. (Remark: The area beyond the Hong Kong territory is produced from Landsat-7 satellite image.)","Yes","No","Rob Davidson","Gil Zaretzer","45"
"377f29d9-838d-4fd4-be02-cbe58235339a","global","2015-09-23T04:06:08","2015","hk","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://epic.epd.gov.hk/EPICDI/air/station/?lang=en","CSV",,,"Inquire and Download Air Quality Monitoring Data","Environment Protection Bureau","Yes","Yes","checked
","This year I've updated the 'available in bulk' to 'no' because the web form requires a minimum of 300 submissions to extract all the data - as per this ongoing FOI request: https://accessinfo.hk/en/request/collated_air_quality_data
NB: the FOI response is currently asking for a large sum to provide the data in bulk, but I have not altered the 'available for free' setting from 'yes' because in theory, the data is available for free if you are willing to use the web form sufficient times.
Air quality Index data (which is based upon the raw data from air quality monitoring network) is available at:
https://www.aqhi.gov.hk/epd/ddata/html/out/24aqhi_Eng.xml
all Pollution are measured except for VOCs","Yes","No","Rob Davidson","yar michl","60"
"396137b7-e916-46ae-a9ac-ab1bfdd36719","global","2015-09-21T02:59:32","2015","hk","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.hko.gov.hk/cis/climat_e.htm",,,,"Climatological Database access via the Climatological Information Services page","Hong Kong Observatory","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 5+ days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.","RSS data via https://data.gov.hk/en-data/provider/hk-hko and database of historical data here? https://www.hko.gov.hk/cis/climat_e.htm","Yes","No","S.C. Edmunds","Neal Bastek","35"
"c798ced2-11e5-401d-a7da-f79936ebbadf","global","2015-09-16T05:59:44","2015","hk","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.elections.gov.hk/legco2012/eng/rs_gc.html","HTML, XLS",,,"Election results (LegCo 2012)","Registration and electoral office, Chief electoral officer, reoenq@reo.gov.hk","Yes","Yes","The data is available in machine available format in bulk. Detailed data is available in XLS for ""counting stations"" at https://www.elections.gov.hk/legco2012/eng/result/rs_ds.html.","Election results are available for LegCo under the 3 headings of:
Geographical constituencies, District/Functional constituencies and Functional constituencies.
Results are displayed in HTML tables, separated over many pages, one for each constituency.
Oddly, results seem to be given as total number of votes received for a block of candidates and then indication of which single candidate from that block was elected - rather than breakdown of votes per candidate. ","Yes","No","Rob Davidson","Kamil Gregor","70"
"2d9f500f-6b9d-4f03-ad1a-e440c29981d3","global","2015-09-23T03:34:28","2015","hk","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.censtatd.gov.hk/hkstat/sub/bbs.jsp","XLS, PDF, HTML",,,,"Census and Statistics Department","Yes","Yes","Data available but no open license.","
[Unemployment][1] data
[GDP][2] data
[Population][3] data
[1]: https://www.censtatd.gov.hk/hkstat/sub/sp200.jsp?tableID=006&ID=0&productType=8
[2]: https://www.censtatd.gov.hk/hkstat/sub/sp250.jsp?tableID=030&ID=0&productType=8
[3]: https://www.censtatd.gov.hk/hkstat/sub/sp150.jsp?tableID=001&ID=0&productType=8","Yes","No","Rob Davidson","Zach Christensen","70"
"6d99a6c2-cb67-4f18-8f18-3f4674d7ee6f","global","2015-10-23T10:48:27","2015","in","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://202.54.31.7/citywx/localwx.php",,,,"Weather Forecast - India Meteorological Department (IMD) is the National Meteorological Service of the country and the principal government agency in all matters relating to meteorology, seismology and allied subjects. It takes meteorological observations and provides current and forecast meteorological information for optimum operation of weather-sensitive activities like agriculture, irrigation, shipping, aviation, offshore oil explorations, etc.","Indian Meteorological Department","Yes","Yes","I changed the license entry from 'unsure' to 'no' because commercial use is not allowed (https://www.imd.gov.in/doc/nccraindata.pdf), but otherwise this submission is accepted as is.","The observational data recorded at various types of surface and upper air observatories, are scrutinised and archived at the National Data Centre, Pune. It has approximately 8 billion characters of data storage which includes ship data and rainfall data of State raingauges spanning over a century. The statistics thus compiled are periodically revised and updated. The archives form the basis for computation of means, normals, frequencies and other derived parameters, for their analysis and interpretation, and for the preparation of district and state climate summaries and atlases. It makes weather forcast for the country and upto the level of cities (https://202.54.31.7/citywx/localwx.php and https://www.indiaweather.gov.in/ - National Weather section) .","Yes","No","anonymous","Neal Bastek","45"
"4446f4cd-1e5c-49e6-b1cf-15bacf0d2a95","global","2015-09-18T11:27:37","2015","in","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Controller General of Accounts - Controller General of Accounts is the principal Accounts Adviser to the Government of India and is responsible for establishing and maintaining a technically sound management accounting system. He prepares a critical analysis of expenditures, revenues, borrowings and the deficit for the Finance Minister every month. He also prepares annual Appropriation Accounts (Civil) and Union Finance Accounts for presentation to the parliament.","Controller General of Accounts, Ministry of Finance, Government of India","Yes","Yes","Submission fixed","National expenditure data is available on the website of Controller General of Accounts, Ministry of Finance at https://cga.nic.in/Forms/Accountingproc.aspx and appropritaion account tab contains ministry and department wise Expenditure data at https://cga.nic.in/forms/List.aspx?Lid=3310&id=36 . The data available on the Controller General of Accounts Website is up to date and totally free for public.
The OGD India also provides important datasets on government spending and outlays which is totally in the machine readable format. The data available on the Data portal is open for reuse and further study.
Data is also available on the Ministry of Finance website ""https://www.finmin.nic.in/the_ministry/dept_expenditure/cca/cca_exp_stat.asp"".
All this data is unfortunately aggregated but it does indicated that the data exists and is digital.","Yes","No","Akhilesh Srivastava","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"9eafd848-3c22-4c85-ad2d-cbbc451f46fb","global","2015-09-18T10:36:04","2015","in","land","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Land Ownership - The National Land Records Modernization Programme (NLRMP) was launched by Government of India in August 2008, aimed to modernize management of land records, land ownership etc through the States which have jurisdiction over landownership.","Various State Governments' Revenue or Land Resources Departments","Yes","Yes","We have been unable to find references related to the geometry of the land parcels. Each state offers a search service with the result in the shape of a form, without any geodata. Thus, the data submitted does not comply with the requirements of the 2015 index. ","Land registration is a State Subject according to Constitution of India. However, under e-Governance initiative, the Central government has put in lot of resources to ensure that all land records are computerized at state level, which are in advanced stages of implementation. Links to the landrecords system/websites of the states in India are as under:
Goa: https://dslr.goa.nic.in/f114new.aspx
Odisha : https://bhulekh.ori.nic.in/
Uttrakhand : https://devbhoomi.uk.gov.in/
Uttar Pradesh : bhulekh.up.nic.in
Madhya Pradesh : https://landrecords.mp.gov.in/newweb/index.html
Gujarat : https://anyror.gujarat.gov.in/
Rajasthan : https://apnakhata.raj.nic.in/
Tamil Nadu : https://edistrict.tn.gov.in/eservicesnew/index.html
Karnataka : https://bhoomi.karnataka.gov.in","Yes","No","Akhilesh Srivastava","Codrina Maria Ilie","15"
"514b71a8-a0a5-4af0-8abb-ddb60c633267","global","2014-10-30T08:45:26","2014","in","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://data.gov.in/catalogs#path=ministry_department/ministry-road-transport-and-highways",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Changed the source of the license. ","While timetables for trains are commonly available, for other modes of transport we could do with more easily available information. The data provided is public, still there is a ""captcha code"" facility which mandates human intervention in the search process. Due the heavy web traffic these websites are slow functioning. Marked as ""no bulk download"" / ""not easily machine readable"" due to capcha Real time train data is easier to find than timetable data. Cannot find open licence. https://enquiry.indianrail.gov.in/ntes/ -- real time train information
https://www.irctc.co.in/ - some train information
Please note that erail.in is not an official government source. ","Yes","No","SUSISahoo KUMAR L","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"ea4bcdf7-8f30-4ec9-ba85-d58f6e7ae3ca","global","2015-09-18T10:27:16","2015","in","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://indiacode.nic.in/",,,,"Legislation of India - All legislation /Acts are made by Parliament of India. India Code Information System contains all Central Acts of Parliament right from 1836 onwards. The Parliament of India comprises of Rajya Sabha & Lok Sabha, the upper house and lower house. The Lok Sabha secretariat and the Rajya Sabha secretariat publishes all its data starting from its members to the various legislative businesses on their respective websites. All the data published by secretariats have been meticuloustly compiled into a digital package by OGD India. The portal also provides data related to the various state legislative assemblies in India.","Legislative Department, Ministry of Law and Justice","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","All legislation /Acts are made by Parliament of India. India Code Information System contains all Central Acts of Parliament right from 1836 onwards which is available on https://indiacode.nic.in/welcome.htm . The Parliament of India comprises of Rajya Sabha & Lok Sabha, the upper house and lower house. The Lok Sabha secretariat and the Rajya Sabha secretariat publishes all its data starting from its members to the various legislative businesses on their respective websites. All the data published by secretariats have been meticulously compiled into a digital package by OGD India. The portal also provides data related to the various state legislative assemblies in India. The data on India Code Information System is open for public use. The websites of the Rajya Sabha and Lok Sabha clearly mention in their terms and copyright that - ""The material listed may be reproduced without formal permission for the purposes of non-commercial research, private study and for criticism, review and news reporting provided that the material is appropriately attributed."" Plus OGD India also provides important data related to legislative business which is openly available at https://data.gov.in/catalogs/ministry_department/lok-sabha-secretariat, https://data.gov.in/catalogs/ministry_department/rajya-sabha and https://data.gov.in/catalogs?query=legislation&sort_by=search_api_relevance&sort_order=DESC&items_per_page=20. The data is openly licensed and open for further reuse. Both the Rajya Sabha and Lok Sabha Secretariat update the information regarding the members and legislative business on a timely basis. ","Yes","No","Akhilesh Srivastava","Kamil Gregor","55"
"04c086a0-5272-48bd-b36f-39ca28db8cae","global","2015-10-23T07:46:39","2015","in","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.gov.in/catalogs?query=air+quality&op=Search&sort_by=search_api_relevance&sort_order=DESC&items_per_page=10","CSV, Excel",,,"Environmental Information System - Realising the importance of Environmental Information, the Government of India, in December, 1982, established an Environmental Information System (ENVIS) as a plan programme. The focus of ENVIS since inception has been on providing environmental information to decision makers, policy planners, scientists and engineers, research workers, etc. all over the country. Since environment is a broad-ranging, multi-disciplinary subject, a comprehensive information system on environment would necessarlly involve effective participation of concerned institutions/ organisations in the country that are actively engaged in work relating to different subject areas of environment. ENVIS has, therefore, developed itself with a network of such participating institutions/organisations for the programme to be meaningful. ","Environmental Information System, Ministry of Environment & Forest, Government of India","Yes","Yes","License - https://data.gov.in/sites/default/files/NDSAP.pdf is not open. Changed the submission. ","OGD India gives an exhaustive amount of data with regard to emission and other related details. The data is in open format and machine readable. Area and pollutant wise air quality can be accesed on Data portal India at https://data.gov.in/catalogs?query=air+quality&op=Search&sort_by=search_api_relevance&sort_order=DESC&items_per_page=10. Real time Ambient Air Quality Data at various locations in the country is available at https://www.cpcb.gov.in/CAAQM/mapPage/frmindiamap.aspx. Data can be easily downloaded in XLS format.
data for air quality is also available at https://cpcbenvis.nic.in/airpollution/air%20data%202011-2007/AIRTAB.html.
Real time Air Quality data across country is available at https://164.100.43.188/cpcbnew/movie.html and live data of Delhi is also available at https://www.cpcb.gov.in/cpcbpa/index.aspx?state=delhi.
Reviewer's note: the license here - https://data.gov.in/sites/default/files/NDSAP.pdf is not open - does not allow commercial use. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"953e1c47-61bc-4f49-96f7-826449222ad0","global","2015-10-28T15:47:50","2015","in","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.gov.in/catalogs#path=sector/statistics-9382","XLS,CSV",,,"National Statistics - The Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation came into existence as an Independent Ministry on 15.10.1999 after the merger of the Department of Statistics and the Department of Programme Implementation. The Ministry has two wings, one relating to Statistics and the other Programme Implementation. The Statistics Wing called the National Statistical Office(NSO) consists of the Central Statistical Office (CSO), the Computer Centre and the National Sample Survey Office (NSSO). The Programme Implementation Wing has three Divisions, namely, (i) Twenty Point Programme (ii) Infrastructure Monitoring and Project Monitoring and (iii) Member of Parliament Local Area Development Scheme. Besides these two wings, there is National Statistical Commission created through a Resolution of Government of India (MOSPI) and one autonomous Institute, viz., Indian Statistical Institute declared as an institute of National importance by an Act of Parliament. ","Ministry of Statistics and Program Implementation, Government of India, Office of Registrar General, India","Yes","Yes","Approved, license was not open","The OGD India (https://data.gov.in/) provides voluminous amount of national statistics and data in this regard which is absolutely open and machine readable. All the national statistics data are open to public, reusable and freely available in Data Portal India. The Data has been shared under National Data Sharing and Accessibility Policy – 2012 (NDSAP-2012). This was a unique initiative taken by Govt of India to facilitate access to Government of India owned shareable data and information in both human readable and machine readable forms.
Review note - This license does not considered open - https://data.gov.in/sites/default/files/NDSAP.pdf","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"26d35674-6984-4a1b-add6-9ae92673fe40","global","2015-09-16T03:24:54","2015","hk","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.budget.gov.hk/2015/eng/estimates1.html","CSV","https://data.gov.hk/en/terms-and-conditions",,"Data related to 2015-16 Estimates of the Government","Financial Services and the Treasury Bureau, info@fstb.gov.hk","Yes","Yes","From the website - ""The usage of the datasets is subject to the Terms and Conditions as stipulated under DATA.GOV.HK"". The license on DATA.GOV.UK seems as it comply with Open Data and allow commercial and non-commercial use. ","Hong Kong released its budget plans in CSV format for the first time this year. The full descriptions for spending are still held in PDF format in the 'Budget Speech' documents: https://www.budget.gov.hk/2015/eng/speech.html
Budget commitments are described in terms of policy areas, but there is a document that links policy area to government departments. The expenditure plans in the CSV format do include a fairly detailed breakdown of 'large' projects that includes past and future expenditure.","Yes","Yes","Rob Davidson","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"75e2a6ad-6a1f-4334-b902-30621a0b315f","global","2015-10-28T15:49:18","2015","in","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.gov.in/catalog/bhuvan-geoportal-nrscisro#web_catalog_tabs_block_1","WMS",,,"Bhuvan Geoportal - It allows users to explore a 2D/3D representation of the surface to view India, offering the highest resolution in this region and providing content in four local languages. Apart from visualization Bhuvan provides free satellite data and a products download facility and rich thematic datasets. Bhuvan is using a crowdsourcing approach to enrich its maps and collect point of interest data.","National Remote Sensing Centre","Yes","Yes","License is not open","The data is fully available in the OGD India website mentioned above with their links. The information available on OGD India and is completely open for reuse and further studies and research. Maps are available at https://data.gov.in/catalog/bhuvan-geoportal-nrscisro#web_catalog_tabs_block_10.
Bhuvan (https://bhuvan.nrsc.gov.in/data/download/index.php) is the gateway on Indian Earth Observation. It gives an easy way to experience, explore and visualize IRS images over Indian region. Bhuvan platform provides wide ranging information through its interactive maps and a number of products which are available on its site. The data is available for download to every one and the policy clearly states that the data can be distributed and further used for developing applications and research. But data doesn't include administrative boundaries, public equipments, transport systems, etc.
Survey of India (https://www.surveyofindia.gov.in/), the National Survey and Mapping Organisation of the country under the Department of Science & Technology, provides varrious types of mapping data. The full list of available mapping products is here: https://www.surveyofindia.gov.in/pages/display/59-publications.
The license here - https://data.gov.in/sites/default/files/NDSAP.pdf does not considered open","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"49420560-7957-44b2-8516-625065095387","global","2015-10-28T15:50:19","2015","in","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.gov.in/catalog/company-master-data","CSV",,,"Company Register - The Ministry of Corporate Affairs is charged with administering the Companies Act of India 1956 and 2013, registration of companies and other issues pertaining to the private sector in India. It is the nodal agency for data pertaining to companies and corporate entities. ","Ministry of Corporate Affairs, Government of India","Yes","Yes","License is not open","Master data of all the companies registered is available on OGD India, which is easily downloadable and available in bulk. Most importantly it is machine readable. The information available on OGD India and is completely open for reuse and further studies and research. It is updated on an annual basis for each financial year.
Data is also available on Ministry of Corporate affairs website:
1. Company Master Data (https://www.mca.gov.in/MinistryV2/masterdatareport.html)
2. Total Companies Registered-Year wise and State wise:
List of Companies registered or incorporated during the year (year wise from 1857 till date) :https://www.mca.gov.in/MinistryV2/CompStat_IFCompLLP.html
List of Companies Registered or incorporated - statewise (Registration from 1857 till date):
https://www.mca.gov.in/MinistryV2/CompStat_IFCompLLP.html
3. Companies Incorporated or Closed during the month:
Month wise Master details of Companies/LLPs Registered (From Nov 2013 to Nov 2014): https://www.mca.gov.in/MinistryV2/eir.html and https://www.mca.gov.in/MinistryV2/eir_Archive.html
This particular data includes information of Indian companies registered,Foreign companies registered and LLP registered.
The license is not considered open - https://data.gov.in/sites/default/files/NDSAP.pdf","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"8eabafcc-1c6f-4b44-82b3-5dfabfe43ebb","global","2015-09-18T11:33:56","2015","in","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://eci.nic.in/eci_main1/ElectionStatistics.aspx","Excel, PDF",,,"Election Commission of India -The Election Commision of India is an autonomous constitional body in India which is tasked with the duty to administer all electoral process within Republic of India. Starting from declaration of elections to conducting them and coming out with results. India being the largest democracy in the world, a mindboggling levels of numbers are associated with the conduct of the elections which can be constituted as data. The Election Commision of India is the sole publisher of data related to elections. ","Election Commission of India","Yes","Yes","The submission does not meet the definition - they are available at constituency level, aggregating votes of up to 3 million people. Polling station data is available at https://eci.nic.in/eci_main1/LinktoForm20.aspx in various formats.","Data of Election result is available at https://eci.nic.in/eci_main1/ElectionStatistics.aspx; Detailed Results of latest elections are available in xls format i.e https://eci.nic.in/eci_main/StatisticalReports/candidatewise/LS-2014_ElectionResult.xlsx and https://eci.nic.in/eci_main1/GE2014/Party_Contested_GE_2014.xlsx
Real time Election Result is available also when actual election is going on and can be accessed through https://eciresults.nic.in/. API is also available for real time election result. Many web/mobile app has been developed using the API of https://eciresults.nic.in/.
Data related to elections is also available on Data Portal.
Details include-
* List of Participating Political Parties
* List of Successful Candidates
* Performance of Political Parties
* Candidate Data Summary
* Electors Data Summary
* Women Candidates
* Constituency Data Summary
* Detailed Results
Data available on OGD India is completely free and open for reuse and further studies and research.
","Yes","No","Akhilesh Srivastava","Kamil Gregor","70"
"59c18c8f-41de-413c-ba25-77a1aa96d63f","global","2015-09-18T08:10:20","2015","in","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://indiabudget.nic.in/ebmain.asp","CSV, Excel",,,"Union Budget of India - The Union Budget of India also known as Annual Financial Statement in Article 112 of the Constitution of Indiais presented each year in the month of February by the Finance Minister of India, in the Indian Parliament. This budget encompasses all the departments of the Government and the various important governance initiatives that are to be undertaken. ","Ministry of Finance, Government of India","Yes","Yes","Terms of use here does not mention the data can be re-used for any porpuse. - https://indiabudget.nic.in/terms.asp","The data is available in the OGD India (https://data.gov.in) website mentioned above with their links. The data is available in machine readable formats. The data portal provides important data pertaining to various aspects of the budget from 2011-12 to 2015-16 in machine readable excel format.
The Ministry of Finance website https://indiabudget.nic.in/index.asp on Union Budget provides up to date information about the budget (In XLS and PDF Format). The information available on OGD India is completely open for reuse and further studies and research. Same is the case with the data available on the budget website.","Yes","No","Akhilesh Srivastava","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"f3ebdd43-b993-4b19-ad7f-20dd824b69bc","global","2014-10-31T21:35:43","2014","hk","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","This is very tricky in HK. As the dataset actually asks about *national-level* transportation services. I do not think HK has any kind of service there. Regarding timetable itself (for city-level transportation service), the data should exist based upon my personal experience, but no idea where is the digital one.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","FENG GAO","0"
"4e9f566a-f4c0-436b-b1bd-2b1fb1e4f843","global","2015-11-10T01:26:19","2015","tw","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,"The Department of Land Administration, Ministry of the Interior /czester@land.moi.gov.tw","Yes","Yes","https://easymap.land.moi.gov.tw/ is an interface to the java-applet powered map that people can query and buy electronic copies of land information.",,"Yes","No","Czester Chen","Codrina Maria Ilie","10"
"34faed5c-db54-4805-b78a-31122d1f0a7d","global","2015-09-28T06:09:56","2015","ua","companies","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","No","Unsure","Unsure",,"Yes","https://usr.minjust.gov.ua/paidextract",,,,"Unified State Register of Legal Entities and Individual Entrepreneurs","Ministry of Justice of Ukraine","Yes","Yes","Data is now held by the Ministry of Justice - updated publisher and description. Filled out criteria according to paid data. It is online because the paid data can be obtained via a web portal, but what form the data is in is unknown (presumably digital, unsure if machine readable).","The register can be searched for free using keywords, although a CAPTCHA must also be entered for every individual search. To make a search in the registry, visit: https://usr.minjust.gov.ua/ua/freesearch
All other data must be purchased, though it is unclear whether or not this is bulk data or what format it is available in.","Yes","No","anonymous","Rebecca Sentance","25"
"d69c2a54-c738-4b9c-9892-5257df8bc5ff","global","2015-10-02T05:42:12","2015","ml","map","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Seems correct.","The National Geographical Institute (IGM) have started with the support of EU funds in year 2013 to realise a map of the country at the scale of 1/200 000","Yes","No","anonymous","Gil Zaretzer","0"
"2e084e12-35af-48a3-9ab1-42efbfc07f23","global","2015-09-13T09:22:42","2015","ir","statistics","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Some data but not recent and not open. ","The statistical data is available via Management and Planning Organization (Statistical Centre of Iran / https://www.amar.org.ir)
Here you can find the population (https://www.amar.org.ir/Default.aspx?tabid=500), last updated on 2011.
Unemployment here (https://www.amar.org.ir/Default.aspx?tabid=498), link not working.
GDP here (https://www.amar.org.ir/Default.aspx?tabid=499), last updated 2011.
","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Zach Christensen","0"
"c1097e43-020b-449d-93a9-b57140297774","global","2015-09-03T08:25:49","2015","im","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","No","No",,"Yes",,,"https://www.gov.im/about-this-site/open-government-licence/",,"primary legislation","HM Attorney General chambers","Yes","Yes","The submission seems to be correct.","All primary legislation is uploaded by the HM Attorney General's department (cloud hosted open source system as per Jersey) and all secondary legislation is uploaded by the IT department at the Isle of Man Parliament (cloud hosted Microsoft Sharepoint). All ""live"" primary legislation is available free online. All secondary legislation from 2000 is available free online and all earlier secondary legislation is available free by email (typically same day) -- all earlier secondary legislation will be uploaded in due course.
Since some of the legislation is not available online, we are marking it as 'unsure'.
Bulk download of all legislations is not present.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","70"
"56c23a1b-db9e-4bbe-b3c5-97ebc70563b9","global","2015-11-09T22:41:41","2015","tw","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"中央政府總結算","Directorate General of Budget, Accounting and Statistics, Executive Yuan, R.O.C.","Yes","Yes","Data is not in transactional level","https://www.dgbas.gov.tw/public/Attachment/4828914358VPAUQXD.xls shows the aggregated data which indicates the transactional data exists and is digital.","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"a14e1452-9d3a-47e9-8086-8953d065e2e6","global","2015-09-14T17:18:37","2015","fr","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.sante.gouv.fr/qualite-de-l-eau-potable",,"https://wiki.data.gouv.fr/images/9/9d/Licence_Ouverte.pdf",,"Qualité de l'eau potable ","Ministère des affaires sociales, de la santé et des droits de femmes & Ministère de l'Écologie, du Développement durable et de l'Énergie","Yes","Yes","The government does provide this data on the web. It does specify when it was collected ""Date du prélèvement"" seems to be every few months, with every area on a different timeline. I couldn't find downloaded bulk data anywhere but they have it in a digital format.","This data is on drinking water and is updated on a daily/weekly basis.
Detailed data on water sources are also available on:
- www.eaufrance.fr: documentation and surface water
- www.ades.eaufrance.fr: on groundwater data
","Yes","No","Claire-Marie Foulquier-Gazagnes","Nisha Thompson","65"
"5d8428a9-0aca-4b54-84a2-e2cd57deebe1","global","2014-12-05T19:51:54","2014","mx","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"National ministry of transport: https://www.sct.gob.mx/
Data exists on municipal level. ","Yes","No","Enrique Zapata","Enrique Zapata","0"
"ceeee6a0-b51e-4ad6-b3ee-8681fdc2b279","global","2015-09-19T11:26:11","2015","ch","map","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.swisstopo.admin.ch/internet/swisstopo/en/home/products/freeproducts.html","WMS, WMTS, SHP, PDF",,,"Swiss Raster Map","Federal Office of Topography swisstopo","Yes","Yes","I found that one must register in order to download even the free content, thus it is not public. The terms and conditions one approves when downloading clearly state that this is not free for commercial use.","A raster map with the scale 1:1.000.000 as well as several vector and geology datasets are provided for free. Additional data is sold via the [online shop](https://www.toposhop.admin.ch/de/shop/index). An [interactive map viewer](https://map.geo.admin.ch/) with all available layers and visualization of changes over time is available here. A catalogue of all [existing geospatial data](https://www.geocat.ch/) is available on a specific data catalogue for geo-data with detailed meta-descriptions and detailed information on updates to topographical maps. Several geographic data sets will also be available on the Swiss [Open Government Data Portal](https://opendata.admin.ch/en/dataset?groups=raum-und-umwelt&_organization_limit=0).","Yes","No","Oleg Lavrovsky","Gil Zaretzer","65"
"4d0bc5ee-c800-4d5c-a8d8-d00c184391a4","global","2015-09-21T18:15:54","2015","gt","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://resultados2015.tse.org.gt/resultados-2015/","Excel",,,,"Tribunal Supremo Electoral - https://www.tse.org.gt/","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The Supreme Electoral Court (TSE) is the highest authority in electoral matters. Elections are intended to elect the President and Vice-President, Members of Congress, Municipal Corporations throughout the Republic, deputies to the Central American Parliament and alternates. The Guatemala Electoral Commission publishes an authoritative collection of electoral results. The Electoral Commission makes the bulk data available for download in PDF and Excel spreadsheet formats. ","Yes","No","Julio Herrera","Kamil Gregor","70"
"01a4f062-0832-472f-8c61-edf0e5f81a12","global","2015-09-28T07:52:58","2015","mm","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","No evidence showing from the President's Officer website that the data is exist. https://www.myanmarpresidentoffice.info/en/ and the dedicated webpage for the cabinet ministries is empty https://www.myanmarpresidentoffice.info/en/?q=cabinet/ministries so no way to find out who are the responsible minister involve. I have found a 3rd party website https://www.ourweb.info/01/directory/myanmar/005/ that provide a list of ministries official websites but some of these websites are not found.
![enter image description here][1]
[1]: https://s9.postimg.org/92ckd9e5b/Screen_Shot_2015_09_28_at_3_51_24_PM.png","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","0"
"58474b4d-4c39-4856-ab68-e5343524d8a5","global","2015-09-28T08:01:22","2015","mm","statistics","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","No official sources found.","No evidence showing from the President's Officer website that the data exist. https://www.myanmarpresidentoffice.info/en/ and the dedicated webpage for the central statistical organization does not work. https://costat.gov.mm","Yes","No","anonymous","Zach Christensen","0"
"919be4be-8874-4d98-89a3-06e2ed64e978","global","2015-10-01T14:42:00","2015","ca","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is correct.
All suggestions in comments are aggregated expenditure or procurement data.","The Government of Canada released a pilot sample dataset matching the criteria for this category for the fiscal year 2013-2014, which has since been discontinued: https://data.gc.ca/data/en/dataset/2eed2fba-1626-4d2e-a511-389cc6b51ddf . The Government of Canada also has a tool for searching expenditure data, but data availability varies by ministry and department. Data is not month to month - it is aggregated by fiscal year - and it is not very detailed. Data cannot be downloaded. https://www.tbs-sct.gc.ca/ems-sgd/edb-bdd/index-eng.html
(No change since 2014)","Yes","No","Neal Bastek","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"68b9e75e-4d17-4300-ac47-a65631fe6f9f","global","2015-11-03T14:39:30","2015","tw","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.gov.tw/node/7264","XML","https://data.gov.tw/license",,"Awarding for Government Procurement","Public Construction Commission Executive Yuan","Yes","Yes","Submission correct. ","Active tenders are searchable. Full data is available through the Open Data portal.
- Zh-TW website: [Link here][1]
- English website: [Link here][2]
[1]: https://web.pcc.gov.tw/tps/pss/tender.do?method=goSearch&searchMode=common&searchType=basic
[2]: https://web.pcc.gov.tw/tps/pss/tender.do?method=goNews","Yes","Yes","lycurgus kk","Georg Neumann","100"
"740aea09-72f9-435d-a775-a43735be3fda","global","2015-11-03T15:19:04","2015","tw","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://data.gov.tw/node/6308","CSV","https://data.gov.tw/license",,"This data set is mainly to provide Taiwan with the water company for each water purification plant water quality information.","Taiwan Water Supply Corp","Yes","Yes","Data is in bulk, however, results are published once a month, and not on a weekly basis. ","The item above is about the water quality of reservoirs in different place. The data is about the name of different reservoirs, townships, layer and depth of sample, and details.
The data update every month and can be download easily in single file.
","Yes","Yes","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","90"
"00f51f91-51b1-4cf0-a7ad-fe3c3cbc9602","global","2014-11-19T14:22:31","2014","si","postcodes","Yes","Yes","No","No","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The data should have postcodes/zipcodes *and* the corresponding geospatial locations. At the moment Slovenia has a postcode data and a separate geospatial locations dataset, but not one dataset that contain the both. Therefore, I changed the review accordingly. ","Data is available from Post of Slovenia, but is hidden in HTML format, not available in bulk and additional skills are needed to extract it. Geodetska uprava (Slovenian equivalent of UK Ordnance survey) resells bulk data with additional GIS information.
For a simpler postname<->postnumber mapping, see this HTML table:
https://www.posta.si/postne-stevilke-doma","Yes","No","Marieke Guy","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"a8d7b9c1-263d-4753-afbe-304d834e3de5","global","2014-12-01T09:26:18","2014","si","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","Yes","No",,"Yes",,"TIFF, SHP, CSV",,,"National Topographic Maps","Prostor","Yes","Yes","Expert review: Criteria were not compliant with neither comment nor reality on the website.","Geodetska uprava (Slovenian equivalent of UK Ordnance survey) takes care of maps and resells them. Bulk data is available against payment. Licensing and reuse is non-free and limited. An 1:1.000.000 topographic raster map is free of charge and free for reuse, if a source is mentioned:
https://www.e-prostor.gov.si/?id=415
The list of all available maps can be found here: https://www.e-prostor.gov.si/si/dostop_do_podatkov/dostop_do_podatkov/
1:25.000 topographic maps are available for online use (but not download) through various free web viewers like the Atlas of environment and Geopedia.si .
Some other minor layers are also available free of charge (like the borders), especially environmental data at https://gis.arso.gov.si/wfs_web .","Yes","No","Daniela Mattern","Daniela Mattern","40"
"884e6ca0-122a-4a7d-9ef5-0f2e46cd3ee7","global","2014-11-23T10:52:54","2014","si","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.ajpes.si/Registri/Poslovni_register/Splosno",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Corrected the old review and added that the data is available to the public. ","Only individual records can be used freely; bulk data is limited by a statement ""Users can get only minor parts of the databases (qualitatively and / or quantitatively) and to the extent provided in the context of available web applications. All other forms of retransmission or enabling the use of third parties (eg, publication of the third-party server or user, reproduction in other documents, etc.). Expressly prohibited. This prohibition applies to all forms of use that goes beyond their own use. In particular, the following practices are prohibited: the use of substantial parts (qualitatively and / or quantitatively) databases (eg reproduction structure databases, parts of the structure of databases, creation of public and private databases, etc..) ..."" (see https://www.ajpes.si/Pogoji_uporabe) Bulk extracts are charged for - see https://www.ajpes.si/Registri/Poslovni_register/Ponovna_uporaba/Nadomestila for a scale of charges) ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","30"
"55f6e8b5-e011-4736-a570-867712ecad16","global","2014-11-19T14:05:28","2014","si","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.dvk-rs.si/","PDF",,,,,"Yes","Yes","License is not open under the definition of the 'open definition'. Therefore, it is not open and was changed. ","The site gives results for instance for the 2012 presidential election down to polling station level. However only PDF format is offered on the website at https://www.dvk-rs.si/index.php/si/strani/volisca-za-volitve-predsednika-rs-2012 The disclaimer on https://www.dvk-rs.si/index.php/si/pravno-obvestilo asserts that under Slovenian Law these results are not subject to Copyright and so can be reused freely. ","Yes","No","Marieke Guy","Mor Rubinstein","55"
"8bb70ea5-5226-4308-a77f-2c889e436ff0","global","2014-11-19T14:20:56","2014","si","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.pisrs.si/Pis.web/","HTML, PDF",,,,"PIS","Yes","Yes","Data is accurate and approved.","Update to previous site :
""We hereby inform you that the contents of the website zakonodaja.gov.si 15 April 2014, became an integral part of the revised Site Legal Information System of the Republic of Slovenia ( PIS ) . ISP offers free access to legislative and other public documents of state bodies and statutory authorities in the Republic of Slovenia and the documents issued by the institutions of the European Union and the Council of Europe""
The previous site eventually points to the Slovenian Official Gazette as at (for example) https://www.uradni-list.si/1/objava.jsp?urlid=200670&stevilka=2999 . This is in HTML and there is no download facility. The licensing conditions at https://www.uradni-list.si/0/legal include (article 14, Google Translate) ""All rights to the home page and all subpages Site-official list.si reserved. The information and materials on this website are protected by intellectual property rights upravljavca.Informacije and materials displayed on the Site may be downloaded for your personal use, however, do not change copyright and other notices relating to intellectual property rights or other rights notices. It is permitted to download and print information and materials for viewing and reading for non-commercial purposes. Any other copying, distribution, reproduction, modification information and materials on this site or send them by mail or distribute in any other way without prior written permission is prohibited. It is also prohibited to use any element of own-list.si for any purpose other than personal, non-commercial use. Restrictions on use of materials not subject to the Official Journal of the Republic of Slovenia, and it posted content."" Therefore this site is not Open, not machine readable and no bulk downloadable.
The legal registry at https://pisrs.si is newer and most of the sites at the original url redirect there. However, it is mostly a usability enhancement. ","Yes","No","Marieke Guy","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"423c1edc-ee79-428d-9ceb-c2fa8f270749","global","2014-11-29T23:00:08","2014","si","spending","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://supervizor.kpk-rs.si/","JSON, JSONP, XML, XLS",,,,"The Commission for the Prevention of Corruption of the Republic of Slovenia","Yes","Yes","Duplicate submission","The first page is not a notice of (un)availability, rather an introductory message. Data is available in a form of a web application, where you are supposed to choose a public body and/or private company doing business with government. Examples:
https://supervizor.kpk-rs.si/organ/16110/ gives a graph and list of all expenses by Ministry of finances. https://supervizor.kpk-rs.si/podj/25028022/ gives all income for Post of Slovenia received from public bodies. Companies also have listed owners, supervisors and directors. You can combine bodies and companies, eg. https://supervizor.kpk-rs.si/organ/12157/podj/25028022/ lists all expenditure from Information comissioner's office given to Post of Slovenia. Bulk data is available at:
https://supervizor.kpk-rs.si/podatki/
All transactions above 2000€ are noted and dated (starting from 2003) with a summary log for the rest. There is an API available and official interface provided, which can list all the transactions, not limited to the abovementioned sum:
https://github.com/Supervizor/supervizor-api
There is also a 3rd-party scrapper available here: https://github.com/dataoko/slobiro/tree/master/superviz2
Additionally , there's detailed monthly and yearly documentation of the balance of public finances at (PDF, XLS):
https://www.mf.gov.si/si/delovna_podrocja/tekoca_gibanja_v_javnih_financah/bilten_jav nih_financ/","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"073cf752-e0b7-475c-bc8c-152cd5e095c8","global","2015-11-03T15:04:02","2015","tw","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://data.gov.tw/node/9219","XML","https://data.gov.tw/license",,"It provides 7 days forecast of temperature, county names, time, and weather conditions.","Central Weather Bureau","Yes","Yes","Data exist in XMl, but not in bulk, wind is in a different dataset. ","The PDF is Chinese-English vocabulary form not about the data, but you can find the 7 days forecast data in XML file.","Yes","Yes","lycurgus kk","Mor Rubinstein","90"
"4aca18d1-cbd2-4724-9f17-14bee07ca89b","global","2015-08-29T14:15:11","2015","tw","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://opendata.epa.gov.tw/Data/Contents/AQX/","XML, CSV, JSON","https://data.gov.tw/opendata/principle",,"County, PSI, Major Pollutant, SO2. CO, O3, PM10, PM2.5, Wind Speed, Wind Direct, Publilsh Time","Environment Protection Agency","Yes","Yes","checked ",,"Yes","Yes","Ying Chu Chen","yar michl","100"
"d6820909-b64d-4388-b489-86136acc082d","global","2015-11-09T01:31:17","2015","tw","postcodes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Zip Code and Administrative boundaries","Ministry of Transportation and Communications and Ministry of the Interior","Yes","Yes","Data for postcodes exist, but does not meet the criteria of geo location. National boundaries are not applicable since there is a postcode system.","1. The Zip Code [above][1]. is in Zh-TW and can be open by unzip tools, and also provide the English post code search interface [here][3].
2. The Administrative boundaries [above][2]. can be open by GIS tools, and also provide the English administrative boundaries search interface [here][4]
[1]:https://data.gov.tw/node/5948
[2]:https://data.gov.tw/node/7442
[3]: https://www.post.gov.tw/post/internet/U_english/index.jsp?ID=240205
[4]:https://taiwanarmap.moi.gov.tw/moiupe/run.htm","Yes","No","lycurgus kk","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"e4a55d0e-35c9-47c2-91b4-751fb9f6dcb7","global","2015-11-03T14:55:15","2015","tw","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://law.moj.gov.tw/PublicData/GetFile.ashx?DType=XML&AuData=CF","XML","https://data.gov.tw/license",,,"Ministry of Justice","Yes","Yes","Data is available in bulk and openly licensed. ","It's a website above is belong to Ministry of Justice, and use to search the laws, date, legislative process.
- English website: [Link][1]
Some legislative records belong to Legislative Yuan. and the gazette of the Legislative Yuan is here [Link][2], but in all in zh-TW PDF files.
[1]: https://law.moj.gov.tw/ENG/index.aspx
[2]: https://lci.ly.gov.tw/LyLCEW/lcivComm.action#pageName_searchResult=1","Yes","Yes","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"c4621a82-bf4a-410e-8e50-5975e8df5ac6","global","2015-11-04T08:03:15","2015","tw","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.gov.tw/node/6803","XML","https://data.gov.tw/license",,"GDP依支出分(對經濟成長貢獻)","Directorate General of Budget, Accounting and Statistics (DGBAS) ","Yes","Yes","Data are openly available and regularly updated. ","Data are openly licensed, current, and available in open formats.
https://data.gov.tw/node/6637
https://data.gov.tw/node/18681
","Yes","Yes","TH Schee","Zach Christensen","100"
"2bdd5d41-0556-4d98-9094-11c8d63957c7","global","2015-11-03T14:58:56","2015","tw","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.gov.tw/node/9363","WMS","https://data.gov.tw/license",,"通用版電子地圖(WMS)","內政部","Yes","Yes","I reviewed this again, since registration is free it is publicly available","The original website (https://emap.nlsc.gov.tw/gis/ ) is a mapping service online, you have to register to use more function.
In 2014, The Ministry of Interior has built their open data platform (only in Traditional Chinese), https://data.moi.gov.tw/MoiOD/default/Index.aspx in June. They provide the map web service to download to use.
They also provide the data to https://data.gov.tw , people also can download the data in https://data.gov.tw/node/9363 .
The Principles of Use are compliant with the open definition.","Yes","Yes","lycurgus kk","Gil Zaretzer","100"
"6a9d00e2-0d4a-45dd-a108-a8e94f0f7d5e","global","2015-08-29T12:58:06","2015","tw","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.gcis.nat.gov.tw/od/detail?oid=AD28285B-7B0E-4241-9F58-F2F0F289333E","CSV","https://data.gov.tw/license",,"Name of company, address, unique identifier of the company, the owner, capital, approved date, registration department"," The Department of Commerce, Ministry of Economic Affairs (data.gcis@gmail.com)","Yes","Yes","Have added some details in details field. All else fine.","Company data is updated month by month. NB, some users may have trouble viewing Taiwanese characters when opening CSV file in Excel.","Yes","Yes","Ying Chu Chen","Rebecca Sentance","100"
"0c781dc7-de6c-4ba7-86ca-0f549fc85d31","global","2015-08-29T13:14:23","2015","tw","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.gov.tw/node/13119","CSV","https://data.gov.tw/license",,,"Central Election Commission","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.",,"Yes","Yes","Ying Chu Chen","Kamil Gregor","100"
"9b08a9e3-2c13-4758-a7a1-f1898f621634","global","2015-08-28T10:26:06","2015","tw","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.gov.tw/node/11851","XML","https://data.gov.tw/license",,,"The Directorate General of Budget, Accounting and Statistics (DGBAS) of Executive Yuan","Yes","Yes","I have checked the data and it is correct. ","They also provide brief presentation on analysis of annual revenue and Expenditure in English, PDF format.
Central Government General Budget, Ficscal Year 2015: [Link][1]
(All in PDF.)
[1]: https://eng.dgbas.gov.tw/ct.asp?xItem=37838&CtNode=6173&mp=2","Yes","Yes","Ying Chu Chen","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"c37796b1-e8c2-4a2d-bbdd-f16469668700","global","2014-11-04T02:38:46","2014","tw","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.gov.tw/node/6138","XML","https://data.gov.tw/?q=principle",,," Ministry of Transportation and Communication","Yes","Yes","The data is provided by Ministry of Transportation and Communication but from different department, and the open data platform is built by Taiwan gov. so, I think those data sets are eligible.","There is no national central public transport data catalog. Taiwan Railway, Taiwan High Speed Rail and etc., all timetables are in different websites. No changes in 2014.
People can download different timetables they need in https://data.gov.tw.
1. Domestic Airline timetable in CSV format: https://data.gov.tw/node/6066
2. Bus timetable in CSV format: https://data.gov.tw/node/6052
3. Railway in XML format: https://data.gov.tw/node/6138
4. High Speed Railway in CSV format: https://data.gov.tw/node/7080
They are all provided by Ministry of Transportation and Communication but from different department.
And the open data platform is built by Taiwan gov. so, I think those data sets are eligible.","Yes","Yes","TH Schee","Ying Chu Chen","100"
"5fa79697-8379-4f68-8327-1e3971cb9fcd","global","2014-11-19T14:59:47","2014","si","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://okolje.arso.gov.si/onesnazevanje_zraka/reporting#Nacionalne%20emisije%20onesna%C5%BEeval%20zraka","XLS, XML",,,," AGENCIJA REPUBLIKE SLOVENIJE ZA OKOLJE","Yes","Yes","Data is accurate and approved. ","The main site is an overview with a set of links mostly pointing to official data submitted to EIONET, for example:
https://cdr.eionet.europa.eu/si/eu/colqba8sg/nec/columnelg/envungf9g
https://cdr.eionet.europa.eu/si/eu/colqba8sg/ghgmm
There is also this official listing, which is much more user friendly and oriented more to the layman than the data scientist. However it's update times are staggering and it's only available in Slovenian.
https://kazalci.arso.gov.si/?data=group&group_id=16 ","Yes","No","Marieke Guy","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"a4d45da4-415e-44bb-8a38-df6bdca8a27c","global","2014-11-19T14:15:31","2014","si","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://pxweb.stat.si/pxweb/dialog/statfile1.asp","XLS, PX, ",,,,"Statistical office of the Republic of Slovenia surs.si-stat@gov.si","Yes","Yes","Changed the license from Open to Not Open. ","Registration needed to access data. The home page states ""Use and publication of data is allowed provided the source is acknowledged.""","Yes","No","Marieke Guy","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"230a407c-12f0-4076-a822-7cecda48f6bd","global","2014-11-19T14:00:00","2014","si","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.mf.gov.si/si/delovna_podrocja/proracun/sprejeti_proracun/","CSV",,,,,"Yes","Yes","On the footer of the website it is mention the follows: ""© 2014 Ministry of Finance. All rights reserved!"" Therefore, I changed the license to ""not open""","Each of the budget revisions are published as an Act and therefore available freely. Click on the links in the content of the page, to get to a page about each revision of a yearly budget. There, the first two links will be the budget in PDF and CSV format. Since 2013 the budget is also provided in CSV. Older PDF and CSV files, general part only (""splošni del""), are provided via a third party, on github:
https://github.com/zejn/prrorracun/tree/master/final/splosni ----
","Yes","No","Marieke Guy","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"3f74e6f5-a265-4833-a3ba-64d114505f69","global","2014-11-19T12:53:22","2014","si","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.ap-ljubljana.si/ https://www.slo-zeleznice.si/en/passengers/slovenia","HTML, XML",,,,,"Yes","Yes","Bustrack.com is not an official government resource, and therefore is not relevant for this survey. At the time of the review the official transport website of the Slovenian government - https://www.jpp.si was under construction and there was no XML dump available. Therefore, I changed the data to non machine readable.
In addition, all the other official but and train sites are licensed in a private copyright. Therefore, the data is not open licensed. ","There are several time tables and web sites available. For long-distance buses in Slovenia, there's a from-to query interface at https://www.ap-ljubljana.si/ . Timetables for railways are available at Slovenian Railways home page, https://www.slo-zeleznice.si/sl/potniki/slovenija/vozni-redi - available are both as a from-to query and based on route (""Vozni redi po relacijah""). There's also an XML dump of bus routes, stations and arrivals available at https://www.jpp.si/Pregled/Register.jsp (but none for trains). Timetables for city bus routes in Ljubljana are available at https://www.lpp.si/javni-prevoz/vozni-redi-mestni-potniski-promet/vozni-redi-redni . There is also a query-style web service, displaying arrival time for city buses in Ljubljana https://bus.talktrack.com/","Yes","No","Marieke Guy","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"1ff89a0b-c26c-4a3b-93ab-65db3d2c57d0","global","2014-11-07T17:43:56","2014","hr","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","This entry is accepted with minor clerification in the comments section.","To our knowledge (and available research), there is no official source linking geospatial data to postcodes in Croatia.
However, the database of postcodes in Croatia (without corresponding locations) is available at:
https://www.posta.hr/postanski-brojevi-i-uredi","Yes","No","Drazen Hoffmann","Stevan Gostojić","0"
"7317967c-9e54-4292-9e49-60f71de90a3d","global","2014-11-30T22:32:03","2014","hr","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","After expert review we changed the data from not existed to exist but not available to the public, that is since there is aggregated data which is composed out of transactions. "," Records of Government spending are only available on semi-annual basis in the form of the State Budget Execution Report, datasets available in three different types of classification as Ms Excel documents: e.g. economical classification dataset https://www.mfin.hr/adminmax/docs/Izvrsenje%20po%20razdjelima,%20glavama%20i%20ekonomskoj%20klasifikaciji.xls","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"138ba798-b0b6-4b40-aa9b-3d9b7f3799d5","global","2014-11-07T18:05:12","2014","hr","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://zrak.mzoip.hr","html",,,,"Meteorological and Hydrographical Service; State Network for Permanent Air Quality Measurement","Yes","Yes","The entry is accepted without any modifications.","This database differs from the one reported upon in 2013, since it contains aggregate nationwide data, as opposed to single pollutant sources (e.g., this database provides information on aggregate emissions in the city of Rijeka, instead of those by different companies nationwide). In addition, this database is updated on a daily basis, whereas the one reported upon in 2013 reports on an annual basis and does not currently (November 7 2014) contain data for 2014.
Data is copyrighted by the Ministry of Environment and Nature Protection.","Yes","No","Drazen Hoffmann","Stevan Gostojić","45"
"7c5b2ac8-00a5-41ba-b296-c2b74f998b83","global","2014-11-07T16:59:20","2014","hr","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://narodne-novine.nn.hr/default.aspx","html",,,,"Narodne novine, public company, which was registered as a joint-stock company with a 100% ownership by the Republic of Croatia","Yes","Yes","This entry is accepted without corrections.","No consolidated texts of the laws. Some consolidated and purified texts are available on unofficial site zakon.hr.
In the terms of use of the website of the Narodne novine company it is stated that datasets are copyrighted by the Narodne novine and may be used only under the conditions prescribed by law. ","Yes","No","Drazen Hoffmann","Stevan Gostojić","45"
"3050a8ee-dcf1-4ac8-a94a-1d5a51ca9b53","global","2014-11-07T17:29:31","2014","hr","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.dzs.hr/","pdf",,,,"Central Bureau of Statistics","Yes","Yes","This entry is accepted without any modifications. Since census data is available in a machine-readable format, the ""Is the data machine readable?"" should maybe be changed to ""Yes"".","Regarding up-to date status of data, the documents are available, but some are very slow processed. It is currently (as of November 2014.) unclear whether the data from the 2011 census is fully published.
Census data is available in a machine-readable format (MS Excel), but most periodical publications are not (available only in PDF or HTML).
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium of any of CBS publications without acknowledging the Croatian Bureau of Statistics as the source is prohibited.","Yes","No","Drazen Hoffmann","Stevan Gostojić","45"
"c32c0189-3ed5-42be-89de-941f1dc1bd82","global","2014-11-07T17:14:01","2014","hr","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://geoportal.dgu.hr/viewer/",,,,,"State Geodetic Directorate","Yes","Yes","The entry is accepted without any modifications.","The State Geodetic Directorate reserves the right to set and change the terms of use of the datasets. Any alterations, making copies of and distributing the data is forbidden.","Yes","No","Drazen Hoffmann","Stevan Gostojić","45"
"3d1f5e0d-8a5b-441a-9411-f5a260c94426","global","2014-11-07T16:38:55","2014","hr","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://sudreg.pravosudje.hr",,,,,"Commercial court ","Yes","Yes","This entry is accepted with correction of the ""Openly licensed?"" category.","Since there is no visible license on the website, we have selected ""No"" for the ""Openly licensed?"" category.
Datasets are provided on a timely and up to date basis according to deadlines regulated by the Act on the Court register. In practice this means that the register is updated whenever company registration procedures are completed.","Yes","No","Drazen Hoffmann","Stevan Gostojić","45"
"ec8b415d-7009-438e-8b3c-a7cf5d2c64a3","global","2014-11-07T16:08:59","2014","hr","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.izbori.hr/izbori/ws.nsf/site.xsp?documentId=A758299505B80F02C1257C8400606C3B",,,,,"State Election Commission","Yes","Yes","This entry is accepted with changes to ""Openly licensed?"" category (it is changed from ""Unsure"" to ""No"" according to the global open data index guideliness)","Since there is no visible license on the website of the State Election Commission, we have selected ""No"" category.
","Yes","No","Drazen Hoffmann","Stevan Gostojić","45"
"24cfaf8c-9b34-435e-b12c-72c5696d1b6d","global","2014-02-25T12:23:19","2014","hr","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.hzpp.hr/lgs.axd?t=16&id=10729","PDF",,,"Vozni red","HŽ Putnički prijevoz","Yes","Yes","This entry is accepted. Data publisher and dataset title are added.","Vozni red 2013/2014. - vlakovi u unutarnjem i međunarodnom prometu
Timetables can also be searched online at:
https://www.hzpp.hr/voznired
There is no national level service operated or regulated by the government for the bus transport.","Yes","No","Miroslav Schlossberg","Stevan Gostojić","55"
"3aa2a0c9-eda0-45e7-9c5d-42eef1855b54","global","2014-11-07T15:33:58","2014","hr","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.mfin.hr/hr/drzavni-proracun-2014-godina; https://www.mfin.hr/adminmax/docs/Posebni%20dio%20Dr%C5%BEavnog%20prora%C4%8Duna%20RH%20za%202014..xls,","xls, pdf",,,,"State Treasury Department within the Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","This entry is accepted.","Older budget records are available in non-machine readable format only.
Since in the impressum of the website of the Ministry of Finance it is not clearly stated whether data is licensed by the Government of Croatia, we have selected ""No"" category.
We have selected ""Yes"" under the ""available in bulk"" category since the whole budget for 2014 is available for download in a consolidated file. ","Yes","No","Drazen Hoffmann","Stevan Gostojić","70"
"849d27bd-435a-42c0-960e-ff3331744ca2","global","2015-09-28T14:18:49","2015","py","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,"PDF",,,,,"Yes","Yes","The data is not geocoded. Due to the level of aggregation for Asuncion, geo-referencing the information is not a simple task. For the rest of the country, I was unable to find official admin boundaries that would allow an attribute join. ","Link to download de data set: (2 parts)
Asuncion (Capital):
https://www.correoparaguayo.gov.py/documents/10179/11670/Codigo+Capital/0f517dcf-f167-4ace-aea1-b631343580c0
Rest of the country:
https://www.correoparaguayo.gov.py/documents/10179/11670/Codigo+Localidades/dc3c3b3f-580e-455b-b458-f55da409d309
The data is complete in the sense that it contains the list of zip codes for the country. Howerver, there is no coordinates or georeferenced data related to each zip code and therefore is does no comply with the definition of the location dataset (ZIP+GEO)
The list of zipcodes is available in PDF.
DIRECCION NACIONAL DE CORREOS DEL PARAGUAY (DINACOPA)
Address: 25 de Mayo esq. Yegros
Phone: (595 21) 498-112/16
ZIP CODE 1301
Open data law 5189:
https://www.correoparaguayo.gov.py/web/guest/transparencia-ley-5.189","Yes","No","Juan Pane","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"d644e03c-481f-4dae-9d7b-7538cafa4770","global","2015-10-08T07:57:14","2015","cn","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://106.37.208.233:20035",,,,"National-wide Air pollutant emission","China National Environment Monitoring Center","Yes","Yes","checked
","The China National Environment Monitoring Center is responsible for gathering and publishing the national-wide air pollutant emission data. Currently All major cities have own monitoring sites and the data are collected and published by the center. Data collected include:
Particulate matter (PM) Levels
Sulphur oxides (SOx)
Nitrogen oxides (NOx)
Carbon monoxide (CO)
The data is updated several times per day. No VOC data is available though. ","Yes","No","OKFN CN","yar michl","45"
"9186ac87-f01b-4832-99c1-2ca1436db553","global","2015-08-31T04:17:20","2015","au","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Yes","No",,"Yes",,"shapefiles, tab",,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","Data aggregated by [PSMA](https://www.psma.com.au/) on behalf of the state, territory and Australian governments. PSMA sells the data through a number of [resellers](https://www.psma.com.au/data-access/find-a-reseller/).
Data is released quarterly. [Metadata](https://www.psma.com.au/cadlite-metadata-statement) and
[specifications](https://www.psma.com.au/psma/wp-content/uploads/CadLiteProductDescription.pdf) are available.
Formats of data vary by reseller. Formats other than those listed may be available.","Yes","No","Stephen Gates","Codrina Maria Ilie","35"
"f16c9d6c-c547-40a6-817d-c1d825189d16","global","2015-10-05T09:06:38","2015","fi","companies","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,"BIS Search","Finnish Patent and Registration Office and the Tax Administration","Yes","Yes","Could not find any evidence of data as detailed by submitter.","The business information system has a limited companies search feature, which can be found here: https://www.ytj.fi/english/yrityshaku.aspx?path=1704;1736;2052&kielikoodi=3
However, I have not been able to find evidence of the data (Data from the Finnish Trade Register's public notices and Data from Finnish Business Information System, in .JSON format) as specified by the submitter.","Yes","No","Jaakko Korhonen","Rebecca Sentance","5"
"470e361a-b24c-490a-909d-288ed39613f8","global","2015-09-25T13:33:31","2015","rs","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://portal.ujn.gov.rs",,,,"Portal javnih nabavki","Uprava za javne nabavke","Yes","Yes","Submission correct.",,"Yes","No","Stevan Gostojić","Georg Neumann","45"
"623891fe-afcc-49ac-9583-33f4933b84dc","global","2015-09-22T16:08:32","2015","ru","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.russianpost.ru/rp/servise/ru/home/postuslug/searchops1#resultancor","HTML, DBF, XML",,,,,"Yes","Yes","If the data has no geospatial info than it does not comply with the 2015 index requirements. Additionally, a post code search service will also not comply with the 2015 index requirements. ","A database of postcodes/zipcodes and a corresponding geospatial locations in terms of a latitude and a longitude (or similar co-ordinates in an openly published national co-ordinate system) DOES NOT EXIST You can only get a list of postcodes, no geospatial information. At the same time we now that by url https://www.russianpost.ru/rp/servise/ru/home/postuslug/searchops1#resultancor we could find a web form using that we could find postcode by address.
So we know that address data exists but it is not publicly available
Comment: No changes since 2013 year
Comment: No changes since 2014 year","Yes","No","Ivan Begtin","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"54110be3-ffba-4e3e-9d2c-2ccba1eb2141","global","2015-09-22T16:03:48","2015","ru","budget","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Russian federal budget datasets (reports, proposed budget and dictionaries)","Ministry of Finances of Russian Federation","Yes","Yes","The site https://budget.gov.ru/data/opendata does not exist anymore and I could not find other source. I have changed the submission accordingly.
","Brief Description: Russian budget data is one of most open data but a bit dispersed over a few government websites. Well prepared machine readable data available on new government webisite Budget.gov.ru right here - https://budget.gov.ru/data/opendata
This data is XML data dumped from government database as XML dumps with XSD (XML schemas) provided. Budget.gov.ru is beta-stage portal for now (November 2014) and this data is not up to date . Up to date data published as XLS on websites of Federal Treasury (https://roskazna.ru) and Ministry of Finances (https://minfin.ru) I suggest to accept this data XML but not to accept it as timely updated for now. Step by step explanation
1. Does the data exist? Yes, national level budget data available at - https://budget.gov.ru/data/opendata 2. Is data in digital form? Yes, data available via website and has digital form. 3. Publicly available? Yes, this data is publicly available. We don't need FOI request to get it. 4. Is the data available for free? Yes, this data is available for free. No payment is required. 5. Is the data available online? Yes. Data available at https://budget.gov.ru/data/opendata 6. Is the data machine readable? Yes, this data provided as XML files 7. Available in bulk? Mostly yes, you need to download a few XML files 8. Openly licensed? No, this data is not formally under open license from OpenDefinition.org 9. Is the data provided on a timely and up to date basis?
Yes, data updated monthly
Comment: Nothing changed since 2014 year
Reviewer's comment - the data is no longer available in 2015. I have changed the data accordingly. ","Yes","No","Ivan Begtin","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"f7a648a2-52a3-4d8f-917a-1bd0da4b1cf5","global","2015-10-25T13:25:17","2015","ru","spending","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission correct","According to IBP's [Open Budget Survey](https://survey.internationalbudget.org) the Russian Federation publishes the year end report. However the [Open Budget Library](https://openbudgetlibrary.org) contains a 2012 year end report which is more than 2 fiscal periods ago so the data does not seem to exist.","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","0"
"2387b64b-9a2f-4865-a572-d4a747d6b07f","global","2015-09-05T07:44:04","2015","jm","land","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.nla.gov.jm/","CSV",,,"The National Land Agency (NLA) is an Executive Agency that falls under the Ministry of Water, Land, Environment and Climate Change.","National Land Agency","Yes","Yes","ok","Based on data availability, the land ownership is found on the iMap Jamaica website: https://www.nla.gov.jm/map.asp where you search by parcel and search by street address.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Codrina Maria Ilie","70"
"355a06be-1b34-43ee-b6c1-ae5f4a0b73c5","global","2015-09-09T14:17:35","2015","ye","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://htb.gov.ye/project_accepted_sh.php",,,,"Tender Announcements and Tender Awards","High Tender Board","Yes","Yes","Submission correct.","The High Tender Board ( https://htb.gov.ye/project_accepted_sh.php ) publishes details about tender announcements and awards. The awards page shows the name of the project, the name of the winning company, the value of the contract and other dates. The tender announcement page does not currently have any announcements, it could be possible that there are no open tenders at the moment because of the crisis in Yemen, but it is also possible that the website is just not up to date.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Georg Neumann","35"
"807557e0-5b77-404f-9b66-1869e78845ce","global","2015-12-16T10:15:44","2015","sk","water","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,"Sampling and analysis of water for customers","Water Research Institute","Yes","Yes","Under the Ministry of the Environment water quality for drinking water is being collected by Water Research Institute https://www.vuvh.sk/?lid=4 And environmental water quality is being collected by the Slovak Hydrometeorological Institute (SHMI). https://www.shmu.sk/en/?%20page=1776","**Data was submitted by Fair Play Alliance and Jano Suchal**","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","5"
"edf49441-481d-4ea6-b20c-aeab8765a386","global","2015-12-16T10:13:58","2015","sk","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.
Data exists and seems to be digital but not made available publicly.","There is some summary information about spending on monthly basis available at https://www.rozpocet.sk/ and https://www.finance.gov.sk/ (see for example https://www.rozpocet.sk/app/homepage/rozpocetVCislach/monitoringStatnehoRozpoctu/mesacnePlnenie/2014/ and also for example https://www.finance.gov.sk/Default.aspx?CatID=9779) but those do not match the definition used by Census.
The data is still relatively recent (a couple of weeks) which indicates digital form of data.
**Data was submitted by Fair Play Alliance and Jano Suchal**
","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"63bf3d98-7bb4-4457-a9a2-ba75e012fb89","global","2015-12-16T10:13:24","2015","sk","companies","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Obchodný register SR (Company register of the Slovak Republic)","Ministerstvo Spravodlivosti Slovenskej Republiky (Ministry of Justice, SR)","Yes","Yes","It is not possible to browse through the database or access data without providing a search term, therefore the registry does not qualify for most of the criteria.","It is only possible to obtain companies data by searching for a keyword. Company names can be clicked on to view more detailed data, although addresses are not included in the database. https://www.orsr.sk/search_subjekt.asp?lan=en
**Data was submitted by Fair Play Alliance and Jano Suchal**","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","15"
"4a31a831-5f60-4052-8512-e9b22ab9c7ac","global","2015-12-16T10:11:56","2015","sk","weather","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","No","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.shmu.sk",,,,,"Slovak Hydrometeorological Institute; shmu@shmu.sk","Yes","Yes","
Changed 'available online' to a yes based on the link provided in the comments.
Otherwise, this submission is accepted as the dataset contains 5+ days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.","Most of the data is available online. The only item from the required minimum that is not publicly available is historical data.
The data is available at https://www.shmu.sk/ only in web view. It is not available in bulk, it is not machine-readable and it is copyrighted, so it is not openly licensed. The topic of copyright protection of meteorological data was publicly discussed for a short while in the past, but the Hydrometeorological Institute fought for the right to continue producing and publishing the data as copyrighted material.
**Data was submitted by Fair Play Alliance and Jano Suchal**","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","25"
"19dbe3b0-193f-473d-996c-ac8a99d8d5ae","global","2015-12-16T10:10:54","2015","sk","land","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Unsure","No",,"Yes","https://www.katasterportal.sk/kapor/",,,,,"Úrad geodézie, kartografie a katastra (https://www.skgeodesy.sk/sk/)","Yes","Yes","When this review was made: ""Cadastral portal is not accessible by reason of data update preparation!","Cadastral data is free for non-commercial usage. Bulk data & commercial usage is only possible after paying fees and under strict licence.
**Data was submitted by Fair Play Alliance and Jano Suchal**","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","30"
"627c4dda-f04c-470a-9ad4-911090fe22c7","global","2015-12-16T10:02:08","2015","sk","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www2.uvo.gov.sk/evestnik",,,,"Public Procurement Bulletin","Office for Public Procurement; info@uvo.gov.sk","Yes","Yes","Submission correct.","The data is available since 2009. It is updated daily and is quite detailed. It is not structured, machine-readable, nor published in bulk or licensed under an open license, though.
The data can be scraped and is being scraped and re-published in structured format by several NGOs.
Office for Public Procurement often changes the structure of the Bulletin, which disables scrapers. A couple of weeks ago the whole Bulletin even moved to a new URL (the original URl was identical tu the current one, except it started with ""www"" not ""www2""). The change made all links to individual data from the Bulletin non-functional and confused users of the data. It is possible that this is a part of a redesign of the Office website and the Bulletin will be moved back to its original location in time.
**Data was submitted by Fair Play Alliance and Jano Suchal**","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"bc3f38d7-b04c-4dfd-a498-abeb06d21c4b","global","2015-12-16T10:01:23","2015","sk","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.shmu.sk/en/?page=991",,,,"Current air quality information","Slovak hydrometeorological institute","Yes","Yes","checked i write no licensed by after i read this txt
© 2015 Slovak hydrometeorological institute All the information, texts and images contained on the https://www.shmu.sk website are intellectual property of the Slovak hydrometeorological institute (SHMÚ) and may be downloaded or copied only for personal use. Appropriate acknowledgement of the SHMÚ is required if material is re-published in any format. SHMÚ disclaims responsibility for quality of meteorological and hydrological information from any other source than SHMÚ.","**Data was submitted by Fair Play Alliance and Jano Suchal**","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"ec9af61b-fdd1-4b56-a9c8-8b09459fa833","global","2015-12-16T10:00:03","2015","sk","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://jaspi.justice.gov.sk/",,,,,"Ministerstvo Spravodlivosti SR (Ministry of Justice of the Slovak Republic); informacie211@justice.sk","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Legally binding is only paper version of statute. Data can be easily scraped from web page. There is a copyright notice so ""no"" is filled for open license.
**Data was submitted by Fair Play Alliance and Jano Suchal**","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"9d98611f-f870-4d12-8f2b-78f8a1a7c498","global","2015-12-16T09:52:53","2015","sk","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://slovak.statistics.sk/",,,,,"Statistical office of the Slovak Republic; info@statistics.sk","Yes","Yes","The data is regularly updated in html","There is no formal license attached to data, only copyright assertion at the bottom of the page. So at least free access is assumed (sort of improvement over 2013), while openly licensed is filled as ""no"".
Not all data is consistently availabe this way but at least those few stats mentioned in Census definition are, thus we can fill ""yes"" for ""is it accessible online"" (again, sort of improvement over 2013).
[Population][1] up to 2014.
[Unemployment][2] (quarterly up to 2015)
[GDP][3]
[1]: https://statdat.statistics.sk/cognosext/cgi-bin/cognos.cgi?b_action=cognosViewer&ui.action=run&ui.object=storeID(%22i700C5B7ABED1414B8B23B4A69E91D146%22)&ui.name=Population%20(absolute%20data)%20%5Bom0001rs%5D&run.outputFormat=&run.prompt=true&cv.header=false&ui.backURL=%2Fcognosext%2Fcps4%2Fportlets%2Fcommon%2Fclose.html&run.outputLocale=en
[2]: https://statdat.statistics.sk/cognosext/cgi-bin/cognos.cgi?b_action=cognosViewer&ui.action=run&ui.object=storeID(%22iB193D1C87387465B954B10BE9F45111D%22)&ui.name=Employed%20by%20the%20Labour%20Force%20Sample%20Survey%20%5Bpr0002qs%5D&run.outputFormat=&run.prompt=true&cv.header=false&ui.backURL=%2Fcognosext%2Fcps4%2Fportlets%2Fcommon%2Fclose.html&run.outputLocale=en
[3]: https://statdat.statistics.sk/cognosext/cgi-bin/cognos.cgi?b_action=cognosViewer&ui.action=run&ui.object=storeID(%22iA188D5A85FEF4EA9B48BC102C7C66758%22)&ui.name=Quarterly%20GDP%20data%20for%202013%20at%20curent%20prices%20%5Bnu0002qs%5D&run.outputFormat=&run.prompt=true&cv.header=false&ui.backURL=%2Fcognosext%2Fcps4%2Fportlets%2Fcommon%2Fclose.html&run.outputLocale=en
**Data was submitted by Fair Play Alliance and Jano Suchal**","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"0aa86b8d-bcea-400e-a665-68fdc0afbe56","global","2015-12-16T09:51:34","2015","sk","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Unsure","https://zbgis.skgeodesy.sk/tkgis/default.aspx",,,,,"Geodetický a kartografický ústav Bratislava","Yes","Yes","My review reached similar conclusions.","Maps are available via interactive portal without means to export data for the general public (other than printing in PDF). Maps are available in resolutions up to 1:2000 .
There is a copyright notice at the bottom of the page, apart from that, no other license is available specifically for the data - so ""No"" is indicated as an answer in this regard.
The data, though, should be available for download, even in bulk, machine/readable formats, for a fee. We couldn't test this functionality, therefore we couldn't specify the formats of the data and stated ""Unsure"" in the question about machine-readability.
According to our knowledge, the data for the whole of Slovakia is updated approximately once in 3 years. The map seems to be up-to-date at the moment, but no information about last updates is provided, so ""Unsure"" is indicated as an answer for the last question.
**Data was submitted by Fair Play Alliance and Jano Suchal**","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"3b0a1f61-0f7e-4458-ac29-1039e83824fd","global","2015-12-16T09:50:22","2015","sk","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://volby.statistics.sk/","CSV",,,"Volby a referendum - Election (national, municipal, EU) and referendum data for all elections since 1990.","Statistical Office of the Slovak Republic; info@statistics.sk","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","All election and refernedum results are available at https://volby.statistics.sk/ The dataset meets all criteria, the only drawback being licensing - as usually in Slovakia, no license is given.
**Data was submitted by Fair Play Alliance and Jano Suchal**","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"bc49003c-f10a-4ae0-b136-6d7c85eaa982","global","2015-12-16T09:46:58","2015","sk","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.rozpocet.sk/","Excel",,,,"Ministerstvo financií Slovenskej republiky (Ministry of Finance, Slovak Republic); info@mfsr.sk","Yes","Yes","I have checked the data and it is correct.","Data is available in a form of ""interactive portal"". XLS export is available for most data. License is not clearly stated and there is copyright notice in the footer of the web page so ""no"" is filled.
**Data was submitted by Fair Play Alliance and Jano Suchal**","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"5f9b30c7-a50f-47cd-be65-6bf2a37d3842","global","2014-10-27T12:24:14","2014","nz","postcodes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Yes","Yes",,"Yes",,"ESRI Shapefile,MapInfo TAB",,,,,"Yes","Yes","Not publically available or online (must email and pay)","Postcode data is managed by NZ Post, a state-owned enterprise, with a commercial model. The Postcode Network File is $400-$2100/year depending on use and the license restricts reuse. ","Yes","No","Mark Heseltine","Alex Sadleir","45"
"76c56e3b-355e-4e1d-a0e3-00e1445d2249","global","2015-09-25T16:49:55","2015","be","companies","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Company register","KBO","Yes","Yes","I could not find evidence of the data as described by the submitter, only the free search feature which is very restrictive.","**Reviewer's comment**: It appears that it is only possible to obtain companies data by inputting a search term of 9 or 10 characters into this free search engine: https://kbopub.economie.fgov.be/kbopub/zoeknummerform.html There is no other way to freely browse or obtain the data. I have been unable to find evidence of the data as described by the submitter below.
**Submitter's comment:**
There are three ways to obtain this data.
One is as an Open Data CSV file that is updated monthly and available for free after registration, in this dataset however you can only see the publicly available information about the companies.
There is also a daily updated webservice where users pay 50 euro per 2000 queries.
And there is a full xml catalogue, daily updated with more up-to-date information on the companies (current and stopped). For this you pay a license of 75000 euro per year.
As long as the basic way to obtain data is not open without needing to register, we cannot see this as open data under the open definition as defined on https://opendefinition.org/.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Rebecca Sentance","15"
"5aed16e1-2a74-4b69-9ecb-9d2bd570f82e","global","2015-09-08T19:21:45","2015","tn","companies","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Changed the dataset's existence to ""unsure"" based on the existence of some qualifying data, but not enough to satisfy the requirements of the Index.","We checked in September 8, and it stated last update was in August 31. So it is updated. In the Industrial Business Directory is contains only companies with more than 10 employees. Total registered is 5,636, as for the Directory Service companies the total registered is 3,117. Names of companies and addresses are listed, but no unique identifier seem to exist, only company legal names (Dénomination) and Raison Sociale. We are not sure these are all the companies in Tunisia, especially that it is stated in their FAQ that ""To be included in the directory of industrial companies, which is available free of charge to operating industrial enterprises operating in Tunisia and employing ten people or more, contact the Regional Directorate of the API implementation that covers your region"". Which means only companies who contact them are being listed.
Last year's comment below:
No information about license, therefore the data is considered non-open.
Industry: https://www.tunisieindustrie.nat.tn/fr/dbi.asp
Services : https://www.tunisieindustrie.nat.tn/fr/dbs.asp ","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"f68284b6-4096-47ca-a0ea-f8efe15b5024","global","2015-10-06T11:27:12","2015","nl","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.verkiezingsuitslagen.nl/","CSV",,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission does not meet the definition. As the submission says, data is only available at the level of municipalities of up to 800.000 people.
","2014 entry:
The data on elections is not open to the public under EML standard. If this data is open it would enable new applications and insights that have a positive impact on our democracy. At this moment, very little information is available about the elections: On the website of the Election Council the results appear only five weeks after the elections in its database. In this database, only the results on the municipal level is shown, not at the level of polling stations. Although the unofficial results of the local elections were announced one day after the elections (March 20, 2014), one is referred to the websites of local governments for the results. On March 28, 2014 when the last recounts were done, one is still referred to the websites of local governments. On election night, news is followed by calls that are made by news agencies to municipalities. These are not actual open data of the actual results. A misinterpretation of results or an error in the news chain could cause wrong information being spread.
https://openstate.eu/2014/05/elections-data-in-the-netherlands-do-our-votes-count/
Update 2015: Data still not openly available - updated some questions from 'unsure' to 'no' based on what's available via https://www.verkiezingsuitslagen.nl/","Yes","No","Sander van der Waal","Kamil Gregor","0"
"71d8fc6d-0f6b-4468-bfd3-baec3b51b5b0","global","2015-12-08T08:53:41","2015","gb","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.gov.uk/contracts-finder","XML, CSV","https://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open-government-licence/version/2/",,"Contracts Finder","Government Digital Service (Cabinet Office)","Yes","Yes","Data is not available in bulk. Data is machine readable and up-to-date. ","In February 2015 the Cabinet Office launched a new version of [Contracts Finder][1] as a beta service. This service provides a search facility for public sector procurement contracts in England. Similar services are available for Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland (though the NI service requires registration).
Cabinet Office has separately made available a [static archive of data from the earlier version of Contracts Finder][2], covering the period from February 2011 to February 2015.
Information posted to Contracts Finder (past and present) is generally re-usable under the Open Government Licence but some contract records contain exceptions and are therefore non-open.
[1]: https://www.gov.uk/contracts-finder
[2]: https://data.gov.uk/data/contracts-finder-archive/","Yes","Yes","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","90"
"e3720a48-02f9-4fbc-a082-c3ce1720bb5d","global","2015-11-23T21:50:33","2015","co","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://sig.anla.gov.co:8083/",,,,"Sistema de Información Ambiental Colombiano-SIAC","Instituto de Hidrología, Meteorología y Estudios Ambientales-IDEAM, Contacto: Leonardo Cárdenas, jefe de sistemas. Contacto: lcardenas@ideam.gov.co","Yes","Yes","The water quality data does exist per resource with the right parameters. However, the system is not easy to use. It does not allow download of the data in bulk of machine readable format, and it is not openly licensed. https://www.siac.gov.co/contenido/contenido.aspx?catID=48&conID=47","Se incluye el visor con el sistema de información ambiental en Colombia-SIAC. En la url https://sig.anla.gov.co:8083/resources/Manuales/InformacionSIAC.pdf podrá encontrar el contenido del SIAC, con datos de calidad del agua.
Por otra parte, podrá encontrar en las siguientes url más información con el estado del agua en Colombia:
https://www.siac.gov.co/contenido/contenido.aspx?catID=860&conID=1373
https://www.siac.gov.co/contenido/contenido.aspx?catID=815&conID=1374
https://www.siac.gov.co/contenido/contenido.aspx?catID=815&conID=1375
","Yes","No","Juan Felipe Devia Rodriguez","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"ca0e0a62-4de9-422e-ac08-885267ec7b0a","global","2015-09-17T12:54:25","2015","bg","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://inspire.cadastre.bg/index.php","json",,,,,"Yes","Yes","Bulgaria has a post code system https://inspire.cadastre.bg/index.php. Admin boundaries file is only accepted for those countries that don't have a post code system.
","Administrative boundaries on all levels including land parcels are available freely. This includes landmarks like springs, etc. The property level information exists only for about 30% of the country.
","Yes","No","Boyan Yurukov","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"2b7fa27f-c5af-4656-892f-bcda58f2761d","global","2015-09-24T18:48:20","2015","dk","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.statbank.dk/statbank5a/SelectTable/Omrade0.asp?SubjectCode=02&ShowNews=OFF&PLanguage=1","PC-AXIS (*.px), Excel (*.xlsx), Excel (*.xls), DBase (*.dbf), DBase in rows (*.dbf), SAS program (*.sas), Semicolon sep. (*.csv), Tab. sep. (*.csv), Comma sep. (*.csv), Matrix (*.csv), Text with layout (*.txt), Text matrix (*.txt), Time series (*.tsd), Time series batch (*.asb)","https://www.dst.dk/da/omds/omweb.aspx",,,"Statistics Denmark","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","First data on candidates etc. is available before election. During the election night results are made public with an estimated ten minutes delay, but not on the lowest geographical level. Full results are available when officially checked the day after the election. Historical data and data from other local elections, regional elections and referendums are available in the same manner.","Yes","Yes","Niels Erik Kaaber Rasmussen","Kamil Gregor","100"
"538118ac-2a3d-431f-aeff-7f895eacdf5a","global","2015-10-02T18:36:42","2015","se","procurement","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Information about the procurement process is available at https://www.konkurrensverket.se and at https://www.upphandlingsmyndigheten.se since September 1, but I can find information on tenders. ",,"Yes","No","Asmen Gül","Georg Neumann","0"
"6ab505fb-0e69-436b-945d-594977a8d2f7","global","2015-10-13T17:16:03","2015","co","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.pronosticosyalertas.gov.co/pronosticos",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Data exist here - https://www.pronosticosyalertas.gov.co/pronosticos but do only contains precipitation and temperature for 3 days, therefore, it does not mean the minimum criteria of weather data. ","Puede consultar más información sobre PRONÓSTICOS Y ALERTAS, dando click en los siguientes temas, ubicados en el portal principal:
Pronósticos
Alertas
Imágenes Satelitales
Modelos de Pronóstico Meteorológico
Información diaria de precipitación y temperatura de los principales aeropuertos del país
Por otra parte, se cuenta también con boletines e informes técnicos, así como de mapas y estimación satelital.
Reviewer's note - Data is only available for three days and does not meet the criteria. ","Yes","No","Juan Felipe Devia Rodriguez","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"4bcd09be-8aca-4829-a826-38d8e9b28e43","global","2015-11-23T13:46:41","2015","no","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.met.no/?module=Articles;action=Article.publicShow;ID=620","XML","https://om.yr.no/info/datapolicy/",,"Met.no provides free weather data through APIs and services. Forecasts are also available via yr.no - a joint service with NRK - the norwegian national brodcasting corportation (https://www.nrk.no/)","Norwegian Meteorological Institute (met.no)","Yes","Yes","Data is available in bulk. Submission accepted. ","Qa review-
The license indicates that there is data in a machine readable format. I found the data in XML format and changed the submission.
Submission 2015-11-23:
- Changed publisher to the meteorological institute, in stead of yr.no, which re-use their data.
- Changed bulk-download from ""Unsure"" to ""Yes"".
- Changed link to data to point to the Norwegian Meteorological Institute's web page about open data. From that page, there's links to api.met.no and yr.no for weather forecasts and to other services for bulk-downloads and historical data.
See previous comment for more details:
https://global.census.okfn.org/submission/b136b239-d962-437f-9bb9-69de95a2296a#comments","Yes","Yes","Bergheimivar L","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"3c9f0640-0e5f-4c2c-9136-a5ad182708c7","global","2015-11-25T11:06:23","2015","je","procurement","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Data does exist and is in digital form, but the award data is not published. Therefore, it is not publicly available, ","The Jersey government through its Corporate Procurement Services, States of Jersey Treasury Department publishes information about [current tender opportunities][1] worth more than £100,000, including an archive of opportunities, but does not publish information about awarded tenders.
[1]: https://www.channelislandtenders.com/procontract/channelislands/supplier.nsf/frm_planner_search_results?OpenForm&contains=&cats=&order_by=DATE&all_opps=&org_id=ALL
There is a strict confidentiality policy in place, so one party accessing the tender documents may not share them with another apart from on a need-to-know basis.
Jersey and Guernsey, which are two different jurisdictions but are only 20 miles apart, use a shared service (Channel Island Tenders) for open tendering. Therefore the assessment of JE and GG should be identical. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"25daa150-3a51-4ab0-986b-1aab6ae9a7d1","global","2015-11-25T11:04:43","2015","gg","procurement","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Channel Island Tenders","Corporate Procurement Services, States of Guernsey Treasury and Resources Department treasury@gov.gg","Yes","Yes","Data exist and digital, but award data is not published. Therefore, the reviewer gave points for the existence and digitization of the data only. ","The Guernsey government through its Corporate Procurement Services, States of Guernsey Treasury and Resources Department publishes information about [current tender opportunities][1], but does not provide an archive of opportunities and does not publish information about awarded tenders.
[1]: https://www.channelislandtenders.com/procontract/channelislands/supplier.nsf/frm_planner_search_results?OpenForm&contains=&cats=&order_by=DATE&all_opps=&org_id=ALL","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"e0e6e87a-982e-4056-951e-d04c66752cf9","global","2015-11-25T10:49:20","2015","ca","elections","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,,"Elections Canada","Yes","Yes","Data is not in poll station level. Change it to exist but not publish. ","2013- 2014 - Elections Canada is the elections authority at a national level. Its terms and conditions prohibit commercial reproduction of materials on its website (https://www.elections.ca/content.aspx?section=ele&document=index&lang=e). However, data.gc.ca publishes many of the same materials under an open license. Elections are also held in the provinces and territories as well as municipalities. Each jurisdiction would need to be contacted to assess the degree of openess. Regarding the conflicting licences we have sent a question to the respective authorities but we have assessed that data is available under an open licence.
Canada does count and report results in [poll station level][1], but it publish and display the results in an [aggregated district level.][2]
Therefore, the data exists and is digital, it just not publicly available.
[1]: https://www.elections.ca/enr/help/help_notices_e.htm#polls
[2]: https://enr.elections.ca/ElectoralDistricts.aspx?lang=e","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","20"
"9ea5bcd3-ea50-4c9d-a72d-0832e4bcb2da","global","2015-11-23T16:40:50","2015","ua","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://tender.me.gov.ua/EDZFrontOffice/menu/en/",,,,"Ukrainian Public Procurements","Zovnishtorgvydav Ukrainy","Yes","Yes","Changed according to the thematic reviewer second review. ","In addition to the website we assessed here, [Prozorro][1], an independent web application that is actively supported and scaled up by the government, is being developed to increase the level of transparency of procurement. Through ProZorro all tender and award data is accessible, machine-readable, & openly licensed.
[1]: https://bi.prozorro.org","Yes","No","Georg Neumann","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"6f2a143d-a2fe-4bd0-a1a8-27e36c2f2e7e","global","2015-11-23T16:45:49","2015","sn","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.marchespublics.sn/index.php?option=com_attribution&task=listeavisattribution&Itemid=203",,,,"Contract awards","Central Directorate of Public Procurement","Yes","Yes","Changed according to the reviewer second review. See comments above. ","The procurement tenders are made available for public on a dedicated website. User can query and download data for free. Bulk download is only available as PDF. ","Yes","No","Georg Neumann","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"4cd88711-28c1-43a4-ab33-5cb9d9b3c1fa","global","2015-11-25T10:15:02","2015","ca","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Canada Lands Survey System - Digital Cadastral Data","GeoGratis - Natural Resources Canada","Yes","Yes","We were not able to identify land parcel information to comply to the index requirements (national coverage, land borders, land size).","Canada as a federation has divisions of powers and distributed responsibility over lands across provinces and territories. Lands is a provincial responsibility however there are federal land responsibilities. Cadastre data are provided for some provinces and territories via GeoGratis. The text below provides additional information and is from the following URL https://clss.nrcan.gc.ca/cadastraldata-donneescadastrales-eng.php
""Canada Lands Digital Cadastral Data provides the cadastral parcel framework for specified Canada Lands. This cadastral line and parcel structured vector data is designed and suited for Geographic Information Systems (GIS) application.
By using this data, it is important to understand and accept that the data is not to be used for defining boundaries. Administrative decisions should be based on legal documents and legal survey plans.
The datasets are updated when new survey plans are recorded in the Canada Lands Survey Records (CLSR). Frequent visits to this site are recommended.
The links below will guide you to the FTP locations where you can freely download our cadastral datasets. Please contact the regional representative for questions pertaining to the data.
Canada Map
Alberta
British Columbia
Manitoba
New Brunswick
Newfoundland and Labrador
Northwest Territories
Nova Scotia
Nunavut
Ontario
Prince Edward Island
Quebec
Saskatchewan
Yukon""","Yes","No","Codrina Maria Ilie","Codrina Maria Ilie","10"
"9ecae855-0c36-4969-b85d-80af75dae585","global","2015-11-04T16:56:17","2015","fr","postcodes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://adresse.data.gouv.fr/download/","CSV","https://opendatacommons.org/licenses/odbl/1-0/",,"BAN National address database (version ODBL)","IGN & La Poste & OSM France","Yes","Yes","Reviewing the location theme for France was not an easy task due to the intricate situation created by the existence of 2 official datasets, one belonging to the National Post and one created in collaboration with other gov departments and with OpenStreetMap France. One significant difference that we need to point out to is the different licensing of the 2: the dataset build in collaboration with OSM has a ODbL license, and the other one has a specific license. The latter is a restrictive proprietary license (https://adresse.data.gouv.fr/static/pdf/BAN%20Licence%20de%20repartage.pdf). An analysis made by the civil society can be found here (https://www.savoirscom1.info/2015/04/ouverture-de-la-base-dadresses-nationale-ban-la-fete-gachee-par-une-licence-piege/).
It clearly shows a situation that has the potential to generate a multitude of legal, but not only, issues that could significantly hider the access to the reuse of this information.
The index has been constructed taking into account the various issues that arise from the mentioned situation, from license, to quality of data, from coverage to the entities and their official role in building this dataset.
We would also like to mention that we recognize the high quality of the dataset built in collaboration with OpenStreetMap and that we applaud this open-mindedness. However, for this wonderful initiative to be truly productive and without a doubt a pillar in the base data of France, we consider that significant steps must be made in the direction of dissolving this complicated situation. ","NEW COMMENT FROM CMFG (ETALAB) :
The national address database (BAN) fulfills the requirements to a larger extent as it gives coordinates for all addresses including their zipcodes. It exists in two versions of the base and the first one is the one that is taken into account in this submission (and not in the previous one). We believe this BAN ODBL version can be accepted as an official source because:
- A link to the ODBL version of the BAN, distributed by OSM France, is provided on an official & governmental website: https://adresse.data.gouv.fr/download/ (second link at the bottom of the page) according to the terms of the official BAN convention signed between IGN, La Poste, Etalab and OSM France https://openstreetmap.fr/f/Convention%20BAN%2015%20avril%202015%20SCAN%20SIGNE.pdf
- the data have the same source than the second version mentionned in the previous comment and is formated at and by Etalab (Prime Minister office for open data and open gov)
PREVIOUS COMMENT FROM REGARDS CITOYENS :
The previously registered ""Base officielle des codes postaux"" by La Poste does not match the new requirements as it only provides openly an association of zipcodes with ciies.
Some cities have multiple zipcodes, so even by associating the data with the opened administrative borders database GEOFLA , we would not be able to get coordinates corresponding to zipcodes.
Although another database could fulfill the requirements to a larger extant : the national address database BAN that gives coordinates for all addresses including their zipcodes. Unfortunately it exists under two different versions:
- one fully opendata provided by OpenStretMap France which is not accepted as a a relevant source here, so we reviewed the following official on
- one free of charge but under a non OpenDefinition compliant license by the national geographic institute IGN and the postal service La Poste
The latter dataset named ""Base Adresse Nationale"" requires registration for direct download and is supplied after form registration under a closed license (see https://www.savoirscom1.info/2015/04/ouverture-de-la-base-dadresses-nationale-ban-la-fete-gachee-par-une-licence-piege/ for a complete legal analysis).
","Yes","No","Claire-Marie Foulquier-Gazagnes","Codrina Maria Ilie","65"
"b86a0d83-c99a-411d-a4c8-5c7e94e2aa7b","global","2015-10-30T12:08:25","2015","gb","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.gov.uk/dataset/metoffice_uklocs3hr_fc","XML, JSON","https://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open-government-licence/version/3/",,"UK 3-hourly site-specific forecast","UK Met Office","Yes","Yes","I altered this submission based on the comments below. This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 5+ days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation, as well as historical data back to 2011.
","Site specific forecasts for over 5,000 sites in the UK, including airports, major landmarks and beaches.
Each site has the following [weather forecast data][1] available for it in 3-hourly intervals out to five days:
- Wind direction (16 point compass)
- Wind speed (mph)
- Screen temperature (degrees Celsius)
- Weather Type (weather ID)
- Visibility (code)
- Screen relative humidity (%)
- Wind gust (mph)
- Feels like temperature (degrees Celsius)
- UV Index (code)
- Precipitation Probability (%)
Met Office provides a restricted API to the forecast data. [restrictions][2] registration and used under [licence][3]. Data is provided in XML and JSON. Data is not available for bulk download.
HOWEVER the Cabinet Office provides an API to all of the data, with unlimited access: [API on Azure Marketplace][5]. The only requirement is that you register, which is reasonable when the Met Office data is about 20GB per day. Since there is no size restriction with this API, beyond technical constraints, you can easily download what you want, so that should be considered easy bulk access.
Some [historic data][4] is available for download but other historic data must be purchased.
[1]: https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/datapoint/product/uk-3hourly-site-specific-forecast
[2]: https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/about-us/legal/datapoint-registration
[3]: https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/about-us/legal/tandc
[4]: https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/public/weather/climate-historic/#?tab=climateHistoric
[5]: https://datamarket.azure.com/dataset/datagovuk/metofficeweatheropendata","Yes","Yes","David Read","Neal Bastek","100"
"95ea069c-a07d-4eb7-b40a-3010f2041747","global","2015-11-10T19:34:48","2015","mx","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Catastro","INEGI","Yes","Yes","One essential condition for the land information dataset is national coverage and the given links do not provide that.","Cadaster data available in INEGI is free, publicly available and online. All in accordance to the Index's definitions and methodology.
Added to the above, parcel information, common use lands, communal polygons, and polygons of land destined to housing are available as open data, with a free license in: https://busca.datos.gob.mx/#/instituciones/ran
","Yes","No","Enrique Zapata","Codrina Maria Ilie","10"
"f837984d-bf8e-461d-a91b-8d6617d39fa6","global","2015-11-23T16:50:49","2015","es","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://centrodedescargas.cnig.es/CentroDescargas/buscar.do","shapefiles",,,"Base Topográfica Nacional (the topographic national database) is offered at the scales 1:50.000, 1:100.000 and 1:200.000.","Instituto Geográfico Nacional","Yes","Yes","There is a survey that users need to fill in before downloading the data. However, it grants the data automatically and does not request for personal information. The data is therefore available to the public and free. ","Files can be downloaded for specific provinces or for Spain as a whole. Downloads require users to register. Also, users need to accept terms of license that exclude commercial use and are not compliant with open licenses: https://www2.ign.es/siane/Principal.do
WMS/WMF service for a scale of 1:5.000 is provided here: https://www.iderioja.larioja.org/municipios/servicios_ogc_es.html. Also a commercial is being maintained, called the Centro Nacional de Información Geográfica (https://www.cnig.es/) where users can purchase PDF maps and download is provided for one sheet/file at a time (not in bulk). On the open data catalogue the topographic database at a scale 1:100.000 is available here (https://datos.gob.es/catalogo/base-topografica-nacional-1100000-0). Download of shapefiles is available in bulk, last update in July 2015 (07-13-2015).
","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"c8a63f35-d547-462b-b2a4-5a3647bbc402","global","2015-11-23T15:59:21","2015","es","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://datos.gob.es/catalogo/air","CSV","https://datos.gob.es/?q=aviso-legal",,"Registro Estatal de Emisiones y Fuentes Contaminantes","Ministerio de Agricultura, Alimentación y Medioambiente","Yes","Yes","Data is available under open data license through the national portal. ","its seem that Spain Autonomous
communities have air Air Monitoring system.also the data can been fond in website Catalog of Public Information
All licenses are identical or similar than CC-by
","Yes","Yes","datosgob .","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"79fed300-67d5-473f-8b06-fccca571a70d","global","2015-11-23T19:56:05","2015","no","water","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Vannverk - inntakspunkt_analyse","Mattilsynet / Norwegian Food Safety Authority","Yes","Yes","Data is not available by source. ","The data is not available now. However, the data will be made available, open and licenced, with all the criteria present in the dataset, later in 2015. ","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","5"
"edae80cf-9175-4b69-a62b-9062e854f2d6","global","2015-11-20T20:46:18","2015","tz","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://tender.ppra.go.tz",,,,"Contract Awards","Public Procurement Regulatory Authority (PPRA) , ceo@ppra.go.tz","Yes","Yes","Changed according to the reviewer's latest submission ","The data is available though, it doesn't conform to open standards. Also, information on award value is not always available. ","Yes","No","Georg Neumann","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"62c7446d-3527-4ac7-b655-fb944469a9dc","global","2015-11-23T16:44:47","2015","cz","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.isvz.cz/ISVZ/Podpora/ISVZ_open_data_vz.aspx","XLS, XML, CSV",,,"Description of the data provided by ministry: https://www.isvz.cz/ISVZ/MetodickaPodpora/Napovedaopendata.pdf","Ministry of Regional Development","Yes","Yes","This submission was reviewed again and the bulk criteria was changed ","Historic machine-readable data is available as a yearly summary for 2012- 2014 but the frequency is insufficient to qualify as bulk download. The license or terms of use of the data is not specified. Current awards are available on the [Journal Procurement][1].
[1]: https://www.vestnikverejnychzakazek.cz/","Yes","No","Georg Neumann","Mor Rubinstein","60"
"6a755a27-2af0-4d99-b563-699377225c37","global","2015-11-23T16:36:20","2015","fr","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.data.gouv.fr/fr/datasets/boamp/","XML","https://www.etalab.gouv.fr/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/Licence_Ouverte.pdf",,"Annonces publiées au Bulletin officiel des annonces de marchés publics (BOAMP)","DILA, Service du Premier Ministre","Yes","Yes","After further examination, the reviewer and the submitter decided that the dataset does not meet the requirements of bulk download. We emphasis that this measurement looks only at data openness, and there is still work to be done about the quality and the completeness of the data. ","Procurements data (both tenders and awarded contracts) is available as open data. However there are challenges with the data:
- Tenders data fit nearly perfectly since recently the requirements, regularily published by DILA as the BOAMP database under the Open Licence as lots of [XML files][1]. The bulk criteria does not apply to this dataset.
- Awards data only provides procurement from a portion of the central governmental entities (see [here][2] and [here][3]), estimated to represent only 40 to 60% of the global amount awarded each year. This dataset is only updated yearly and has been published on an irregular basis and inconsistent formats for the last four years making the bulk criteria not applicable to the French dataset.
The dataset on [2014 procurement tenders][4] is an extract of PLACE, the national procurement marketplace. It includes tenders name, description of the tenders and status of the buying unit, supplier name, award title, date of the notification (DAY/MONTH) city, zip code, value of the award, description of the award, if it was attributed to an SME.
[Data from 2011, 2012, 2013][5]
Data on procurement tenders by some sub-national entities (city, departments, regions) and independant administrative authorities are generally not present on data.gouv.fr but there are some, such as [CNIL][6] and the [City of Poitiers][7].
[1]: https://www.data.gouv.fr/fr/datasets/boamp/
[2]: https://www.etalab.gouv.fr/leservicedesachatsdeletatpublielalistenonexhaustivedesmarchesconclusparlesservicesdeletatetcertainsdesesoperateursaucoursdelannee2012
[3]: https://www.lesechos.fr/20/05/2015/LesEchos/21941-351-ECH_marches-publics---quand-l-etat-ne-s-applique-pas-la-rigueur.htm
[4]: https://www.data.gouv.fr/fr/datasets/liste-des-marches-publics-conclus-en-2014/
[5]: https://www.data.gouv.fr/fr/datasets/liste-des-marches-publics-conclus/
[6]: https://www.data.gouv.fr/fr/datasets/marches-publics-de-la-cnil/
[7]: https://www.data.gouv.fr/fr/datasets/citoyennete-liste-des-marches-publics-pour-poitiers/","Yes","Yes","Georg Neumann","Mor Rubinstein","90"
"32ffcbbf-6cfa-4a22-8006-14e0841d4b7d","global","2015-09-20T21:41:06","2015","es","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","No","No",,"No","https://www.msssi.gob.es/profesionales/saludPublica/saludAmbLaboral/calidadAguas/publicaciones.htm",,,,"National Information System on Drinking Water (SINAC","Ministry of Health, Social Services and Equality","Yes","Yes","The local level does make available up to date datal.
https://datos.gob.es/catalogo/calidad-de-aguas-de-consumo-de-euskadi-durante-2015
As well as real time monitoring of water quality stations at the state level for surface water.
https://www.chduero.es/Inicio/Gesti%C3%B3ndelaCuenca/Estadoycalidaddelasaguas/AguasSuperficiales/Estadodelasmasasdeaguasuperficiales/tabid/617/Default.aspx
","The Náyade project provides the dataset for Water Quality under the [National Law 1341/2007][1], but it does not matches the evaluation criteria:
* Only the ""Enterococos Intestinales"" and ""Escherichia Coli"" levels are meassured (fecal bacteries)
* There's no evidence of meassures for arsenic, fluoride levels or nitrates.
The Náyade project publish the information on a yearly basis and no evidence of re-using policy was found. The Spanish Open Data Portal offers [water quality datasets with open licensing for some regions][2].
[1]: https://nayade.msssi.es/Splayas/html/ciudadano/documentos/RD_1341-2007.pdf
[2]: https://datos.gob.es/catalogo/aguas%2520ba%25C3%25B1o?title=nayade&order=6","Yes","No","José Félix Ontañón","Nisha Thompson","20"
"c49a4906-f0f6-49b2-bd9f-e97ed15f22e7","global","2015-09-20T20:22:33","2015","es","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Ejecución presupuestaria del sector público estatal","Ministerio de Hacienda y Administraciones Públicas","Yes","Yes","Submission is correct","The IGAE website offers a [monthly updated Government Spending][1] excel file for 2015 Government Budget (actual), but this dataset doesn't matches the following evaluation criteria:
* No Individual record of transactions, just aggregated figures.
* Therefore, no date of the transactions.
That's why we marked a '*No*' on the ""*Publicly available*"" question.
The same organization is offering a more detailed spending excel file for the [2014 spending][2].
[1]: https://www.igae.pap.minhap.gob.es/sitios/igae/es-ES/EjecucionPresupuestaria/Paginas/EjecucionPresupuestaria.aspx
[2]: https://www.igae.pap.minhap.gob.es/sitios/igae/es-ES/EjecucionPresupuestaria/Paginas/ialiquidacionestado.aspx","Yes","No","José Félix Ontañón","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"12e36294-49af-42be-8875-4ec529e3fa4f","global","2015-11-23T11:01:08","2015","gb","water","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,"Drinking Water Inspectorate ","Yes","Yes","Since the data is not published at source level we dont accept the current site of the UK water information. Data is not publicly available or open."," Drinking Water Inspectorate (DWI) collects data from private companies in [this link][1]. It contains the following aggregated information:
- The Drinking Water Inspectorate Annual Report 2014 provides an overview of the quality of public and private water supplies in England and Wales.
- Regional reports covering the four regions of England and additionally Wales and summarising the testing and results of water quality tests, events and technical audit activity in the region. As you are aware there are examples of data for parts of the country available directly from the relevant water companies
- Private water supplies - Presented as separate reports for England and Wales and publishing numbers and types of supplies, a summary of monitoring results and case studies.
- Company data look up tables – data on each of the 27 private water companies
- Water Company Statistics
- Drinking Water Quality Events
- Prosecutions and Cautions
Data is not in weekly reports level, parameters are not from source level and is not in open formats.
[1]: https://www.dwi.gov.uk/about/annual-report/2014/index.html","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Nisha Thompson","10"
"f3ca7d0a-8275-41d1-8ec4-d0e9c7da1491","global","2015-11-21T12:52:20","2015","gb","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.legislation.gov.uk/","XML, XHTML, HTML 5, PDF","https://www.legislation.gov.uk/",,"Legislation.gov.uk","National Archives","Yes","Yes","Information correct. Changed description for 2015. ","[Legislation.gov.uk][1] is a comprehensive public database of UK legislation maintained online by The National Archives, an executive agency of the Department for Culture, Media and Sport. The information is re-usable under the UK's Open Government Licence.
Machine-readable open data from Legislation.gov.uk is available through an [API][2] and as [bulk downloads][3]. PDF copies of legislation are also available in bulk.
[1]: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/
[2]: https://www.legislation.gov.uk/developer
[3]: https://leggovuk.s3-website-eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/texts/index.htm","Yes","Yes","Owen Boswarva","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"54b629a8-9a0e-473b-8404-5a7ce1edc924","global","2015-09-19T09:30:23","2015","il","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://he.mot.gov.il/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&iotype=w&id=2244:pub-trn-gtfs&catid=167:pub-trn-dev-info&Itemid=304&lang_ovrrde=ENG","GTFS - General Transit Feed Specifications, and SIRI - Service Interface for Real time Information",,,"מידע בזמן אמת - Service Interface for Real time Information","Ministry of Transportation and Road Safety","Yes","Yes","I've changed the URL to the public transit timetables.","The Israeli Ministry of Transport issues real-time and static information - GPS locations of vehicles, time tables, routes, etc. The website and the information it contains is the property of the Israeli government, and the Ministry of Transport. In addition to the real-time data, the Ministry provides static, statistical data.
The ministry also provides statistical data about ride times for all publicly available transport, in the GTFS format, and updates nightly:
https://he.mot.gov.il/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&iotype=w&id=2244:pub-trn-gtfs&catid=167:pub-trn-dev-info&Itemid=304&lang_ovrrde=ENG
","Yes","No","ido ivri","Pieter Colpaert","70"
"7fd1075b-aa94-4536-a70f-91e69cc963c7","global","2015-11-16T17:59:53","2015","us","elections","Yes","Unsure","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,"Federal Elections Commission ","Yes","Yes","The US run federal elections in all 50 states, how ever, data is aggregated in state level, and is not in poll station level. We suspect that the data exist in poll level, but we do not know how it is provided for each state. Currently, the US government does not aggregated elections results in poll station level for federal elections. ","Data prior to 2004 is not machine readable although recent results are; marked as ""machine readable"" as this is the present data and direction of travel. Numbers are for ""primary, runoff and general election results for the U.S. Senate, the U.S. House of Representatives and, when applicable, U.S. President."" They are ""obtained from each state’s election office and other official sources."" Raw data for the 2000, 2004, and 2008, 2012 Presidential General Elections are also available through the National Atlas.
For elections on the state, local and territory level, please see the Combined Federal/State Disclosure and Election Directory. It provides contact information and links to the elections offices of the 50 states, the District of Columbia, American Samoa, Guam, Northern Mariana Islands, Puerto Rico, and the U.S. Virgin Islands.
Also, see the efforts to standardize local government election data being conducted by: https://openelections.net/
","Yes","No","Blessing Jee","Mor Rubinstein","5"
"cc632312-26c1-40a2-a1d0-9dd53da914e4","global","2015-11-16T17:50:17","2015","us","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www3.epa.gov/airdata/","CSV","https://www.copyright.gov/title17/92chap1.html#105",,"airdata","US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)","Yes","Yes","Another site of the epa only for pm vale https://www3.epa.gov/airtrends/pm.html i didnt see VOCs measurement but i think it shold be in NATTS (National Air Toxics Trends Stations) that dont look to work in this time","Another site of the epa only for pm vale
https://www3.epa.gov/airtrends/pm.html
i didnt see VOCs measurement but i think it shold be
in NATTS (National Air Toxics Trends Stations) that dont look to work in this time
On open licenses:
https://wiki.creativecommons.org/wiki/Government_use_of_Creative_Commons#Federal
Note: ""Works by the US federal government are automatically part of the public domain in the US""","Yes","Yes","Blessing Jee","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"1a36f653-4a1b-438c-9fef-23e0dbe19707","global","2015-11-18T10:22:02","2015","sy","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","There is no data about air quality in Syria. ","The official website of ministry of environment (https://moen.gov.sy/)","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"1813107d-3b65-4538-b8bf-ae62d2754c0a","global","2015-11-17T12:57:30","2015","aw","emissions","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Could not find the data on the internet. ","Could not find air quality data for Aruba","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"c37cbc30-5107-49d0-9ad6-5f244aa91b5b","global","2015-08-25T19:24:12","2015","ar","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.hidricosargentina.gov.ar/acceso_bd.php","HTML",,,"BDHI | Base de Datos Hidrológica Integrada","CONSEJO HIDRICO FEDERAL, Subsecretaría de Recursos Hídricos form the National Planning Ministery:","Yes","Yes","After clarifying with submitter the data is there, with the parameters, and public though behind a form. ","**Data quality**
Data has warnings on accuracy, and not all data is available for all locations.
**Please check.** This is the list of types of data available, I'm not able to determine if this fulfills the requirements of this index:
- Aforos
- Altura
- Altura E.A.N. en Snow Pillow
- Anemometro Tanque Evaporacion
- Area de Radiación
- Caudal Medio Diario
- Caudal Medio Diario Máximo
- Caudal Medio Diario Minimo
- Caudal Medio Mensual
- CLORUROS
- Conductividad Eléctrica
- Conductividad Específica a 25 C
- Densidad media de nieve
- Dirección del Viento
- E.A.N. resultante de cateos
- Espesor de nieve
- Evaporacion
- Heliofania
- Humedad
- Lluvia Pluviómetro Tanque Evaporación
- Long. media del núcleo cateador
- Nitrógeno Amoniacal Total
- Nitrógeno de Nitratos
- Nivel Final de Tanque Evaporación
- Nivel Inicial Tanque Evaporación
- Oxígeno Disuelto
- pH
- Porcentaje de Oxígeno Disuelto
- Potencial óxido Reducción
- Precipitación
- Presión Atmosférica
- Profundidad de Medición
- PROGRESIVA 1
- PROGRESIVA 2-1
- PROGRESIVA 2-2
- PROGRESIVA 3
- QMax Instantáneo
- QMin Instantáneo
- Radiacion Diaria
- Salinidad
- Solidos Disueltos Totales
- Sólidos Disueltos Totales por Evaporación
- Temperatura Bulbo Humedo
- Temperatura Bulbo Seco
- TEMPERATURA DEL AGUA
- Temperatura Máxima
- Temperatura Media
- Temperatura Mánima
- Temperatura Tanque Evaporacion
- TURBIDEZ
- Velocidad del Viento
- Velocidad del viento máxima
- Velocidad del viento media
**On licensing:**
- Custom license
- Free
- Attribution mandatory
- Personal information required to access
On this page:
https://www.hidricosargentina.gov.ar/acceso_bd.php
Text reads ""La descarga de datos de la Base de Datos Hidrológica Integrada es libre y gratuita, pero el consultante se compromete a citar a la Subsecretaría de Recursos Hídricos de la Nación, o al organismo responsable de la red correspondiente, como fuente de información en cualquier estudio o trabajo que utilice estos datos.""
**Other water-related data sources**
- Index of argentinian river basins and their authorities: https://www.hidricosargentina.gov.ar/cuencas_cuencas.php
- Official river map from the Subsecretaría de Recursos Hídricos form the National Planning Ministery: https://pag-ar00.minplan.gov.ar/atlas2002_web/
- More information sources: https://pag-ar00.minplan.gov.ar/","Yes","No","Martín Szyszlican","Nisha Thompson","60"
"9750ee38-fe44-42b1-a459-65482f2b40ea","global","2015-11-16T16:40:19","2015","dm","companies","Yes","Yes","Unsure","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,"Companies & Intellectual property office","Yes","Yes","The relevant government website is: https://www.cipo.gov.dm/index.php/businesses-and-companies/name-search","The office allows a name search of the companies, but we could not find the full dataset in bulk without a search term. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"9f5721bd-c07f-49f9-ad97-d4228599f543","global","2015-08-30T14:31:46","2015","eg","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Accept submission","The Egyptian Meteorological Authority (EMA) provides 5 days forecast (6 hours) for Air Pollution, as well as monthly reports for actual observations [https://nwp.gov.eg/index.php/air-pollution]. The Following measurements are required by the Index, and in between square brackets we list what is provided by EMA:
* Particulate matter (PM) Levels [DUST in forecast, and Particulate Matter (PM10) in the monthly report]
* Sulphur oxides (SOx) [Sulphur Dioxide]
* Nitrogen oxides (NOx) [Nitrogen Oxides Forecast only]
* Volatile organic compounds (VOCs) [Only forecast for Organic Carbon and Secondary Organic Aerosol]
* Carbon monoxide (CO) [Carbon Monoxide Forecast only]
Reports vary in the measurements shown there. Most of the measurements are missing in recent reports, while they existed in last year's reports. Some other measurements are only shown as forecast but not in reports for actual measurements. The data is only shown in charts, which makes it not possible to extract daily measures. Finally, the most recent report was for May 2015, and it is for one station only (Cairo), older reports had measurements for more stations.
Egyptian Meteorological Authority (EMA) has 5 stations to measure the background pollution around Egypt. The stations are Cairo, South Valley, Marsa Matruh, Hurghada, and Farafra. However, as stated above, the recent reports only shows results from Cairo station, while measurements of other stations were only shown in older reports. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"74d974e5-82eb-4957-bc32-5e54362e8f0c","global","2015-11-16T16:28:37","2015","et","map","Yes","Unsure","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,"Ethiopian Mapping Authority","Yes","Yes","Data is not available online. ","The website of the Ethiopian Mapping Agency was not available. We have changed the answered to NO. https://www.ema.gov.et/","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","5"
"fbc49a31-541b-407e-92e4-25044cefc508","global","2015-11-16T16:18:23","2015","vc","land","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,"Ministry Of Housing And Urban Development ","Yes","Yes","Could not find the data on the government website - https://www.housing.gov.vc/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=16&Itemid=3","This [website][1] suggest that there is cadastre data for St. Vincent and the Grenadines, however, we could not find an official online data.
[1]: https://www.gesp.it/en/experience-qualifications/22-referenze/116-national-land-titling-project-en.html","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"230e9538-73c5-4d23-a4b4-477d25924548","global","2015-11-16T16:13:26","2015","tl","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.jornal.gov.tl/?q=node/12",,,,"The Republica Journal","Government of TImor Leste","Yes","Yes","Data is correct.","All laws and resolutions of the Parliament are available under the Journal website. The file are in PDF format. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","55"
"d94cc46e-68e7-4e6c-8195-50def22f798a","global","2015-09-28T21:24:28","2015","sv","land","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Could not find the data online. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"76d81315-0276-4453-ad00-a46ec7f35b7f","global","2015-09-09T09:15:37","2015","et","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Uncertain if data exists",,"Yes","No","Solomon Mekonnen","Bruce Hoo Fung","0"
"ff1d0239-89f1-4655-9c32-eb79bcd5f576","global","2015-09-20T01:15:44","2015","tg","postcodes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","No official source for administrative boundaries. ","No zipcodes system in Togo.
Could not find an official source for administrative boundaries. ","Yes","No","Richard Komlan Folly","Mor Rubinstein","5"
"1ffe1e80-db35-4ce5-add6-54b7d646b502","global","2015-09-21T03:07:45","2015","dm","postcodes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"No information available","Department of Lands and Surveys, Ministry of Housing, Lands and Water Resource Management","Yes","Yes","Could not find more data for Dominica. Data is approved. ","This information would probably be gathered from the Land and surveys department. The information is not publicly available as in on the website for download or utilize, however, it can be requested from the department.
The department can be contacted at:
https://housing.gov.dm/index.php/divisions/lands-and-surveys-division
Lands and Surveys Division
Top Floor, Vanoulst House
Tel: (767) 266 3431
Fax: (767) 449 9869
E-mail: landsandsurveys@dominica.gov.dm","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","20"
"c0688552-2755-45da-9618-39250f718fd0","global","2015-11-16T12:59:24","2015","bb","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The data does not meet the minimum criteria and have only one day of forecast (and not 5). ","The Barbados Meteorological Services operates as a self-contained department within the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Development. Its basic public interest functions are funded by the Barbados Government. It gives a forecast of temperature, precipitation and wind for one day.
https://www.barbadosweather.org/ ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"3d8fc3da-b91c-431a-ae28-9227929fb283","global","2015-09-29T04:16:08","2015","tt","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.iisd.org/pdf/2012/nama_concepts_trinidad.pdf",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The reviewer could not find an official government source for the data. Therefore, the entry was marked as NO. ",,"Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"5c047c58-cbaf-4416-b84c-a0c6a25ae2a8","global","2015-09-25T16:10:33","2015","do","emissions","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,"Inventario De Emisiones De Contaminantes Criterio del Aire","Ministerio de Medio Ambiente y Recursos Naturales","Yes","Yes","The link that the user provided - is not available. I was not able to find the data and therefore change it from Yes or No to unsure.
https://www.ambiente.gob.do/IA/GestionAmbiental/Calidad-Ambiental/Documents/INVENTARIO%20DE%20EMISIONES%20DE%20REPUBLICA%20DOMINICANA.pdf",,"Yes","No","Eliaquín Encarnación","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"44431891-bf31-4d08-89fd-8162000fc89b","global","2015-11-01T07:50:18","2015","eg","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.elections.eg/","Excel and CSV",,,"1- Presidential Election Results. 2- Parliament Election Results. 3- Constitutional Referendum Results ","High Election Committee","Yes","Yes","Data is in poll station level. Submission approved. ","Election data is published by the High Election Commission. Older election results are available in separate subdomains accessible from a dropdown list on the upper left hand corner of the website. All data is licensed under restrictive terms (data belongs to the High Election Commission).","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"0cbc1112-0df7-4193-a80e-06aa05f412db","global","2015-11-15T14:02:42","2015","au","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://data.gov.au/"," CSV",,,"Air Quality","Department of the Environment","Yes","Yes","Changed to a more updated submission. ","The data for air pollutants is available and up-to-date up but its provided by the Australia Federal Government. Each State's Environmental Protection Agency provides data to https://data.gov.au/ that aggregate data -
https://data.gov.au/dataset?q=pm&sort=extras_harvest_portal+asc%2C+score+desc%2C+metadata_modified+desc
State Data:
- Western Australia - https://www.der.wa.gov.au/your-environment/air
- Victoria - https://www.epa.vic.gov.au/
- New South Wales - https://www.environment.nsw.gov.au/
- Northern
Territory-https://www.ntepa.nt.gov.au/waste-pollution/air
- Queensland - https://www.qld.gov.au/environment/pollution/monitoring/air/
- Tasmania - https://epa.tas.gov.au/epa/real-time-air-quality-data-for-tasmania
- South Australia - https://data.sa.gov.au/data/dataset?q=pollution&sort=extras_harvest_portal+asc%2C+score+desc%2C+metadata_modified+desc","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","60"
"8c19ab19-3943-476c-8ab0-cfe6c5488dfb","global","2015-08-31T14:08:42","2015","jo","legislation","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://www.pm.gov.jo/arabic/index.php?page_type=gov_paper&part=1",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The link - https://www.pm.gov.jo/arabic/index.php?page_type=gov_paper&part=1 was not available during the review. I have changed the data to Unsure. ","All legislation are published as bulletin the Official Gazette which can be found at cabinet presidency website. You can choose any year or the search for number or subject of the legislation. It is on daily basis.
The format of the data are: PDF and TIFF
The legislation under public domain according to Jordanian copyright law
","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"f54fb0d2-53cd-4cd0-a514-ca130087b0bf","global","2015-09-28T16:44:31","2015","ml","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"No","https://www.sgg.gouv.ml","HTML, PDF",,,"official journal","National Government Office","Yes","Yes","There was no machine readable version of the data. Data is not up to date. ","Only data between 1994 and 2004 available.","Yes","No","Ousmane Ly","Mor Rubinstein","50"
"ddb87d37-f08f-47c2-b871-bf21aa75a5f8","global","2015-09-27T23:31:06","2015","bw","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.elaws.gov.bw/",,,,," Attorney General's Chambers, Botswana - https://www.agc.gov.bw/","Yes","Yes","Approved submission for 2015. ","Reviewer's comment: Submission seems largely correct, but I've changed a couple of markings: Machine readable changed from 'Unsure' to 'No' (because it's mainly pdf format). Bulk changed to 'No', since download requires accessing each law separately.
Data update for December 2012. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","35"
"4289e9ac-9a82-4157-977e-d7469b25cb90","global","2015-08-31T15:32:24","2015","eg","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.ap.gov.eg/index.php/%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%85%D9%83%D8%AA%D8%A8%D8%A9-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%82%D8%A7%D9%86%D9%88%D9%86%D9%8A%D8%A9/%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%AC%D8%B1%D9%8A%D8%AF%D8%A9-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B1%D8%B3%D9%85%D9%8A%D8%A9.html",,,,"The Official Gazette","Official Administrative Prosecution","Yes","Yes","Changes license from unsure to no","All legislation are published as bulletin the Official Gazette which can be found at official administrative prosecution website. The data format is PDF. Last updated three months ago.
Reviewer's note - The site mentions that all rights are reserved
to the Administrative Prosecution Authority.","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"82d3febb-9356-4be6-9ba9-151c69f13db7","global","2015-10-02T15:05:25","2015","dm","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://dominica.gov.dm/laws-of-dominica",,,,"Revised Laws of Dominica 1990, Acts & Statutory Rules and Orders 1991 - 2009. Enter keywords from the title of the law, e.g. constitution, chapter 67:01, act 12 of 2007.","Government of the Commonwealth of Dominica ","Yes","Yes","I have changed the link to the data. Data for 2015 is available, therefore it is timely. ","A search has to be made based on either title or year.
Data is in pdf format and not machine readable.","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"58d0f84b-2877-4690-afd4-ba043e09a60b","global","2015-10-27T16:51:11","2015","gy","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.finance.gov.gy/publications/budget-estimates",,,,"Budget estimates","Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","Amended the submission. There is a budget for sub programs. ","The Government Budget estimates are provided through the Ministry of Finance website (https://www.finance.gov.gy/) and is currently available for the period 2010-2015 via the following link:
https://www.finance.gov.gy/publications/budget-estimates
Subsequently mid-year reports, from 2008-2015, are available via the following link:
https://www.finance.gov.gy/publications/mid-year-reports
","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","55"
"40999418-d336-4b39-be82-7dc21bb98acf","global","2015-10-27T16:45:04","2015","gy","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://legalaffairs.gov.gy/information/laws-of-guyana",,,,,"Ministry of Legal Affairs ","Yes","Yes","It is unknown when was the data updated, therefore, timely is unsure. ","The laws of Guyana are available on the Ministry of Legal Affairs website (https://legalaffairs.gov.gy/) via the following links:
https://legalaffairs.gov.gy/information/laws-of-guyana
Whilst subsequent Acts and amendments are available on the Parliament of the Cooperative Republic of Guyana website (https://parliament.gov.gy/) website via the following link:
https://parliament.gov.gy/publications/acts-of-parliament/
All for your information and consideration.","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","35"
"a73f75d5-b25b-4969-aadf-0d73b3aa3f50","global","2015-10-02T14:44:25","2015","ne","legislation","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,"Adopted laws","National assembly","Yes","Yes","Some of the laws can be found on this website- https://www.assemblee.ne/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=79&Itemid=164 However, it a probably small part of the whole book of laws. ","After the adoptions, the laws are available at the national assembly for free. It is not yet published by default on the website of the assembly, but can be found on independent websites.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","5"
"99ced13e-cb1f-48f3-8eae-5b5e6da47841","global","2015-10-02T14:26:06","2015","ne","elections","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","At the time of the review, the website of the electoral commission was not working. Data was marked as Unsure. https://www.gouv.ne/index.php/institutions/commission-electorale-nationale-independante","According to the national commission, the results are available online, but their website is down. They also said that the data can be provided in excel format event if it is available in pdf on the website.","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"f4a9cf68-fbfc-4220-9152-8bf26e16bf7c","global","2015-09-09T08:01:08","2015","ph","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.pagasa.dost.gov.ph/ ",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Data does not meet the criteria, therefore, data does not exist. ","https://www.pagasa.dost.gov.ph/ publish weather forecast of Temperature for 1 day, and precipitation forecast of a week. No wind. Data therefore is not sufficient to meet the minimum criteria. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"68c3e9a9-fce6-4f3b-96eb-bfcbd282073d","global","2015-10-02T12:24:24","2015","ne","weather","Yes","Yes","No","No","Unsure","No","Unsure",,"No",,,,,"weekly weather forecast","National Direction of Meteorology of Niger","Yes","Yes","Since we can not find the data online, I have changed publicly available from yes to no. ","The direction of meteorology said that they provide a weekly weather forecast, but the data is not available on their website.","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"f83d5463-bb3b-4d2d-a8d2-2fef990886b6","global","2015-10-02T04:59:09","2015","ci","weather","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,"Privisions méteorologiques","Meteo cote d'ivoire","Yes","Yes","I could not find the data as well. Therefore, data is unsure. ","Could not find any data online for an official meteorological data in Côte d'Ivoire. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"e805024f-fc68-4997-b1d2-20e2d1356db8","global","2015-09-03T11:03:03","2015","tj","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","No",,"Yes","https://www.meteo.tj/",,,,"Hydro-meteorology is in charge of collecting, processing, storing, forecasting and distribution of weather data. It has its own network of stations across the Country. Hydro-meteorology is part of the regional/international meteorological network.","State Institution on Hydro-meteorology of Tajikistan, www.meteo.tj, office@meteo.tj ","Yes","Yes","Data is not machine readable. Changed to not machine readable. ","Data online are available in .pdf, .doc, and .html formats - it is not machine readable. ","Yes","No","Asomiddin Atoev","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"078625f2-8927-4241-8c92-665ff90bcf81","global","2015-09-16T04:46:04","2015","gd","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.yr.no/place/Grenada/",,,,"Weather forecast for Grenada","YR","Yes","Yes","Data is in pdf format and not machine readable.","In order to view the data you have to select the city. The data can be downloaded freely in a PDF format and statistics can be viewed online as well.
Data is in pdf format and not machine readable.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Neal Bastek","55"
"82251fa2-8f8a-4149-8f59-f5e110944aa5","global","2015-09-20T06:11:56","2015","pk","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.pmd.gov.pk/WeeklyWeather/WeeklyWeather.html",,,,,"National Weather Forecasting Center, Pakistan Meteorological Deparment","Yes","Yes","Added description of the data. Data is really hard to analyse. ","Copyright © 2010 Pakistan Meteorological Department. All Rights Reserved.
The forecast is textual in HTML, and has 7 days of forecast of precipitation. Temperature can be found in a different link for 4 data - https://www.kma.go.kr/ema/ema03/ra2_eng_index.html. Data is really hard to gather or to analyse. ","Yes","No","Nouman Nazim","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"bd129b47-b700-4432-a145-2bae701f68a6","global","2015-11-13T21:15:53","2015","ro","weather","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,,"Administrația Națională de Meteorologie","Yes","Yes","Added historical data. Changed to timely since data is up-to-date. ","The National Administration for Meteorology (ANM) provides weather data by contract only and retains copyright on all historical data provided:
https://www.meteoromania.ro/anm/?page_id=140
ANM explicitly forbids any re-use of its data by anybody that does not have a commercial contract with ANM, which of course includes citizens that are already paying the cost of operations through their taxes:
https://www.meteoromania.ro/anm/?page_id=49
Data in non-machine readable data and bulk is available without a payment - https://vremea.meteoromania.ro/prognoza_extinsa/12
Addition on historic weather data:
Daily records of nine meteorological variables covering the interval 1961-2013 were used in order to create a state-of-the-art homogenized climatic dataset over Romania at a spatial resolution of 0.1°. All meteorological stations with full data records, as well as stations with up to 30 % missing data, were used for the following variables: air pressure (150 stations); minimum, maximum, and average air temperature (150 stations); soil temperature (127 stations); precipitation (188 stations); sunshine hours (135 stations); cloud cover (104 stations); relative humidity (150 stations). The data are freely available on request in netCDF (Network Common Data Form) format. Any user who accepts our data release guidelines may ask Marius-Victor Birsan (marius.birsan@gmail.com) or Alexandru Dumitrescu (alexandru.dumitrescu@gmail.com) to obtain an account to download the dataset. Size: 1085.0 MBytes
https://doi.pangaea.de/10.1594/PANGAEA.833627
","Yes","No","Codrina Maria Ilie","Mor Rubinstein","20"
"88826562-e76e-4b70-a1b6-aa12589cac57","global","2015-09-07T12:04:04","2015","bh","emissions","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,,"Authority for the Protection of Marine Resources, Environment, and Wildlife ","Yes","Yes","checked","The Supreme Council for Environment in Bahrain is responsible for environmental issues.and it seem data of Air Quality Monitoring
is been collected
Air Quality Monitoring
Air quality in Bahrain is monitored through
five Monitoring station placed one in each
governorate (Muharraqe-Capital-Central-southern-Northen)
• 14 parameters are monitored:
CO- SO2- NO2- PM, Ozon,VOC…..
from -https://www.unep.org/transport/pcfv/PDF/dieselretrofitproject-031308.pdf
and
https://oservices.bahrain.bh/wps/portal/!ut/p/c4/04_SB8K8xLLM9MSSzPy8xBz9CP0os3iDYCMDD1MjYwN3H2cXA6MgT09vgwBXQxNjQ_3g1Dz9gmxHRQCjTimv/?WCM_PORTLET=PC_7_0S20H5230GLCD02RIIK0PE14B7_WCM&WCM_GLOBAL_CONTEXT=/wps/wcm/connect/egov+english+library/egovernment+site/general/progress+in+the+area+of+sustainable+development+to+protect+the+environment+and+natural+resources
it seem the data is not Publicly available","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","yar michl","10"
"74895ece-f4bb-4d43-9da4-37c56b3ebe0d","global","2015-09-27T19:11:35","2015","cr","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked ","There is partial information that is hard to find and mostly available on official reports. The last report on greenhouse emissions was from 2014 and available en PDF https://cglobal.imn.ac.cr/sites/default/files/documentos/inventariogasesinvernadero2010-web_0.pdf. ","Yes","No","camila salazar","yar michl","0"
"a1606348-da34-4517-ac83-b4cc9cf9cb82","global","2015-09-25T12:29:14","2015","kz","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.kazhydromet.kz/",,,,"This national portal contains information about weather forecast for 5 upcoming days and you can also see statistics for the past year for each city.","Kazakhstan Hydrometeorology","Yes","Yes","Data has wind, precipitation and temperature for three day (today +1 ), which meet the minimum criteria. The submission is correct. ","It was not stated that the information provided is Open License. Open Government project team initiated request to get information about weather forecast and make it machine readable.
Weather statistics per year can be seen on https://www.kazhydromet.kz/ru/inforeg/
","Yes","No","Nazerke Akhmetzhanova","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"8054bb91-c7cd-4856-8986-7af805987014","global","2015-09-27T11:33:50","2015","cm","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is valid.
Thank you for your submission to the 2015 Global Open Data Census. ","In principle, Cameroon has an institution in charge of collecting, processing and publishing weather forecast data : The Direction of National Meteorology of the Ministry of Transport.
The website of this direction has not been updated since 2012 : https://www.meteo-cameroon.net/
This is why I choose to indicate that, from this official source, weather forecast data in non-existant, even though our national broascasting TV (Cameroon Radio and Television - CRTV) has a daily weather service. It is easy to understand that these data come from other non-official sources.
The same CRTV annouced in February 2015 that the Government has signed a contract with a Moroccan consortium to offer weather forecast service in Cameroon.
https://crtv.cm/fr/latest-news/economie-3/cameroun-bientt-un-service-meteorologique--14095.htm","Yes","No","Charlie Martial NGOUNOU","Stephen Gates","0"
"9c52b866-86e1-470b-8f0e-db61dfe736d4","global","2015-09-23T14:38:40","2015","ke","land","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission accepted","A National Titling Centre was commissioned by the Ministry of Land, Housing and Urban Development in May 2014 and tasked by the Government to digitize all its content. It was launched in February 2015. No information has been made available yet, at least not publicly.","Yes","No","Serah Rono","Bruce Hoo Fung","0"
"7fc1af1e-e554-4544-940f-370c189f895c","global","2015-11-13T20:05:20","2015","sn","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,,"Direction générale des Impôts et des Domaines (DGID)","Yes","Yes","Added data about procedure to purchase cadastre. ","According to [this article][1] from the government website, cadastre data does exist and in digital form, but I could not find a version of it in the web and publicly available.
According to [this webpage][2], cadastre can be purchased in paper copy.
[1]: https://www.impotsetdomaines.gouv.sn/fr/numerisation-du-plan-cadastral-au-senegal-17-milliards-pour-connecter-40-grandes-villes
[2]: https://www.servicepublic.gouv.sn/index.php/demarche_administrative/demarche/2/531","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"1d9a693b-21fb-4fa6-b8e7-0f24e1fd3601","global","2015-08-27T09:05:03","2015","je","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://issuu.com/jerseywater/docs/water-quality-report-2014?e=6478630/12206201",,,,"Water quality report","Jersey Water. Contact is David Mayman","Yes","Yes","Approving this submission.","Jersey Water is the sole provider of drinking water on the Island. The government is the majority shareholder (Approximately 74%)
The local open data lobby will contact Jersey Water to ask if the data can be made available online, in bulk, on a timely basis in a machine readable format under an open licence.","Yes","No","Marcus Ferbrache","Nisha Thompson","35"
"b3fe9355-3ea1-4343-9b92-6f8b0878ddb0","global","2015-09-08T18:03:00","2015","ae","land","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Reviewer's comment:
It doesn't seem that the data is available to the public, the submitter's comment confirms this. Thus, I will mark this as unavailable","Land Ownership matters in the UAE are dealt with on the individual state (Emirate) level and not on the federal level. The Abu Dhabi City Municipality ( https://www.adm.gov.ae/ ) appears to be the body responsible for the registration of real estate in the capital, but it does not share the data publicly.
Reviewer's comment:
It doesn't seem that the data is available to the public, the submitter's comment confirms this. Thus, I will mark this as unavailable","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Tarek Amr","0"
"b6700ab0-f310-4db4-80e3-e279cf3e140f","global","2015-09-19T00:02:30","2015","aw","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Unsure","https://www.overheid.aw/bestuur-organisatie/landsverordeningen-wetten_3439/",,,,"Land Regulations (laws)","The Government of Aruba","Yes","Yes","Accepted submission. Date of update is unknown, therefore I have changed timely to unknown. ","In Aruba a law is called an ordinance. An ordinance is a generally binding regulations containing decision jointly by the Government and the States taken by a procedure as described in the Constitution of Aruba. These ordinances are made available to the public via PDF files.
Copyright -"" There exists regarding the contents of this website, subject to the legislation, no freedom of takeover; All copyrights, including those referred to in art. 1 of the Copyright Act (AB 2003 no. GT10) are reserved. This website is otherwise Aruban law""
Date of update is unknown. ","Yes","No","Kimberly Soares","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"128f2e67-0ee5-40de-b223-a4aff82a4847","global","2015-09-17T03:35:28","2015","lc","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.slumet.gov.lc/",,,,"Saint Lucia Meteorological Service","Government of Saint Lucia","Yes","Yes","Data is in html format and not machine readable.","Data is in html format and not machine readable.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Neal Bastek","55"
"b49ca2f9-f4f0-41ad-b96c-ab2c8d15398a","global","2015-09-16T22:34:25","2015","lc","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.saintluciaifc.com/legislation/legislation.htm",,,,"Saint Lucia International Financial Centre","Government of Saint Lucia","Yes","Yes","Data is in pdf format and not machine readable.","Data was updated up to the year 2013.
Data is in pdf format and not machine readable.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Neal Bastek","55"
"469695f4-331f-4c39-b0d0-ee97c9a923a3","global","2015-09-16T05:07:10","2015","ir","map","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The site is still under construction so still unsure","Iran National Cartographic Centre (https://www.ncc.org.ir/) seemed to be down when we tried to access it.
The map section of the National Geoscience Database of Iran (https://www.ngdir.ir/Maps/Maps.asp) is under construction. While the map here (https://www.ngdir.ir/thematicgeology/Geology.asp) is not up to scale, and doesn't show roads or administrative boundaries.
","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Gil Zaretzer","0"
"2b739a73-d4ac-46bd-ab63-d1b7e18cfbd1","global","2015-09-23T12:05:34","2015","ke","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://kenyanswag.blogspot.com/2013/05/kenya-postal-codes-addresses.html","HTML",,,,"Titus Talam","Yes","Yes","Submission complete","The data that is available from the official postal website by search does not have geolocations nor corresponding geospatial locations in terms of a latitude and a longitude (or similar co-ordinates in an openly published national co-ordinate system) hence the answer is data does not exist (no changed from 2013).","Yes","No","Serah Rono","Bruce Hoo Fung","0"
"bf3b76e6-94fe-4940-a7cc-6b8bda559b92","global","2015-09-23T13:42:22","2015","ke","health","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.ehealth.or.ke/","Excel",,,"e-health Kenya contains information on health facilities across the country.","Ministry of Health, Kenya","Yes","Yes","Submission complete","The e-Health Kenya data portal provides a regularly updated list of Kenya Health Facilities complete with services offered at these public facilities. The last update was made on September 23, 2015.
No data currently exists on infectious diseases on the portal (polio vaccination is explicitly highlighted though, with an emphasis on no charge)
Kenya Open Data Portal contains information on HIV Prevalence rates at county level and by Gender. Data on other infectious diseases does not exist from Government sources.","Yes","No","Serah Rono","Bruce Hoo Fung","70"
"a7722bc2-c670-4d91-a3e1-708bb895fc0d","global","2015-09-18T18:44:42","2015","ag","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://laws.gov.ag/new/index.php",,,,"Antigua and Barbuda Laws","Government of Antigua and Barbuda","Yes","Yes","Data is in pdf format and not machine readable.","Data is in pdf format and not machine readable.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Neal Bastek","55"
"124d9105-8c3d-4953-a629-b67f0eb252f5","global","2015-09-25T14:45:19","2015","vc","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://svgfsa.com/laws.html",,,,"Laws and Regulations","Financial Services Authority","Yes","Yes","Data is in pdf format and not machine readable.","Most of the data provided are updated to 2011.
Data is in pdf format and not machine readable.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Neal Bastek","55"
"5746b787-6328-419b-8968-e40cb9ecdf0c","global","2015-11-13T11:22:50","2015","tc","legislation","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Could not find a source online. ","There is a webpage for Turks and Caicos [house of assembly][1], however, I could not find any source for legislation. Data therefore exist, but the form of it is unknown.
[1]: https://www.gov.tc/government/house-of-assembly","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","5"
"3b235239-5606-4faa-a60d-ea8029c826ee","global","2015-09-30T22:58:49","2015","tc","elections","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,"Turks and Caicos Islands Elections","Caribbean Elections","Yes","Yes","There is no data from an official source. Therefore, data exist, but it is unsure about its status","very limited content on the government website:
https://www.caribbean360.com/index.php/news/turks-and-caicos-news-latest-caribbean-turks-and-caicos-news/633243.html#axzz2h38gyt2h
https://www.caribjournal.com/2013/03/22/amanda-misick-wins-turks-and-caicos-by-election-pnp-retains-power/
There is no data from an official source. ","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Mor Rubinstein","5"
"33cedd50-0ac3-4e38-ab13-0305e994e208","global","2015-11-12T13:33:32","2015","sg","land","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Unsure","https://ref.data.gov.sg/common/search.aspx?r=1&q=cadastre&s=default&o=a&a=SLA%2cURA&c=07&f=KML%2cPGDB%2cSHP%2cOTHERS&count=10&page=2","shp, kml",,,,"Singapore Land Authority","Yes","Yes","Viewer available https://www.onemap.sg/index.html. ","Data is licensed under the government of Singapore and Onemap. I could not download the data or find it in machine readable format. According to the feedback from Singapore Government, the data is updated frequently through ref.data.gov.sg","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Codrina Maria Ilie","60"
"151bf1a4-1a2a-48c7-b1f3-30e598b577d1","global","2015-11-09T19:28:14","2015","sg","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.gebiz.gov.sg/",,,,"GeBIZ is the Singapore government's one-stop e-procurement portal","Government of Singapore","Yes","Yes","Agree with the reviewer. ","Only tentative tender data available [on the website][1] of the Ministry of Finance. Individual agencies/ministries do provide more information, such as [land tender award for HDB][2].
[1]: https://app.mof.gov.sg/mfeupdate/list_plan.asp
[2]: https://www.hdb.gov.sg/fi10/fi10330p.nsf/w/LandDevMangFinalResult?OpenDocument
Reviewer's comment - There is an alternative website for tenders and awards - see here https://www.gebiz.gov.sg/","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Georg Neumann","45"
"5916e22d-3861-4290-936c-bbe2226f12b6","global","2015-11-11T19:42:56","2015","co","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://datos.gov.co/frm/catalogo/frmCatalogo.aspx?dsId=63800","CSV","https://datos.gov.co/frm/Desarrolladores/frmTerminosCondiciones.aspx",,"Contratos 2015 SECOP I y II-Sistema Electrónico de Contratación Pública","Colombia Compra Eficiente. Contacto: María Margarita Zuleta González, Directora General. Contacto: paca.zuleta@colombiacompra.gov.co ","Yes","Yes",,"Se actualiza la información y las url de acceso al catálogo de datos abiertos del Estado. A continuación se relaciona otra url con más información: https://datos.gov.co/frm/catalogo/frmCatalogo.aspx?dsId=63801
Adicionalmente se cuenta publicada la información [en el buscador de procesos de contratación][2] de la entidad Colombia Compra Eficiente.
[1]: https://datos.gov.co/frm/catalogo/frmCatalogo.aspx?dsId=63500
[2]: https://community.secop.gov.co/Public/Tendering/ContractNoticeManagement/Index","Yes","Yes","Juan Felipe Devia Rodriguez","Georg Neumann","100"
"a3bb557d-451d-4156-a63b-a92a19b350a2","global","2015-11-12T15:35:12","2015","sg","companies","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","No","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.acra.gov.sg/","XLS",,,,"Government of Singapore","Yes","Yes","Have added information regarding SingPass account. Data is not publicly available and have marked as such. The data is available in bulk and Machine readable once it is purchased. ","Accounting and Corporate Regulatory Authority (ACRA) holds this data. However, you have to pay to get the data. According to the website https://www.psi.gov.sg/NASApp/tmf/TMFServlet?app=MYBIZFILE-SHOP-CART&version=&S=926cf361e94397c4969b52f67ddb&D=&AT=OUT&isNew=true&Reload=true&AN=PP01 the relevant information is the ""Business Profile"" containing ""information such as registration number, entity name, business activities, registration date, owners and charges of the entity. Please click to see samples of business profiles for different entity* types."" According to the brochure at https://www.bizfile.gov.sg/mybizfile/prod/ird/Information_Services_Product_Brochure.pdf these cost $5.50 per report and upon purchase ""An email with a URL will be sent to requestor within 30 minutes.""
Additionally, obtaining data now requires a ""SingPass"" account, which is only made available to Singapore citizens and permanent residents. Those who cannot obtain an account are referred to this list of information providers: https://www.acra.gov.sg/components/wireframes/howToGuidesChapters.aspx?pageid=1262#1277","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","50"
"9035b026-ba77-41e5-81d9-d284720945bd","global","2015-11-12T15:01:58","2015","sg","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.nea.gov.sg/api/","XML","https://data.gov.sg/terms",,"NEA's datasets","NEA","Yes","Yes","Amended according to Singapore's government feedback. ","Accessible via API
API is accessible and is Openly licensed. ","Yes","Yes","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"87787f7a-0570-486f-8a06-03a54b59fdd7","global","2015-11-12T13:24:49","2015","sg","map","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Yes","Yes",,"Yes",,"SHP",,,,"The Singapore Land Authority","Yes","Yes","I changed ""publicly available"" to ""no"" because it is only available to business applying for the data, I changed ""machine readable"" to ""yes"" since they are selling the data it makes sense that it would be usefull, I changed ""available online"" to ""no"" because it is not, the only thing available online to the publis is a map viewer where they can save picture files but not get the actual data.
Data after payment is available in bulk and is timely, according to the government feedback to us. ","The Singapore Lands Agency will provide digitised mapping information, but this is sold and not under an open licence. In addition the SLA make available a mapping API (One Map) similar to Google Maps, but the terms make clear that the mapping information within the API cannot be used elsewhere (see https://www.onemap.sg/home/TermsOfUse.html section 3(b)(i) ""you shall not: store, download, archive, print, distribute, reproduce, copy, modify, edit, transmit, upload in any medium or incorporate into any other materials, any of the Site or the Material; or""
2015 -
Data is updated regularly and after payment it is available in bulk.
Data can be bought here - https://www.onemap.sg","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"d2b1d40f-df7b-49df-86a2-582016694b33","global","2015-11-12T13:20:52","2015","sg","postcodes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Yes","Yes",,"Yes",,"shapefiles",,,"List of Postal Districts","Urban Redevelopment Authority","Yes","Yes","Changed the data according to the government feedback. Data is not publicly available. ","The data on postal/zip codes was easily available on the site geopostcodes.com . This site even have details on the latitude and longitude of the cities of the country.
*Data didn't change*
Data is available in this link - https://www.sla.gov.sg/Services/StreetMap/LicensingofDigitisedLandInformation.aspx#2 In order to get license for the data, one need to apply and pay for it. Data therefore, is not publicly available. After payment, data is available in machine readable format and in bulk. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"475c7c7c-f5d2-4fae-8a8a-44b49ae98a5a","global","2015-09-23T11:06:10","2015","ke","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure",,"Yes","https://www.kenyalaw.org:8181/exist/kenyalex/index.xql","XML, PDF, Word","https://kenyalaw.org/kl/index.php?id=2161",,"Laws of Kenya","National Council for Law Reporting","Yes","Yes","submission complete","The primary format is XML. Acts and other pieces of legislation can be downloaded for free in different formats including PDF and DOC. Another viable and good source is the Kenya Parliament website: https://www.parliament.go.ke/ in pdf formats too.
[According to Ahmed Maawy - No changes from 2013]
Kenya Gazettes from as far back as 2006 are also available in PDF format. Upon request, Code for Africa was able to obtain Kenya Gazettes from as far back as 1896. All of them live on the sourceAfrica platform (https://sourceafrica.net) currently. ","Yes","Yes","Serah Rono","Bruce Hoo Fung","90"
"72e0c941-9846-4356-b4f2-e3abe60d6805","global","2015-11-09T15:36:43","2015","lu","water","Yes","Unsure","No","Yes","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.drenkwaasser.lu/",,,,"Campagne Drénkwaasser","Administration de l'eau","Yes","Yes","Data is correct","Individual communes must control the quality of their drinking water by law, and are supposed to publish water quality bulletins; the actual level of openness varies vastly. In the best case, the website of the cummune contains a PDF that can be a couple of months old, and usually forbids reuse, e.g. https://www.topographie.lu/global_data/pdf/eaux/wasseranalysen_komplett/ZONE2_C_d431c5cc-3484-45ad-870d-c23e9bcc5639.pdf
It is unknown whether all communes even digitalise their water quality bulletins.","Yes","No","Guillaume Rischard","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"d584da55-6fc7-4aa2-b587-8aa87dcfed53","global","2015-11-04T10:35:15","2015","lu","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://eli.legilux.public.lu/",,,,"Legilux, Journal Officiel du Grand-Duché de Luxembourg","Service central de législation","Yes","Yes","HTML is not considered machine readable in the Index. I have changed the submission accordingly. ","HTML attributes make the data machine readable.
New site with legislation in RDF format planned for 2017.","Yes","No","Guillaume Rischard","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"94024bc8-8fcc-41b4-9b58-a8a577c6d44f","global","2015-10-22T17:59:09","2015","ge","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.air.dnr.state.ga.us/amp/",,,,"Ambient Monitoring Program - DeAnna Oser, Program Manager","Georgia Department of Natural Resources, Environmental Protection Division, Air Protection Branch","Yes","Yes","Accepted reviewer's submission","all air pollution is monitor Apart from VOCs","Yes","No","yar michl","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"64c1fad9-f2f6-4e05-99d6-a52fce8516d2","global","2015-09-16T14:44:05","2015","rw","water","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission complete",,"Yes","No","Stephen Abbott Pugh","Bruce Hoo Fung","0"
"7b582625-cbfe-4973-ace3-5657c67cb42a","global","2015-11-10T20:23:03","2015","co","land","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","Yes","Yes",,"Yes",,"XML",,,"Mapa de Sistema Nacional Catastral","Instituto Geográfico Agustín Codazzi-IGAC. Contacto: Maria Elena Silva Fandiño-Oficina de Informática y Telecomunicaciones. Correo: mariae.silva@igac.gov.co","Yes","Yes","https://ssiglwps.igac.gov.co/ssigl2.0/visor/galeria.req?mapaId=23 - geoportal for vizualization","Estimada Codrina, muy respetuosamente considero que los datos están disponibles en linea, teniendo en cuenta que se pueden acceder a través de una página web. De igual manera se pueden descargar gratuitamente en formato XML, a pesar de que no se encuentre la información con todas las características solicitadas por la comunidad: https://www.igac.gov.co/wps/portal/igac/raiz/iniciohome/MapasdeColombia/Descargas
Con el fin de contribuir con mayor información, incluyo la url del ICDE (Infraestructura Colombiana de Datos Espaciales), con los datos en formato XML del mapa catastral: https://www.icde.org.co/web/guest/wms_igac
Muchas gracias por tus observaciones, las tendremos en cuenta para comunicarlas al IGAC y mejorar nuestra información.","Yes","No","Juan Felipe Devia Rodriguez","Codrina Maria Ilie","50"
"486b8732-00de-47ab-844a-3d7d5f4df08e","global","2015-08-21T10:37:03","2015","il","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.ims.gov.il/ims/all_tahazit/","XML",,,"Weather Forecast for 4 days","Israel Meterological service","Yes","Yes",,"Data is only available for 4 days and not 5 for 15 cities in Israel. There is also an Historical dataset on the government open data portal, the data there can be produce in a XLS. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","60"
"bce39095-8577-47c2-8456-cad910cbc2c1","global","2015-09-27T21:33:55","2015","bg","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://weather.bg/",,,,"ПРОГНОЗИ ЗА ВРЕМЕТО","Национален институт по метеорология и хидрология","Yes","Yes","I have reviewed the data and it is correct.","While the data is avilable though the site, it's as images and maps and not as opendata.
4 days of precipitation and temperature. ","Yes","No","Boyan Yurukov","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"027d19a0-346c-4fa5-98e7-7d69a1d442af","global","2015-11-11T16:51:55","2015","md","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No",,"No","https://geoportal.md/en/default/map#lat=204865.500000&lon=201581.000000&zoom=0",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Data is correct. "," Same as last year. I could not find a machine readable format. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","20"
"f41364ad-48ed-4d8d-89dd-153c4a8d83be","global","2015-09-28T10:51:07","2015","md","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.cec.md/index.php?pag=news&id=1548&rid=12866&l=ro","Excel","https://lex.justice.md/index.php?action=view&view=doc&lang=1&id=347200",,,"Central Election Commission of Moldova","Yes","Yes","Data is correct and timely. "," Most recent data is from 2014.","Yes","Yes","Victoria Vlad","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"cc0720dc-550f-4f8a-831e-61e22122e2f1","global","2015-10-22T17:54:08","2015","md","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://pops.mediu.gov.md/",,,,,"Ministry of Environment","Yes","Yes","Accepting reviewer's submission. "," The data can be retrieved only through the flash application provided
add by yaron
not sure the data in the web site is Air Quality Monitoring Data","Yes","No","yar michl","Mor Rubinstein","35"
"b24ea004-638a-433b-bf9e-5d1da7f4f4fb","global","2015-09-14T16:11:49","2015","co","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Portal de transparencia económica del Estado","Ministerio de Hacienda y Credito Público aicruz@minhacienda.gov.co","Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.","A portal of the ministry of finance: https://www.pte.gov.co/WebsitePTE/ has a very user friendly way of accessing aggregated spending data but no transactional data.
","Yes","No","Juan Felipe Devia Rodriguez","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"623abd26-cb58-4657-b2bc-f322988295bb","global","2015-09-16T14:25:10","2015","rw","weather","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Unsure","No",,"Yes",,,,,,"Rwanda Meteorology Agency","Yes","Yes","Submission accepted","The Rwanda Meteorology Agency holds weather forecast data for Rwanda and makes clear on their website that people can apply to them for access to this data: https://www.meteorwanda.gov.rw/index.php?id=35
But the data is not publicly available and is only provided under a private licence agreement. Reuse of the data beyond the original licence agreement terms is not allowed.","Yes","No","Stephen Abbott Pugh","Bruce Hoo Fung","20"
"149cd975-e2bb-47f3-bd87-929d81661976","global","2015-09-10T06:30:58","2015","jp","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.jma.go.jp/jp/week/",,,,,"気象庁","Yes","Yes","I corrected the submission to the right source. ","Weekly weather forecast which includes temperature and precipitation can be found in the link above. Data is bulk, but is not in machine readable format. ","Yes","No","Satoshi IIDA","Mor Rubinstein","55"
"56d7574b-0010-4230-b909-1614a8fbdeb2","global","2015-11-11T14:08:40","2015","jp","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://law.e-gov.go.jp/cgi-bin/idxsearch.cgi",,"https://www.japaneselawtranslation.go.jp/law/detail_main?re=01&vm=&id=1980#en_ch2sc1at5",,,"The Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications Japan","Yes","Yes","Data is correct.","Seems no restriction for its use but not clear, but unified bulk data seems not available (you have to download them one by one). English translation of those laws are also available (https://www.japaneselawtranslation.go.jp/) but not always up-to-date. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","75"
"3c1ead27-7c70-420a-aaf3-d2636dea5c13","global","2015-09-05T07:09:09","2015","jm","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.metservice.gov.jm/index.asp",,,,"In Jamaica, the Meteorological Service of Jamaica, which is a scientific division of the Ministry of Land and Environment, handles this very important business of meteorology.","Meteorological Service of Jamaica","Yes","Yes","
Data is in pdf format and not machine readable.","The Meteorological Division is comprised of three distinct Branches, all overseen by the Director of Meteorological Services and managed by separate Branch Heads. These are the Administration and Support Services Branch, the Weather Branch and the Climate Branch.
The data is available through the URL https://www.metservice.gov.jm/climate.asp?id=3
Data is in pdf format and not machine readable.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Neal Bastek","55"
"08be32f3-57a3-4f04-a159-2e096dc9c13d","global","2015-09-05T01:18:36","2015","jm","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://moj.gov.jm/laws?title",,,,"The Ministry of Justice (MOJ) is a Government of Jamaica ministerial entity, headed by the Minister of Justice. It was formed at the end of October 2001 when it was separated from the then Ministry of National Security and Justice.","Ministry of Justice","Yes","Yes","Data is in pdf format and not machine readable.","Data is in pdf format and not machine readable.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Neal Bastek","55"
"024eaa3b-6b9f-4301-a4be-66e471e51ad5","global","2015-09-21T12:28:00","2015","de","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission corrected.
Thank you for your submission to the 2015 Global Open Data Census. ","[Das Bundesministerium für Verkehr und digitale Infrastruktur; Deutscher Wetterdienst][1] publish historic data and current measurements.
There are 4 day maximum temperature forecasts ([Example][2]).
There are no wind or precipitation forecasts.
[1]: https://www.dwd.de/bvbw/appmanager/bvbw/dwdwwwDesktop?_nfpb=true&_pageLabel=dwdwww_start&_nfls=false
[2]: https://www.dwd.de/bvbw/appmanager/bvbw/dwdwwwDesktop?_nfpb=true&_pageLabel=_dwdwww_wetter_warnungen_regionenwetter&T1400087811143553398307gsbDocumentPath=Content%2FOeffentlichkeit%2FWV%2FWV11%2FWarnungen%2FWetter__Aktuell%2FRegionenwetter%2FRegion__Nordwest__Teaser.html&_state=maximized&_windowLabel=T1400087811143553398307&lastPageLabel=_dwdwww_wetter_warnungen_regionenwetter","Yes","No","Julia Kloiber","Stephen Gates","0"
"3d2ec4c5-f58e-4d7b-928c-713686183b1a","global","2015-09-20T21:02:56","2015","es","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,".txt",,,,,"Yes","Yes","If the post code database is not geocoded than the datasets do not comply with the 2015 index requirements. Analyzing the technical details of the files https://aplicacionesweb.correos.es/descargaCP/Estructura_BD_Codigos_Postales.pdf shows a difficult geocoding processing for the desired result (post codes are at street level). ","Postcode data are available without georeference and under licence fee here https://www.correos.es/ss/Satellite/site/pagina-1349169615030/info
","Yes","No","José Félix Ontañón","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"3950a971-9670-4f41-87ba-176721cb01a8","global","2015-10-08T09:22:38","2015","it","postcodes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Yes","No",,"Yes",,"mdb, shp",,,"italian national post agency","Poste Italiane","Yes","Yes","The postcode data is significantly divided geographically and legislative (different licenses provided by different regions/institutions). The linked [study][1] states: ""The percentage of house numbers made available as such, and not <> from other themes, up from 10% to 25% of all information collected and then a good result in terms of growth (the first version saw a rate of 5% )"". Thus, the data is not publicly available.
[1]: https://cesaregerbino.wordpress.com/2015/09/27/numeri-civici-open-data-in-italia-disponibile-la-release-3-0-della-raccolta/","The data of the Italian zipcode are available with a restricted form online (= captcha)
The entire data set is for sale.
The national open data agenda of the italian digital agency announces the release as open data in late 2014.
Currently there are no confirmation.
Poste Italiane doesn't offer also the address number.
This resource is managed by local authorities.
The Italian Institute of Statistics is also involved in this data, but doesn't release address numbers or streets with coordinates.
The current status of the release of adddress numbers is in a [study][1] (often updated) by Cesare Gerbino
QA review - Changed the answered so they will refer to the dataset in bulk and not to the online application. Therefore - Publicly available, not for free, not online, is machine readable.
[1]: https://cesaregerbino.wordpress.com/2015/09/27/numeri-civici-open-data-in-italia-disponibile-la-release-3-0-della-raccolta/","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Codrina Maria Ilie","35"
"0e513b7d-e04f-480e-99f0-64f5cfebe5cc","global","2015-11-06T20:46:56","2015","br","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://dadosabertos.senado.gov.br/dataset/api-search-and-retrieve-via-url-sru","metada XML, law-documents in HTML and PDF","https://github.com/ppKrauss/openCoherence/blob/master/reports/inferredLicense-BR.md",,"LexML: Brazilian Legal and Legislative Information Portal","Secretaria Especial do Interlegis","Yes","Yes","Accepted. ","The LexML is a (governmental) ""voluntary initiative"", not an robot (like google) neither an ""obligation"", but is complete about Federal law, statutes and judgments.
LexML collection of legal metadata have only links to documents, today is not a full-text repository. This metadata includes official links (in general HTML converted-publication) and link to the Official Gazette (original online PDF).
There are no **""oficial license""**, only [""inferred license""][1], based on official position about it (copyright law interpretation).
About **""machine readable""**: the metadata is machine readable in XML via the web service, but the legal content in the links is HTML, with no semantic markup or structural conformity. Machine readability in this context is assumed to be referring to legislation metadata, not the legal content itself.
There are ~260000 documents described in metadata repository of Federal law, it is **available in bulk**. The URL and documentation is available at [LexML's dataset page][4] in the Senate's open data catalog.
About ""timely and up to date basis"": have all (precise) metadata, but ""up to date"" is not a precise criteria for enacting authorities – they are the metadata publishers.
------
More details: [LexML sommary][2], [Wikipedia's description][3]
[1]: https://github.com/ppKrauss/openCoherence/blob/master/reports/inferredLicense-BR.md
[2]: https://projeto.lexml.gov.br/documentacao/resumo-em-ingles
[3]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LexML_Brasil
[4]: https://dadosabertos.senado.gov.br/dataset/api-search-and-retrieve-via-url-sru
Credits due to Peter Krauss for submitting most of this information. Some further additions by Carlos Melo and Augusto Herrmann.","Yes","Yes","Peter Krauss","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"faf256c0-f371-425a-bbf5-863bfa396050","global","2015-10-05T09:55:13","2015","is","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.vedur.is/vedur/spar/stadaspar","XML","https://www.vedur.is/um-vi/vefurinn/notkunarskilmalar/",,,"Veðurstofa Íslands / Icelandic Met Office","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 5+ days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.
","PDF describing XML service: https://www.vedur.is/media/vedurstofan/XML-thjonusta-vedurspa.pdf","Yes","Yes","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Neal Bastek","90"
"7ab8fb9d-8b9f-4a91-9308-e209cb592233","global","2015-10-08T08:48:11","2015","ie","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.met.ie/","TSV",,,"Air Temperature, Soil Temperatures, Earth Temperatures, Grass Temperature, Rainfall, Wind speed and Direction, Atmospheric Pressure, Relative Humidity, Global Radiation","Met Éireann, the Irish National Meteorological Service, is a line division of the Department of the Environment, Community and Local Government.","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 5 days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.
","Part of Met Eireann data is accessible through the Met Eireann site but in HTML only. Copyright notice on https://www.met.ie/copyright/default.asp states attribution only required however commercial use of data is prohibited.
Other data is available on https://data.gov.ie/dataset/weather-observations however this is only on a monthly basis. No licence information is provided. The direct links, again, extend out to another website, https://eca.knmi.nl/dailydata/customquery.php where data can only be downloaded on a piece by piece basis. The data on this site does not include all testing stations.
There is no machine readable daily accessible feed of data open to the public that can be found
","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Neal Bastek","60"
"f7e61c18-b333-4244-b566-7e02670dfd98","global","2015-10-26T14:51:59","2015","co","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.igac.gov.co/wps/portal/igac/raiz/iniciohome/MapasdeColombia/","wms","https://www2.igac.gov.co:8080/igac_web/UserFiles/File/Decretos/Terminos.pdf",,"Mapas de Colombia","Instituto Geográfico Agustín Codazzi. Responsable Maria Elena Silva Fandiño Correo: mariae.silva@igac.gov.co","Yes","Yes","I reviewed this again and the first review was wrong, everything is correct","Estimado Gil Zaretzer:
Con respecto a la evaluación del Dataset del mapa nacional, cordialmente aclaramos que en Colombia esta información es gratis, de hecho relaciono a continuación una url donde encontrará una lista de servicios web geográficos wms y wfs de consumo gratis:
https://www.igac.gov.co/wps/portal/igac/raiz/iniciohome/MapasdeColombia/Descargas
Quedo atento ante cualquier inquietud.
Gracias.","Yes","Yes","Juan Felipe Devia Rodriguez","Gil Zaretzer","100"
"02920e22-dd85-4684-828a-32d15506e8b3","global","2015-11-10T14:13:20","2015","ro","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.gov.ro/dataset/achizitii-publice-2007-2015-contracte","XLS","https://data.gov.ro/base/images/logoinst/OGL-ROU-1.0.pdf",,"Public Procurement","Agenția pentru Agenda Digitală a României","Yes","Yes","Change the link to the data and the data availability accordingly. ","Older data (2007-2014) is available in CSV format on the national open data portal:
https://data.gov.ro/dataset/achizitii-publice-2007-2015-contracte
The data is also available on the procurement portal - https://www.e-licitatie.ro/Public/Common/Content.aspx?f=PublicHomePage but not in bulk or machine readable. ","Yes","Yes","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"18ebca51-0b76-489f-a11f-70372097f29d","global","2015-11-10T14:06:02","2015","ro","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://legislatie.just.ro/Public/Acasa","TXT","https://legislatie.just.ro/Public/Termeni",,"National Legislation Portal","Ministerul Justiției","Yes","Yes","Data can be download in bulk. I have changed the submission. ","On November, 12th, 2014, the Ministry of Justice launched a new legislative portal, which offers free online access to all legislation. The access is possible through the web interface or through the API.
By law, the data is not protected by copyright and can be re-used without any restrictions.
There is an API to that allow to download the data in bulk - https://github.com/govro/legislatie-just-python-soap-client
","Yes","Yes","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"d1b13ff3-76e3-4df9-b40f-01a72431274d","global","2015-11-10T14:01:03","2015","ro","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.insse.ro/cms/","PDF, CSV, XLS,DOC","https://www.insse.ro/cms/en/content/copyrighten",,,"Institutul Național de Statistică","Yes","Yes","Added the open license. Data does exist for 2015 (GDP and Unemployment). ","The National Statistics Institute collects the data and it can be retrieved:
(1) online, free of charge, PDF format, for the main indicators
(2) online, interrogation of the database using the interface provided by an institution. Most data is free but it requires an account (also free). Data can't be downloaded in bulk.
(3) Offline, **data can be downloded in bulk data, for a fee, after submitting a specific request**
(4) the data are under copyright © 1998-2014 Institutul National de Statistica - ROMANIA, and it is unclear if there is a licence.","Yes","Yes","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"65a69fc2-1c37-402e-99b8-cb9997cb1fa4","global","2015-10-07T15:44:27","2015","ie","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"No","https://gis.epa.ie/GetData/Download",,"https://gis.epa.ie/ContactUs/Policy",,"River water quality; lake water quality; bathing water quality; groundwater quality; estuarine and coastal water quality; river risk assessment; lake risk assessment; transitional risk assessment; coastal risk assessment; groundwater risk assessment; river basin districts; Water Framework Directive (WFD); fish kills; pollution at sea incidents.","Environmental Protection Agency","Yes","Yes","All parameters are there, submission is accurate regarding data being available and the download issues.","Water Quality is monitored by the Irish EPA and data is publicly released. Only attribution is sought, however no specific licence type is applied.
Data monitoring happens on a regular basis, however, the most recent files available for download are 10 months old indicating data is not provided in a timely and up to date manner
Data is accessible through the following series of steps
- Access through https://data.gov.ie/dataset/water-quality
- Click ""Direct Link"" under Geospatial (which is not a direct link)
- Brings you to https://gis.epa.ie/
- Click little arrow under Get Data
- Click little arrow under EPA Database
- Select Water Quality and Monitoring
- Select appropriate file
- Enter email address at bottom of table
- Enter email address again
- Complete Captcha
- Click ""Send""
- Wait an indeterminate amount of time (after 90 mins at time of writing, no email from EPA has arrived)
On this basis, machine readable category has been set to no as it can not be determined at time of writing","Yes","No","anonymous","Nisha Thompson","75"
"2d18360f-0d80-435b-b8e2-d9f3f3df5d36","global","2015-10-05T18:18:46","2015","ca","postcodes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Postal Code","Canada Post","Yes","Yes","ok","Canada Post is a Crown corporation of the Government of Canada. Commercial use of Canada Post's Postal Code Address Data (PCAD) product has been quoted at $50,600 per year. Canada Post claims copyright in its database of postal codes. It has recently defended its claim by filing a lawsuit against Geolytica: https://cippic.ca/en/copyright/geolytica-statement-of-defence.
The data are available over the web and in bulk but these are restricted and behind are not for free.
There are different maps available:
Forward Sortation Areas - https://www5.statcan.gc.ca/olc-cel/olc.action?objId=92-179-X&objType=2&lang=en&limit=0
Postal Code Conversion File - https://www.statcan.gc.ca/daily-quotidien/110720/dq110720f-eng.htm
Address Data Products - https://www.canadapost.ca/cpo/mc/business/productsservices/mailing/pcdp.jsf
Many other products are available here - https://www.canadapost.ca/cpo/mc/business/productsservices/mailing/pcdp.jsf","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Codrina Maria Ilie","20"
"7a6876d8-9d8e-4e5d-9409-11a7e763f988","global","2015-10-29T21:33:27","2015","gb","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.ordnancesurvey.co.uk/opendatadownload/products.html","ESRI Shape, GML 3, TIFF","https://www.ordnancesurvey.co.uk/business-and-government/licensing/using-creating-data-with-os-products/os-opendata.html",,"OS OpenData (a suite of national mapping datasets at 1:250,000 scale +)","Ordnance Survey (for Great Britain) and OSNI (for Northern Ireland)","Yes","Yes","Data is correct. I included this as bulk although Northern Ireland is not a part of this dataset. ","National map data is published by Ordnance Survey (https://www.ordnancesurvey.co.uk/) for Great Britain and is open data: https://www.ordnancesurvey.co.uk/opendatadownload/products.html
Ordnance Survey's OpenData suite of digital products includes 1:250,000 scale raster mapping for all of Great Britain, and additional national mapping at higher resolution (OS StreetView, OS Open Map - Local, OS Open Roads, OS Open Rivers and OS Boundary-Line).
The Ordnance Survey's OpenData product suite is released under the Open Government Licence, which complies with the Open Definition. The mapping is actively maintained and updated regularly.
As Ordnance Survey is the national mapping agency for Great Britain only, the coverage excludes Northern Ireland, the Isle of Man and the Channel Islands.
Separate national mapping data for Northern Ireland is produced by Ordnance Survey for Northern Ireland (OSNI) (https://www.nidirect.gov.uk/ordnance-survey-of-northern-ireland). However open data mapping for Northern Ireland is not currently available at resolutions of 1:250,000 or better.(https://www.nidirect.gov.uk/index/information-and-services/property-and-housing/your-neighbourhood-roads-and-streets/ordnance-survey-of-northern-ireland/product-range/digital-products.htm). OSNI mapping is available for re-use on commercial terms.
","Yes","Yes","Owen Boswarva","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"f5e9dc4b-d353-45c3-8595-8411d65294d4","global","2015-11-09T19:12:00","2015","sg","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"No","https://ref.data.gov.sg/Metadata/SGMatadata.aspx?id=2614010000000011201U&mid=184755&t=TEXTUAL","XLS","https://www.pub.gov.sg/general/watersupply/Pages/DrinkingWQReport.aspx",,"Drinking Water Quality Report","PUB","Yes","Yes","Data should be updated on a weekly basis. ","There is water quality report on the open data portal, it is not updated as needed. There is not historical data and the last update was done in March 2015. ","Yes","Yes","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","80"
"b01d14d5-3b4e-4f39-b256-b10d63f5ce57","global","2015-11-04T09:51:52","2015","lu","companies","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Le Registre de Commerce et des Sociétés (RCS) constitue un répertoire officiel de toutes les personnes physiques et morales faisant le commerce ainsi que d'autres entités. Les buts du RCS sont d'assurer l'identification des personnes dont l'immatriculation ou l'inscription est requise par la loi en dressant un inventaire permanent, de conférer une plus grande sécurité aux transactions, et d'informer les tiers","Registre de Commerce et des Sociétés GIE","Yes","Yes"," The dataset isn't available in bulk — neither for free nor for sale.","Data is also published in the Mémorial C, https://www.legilux.public.lu/entr/. People have written scrapers for both, e.g. https://legicopylux.free.fr/","Yes","No","Guillaume Rischard","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"99555718-7297-4c77-8b6e-fa45f1a74b8e","global","2015-11-09T05:08:37","2015","co","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.sisaire.gov.co:8080/faces/indiceIndicador/indiceNacionalDepartamentos.jsp","csv",,,"Sisaire Subsystem is the Air Quality Information","Instituto de Hidrología, Meteorología y Estudios Ambientales-IDEAM, Contacto: Leonardo Cárdenas, jefe de sistemas. Correo: lcardenas@ideam.gov.co","Yes","Yes","check","add by yaron its seem the data for air pollution is for in 3 city is give by the local city
Bogota-https://oab.ambientebogota.gov.co/
cail-https://www.cali.gov.co/dagma/
medellin-https://www.metropol.gov.co/CalidadAire/Paginas/inicio.aspx
It seems that all air pollutants are measured except VOC
but this link that was give by Submitter is theA coordinating body measurements federal level air pollution-
Además se cuenta con el portal SISAIRE- Subsistema de información sobre calidad de aire, el cual se puede consultar a través del siguiente link:
https://www.sisaire.gov.co:8080/faces/indiceIndicador/indiceNacionalDepartamentos.jsp
Con el fin de aclarar, SISAIRE hace parte del Sistema Nacional de Información Ambiental para Colombia (SIAC-Módulo Aire). El SISAIRE es la principal fuente de información para el diseño, evaluación y ajuste de las políticas y estrategias nacionales y regionales de prevención y control de la calidad del aire del país.
add by yaron-its seem the Submitter is Refers for Pollutant Emissions in the Originally link","Yes","No","yar michl","yar michl","70"
"610b685c-d341-4146-b6b5-bada072732eb","global","2015-11-09T01:47:57","2015","dk","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://download.kortforsyningen.dk/","shape, tab, gdb","https://download.kortforsyningen.dk/content/vilkaar-og-betingelser",,,"Danish Geodata Agency (Geodatastyrelsen)","Yes","Yes","Registration is automated, therefore data is publicly available. ","A map of Denmark at the scale 1:200.000 is provided here: https://download.kortforsyningen.dk/content/danmark-1200000
To download the map you need to register with an email address. The process is automated.","Yes","Yes","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"d65eaa2b-91d1-4b70-b8b9-7d00ef3c9282","global","2015-10-07T15:43:40","2015","ie","postcodes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Unsure","No",,"Yes",,,,,,"Eircode","Yes","Yes","I accept further details. ","Ireland has just released its postal code data. I have sent them a question with regards to data formats.
The data are machine readable, and the data can be downloaded in bulk and they are available online but only for a fee. https://www.eircode.ie/business/products-and-services
The pricing and licences are as follows: https://www.eircode.ie/docs/default-source/Common/licensing-and-pricing-information-as-of-september-2015---published-v-3.pdf?sfvrsn=2","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","20"
"38a9a70e-0eee-4e18-b2e3-248ccbd58e1c","global","2015-09-28T20:21:51","2015","br","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://www.ibge.gov.br/english/geociencias/default_prod.shtm","shape files, .prf, .mdb",,,"Topographic Mapping","Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatística","Yes","Yes","Everything seems correct","There is a machine-readable 1:250.000-scale vectorial map data suitable for ingestion in digital map-making systems (GIS), which includes administrative boundaries, water bodies, transportation infrastructure, energy and communication, etc. There are several other map products, at scales both greater and smaller that the above one. The licensing is unclear on the website of IBGE. As no clear license is available it has been evaluated as ""not openly licensed"". Also, proprietary formats are used to publish data. However, data is claimed to be public domain on Open Street Map, see .
Evidence from the server where the files are hosted suggest that these maps are from 2013, in which case they are not being regularly updated (the criteria for it is to be updated at least once a year).","Yes","No","Augusto Herrmann","Gil Zaretzer","60"
"cbe7795b-cccc-4c6f-ad42-f24c3c02965a","global","2015-11-06T18:05:49","2015","br","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www1.siop.planejamento.gov.br/downloads/rdf/loa2015.zip",".rdf",,,"Orçamento Federal","Secretaria de Orçamento Federal - SOF/MP","Yes","Yes","License is not open. Accepted submission. ","Data is also published on the website of the Brazilian planning Ministry: https://www.planejamento.gov.br/ministerio.asp?index=8&ler=t297 But links are broken. In June 2014 the Brazilian government published all budget data as .rdf data on the Open Data Catalogue https://dados.gov.br
Review- 2015 - The file is not updated on the CKAN portal. It can be found in this link - https://www1.siop.planejamento.gov.br/downloads/rdf/loa2015.zip
There is no license attached to this source. ","Yes","No","Everton Zanella Alvarenga","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"a78fcce8-adf8-43d4-bd9f-35c90c7b412d","global","2015-11-06T18:51:47","2015","br","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.tse.jus.br/eleicoes/estatisticas/estatisticas-eleitorais-2014"," csv ","https://github.com/ppKrauss/openCoherence/blob/master/reports/inferredLicense-BR.md",,"Resultado das Eleições","Tribunal Superior Eleitoral - TSE","Yes","Yes","Accepted commenter comments on license. ","The repository of election data is available since 1945. There is no license available on the website. An introductory text explains that data can be freely used by researchers and citizens but no reference is made to open data. Also on the Open Data Catalogue (https://dados.gov.br/dataset/resultado-das-eleicoes/resource/bfd28046-7236-4a4a-82ef-3e0fcd92771c) no license is specified. Data is not timely on the Open Data Catalogue but on the primary source (website of Tribunal Superior Eleitoral).
2015 -
The result can be exported to CSV from the commission's website.
----
comment of reviewer
About Openly licensed, in Brazil there are no explicit licence for governamental products, is rare and there are no tradition about this kindo of notice in a document. The [link illustrates the inferred licence of law-documents][1], and similar inference must be done for elections datasets.
[1]: https://github.com/ppKrauss/openCoherence/blob/master/reports/inferredLicense-BR.md","Yes","Yes","Peter Krauss","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"7c1b4adb-1489-47a4-b588-16a6902fc08e","global","2015-11-08T15:27:47","2015","fr","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.data.gouv.fr/fr/datasets/budget-de-letat-exercice-2014/","CSV","https://wiki.data.gouv.fr/wiki/Licence_Ouverte_/_Open_Licence",,"Budget de l'Etat","Cour des Comptes","Yes","Yes","Added new comments. ","Revision: The originally proposed link pointed to a bunch of very different files including non budget ones, and only reflected the government's *intended* budget, before it was discussed and largely modified by the parliament (the data is from october 14th 2014, whereas the discussion lasted until the end of december : https://www.assemblee-nationale.fr/14/dossiers/loi_finances_2015.asp ).
It seems better to reference data published by the Cour des Comptes which corresponds to the actual final government budget, programme by programme, published as a whole : https://www.data.gouv.fr/fr/datasets/budget-de-letat-exercice-2014/","Yes","Yes","Regards Citoyens","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"dbafcbe4-4b73-4afd-b6dc-3db5ef41d3d3","global","2015-11-08T15:33:02","2015","fr","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://donneespubliques.meteofrance.fr/?fond=produit&id_produit=130&id_rubrique=51"," GRIB V2","https://wiki.data.gouv.fr/images/9/9d/Licence_Ouverte.pdf",,"Données de modèle atmosphérique global","Météo France","Yes","Yes","Added new comments. ","The ""Données de modèle atmosphérique global"" includes the forecast of temperature, precipitation, and wind on a worldwide scale. Data are updated every 6 hour. It forecasts at H+102 hours. All the parameters are available here: https://donneespubliques.meteofrance.fr/client/document/description_parametres_modeles-arpege-arome-v2_184.pdf
The ""Modèle Arome"" gives a more precise H+42 hours forecast on these parameters for mainland France. The dataset can be dowloaded here: https://donneespubliques.meteofrance.fr/?fond=produit&id_produit=131&id_rubrique=51
Historical temperature data is collected in more than 60 meteorological weather stations, every 3 hours since 1996, and it is made available here: https://donneespubliques.meteofrance.fr/?fond=produit&id_produit=90&id_rubrique=32
Revision: just added the complementary missing information on the historical temperature data that was further added by Claire-Marie Foulquier-Gazagnes via comment.","Yes","Yes","Regards Citoyens","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"c9a62e4d-128b-42f4-b788-77b342377cea","global","2015-11-08T15:34:10","2015","fr","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure",,"Yes","https://www.airqualitynow.eu/comparing_home.php",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Approving comments with more details. ","It seems that all the data is collected monthly but not released by the government. Although a web site of the European Commission publishes data for many cities in France https://www.airqualitynow.eu/comparing_home.php
The previously registered dataset from Ministère de l'Environnement only provides yearly aggregates at a national level by regions of the required air pollutants emissions. The dataset stopped in 2009 and no update has been published since. Moreover, whereas the dataset requires regular measures, the data offers historical mean annual data. We think this is sufficiently old and unprecise to not be considered here.
Some cities provide data on the national OpenData platform, for example in Nantes , Lyon or Saint-Malo but it is also updated yearly.
In other cities such as Paris, this is closed data .
Revision: completed the comment with more links and infos","Yes","No","Regards Citoyens","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"a90c84ec-2da6-45e0-997f-774a7ec3dec6","global","2015-11-08T15:29:09","2015","fr","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.etalab.gouv.fr/le-ministere-de-linterieur-ouvre-les-donnees-des-resultats-electoraux-par-bureaux-de-vote-depuis-1999","TXT","https://wiki.data.gouv.fr/wiki/Licence_Ouverte_/_Open_Licence",,"Résultats électoraux par bureaux de vote depuis 1999","Ministère de l'Intérieur","Yes","Yes","Changed to correct link. ","All the main elections results since 1999 are now available in open data at the polling station level (Bureaux de vote):
Élections présidentielles : données 2002, données 2007 (available on Monday 09/28), données 2012
Élections législatives : données 2002, données 2007, données 2012
Élections européennes : données 1999, données 2004, données 2009, données 2014
Élections municipales : données 2001 (available on Monday 09/28), données 2008 (communes de plus de 3500 habitants), données 2014
Élections régionales : données 2004, données 2010
Élections départementales : données 2005
Élections cantonales : données 2001, données 2004, données 2008 (available on Monday 09/28), données 2011
Référendum : données 2000, données 2005
Revision: changed the url to point to an actual list of all corresponding elections datasets, instead of all of the Ministère de l'Intérieur's datasets which include many unrelated ones.","Yes","Yes","Regards Citoyens","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"953dc709-6da2-44df-b211-a85762a3a5d7","global","2015-11-06T19:12:32","2015","gb","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Land Registry title registers and title plans","Land Registry (England and Wales), Registers of Scotland, Land Registry (Northern Ireland)","Yes","Yes","ok","There is little or no open data on land ownership available for the UK. Authoritative land ownership records are held by the [Land Registry (England and Wales)][1], [Registers of Scotland][2] and [Land Registry (Northern Ireland)][3]. Individual records are [available to the public for a fee][4]. Records take the form of a title register (which identifies the owner and any rights of way or restrictions on the land) and a title plan (which defines the extents of the land). These are usually supplied in non-re-usable formats.
Data on properties in England and Wales owned by commercial and corporate entities is [available in bulk][5] and in a re-usable format, but on commercial terms rather than as open data.
Government agencies in each part of the UK also maintain ownership registers for agricultural land for purposes of compliance with the Single Payment Scheme (SPS), an agricultural subsidy scheme for farmers in the European Union. For example, the [Rural Land Register][6] for England is maintained by the Rural Payments Agency. These ownership records are not available for public re-use.
Land Registry has released a spatial dataset called [INSPIRE Index Polygons][7] that contains boundaries for registered freehold land and property in England and Wales. This dataset is available for public re-use but only the IDs attached to the boundaries are licensed as open data. The boundary polygons themselves are subject to additional licensing restrictions because they contain derived data from Ordnance Survey. The boundaries are not cadastral data and the dataset does not contain any ownership information.
[1]: https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/land-registry
[2]: https://www.ros.gov.uk/
[3]: https://www.nidirect.gov.uk/searching-the-land-registry
[4]: https://eservices.landregistry.gov.uk/wps/portal/Property_Search
[5]: https://www.gov.uk/guidance/commercial-and-corporate-ownership-data
[6]: https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/rural-land-register
[7]: https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/download-inspire-index-polygons","Yes","No","Owen Boswarva","Codrina Maria Ilie","20"
"5212540b-f50f-4206-9365-3ac48b7cd02e","global","2015-11-04T11:44:27","2015","no","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure",,"Yes","https://www.luftkvalitet.no/","Excel",,,"Current (daily) readings from air monitoring stations in Norway.","Norwegian Institute for Air Research (NILU.no)","Yes","Yes","Data can be retrieved in machine readable form. I have changed the submission according to the submitter. ","Luftkvalitet.info is run by Norwegian Institute for Air Research (NILU.no) on behalf of the Norwegian Environment Agency (miljodirektoratet.no).
The Environment Agency also have aggregate statistics available as open data at https://www.miljostatus.no
Note that measurement of benzene (""VOCs"") seems to be done by lab analysis, and is not available weekly.
Luftkvalitet.no has data available for download, but you have to be registered:
https://www.luftkvalitet.info/omnettstedet.aspx
This seems to be so that they can add you to their mailinglist where you get information about downtime due to maintenance etc.
You are not given an individual user account.
There's some parallel environmental information, also in free ( by attribution) machine readable form, available from Statistics Norway https://ssb.no/natur-og-miljo?innholdstype=statistikk / google translated: https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=no&tl=en&js=n&prev=_t&hl=en&ie=UTF-8&u=http%3A%2F%2Fssb.no%2Fnatur-og-miljo%3Finnholdstype%3Dstatistikk
Note to reviewer: changed machine-readable to yes.
Data queried from front end can be downloaded as an Excel-file suitable for machine-reading.","Yes","No","Bergheimivar L","Mor Rubinstein","60"
"683f90bc-e18f-4f7c-8db7-72a37eb55f89","global","2015-10-27T08:27:56","2015","no","elections","Yes","Unsure","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Overview election results at level of the polling station","Ministry of local government and modernisation (www.regjeringen.no/kmd)","Yes","Yes","This dataset has to be in a polling level station, any aggregation marks this as not available. I have changed the data to data exist, but not publicly available. ","License is open when you also look at these web pages:
https://ssb.no/informasjon/om-statistikkbanken/hvordan-bruke-statistikkbanken
https://ssb.no/informasjon/om-statistikkbanken/generelle-vilkar-for-bruk-av-statistikkbanken
License(""URL to license or terms of use"") in the link is not strictly an open license, and this seems to be since it's a general notice which also includes text, layout etc. on the website.
(Reviewer notice, 2014)
Edit 2015: Stastistics Norway publish all statistics for all elections and public votes on municipailty level, including registered votes, invalid votes, spoiled votes, blank votes and election turnout. The data is reported on municipality level (428 municipalities). All the data is open and licensed.
Edit 2015 II, (Oct 27, 2015): The election results are not reported at polling station level, but at the level of electoral district. This data can be found at valgresultat.no. You will find all the information about the election, including registered votes, invalid votes, spoiled votes, blank votes and election turnout. The data is also found, although aggregated to municipality level, at ssb.no:
https://statbank.ssb.no/statistikkbanken/?PLanguage=1","Yes","No","Elianne Eggum","Mor Rubinstein","15"
"32c4cda8-5104-4bc9-a6c3-2a93c5bb5bef","global","2015-11-08T14:25:33","2015","no","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.kartverket.no/download/","Sosi, json","https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/",,,"The Norwegian Mapping Authority (no.: ","Yes","Yes","Change to publicly available. Anyone can register to the service with no problems, therefore, it is publicly available. ","License is CC 4.0 BY. As of 26.09.2013 extensive portions of Norwegian map data is released in digital form, under a open license ( CC 3.0 BA ) - the announcement is here: https://www.kartverket.no/Om-Kartverket/Nyheter/Nasjonale-kartdata-blir-gratis/ New maps will be added, but at this point in time Norway maps with a resolution 1:50 000 and up, are available, here: https://data.kartverket.no/download/
2d views, terrain models, location names, road data, and boundary maps are all part of this map release. An online (WMS) version of the maps is available, freely, here: https://beta.norgeskart.no/
In order to download data, the portal requires users to register.
Update 2015: Markings of national roads, national boarders, streams, rivers, lakes and mountains are also included in the data avaliable. The data is updated at least once a year, some every week. ","Yes","Yes","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"87e60a10-d38f-4adb-952f-357a3fa51a3d","global","2015-11-06T13:16:29","2015","no","land","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.seeiendom.no/",,,,"The Norwegian Mapping Authority is a public agency under the Norwegian Ministry of Local Government and Modernisation.","Kartverket - The Norwegian Mapping Authority","Yes","Yes","data is correct.","Kartverket provides an online service (https://www.seeiendom.no/) that allows the user to look up a specific property, returning borders on a map with property details (e.g size).
Owner is not available.
","Yes","No","Elianne Eggum","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"4963d87d-7d0d-499e-8710-afe5bba46cbc","global","2015-10-02T17:02:58","2015","dk","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://envs.au.dk/en/knowledge/air/",,,,"AIR QUALITY MONITORING - RESULTS","Region Syddanmark (Region South Denmark)","Yes","Yes","checked","All air pollutants are measured
you can donwload data in table fromt but not raw data -the data is givan after some Statistics-so no bulk dwonload and no data machine readable
","Yes","No","Christian Villum","yar michl","45"
"7ac2d3ae-16d4-4fe0-baca-ca30ed3dae70","global","2015-10-27T15:56:21","2015","co","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://sirem.supersociedades.gov.co/Sirem2/","Excel, TXT",,,"SIREM-Sistema de Información y Reporte Empresarial","Superintendencia de Sociedades, sirem@supersociedades.gov.co","Yes","Yes","I am happy to let this replace the former submission, even though it is not timely. Instructions for finding the datasets have been added in English. ","The Corporate Information System-SIREM Report publishes information reported by companies that are subject to monitoring, control and inspection by the Superintendency of Corporations of the State.
To download datasets, navigate to ""Estados financieros"" and then ""Todas las sociedades"". Datasets can be downloaded on a year by year basis, from 2004 to 2013. No datasets more recent than 2013 are available.
The default format of data files is TXT, but instructions for opening the files in Excel are outlined in this document (language: Spanish): https://sirem.supersociedades.gov.co/Sirem2/Datos/GuiaExcel.pdf
It is also possible to obtain limited company data by inputting a search term here: https://www.rues.org.co/RUES_Web/Consultas but not to browse or access data by any other means. Address details of companies are also not held.","Yes","No","Juan Felipe Devia Rodriguez","Rebecca Sentance","60"
"35761295-e466-4ea4-b2b6-bea98c14fa30","global","2015-09-24T17:27:12","2015","dk","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.dmi.dk/vejr/",,,,"Vejrarkiv (Weather Archive)","DMI - Danmarks Meteorologiske Institut","Yes","Yes","I changed it to forecast. Data is still not in machine readable format. ","You can access the data via a search function, which let's you see the archive in monthly increments. No download function.
There is also a weather section from DMI on the Danish national open data portal (digst.dk), but it only contains no data, only references to the DMI portal (https://digitaliser.dk/resource/666599).
Data forecast is available for 5 days, for wind, temperature and precipitation, but not in machine readable format.
But they're on Twitter ;) #fancy ","Yes","No","Christian Villum","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"67c9f203-20b4-42f1-bc52-1123b814def9","global","2015-11-04T15:26:31","2015","lu","land","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://map.geoportail.lu/?layers=parcels",,,,"Le plan cadastral numérisé (PCN) est une banque de données vectorielle et représente le seul référentiel existant pour la représentation du parcellaire. Les données sont structurées en différents thèmes: parcelles, numéros parcellaires, bâtiments, toponymie, diverses informations topographiques, limites administratives","Administration du Cadastre et de la Topographie","Yes","Yes","I have checked the data and it correct. ","The land owner’s name attribute is known by the cadastre, but not included in the public dataset.","Yes","No","Guillaume Rischard","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"81b48b38-200a-4b87-b38c-88b86185d49f","global","2015-11-04T15:38:33","2015","lu","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://meteolux.lu/previsions-meteorologiques","json",,,"Prévisions météorologiques","Meteolux","Yes","Yes","I have checked the data and it is correct. ","JSON for weather forecast at https://meteo.public.lu/widget/access.php
Historical temperature data is restricted.","Yes","No","Guillaume Rischard","Mor Rubinstein","60"
"b6ac9628-7a3a-4d95-b7fd-8072cb060a5c","global","2015-11-04T10:46:08","2015","lu","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://map.geoportail.lu/?layers=addresses",,,,"Points adresse issus du Plan Cadastral Numérique. Données vectorielles issues de la base de données du PCN (Plan cadastral numérisé), contenant les points adresse. Ces points sont issus du PCN et se trouvent au centre du bâtiment d'habitation ayant la plus grande surface qui se trouve sur la parcelle à laquelle l'adresse est rattachée. Plusieurs points peuvent se superposer, si plusieurs adresses sont rattachées à une parcelle. Les adresses respectent la syntaxe du registre national des adresses (CACLR).","Administration du Cadastre et de la Topographie","Yes","Yes","I have checked the data and it is correct. ","The whole database is also sold as a SHP file: https://shop.geoportail.lu/Portail/menuAction.do?dispatch=load&menuToLoad=inspireViewMetadataExt&metadataId=2399
Data updated weekly.","Yes","No","Guillaume Rischard","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"e1b7d72d-d211-48bf-9cd6-ecb849eafa31","global","2015-11-04T14:17:35","2015","lu","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://deee.aev.etat.lu/air_emwelt/data_actual_lastone.php?V_LANGUAGE=fr",,,,"Réseau de télécontrôle de la qualité de l'air","Ministère du développement durable et des infrastructures, division Air/Bruit de l'Administration de l'Environnement","Yes","Yes","I have checked the data and it is correct. ","VOCs and CO measures are not online.
","Yes","No","Guillaume Rischard","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"9f159338-6767-41bd-b165-fe8bad6523cf","global","2015-11-04T09:55:41","2015","lu","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://map.geoportail.lu",,,,"La BD-L-TC est une banque de données topographique vectorielle à l'échelle 1:5000 et représente le référentiel de base pour toutes applications à référentiel géographique","Administration du Cadastre et de la Topographie","Yes","Yes","I have checked the data and it is correct. ","The vectors of the data are also sold in machine-readable format:
https://www.act.public.lu/fr/espace-pro/bd-topo-carto/bd-l-tc/
The Inspire portal at https://inspire.geoportail.lu/geoportal/catalog/main/home.page offers vectors over WMS in SVG format.","Yes","No","Guillaume Rischard","Mor Rubinstein","35"
"8a470f9b-fe16-48fc-8976-d8aa29bb52be","global","2015-11-04T14:23:04","2015","lu","procurement","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Portail des marchés publics","Ministère du développement durable et des infrastructures","Yes","Yes","Changed to not online, since only some of the data is online. ","Awards are not public. Tenders aren't aggregated by office. Some awards (""procédure restreinte"") are not public.
Some of the data can be shown here - https://www.marches.public.lu
","Yes","No","Guillaume Rischard","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"ffb55c38-4d29-4710-bfa7-feaf2320e225","global","2015-08-28T09:41:29","2015","lu","elections","Yes","No","No","Unsure","Unsure","No","Unsure",,"Yes",,,,,,"Government of Luxembourg","Yes","Yes","Data for poll stations is not open and not in machine readable. ","Elections results are provided by the national government.
The website site was set up by the Luxembourg Government.
The site content is edited by the ""Information and Press"" and ""Technology Information Center of the State"".
Data is shown here- https://www.elections.public.lu But not in poll station level. ","Yes","No","Slim Turki","Mor Rubinstein","15"
"e7483072-85e2-4054-ace1-6a6e53cfcb84","global","2015-11-04T10:23:38","2015","lu","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.statistiques.public.lu/fr/agenda/calendrier-diffusion/SDDS","Excel","https://www.statistiques.public.lu/en/support/notice/index.html#copyright",,"STATEC is the National Institute of statistics and economic studies of the Grand Duchy of Luxembourg. Its missions are to provide a public information service of high quality to public and private decision-makers as well as to citizens. STATEC is committed to produce statistics, analyses and studies giving a detailed, reliable and objective image of the society of Luxembourg.","STATEC","Yes","Yes","I have checked the submission and it is correct.","Copyright terms will become CC0 within a few days.
","Yes","Yes","Guillaume Rischard","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"99d95925-6a52-41a6-b9e8-d474de7de258","global","2015-11-04T09:02:08","2015","lu","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Évaluation mensuelle directive SEC","Ministère des Finances","Yes","Yes","Not transactional. Changed the submission. ","Individual transactions are not public. A monthly summary is published online. See PDF documents at the top right of the linked page. Summary can be found here - https://www.budget.public.lu/lu/budget2016/evaluation-mensuelle","Yes","No","Guillaume Rischard","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"a9f83841-4d99-4361-9abc-fb60e46b9368","global","2015-11-04T08:52:49","2015","lu","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.budget.public.lu/","Excel","https://www.budget.public.lu/lu/support/aspects-legaux",,"De Budget","Ministère des Finances","Yes","Yes","I have reviewed the data and it is correct. ","How detailed do the descriptions have to be? Is something like https://www.budget.public.lu/lu/budget2016/am-detail enough?","Yes","Yes","Guillaume Rischard","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"cb5cebbe-1d56-4271-bdd6-a2b8985fcdc0","global","2015-10-23T16:10:02","2015","je","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.gov.je/Government/JerseyWorld/StatisticsUnit/Pages/default.aspx",,,,,"Statistics Unit","Yes","Yes","Data is on a timely basis. ","GDP is reported annually, at the end of September / early October, for the prior year - e.g. 31/9/15 for 2014 (https://www.gov.je/Government/JerseyWorld/StatisticsUnit/BusinessEconomy/Pages/GVAandGNI.aspx#anchor-1)
Unemployment figures are published monthly in arrears
[Unemployment][1] data (in PDF)
[GDP][2] data (in PDF)
[Population][3] data (up to 2014)
[1]: https://www.gov.je/Government/JerseyWorld/StatisticsUnit/EmploymentEarnings/Pages/RegisteredUnemployment.aspx
[2]: https://www.gov.je/Government/JerseyWorld/StatisticsUnit/BusinessEconomy/Pages/GVAandGNI.aspx#anchor-1
[3]: https://www.gov.je/Government/JerseyWorld/StatisticsUnit/Population/Pages/Population.aspx","Yes","No","Marcus Ferbrache","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"aacb83c9-d982-45c6-a42d-9453545c6eee","global","2015-10-04T14:39:21","2015","rw","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.statistics.gov.rw/geodata","Shapefiles, CSV, PDF","https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/",,,"National Institute of Statistics of Rwanda","Yes","Yes","Data is correct. ",,"Yes","Yes","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"e0f39142-b720-4583-a1e4-c4687d68e232","global","2015-10-01T14:50:25","2015","ca","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/","XML, HTML, PDF",,,,"Department of Justice","Yes","Yes","The submission seems to be correct.","The data from the cited website is available in a good variety of formats including machine-readable XML but is not available in bulk (you cannot download the entire code at once easily). In terms of open licensing the Terms and Conditions at https://www.justice.gc.ca/eng/terms-avis/index.html indicate that non-commercial use is permitted but commercial use is not (you must apply for specific permission).
There is also the Parliamentary website at https://www.parl.gc.ca/LegisInfo/ which contains HTML and XML on legislation before Parliament. This material is not openly licensed - the Copyright's Page https://www.parl.gc.ca/ImportantNotices.aspx?Language=E states ""The contents of this Web site are covered by the provisions of the Copyright Act and related regulations and international agreements. Permission to reproduce in whole or in part or otherwise use content on this Web site may be sought from the appropriate source."" It also links in turn to Speaker Permission page https://www.parl.gc.ca/SpeakerPermission.aspx?Language=E which states ""Reproduction of the proceedings of the House of Commons and its Committees, in whole or in part and in any medium, is hereby permitted provided that the reproduction is accurate and is not presented as official. This permission does not extend to reproduction, distribution or use for commercial purpose of financial gain"".
(No change since 2014)","Yes","No","Neal Bastek","Kamil Gregor","60"
"be884ca0-a958-46d1-b4ba-674497eb6eb6","global","2015-09-14T20:12:54","2015","co","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.secretariasenado.gov.co/index.php/vigencia-expresa-y-sentencias-de-constitucionalidad",,"https://www.senado.gov.co/condiciones-de-uso",," Buscador Legislativo","Secretaría del Senado - Gregorio Eljach Pacheco-Secretario General, Correo Electrónico: secretaria.general@senado.gov.co","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Se evalúa como insegura la respuesta a la pregunta de disponibilidad en lotes, teniendo en cuenta que la normatividad es descargable de acuerdo a su interés. Siendo así cumpliría esta pregunta.","Yes","No","Juan Felipe Devia Rodriguez","Kamil Gregor","75"
"f3037f74-5066-4eec-8af9-90fdd0fee294","global","2015-11-06T14:05:42","2015","ua","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://zakon4.rada.gov.ua/laws?lang=uk",,,,,"The Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine","Yes","Yes","I have reviewed the dataset and it is correct. ","Every draft law (bylaw) and passed legislative acts are posted on the portal Laws of Ukraine. No PDF format available. Reuse of data is enforced by Copyright Rules.- ""the Database is not designated for commercial use;""
License: https://zakon4.rada.gov.ua/laws/main/rules?lang=en","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"28a93140-795c-400f-8d5d-16237fae9269","global","2015-09-14T23:35:40","2015","gd","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.geopostcodes.com/Grenada","CSV",,,,,"Yes","Yes","According to the Universal Postal Union, Grenada does not have a postcode system implemented https://www.upu.int/fileadmin/documentsFiles/activities/addressingUnit/grdEn.pdf
The initially submitted dataset is not official. It is provided by the GeoData Limited https://www.geodata.ae/ . The data does not have postcodes.
We did not find any official datasets regarding administrative boundaries.
third party dataset availability https://www.gadm.org/download","Based from the information gathered for the postcodes, they are retrieved by downloading the zip file. Extracting the zip file will show a variety of folders and files where there are additional formats (kml, json)","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"32eaa137-05ba-4fbf-a9a0-5189c029ffb3","global","2015-09-01T12:39:23","2015","je","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No",,"Yes","https://maps.digimap.gg/jersey/postcodes/",,,,"Map of Jersey postcode areas","Digimap","Yes","Yes","The bulk access to the data is chargeable. The description of what is available can be found at https://www.digimap.je/data-prices","also ad hoc searches without lat/long geolocation data:
https://www.jerseypost.com/tools/postcode-address-finder/ ","Yes","No","Marcus Ferbrache","Codrina Maria Ilie","30"
"f1cdab73-884b-456a-b4ee-459baf6cbd15","global","2015-09-28T08:42:04","2015","it","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Yes","No",,"Yes",,"cxf",,,"catasto","Agenzia delle Entrate","Yes","Yes","The gateway to access the land survey data is https://sister.agenziaentrate.gov.it/Main/index.jsp, but in order to view/download the data one must have an account. Prerequisite for an account: 1. an Italian digital signature 2. send some documents 3. wait the approval process. Only the cadastral data of Province of Trento is open data.
One can download it from here https://dati.trentino.it/organization/pat-s-catasto.
","CXF is a dialect of DXF format created by the Agenzia delle Entrate to manage the cadastry data
The Autonomous Province of Trento offers the data in the land registry as public domain (cc0)","Yes","No","Maurizio Napolitano","Codrina Maria Ilie","35"
"3ccee832-bfe4-40e2-adb6-a1eafebd23cd","global","2015-09-21T18:49:16","2015","us","land","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","We have not identified any references indicating that US has a unified land survey system.","It does not seem that federal / national government has a database... The Bureau of Land Management has a pretty antiquated [website][1] that does not have a great cadastre survey page. There is a [company][2] that sells parcel-level data, and a client they note is the government. The state of Montana has a pretty good [cadastre map][3] and [Oregon][4] something similar but I don’t think there is a national map that has all the aggregated cadastre maps.
[1]: https://www.blm.gov/wo/st/en/prog/more/cadastralsurvey.html
[2]: https://www.corelogic.com/products/parcelpoint.aspx
[3]: https://svc.mt.gov/msl/mtcadastral/
[4]: https://www.ormap.net/flexviewer/index.html","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"6729f41c-81f5-4333-8359-c197f8d62b09","global","2015-10-31T11:55:06","2015","je","companies","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Yes","Yes",,"Yes",,"Excel",,,"Jersey companies registry","Jersey Financial Services Commission registry@jerseyfsc.org","Yes","Yes","I am accepting this revised submission as last time I had reviewed the submission before Marcus was able to confirm that the bulk data is in machine-readable format. Thanks for resubmitting!","Users can perform ad hoc searches of the companies database at: https://www.jerseyfsc.org/registry/documentsearch/
All data can be obtained in bulk in Excel format for a fee of £100 (please contact registry@jerseyfsc.org). The registry has confirmed via email that when paid for, the bulk data is provided in Excel format.","Yes","No","Marcus Ferbrache","Rebecca Sentance","45"
"5112bae5-2181-44d7-9e90-515de593da0e","global","2015-08-24T15:57:58","2015","ng","land","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","Land and Cadastral Survey of the [Office of the Surveyor General][1] should have been responsible for publishing Land boundaries and ownership. Although it is claimed to be available in certain states, nationally, it is not available
[1]: https://osgof.gov.ng/index.php/products-services/cadastral-survey","Yes","No","Oludotun Babayemi","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"8ceb5dc3-26dd-4912-b599-8227bd3d760b","global","2015-09-14T11:16:25","2015","at","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Unsure","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Grundbuchdatenbank","Ministry of Justice","Yes","Yes","ok","This data is managed very similar to many registers (e.g. company data) in Austria - the national government owns and manages the data and then there are several companies that buy this data from the government and provide the data in bulk or single request or via API.
A good overview of how this is managed as well as of providers of this data can be found here: https://www.justiz.gv.at/web2013/html/default/2c9484852308c2a601240b4acb4b0842.de.html","Yes","No","Martin Kaltenböck","Codrina Maria Ilie","20"
"ebb29541-5712-466f-9dda-2f6abd04f063","global","2015-09-16T05:03:36","2015","kh","land","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The national agency is General Department of Cadastre and Geography, Ministry of Land Management, Urban Planning & Construction. ",,"Yes","No","Vantharith Oum","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"1e825f2b-0885-41e2-ae59-586a69f39af2","global","2015-10-02T15:32:57","2015","ne","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Yes","No",,"Yes",,"xls",,,"Domaniales and Cadastral database","Department of Domaniales and Cadastral Affairs ","Yes","Yes","ok","The Direction of cadastral and domaniales affair is the one who manage land records. The records are stored in a database with restricted access","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","35"
"184c6907-50fd-4719-bc10-28a9012c4137","global","2015-09-29T05:03:27","2015","tt","land","Yes","Unsure","No","No","No","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,"Maps and Survey Control","Government of The Republic of Trinidad and Tobago","Yes","Yes","ok","Map and Survey Control are found on https://www.ttconnect.gov.tt/gortt/portal/ttconnect/!ut/p/a1/jdDBCoJAEAbgp_HqjC5b2c2DlRqERmV7CYttVVZX1LTHz7qFZc1thu-HnwEGEbAiblMRN6kqYvnc2eTkByZS1yK4CdBCM3QNB6lPllPSg-MbCJeLHjjUWPl7goj_5fHL2D_zW17AAdgo8-gADGu-wEgPD5iQ6vz6ydEuzmQmgFX8yite6beqPydNU9ZzDTXsuk4XSgnJ9YvK9SzX8FMqUXUD0QBDme-iu5tR2a7tB05-TX8!/dl5/d5/L2dBISEvZ0FBIS9nQSEh/?WCM_GLOBAL_CONTEXT=/gortt/wcm/connect/gortt+web+content/TTConnect/Citizen/Topic/FoodandAgriculture/Land-Related+Services/Maps+and+Survey+Control but requires login authentication.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Codrina Maria Ilie","5"
"d8ebb410-75b3-4688-87f0-aced1ac8884d","global","2015-10-08T08:46:57","2015","ie","land","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.landdirect.ie","GML",,,"Land Registry","Property Registration Authority info@prai.ie","Yes","Yes","Metadata available https://www.geoportal.ie/geoportal/catalog/search/resource/details.page?uuid=%7B7694AD1E-CA9C-41D6-B6C2-4AEE89C48BCD%7D
","These data are fully described on the GeoPortal here - https://www.geoportal.ie/geoportal/catalog/search/resource/details.page?uuid=%7B7694AD1E-CA9C-41D6-B6C2-4AEE89C48BCD%7D
The URL provided is to a viewer https://www.landdirect.ie, and I was unable to access or view national parcel data.
I have sent a note to the PRA.
","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Codrina Maria Ilie","55"
"117efbd0-4c7b-40f9-8999-14927e343b2b","global","2015-09-20T22:19:45","2015","es","land","Yes","Unsure","No","No","No","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,"Registro de la Propiedad. Catastro de España","Ministerio de Justicia. Ministerio de Hacienda y Administraciones Públicas","Yes","Yes","ok","To match the evaluation criteria, two different sources of public information should be analyzed: The [Land Registry][1] and the [Cadaster of Spain][2].
There's no evidence of data publicly available in digital form available for download on the land ownership data on the Land Registry, whereas the Cadastre of Spain provides accurate information on land boarders and size updated frequently.
[1]: https://www.registradores.org/
[2]: https://www.catastro.meh.es/","Yes","No","José Félix Ontañón","Codrina Maria Ilie","5"
"da9ff3be-0753-4401-8b58-1202597b31c7","global","2015-09-15T16:52:28","2015","il","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Unsure","No",,"Unsure",,,,,,"Survey of Israel","Yes","Yes","ok","https://mapi.gov.il/ProfessionalInfo/Cadastre/Pages/tazpit.aspx - is an archive of cadastres in Israel. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Codrina Maria Ilie","10"
"13f0bd56-3340-4770-988c-f6674f347bbd","global","2015-09-10T07:56:10","2015","kr","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Internet Registry System - e-registry for real property registration","Supreme Court of Korea","Yes","Yes","ok","Land ownership data of Korea, Republic of is maintained in the official registry managed by the Supreme Court of Korea in accordance to the law. However, the data is not publicly available. The system requires you to pay a small amount of fee for access and print separately, and I guess the data is available only in the plug-in, not in machine-readable formats, and not openly licensed.","Yes","No","James G. Boram Kim","Codrina Maria Ilie","20"
"b046084b-c007-49b4-a055-74b7ff222fe1","global","2015-09-28T04:12:51","2015","ar","land","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","""Due to the fact that the provincial laws have full autonomy in cadastral matter, the territorial
cadastres are different in the several Argentine provinces. An essential element of the
cadastral registration is the cadastral map; this constitutes a basic element to support to the real-estate registration [.....]"", ""Currently still exist various provinces that have not developed graphic records in the whole of its jurisdictions, though it has been preoccupation by strengthening the Provincial Cadastres, so that represent all the parcels of its respective jurisdictions in cadastral maps."". Extract from https://www.fig.net/resources/proceedings/fig_proceedings/fig2006/papers/ts39/ts39_04_herrera_0585.pdf ","The site of the National Registry of Rural Lands contains datasets to be used
https://www.jus.gob.ar/tierras-rurales.aspx","Yes","No","Yamila García","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"19f6e37d-0a6c-46c4-ad7a-dfc327f84a47","global","2015-09-16T12:40:37","2015","nl","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Yes","No",,"Yes",,"shapefiles",,,"Basis Registratie Kadaster (BRK)","Het Kadaster - Dutch Government","Yes","Yes","ok","The Kadaster provides useful open data but unfortunately not on landownership. Even National and Subnational Governments pay for the service via contracts while the Kadaster is a Zelfstandig Bestuurs Orgaan (ZBO). This means that the organisation is providing national services for the national government (and is funded by the government) while it is not place under the responsibility of a Department/Minister. Effectively this is a good example where citizens pay one time via tax and a second time via the actual service. This hampers service delivery and transparency. ","Yes","No","Ben Schaap","Codrina Maria Ilie","35"
"5b053198-7ac7-4e54-8f74-9d5aad7a2bf8","global","2015-09-17T12:49:57","2015","bg","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,,"Имотен регистър/Land ownership registry","Yes","Yes","The provided link https://www.icadastre.bg/ leads to a search payed service. ","The land ownership registry is a service where one pays for a number of queries done in the system.","Yes","No","Boyan Yurukov","Codrina Maria Ilie","20"
"a3301a0f-bee1-4125-9d92-a7c67cd79ca0","global","2015-09-27T11:22:38","2015","ma","land","Yes","Unsure","No","No","No","Unsure","Unsure",,"Yes",,,,,,"agence nationale de la conservation foncière du cadastre et de la cartographie","Yes","Yes","The national agency charges for access and use of data. From the sample available at this link https://www.ancfcc.gov.ma/FR/SGC.php/12/84/liens it is difficult to draw any conclusions regarding the format. ",,"Yes","No","Chadi Nanaa","Codrina Maria Ilie","15"
"8eb3462b-12d8-4cf5-ab24-cc9b06b4ace0","global","2015-09-10T17:18:24","2015","om","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Unsure","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Land boarders and property registration details.","Ministry of Housing","Yes","Yes","ok","The Ministry of Housing of Oman has an electronic database for lands in the country that it uses to administer land registrations. An interface has been made available for residents in the capital to access the data for own property on the system ( https://eservices.housing.gov.om/arb/Pages/Maps.aspx ). It is not possible to generally browse the database or look up properties owned by other people.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Codrina Maria Ilie","20"
"e2b96002-4aa4-4599-b56b-deac6a25de3c","global","2015-10-03T08:48:16","2015","tr","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,"Land Registry Inquiry","Land Registry Inquiry","Yes","Yes","The provided link https://www.takbis.com/tracker does not lead to the dataset, thus the data is not online available. ",,"Yes","No","Pinar Dag","Codrina Maria Ilie","10"
"de17f881-27cc-4528-b5b9-628926545c47","global","2015-09-29T17:30:37","2015","dk","land","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://download.kortforsyningen.dk/content/matrikelkortet","SHP (ArcGIS)","https://eng.gst.dk/media/gst/2364686/Conditionsforuseofopenpublicgeographicdata.pdf",,"Matrikelkortet","Geodatastyrelsen/Kortforsyningen","Yes","Yes","ok","The data is de facto open, although it is not licensed under an Open Definition license. However the terms listed state that the publisher grants anyone a global, free, non-exclusive and unlimited right to use the data for any purpose, both commercial and non-commercial, as well as the right to alter and redistribute the data without prohibition.
As for the timeliness: The data is updated every 3 months which I have estimated as being up to date in this context.","Yes","Yes","Christian Villum","Codrina Maria Ilie","100"
"0dd61148-9e49-4c15-8d8a-d4c35c4d3f05","global","2015-09-26T18:17:53","2015","ko","land","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://geoportal.rks-gov.net","shapefiles, geojson",,,"Kosovo Geoportal","Agjencia Kadastrale e Kosovës","Yes","Yes","ok","Land owner's name is not made public to the general public through the geoportal. ","Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Codrina Maria Ilie","45"
"2a127f3e-c34e-4d09-ba08-2a19382caa31","global","2015-09-16T10:26:21","2015","kg","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Yes","Yes",,"Yes",,"Excel",,,"They have all the information on land ownership","Department of cadastre and registration of real estate rights, https://www.gosreg.kg/","Yes","Yes","The provided link https://klis.gosreg.kg/ does not allow data access: ""Dear users EISN,
To access the electronic paid services of the Department of cadastre and registration of real estate rights, you must go to the head office for drawing up the contract for services at [...] "" (translated with the help of Google services)","The detailed information cannot be obtained for free. But they have automated information system, the access can be gained by paying and signing agreement with the department.","Yes","No","Azamat Tokhtaev","Codrina Maria Ilie","45"
"aa8b15dd-a958-4ac1-9abc-0ec5adf84dc2","global","2015-09-18T21:41:18","2015","is","land","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Called Landeignaskrá.","Registers Iceland","Yes","Yes","ok","Landeignaskrá is fairly new in digital form. According to their own website, the database is far from complete and in such an early stage that it cannot be considered to be available digitally, even by the data publisher. The information is there on paper and up-to-date although it must be requested on a land-by-land basis.","Yes","No","Svavar Kjarrval","Codrina Maria Ilie","15"
"00c0e4e7-d11e-4e21-88a0-e693aa34a0dd","global","2015-10-04T14:18:07","2015","az","land","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","The data seem to exist, but is not public. ","Yes","No","Codrina Maria Ilie","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"103333d2-9df9-45e4-b2ce-f03d503fa347","global","2015-10-03T13:18:31","2015","tj","land","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,"The State Committee was founded in March 2010. Its main objectives are implementaton of the state policy in in the field of land affairs, geodesy, cartography, state registration of real estate property and property rights as well as implemnetation of works on the topography and geodesy, aerospace, cartographic and cadastre.","State Committee on Land Management and Geodesy of Tajikistan ","Yes","Yes","ok","Data can be provided upon request. Though the legal regime provides norms for proactive disclosure of data, they are not always followed.","Yes","No","Asomiddin Atoev","Codrina Maria Ilie","5"
"0d24f550-8c61-49bd-82d6-1b22986cf99d","global","2015-09-15T16:10:14","2015","my","land","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Land","Official Portal Ministry of Natural Resources and Environment (NRE)","Yes","Yes","ok","In Malaysia, land ownership at national level is managed by 2 agencies; Department of Lands and Mines (JKPTG) & The Department of Survey and Mapping Malaysia (JUPEM). Link: https://www.nre.gov.my/ms-my/Tanah/Pages/default.aspx. Since, JKPTG and JUPEM are under the federal territory, the data available are not open to the public and entrance fees are required to request the data. However, there are several cases whereby Malay reserve land owner able to request the data at their respective state from the Land Department Office, which for Selangor and Penang case, the FOI act is available. Thus, the owners have their right to request access of the data.","Yes","No","Hazwany Jamaluddin","Codrina Maria Ilie","15"
"4772780f-a435-4c39-bb80-4c30f51ad370","global","2015-09-12T10:46:00","2015","tn","land","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","We found references of a project developed between 2007 - 2010 with ""The goal is ultimately to have a modern, efficient, common tool disposer for the management of land titles that integrates a geographic (GIS) component. They also wanted a digital cadastral referential for the land information and to implement an open architecture for the different organisations that manage the territory’s data. "" No reference to the results have been identified. ",,"Yes","No","Yosr Jouini","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"d42f7bae-af65-496f-823f-7ffcee7f3304","global","2015-09-08T21:06:11","2015","iq","land","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","Land ownership registration is part of the Iraqi ministry of justice, in their page (https://www.moj.gov.iq/tashkelat.7/ and https://www.moj.gov.iq/registration/) there are some news about the agency, but no way to request or search of the registration data. ","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"0e83734f-d7aa-4f3d-9c4c-a660db5726ba","global","2015-09-27T23:31:32","2015","gy","land","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","We could identify a surveying department within the government, Guyana Lands and Surveys, but in their published data catalog we could not find any reference to land parcel data. https://www.lands.gov.gy/3.4,%203.5%20catalogue%20of%20mapping%20products%20and%20GIS%20services.PDF","It is uncertain if the data exists","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"797af76d-715a-4f51-afed-98d68b05438e","global","2015-09-08T14:12:14","2015","sa","land","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","The Ministry of Justice has a real estate register ( https://www.sc.gov.sa/ ) in which all properties are registered. No information is available about the data and the relevant information for this dataset does not appear to be accessible to the public.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Codrina Maria Ilie","5"
"ca24edf0-11b7-4c4a-b9ba-f97d250d10df","global","2015-09-16T14:55:15","2015","fr","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Unsure","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Cadastre","Direction générale des Finances publiques, Ministère de l'économie, des finances et de l'industrie ","Yes","Yes","The provided link https://www.cadastre.gouv.fr/scpc/accueil.do offers only a search service and thus does not comply to the 2015 index requirement to be ""data available online"". As I have not been able to download a data sample, I can not determine either the data is machine readable. Following the provided link, it looks as though the data is not in vector format, but scanned images. ","The landowner name is not provided in order to protect owners' privacy in accordance to https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/affichTexte.do?cidTexte=JORFTEXT000000886460 ","Yes","No","Claire-Marie Foulquier-Gazagnes","Codrina Maria Ilie","20"
"3c9dbc6b-20a9-4e2b-92b6-18d9897b4ef6","global","2015-08-27T14:53:06","2015","cl","land","Yes","Unsure","No","No","No","Unsure","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","There is a registration of land ownership but it is not public information.
(https://www.conservador.cl/portal/) The site only allows you to manage your piece of land using your private information.","Yes","No","Ahumada Abrigouis Alberto L","Codrina Maria Ilie","5"
"fb31962a-d527-48f5-8f42-57561fd3681c","global","2015-09-29T02:10:10","2015","ec","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Unsure","No",,"Yes",,,,,,"Each local government","Yes","Yes","ok","Each local government manages the land ownership database which is not available to the public. Usually land owners can query the database to know how much they need to pay for property tax each year. In order to query the database you need to know the property cadastral code.","Yes","No","Eduardo Bejar","Codrina Maria Ilie","20"
"772d2a0f-ccc3-4091-9128-5ae1ac879081","global","2015-10-01T14:36:42","2015","bj","land","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,"Base de données foncière","Commission Nationale de transformation des Permis d'Habiter en Titres Fonciers","Yes","Yes","ok","With support from the Millennium Challenge Account, Benin has restructured his land data management with a land information system, that help towns improve their work. There is no evidence about the availability of the data collected.","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","10"
"bc926139-977d-4cd8-b5c5-6bb5152e06a7","global","2015-09-22T13:41:49","2015","gg","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Yes","No",,"Yes",,"unknow",,,"Cadastre","States of Guernsey Treasury and Resources Department Cadastre","Yes","Yes","The provided link https://www.gov.gg/article/111893/Cadastre did not work at the time of this review. ","The description of the https://www.gov.gg/article/111893/Cadastre indicates that subscribers can pay for online access to the cadastre. It also indicates that enquiries can be made in person, by telephone and by email (presumably at no cost).
The logon screen for online access to the cadastre for subscribers is at https://www.gsydigimap.gov.gg/PublicAuth/logOn.asp?redir=%2FCadastreInternetSite%2Fcadsearch%2Easp
The Royal Court greffe holds records of land conveyances, and the registry is open to the public:
https://www.guernseyroyalcourt.gg/article/1638/Conveyances-and-Bonds
https://www.guernseyroyalcourt.gg/article/1919/Conveyances
There is a reference to a digital copy of the cadastre at
https://www.guernseyroyalcourt.gg/article/6868/An-Overview","Yes","No","Marcus Ferbrache","Codrina Maria Ilie","35"
"9ce964ad-29ab-419a-98c7-89d0e5bd132e","global","2015-10-01T13:12:24","2015","ky","land","Yes","Unsure","No","No","No","Unsure","No",,"Unsure",,,,,"Cayman Maps","Lands & Survey Department, Ministry of District Administration, Works, Lands and Agriculture","Yes","Yes","https://www.caymanlandinfo.ky/StandardMaps/tabid/66/Default.aspx","https://www.mondaq.com/caymanislands/x/20903/Market+Commentaries/Dealing+In+Land tells about how to get a land registered but it is uncertain if records of land registration are present","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Codrina Maria Ilie","5"
"b7c70b9e-f50c-4721-a691-889fe5eff733","global","2015-08-30T07:49:31","2015","np","land","Yes","No","Yes","No","Unsure","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,,"Ministry of Land Reform and Management, Department of Land Reform and Management","Yes","Yes","ok",,"Yes","No","Nikesh Balami","Codrina Maria Ilie","10"
"4fe89d21-7df8-4c6e-90be-279ffc9a342b","global","2015-10-07T02:28:55","2015","cn","land","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,"Land right use database","Ministry of Land and Resources","Yes","Yes","ok","All lands are owned by the government but the land use right can be sold to other bodies.
The https://www.mlr.gov.cn/tdsc/ website publishes all information regarding the tender and award of land use right. The website provides information on land size but it does not provide detailed information on land boarders.
The information on land boarders can only be obtained in paper form from the local government office and the local government has its own criteria on who can obtain such document (e.g. whether you are a legal person of a company who will bid for the land use right)
","Yes","No","OKFN CN","Codrina Maria Ilie","5"
"7e3d8ba9-201f-45cf-90e6-5a65debce096","global","2015-09-28T11:25:14","2015","ge","land","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","No","No",,"Yes",,,"https://not-known.data",,,"National Agency Public Registry","Yes","Yes","ok","The National Agency of Public Registry maintains the land ownership data. It is not available for analysis, but for personal use cases, and so bulk data download and use are not envisioned or encouraged - much like the NAPR's company data registry.","Yes","No","Eric Barrett","Codrina Maria Ilie","70"
"be9f01d3-c188-497e-8501-8ec972a208e4","global","2015-10-03T09:04:22","2015","gn","land","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","We could not find any official data. However, we did find reference to projects implemented through United States Land Governance Program, that target Guinea among other countries. https://www.usaidlandtenure.net/where-we-work?utm_source=Where%2520We%2520Work%2520Spotlight&utm_medium=Spotlights&utm_campaign=Spotlights
No data available from this investment has been found. ","no evidence","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"ba418186-05d5-45fb-a054-d5df4af9d128","global","2015-10-02T04:57:26","2015","ci","land","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","No land information data has been identified. However, online references have been found, for example: https://www.fig.net/resources/proceedings/fig_proceedings/fig2011/ppt/ts04h/ts04h_zalo_sabaliauskas_et_al_5070_ppt.pdf.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"43d8b9e3-53e9-40a0-89dd-1e7c4f3c2786","global","2015-09-20T22:16:46","2015","br","land","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://acervofundiario.incra.gov.br/","shapefile",,,"Land Archives (Acervo Fundiário), part of the Land Management System (Sistema de Gestão Fundiária, SIGEF).","National Institute for Colonization and Agrarian Reform (INCRA)","Yes","Yes","The dataset is not available in bulk because, as it has been mentioned by the submitter, the urban areas are not within the same dataset.","The information above covers only rural land; urban properties do not have a centralized archive and varies widely for different cities, towns, and municipalities. Bulk download available via menu item, or directly at https://acervofundiario.incra.gov.br/i3geo/datadownload.htm Unclear legal status -- no licensing claimed.","Yes","No","Felipe G. Nievinski","Codrina Maria Ilie","60"
"4b3ccc81-5573-48c6-a03f-f8edef73642a","global","2015-09-29T05:45:47","2015","tg","land","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The only available info online relevant is the name of the national mapping agency: Direction de la Cartographie Nationale et du Cadastre.",,"Yes","No","Richard Komlan Folly","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"dcb12f4a-453c-4237-a2ec-51ef71504534","global","2015-09-28T15:28:52","2015","py","land","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Unsure","https://www.catastro.gov.py:8060/pmapper/map_default.phtml",".dwg",,,"Imágenes de Cartografía Catastral, Mapa de catastro, Consulta de Cuentas Rurales y Urbanas,","Servicion Nacional de Catastro","Yes","Yes","ok","The data is managed by the National Cadastral Service, dependent of the Ministry of Finance (Ministerio de Hacienda), which publishes the information scattered in different parts:
- The national map in the geo portal [1]
- The downloadable map files (as .dwg autocad format), containing the shapes and identification information about each parcel [2]
- This identification information can then be used to query ownership information in two services, one for urban parcels [3] and another for rural parcels [4].
References:
- [1] https://www.catastro.gov.py:8060/pmapper/map_default.phtml
- [2] https://www.catastro.gov.py/imgcarto.php
- [3] https://www.catastro.gov.py/consulu.php
- [4] https://www.catastro.gov.py/consulr.php","Yes","No","Juan Pane","Codrina Maria Ilie","50"
"202d9ac6-f6e7-4c18-9a9d-6c58c3acc47b","global","2015-09-20T03:03:47","2015","uy","land","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://catastro.mef.gub.uy/10251/10/areas/datos-abiertos.html","CSV, Shapefile, WFS","https://catastro.mef.gub.uy/10251/10/areas/datos-abiertos.html",,"Datos Catastrales","Dirección Nacional de Catastro","Yes","Yes","ok","Land Owners name is not public data in Uruguay.
Shapefile and WFS data at: https://catastro.mef.gub.uy/12360/10/areas/geocatastro.html","Yes","Yes","Daniel Carranza","Codrina Maria Ilie","100"
"e5f9d6d7-a4ab-4a2a-bb33-a802069492a5","global","2015-10-02T09:04:00","2015","bo","land","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","""Bolivia has a decentralized cadastre, survey and registry system, made up of: (1) the INRA, which is responsible for rural cadastre registry; (2) a formal Cadastre Unit responsible for maintaining, developing, and executing the urban cadastre registry; (3) the municipal governments, which maintain local registries; and (4) the Property Rights Registrar. The Registrar registers urban and rural land ownership, has regional locations, and is under the
management of the General Direction of Public Registration. The Vice Ministry of Housing and Urbanism within the Ministry of Public Works, Services and Housing is responsible for the regularization and registration of urban land, particularly clandestine properties (Chemonics 2005).
Customary institutions that often assume a role in land matters include indigenous councils of elders and leaders, religious leaders, unions, and leaders of land movements. Local Rural Development Councils (Consejo de Desarrollo Agrario Local – CODAL) are local-level decision-making bodies comprised of representatives from the Department of Natural Resources, municipal officials, and organized civil society from the rural labor confederations (World Bank 2005; World Bank 2007). "" Extract from the USAID COUNTRY PROFILE - PROPERTY RIGHTS AND RESOURCE GOVERNANCE - Bolivia [https://www.usaidlandtenure.net/sites/default/files/country-profiles/full-reports/USAID_Land_Tenure_Bolivia_Profile.pdf]
The provided link didn't work during reviewing. ","There is a land registry under the ministry of agriculture, but not a cadastre. https://www.inra.gob.bo/InraPb/paginaController?cmd=contenido&id=6650","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"dcf4406c-f044-4fc9-90d0-dd75f3b1cc2b","global","2015-08-26T15:11:53","2015","tz","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Unsure","No",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","The ministry of lands has a database of all land owners and all associated information , but in order to query anything you have file a request on what information you want and also have to pay a certain fee.","Yes","No","Joachim Mangilima","Codrina Maria Ilie","10"
"35f2b217-8738-4c69-80a8-a7d8e307b485","global","2015-09-28T08:50:57","2015","bf","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Unsure","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Base de données foncière, domaniales et cadastrales - ","Direction générale des impots","Yes","Yes","ok","With a support from the Millennium Challenge Account (MCA), the general direction of taxes have made a database of land ownership and land usage. But there is a limited access to only those who are working with these data.
","Yes","No","Idriss TINTO","Codrina Maria Ilie","20"
"d1ebc34a-db55-4aa6-99eb-22756ffc51fe","global","2015-09-17T18:43:47","2015","kw","land","Yes","No","Unsure","No","Unsure","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","Kuwait has a real estate register(https://www.moj.gov.kw/sites/ar/RealEstate/Pages/Introduction.aspx), but we could not find the data online. There is only record of sold properties on ministry of justice website(https://www.moj.gov.kw/sites/ar/Pages/Contents/Statistics/RealState.aspx).","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Codrina Maria Ilie","5"
"c3eac066-0516-4573-bb5c-bb76df2afaf9","global","2015-10-02T11:53:34","2015","ne","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.stat-niger.org/statistique/file/RENACOM/RENALOC_Niger_733.rar?lng=fr","shapefile",,,,,"Yes","Yes","The initially provided link https://www.stat-niger.org/statistique/file/RENACOM/RENALOC_Niger_733.rar?lng=fr , from the official source of the Niger, Institut National de la Statistique provides the shapefile of the Uruguay postcodes. We have not been able to identify other official postcode dataset. ","The directory have been published in 2014, and contain Niger location data. It is available online and for free.","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"42126964-97e9-455d-bbc9-a446f73c495a","global","2015-09-30T20:12:21","2015","tc","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","post code system: https://www.upu.int/fileadmin/documentsFiles/activities/addressingUnit/tcaEn.pdf. We could not identify if the data exists, either analog or digital. ","It is uncertain if location datasets exists","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"a94913c4-82a2-4393-9ff0-ae3422972a61","global","2015-09-25T07:42:58","2015","za","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.postoffice.co.za/tools/postalcodes.xls","XLS",,,,,"Yes","Yes","""In South Africa, multiple address datasets are developed and maintained by various public and private organizations with little or no cooperation on data sharing."" (research paper by Malete Daniel Sebake - Council for Geoscience, Pretoria, South Africa and Serena Coetzee - University of Pretoria, Pretoria, South Africa, published in International Journal of Spatial Data Infrastructures Research, 2013, Vol.8, 1-20).
According to official news, the ZA Postal Office is heading towards bankruptcy [1], [2], [3]. A private company (AfriGIS) has compiled a dataset of postcode boundaries, based on suburb names and boundaries which are linked to poscodes, [4]. The data is privately owned.
[1] https://citizen.co.za/354910/sapo-saa/
[2] https://www.news24.com/Tags/Companies/sa_post_office
[3] https://www.fin24.com/Tech/Companies/Post-Office-on-the-brink-of-collapse-MPs-told-
[4] https://www.afrigis.co.za/solutions/afrigis-data/ ","Here is an extract from the website terms of use (there is no specific licence attached to the post codes database):
* Unless otherwise indicated, users are welcome to copy, download or print any of the visible text or images on this website for personal and non-commercial use.
* Users wishing to utilise content for their own commercial purposes may only do so with prior written permision of the website owner. Requests for commercial use may be submitted by e-mail to customer.services@postoffice.co.za","Yes","No","Greg Kempe","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"03374f54-ea71-4d16-8278-6f0d149935e6","global","2015-09-15T20:56:11","2015","bh","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","Bahrain does not use a postcode/zip code system. It is unknown if there is a dataset of administrative borders with the required descriptions is available.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"c65fd3f8-33eb-4ad1-b15d-aaf0869cd690","global","2015-10-01T16:02:07","2015","gt","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The datasets do not comply with the 2015 index requirements. ","There is a postcode dataset, not a geolocation one. https://www.correosytelegrafos.gob.gt/Codigos.htm
This is a postcode dataset from a third party:
https://www.elportaldelcomercio.com/servicios/codigos-postales-de-guatemala.php","Yes","No","Iscelle Marsicovetere","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"26a8f450-4fdb-4763-81c2-e99f5fb81652","global","2015-08-27T15:34:28","2015","cl","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Service unavailable. ","Data with Geolocation is available here under Correo de Chile -https://codigopostal.correos.cl/correos_cp/soporte_web/consulta_web/versionphp2006/pagina_interior/codigo_postal/consulta_web/pgn_modulo_codigopostal.asp?szTipo=d#","Yes","No","Diego Ignacio","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"3cf2cd7c-7395-443b-9084-a0e99ecd2af6","global","2015-09-16T09:23:36","2015","kg","postcodes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","No","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Yes",,,,,"Address Register of the Kyrgyz Republic","State Register Service of the Kyrgyz Republic","Yes","Yes","The links provided do not work. ","The Address register of the Kyrgyz Republic provides all the locations of the country. Additionally they have SOAP API https://www.darek.kg/service/help","Yes","No","Azamat Tokhtaev","Codrina Maria Ilie","15"
"b74106e7-4a4c-4b78-ac0f-0504553e7d0a","global","2015-09-17T11:39:11","2015","ly","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Did not identified any official admin boundaries. Not endorsed admin boundaries are available here https://www.gadm.org/download.","Libya does not have street naming or postcode / zip code system. Such dataset is not avaliable. ","Yes","No","Maraim Elbadri","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"24f2f4a2-2aa5-418b-91e6-6046e4984a71","global","2015-09-23T11:34:06","2015","sd","land","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Yes",,,,,"Real Estate record certificate","Real Estate Office","Yes","Yes","ok","The data were taken from study about real estate register in Sudan Dubai (https://sudalawyers.com/vb/showthread.php?t=991)","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Codrina Maria Ilie","15"
"5c587a88-fb8d-44c8-8b9d-81f65a38e865","global","2015-09-23T08:01:40","2015","fi","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Yes","No",,"Yes",,"XML",,,"Land Information System","National Land Survey of Finland","Yes","Yes","https://www.maanmittauslaitos.fi/en/kartat","Land Ownership data is public data but open access is prohibeted according privacy laws. User has to have a legal purpose stated in the law in order to be able to handle personal (privacy) data. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","35"
"f05b5d30-ca04-4c39-b7ca-28ebc2171842","global","2015-09-27T19:16:07","2015","ms","land","Yes","Unsure","No","No","No","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,"Department of Lands and Survey","Yes","Yes","References on Montserrat cadastre system have been identified in the proceedings paper GIS Application for Land Planning and Management in Montserrat, West Indies, by Iftikhar Ahmed, Franklyn Greenaway, presented in 2002 at the Open Source GIS GRASS Users Conference 2002.","It is uncertain that data for land ownership exists in Montserrat","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Codrina Maria Ilie","5"
"0bf84c81-02fe-4740-bdda-a442ce9641ce","global","2015-09-28T05:27:13","2015","th","land","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Digital Cadastral Base Map","Department of Land, Ministry of Interior ","Yes","Yes","Information related to land survey in Thailand has been found in a proceedings paper Reporting Thailand Cadastral System in Cadastre 2014 Trends, by Vuttinan UTESNAN, Thailand at the [https://www.fig.net/resources/proceedings/fig_proceedings/fig2010/papers/ts08k/ts08k_utesnan_3966.pdf] at the International Surveyors Conference. ","No information found for land ownership in Thailand","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","5"
"ab11b694-48cd-4310-bfbc-0a4ae33360d8","global","2015-09-29T00:05:35","2015","pa","land","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok",,"Yes","No","HAMZAH HAJI","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"210f9d17-0a33-4e8b-a397-33e7a5fe2ee6","global","2015-10-01T16:41:10","2015","gt","land","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","Th website for the General Property Registration only contains data about the registration procedures and information about the Public Information Access Law.
https://www.rgp.org.gt/index.php/informatcion-publica","Yes","No","Iscelle Marsicovetere","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"e4afc303-b375-4e90-a359-8ada40b6813c","global","2015-09-27T02:53:03","2015","cr","land","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The description of the national institution Junta Administrativa del Registro Nacional, implies that there might be geospatial data. We could not identify any geoportal or sample of data.
",,"Yes","No","Alejandro Sanabria","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"52ae7fa7-2d05-48e6-8bd1-fb672e3f5043","global","2015-09-19T15:18:30","2015","pr","land","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://www.satasgis.crimpr.net/flexviewers/cdpr_crim/","vector format (?)",,,"Catastro Digital","Centro de Recaudación de Ingresos Municipales (CRIM)","Yes","Yes","ok",,"Yes","No","Instituto de Estadísticas de Puerto Rico","Codrina Maria Ilie","50"
"ade7ffff-e4c7-49e1-b4bf-8993161ddd24","global","2015-09-28T06:28:24","2015","ua","land","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.map.land.gov.ua/kadastrova-karta","vector format (?)",,,," Державна служба України з питань геодезії, картографії та кадастру (The State Service of Ukraine for Geodesy, Cartography and Cadastre)","Yes","Yes","ok","National Cadaster Agency is providing the cadaster information in the map only format with no details on ownership, but those can be provided on demand.","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","60"
"ab30036e-5d84-41c9-99b5-0d8f6bd6f806","global","2015-09-07T12:16:54","2015","bh","land","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","The Survey and Land Registration Bureau of Bahrain has a department that is responsible for the land register. However, no information is available about the status of the data and it is definite that this data is not publicly available.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"c4887d51-e4ab-4a39-aa0d-97bbb19b97f4","global","2015-10-30T16:36:44","2015","se","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,"Lantmäteriet (The Swedish mapping, cadastral and land registration authority)","Yes","Yes","ok","""Today, we are required to collect fees from those who want to use products from our range of maps, geographic information and property information - what we collectively call for geodata. Our hope is that we will get a new funding model that makes it possible to abolish fees and restrictive conditions of use."" [https://www.lantmateriet.se/en/Maps-and-geographic-information/Maps/oppna-data/]","Yes","No","Codrina Maria Ilie","Codrina Maria Ilie","10"
"58a21014-244a-4649-9804-3e1feb71f51c","global","2015-09-27T22:41:31","2015","md","land","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://www.geoportal.md/en/default/map#lat=294173.212781&lon=162323.548328&zoom=9","vector format (?)",,,"National geospatial data fund - Cadastre - uildings and Land parcels (2012-05-25)","Agency for Land Relations and Cadastre of the Republic of Moldova","Yes","Yes","ok",,"Yes","No","Victoria Vlad","Codrina Maria Ilie","45"
"10b682e7-f306-43e0-9ff0-4f93e20a91f8","global","2015-09-02T12:27:49","2015","je","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","Jersey has a land register, but not in the form of a cadastre.
A GIS layer is used to link land parcels to the court registry records (scanned document images in PDF format) which detail property transactions registered before the Royal Court.
Members of the public can request information about land ownership from the court registry.
Each land polygon has a pointer to relevant record in the court registry document management system ('PRIDE').
Access to both the GIS system and the PRIDE system would be required to identify the ownership and size of a parcel of land.","Yes","No","Marcus Ferbrache","Codrina Maria Ilie","20"
"75f46d84-a243-4188-9867-3ddf3f094ba7","global","2015-09-30T22:43:58","2015","tc","land","Yes","Unsure","No","Unsure","No","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,"Survey and Mapping Department","Yes","Yes","The list of available products can be found here:
https://www.gov.tc/index.php/survey-and-mapping-department","It is uncertain if the data exists.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Codrina Maria Ilie","5"
"9b74d81e-a68d-48c5-9dba-71e78c44fa3f","global","2015-09-16T18:23:42","2015","sy","land","Yes","No","Yes","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Real Estate record","Property Registry, Real Estate Authority ","Yes","Yes","ok",,"Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Codrina Maria Ilie","20"
"90ca6577-dd56-4e4d-a962-b82191d23de4","global","2015-09-11T18:41:36","2015","dz","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.sntf.dz/",,,,,"Société Nationale des Transports Ferroviaires","Yes","Yes","Ok","On this site (https://www.sntf.dz/) you can search for trains, it gives you departure and arrival times and we were able to find results for the upcoming days, which means it is most likely up to data","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Pieter Colpaert","45"
"67d2d9b0-54a7-4639-a458-a5ec28c56f7d","global","2015-09-25T15:16:21","2015","sk","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://ikvc.slovakrail.sk/inet-sales-web/pages/connection/initSearch.xhtml","HTML",,,,"Železničná spoločnosť Slovensko (Slovak Railway Company); zsskok@slovakrail.sk","Yes","Yes","Ack","Timetable data on national level is only available for the railway system. It is provided by the national operator of the railway public transport system, it is searchable online, but is not machine-readable or downloadable.
Other national-level transportation data is published on https://cp.atlas.sk - a private, commercial company that provides bus and railway timetables.","Yes","No","Eva Vozárová","Pieter Colpaert","45"
"228ffee0-98e6-47cc-9565-327db1c70f87","global","2015-09-22T16:03:13","2015","ru","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://pass.rzd.ru","HTML",,,"Russian railways timetable","JSC Russian Railways","Yes","Yes","Ok!","Brief description:
Transport timetables is one of most common issues here in Russia Timetables managed not by federal, but by regional and local governments. Each regional and local governments publish with several issues: 1. Data is not always published online 2. Data is not always up to date 3. Data is not available as open data 4. No open licenses 5. Measurement of openness of transport data is very limited since it's not concentrated anythere. But rail transport schedules and most airports are public so timetables available. Step by step explanation
1. Does the data exist? Yes, national level transport timetables available at https://pass.rzd.ru - it's Russian rail data 2. Is data in digital form? Yes, data available via website and has digital form. 3. Publicly available? Yes, this data is publicly available. We don't need FOI request to get it. 4. Is the data available for free? Yes, this data is available for free. No payment is required. 5. Is the data available online? Yes. Data available at https://pass.rzd.ru 6. Is the data machine readable? No, this data provided only as HTML pages 7. Available in bulk? No, this data provided only as HTML pages so it's not available in bulk. 8. Openly licensed? No, this data is owned by federal state enterprise and it's not even public domain data. 9. Is the data provided on a timely and up to date basis?
Yes, this information updated frequently, on hourly basis.
2014 Comment: No updates since 2013 year
2015 Comment: No updates since 2014 year","Yes","No","Ivan Begtin","Pieter Colpaert","45"
"3e503f04-62de-463f-b583-b5646f38396d","global","2015-09-27T23:00:28","2015","bw","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Yes","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,"Route milage and fares","DRTS. Department of Road Transport and Safety","Yes","Yes","Ok","Submitter's comments: There are no digital timetables available online, (there is no passenger train service). All public transport is privately owned. There are basic timetables available in printed form upon request as is a rudimentary description of minibus routes - but not online.
Reviewer's comments: Online research confirms that since 2009 there has not been public train transportation services in Botswana (since state-owned Botswana Railways folded), although services from Zimbabve still run through a very small part of the country. There are plenty of bus services, but all appear to be run by privately owned companies. As a consequence I have marked this dataset as not available.","Yes","No","anonymous","Pieter Colpaert","30"
"059d79b0-d2b8-4fa8-b546-931a7f38c005","global","2015-08-29T16:27:31","2015","sv","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Ok","A public transportation timetable in El Salvador doesn't exist at all.","Yes","No","Iris Palma","Pieter Colpaert","0"
"01c58ef8-d0c5-4aa7-b191-c768efa62b13","global","2015-09-24T09:35:10","2015","mk","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://liniskiprevoz.gov.mk/search.aspx",,,,"Electronic Registration of Bus Lines, Timetable of Macedonian Railways","Ministry of Transport and Communications, Macedonian Train Company","Yes","Yes","Difficult to review this as the bus and railways are in different states. Buses are not publicly available (only a route planner on the website), the train schedules are in PDF.","The Ministry of Transport and Communications provide a registry of all bus lines.
There is only an online search function. Search results are provided in HTML format, no download is available.
Train timetables are maintained by the Macedonian Rail Company (https://mztransportad.com.mk/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=160&Itemid=287&lang=mk) but only provided in PDF format. The train timetables can be found here: https://mztransportad.com.mk/dokumenti/DZEPNO%2014-15.pdf","Yes","No","Metamorphosis Foundation","Pieter Colpaert","35"
"4cb34d3b-bc71-4de3-80cb-a515689de135","global","2015-09-25T09:42:45","2015","kz","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://temirzholy.kz/informatsiya-dlya-pasazhirov/raspisanie-poezdov/",,,,"Kazakhstan Railways: timetables, routes sorted by cities. Infobus.kz: online routes of current operating buses sorted by cities","Kazakhstan Railways: https://temirzholy.kz/informatsiya-dlya-pasazhirov/raspisanie-poezdov/ Infobus.kz: https://infobus.kz/","Yes","Yes","Ok. Good review","The information about railway services are provided by a company representing the government. The information about buses are shown by third party company, but the source of the information comes from local officials: https://infobus.kz/; the website shows bus routes online. ","Yes","No","Nazerke Akhmetzhanova","Pieter Colpaert","45"
"a4969fb9-9695-4148-800f-5fd0e2afa596","global","2015-10-05T18:14:35","2015","ca","timetables","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Ok: Canada should be left out the rankings somehow...","NOT APPLICABLE WOULD BE THE BEST RESPONSE HERE. There is no national public transit system in Canada. Public transportation data are only available at the jurisdiction where the service is delivered. Canada as a federation of provinces and territories delivers transit at the level of the city or municipality or other local authority which fall under the jurisdiction of provinces and territories. Cross provincial and territorial transportation would be federally administered but this is not a transit system.
(No change from 2014)","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Pieter Colpaert","0"
"81a66113-97f6-4746-9b71-eef3ed6df282","global","2015-09-09T15:21:09","2015","pt","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.cp.pt/passageiros/pt/consultar-horarios","online, PDF",,,,"CP","Yes","Yes","Ok","Timetables of the national-level public train services are available and up to date online but only through ""search"" of PDF.
No national bus level service is known.
(No changes from 2013)","Yes","No","Aurelio Pires","Pieter Colpaert","45"
"ae7efaf8-a2f7-40b1-a7f8-6b566f92e59c","global","2015-09-21T10:30:53","2015","im","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.gov.im/publictransport/","PDF","https://www.gov.im/about-this-site/open-government-licence/",,,"Department of Infrastructure","Yes","Yes","Remarkable that the data is not machine readable, but it is openly licensed! Good review","Includes bus, steam train, electric tram and horse tram timetables in PDF.
Requested CSV/XLS export but apparently issues with legacy system, resources, etc. Recently more positive engagement, so hopeful a shift to GTFS and mobile app. Most routes have already been independently handcoded into GTFS format by the local open data community to accelerate adoption.
Confirmed that footer on public transport content is outdated and incorrectly links to outdated terms and conditions not the new IM OGL based on the UK OGL.","Yes","No","Graeme Jones","Pieter Colpaert","75"
"bede898d-4971-4db9-9704-f306d711d43a","global","2015-09-17T08:56:57","2015","cz","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","No",,"Yes","ftp://ftp.cisjr.cz/","xls, pdf",,,,"Ministry of Transport","Yes","Yes","Good review","There has been a lenghty dispute over this data, as it's maitained by CHAPS, a commercial company. CHAPS was ordered to open the data. They put it on a FTP, with no metadata and no licence. It's a collection of a thousands of zip archives.
Bus schedules are available in JDF format (a CSV like structure), train data is a bunch of PDFs.
Apparently, CHAPS doesn't want to let go of it's monopoly.
","Yes","No","Michaela Rybičková","Pieter Colpaert","45"
"4d2b516a-c875-4ec2-b5e7-22e96d010afa","global","2015-10-04T14:44:09","2015","et","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","No data or transit exists",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Pieter Colpaert","0"
"f1c8d828-dc18-4d69-9663-405f8c46cdf4","global","2015-10-02T13:13:37","2015","rw","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Ok","Rwanda's Ministry of Infrastructure (MINIFRA) are responsible for transport in Rwanda and acts as a regulator, but they do not provide public transport across the country: https://www.mininfra.gov.rw/
Some local/regional authorities like the City of Kigali do provide some details on their website of public transport/bus timetables but the information is in text form and it is not clear how reliable the information is as private operators provide the services: https://www.kigalicity.gov.rw/spip.php?article1174&var_recherche=transport","Yes","No","anonymous","Pieter Colpaert","0"
"b0071ac4-4bb2-4aa4-9955-5f75d45b3596","global","2015-10-05T18:16:26","2015","ca","companies","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Federal Corporation Information","Industry Canada","Yes","Yes","It is not possible to browse through the database or access data without providing a search term, so I have penalised the registry as placing too many restrictions on data access.","It is possible to retrieve some company information by inputting a keyword of at least 3 characters into a search here: https://www.ic.gc.ca/app/scr/cc/CorporationsCanada/fdrlCrpSrch.html?locale=en_CA up to a maximum search size of 200 results. However, this places restrictions on what data can be obtained, even though the data does exist. More details below:
Because Canada is a federation of provinces and territories, these data would be considered incomplete, as companies are also registered, sometimes exclusively at those jurisdictions. A complete picture would require going to each jurisdiction and assessing their degree of openness. This response is solely for the federal / national level. These data are however generally incomplete, are destroyed every 7 years as per the tax act and are inconsistently managed. They are also not easily available to the public. While these national scale data meet many of the OKFN criteria, the fact that they are incomplete, inaccurate and destroyed every seven years is problematic, especially regarding transparency and investigations into money laundering. Furthermore, they are not readily accessible by the data producer, you can find a company but not a list of all the companies. Also, the Corporations Canada database ""does NOT include corporations created under financial legislation (such as financial institutions, insurance companies or loan and trust companies) or those created under provincial/territorial legislation or corporate legislation from another jurisdiction."" See also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_company_registers#Canada
The terms and conditions restrict commercial use, therefore the data is not openly licensed: https://www.ic.gc.ca/eic/site/icgc.nsf/eng/h_07033.html#ownership
(No change from 2014)","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Rebecca Sentance","15"
"03705468-21ef-4317-b8e3-8af85c6dca78","global","2015-09-19T11:22:28","2015","ch","companies","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Central Business Names Index","Federal Commercial Registry Office","Yes","Yes","It is not possible to browse through the database or access data without providing a search term, so I have penalised on the basis of being too restrictive. ","It is only possible to obtain companies data by inputting a search term into the search engine here: https://zefix.admin.ch/zfx-cgi/hrform.cgi/hraPage?alle_eintr=on&pers_sort=original&pers_num=0&language=4&col_width=366&amt=007 and it is not possible to browse or otherwise access the data without these restrictions.
Data is available for personal use: ""publication of the whole database, or of parts of it, by any means is strictly forbidden"". https://zefix.admin.ch/hrweb/eng/about.htm
There are daily summaries of new entries, changes and deletions to the register available to download on this page: https://zefix.admin.ch/shab/ but they are likely meant more as notifications than as a comprehensive resource.","Yes","No","Oleg Lavrovsky","Rebecca Sentance","15"
"300af7e2-269a-48bc-959f-c0f0d1804cad","global","2015-09-28T20:18:51","2015","br","companies","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Cadastro de Empresas","Data for the State of São Paulo is maintained by Jucesp: https://www.jucesponline.sp.gov.br/Default.aspx, every state has a similar institution. Currently, the Finance Ministry (Receita Federal) maintains a consultation service for all the companies in Brazil. In order to use it, citizens need to know the unique identifier: https://www.receita.fazenda.gov.br/pessoajuridica/cnpj/cnpjreva/cnpjreva_solicitacao.asp ","Yes","Yes","I am taking the submitter's word that the data exists, as it is difficult to verify without knowing a corporate number to input. However, the data is very difficult to access under such strict terms and I have penalised it on that basis.","Access to company data in Brazil - on a federal level - is very limited. In order to access data, one needs to know the identification number of the company. There is no service where people can search for the identification number if they only know the name.
On a state level every state has a company registration agency that maintains company data. Data for the state of São Paulo is available here: https://www.jucesponline.sp.gov.br/Default.aspx
There is also a dataset of the government supplier registry that can be queried by name, has the legal name and identifier as well as addresses of companies. However, it is not updated regularly. Last update: January 2015. Companies that have never either laid bids for procurement with the government (mandatory) or just registered themselves (voluntarily) are not listed. Not available in bulk but is openly licensed.
https://compras.dados.gov.br/fornecedores/v1/fornecedores.html","Yes","No","Augusto Herrmann","Rebecca Sentance","15"
"323507b4-0404-4e5c-a603-906b5ae13fcb","global","2015-09-20T22:12:01","2015","pt","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://publicacoes.mj.pt/",,,,"Publication Search","Publicações Ministério da Justiça","Yes","Yes","Added title and more details. I am being lenient with the lack of addresses provided as it could be argued that this does not constitute a companies register. I have decided to give it the benefit of the doubt.","Platform provides a search interface for company information. Search is heavily crippled by CAPTCHA and delays on multiple searches, features that severely limit scraping. The information provided is also limited and does not include address details.
It is possible to browse the registry without a search term by selecting other criteria, though to do so would take a very long time.","Yes","No","Ricardo Lafuente","Rebecca Sentance","45"
"f0dc9387-ede9-4748-96be-84d7bb291d59","global","2015-09-28T12:45:41","2015","gg","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.greg.gg/webCompSearch.aspx",,,,"Guernsey Registry - Company, Reserved Name & Limited Partnership Search","Commerce and Employment Department (enquiries@guernseyregistry.com )","Yes","Yes","Added details in details field and added dataset title."," The registry can be browsed by entering a ""%"" as search term, though the results are limited to 500. Users can click to view more company details and company documents.","Yes","No","Marcus Ferbrache","Rebecca Sentance","45"
"085944b3-3817-4ae5-b138-258532a9fcf5","global","2015-09-08T11:39:28","2015","am","companies","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://www.e-register.am/",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Changed status of dataset to ""unsure"" as it is not possible to verify enough data exists to qualify, without paying for it.","There is an online search feature available at: https://www.e-register.am/am/search which when a keyword is inputted can bring up names of companies and their founders. However, payment is required to access any more information, so it has not been possible to verify whether the data is held as required. ","Yes","No","Abraham Artashesyan","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"3256016e-e7c8-4213-9e87-be2ee2d6616d","global","2015-09-22T16:06:18","2015","ru","companies","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"EGRUL - unified government registry of companies","Federal Tax Service (Federalnaya Nalogovaya Sluzhba)","Yes","Yes","It is not possible to browse through the database or access data without providing a search term, therefore the registry does not qualify for most of the criteria.","Brief Description: Russian companies registry data is available to be searched via the https://egrul.nalog.ru website.
This data is up to date, free, but limited by company name, it's unique registration number, address and short list of latest registration actions without details. It is also not possible to obtain data without inputting a search term, which restricts users from browsing the database freely. Any financial information is provided with fee or via commercial services. Most important issues:
1. No machine readable data
2. No bulk download
3. No open licenses
4. Data hidden behind captcha
5. Public information is very limited.
Comment: Nothing changed since 2014","Yes","No","Ivan Begtin","Rebecca Sentance","15"
"4d169a75-fa86-4d52-9e09-b7d272e937af","global","2015-09-01T15:30:46","2015","kr","companies","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Internet Registry System - e-registry for real property registration","Supreme Court of Korea","Yes","Yes","I determined that the search feature is too restrictive, and also requires the installation of an unknown .exe file in order to test.","The list of registered companies is maintained in the official registry managed by the Supreme Court of Korea in accordance to the law. (https://www.iros.go.kr/ifrontservlet?cmd=INSEWelcomeNseFrmC) Even though the list can be searched on the Web, the whole list of registered companies is not available, and the information acquired by searching cannot be re-used since the information is copyrighted. It is also necessary to download and install an unknown file in order for the search feature to work.
Actually, the site insists linking to the site requires a pre-registration, but in my opinion, this is not the right that can be protected by the law.","Yes","No","James G. Boram Kim","Rebecca Sentance","15"
"57ec7736-3bfb-49cd-84c0-f802dcc33e21","global","2015-10-01T21:57:36","2015","it","companies","Yes","Unsure","No","Unsure","No","Unsure","Yes",,"Unsure",,,,,"The business register of the Italian Chambers of Commerce","Chambers of Commerce (Camere di Commercio)","Yes","Yes","Filled in the criteria according to the availability of bulk data (i.e. the whole data set) as the free search feature is too restrictive.","""Is it up to date?"": there are several inconsistencies.
You can access to individual entries via the online form with a search term, (https://www.registroimprese.it/richiedi-subito-documenti) but you can't download it. It's possible to pay to get the whole dataset via email. ","Yes","No","Francesca De Chiara","Rebecca Sentance","15"
"0d39b6e6-afe2-4e1e-b589-5d645ce53f96","global","2015-10-07T08:12:54","2015","il","companies","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Registrar of Companies","Ministry of Justice - the Israeli Corporations Authority","Yes","Yes","It is not possible to browse through the database or access data without providing a search term, therefore the registry does not qualify for most of the criteria.","Despite the official description, only basic data is available for for free, and obtaining it requires inputting a search with a minimum of 3 characters. Advanced details about a corporation (e.g. debt status, insolvency) require identification and payment.
It is stated that information online may also be missing, out of date or inaccurate.","Yes","No","anonymous","Rebecca Sentance","5"
"5750eb8e-3968-4f92-b3fc-18cf3590f948","global","2015-10-02T09:32:08","2015","ke","companies","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,"HTML",,,,,"Yes","Yes","I have changed the data's existence to ""uncertain"" based on submitter's comments. I also removed the portion about the Kenya Ports Authority as I could not find this data anywhere online.","Data on companies is not available online from Government sources it is available upon request at the respective government office. There is a fee for the 'search' to de done and it is not clear in what format the requesting person receives the data. I am also not sure if the data at the offices is fully digital though this could be possible and unfortunately I cannot verify in good time.
[According to Ahmed - No changes from 2013]
Data on company registry is available from other non-governmental sources such as the Credit Risk Monitor (https://www.crmz.com/Directory/CountryKE.htm).","Yes","No","anonymous","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"25e28808-63bd-45f5-acdd-d562e1e12eca","global","2015-09-25T12:12:51","2015","al","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.qkr.gov.al/nrc/Kerko_Per_Subjekt.aspx",,,,"Company search - There is a historical abstract for each company.","National Registration Center","Yes","Yes","Added details on browsing the database and on extract downloads.","The registry is not updated very often as a result of delay on the publishing of financial statement from companies. Users can browse the registry by entering a ""%"" as search term into any of the fields.
To see company details, it is necessary to download a Historical Extract or Simple Extract in .doc form. ","Yes","No","Blerta Tuci","Rebecca Sentance","35"
"490916f1-1d2f-4a7b-a2a8-02a885301059","global","2015-10-02T13:15:11","2015","rw","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://org.rdb.rw/inf/Public/Products/EntSearch.aspx",,,,"Office of the Registrar General: Information Services","Rwanda Development Bank","Yes","Yes","I have determined that the database is publicly available and for free, as it can be browsed by inputting a blank search. Therefore I have filled out criteria and details accordingly.","Rwanda's company register is held and maintained by the Rwanda Development Board (RDB). Their website is https://org.rdb.rw/?page_id=203. The register can be browsed by users by selecting Enterprise Search (https://org.rdb.rw/inf/Public/Products/EntSearch.aspx) and entering a space as the search term, or else searching for a keyword. The database provides company name, registration number, registration date and address details.","Yes","No","anonymous","Rebecca Sentance","45"
"90f913ef-37c6-46f5-96c9-deae1664b218","global","2015-08-31T14:30:35","2015","jo","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.ccd.gov.jo/e-services/home/db",,,,"Query companies","Companies Control Department","Yes","Yes","Added information re: browsing the register. Have determined that data is not machine readable.","The Companies Control Department register can be searched for free on its website, using a wide range of queries including company name, trade name, company capital, board member name, etc. It is possible to browse the register by inputting a blank search (""%"") although an upper limit of search results is imposed, 500 in some places and 250 in others. Clicking on a company's name will bring up more detailed information.","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Rebecca Sentance","35"
"31e48919-894d-41ae-aa5d-8fb2b750b781","global","2015-09-15T09:58:37","2015","dz","companies","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Added more details about looking up company names and it is not possible to determine the existence of the data.","The CNRC (Centre National du Registre de Commerce) appears to hold companies data, but it has not been possible to determine what kind, or how detailed it is. It is only possible to bring up a list of company names (either by inputting a keyword, or a space as a blank search) using the online search feature. https://www.cnrc.org.dz/fr/src/recherche.php
The whole database is available under conditions and paying fees, though the cost is not specified, and it is still unknown what data this would constitute. https://www.cnrc.org.dz/fr/services/index3.html
No official information about the frequency of database updates.","Yes","No","Aldja Computer","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"fc0fbc30-46d5-4ce0-bae2-d25898163b24","global","2015-09-25T10:33:35","2015","kz","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://stat.gov.kz/faces/wcnav_externalId/homeNumbersBusinessRegistersReestr?lang=ru&_afrLoop=15049312718668981#%40%3F_afrLoop%3D15049312718668981%26lang%3Dru%26_adf.ctrl-state%3Dlbr7pkjyl_55","EXCEL (xls)",,,"Excel documents published in bulk for each region. The information shows: unique identifier (BIN), full name, occupation, city/town located","Statistics Committee of the Ministry of National Economics","Yes","Yes","I have marked data as available in bulk as it is still possible to obtain the whole dataset quite easily - dividing into regions is not uncommon.","The information provided by government officials in Kazakhstan (by default) is open for reuse, publishing as cited by the law. However, it is unclear whether this extends to company documents. The information provided is uploaded in bulk by each region, but you can not access it all in one file. ","Yes","No","Nazerke Akhmetzhanova","Rebecca Sentance","70"
"ea29ab7d-3554-4412-a271-1e39b2d08cfb","global","2015-08-30T14:12:13","2015","sa","companies","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Changed dataset's existence to ""unsure"" based on submitter's comments.","The Ministry of Commerce and Industry provides a web based system for querying the company register (https://eservices.mci.gov.sa/Eservices/Verification/PageVerify.aspx?docId=3). However, this system retrieves data by using the commercial registration number of a company in order to retrieve data about it. Due to the lack of a valid commercial registration number, it could not be verified if (a) the system works, and (b) it contains the data required for satisfying the requirements of this question.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"b4563d81-43ef-4227-a303-2b3e939a4686","global","2015-10-04T18:01:42","2015","tr","companies","Yes","Unsure","No","Yes","No","Unsure","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.ticaretsicil.gov.tr/english/genel/veritabani.php",,,,"Turkish Trade Registry Gazette ","The Union of Chambers & Commodity Exchanges of Turkey (ttsgmd@tobb.org.tr)","Yes","Yes","Filled in criteria according to the paid bulk data which can be obtained, as opposed to the limited company name search.","It is possible to obtain in full information held by the Trade Registry Gazette, from 1992 until the present day, in exchange for a fee. The data can be obtained online but the format is unknown.
It is also possible to perform a free search for company names, mostly for the purposes of checking the availability of a name. A search term of at least 5 characters is required. https://www.ticaretsicilgazetesi.gov.tr/english/sorgu_acik.php","Yes","No","Pinar Dag","Rebecca Sentance","30"
"4999b4d2-0703-44d4-9784-730e6439be99","global","2015-09-15T12:39:32","2015","ko","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.arbk.org/en/Home",,,,"Registry","Kosova Business Registration Agency infoarbk@rks-gov.net","Yes","Yes","I have marked the open license status of the register as uncertain as I am not convinced that company data falls under the category of official or government documents.","The companies register of Kosovo can be searched through, or browsed by inputting a blank search. The registry contains the name, address and type of company; there is a field for register number, but for some reason it appears blank for all companies.
The licensing status of the information is uncertain; Article 12 of Law No. 04/L-065 on copyright and related rights indicates that public documents such as government publications are not subject to copyright, but this may not apply to company documents or data. https://gzk.rks-gov.net/ActDocumentDetail.aspx?ActID=2787","Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Rebecca Sentance","45"
"bcba5da5-a6e5-4190-acfa-7c05d7f723a0","global","2015-09-15T06:43:31","2015","kg","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://register.minjust.gov.kg/register/SearchAction.seam?logic=and&cid=204",,,,,"The Ministry of Justice","Yes","Yes","Data is not machine readable due to being in HTML format. Added details on browsing the register and viewing companies registration documents.","The Ministry of Justice has the full database of all the companies registered in a country. The information can be obtained by entering name of the company, registry number or identification number. Alternatively it is possible to bring up a list of all companies by inputting ""%"" as the search term. Clicking in the furthest right column allows users to view registration documentation and download it as a PDF.","Yes","No","Azamat Tokhtaev","Rebecca Sentance","45"
"9e1d8888-a63d-49ab-8bb9-da37098765cf","global","2015-09-18T20:54:14","2015","is","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://rsk.is/fyrirtaekjaskra/",,,,"Search Businesses","Ríkisskattstjóri (RSK) rsk@rsk.is","Yes","Yes","Added details re: browsing the database. All else fine.","Companies data can be accessed via a web form (search), or browsed by inputting a blank search (space), though possibly not in its entirety. Clicking on the company will reveal more details including limited information on financial statements and VAT number.
Bulk data is available under a very restrictive licence and for a fee.
There are database rights associated with the collection, pursuant to Copyright Law.","Yes","No","Páll Hilmarsson","Rebecca Sentance","45"
"3006c942-be01-4bd9-ac9a-b9c24717647d","global","2015-10-12T17:12:19","2015","tj","companies","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://www.andoz.tj/index.php/nalogoplatelshchikam/elektronnye-uslugi/informatsiya-po-gosudarstvnnomu-reestru/reestr-yuridicheskikh-lits",,"https://www.andoz.tj/",,,,"Yes","Yes","Included justification in details section - this is a tax register, not a companies register.","Tajikistan has a ""Legal register of taxpayers"" online which can be searched and browsed (by submitting a blank search) and includes information on private entities and legal entities which pay tax.
The data license is open according to the legislation on access to information - https://www.andoz.tj/
It includes entity names, tax numbers and registration dates, but is unarguably still a tax register and not a companies register. Therefore it is not possible to say with certainty whether Tajikistan has the data as detailed by the Index.
https://www.andoz.tj/index.php/nalogoplatelshchikam/elektronnye-uslugi/informatsiya-po-gosudarstvnnomu-reestru/reestr-yuridicheskikh-lits","Yes","No","anonymous","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"69616144-c14e-45fb-9c14-b51be92bc8f8","global","2015-09-28T14:33:41","2015","ht","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://cnmp.gouv.ht/marchespublicssanspassation/",,,,"Publication des marchés passés","Commission Nationale des Marchés Publics","Yes","Yes","Submission updated.","The Commission Nationale des Marchés Publics (National Commission on Public Procurement) publishes data on tenders and awarded contracts but only in html format and without any proper open data license. There is, moreover, no evidence that the datasets are complete and up to date.","Yes","No","Pierre Chrzanowski","Georg Neumann","35"
"607a6997-af85-43aa-8f89-8acc5041bef5","global","2015-09-28T11:01:54","2015","ge","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://enreg.reestri.gov.ge/main.php?m=new_index&state=search",,,,,"National Agency of the Public Registry, info@napr.gov.ge","Yes","Yes","I have changed the licensing to ""unsure"", based on the submitter's comments that it is normally public domain information but there is no licensing information included in this data set.","Data is available for free; no charge is required for any site functions.
A search interface to access the full data is available at the link given. It is possible to browse the whole database by submitting a blank search, and clicking to reveal more detailed company information (after submitting a CAPTCHA). However, address information does not seem to be included.
The data is not machine-readable because most important data, including data on company ownership and directors, is in PDFs and/or DjVu format.
The data is not available in bulk. Transparency International Georgia (an NGO) runs a web scraper which republishes the information in a machine-readable format with an API at https://www.companyinfo.ge/en/ . However, this information is not timely, and the Public Registry recently installed a CAPTCHA which prevents the web scraper from functioning.
All government-generated information in Georgia is legally in the public domain. However, there is no licensing information included with this data set.
The data set pulls directly from the central database of company registrations and is therefore always up to date.","Yes","No","Eric Barrett","Rebecca Sentance","45"
"72e52c95-1442-41d1-a2db-5866b85ab969","global","2015-09-04T18:05:38","2015","jm","companies","Yes","Unsure","No","Unsure","No","Unsure","No",,"Yes",,,,,"The Companies Office of Jamaica which originally formed part of the Registrar General's Department was established as a separate Department in 1975 under the then Ministry of Marketing and Commerce, now the Ministry of Industry, Investment and Commerce with responsibility for the day to day administration of the following subjects: companies, business names","Companies Office of Jamaica","Yes","Yes","To truly obtain company details it is necessary to pay for the data, thus I have updated the criteria according to the paid data and not the free company search, which is not substantial enough to count.","Data is held by the Companies Office of Jamaica. It is possible to manually search for companies by name, which will provide the company number, name, industry and status but no further details. There is no browsable or downloadable dataset.
The URL https://www.orcjamaica.com/CompanySearch.aspx provides a search engine and let's say you enter `Sutherland & Gabbidon Enterprise` a list of companies from any of the names will be printed. Sutherland & Gabbidon Enterprise began in the year 2015. However, the data via PDF format or to print online is not for free.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Rebecca Sentance","15"
"3438e8f2-d24d-46a3-962a-70edac1d0335","global","2015-09-18T18:42:47","2015","pe","companies","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,"Directorio Nacional de Personas Jurídicas","Superintendencia Nacional de los Registros Públicos","Yes","Yes","The original submission was for Ministry of Health data and not a companies register. I have replaced it a government companies register that I found and filled in fields accordingly.","SUNARP holds the official companies registry for Peru, but the only way to obtain data from it is with a search term of at least 3 characters. (https://www.sunarp.gob.pe/RelacionS_01.asp) It is not possible to freely browse or download the data. Also, full address details are not given. ","Yes","No","Victoria Meneses Carriónizette L","Rebecca Sentance","5"
"d97b4d61-b13c-413b-b6ba-9233a2fcca18","global","2015-09-27T11:19:29","2015","ma","companies","Yes","Unsure","No","No","No","Unsure","Unsure",,"Yes",,,,,,"Office Marocain de la Propriété Industrielle et Commerciale (OMPIC)","Yes","Yes","The information exists. However, the version that would fulfil the requirements of the companies register requires payment, and it is unclear what form it takes or how to obtain it.","Data is not really shared : at directinfo.ma (the e-service side of OMPIC), there is a form to fill (web-based query) where to enter the search criteria. (https://www.directinfo.ma/fr/fc) Only very limited information on each company is given; for any further detail, the visitor needs to pay. The pricing policy is available here: https://www.directinfo.ma/directinfo/DownloadDocPDFServlet?type_doc=tarif (PDF, in French).","Yes","No","Chadi Nanaa","Rebecca Sentance","15"
"970b6c9d-49e0-42cf-ba14-e6018f84f0bb","global","2015-09-17T20:04:09","2015","gd","companies","Yes","Unsure","No","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,"Corporate Affairs and Intellectual Property Office Company Registry","Corporate Affairs and Intellectual Property Office","Yes","Yes","I have changed most criteria to ""unsure"" as it is really impossible to know what the data consists of or how it is accessed. I am taking the submitter's word for it that it is possible to obtain the data in this way, but I can't be sure that it is free either. However if you have to submit a request, it is definitely not publicly available.","To access the information, a formal request needs to be submitted to Legal Affairs/ the Corporate Affairs of Intellectual Property Office. This can be done though email to annettehenry7@gmail.com OR
legalaffairs@spiceisland.com","Yes","No","anonymous","Rebecca Sentance","5"
"052fcd97-dc3b-4077-8267-f3dd56d06d9f","global","2015-09-28T15:38:27","2015","fr","companies","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Yes","No",,"Yes",,"xml, csv",,,"SIRENE Official company register, accessible under payment","INSEE","Yes","Yes","All seems fine.","The whole bulk data is available online under highly restricted conditions for 70 374 € :
- https://www.sirene.fr/sirene/public/static/tarifs-rediffusion
- https://www.sirene.fr/static-resources/doc/redifsirR2a.pdf ","Yes","No","Regards Citoyens","Rebecca Sentance","35"
"d0e999f9-b64d-4d02-8bc3-651cd98f16c6","global","2015-09-29T02:14:44","2015","ec","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure",,"Yes","https://appscvs.supercias.gob.ec/portalInformacion/sector_societario.zul","HTML, XML, PDF, CSV",,,,"Superintendencia de Compañías, Valores y Seguros","Yes","Yes","Website is now working again and it is possible to verify that file formats are the same as last year's. However I am unsure about the availability of bulk download, as the download has yet to complete while I am reviewing so I cannot see what it consists of.","Information about companies is available though an online database. The registry can be browsed through page by page and saved in a range of formats both machine readable and not. (This action takes some time to complete and it is unclear whether it saves the whole database or a single page).","Yes","No","Eduardo Bejar","Rebecca Sentance","60"
"4bc41a5f-283d-4085-a304-c457db846bc2","global","2015-09-28T13:31:33","2015","py","companies","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://marangatu.set.gov.py/eset/perfilPublicoContribIService.do","txt","https://www.hacienda.gov.py/web-hacienda/index.php?c=109",,,,"Yes","Yes","Have changed dataset existence to unsure as all links are broken.","At the moment, all the links which used to lead to data on Paraguay are not working. There was a company search feature in which you could obtain data by knowing the Company Registry ID (RUC), but this link was not working at the time of data review. https://marangatu.set.gov.py/eset/perfilPublicoContribIService.do
Formerly, the data was also available for bulk download at
https://www.set.gov.py/pset/hgxpp001?6,18,543,O,S,0,MNU;E;106;11;MNU
or
https://www.mic.gov.py/GuiaIndustrial/
However, these two links are also now broken.","Yes","No","Juan Pane","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"491d4644-6316-4054-a0ef-b9f9c020b505","global","2015-09-27T21:10:03","2015","uy","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://catalogodatos.gub.uy/dataset/registro-de-empresas-industriales","CSV","https://www3.ine.gub.uy:82/Anda4/index.php/opendata",,"Industrial Companies Registry","INE","Yes","Yes","As the data on small and medium enterprises still cannot be accessed, I have filled out the criteria for the industrial companies register, and included information on SME register (plus fusion table links) in the details box.","The Register for Industrial Companies only accounts for a minority of companies in Uruguay, but is freely downloadable in bulk and available as open data. It is updated monthly.
Previously, it was also possible to download data on Small and Medium Enterprises (which account for the other 80-90% of companies), but the URL currently seems to be down. https://www3.ine.gub.uy:82/Anda4/index.php/catalog/677
However, the data on small and medium enterprises is available in the following Fusion Tables:
https://www.google.com/fusiontables/data?docid=146Oe8VPNVodEEXydYnWKJkjXVjvjYZ6ulA9jZN41#rows:id=1
https://www.google.com/fusiontables/data?docid=14QRQ0B0avlPeI5QV89-VWPc27k-H0nu582dYMO4H#map:id=3
This data corresponds to the year 2014.","Yes","Yes","Daniel Carranza","Rebecca Sentance","100"
"7035c1e4-a64e-4b78-bbc0-c3c7903495e7","global","2015-09-18T15:14:54","2015","ro","land","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://geoportal.ancpi.ro/geoportal/imobile/Harta.html","vector format (?)",,,"Imobile ANCPI","Agentia Nationala de Cadastru si Publicitate Imobiliara","Yes","Yes","ok","According to the Partnership Agreement Romania-EU 2014-2020, the data is not in digital format and Romania requested financial support to digitize it. ","Yes","No","Ovidiu Voicu","Codrina Maria Ilie","45"
"4599e4fe-1bc7-43e9-8830-245119d8dffb","global","2015-09-24T06:23:22","2015","bf","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://cci.bf/?q=fr/entreprise",,,,"The chamber of trade and industry have a database called fichier NERE (fichier National des Entreprises et des Regroupements d’Entreprises) that contain all registered company in Burkina Faso. ","Chambre de commerce et d'industrie du Burkina (dpie@cci.bf)","Yes","Yes","Added info on browsing dataset and what company details are included. ","The chamber of trade and industry have a database of all the registered companies in Burkina Faso. On his website there is a page where information related to the companies can be search, but all the dataset cannot be downloaded. Beneath the search box it is also possible to browse the register page by page. Clicking ""Voir les détails"" will give more detailed information about that company, e.g. trading name, category, RCCM number. Full address details are not always included.
It it said (on the website) that those who need the whole dataset must send an email. We contacted the chamber of trade and industry related to the dataset and they let us know that the reusable format of the whole dataset must be purchased.","Yes","No","Idriss TINTO","Rebecca Sentance","35"
"971ed009-06a1-4b6c-b77c-b7fee471b062","global","2015-09-24T12:26:51","2015","dz","land","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","We were not able to find this data","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"3ddd9c6c-0d13-4e83-a29d-e6f6b19dc67b","global","2015-09-17T15:13:04","2015","ru","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Yes","No",,"Yes",,"XML",,,"Russian property cadastr","The Federal Service for State Registration, Cadastre and Cartography (Rosreestr)","Yes","Yes","ok","The Federal Service for State Registration, Cadastre and Cartography (Rosreestr) provides online service to get up to date information about land ownership.
This service is:
- public
- available online
- up to date
- not openly licensed
- not free, require personal information and payment for each request
- not bulk, only request per object based (https://rosreestr.ru/wps/portal/online_request)","Yes","No","Ivan Begtin","Codrina Maria Ilie","35"
"67bbe610-9918-4052-b890-c68c18cfe757","global","2015-09-27T23:50:06","2015","bw","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Yes","No",,"Unsure",,"shapefiles, CSV, PDF etc",,,,"Ministry of lands and housing","Yes","Yes","ok","Data available on request, unlikely to get access to bulk, my personal applications for sub datasets were rejcted in the past","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","25"
"3c4ac8a2-547e-4166-943a-5441b7736d29","global","2015-09-24T10:20:15","2015","mk","land","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","No",,"Unsure","https://gis.katastar.gov.mk/arec","ArcGIS Coverage",,,"Interactive map","AREC (Agency For Real Estate Cadastre)","Yes","Yes","Metadata is available https://www.katastar.gov.mk/userfiles/file/Specifikacija-JICA%2025000.pdf","AREC's interactive map fulfills all but one of the criteria: the information about the names of the owners of the parcels are not available.
It is otherwise, easy to navigate, can be displayed on different backgrounds, points of interest can be toggled on or off, agricultural parcels can be displayed etc.","Yes","No","Metamorphosis Foundation","Codrina Maria Ilie","35"
"4f883476-85d2-4a6e-b175-1f5d1a328800","global","2015-10-04T11:39:38","2015","az","companies","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I have determined that the dataset does not exist such as we are looking for. There is a tax register, which is not the same as a companies register but contains company names, so I have provided details about it.","There is not evidence of a companies register such as we are looking for. The Ministry of Taxes has a ""state register of business entities"" which is searchable, but it is geared towards taxes, thus it only provides company names and Taxpayer Identification Number - not company registration number or any other company details. https://www.e-taxes.gov.az/ebyn/commersialChecker.jsp","Yes","No","Codrina Maria Ilie","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"db18187e-6cac-4093-9186-a8867c08c8c6","global","2015-08-31T10:27:31","2015","lb","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://cr.justice.gov.lb/search/res_list.aspx",,,,"Commercial Register Search","Minister of Justice / Commercial Register ","Yes","Yes","Added details on how to browse the register. Have deleted comment from last year re: foreign companies data as very little useful data is contained within the files.","The ministry of Justice has a Commercial Register site which provides the ability to search within company registers. The register can be browsed by submitting a blank search (space). There is no way to download the data as bulk. We found results for companies registered in 2015, yet there is no metadata or any other means to check how frequent the information is updated. The site and its content have a non-open license.
https://cr.justice.gov.lb/search/res_list.aspx
Here is an example for one of the results
https://cr.justice.gov.lb/search/result.aspx?id=1000119598
It shows the Name of company, Unique identifier of the company (1019890 here), Company address, as well as other information such as capital, date of registration, its legal form and names of equity holders.
","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Rebecca Sentance","35"
"4afbb571-8fef-4a85-a73f-5ec36278f43d","global","2015-09-25T12:21:05","2015","kz","land","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","We have a Land Codex that states that population has rights to know the information about land ownership. But we could not find source, where the land ownership is shown on the map. ","Yes","No","Nazerke Akhmetzhanova","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"55eba01f-4189-4570-a960-368e7ee8d5fb","global","2015-09-14T20:39:46","2015","pt","land","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","Existing data is based on a mid-20th century survey; it has been scanned and the PDF made available on the DGTerritório, but it's useless. Efforts to make a digital survey are ongoing (with some cities covered like Lisbon or Setúbal) but far from complete.","Yes","No","Ricardo Lafuente","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"69f6ac7a-422c-4952-92d2-fd7a5962d7db","global","2015-09-21T09:38:25","2015","im","land","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Unsure","Yes","Unsure",,"Yes","https://www.gov.im/maps/","vector format (?)",,,"Land Registry","Land Registry, Isle of Man Government","Yes","Yes","ok","https://www.gov.im/maps/
MANNGIS shows land boundaries and land size at a national level with same day updates via ESRI GIS
land ownership is available free of charge via public terminal at the Land Registry -- the division has been merged with the Companies Registry and the offline system will be migrated to an online system in the next 6 months to assist estate agents and law firms with out of hours property and land searches
","Yes","No","Graeme Jones","Codrina Maria Ilie","40"
"6cf58e4d-3fba-4ccf-885e-cb799894d2ac","global","2015-09-30T22:05:20","2015","tc","procurement","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission updated.","While tender information is [available][1], the link to the awards is not active.
[1]: https://www.gov.tc/government-tenders#","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Georg Neumann","0"
"e48a93de-d1b7-4a15-9243-2838130a0717","global","2015-10-26T22:48:48","2015","sy","procurement","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission updated. Information not available.","In Syria this kind of data should be available for public by the department or ministry who asks the public to apply for tenders.
Reviewers comment:
Couldn't find the data, and I doubt they release awards details ","Yes","No","Georg Neumann","Georg Neumann","0"
"4f26653f-8128-4c18-8542-89d0662fb309","global","2015-09-25T13:07:23","2015","al","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://app.gov.al/ep/2015_Arkiva_e_Buletineve.aspx",,,,"Procurement Tenders","Public Procurement Agency","Yes","Yes","Submission correct.",,"Yes","No","Blerta Tuci","Georg Neumann","45"
"9afc5634-c7b3-4ebc-9d3b-c5a64ff45208","global","2015-09-25T13:59:01","2015","do","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.dgii.gov.do/app/WebApps/Consultas/rnc/DGII_RNC.zip",,,,"Listado de todos los RNC","Dirección General de Impuestos Internos","Yes","Yes","I have marked the data as not machine readable because when I checked the file format, it was a .TXT file and not .CSV.",,"Yes","No","Eliaquín Encarnación","Rebecca Sentance","55"
"49ea2243-7845-444a-a182-d063f930edd7","global","2015-10-08T09:42:18","2015","no","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.norge.no/data/registerenheten-i-br%C3%B8nn%C3%B8ysund/enhetsregisteret","CSV, JSON, JSONP, YAML, XML","https://data.norge.no/nlod/no",,,"The Brønnøysund Register Centre","Yes","Yes","Looks good to me.","Since the 2014 index, the data sets are available directly from the publisher, The Brønnøysund Register Centre, in addition to Difi's data hotel. Follow link to dataset for more information.
Through the last couple of years, the data set has been expanded with more fields, e.g. number of employees.","Yes","Yes","Mor Rubinstein","Rebecca Sentance","100"
"2024163f-ff33-4912-b8d7-403e0c32595b","global","2015-08-31T15:49:24","2015","eg","companies","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.tpegypt.gov.eg/Arabic/EgyDirectory.aspx",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I agree with the commenters that the information source given doesn't constitute a real companies database, and I have been unable to find another. ","It has not been possible to find an official Egyptian companies register or database that contains comprehensive company information.
The Egyptian International Trade Point (https://www.tpegypt.gov.eg/Arabic/EgyDirectory.asp) has a companies search feature of sorts, but it appears to be geared around buying and selling products rather than information about companies.","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"51ef6d90-26ff-4b25-958d-10db0b72907b","global","2015-09-27T08:49:51","2015","lv","land","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Unsure",,"Yes","https://www.kadastrs.lv","vector format (?)",,,,"Valsts zemes dienests","Yes","Yes","OK.","The data is available in the https://www.kadastrs.lv website. Some of the data can be viewed online without restrictions, more detailed information can be accessed and downloaded after paying a fee.","Yes","No","Toms Ceļmillers","Codrina Maria Ilie","45"
"c43514a0-d752-4a61-8308-bc05765c616b","global","2015-09-15T15:20:39","2015","th","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.go.th/DatasetDetail.aspx?id=a4638ea2-3813-4679-9bbf-b013f7519809","Excel","https://data.go.th/LicenceDetails.aspx?id=3a937417-8ccb-42a1-8923-a920851008db&ReturnId=a4638ea2-3813-4679-9bbf-b013f7519809",,"Government Procurement Report October 2014 to September 2015","Eletronic Government Agency","Yes","Yes","Submission correct.","Many of government procurement datasets were release on data.go.th ","Yes","Yes","Klaikong Vaidhyakarn","Georg Neumann","100"
"72836634-c492-4328-8abc-3fbd64472a39","global","2015-09-24T21:13:35","2015","vc","companies","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I have marked the dataset as non-existent as the submitter has not replied and I cannot find any evidence of it.","It has been difficult to determine the existence of a companies register on the Commercial and Intellectual Property Office website. (https://www.cipo.gov.vc/) There is mention of an ""Inspection of documents"" fee which could refer to inspecting company documents, but this is not certain. (https://www.cipo.gov.vc/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=54&Itemid=38) ","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"4e0a98c4-ab37-47b7-b30a-07a8124dd7ce","global","2015-09-29T00:03:57","2015","pa","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.panamacompra.gob.pa/portal/transparencia.aspx",,,,"Panama Compra: Licitaciones Públicas para todos. Simple, eficaz y transparente.","Gobierno de Panama","Yes","Yes","Submission updated with tender information.",,"Yes","No","HAMZAH HAJI","Georg Neumann","45"
"f2702542-e192-4879-bf0d-c9747280fe20","global","2015-09-08T13:53:31","2015","sa","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.csc.org.sa/Arabic/OurServices/TendersAndContracts/Pages/AllTenders.aspx",,,,"Tenders and awards (signed contracts).","Council of Saudi Chambers","Yes","Yes","Submission correct.","The Council of Saudi Chambers publishes the [details of government tenders][1] and the details of the contracts signed by the government in regard to these tenders - i.e. [the awards][2]). The details of the project, company, and contract value is available. However, the websites does not show the date of tender or award and it appears to be out of date.
[1]: https://www.csc.org.sa/Arabic/OurServices/TendersAndContracts/Pages/AllTenders.aspx
[2]: https://www.csc.org.sa/Arabic/OurServices/TendersAndContracts/Pages/AllContracts.aspx","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Georg Neumann","35"
"e03ba796-ff15-466d-9e97-c7d3f601f08d","global","2015-09-28T21:18:11","2015","sv","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.comprasal.gob.sv/comprasal_web/det_resultados_01.jsf","CSV, Excel",,,"Comprasal","Ministerio de Hacienda","Yes","Yes","Submission correct. Updated information on availability.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Georg Neumann","70"
"f2f71b1d-9dd2-4293-823e-5ffae11f1f60","global","2015-09-08T13:31:19","2015","qa","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.ctc.gov.qa/tender-en.aspx",,,,"Tender and awards information","Central Tenders Committee","Yes","Yes","Information includes recent awards, a strong indication the information is kept up-to-date.","The Central Tender Committee of Qatar publishes information about the tenders for government projects and the awards for these tenders. The tender data appears to be up to date and includes the tender number, type, subject matter of the tender, client, closing date, expected value, tendering format, and tender fees. The tender award data includes the tender name, type, subject matter of the tender, client, closing date, winning company name, and accepted value. However, it is difficult to verify if the award data is up to date because the awards are not ordered chronologically. ","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Georg Neumann","45"
"052977d7-2c28-425e-b051-e3f959636f8b","global","2015-10-07T16:03:53","2015","tt","companies","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","No","No","Yes",,"Unsure","https://rgd.legalaffairs.gov.tt/",,,,"Companies Registry Online","Ministry Of Legal Affairs","Yes","Yes","I have marked data as not publicly available as it requires payment to access.","Data is available through bulk download, however there is a paywall. Any individual interested in gaining access to the dataset must pay per download.","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Rebecca Sentance","25"
"ab10c490-230b-4f6c-824a-0c43dacfadd9","global","2015-09-14T21:14:58","2015","pt","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://base.gov.pt","XLS ",,,"Contratos Públicos","Base.gov.pt","Yes","Yes","Submission updated on license.","There is no reference on the site to the terms of usage or license of the published information.","Yes","No","Ricardo Lafuente","Georg Neumann","60"
"ba3da84f-c348-4fd1-8daa-c4ea2087cc8a","global","2015-09-20T20:37:21","2015","es","companies","Yes","Unsure","No","Unsure","No","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,"Registro Mercantil","Registro Mercantil Central","Yes","Yes","Marked as ""unsure"" whether data is in a digital format and online, as there isn't any way to verify these two details.","An user account is needed to access the Company Register of Spain. Accessing a company file isn't freely available. https://www.rmc.es/privado/LoginConvenio.aspx?ReturnUrl=%2fsociedadesInscritas%2fNombreSocial.aspx","Yes","No","José Félix Ontañón","Rebecca Sentance","5"
"72f6f1a6-c9c1-4547-b616-b152b703f07f","global","2015-09-26T22:00:13","2015","pr","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www2.pr.gov/subasta/Pages/subastas.aspx",,,,"Registro Unico de Subastas. It is the official central registry of notices of auctions from all agencies of the Executive Branch and Public Corporations of the Government of Puerto Rico.","Administración de Asuntos Generales (pr.gov)","Yes","Yes","Submission updated on qeustions in doubt.","The Administración de Asuntos generales has a link to this website https://www2.pr.gov/subasta/Pages/subastas.aspx , the unique registry for auctions; you can search for auction information by auction number, awarding agency, or contract type. For closed auctions, this link does not include who the contract was awarded to or the value of the award.
The Administración de Asuntos Generales, has a separate registry of awarded contracts, which includes the scanned original contracts-- these contracts include auction number, amount awarded, etc:
https://www.asg.pr.gov/Compras-y-Suministros/Contratos
The information is there, but it is not easy to match. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Georg Neumann","45"
"bc5e10b6-c40d-42a6-951a-85a721d9ae8a","global","2015-09-08T17:44:51","2015","ae","companies","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I have marked the existence of the data as ""unsure"" based on the fact that it only meets some of the criteria.","The Ministry of Economy of the UAE has an online system for querying the unified central register of businesses in the UAE. ( https://cbls.economy.gov.ae/ ) The feature for searching for the business name displays the name of the business, its unique identify, and the date of its registration and expiration. The address is not available from this form. There is another search option for looking up business activities ( https://cbls.economy.gov.ae/BASearch.aspx ) but it is difficult to use this system to verify if it shows the address of the business or not.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"ad0b6d28-1767-49b4-853f-9eac34e3536c","global","2015-09-18T19:07:36","2015","ag","companies","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Have marked dataset as non-existence based on lack of any evidence of one.","The most likely body responsible is the Financial Services Regulatory Commission (https://www.fsrc.gov.ag/), but there is no evidence of a companies registry on that site.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"1c0a9aff-25f1-4e9b-a0bd-5272e768833a","global","2015-09-12T05:37:48","2015","jp","companies","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","No","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.touki.or.jp/",,,,,"Minji Houmu Kyoukai","Yes","Yes","I have marked dataset as not publicly available as it requires payment to access.","PDF, so not machine readable. No bulk data, no open license, charge to access data. ","Yes","No","Satoshi IIDA","Rebecca Sentance","25"
"06f50676-62f1-4567-a9ab-ed783be68fa9","global","2015-09-28T05:56:38","2015","ph","companies","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I am marking the data as non-existent based on the submitter's comments (and because I can also not find evidence of it).","No data found from https://www.sec.gov.ph/ nor anywhere in the official government website https://www.gov.ph/about/gov/","Yes","No","anonymous","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"b657a669-ef6c-4253-814f-c7455c69b4b8","global","2015-09-25T14:29:07","2015","de","companies","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","No","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.unternehmensregister.de/ureg/",,,,"Company Register - The central platform for the storage of company data",,"Yes","Yes","I have marked the data as not publicly available as payment is required, which places a restriction on access. ","The company register is protected by data base rights and might not be reused without permission. Original License notice states: ""Das Unternehmensregister genießt Datenbankschutz nach § 87a ff. UrhG und darf insoweit nicht ohne Zustimmung des Verlags außerhalb der gesetzlichen Vorschriften genutzt werden.""
No change from 2013 and 2014.","Yes","No","walter palmetshofer","Rebecca Sentance","25"
"5d994b25-6a39-4204-bd82-0892282a648e","global","2015-09-25T08:14:54","2015","za","companies","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Unsure","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Request for Corporate Info or Perusal of files (Companies and Close Corporations)","Companies and Intellectual Property Commission","Yes","Yes","Updated title/description and added link. ","Users must subscribe and pay for access to company data such as directors, addresses and registration details. https://www.cipc.co.za/index.php/find-enterprise-ip-informatr/moo2/public-disclosure/","Yes","No","Greg Kempe","Rebecca Sentance","20"
"7e6443e9-4c94-4316-9ccb-ad1de3b0d43f","global","2015-09-10T14:37:10","2015","at","companies","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","No","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.justiz.gv.at/web2013/html/default/2c9484852308c2a601240b693e1c0860.de.html",,,,"Company Register","Ministry of Justice (company register) and Ministry of Economy (trade register)","Yes","Yes","I have marked the data as not publicly available and not free based on the submitter's comments and the information on the website.","Access to the corporate registry is only possible through several private actors who obtained a license from the government to sell access to the A) company register (https://www.justiz.gv.at/web2013/html/default/2c9484852308c2a601240b693e1c0860.de.html) and B) trade register (https://www.bmwfw.gv.at/Unternehmen/Gewerbe/Seiten/ZentralesGewerberegister.aspx). Among these service providers is now also the fully state-owned Wiener Zeitung, the Republic's official gazette, which provides free access on https://firmenmonitor.at. There are several private operators that, like the Wiener Zeitung, offer free access to corporate ownership data, applying an add-supported business model or charge for access to financial corporate data. But none of the free offers provides an official extract of the data, and there appear to be some discrepancies in terms of how current the datasets of various providers are. ","Yes","No","Martin Kaltenböck","Rebecca Sentance","25"
"cda87950-070e-4742-9810-b7a8c221ecc0","global","2015-09-19T21:41:52","2015","aw","companies","Yes","Unsure","No","Unsure","No","Unsure","Yes",,"Yes",,,,,"Registry Search","Aruba Chamber of Commerce and Industry (Kamer van Koophandel en Nijverheid Aruba) info@arubachamber.com","Yes","Yes","Filled out criteria according to bulk data available; added contact information and updated details field.","The Aruba Chamber of Commerce and Industry allows users to purchase information on all businesses registered with them, for a fee. (https://www.kvk.aw/products) An order can be placed with info@arubachamber.com.
The Chamber also offers a free online company registry search (https://www.kvk.aw/registers), which requires inputting the branch or KvK number of a company in order to find data. The search results show the company's name, trade name, address, KvK number, branch and a Google map showing the company's location.","Yes","No","Kimberly Soares","Rebecca Sentance","25"
"8a29a809-4fc1-4f43-95d0-b0e268e478c7","global","2015-09-16T14:04:36","2015","gt","companies","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I have marked the dataset as non-existent as it is not possible to verify that it exists. ","The website for company registration in Guatemala appears to be: https://www.registromercantil.gob.gt/ but it is impossible to view anything that might be company data without a registered account, which requires ID such as a passport. Therefore, the data's existence cannot be verified.","Yes","No","Joel Peñate","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"5f084b3c-34f4-4381-8c6e-20f2ad6c7bed","global","2015-10-13T16:01:33","2015","ci","companies","Yes","Unsure","No","No","No","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,"List of companies and prospective files","Chamber of Trade and Industry","Yes","Yes","I have marked as ""unsure"" whether or not the dataset is digital, as there is no information given as to what form the data can be purchased in. The timeliness of the dataset is also unknown.","It appears that the data is available from the Chamber of Commerce but you need to pay for access. For a quotation, you must send an email to a given address.
- Website: https://www.cci.ci/index.php/informer/information-economique-liste-des-entreprises-et-fichiers-de-prospects
Therefore, the data is not publicly available.","Yes","No","anonymous","Rebecca Sentance","5"
"4c62bc21-1b29-42ed-8643-e9ed26299306","global","2015-10-01T12:10:18","2015","ky","companies","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","No","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.ciregistry.gov.ky/",,,,"General Registry Cayman Islands","Government of the Cayman Islands","Yes","Yes","I have marked the data as not publicly available due to the need to complete a several-step registration process and pay a fee in order to view data.","Account registration is required to search the companies database. Upon making a search, company names only can be viewed for free; viewing any more details requires a payment to be made.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Rebecca Sentance","25"
"15deafc2-9ee8-407c-94c6-880a6c012dd8","global","2015-10-04T14:45:10","2015","et","companies","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Marked dataset as non-existent based on a lack of evidence to the contrary.","The Ministry of Trade (https://www.mot.gov.et/) appears to be the body responsible for company registration, but many of the website links are broken, and it has not been possible to verify the existence of a companies register.","Yes","No","anonymous","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"771a7fef-a501-4d15-9b8b-b4d7807312ad","global","2015-08-30T13:56:22","2015","np","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://ocr.gov.np/search/",,,,"Office Of Company Registrar","Ministry of Industry","Yes","Yes","Fixed URL, all else fine.","Office of Company Registrar is responsible for data but they haven't provided these data in Open Format. However, the company register can be browsed by the public and contains company registration number, name, type and address as well as advanced search filters.","Yes","No","Nikesh Balami","Rebecca Sentance","35"
"d0e9209a-4d1b-4c89-ba06-051d71573f88","global","2015-08-29T16:34:22","2015","om","companies","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Some data is available, but not enough to qualify, therefore data existence has been marked as uncertain.","The Ministry of Commerce ""One Stop Shop"" website provides many services to the public includes a feature to search the listing of the commercial register to look for basic information about registered companies. The data available to the public is limited and provides only details of the registration number, name, number of branches, company type, registration date, and whether or not the company is still active.
As there is not enough data to qualify for the minimum criteria, the dataset's existence has been marked as uncertain.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"b1230d39-4ea7-4880-a093-f0ca80b6a298","global","2015-09-27T23:18:47","2015","bw","companies","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I am marking this dataset's existence as ""unsure"" based on my criteria which is that some information is available, but not enough to qualify.","Submitters comments: There is a names register online - but this does not provide additional information such as address etc. https://www.mtinamesearch.gov.bw/search/
It appears that Botswana does not use company registration numbers, but only register businesses by their name (https://www.gov.bw/en/Business/Sub-audiences/Small--Medium-Businesses/Company--Business-Name-Registration/#a35fb00617eb47dd93b0193e9d5eb0d4).","Yes","No","anonymous","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"fa15c3a4-8c01-4da8-926e-7d12019565db","global","2015-08-20T10:49:45","2015","my","companies","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I have marked the dataset as non-existent based on submitter's comments.","From the Companies Commission of Malaysia official portal, there datasets are not available. The only information that is available online is the generic information about number of registered companies and business. Given that the institution is in the Federal State territory, submitting for Freedom of Information request is impossible because there is no Freedom of Information Act for the Federal State Wilayah Persekutuan.","Yes","No","Hazwany Jamaluddin","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"838cb265-feab-468e-b1ba-4ecb5e69c2d6","global","2015-10-26T17:08:41","2015","im","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Postcodes","Isle of Man Post Office","Yes","Yes","ok","The Isle of Man Government owns the Isle of Man Post Office.
Postcode searches require a registered email address (free) and rate limited to 10 searches per day.
The government IT department sells the postcode/geolocation dataset to a very small customer base of couriers, dairy co-operative doorstep milk delivery service, Tesco, etc.
An IT services company (https://www.afd.co.uk/) also resell geolocation datasets and data cleansing services.
Sep 2015: not all data available online or in one place but specific meta data available on request from public counters
Sep 2015: clarified that the Isle of Man Post Office supplies postcodes to UK Royal Mail PAF under a contract but it is unclear if the contract is exclusive or non-exclusive and a request to establish legal certainty some time ago has still not had a response (unsurprisingly if non-exclusive lol)
Sep 2015: coordinates are in ESRI GIS system (Cabinet Office) and UNIFORM gazetteer (Department of Infrastructure) as northings/eastings but standard algorithms to convert to lat/long kn Google Maps, etc.","Yes","No","Codrina Maria Ilie","Codrina Maria Ilie","25"
"cbd56896-5f34-4bde-9163-3a450484ec8e","global","2015-09-13T13:03:46","2015","cz","land","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://nahlizenidokn.cuzk.cz/VyberKatastrMapa.aspx","vector format (?)",,,"GIS shapes - RUIAN; ownership info: Výměnný formát katastru nemovitostí - VFK (e.g. proprietary XML style cadastre exchange format)","State Administration of Land Surveying and Cadastre","Yes","Yes","We could not find the way to download vector data, but only to print the data in a selection. ","Vector cadastre data (GIS vector data) are downloadable free of charge, but the information about ownership is provided on paid basis.","Yes","No","Honza Cibulka","Codrina Maria Ilie","45"
"2a2745ff-1b03-4b15-ab8c-783963af5f14","global","2015-09-27T23:39:40","2015","bw","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.ppadb.co.bw",,,,,"Public Procurement and Asset Disposal Board","Yes","Yes","Submission correct.","Note data is very hard to use, not easily searchable and organised by date of decision.","Yes","No","anonymous","Georg Neumann","45"
"846e556c-08a8-48c7-9fa9-1c350061591b","global","2015-08-30T09:59:27","2015","np","procurement","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"Government Of Nepal, Public Procurement Monitoring Office does not publish information on contract awards, only tenders. Procurement portal available [here][1].
[1]: https://ppmo.gov.np/index.php?route=information/notices","Yes","No","Nikesh Balami","Georg Neumann","0"
"fd4608c1-0798-4482-aa72-4680bc170929","global","2015-08-24T12:39:42","2015","ng","procurement","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission correct.","The [Bureau of Public Procurement][1] is responsible for publishing tenders and awards of the federal government, and its Ministries, Departments and Agencies.
The last consolidated procurement records released by this government agency [was in 2011, while having some from 2010][2]. However, it should be noted that the agency publishes [Federal Executive Council's contracts][3] for every three months in PDFs, which doesn't include the tender status.
[1]: https://www.bpp.gov.ng/
[2]: https://www.bpp.gov.ng/index.php?","Yes","No","Oludotun Babayemi","Georg Neumann","0"
"cdbfd05a-a148-4228-bbc6-04bb2ba7ee03","global","2015-09-24T09:52:12","2015","mk","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://e-nabavki.gov.mk/PublicAccess/home.aspx#/home",,,,,"Ministry of Finance, Public Procurement Bureau","Yes","Yes","Submission updated. Information on awards is sufficient. ","The official e-system for public procurement (https://e-nabavki.gov.mk/PublicAccess/home.aspx#/completed-procedures) is kept up-to-date, the interface is easy to use and data is avaliable in great detail. ","Yes","No","Metamorphosis Foundation","Georg Neumann","45"
"443cbffb-6974-468a-90f1-773c3a219310","global","2015-09-18T21:58:38","2015","is","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.rikiskaup.is/",,,,"Útboð - Government Purchases","Ríkiskaup","Yes","Yes","Information is sufficient to classify as openly available. Updated. ","Ríkiskaup has a list of recent public tenders and awards on their website:
* Currently being advertised: https://www.rikiskaup.is/utbod/i-auglysingu/ (no tenders made),
* Still open tenders https://www.rikiskaup.is/utbod/fundargerdir/ (tenders submitted and are being evaluated), and
* Awards https://www.rikiskaup.is/utbod/lokid/ (closed tenders),
The awards do not always show who was awarded nor do they always provide a description. Open tenders do show suppliers and the value. Sometimes the data is available on the site in the right field so in all likelihood this is caused by the data not being put on the website, but according to a conversation with Ríkiskaup this is all recorded in a computer system.","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Georg Neumann","45"
"3109bc0b-8cbe-41af-9bec-d6fb0fa7eef6","global","2015-10-04T14:40:38","2015","rw","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,,"Rwanda Natural Resources Authority","Yes","Yes","The data is not publicly available because one need an ArcGIS online account to be able to query the database. Otherwise, one can only see the land parcels. https://rwandalanduse.rnra.rw/",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","20"
"3eeb5698-7b7f-46a4-a6fe-9f6f7fe53992","global","2015-09-12T22:23:32","2015","it","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://portaletrasparenza.avcp.it/microstrategy/html/index.htm","XML","https://www.dati.gov.it/iodl/2.0/",,"Anti-corruption Authority in Italy","ANAC - Autorità Nazionale Anti Corruzione","Yes","Yes","Submission correct. ","The main limit of this service is the lack of a bulk download data and the need to know the names of the government institutions in order to make use of the search engine.
The license should be IODL, but isn't specify the version.
I assume is the 2.0 (the last that sounds like a cc-by).
The specifications are [here][1].
[1]: https://www.anticorruzione.it/portal/rest/jcr/repository/collaboration/Digital%20Assets/pdf/AllCom27.05.13SpecificeTecnichev1.0.pdf","Yes","Yes","Maurizio Napolitano","Georg Neumann","90"
"314e4d49-07eb-412c-ba81-e17d1e748a25","global","2015-09-25T16:17:22","2015","do","land","Yes","Unsure","No","No","No","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,"Dirección General del Catastro Nacional","Yes","Yes","ok","The institution Dirección General del Catastro Nacional has this data, however we weren't able to find any public records of it.","Yes","No","Eliaquín Encarnación","Codrina Maria Ilie","5"
"407c42e6-e63f-43c2-addb-9670c0730079","global","2015-09-17T15:31:41","2015","ly","land","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","This article https://www.gim-international.com/content/article/cadastre-modernisation mentions a new project for Libya’s Land Administration System that started in 2010. Although there are mentions of a geoportal, we could not identify any links. ","It is not clear which authority is responsible for the land ownership registration. No data is available. ","Yes","No","Maraim Elbadri","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"fe546ffb-07d8-4228-90ba-1dd52c1936d6","global","2015-09-27T13:01:27","2015","cm","land","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Data on Cadaster and Land Ownership","Ministry of Domains, Cadaster and Land affairs","Yes","Yes","ok","The Ministry of Domains, Cadaster and Land affairs doesn't have a working website. Land ownership is Cameroon has been so far a very serious problem due to ill management, generating resentment between citizens, loss of confidence in land titles, various losses to land owners. A research report from African Development Bank noticed that anyone need a 2 to 7 years period to acquire a land title in Cameroon.
The Ministry website is not working at the time of this survey.
https://www.mindaf.gov.cm/
So there is project going on launched (PAMOCCA) with ADB support to streamline the process for land ownership, computerizing existing documents, building a unique geodesical database, publishing cadaster data online, etc.
https://www.spm.gov.cm/actualites/actualite/article/communique-a-lissue-du-conseil-de-cabinet-du-jeudi-28-mars-2013.html","Yes","No","Charlie Martial NGOUNOU","Idriss TINTO","5"
"9a24d69f-6ba8-4808-8858-996fc92e36ba","global","2015-09-16T05:24:16","2015","ir","land","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The State Organization For Registration of Deeds and Properties has published in 2009 a Cadastre Report prepared by Iran. https://unstats.un.org/unsd/geoinfo/RCC/docs/rccap18/CRP/18th_UNRCCAP_econf.100_crp18.pdf In this report it is stated that by year 2009, from approximately1,200,000 ha of urban area, over 600,000 of cadastral maps have been prepared. We did not find any reference to the status of this implementation. ","We could not find this information ","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"e123b088-2ac9-49a0-b736-c52049b8563a","global","2015-09-13T11:36:42","2015","jo","land","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","Yes","Yes",,"Unsure",,"vector format (?)",,,,"Jordanian Department of Land and Survey","Yes","Yes","The viewer service makes it obvious that the data is in digital format, vector format, but we couldn't identify which one. ","The Jordanian Department of Land and Survey provides this search tool (https://www.dls.gov.jo/dlsweb/index.html) where you can find lands by their location for the whole nation. Lands have IDs, and results include coordinates where you can determine its borders and area. It say the website was last updated 24 hours ago.
However, results does not provide the owner of the land.","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Codrina Maria Ilie","40"
"e3379418-42a7-4585-98d9-5f6db11d42ef","global","2015-10-02T14:24:21","2015","bs","companies","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://rgd.bahamas.gov.bs:8081/netdata/db2www.pgm/findcompany.ndm/searchcomps",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I have deemed the dataset's existence as ""unsure"" as the information available doesn't satisfy the minimum criteria for a companies register.","The Registrar General's Department has a free company search feature which allows users to look up company names and registry numbers: https://rgd.bahamas.gov.bs:8081/netdata/db2www.pgm/findcompany.ndm/searchcomps
It can also be browsed by entering a space as the search term, though with a limit of 100 search results displayed at a time.
There are no other details provided and it is unclear how often the database is updated.","Yes","No","anonymous","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"d21b0ae2-7104-47ad-8b72-1dfa04f95a00","global","2015-09-03T21:27:21","2015","lb","land","Yes","Unsure","No","No","No","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,"dlrc.gov.lb","Yes","Yes","ok","Land ownerships are registered by dlrc.gov.lb, however, they do not make such data available to the public. It is not available online, and it is most likely that only owner of a land or his legal representatives can get the ownership documents of their own land offline. We were not able to find any means for the public to request lists of all lands and their owners.
","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Codrina Maria Ilie","5"
"037a9b95-4ce5-45e2-bf10-db08f0e91257","global","2015-08-31T08:14:53","2015","eg","land","Yes","Unsure","No","No","No","No","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,"Egyptian Survey Authority","Yes","Yes","ok","Land ownerships are registered by the Egyptian Survey Authority (www.esa.gov.eg), however, they do not make such data available to the public. It is not available online, and according to its law (https://bit.ly/1hNXtGG) and the forms submitted (https://bit.ly/1iemT0b) only owner of a land or his legal representatives can get the ownership documents of the land. We were not able to find any means for the public to request lists of lands and their owners.
P.S. The website (www.esa.gov.eg) is down, and we used the cached version by Google for our research.","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","5"
"a20de16f-7c0e-41fb-8db8-f245000ac9e4","global","2015-09-17T11:29:16","2015","be","land","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","Yes","No",,"Unsure",,"vector format (?)",,,"Cad geo viewer of the Belgian Cadaster","Federal government service for finances","Yes","Yes","The CADGIS Viewer provides discovery and search services on land information database, it does not offer access to the data itself, thus the data is not available online. ","CadGis is still more an online viewer, rather then it is a dataset. However it is a free service that shows the required information on a national level, except for the name of the owner. Due to this being private information.
The application is not openly licensed as it states that excerpts can only be used for private usage. ","Yes","No","Pieter-Jan Pauwels","Codrina Maria Ilie","30"
"26f5216e-735e-4d14-b5f7-923d44842cd8","global","2015-09-22T13:17:13","2015","ml","land","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok",,"Yes","No","Renaud Gaudin","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"ae4279d6-3ba3-42e1-9048-fe4564391a36","global","2015-09-20T06:09:01","2015","pk","land","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://lrma.punjab-zameen.gov.pk/haqooq-e-araazi",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The dataset must cover the entire territory of the country. According to a research from 2012 (Ali, Shakir 2012), there is no cadastre united up-to-date system. ""LIS [Land Information System] in Pakistan is based on traditional system of land registers and records that are somewhat complicated, outdated, and quite incompatible to new development"" https://geografie.ubbcluj.ro/ccau/jssp/arhiva1_2012/06JSSP012012.pdf ","The data is provided by Government of Punjab for major cities in Punjab only.","Yes","No","Nouman Nazim","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"4a906f6e-faf9-4ad9-ae78-34bea10664ba","global","2015-09-13T00:15:56","2015","jo","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.gtd.gov.jo/",,,,,"Jordan Tenders Department","Yes","Yes","Submission correct.","Here are ongoing tenders, https://www.gtd.gov.jo/?page=ar/tenders/category/1/upload_files.html - and here are the awards, https://www.gtd.gov.jo/?page=ar/tenders/category/4/import_files.html
","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Georg Neumann","45"
"b66ca6e3-d34d-4551-9ed8-1edef4fe2a92","global","2015-09-16T09:41:40","2015","kg","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://zakupki.okmot.kg/pub/publicOrder.action","CSV, XLS, XML",,,"State portal for governmental tenders.","Ministry of Finance of the Kyrgyz Republic","Yes","Yes","Submission updated with correct machine-readable data files.","The state portal for governmental tenders https://zakupki.okmot.kg/. Provides all the information about all the tenders created by government. Additionally they provide the data about winners. It is required by the law that all governmental agencies and bodies have to publish their tenders on the web site. ","Yes","No","Azamat Tokhtaev","Georg Neumann","70"
"37134b63-af1a-4ca6-9e6c-7b32db7bf96b","global","2015-09-28T01:05:56","2015","ar","companies","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I agree with the submitter that the data does not exist.","Unable to find a definitive register of companies information in Argentina.","Yes","No","Yamila García","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"6a6d0dad-91ad-4044-b1fe-7056013473e3","global","2015-09-27T22:30:42","2015","gy","companies","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Updated submission with actual information.","The Guyana Office for Investment is the body responsible for incorporation of companies (https://goinvest.gov.gy/investment/incorporation/), but it is unclear whether or not it has a companies registry or how to access it.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"ad0997ad-8697-42cd-ab8b-c8085cb41e05","global","2015-09-01T18:56:24","2015","iq","companies","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Marked dataset as non-existent based on submitter's comments.","The Ministry of Trade has a department to register companies, you can only find the numbers of of companies from 2003 until 2013 on the ministry website. It is not clear if that department has a detailed record of registered companies in Iraq (https://www.mot.gov.iq/index.php?name=Pages&op=page&pid=57).","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"04ee4c76-5562-4b28-a1ab-a70a01f89565","global","2015-09-13T09:08:16","2015","ir","companies","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Marked data as non-existent based on submitter comments.","We were not able to find the data on the website of the Company Registration General Office here (https://sherkat.ssaa.ir/Default.aspx?tabid=4767)","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"40f1514c-35fb-4510-9360-65be40f4e871","global","2015-10-06T11:28:30","2015","nl","companies","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","No","Unsure","No",,"No","https://www.kvk.nl/producten-bestellen/bedrijfsprofiel/",,,,,"Chamber of Commerce (Kamer van Koophandel)","Yes","Yes","Updated criteria based on what I found on the website.","For a fee, users can purchase company data from the Netherlands Chamber of Commerce, which includes ""a complete view of an organization; product extracts, history, filings and also where available financial statements and corporate relationships"". These are available in digital or paper form. ","Yes","No","Sander van der Waal","Rebecca Sentance","15"
"e1287329-9f8a-4ca3-8662-9ad7e8fcf394","global","2015-09-24T10:28:53","2015","mk","companies","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Unsure","No",,"Yes",,,,,,"Central Registry of the Republic of Macedonia","Yes","Yes","I have marked the data as timely based on the submitter's comments.","The Central Register of Macedonia gathers and administers company registries. Citizens can consult the registry (https://www.crm.com.mk/DS/default.aspx?MainId=12) but they need the number of the legal entity to get access to the data. Data is maintained timely (there is a related e-government service to business registration) but is not publicly available. ","Yes","No","Metamorphosis Foundation","Rebecca Sentance","20"
"32f1c38f-7a77-4dcc-9929-0214a72ea75b","global","2015-09-17T22:41:01","2015","lc","land","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","We could not find info related to data existence, but the Ministry of Physical Development, Housing and Urban Renewal - Land Registry Section is responsible with land survey. ",,"Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"2f10f56c-f95a-445c-8269-e517637f6daa","global","2015-09-21T15:13:05","2015","bb","companies","Yes","Unsure","No","Unsure","No","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,"A division of the Ministry of Industry, International Business Commerce and small business development","The Corporate Affairs and Intellectual Property Office","Yes","Yes","The link given in the original submission didn't work, so I performed a search of what was available on the website and filled in the criteria accordingly.","The Corporate Affairs and Intellectual Property office allows the public to perform a ""Company Inquiry"" for a fee of $5, though there is no information given about what data the inquiry would return or its format. https://www.caipo.gov.bb/site/index.php/fees/article/24-company-inquiry
The office makes available a very limited free internet search facility, which allows the user to search for or browse through the names of registered companies and view registration numbers and dates. However, the database is not regularly updated and is not meant to be used as a substitute for a paid search of the official records. https://www.caipo.gov.bb/site/index.php/search/search-our-database/","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Rebecca Sentance","5"
"cca15d9f-2b26-4413-a832-f0a8b076943c","global","2015-10-14T18:06:21","2015","fi","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.hankintailmoitukset.fi/fi/docs/hakuohje/",,,,"Hilma procurement data","Edita Publishing","Yes","Yes","Submission updated taking into account the EU level tenders. ","Hilma data is in https://www.hankintailmoitukset.fi/fi/, and has been at times obtained through FOI requests, but is not published as open data. Tender and award data over 120,000 Euro is available throught the European tender system TED.","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Georg Neumann","45"
"70713ccc-7288-4031-bf56-222c4f519934","global","2015-10-02T20:14:59","2015","sn","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://creationdentreprise.sn/rechercher-une-societe",,,,"Legal Notices Database (Base de données des annonces légales)","Corporate Establishment Support Office","Yes","Yes","I have marked the data as not machine readable as I can't find how to get the XLS version of the data, and if it requires a special process, that effectively makes the machine-readable data inaccessible to the public.","The office that published the companies register (BCE) helps entrepreneurs establish their companies. It has a database of all established companies that can be searched through, or alternatively browsed beneath the search engine. You can click each company name to view more details.","Yes","No","anonymous","Rebecca Sentance","35"
"fdae2567-557c-4c8f-9331-ae686e4beb13","global","2015-09-14T18:22:10","2015","sy","companies","Yes","No","Yes","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Company registry","The trust of commercial register","Yes","Yes","Looks fine to me.","Company registration information is available through the trust of commercial register in the province that the company belong to, according to Syrian company law 2011(https://www.dcc-sy.com/pgimg/Tamim/1327399691.7812.pdf).","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Rebecca Sentance","20"
"976d3259-aa51-43c6-8c5c-21e17de3bfab","global","2015-09-26T17:20:43","2015","kn","companies","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I am marking the dataset as ""non-existent"" based on a lack of evidence to the contrary.","The body responsible for company registration is the Financial Services Regulatory Commission: https://www.fsrc.kn/
There is no evidence of a companies register on the site.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"e519c95a-3ed4-4528-89fc-65086ae77b3c","global","2015-09-28T11:39:06","2015","pk","companies","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://www.secp.gov.pk/CLD/cld_stakeholders.asp",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The dataset given (company names only) isn't enough to qualify as a companies register, so I have marked the data's existence as ""unsure"".","Only names and website links of registered companies are available, published by the Securities Exchange Commission of Pakistan: https://www.secp.gov.pk/CLD/cld_stakeholders.asp
There is also a company name search feature, which gives access to registration numbers, incorporation dates and incorporation status: https://www.secp.gov.pk/ns/index.asp","Yes","No","anonymous","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"8d9ed94e-9f62-4611-a73c-621f2108ea16","global","2015-09-15T15:05:58","2015","th","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://data.go.th/DatasetDetail.aspx?id=9b89a54c-f0dd-405b-9e88-7710ebd52d73","CSV, XLS","https://data.go.th/LicenceDetails.aspx?id=3a937417-8ccb-42a1-8923-a920851008db&ReturnId=ffe0737c-e9d9-40be-89bb-46d2a109b383",,"List of companies registered in June 2015","Department of Business Development (document@dbd.go.th)","Yes","Yes","I have marked data as not available in bulk based on the fact that you have to go to each month's individual page to download data, even though the whole dataset *can* be downloaded in one go. Also, if you don't have the links to each month's data, you have to search for it.","NB: Data is only available for companies registered in the year 2015, on a month-by-month basis. The link given above is the company registration data for the month of June.
January: https://data.go.th/DatasetDetail.aspx?id=ffe0737c-e9d9-40be-89bb-46d2a109b383
February: https://data.go.th/DatasetDetail.aspx?id=ecf759a9-35fa-4962-bcf7-9e265dfb9d0e
March: https://data.go.th/DatasetDetail.aspx?id=43bf1b24-fc13-42dc-bc89-77cb695f1b77
April: https://data.go.th/DatasetDetail.aspx?id=96d63e86-9711-4ccb-851d-8aa4f17a6ed1
May: https://data.go.th/DatasetDetail.aspx?id=989e24a8-6fd8-4f76-8cea-ea5ca091a79c","Yes","Yes","Klaikong Vaidhyakarn","Rebecca Sentance","90"
"c95fd308-77c3-4116-9751-67c672ef51c4","global","2015-10-02T11:11:26","2015","ne","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","Yes","Unsure",,"Unsure",,"shp",,,"national basemap","National geographic institute of niger","Yes","Yes","Everythins seems correct","The national basemap is provided by the national geographical institute at the scale of 1/50 000e, 1/200 000e, 1/500 000e, 1/1 000 000e(1)
1. https://ign-n.ne/index.php/le-ministere","Yes","No","anonymous","Gil Zaretzer","30"
"0f0b2451-a287-48e7-afc7-e7b049a30359","global","2015-09-30T18:43:31","2015","tc","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.turksandcaicos.tc/turks/",,,,,"TURKS AND CAICOS ISLANDS MAPS","Yes","Yes","Everything seems correct","For the Turks and Caicos national map, there are external websites that can be viewed such as:
https://www.google.com/maps/d/viewer?mid=z23Hv3inRkKM.k_2Z3THUsfdE&hl=en
https://www.visittci.com/providenciales/maps/national-parks
","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Gil Zaretzer","35"
"55e1d622-9d49-4ea2-8100-d45170eebdfa","global","2015-09-01T13:19:12","2015","je","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://maps.digimap.je/menu/",,,,"States Corporate Digimap System","Mapping Services, Chief Minister's Department mst@gov.je","Yes","Yes","Everythings seems correct","In addition to web browser access to the online maps, mapping data can be purchased for offline use in various product forms (https://www.digimap.je/data-prices)
Providing the base map data for free is under consideration as part of an open data initiative (https://blog.gov.je/2015/07/17/open-data-the-story-so-far/)","Yes","No","Marcus Ferbrache","Gil Zaretzer","45"
"87e623be-b2c6-4279-8c21-8bf802be3def","global","2015-10-07T15:39:00","2015","pr","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://prcorpfiling.f1hst.com/CorporationSearch.aspx",,,,"Registro de Corporaciones / Corporate Registry","Departamento de Estado de Puerto Rico / Puerto Rico State Department","Yes","Yes","I agree with this assessment, on the basis that the company register can also be browsed by submitting a blank search. I would assess that the data is not available in bulk or machine readable. Licensing details are unclear.","The Corporate Registry is continually updated. It can be browsed by submitting a blank search term, though the search is limited to 250 results at a time.","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Rebecca Sentance","45"
"cf010cbc-d35f-4217-90fe-380e1d9f9572","global","2015-10-13T21:18:38","2015","tg","companies","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://togo.eregulations.org/procedure/3/2?l=fr",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The site was working when I reviewed, but does not appear to hold company data. I think the submitter may have mistaken company registration documents for company data.","There is a resource provided by the Ministry of Industry, Free Zone and Technological Innovations to aid in the creation of businesses (https://togo.eregulations.org/), but it does not appear to hold company data or make it available. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"ced74643-97d5-4616-ab04-0815a0922c36","global","2015-09-07T11:44:09","2015","bh","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.business.gov.bh/",,,,"Company Register including unique company identifier, name, address, registered activities, and shareholder details.","Ministry of Industry and Commerce","Yes","Yes","Added details on browsing vs. searching. All else seems fine!","The Ministry of Industry and Commerce in Bahrain provides a dedicated website for the company register (https://www.business.gov.bh/ ) that allows the public to search or browse the register and find up to date details about any company with information including the company registration number, address, telephone number, shareholders, registered activities and more.
To browse the register, select ""Information Request"" at the side. The information is sorted by Block (area), Industry or Company Type, and at least one of these criteria must be chosen to make a search; but the data can otherwise be browsed freely.
To perform a search with keywords, select ""Search"" at the side and enter the company name or registry number to obtain search results.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Rebecca Sentance","45"
"be0476f5-ee10-45e1-8bd4-65604f4c07c8","global","2015-10-02T00:02:56","2015","se","companies","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","No","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.bolagsverket.se/be/sok/xml","XML",,,"Business Register","Ministry of Enterprise and Innovation (Näringsdepartmentet)","Yes","Yes","Updated criteria based on the availability of XML packet.","Very sparse information available as open data in CSV format(https://www.bolagsverket.se/om/oss/vidareutnyttjande/oppna-data-1.10631) but doesn't include basics such as address.
Bulk data is available for a fee as an ""XML packet"", which retrieves data directly from the register. It can be accessed online with a server certificate. For more information, the contact email is: forsaljning@bolagsverket.se","Yes","No","Asmen Gül","Rebecca Sentance","50"
"b8ca784b-c11f-4e4c-8408-27d00ed0e72f","global","2015-10-14T18:21:58","2015","pa","companies","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,,"Public Register of Panama","Yes","Yes","I agree with the assessments of the submitter and the QA reviewer. All fine.","You have to register for an account to access the data.
Unofficial sources:
https://www.panadata.net/sociedades
https://www.panadata.net/personas","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Rebecca Sentance","10"
"315c584b-61d6-48a2-8ab1-ca18c8046d0f","global","2015-10-25T14:08:02","2015","md","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission correct","There is [aggregated data for spending data](https://data.gov.md/ckan/ro/dataset/5013-clasificatia-functionala-a-cheltuielilor-bugetare), but not not transactional data.","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"5f30108f-5a47-45a5-b3ff-a8862a84e9cb","global","2015-09-27T19:01:48","2015","uy","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed","The national transactional spending data is not available but aggregated results are [available](https://www.mef.gub.uy/540/1/mef/informacion-de-resultados-del-sector-publico-a-agosto-de-2015.html) and very fresh which indicates the data exists and is digital.
Procurement data (which is a big subset of national spending data but not counted as part of this dataset) is however available as open data. It can be downloaded in bulk from: https://comprasestatales.gub.uy/inicio/datos-abiertos/interfaz-consulta-publicaciones /interfaz-consultas-publicaciones.
XML files in a dataset in Uruguay's CKAN instace at https://catalogodatos.gub.uy/dataset/compras-estatales correspond to the codelists used in the actual data.","Yes","No","Daniel Carranza","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"dd980ae1-a88a-4b43-a3b5-0a9f9249841b","global","2015-09-28T13:57:50","2015","py","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Pagos a Proveedores","Dirección Nacional de Contrataciones Públicas","Yes","Yes","Submission fixed (original submission about procurements and tenders).","The execution of the budget is presented in a financial reporting system: https://www.hacienda.gov.py/analytics/saw.dll?Go
This indicates that the data exists and is digital but it is aggregated.
Comments about procurement platform which is not considered enough:
* Quality of the Data (Content): 10, all information is available in great detail.
* Quality of Data (Structure): 6, the data format is PDF or Excel, which are not the most user-friendly formats.
All government spending must go through the [e-procurement platform](https://www.contrataciones.gov.py/sicp/pago/busquedaProveedoresSiaf.seam) (source of spending data) except salaries which are exempt from it. The producrement phases are: planning, tender, award, contract, admemends, implementation. At the time of the review, all this information, except ""implementation"" (which contains the payment information) is available at the open data platfrom from the ""Dirección Nacional de Contrataciones Públicas"" which can be browsed and downloaded in bulk and via an HTTP API at https://www.contrataciones.gov.py/datos.
However, the individual payment information can still be queried at the provided link, and the DNPC is in the process of integrating this phase in their open data portal.
The information available on the web is constantly updated.
","Yes","No","Juan Pane","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"16ce3789-ef30-4820-88f6-10b7229fd711","global","2015-10-25T13:34:18","2015","no","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed","Records of spending on a transactional level is not openly available online, and have to be requested.
There are some higher-level numbers available;
Monthly expenses:
https://www.dfo.no/no/Forvaltning/Statsregnskapet/Manedlig-statsregnskap/
Statistics Norway:
https://www.ssb.no/statistikkbanken/selecttable/hovedtabellHjem.asp?KortNavnWeb=statsregn&CMSSubjectArea=offentlig-sektor&checked=true","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"52b77db4-11bd-42be-a283-03fed96da12b","global","2015-10-25T13:33:08","2015","it","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed","The Italian Government has released Soldi Pubblici, https://soldipubblici.gov.it/ based on the data available through the SIOPE platform. This is the Information system through which any treasurer of public agencies reports payments on daily basis. The data however is aggregated and not transactional but the frequency indicates the data exists and is digital.","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"e3755c80-3187-428d-9945-6caf04e84d0f","global","2015-10-25T13:31:36","2015","tt","spending","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.","According to IBP's [Open Budget Survey](https://survey.internationalbudget.org) the year end report is not published which indicates that the data does not exists (but the audit report is published). However the [Open Budget Library](https://openbudgetlibrary.org) has the 2012 audit report (2 fiscal periods ago).","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","0"
"c37806c9-6a60-4746-996f-506f240cc7c7","global","2015-10-25T13:27:47","2015","dz","spending","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed","According to IBP's [Open Budget Survey](https://survey.internationalbudget.org) the Algerian government does not publish year end reports so the data does not seem to exist","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","0"
"42d025c2-43aa-43cc-b5fa-9317881e4f8b","global","2015-10-25T13:23:00","2015","bw","spending","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission correct","This website mentions that there are spending reports but they are not available on the website and there is no mention of whether it is digital or not: https://www.finance.gov.bw/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=23&Itemid=139&catid=16
This is confirmed by IBP's [Open Budget Survey](https://survey.internationalbudget.org) which says the year end report exists. The [Open Budget Library](https://openbudgetlibrary.org) has a record of the 2013 year end report which indicates that the data exists but is perhaps not fully digital.","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","5"
"df2356ac-f76e-45ab-8b87-4f0e9b062bef","global","2015-10-25T13:19:01","2015","pt","spending","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission correct","There is no data available on day-to-day spending, i.e. transactional spending.
According to IBP's [Open Budget Survey](https://survey.internationalbudget.org) the data exists (there is a year end report) but the [Open Budget Library](https://openbudgetlibrary.org) holds the 2012 version of the year end report. That's more than 2 fiscal periods ago so we cannot say that the data exists.
Although the Portugal government claims that they have reformed management of public accounts: https://www.portugal.gov.pt/pt/os-temas/20150504-reformas-estruturais/fin-pub/pin-pub-1.aspx (there is however no evidence of this being done now).","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","0"
"b51fc1fb-9e54-4233-b1a6-ff59541ec273","global","2015-10-25T13:07:32","2015","cz","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Data about government spending are available. But every ministry and office publish them on their own website. ",,"Yes","Yes","Submission correct","The data does exist as presented on https://data.mfcr.cz/en/node/93 ","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"ad453e92-3a2f-4101-9826-8a7a7c3aba63","global","2015-10-25T13:05:39","2015","rw","spending","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is correct","According to IBP's [Open Budget Survey](https://survey.internationalbudget.org) the year end report exists which indicates that the data exists. On the [Open Budget Library](https://openbudgetlibrary.org) the year end report is for fiscal year 2012-2013 which indicates that the data is not fully digital.","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","5"
"27b1ea62-df08-43a9-a677-20f8d75d6f8c","global","2015-10-25T13:02:46","2015","do","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Económica del gasto, funcional del gasto, institucional del gasto","Dirección General de Presupuesto","Yes","Yes","Submission comment fixed","Aggregated data is available on https://www.digepres.gob.do/?page_id=969","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"ab5bf098-2334-4795-9146-d521626ab2f0","global","2015-10-25T13:01:51","2015","ms","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed","The Montserrat government releases quarterly budget performance reports. e.g.: https://www.gov.ms/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/Budget-Performance-Report-Q2-2014-15-UL20141022.pdf for the second quarter of the 2014/2015 fiscal year. This indicates that the data exists and is digital but the transactional data is not public.","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"91fb119e-1644-44c6-afda-74c26f626c7c","global","2015-10-25T12:59:55","2015","jo","spending","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.","In minister of finance website [they mention](https://www.gfmis.gov.jo/ar/content/%D8%A8%D9%8A%D8%A6%D8%A9-%D8%B9%D9%85%D9%84-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%A5%D8%AF%D8%A7%D8%B1%D8%A9-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%85%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%8A%D8%A9-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%AD%D9%83%D9%88%D9%85%D9%8A%D8%A9) that every minister and department should send summary of their spending to minister of finance, it is unclear how, and if they should send it ever month or year.
According to IBP's [Open Budget Survey](https://survey.internationalbudget.org) there are year end reports and audit reports. In the [Open Budget Library](https://openbudgetlibrary.org) the last year end report is from 2012 which indicates that the data does not exist (it's from 2 fiscal periods ago).","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","0"
"518be0b0-90e9-4544-a61a-0f32d7d143af","global","2015-10-25T12:55:32","2015","lb","spending","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is correct.","There is a monthly aggregated report of government expenditure. There is no report that publish data per transaction. All data is copyrighted under the 2010 Ministry of Finance.
IBP's [Open Budget Survey](https://survey.internationalbudget.org) shows that almost nothing except year end report is published and the year end report in the [Open Budget Library](https://openbudgetlibrary.org) is from 2012. So the data does not seem exist since then (2 fiscal periods ago).","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","0"
"76d9f502-9805-4b79-8446-ea07ccfaef83","global","2015-10-25T12:50:17","2015","eg","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed","IBP's [Open Budget Survey](https://survey.internationalbudget.org) shows that the year end report exists. In the [Open Budget Library](https://openbudgetlibrary.org) has a 2013/2014 copy which indicates that the data exists and is digital.","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"5a6d87f2-d3df-4634-babb-ad7a0ce9df12","global","2015-10-25T12:46:28","2015","ng","spending","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is correct","Actual spending report is presented in aggregated form in the budget implementation reports. At the level of presentation, data is minimally useful.
IBP's [Open Budget Survey](https://survey.internationalbudget.org) shows a year-end report. The [Open Budget Library](https://openbudgetlibrary.org) contains a year end report from 2013 which indicates that the data is not fully digital.","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","5"
"94389282-debe-482d-b848-3c1463d93026","global","2015-10-25T12:41:50","2015","vc","spending","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Tax E-Filing System","Government of St Vincent and the Grenadines","Yes","Yes","Submission correct","Data is not available but according to https://www.finance.gov.vc/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=55&Itemid=42 there is a specific department of the treasury that collects expenditure and revenue transactions on a daily basis. That does not mean that it is done digitally though.","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","5"
"52466e80-74ff-4c5d-be2e-9d3688672e7f","global","2015-10-25T12:34:14","2015","ke","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"e-ProMIS Kenya is an application run and managed by the Ministry of Finance that allows users to effectively track, update, and analyze project inputs, outputs, outcomes and impact","https://e-promis.treasury.go.ke/e-promis - e-promisadmin@treasury.go.ke, e-promismanager@treasury.go.ke","Yes","Yes","Submission is correct","Data on all projects funded by donors through government can be found on National Treasury platform which is an application run and managed by the Ministry of Finance that allows users to effectively track, update, and analyze project inputs, outputs, outcomes and impact in all counties in Kenya.
Data is not publicly available since it requires login credentials as shown from the source: https://e-promis.treasury.go.ke/e-promis/
Also that's limited to donors. The year-end report and audit reports do exist according to IBP's [Open Budget Survey Explorer](https://survey.internationalbudget.org) and they're very recent according to the [Open Budget Library](https://openbudgetlibrary.org) which indicates that the data exists and is digital.","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"972470d4-1b49-4e04-b740-b66c4ca48f7b","global","2015-10-25T12:28:51","2015","tl","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is correct","The documents that are available in the Budget & Spending Documents webpage do not meet the above criteria especially in regard to individual records of transactions, date of transactions and transactions updated on a monthly basis.
Budget & Spending Documents https://www.mof.gov.tl/budget-spending/budget-treasury-documents/?lang=en
This still indicates that the data exists and is digital.","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"98dc5993-d976-478a-b14b-2ca164c4476c","global","2015-10-02T00:20:31","2015","se","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.geodata.se/GeodataExplorer/index.jsp?loc=en",,,,"Geodata Portal","National Land Survey","Yes","Yes","Everything seems correct","An online map for navigation and selecting various layers is available here: https://www.geodata.se/GeodataExplorer/index.jsp?loc=en User can only download the current view of the map as PDF
Lantmäteriets National maps are availiable in the scales 1:1 000 000 (Sweden map), 1:250 000 (Overview map), 1:100 000 (Roadmap) and 1:10 000 (Real property map) with national coverage. There is also a terrain map in the scale 1:50 000. The agency is funded by charging for data and thus very little open data is available. A couple of map products is provided (https://www.lantmateriet.se/en/Maps-and-geographic-information/Valj-produktomrade/#faq:Digitala-allmanna-kartor). Data can't be downloaded in bulk though. The license is not open: https://www.lantmateriet.se/en/Maps-and-geographic-information/Geodata-services/Villkor-och-avgifter/
The only openly licensed map data (in the scale 1:1 000 000) is available at this url: https://www.lantmateriet.se/Kartor-och-geografisk-information/Kartor/Sverigekartor/Gratis-Sverigekartor/
","Yes","No","Asmen Gül","Gil Zaretzer","30"
"4748e4c7-1dfc-4009-aae0-9c15f153dd76","global","2015-09-07T11:54:33","2015","bh","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.bahrainlocator.gov.bh/",,,,"Interactive map of the Kingdom of Bahrain","Central Informatics Organization","Yes","Yes","Everything seems correct","Central Informatics Organization is responsible for creating and maintaining GIS data in Bahrain, it provides a number of applications for browsing the data such as the Explore Bahrain App ( https://www.bahrainlocator.gov.bh/ ). However, the data cannot be downloaded, is not machine readable, and is not open.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Gil Zaretzer","35"
"c8ec3d0d-8802-4d1a-9a0f-5e0658ed1783","global","2015-09-28T06:24:23","2015","ua","map","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","My only lead that makes me thing some data exists is a name of the Ukrainean national mapping service: Holovne Upravlinnja Heodezii Kartografi ta Kardastruv, however they do not seem to have any website, thus everything is unsure, but if there's a mapping service I hope it means they do have data.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Gil Zaretzer","0"
"1e8fa6e0-91a2-430d-b48e-581008ef7f19","global","2015-10-07T15:39:17","2015","pr","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://www.jp.pr.gov/portal_jp/Servicios/GIS/PuertoRicoInteractivoPRI/tabid/81/Default.aspx",,,,"Mi Puerto Rico Interactivo","Junta de Planificación de Puerto Rico / Puerto Rico Planning Board","Yes","Yes","When trying to access the online viewer I'm blocked and unable to test this entry, I am approving it as is.",,"Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Gil Zaretzer","35"
"1975abc0-7558-488e-8b5a-510a695009bc","global","2015-10-05T18:25:46","2015","gt","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.ign.gob.gt/geoportal/index.html",,,,,"Instituto Geográfico Nacional","Yes","Yes","I agree with past conclusions, the data is free and online but it doesn't seem possible to bulk download machine readable files for re-use, licnesing is also not clear.","Same as last year. Map upload really slowly. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Gil Zaretzer","45"
"40822509-f49f-41db-8d24-8de110a8a9ce","global","2015-09-28T23:58:01","2015","pa","map","Yes","Yes","No","Unsure","No","Unsure","Unsure",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The preview and the answers given did not match, so I changed the answers accordingly, the data exists, digital and seems up to date, but it is not public or free, the rest is unclear.","There are several government organizations related to geospatial data collection:
- [Panamanian Infrastructure for Spacial Data][1]
- [National Geographic Institute ""Tommy Guardia""][2]
- [National Land Distribution Authority][3]
The Tommy Guardia Institute recently led several projects in an effort to create geographically accurate national maps, but the maps themselves are not publicly available and not online. To get a map (in digital or physical form), a person must go to the Tommy Guardia Institute's office and pay $50.00 for the 1:250000 map.
Also on their website, there is a portal at the bottom of the page called ""Cors"" where anyone can log in with username ""corsigntg"" and password ""corsigntg "" and retrieve what looks like geographic data collected on a monthly basis. ([Log in here][4]) I don't personally understand the data, but it looks like latitudes and longitudes and I believe [this page][5] explains the data format.
[1]: https://%20https://www.ipde.gob.pa/ ""Panamanian Infrastructure for Spacial Data""
[2]: https://ignpanama.anati.gob.pa/
[3]: https://www.anati.gob.pa/
[4]: ftp://168.77.211.56/ARMU/
[5]: https://www.pancanal.com/esp/eie/surveys/topography/gps/parametros.html","Yes","No","HAMZAH HAJI","Gil Zaretzer","10"
"89e90b35-845a-4665-a1e3-803a583acac6","global","2015-09-28T05:33:26","2015","th","map","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://nsdiportal.gistda.or.th/geonetwork/srv/en/main.home",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I found that Thailand has a Spatial Data Infrastructure which offer an online viewer with different layers of Data, so the data exists, digitaly and online, however, I'm not quite sure about download option since I only find PDF save option, I also see nothing about upadtes and licnesing, and since this is the first we are seeing this I marked everything else as unsure, hoping this will help get better results in the future.","Data did not change","Yes","No","anonymous","Gil Zaretzer","15"
"43f00204-6950-4231-9992-306f1d5ef07e","global","2015-09-27T15:16:53","2015","kn","land","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","It is uncertain if the data exists.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"0e1d493f-3616-4071-8a8c-457f2151d37b","global","2015-09-27T17:54:26","2015","ms","map","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Yes","Unsure","No","No",,"Unsure","https://ls.gov.ms/?page_id=6",,,,"Lands & Survey Department","Government of Montserrat","Yes","Yes","The Department of Land and Survey has a mapping service whiche suggets that digital data exists, however it is not online, and everything else is unclear, I adjusted the answers accordingly","It is possible that the national map exists but is not accessible.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Gil Zaretzer","15"
"9fe0a6e4-6210-4edb-a856-aebe662e2ebf","global","2015-10-02T20:47:24","2015","sn","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.basegeo.gouv.sn/-Donnees-vectorielles-au-1-100-0000-.html","shp,kml,svg",,,,"Directorate of geographical and cartographic works","Yes","Yes","Everything seems correct, I only changed the answer to Bulk to yes since it does seem available, I also couldn't find anything on licensing to suggest openes.","The National Agency for Spatial Planning with the collaboration of IT agency of the State, have launched a geodata portal and allow users to download the data in machine readable format. there was trying to apply opn data principles, but there are no license and the legal mentions do not clarify the user right to reuse the data.","Yes","No","anonymous","Gil Zaretzer","70"
"d273d2ea-9d20-4e50-bbf1-579f18687197","global","2015-09-14T18:32:15","2015","sy","map","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The Ministry of Tourism's city plans don't meet our criteria, for many obvious reasons, the national map doesn't apear to work, and it's understandable, so I'm keeping this as unsure since the data might exist.","There is a map of Syrian provinces on The ministry of tourism official website (https://www.syriatourism.org/modules.php?op=modload&name=My_eGallery&file=index&do=showgall&gid=263).
The page for Syrian map has an error (https://www.syriatourism.org/modules/My_eGallery/public/nmpopupa.php?z=/servers/gallery/nopic.gif&n=123457746)","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Gil Zaretzer","0"
"9b1d48b9-71bc-4068-8ceb-69243892fe07","global","2015-09-26T13:02:17","2015","sd","map","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Seems correct","It appears that the Sudanese Survey Department (هيئة المساحة السودانية) is the body responsible for preparing maps in Sudan, but no information is available about this department on the internet.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Gil Zaretzer","0"
"5c105945-8f8f-4125-a15a-420d442793c8","global","2015-10-14T13:44:54","2015","kw","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.e.gov.kw/sites/kgoArabic/Portal/Pages/Others/KuwaitMap.aspx",,,,"Kuwait Map","Kuwait Portal (eGov)","Yes","Yes","Map doesn't work again so I'm approving the last conclusions.","Kuwaiti government online has a page for Kuwaiti map but there is an error in the page (https://www.e.gov.kw/sites/kgoArabic/Portal/Pages/Others/KuwaitMap.aspx).
The municipality of Kuwaiti has a map fro Kuwaiti linked with google maps (https://gis1.baladia.gov.kw/).
Reviewer's comment:
When checking again, the map worked. It has zoom up to 1:150,000, further zooms sometimes don't show anything, though, it apparently provide zoom up to 1:5,000 for some locations. The map has marks for roads, national borders, etc. Not sure when it is updated though.","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Gil Zaretzer","35"
"4feb9abf-4359-497b-b8d1-55035282a7f8","global","2015-10-02T10:35:50","2015","fi","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.maanmittauslaitos.fi/aineistot-palvelut/latauspalvelut/avoimien-aineistojen-tiedostopalvelu","TIFF, GML, Shape","https://www.maanmittauslaitos.fi/aineistot-palvelut/latauspalvelut/avoimien-aineistojen-tiedostopalvelu",,,"National Land Survey of Finland","Yes","Yes","Everything seems correct","A list of current datasets to be downloaded
https://www.maanmittauslaitos.fi/aineistot-palvelut/latauspalvelut/avoimien-aineistojen-tiedostopalvelu (in Finnish)
Currently users can download the basic, terrain map (raster) in 1:50 000 resolution. In the future other map data will be published for free download ja use. Roadmap in Finnish: https://www.maanmittauslaitos.fi/aineistot-palvelut/latauspalvelut/avoimien-aineistojen-tiedostopalvelu
No changes from 2014","Yes","Yes","Mor Rubinstein","Gil Zaretzer","100"
"5b36152d-ea01-4af4-a487-8bac58e3c331","global","2015-09-24T07:56:56","2015","bf","map","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The website of the geographical institute of Burkina Faso (IGB) apears to be down at time of review so I'm accepting it as is.","The better scale we have in Burkina Faso is 1:200 000, realised with the support of the european union. The map data are managed by the geographical institute of Burkina Faso (IGB)","Yes","No","Idriss TINTO","Gil Zaretzer","0"
"6f3d8ae9-aab8-4a02-a180-28a5f49fcbac","global","2015-09-30T20:33:29","2015","tz","map","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,"Tanzania Administration","Survey and mapping Division, Ministry of Lands","Yes","Yes","The Tanzania Ministry of Lands has a Mapping Division and a Digital Mapping Subdivision, but other than that, it is unclear if it is available to the public on or off line.
https://www.ardhi.go.tz/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=258&Itemid=333",,"Yes","No","Joachim Mangilima","Gil Zaretzer","10"
"2e1fe9fc-18af-47ac-ae62-9ba0e3a1d107","global","2015-09-08T15:28:44","2015","bo","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://geo.gob.bo/","shapefiles",,,"GEOBOLIVIA","GEOBOLIVIA/VICEPRESIDENCIA DEL ESTADO PLURINACIONAL DE BOLIVIA","Yes","Yes","Since it is possible to download the compelete 4.6G dataset, I'm marking yes on bulk download, other than that everything seems correct.","GeoBolivia pretende dotar a
instituciones y usuarios en general, de información geográfica de interés de rápido acceso e
independientemente del lugar o dispositivo del cuál se acceda; es decir, disponer de una información
geográfica relevante, actualizada, armonizada y de calidad para apoyar la toma de decisiones y el
desarrollo social, económico y ambiental del país.
Presentacion WEB: https://geo.gob.bo/presentacion/#/
Video: https://goo.gl/62tvEN
","Yes","No","FERNANDO MOLINA","Gil Zaretzer","70"
"9066815e-b099-45d1-8b43-fe383506bb44","global","2015-09-27T21:18:31","2015","uy","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://descarga-cdp-ide.agesic.gub.uy","raster, vector",,,,"Infraestructura de Datos Espaciales (IDEuy)","Yes","Yes","eveything seems correct","Infraestrutura de Datos Espaciales (IDEuy) is responsible for aggregating information on geospacial data produced by different government agencies.
Beyond the linked data, one can find other maps visualizations (https://ide.uy/inicio/herramientas/visualizadores-de-mapas/visualizadores-de-mapas some of them with downloadable data), a metadata catalogue (https://ide.uy/inicio/herramientas/catalogo+de+metadatos/catalogo+de+metadatos) and geoservices (https://ide.uy/inicio/herramientas/geoservicios).","Yes","No","Daniel Carranza","Gil Zaretzer","70"
"63c5c111-2fae-4e4d-9f50-f12b79e3fe92","global","2015-09-28T18:00:11","2015","py","map","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.disergemil.mil.py","jpg",,,,,"Yes","Yes","eveything seems correct","According to Juan, did not changed from 2014. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Gil Zaretzer","10"
"cb25b51c-bef9-4ddc-bf64-5bc1b81acb33","global","2015-10-13T21:22:08","2015","tg","map","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.asftogo.org/ckfinder/userfiles/images/carte.jpg",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The entry was from an unofficial source and not up to scale, I couldn't find anything on Google to suggest there is any official data.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Gil Zaretzer","0"
"eed161e6-9a1e-4836-96a3-f403c989b63a","global","2015-10-03T08:14:55","2015","gn","map","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Everything seems correct","The available national map, is only in the scale of 1/200000.","Yes","No","anonymous","Gil Zaretzer","0"
"ee55e58b-1997-4d93-ba39-0e6686a257b6","global","2015-10-01T22:22:26","2015","ci","map","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://tinyurl.com/lsqfloj",".zip","https://www.orange.com/en/about/Group/our-features/2013/D4D/Data-for-Development",,,"Orange Labs shared the document as part of the Orange 2013 Data for Development competiton (D4D challenge, in cooperation with Orange Ivory Coast, local authorities and regulatory bodies): https://tinyurl.com/lsqfloj","Yes","Yes","Everything seems correct","After significant amount of research on government websites of Côte d'Ivoire and on Google it appears that this data does not exist yet. Some evidence for this:
- no government agency seems to be responsible for gathering this type of data (for instance the Statistical Agency ""Institut Nacional de la Statistique"" doesn't produce this type of data and searching on google for ""institut geographique côte d'ivoire"" shows that such institution existed in the 1980s but today does not have any presence on the internet.
The administrative boundaries have been published by Orange Lab, a telecommunications company together with locations of their transmission towers (https://sodexo.orange-labs.fr/GEOM_SUB_PREFECTURE.zip). The data is available in shapefile format which is vector data and the scale can not be determined. As it is not the full dataset required here, the evaluation is that detailed map data at a scale of 1:250,000 or better doesn't currently exist for Côte d'Ivoire.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Gil Zaretzer","0"
"3cac9390-1a67-4590-924a-341d4b0adca4","global","2015-09-28T11:29:27","2015","ge","map","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","My review agrees with these findings, the data exists in digital form somewhere but it is not public or anything else.","A detailed, zoomable map is made available by the National Agency of Public Registry (https://maps.napr.gov.ge/) which operates under the Ministry of Justice and maintains the cadasters. The map appears to be timely. Users can mainly only display data on cadasters, topographic data and information on administrative boundaries, etc. is not available online.
The Ministry of Environment and Natural Resources Protection of Georgia makes available linked PDF (and many others) at https://moe.gov.ge/index.php?lang_id=GEO&sec_id=56&info_id=0&mod_id=0&new_year=0&limit=0&date=&new_month=&entrant=1. There are no maps with the required scale though.
However, these maps themselves are low-resolution PDFs renderings of the actual map data; it is therefore possible that the online datasets do not meet the scale requirements, since the resolution of the map which is available online may be less than 1:250,000.
This also means that the maps are not available in machine-readable format, since no Shapefile or similar file type is available.
High resolution maps of Georgia exist as can be confirmed on the website the private company Geoland Ltd. The company offers the service https://www.mygeorgia.ge/ where users can obtain different high-level maps and also download the current screen or create a link related to the current view.
All data generated by the Georgian Government is legally in the public domain.","Yes","No","Eric Barrett","Gil Zaretzer","10"
"3e23d6e2-ed95-483b-96e2-589e986f422a","global","2015-10-07T01:51:41","2015","cn","map","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Everythins seems correct","State Bureau of Surveying and Mapping is responsible for map data. The agency only provides low resolution online (max 1: 4 000 000) in JPG or EPS format (1).
##Sources
(1) https://219.238.166.215/mcp/index.asp Accessed on 2014-10-16
Nothing changed in 2015","Yes","No","OKFN CN","Gil Zaretzer","5"
"1d24defa-936c-4cb7-aa4c-4ef4f94ed166","global","2015-09-18T14:40:52","2015","il","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed","https://www.ag.mof.gov.il/AccountantGeneral/BudgetExecution/BudgetExecutionTopNavEng indicates that the data exists and is digital but transactional data is not published.","Yes","No","anonymous","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"0f198971-4125-4b13-8ce5-23b2af15a839","global","2015-09-28T18:18:19","2015","sv","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Resumen Ejecutivo Ejecución Presupuestaria Gastos . Monthly Executive summary from 2005 to 2014","Ministerio de Hacienda - Transparencia Fiscal - email: transparencia.fiscal@mh.gob.sv","Yes","Yes","Submission fixed","Data on Government Spending exists but it is very spreaded in the website. Detailed information is provided mainly in PDF format, but some aggregated data for different years is also provided through excel files in the URL:
https://www.transparenciafiscal.gob.sv/portal/page/portal/PTF
That indicates that the data exists and is digital.","Yes","No","anonymous","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"78cf327d-dca5-4dae-843c-e7e0745528fd","global","2015-10-25T00:12:01","2015","kz","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Excel files showing the amount of budget funds officials received and spent relative to the initial plan. The information is updated once a month. The information about Republic Budget and Local Budget are shown seperately. ","The Ministry of Finance of Republic of Kazakhstan","Yes","Yes","Submission is correct","The [information provided](https://www.minfin.gov.kz/irj/portal/anonymous?NavigationTarget=ROLES://portal_content/mf/kz.ecc.roles/kz.ecc.anonymous/kz.ecc.anonymous/kz.ecc.anonym_budgeting/budgeting/reports_fldr/budget_execution_fldr) by government officials in Kazakhstan (by default) is open for reuse, publishing as cited by the law. The website provides information about government spendings (local and nationwide) albeit in aggregated form but the data seems to exist and be in digital form.","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"740942f2-b7a1-4f22-a449-fbdc3db5cf61","global","2015-10-02T11:30:10","2015","ne","spending","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Budget Execution","Ministry of finances","Yes","Yes","Submission fixed","The spending data is not published by default as there are many kinds of spending, including sensitive data. The user can request for the type of data at the ministry, and get access to it for free, but there can be restrictions for the reuse of the data.","Yes","No","anonymous","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","5"
"0460ed8d-5e08-41c7-b884-33ae30f4e15d","global","2015-09-30T22:54:56","2015","tc","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed","The government publishes monthly financial reports: https://www.gov.tc/treasury/index.php/publications/government-financial-reports/7-2015-monthly-financial-reports which indicates that the data exists and is digital.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"95f3ebdb-d01d-4db9-b8c3-ae3049d7a6e7","global","2015-09-01T13:04:13","2015","je","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is correct.","Annual accounts for 2003 to 2014 are available at
https://www.gov.je/Government/PlanningPerformance/BudgetAccounts/Pages/StatesofJersey2008Accounts.aspx
","Yes","No","Marcus Ferbrache","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"5ceb1037-dd69-4466-a940-2e21c9b6f670","global","2015-10-01T23:50:41","2015","se","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,"Department of Finance (Finansdepartementet)","Yes","Yes","Submission is correct","Not clear if detailed spending records could be retrieved from the government offices (Regeringskansliet) under a FOIA request.
Latest annual report is from 2014 (last budget year):
https://www.regeringen.se/sveriges-regering/finansdepartementet/statens-budget/tidigare-budgetar/ which indicates that the data exists and is in digital form.
","Yes","No","Asmen Gül","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"e1a1149e-c539-4481-9edd-e778e4b19604","global","2015-09-15T20:54:43","2015","bh","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.","The government of Bahrain seems to collect transactional data digitally given their most recent final accounts statement: https://www.mofne.gov.bh/showdatafile.asp?rid=2991&ftype=file1 but no transactional data is published.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"05cfd916-32f0-43fd-8919-f1f370f6fb8b","global","2015-10-02T15:12:15","2015","ne","water","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Measurement of water quality","Heritage Water Company of Niger (https://www.spen.ne/)","Yes","Yes","Treatment plant must collect water quality, can't find any data, so changed submission to unsure.","Daily analisys is done by the company, and the data can be delivered for free on demand.","Yes","No","anonymous","Nisha Thompson","5"
"956c357b-e3e3-4d73-9b65-bbbfe0423ea4","global","2015-10-24T20:14:52","2015","tr","water","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,"General Directorate of Water","Ministry of Forestry and Water Affairs","Yes","Yes","Ministry of Forrest and Water is in charge of water quality and they refer to collecting it but I couldn't find the actual data.","Can only logging with username to get infomation. Can not acces data set easly.
https://cbs.cevresaglik.gov.tr/cevresaglik/giris.aspx","Yes","No","Nisha Thompson","Nisha Thompson","5"
"14aa3028-2a08-4da2-ab59-f10b3ec7ba8a","global","2015-09-27T23:44:48","2015","bw","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Unsure",,"No","https://www.water.gov.bw/images/Reports/Botswana-SA_Joint_Water_Quality_Baseline_Report_for_Limpopo_Transboundary_River_2013_(Final).pdf",,,,"Vasriousd surveys and samplings","Department of water affairs","Yes","Yes","Found the water quality report but it is from 2012. ","Surveys and samplings are done but datasets are shallow","Yes","No","anonymous","Nisha Thompson","35"
"e9fa1817-0281-4381-9c97-e30b821d129a","global","2015-09-27T18:32:04","2015","ms","water","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,,"Montserrat Utilities Ltd.","Yes","Yes","Data is old from 2012, report is available online but data isn't.","Montserrat Utilities Ltd was formed through the merger of the existing electricity (Monlec) and water (MWA) utilities. On completion of the merger process, MUL acquired all the assets, liabilities, duties and privileges of the predecessor organisations, and began operation under new legislation (the Utility Act).
MUL therefore became an umbrella company for the predecessor organizations, Montserrat Electricity Services Ltd. and Montserrat Water Authority, which continue to be responsible for electricity and water on Montserrat.
It is unclear if they have data for water quality regarding fecal coliform, arsenic, fluoride levels, nitrates and TDS (total dissolved solids).","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Nisha Thompson","10"
"51b6cbe5-d8b2-4191-b041-7378d33b01b1","global","2015-10-03T08:42:14","2015","gn","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Couldn't find any government website or water authority that talks about water quality collection or monitoring. So I changed the submission to UNSURE","The guinea water point service is doing daily analysis of water quality, but no evidence about the availability of the data","Yes","No","anonymous","Nisha Thompson","0"
"01e98af0-964e-4f78-b61e-f04b3b3f7777","global","2015-10-02T04:32:19","2015","ci","water","Yes","Unsure","No","No","No","Unsure","Unsure",,"Yes",,,,,"Analyse quotidienne de la qualité de l'eau","Office National de l'Eau Potable (National Drinking Water Office)","Yes","Yes","Couldn't find any reference on the water supplier's site regarding water quality.
https://www.onepci.net/onepci_documents_scientifiques.php
So changed the submission to UNSURE.","The National Drinking Water Office realises daily analysis of the drinking water, but the résults are not published by default. The user need to send a request to have the data.","Yes","No","anonymous","Nisha Thompson","15"
"df4edd47-43d6-42c1-b8bd-6b6095e3886b","global","2015-10-02T06:03:48","2015","ml","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Couldn't Malian society drinking water heritage online or references to it as the major agency for water supply. Also couldn't find any references to water quality collection. Because of this I changed the submission to UNSURE.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Nisha Thompson","0"
"0a5abc75-08df-4beb-922d-ce3b321ad10c","global","2015-10-02T11:49:24","2015","ba","water","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Approving submission, can't find any water quality or reference to collecting water quality.","There is no detailed data about government spending.","Yes","No","dalio sijah","Nisha Thompson","0"
"51375377-8065-4047-b4c0-35f3158323ee","global","2015-09-25T19:33:30","2015","do","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://datos.gob.do/dataset/datos-de-potabilidad-del-agua/resource/d8f7c0e9-51f6-4489-8b64-0b7a459b6f44","Excel","https://datos.gob.do/dataset/datos-de-potabilidad-del-agua/resource/d8f7c0e9-51f6-4489-8b64-0b7a459b6f44",,,,"Yes","Yes","The data that is available is only for 1 parameter, not the others, the source's website is not working so I changed the submission to ""Unsure""",,"Yes","No","Eliaquín Encarnación","Nisha Thompson","0"
"b3176107-0ddc-43f5-b39e-41238c43f6a6","global","2015-09-16T09:46:45","2015","kg","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Yes","No","No",,"No",,,,,"They provide information on water quality and about environment in general","State Agency on Environment Protection and Forestry, https://nature.gov.kg/index.php?Itemid=103","Yes","Yes","While there is a lot of references to collecting water quality but no data just reports and summaries. ","State Agency on Environment Protection and Forestry provides information about environment in the country.","Yes","No","Azamat Tokhtaev","Nisha Thompson","30"
"34c37c33-6dcb-451b-922d-d0d4e35d805a","global","2015-09-15T15:35:39","2015","th","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://wqmonline.com/",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","There is a water quality online portal but I can't log in so I can't confirm if the parameters we want are there. ","This is a web application. It allowed public access through login page as 'guest'","Yes","No","Klaikong Vaidhyakarn","Nisha Thompson","0"
"61e27e71-67e2-4112-b24b-f623f9c57edf","global","2015-09-25T13:16:06","2015","al","water","Yes","No","No","Yes","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.mjedisi.gov.al/al/dokumenta/raporte-te-gjendjes-se-mjedisit/monitorim-mjedisor",,,,"Water quality","Ministry of Environment","Yes","Yes","Report of water quality is available but from 2013 but the data is not available.","These data is made available from the authorities, but is not easily accessible. ","Yes","No","Blerta Tuci","Nisha Thompson","10"
"0c29ae4d-b0e2-4cda-9711-94cc8f8cfacc","global","2015-09-17T18:58:40","2015","us","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://viewer.nationalmap.gov/viewer/","shapefiles","https://www.usgs.gov/faq/categories/10154/3550",,"The National Map","U.S. Geological Survey","Yes","Yes","I'm approving this although I'm unable to download at the moment, the FAQ mentions some kind of tab or control which does not show, I am giving them the benefit of the doubt that they do inted to have download capabilities.","Use The National Map Viewer and Download Platform to visualize, inspect, and download our most current topographic base map data and products for free. Managed by the USGS National Geospatial Program (NGP), the National Map Viewer provides access to all eight primary data themes of The National Map to include US Topo and historical topographic map products. The viewer platform is extended upon the National Geospatial Intelligence Agency's (NGA) Palanterra x3 Viewer.
Data include: Elevation, Orthoimagery, Hydrography, Geographic Names, Boundaries, Transportation, Structures, and Land Cover, while products include: US Topo and Historical Topo Maps. The National Map Viewer also allows visualization and identification queries (but not downloads) of Other Featured Data, to include Scanned Topo Maps, Ecosystems, Protected Areas, Gap Analysis Program Land Cover, Wetlands, Public Land Survey System, and National Park Service Boundaries. Also included is a Natural Hazards panel to view hazards-related information, such as for earthquakes, floods, wildfires, and weather, along with the U.S. National Grid for emergency response.
Observation: expert review was done on 27th and 28th of November and on both dates the map viewer did not load on Chrome and Firefox.","Yes","Yes","anonymous","Gil Zaretzer","100"
"9e1e8b3a-a2f4-4edb-b787-20a30e2457ec","global","2015-10-02T09:34:03","2015","ke","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Approving submission, site is down can't find alternative sources.","The National Environment Management Authority responsible for this information might hold data, website (https://www.nema.go.ke/) is down at the moment- no other way to ascertain whether or not official information exists.
The Ministry of Water and Irrigation does not handle water quality tests, research and regulation.","Yes","No","anonymous","Nisha Thompson","0"
"40f8105d-be1a-4fec-b863-31dbce8f8ae6","global","2015-09-16T05:35:33","2015","gd","land","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The responsible agency is the Grenada Land Agency - Land Data and Revenue Centre
https://www.gov.gd/landagency/beta/gla/services/eland-services/
The eLandRegistry page is not working 69.73.208.69/uwi6/ at the time of the review. ",,"Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"304a9299-f0a9-40e4-89dd-3153cd323e5c","global","2015-09-20T05:36:13","2015","dm","land","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,,"Land Registry","Yes","Yes","""A search can be conducted at the Registry of Titles of any Certificate of Title to determine whether there are any encumbrances or matters affecting it. The records at the Land Registry are recorded by number in the computer system, while the original certificates are kept in paper form."" https://www.doingbusiness.org/data/exploreeconomies/dominica/registering-property/","Land data is not in digital format, instead it is paper format. The data collected is fairly up to date. No known websites we could visit to gather this information.","Yes","No","Veronne Nicholas","Codrina Maria Ilie","5"
"21ab5603-d108-4828-828e-f6630b7e5f25","global","2015-09-28T05:36:00","2015","bm","land","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok
","It is uncertain if land ownership data exists","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"50cb5034-8d7e-4c2a-85aa-123cf007cecc","global","2015-09-20T15:43:07","2015","bb","land","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"dc486693-c4d3-4166-bd44-5a8bbadec9df","global","2015-09-23T15:44:44","2015","bs","land","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","""The Land Information System (LIS) which prevails in the Bahamas is mainly discreet in
nature. Many records exist about land and property rights, how ever they are often stored manually in files, large manual books of documents in volumes, or archived on microfilm. "" https://www.fig.net/resources/proceedings/fig_proceedings/fig2006/papers/ts66/ts66_01_ferguson_0721.pdf","It is uncertain if the data for land ownership exists","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"184768a1-3edc-4932-885d-9a0305595b21","global","2015-09-28T00:04:03","2015","aw","land","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","It is uncertain if data for land ownership in Aruba exists.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"148848d7-fc51-498a-9fad-cfccf69f062a","global","2015-09-20T12:45:07","2015","ag","land","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Under a Public-Private partnership Framework, the OAS and the multinational Stewart Global Solutions embarked in an initiative aimed at contributing to the improvement of the land administration, property registry, tax revenue collection and transparency of the public administration of the eastern Caribbean countries (OECS), trough an integration of the cadastral and registry systems. The pilot Project for this regional initiative was implemented in Antigua and Barbuda. https://portal.oas.org/Portal/Sector/SAP/DepartamentoparalaGesti%C3%B3nP%C3%BAblicaEfectiva/NPA/MuNetCatastro/OASCadastreProjects/tabid/1821/Default.aspx?language=en-us",,"Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"4e43d39a-7cce-4b52-9396-92d605016835","global","2015-10-24T16:05:29","2015","al","land","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","No","Unsure","Unsure",,"Yes","https://geoportal.asig.gov.al/en/InfoandServices.aspx?lang=EN",,,,"Land Ownership","ZYRA E REGJISTRIMIT TË PASURIVE TË PALUAJTSHME","Yes","Yes","ok","These dataset is not public, is available but the information can be accessed only from the owner and or a person who have legal authorization from the owner. Metadata available - layer building (address system) https://geoportal.asig.gov.al/en/InfoandServices.aspx?lang=EN ","Yes","No","Codrina Maria Ilie","Codrina Maria Ilie","25"
"911778a8-334f-443d-b639-dd2dd303dbbc","global","2015-09-25T12:45:21","2015","al","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://gis.ceshtjetvendore.gov.al/","geojson",,,"Location Datasets","GIS-Ceshtjet Vendore","Yes","Yes","ok","The dataset was updated after the new Administrative Reform, but its does have the Zipcodes, the addresses and geographical coordinations.","Yes","No","Blerta Tuci","Codrina Maria Ilie","70"
"741ee1bc-39f7-4a15-8e87-1490b3049e29","global","2015-08-30T14:05:41","2015","np","map","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,"Ministry of Land Reform and Management, Department of Survey, National Land Use Project","Yes","Yes","The website apears to be working, but offers no data to download or view, so while it seems the data does exist digitaly, the rest of our questions are left unanswered.","Data is under SURVEY DEPARTMENT, Ministry of Land Reform and Management Government of Nepal. Site under maintenance at the time of review.
https://dos.gov.np/language/en/","Yes","No","Nikesh Balami","Gil Zaretzer","10"
"4a81aa12-0ffa-487b-9549-9c9fac5684e0","global","2015-09-27T12:20:32","2015","tl","land","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The official administration in charge with the cadastre system is the SNC - Sistema Nacional de Cadastro, under the Ministry of Justice. The cadastre database is under construction, according to their website. https://www.snc-timorleste.com/","There are no dedicated department(s) nor ministry found to be responsible on informing the public about the status of land ownership in Timor-Leste.","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"67e7ba14-88f9-4082-905b-3782930035bc","global","2015-09-21T02:18:02","2015","ph","land","Yes","Unsure","No","No","No","Unsure","No",,"Unsure",,,,,,"Land Management Bureau ","Yes","Yes","The Land Management Bureau (Filipino: Kawanihan ng Pamamahala sa mga Lupa, abbreviated as LMB), is an agency of the Philippine government under the Department of Environment and Natural Resources responsible for administering, surveying, managing, and disposing Alienable and Disposable (A&D) lands and other government lands not placed under the jurisdiction of other government agencies (Wikipedia). Official page: https://www.lmb.gov.ph/",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","5"
"0cedfcc8-3207-450f-ba99-ffc1d97cd33e","global","2015-10-01T12:12:36","2015","ky","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Lands and Survey Department","Cayman Land Info","Yes","Yes","The data is digital since the maps are printed from digital source (most probably), however it is not online since you can only order it online but recive a printed map. ","Can argue that this data is not digital - you can only get printed versions not the files themselves (although it must exist in a digital format for them to be able to generate these prints).
https://www.caymanlandinfo.ky/StandardMaps/tabid/66/Default.aspx","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Gil Zaretzer","25"
"8a9ea0e5-71e4-4d63-879b-c3617c55bb3b","global","2015-09-28T13:10:54","2015","gg","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://maps.digimap.gg/","HTML+JS",,,"Guernsey Geographical Layers","Digimap","Yes","Yes","Everything seems correct","Selected layers available. Not all layers available in a single map.
Outsourced to Digimap
Powered by ESRI
","Yes","No","Marcus Ferbrache","Gil Zaretzer","45"
"777b0b71-2419-45f5-aad5-e909a836bea4","global","2015-10-01T09:43:56","2015","bj","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Unsure","Yes","No",,"No",,"shp",,,"Carte de base du territoire national","Institut géographique national du Benin","Yes","Yes","At the time of this review, all of the Benin government websites apear to be down, so I'm leaving this entry as is.","The Geographical National Institute of Benin is responsible for the production of topographic maps at the scale of 1:200000, 1:50000, 1:25000 but according to a 2008 report from the Ministry of Mines, Energy and Water, whole coverage of the country is only available at 1:200000 scale","Yes","No","anonymous","Gil Zaretzer","30"
"775d2f35-c1b5-4263-a250-b60c39b39a66","global","2015-09-28T08:14:11","2015","mm","land","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","We have identified news related to Myanmar survey activities (https://unhabitat.org.mm/news/land-administration-and-management-programme-lamp-in-myanmar-news/expanding-coverage-of-rural-cadastral-mapping-by-kwin-mapping-in-unsurveyed-areas/) , but we were unable to find out if the data exist. ","No evidence from the President's Officer website that the data exists. https://www.myanmarpresidentoffice.info/en/ and the dedicated webpage for the cabinet ministries is empty https://www.myanmarpresidentoffice.info/en/?q=cabinet/ministries so no way to find out who are the responsible minister involve. I have found a 3rd party website https://www.ourweb.info/01/directory/myanmar/005/ that provide a list of ministries official websites but some of these websites are not found.
Kindly note that there is a high possibility that Myanmar government did not update each of these ministries websites so there is an error while trying to gain access to these websites.","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"f5d76664-02ae-417e-a4f8-7f0d6c9d4a79","global","2015-09-27T00:58:18","2015","cr","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Government spending","Contraloría General de la República","Yes","Yes","Submission fixed","The Contraloría General de la República has information about public spending of different public institutions: https://cgrweb.cgr.go.cr/apex/f?p=10263:3:0::NO:::
Nevertheless the site is not friendly and the data is only aggregated. ","Yes","No","camila salazar","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"aa174765-5186-4c55-92b4-59d0a67b97b8","global","2015-09-16T13:59:19","2015","gt","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed (original submission was about procurements)","Budget execution is available at: https://siafmuni.minfin.gob.gt/siafmuni/MainGenerica.aspx?pResolucion=1024&pForma=GASTOSnew.aspx?pResolucion=1024 but only shows aggregated results. The data still seems to exist in digital form.","Yes","No","Joel Peñate","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"b05ca26e-6707-47dd-882d-4fcef530c952","global","2015-09-28T07:08:40","2015","id","land","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","We have identified a master thesis ""The Workflow of Maintenance of Cadastral Data as
based on Land Administration Domain Model (LADM) A case study in Indonesia "" by
Kurnia Wulan Sari released in 2010. The author investigates the land survey system in Indonesia. According to her findings, the data exists, but we can not verify by testing a sample datasets. For more info https://www.itc.nl/library/papers_2010/msc/la/sari.pdf","No data found from Open Government Indonesia https://data.go.id/dataset?_groups_limit=0","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","5"
"c1a9a31a-0390-478f-bd20-a45002292d32","global","2015-09-23T07:24:49","2015","fi","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,"The State Treasury / Financial al and Personnel Administration/ netra@valtiokonttori.fi","Yes","Yes","Submission fixed. Not transactional data.","Certain data assets of The State Treasurey internet reporting system (https://netra.fi) are available on Finnish data portal https://avoindata.fi. The data is available in aggregated form, not transactional but it is clear that the data exists and is digital.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"f188e857-54fa-47d9-b339-997fa1e79b04","global","2015-09-28T23:40:02","2015","pa","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,"ANTAI","Yes","Yes","Submission is correct (except timely can't be yes because the data is not publicly available)","Data is aggregated, not in a transactional form.
Summarized by month at this url:
https://contraloria.gob.pa/index.php?opcion=InfContral
If you know the number of the check or contract you can look it up on their site:
https://www.contraloria.gob.pa/Sicowebconsultas/buscar.aspx
I have extracted most of the data and published it here:
https://www.panadata.net/contraloria","Yes","No","HAMZAH HAJI","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"4f616761-4544-49d6-89db-46ae61beccfa","global","2015-01-17T11:14:12","2015","th","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"The summarization of actual spending of government spending. The government of Thailand use gF ( government fisical ","information and communication technology center under the ministry of financE","Yes","Yes","Submission is correct (fixed publicly available to no, since transactional data is not publicly available)","There are 4 types of spending data published by the Ministry of Finance, albeit in aggregated form, not as transactional data:
1. Budget spending by ministry (การเบิกจ่ายเงิน จำแนกตามกระทรวง)
2. Budget spending by economic type and ministry (การเบิกจ่ายเงิน จำแนกตามลักษณะเศรษฐกิจและกระทรวง)
3. Budget spending by spending type (การเบิกจ่ายเงิน จำแนกตามหมวดรายจ่าย)
4. Budget spending by sub-spending type (การเบิกจ่ายเงิน จำแนกตามหมวดรายจ่ายย่อย)
All four types are available at: https://dwfoc.mof.go.th/menu3.htm
This is aggregated data and not transactional data but it indicates that the data exists in digital form","Yes","No","Orachat Work","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"40092613-15e2-4901-948f-500f7cbdc2fd","global","2015-10-02T19:40:04","2015","sn","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Budget execution","Forecasting Directorate and Economic Studies","Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.","There is a [aggregate spending data][1] that are publicly available online as pdf documents. The detailed data can be accessed by request for free.
[1]: https://www.dpee.sn/IMG/pdf/sigfip3108.pdf","Yes","No","anonymous","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"8d402c1b-59dd-49c2-aafd-8c32d6414e31","global","2015-08-27T13:27:59","2015","cl","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://catalogo.geoportal.cl/geoportal/","XML, shape, kmz, geotiff, others",,,"National Catalogue of Geospatial Information","National Land Ministry, National Spatial Data Infrastructure.","Yes","Yes","Everything seems correct","Allows to search for geospatial information published in different formats by the institutions that are part of the National Geospatial Information Catalog.
Data is updated, but there is no specific license. ","Yes","No","Diego Ignacio","Gil Zaretzer","60"
"314b2bf6-de87-4b66-b8c4-bee6dc61b43c","global","2015-09-28T16:20:34","2015","fr","map","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Yes","No",,"Yes",,"Shapefile",,,"BD TOPO Full 3D vectorized national database of geographical elements","IGN","Yes","Yes","Review: everything seems correct.","Previous revision was proposing FranceRaster, which is only TIFF images, not matching the prerequisites here.
After full examination of all open or not available data from IGN (national geography administration), BD TOPO as shapefiles seems the only dataset matching all the requirements of yearly updates, precision and contents.
Some of the different contents can be accessed openly through some of the following databases but either with not enough precision or not enough updates. No combination of those allow to build the full requirements:
- ROUTE500 https://professionnels.ign.fr/route500 (roads + national limits, no fresh update)
- BD ALTI250 MNT https://professionnels.ign.fr/bdalti (moutains)
- BD CARTO https://professionnels.ign.fr/bdcarto (roads + water + national limits, not open)","Yes","No","Regards Citoyens","Gil Zaretzer","35"
"9e0c3bdb-e554-49b3-8ba9-b9f466b5113b","global","2015-08-30T14:21:41","2015","sa","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,"Official maps of Saudi (general, baseline, terrain, etc)","General Commission for Survey","Yes","Yes","Everything seems correct","General Commission for Survey of Saudi ( https://www.gcs.gov.sa/Home.aspx ) is responsible for maintaining and publishing official maps of Saudi. Maps at the detail level required by the index (1:25000) ( https://www.gcs.gov.sa/Products/DetailedMaps.aspx ) cannot be downloaded from the website and can only acquired by request. It is not clear from the website if payment is required to acquire these maps.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Gil Zaretzer","15"
"bf452acd-6b56-4fbe-bbc9-239df2e9914b","global","2015-10-12T19:13:37","2015","gy","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,"Guyana Land & Surveys Commision","Yes","Yes","The Guyana Land and Surveys Commision offers mapping data for sale, the catalogue is from 2007, the data exists, and is public but not free, it is not online and the rest is unknown since I cannot varify anything else.
The website: https://www.lands.gov.gy/index.php",,"Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Gil Zaretzer","15"
"508b1e29-179a-412c-8572-9887f9ea1295","global","2015-09-01T19:20:40","2015","iq","map","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I couldn't found anything relevant online, all I could find was a report from 2014 about establishing a national GIS program, so maybe some data exists.",,"Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Gil Zaretzer","0"
"689c5ffe-57eb-47df-a9ce-33565272af0c","global","2015-09-15T12:00:56","2015","tn","map","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","My review reaches the same conclusions as the years before.","We could not find data beyond what is mentioned last year. We checked this (https://www.cnt.nat.tn/ar/index.php?m=45) and here is last year's comment below:
Data is not available online at all.
The Interior Ministry's Open Data website has a map with names of governorates (provinces) and the respective number of delegations for each. But it's not map data as per the indicator's definition. https://opendata.interieur.gov.tn/fr/datas/index/type:3
The map data on this website is from OpenStreetMap. The license is CC-by 3.0 Unported (indicated at the bottom of the website).","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Gil Zaretzer","0"
"d911c42c-b4d2-4e6a-a5b5-a992c8e1d98e","global","2015-08-20T10:52:43","2015","my","map","Yes","No","Unsure","Unsure","No","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","the Department of Survey and Mapping Malaysia official portal seems to offer different kinds of maps and data for sale, but the catalauge doesn't work at the time of this review, thus the data exists, not for free, and the rest is unknown in my opinion.","From the Department of Survey and Mapping Malaysia official portal, there datasets are not available. Given that the institution is in the Federal State territory, submitting for Freedom of Information request is impossible because there is no Freedom of Information Act for the Federal State Wilayah Persekutuan.","Yes","No","Hazwany Jamaluddin","Gil Zaretzer","5"
"3b1e696e-43aa-4563-8896-666fd39d16dd","global","2015-10-12T17:13:14","2015","tj","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Unsure","Yes",,"Unsure","https://mapfactory.tj/tg/catalog/all",,,,"The State Unitary Enterprise ","State Unitary Enterprise ","Yes","Yes","The images from the website of State Committee on Land Management and Geodesy of the Republic of Tajikistan do not meet our criteria, but the data sold by State Unitary Enterprise seems to do, I am also pretty sure it is machine readable but since I cannot varify it I'm changing it to unsure. Other than that, the data exists, digitialy, open to the public for a negotiable price, in bulk, but not in an open license. ","At the same products relevant to emergency situations mapping are available for free in the website of State Committee on Land Management and Geodesy of the Republic of Tajikistan. https://goskomzem.tj/index.php/geoportal/karta","Yes","No","anonymous","Gil Zaretzer","30"
"41fa2fae-85ae-4730-b8f1-782cea06ee2e","global","2015-09-15T13:00:50","2015","bd","water","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","Unsure",,"No",,,,,"https://www.mowr.gov.bd/","Ministry of Water Resource ","Yes","Yes","Found a catalog of the data available and reference to its meta data
https://www.warpo.gov.bd/pdf/Datacatalogue.pdf
https://www.warpo.gov.bd/pdf/nwrd_Data_list.pdf
however couldn't find the data itself. ",,"Yes","No","Hasive Nur Chowdhury","Nisha Thompson","10"
"33ae2510-048e-4e9f-a8e1-1e794478cd62","global","2015-10-04T12:15:14","2015","az","map","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The only thing I could find about Azerbaijan is an interactive map with some statistical data, but it does not meet our criteria, however it makes me thing that the data we are looking for probably exist but in no way open, thus I am giving Azerbaijan the benefit of the doubt and leaving it as ""unsure"".",,"Yes","No","Codrina Maria Ilie","Gil Zaretzer","0"
"afc054f4-f702-49e8-8194-982415464f46","global","2015-08-30T14:24:41","2015","np","water","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,"Ministry of Urban Development, Department of Water Supply and Sewerage","Yes","Yes","Links are not working on site, can't find alternative links. The general website looks like it contains the data. Moved the assessment to unsure. ",,"Yes","No","Nikesh Balami","Nisha Thompson","5"
"9648cc80-c96b-4266-a36e-5b6b68331d07","global","2015-10-02T21:32:21","2015","sn","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","After researching I could not find any reference to National Water Society of Senegal or water quality measurements being available online in a digital format. So changing to unsure. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Nisha Thompson","0"
"782178d4-6e6b-4c7c-979c-21ddadd1be28","global","2015-01-12T21:30:00","2015","is","map","Yes","Yes","No","No","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes",,"tiff, gdb, shp","https://www.lmi.is/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/Almskilm.pdf",,,"Landmælingar Íslands","Yes","Yes","Access to the data of the national survey of Iceland is not considered as online or public by this index, since one has to register and recive a download link to access the information and cannot look at it without doing so.","English version of license terms is available at: https://www.lmi.is/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/licenceNLSI.pdf
Users have to register to have access to the service. A download link is provided that can be used during 2 days from the registered IP. Raster maps are provided for the following scales: 1:25.000, 1:100.000 and 1:250.000","Yes","No","Yuhan Ma","Gil Zaretzer","90"
"bc29cbf4-0856-4548-93e0-e6791217700e","global","2015-09-15T07:55:03","2015","kg","map","Yes","No","Yes","No","Yes","No","No",,"No",,,,,,"State Service of Geodesy and Cartography of Kyrgyz Republic","Yes","Yes","I reviewed this information and it seems correct.","State Service of Geodesy and Cartography of Kyrgyz Republic has a printed map of the country and cities. But for some cities the data is not publicly available at all.","Yes","No","Azamat Tokhtaev","Gil Zaretzer","25"
"1981489f-b37f-4982-be59-f2dc77c2fcf9","global","2015-09-29T18:41:49","2015","bf","water","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","No","Unsure","No","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,"Relévés sur la qualité de l'eau","Office National de l'Eau et de l'Assainissement","Yes","Yes","Since the website for the water utility is down and there is no mention on the Ministry website of water quality, I can't confirm submitter's affirmation that the data is available and timely so have moved assessment to unsure. ","The water and sanitation agency is the one who have water quality data at the national level. The quality of the water is measured daily, but not published by default. It can however be accessed from the agency when requested .
The ministry of agriculture and water also collect water quality data in some areas of the country for the need of some projects, and these data are also publicly available.","Yes","No","Idriss TINTO","Nisha Thompson","5"
"6635f526-fcce-43d3-bbc3-efbe35d2a7dc","global","2015-09-25T14:05:40","2015","rs","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Approving submission. Can't find water quality parameters we are specifying. ","There is publicly available dataset in digital form. It is published online by Agancija za zaštitu životne sredine for free and on a timely and up to data basis. The dataset is available at https://80.93.233.118:8080/apex/f?p=406:4. However, levels of chemicals different that chemicals necessary to satisfy minimal requirements are measured. ","Yes","No","Stevan Gostojić","Nisha Thompson","0"
"0d06ac0a-fddf-4df6-ae32-76ff38f378ca","global","2015-09-18T14:58:42","2015","ro","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.ms.ro/?pag=295",,,,"Drinking water quality","Ministry of Health","Yes","Yes","The submitter originally included links that didn't have water quality information with it just status of water bodies. I found that the Ministry of health does collect the data of all the parameters. ","The National Authority „Romanian Waters” collects the data and publishes occasionally synthesis:
https://www.rowater.ro/Lists/Sinteza%20de%20calitate%20a%20apelor/AllItems.aspx
But the raw data is not available.","Yes","No","Ovidiu Voicu","Nisha Thompson","35"
"f137c487-0aae-44e3-a821-0e5915b0cbdf","global","2015-09-09T09:00:39","2015","kr","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"No","https://www.waternow.go.kr/openPage.do?OPENCODE=PG_WDATA01",," https://www.koreawqi.go.kr/ ",,"Tapwater Quality","National Waterworks Information Network","Yes","Yes","Some confusion with the submitting regarding what we were looking for. However, after clarifying found the data. Korea has really good data.","There is no data which meets the minimum criteria in Korea, Republic of. Data about the required chemicals is only available for filtration plants, and this dataset is updated monthly. The data for filtration plants is available on the site called [National Waterworks Information System (NWIS)][1] managed by the Ministry of Environment. Data about TDS (Total Dissolved Solids) is not available for filtration plants or water sources. Only data about TS (Total Solids) is available for filtration plants. Data for filtration plants is accessible via [Web APIs][2] after the registration.
Available data about water sources in Korea is on the level of the following:
- water temperature
- pH
- DO (Dissolved Oxygen)
- EC (Electric Conductivity)
- TOC (Total Organic Carbon)
- TN (Total Nitrogen)
- TP (Total Phosphorus)
The data is collected by the [National Auto Water Quality Monitoring Network][3], and it is available at https://www.koreawqi.go.kr/ under the KOGL Type 1, which is an open license. This dataset is also accessible via [Web APIs][4] after the registration.
[1]: https://www.waternow.go.kr/
[2]: https://www.data.go.kr/subMain.jsp#/L3B1YnIvdXNlL3ByaS9Jcm9zT3BlbkFwaURldGFpbC9vcGVuQXBpTGlzdFBhZ2UkQF4wMTJtMSRAXnB1YmxpY0RhdGFQaz0zMDcyNTc4JEBeYnJtQ2Q9T0MwMDEyJEBecmVxdWVzdENvdW50PTIzJEBeb3JnSW5kZXg9T1BFTkFQSQ==
[3]: https://www.keco.or.kr/en/core/water_waste2/contentsid/1967/index.do
[4]: https://www.data.go.kr/subMain.jsp#/L3B1YnIvdXNlL3ByaS9Jcm9zT3BlbkFwaURldGFpbC9vcGVuQXBpTGlzdFBhZ2UkQF4wMTJtMSRAXnB1YmxpY0RhdGFQaz0zMDM4NDE3JEBeYnJtQ2Q9T0MwMDEyJEBecmVxdWVzdENvdW50PTI3JEBeb3JnSW5kZXg9T1BFTkFQSQ==","Yes","No","James G. Boram Kim","Nisha Thompson","75"
"ba98dd38-aca0-460f-b3fc-91a50db040f7","global","2015-09-19T11:44:43","2015","ch","water","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.bafu.admin.ch/wasser/13465/13483/14976/index.html?lang=de",,,,"Nationalen Daueruntersuchung der Fliessgewässer (NADUF)","Federal Office for the Environment","Yes","Yes","The original link provided by the submitter wasn't water quality. I found groundwater quality but the data seemed to be in some monitoring system that wasn't publicly available. There are reports and maps though. ","For more information about the underlying datasets contact the [Surface Water Hydrology Section](https://www.bafu.admin.ch/org/organisation/00196/00223/index.html?lang=en) of FOEN.","Yes","No","Oleg Lavrovsky","Nisha Thompson","30"
"637e8eb8-0848-42eb-89da-1ce6ccb37046","global","2015-05-18T18:14:49","2015","ko","map","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","No","Yes","Unsure",,"Yes","https://geoportal.rks-gov.net/","shapefiles",,,,"Kosovo Cadastral Agency","Yes","Yes","Kosovo has a very good online viewer with different data layers, it is free and open to use and with limited save as image files capabilities, however one needs to register to download the data in a machine readable format, so I changed ""public"" to no accordingly, I also changed ""bulk"" to unsure because I cannot know if a bulk download of the data is available after registration. ",,"Yes","No","Adis Ademi","Gil Zaretzer","40"
"376adbea-29f6-42d2-bb42-6dc48f19e8e2","global","2015-09-19T00:48:27","2015","mx","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.inegi.org.mx/geo/contenidos/mapadigital/","WMS, PDF, SHP","https://sc.inegi.org.mx/repositorioNormateca/Nod_23Sep14.pdf",,"Mapa Digital de México","Instituto Nacional de Estadística e Geografía","Yes","Yes","Since the preview says that data is not available in bulk, I changed it accordingly, other than that everything seems correct.","The list of available web services can be found here: https://www.inegi.org.mx/inegi/contenidos/serviciosweb/infogeografica.aspx Topographical maps can be found here: https://www3.inegi.org.mx/sistemas/biblioteca/detalle2.aspx?c=2031&upc=0&s=geo&tg=999&f=2&cl=0&pf=prod&ef=0&ct=206000000
Data is provided by INEGI in a large variety of formats, including SHP, WMS, GIF, TIF and GEOPDF. It cannot be downloaded in bulk but only for administrative regions. The downloadable is also not timely. But the webservice is. Also the complete webservice application can be downloaded and installed on a PC.
INEGI changed its internal normativity to make all information free. They only charge a cost of distributrion is incurred (eg. printing): https://sc.inegi.org.mx/repositorioNormateca/Nod_23Sep14.pdf
Right now the terms of use clearly state that the only requirement is the source attribution.
Furthermore, following the change in normativity already provided, starting november 11th, INEGI will adopt the Mexican Open license that can be found at 'https://datos.gob.mx/libreusomx/'.","Yes","Yes","Enrique Zapata","Gil Zaretzer","90"
"99961abc-f30f-4929-9f8f-9e823661515f","global","2015-10-11T14:16:54","2015","tr","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.hgk.msb.gov.tr/",,,,"General Command of Mapping ","General Command of Mapping webmaster@hgk.msb.gov.tr","Yes","Yes","The website seems to have some kind of mapping application that does not work at the time of this review, so giving them the benefit of the doubt I'm marking unsure for machine readable.","QA review - the footer notes it is © 2014 Harita Genel Komutanlığı eposta
","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Gil Zaretzer","55"
"1f9de60f-0159-4bd0-8b6a-596eb8e0f0b8","global","2015-08-29T16:45:04","2015","om","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://nsdig2gapps.ncsi.gov.om/geoplatform/",,,,"Digital maps and satellite images of Oman linked to a variety of data.","National Centre for Statistics and Information","Yes","Yes","Review: everything seems correct.","The National Centre for Statistics and Information provides a number of geospatial data that could be navigated through web-based and mobile apps.
The GeoPlatform App provides users with the ability to view graphic and satellite maps and overlay different informational geographic and social layers. There are also other apps that focus on specific layers such as government services.
Viewing the maps does not require any registration and is available for free. Downloading the data requires registration which involves a manual activation and cannot be completed entirely online. It could not be confirmed if machine-readable data could be downloaded or the extent to which data could be downloaded in bulk. ","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Gil Zaretzer","35"
"48d23754-4716-4d5c-be89-78097f6b27f8","global","2015-09-07T18:00:32","2015","qa","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://geoportal.gisqatar.org.qa/qmape/index.html",,,,"interactive map of Qatar.","Ministry of Municipality and Urban Development","Yes","Yes","Unfortunatly when I tried the portal it didn't load so I could not review the data, so I'm leaving this entry as is.","Qatar has an official geospatial data portal ( https://geoportal.gisqatar.org.qa/qmape/index.html ) that provides an interactive map with a variety of data layers. However, it is not possible to download the data from the website and the website is built using Flash and can only be accessed through direct human input. It is not clear from the website the date of the last update of the data of this map.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Gil Zaretzer","35"
"cb37d6c5-ec63-48c0-85db-dd20aaf7eec1","global","2015-10-10T14:56:09","2015","ma","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.mtpnet.gov.ma/routier/Infrastructures-Routieres/Reseau-Routier-du-Royaume/Pages/Cartes-routieres.aspx",,,,,"Ministère de Transport et de l'équipement ","Yes","Yes","In my review I reached similar conclusions: data is digitial, public, free, and online, however it is not machine readable, available in bulk, openly licensed, or updated timely.","Updating previous submission by Chadi, changing the ""machine readable"" question to No, as maps are in PDF format","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Gil Zaretzer","35"
"78243b05-35eb-4c70-8f5d-5118153a05cd","global","2015-09-09T13:33:03","2015","ae","map","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","My review and search found similar results, however, it is worth noting that the UAE has a Data Portal, with a lot of data, I couldn't find anything on maps, yet. Link to the data portal: https://bayanat.ae/","It is difficult to find out if such a map exists and what body is responsible for it due to the federal system of the UAE. Individual emirates, or states, could be responsible for maintaining and publishing their own maps. For example, the emirate of Abu Dhabi has a website for geospatial information ( https://sdi.abudhabi.ae/ ) , but naturally covers only its own territory and not the territory of other emirates.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Gil Zaretzer","0"
"474d39b9-f7d7-415b-a6af-a3fc29ff2d39","global","2015-10-09T14:49:09","2015","nl","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://www.pdok.nl/nl/producten/pdok-downloads/basis-registratie-topografie/topnl/topnl-actueel/top50nl","shape, GML","https://www.kadaster.nl/opendata",,"Basisregistratie Topografie","Kadaster","Yes","Yes","Review: everything seems correct","The full data set is openly licensed (CC-BY) and available via direct download on the PDOK website in scale 1:50,000 (700MB) and 1:10,000 (2GB).
There is further information available on the website of Kadaster (https://www.kadaster.nl) but they do request registration first. Data is available there in several scales starting from 1:5000 until 1:250,000.
The current data is outdated however, with part of the map data from 2013 (also in the prospective release in Nov). Therefore changed 'up-to-date' to 'no'. ","Yes","Yes","Sander van der Waal","Gil Zaretzer","90"
"217e4c24-88b7-4d02-ae0d-7ca626fead79","global","2015-10-02T18:57:54","2015","se","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.havochvatten.se/hav/samordning--fakta/data--statistik.html","CSV , HTML , PDF , TXT , XLS , XML ",,,,"Ministry of the Environment and Energy (Miljö- och energidepartementet)","Yes","Yes","Approving submission, groundwater data has all the parameters and is used for drinking. ","Havs- och vattenmyndigheten is an ""sub-""authority issued by Ministry of the Environment and Energy (Miljö- och energidepartementet).
","Yes","No","Asmen Gül","Nisha Thompson","60"
"8d28344f-3d74-44a3-a513-291d7f3a2599","global","2015-09-11T23:50:11","2015","sy","spending","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission clarified.","No data seems to exist.","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","0"
"9bb70d78-5deb-4854-b740-b192d4ff8cc3","global","2015-09-26T12:57:26","2015","sd","spending","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.","According to IBP's [Open Budget Survey](https://survey.internationalbudget.org) Sudan does not publish anything except the enacted budget and the year-end report. The audit is internal so it is not safe to say that the year-end report is valid or that the data exists.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","0"
"ade5dbe8-f5c5-4e00-8c83-bbd897ef02fc","global","2015-09-21T20:27:33","2015","gt","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.insivumeh.gob.gt/hidrologia/Calidad_del_%20Agua.htm",,,,"Instituto Nacional De Sismología, Vulcanologia, Meteorología E Hidrologia - Insivumeh","Instituto Nacional De Sismología, Vulcanologia, Meteorología E Hidrologia - Insivumeh","Yes","Yes","Approving submission, water quality data is in the report, with the parameters.",,"Yes","No","Julio Herrera","Nisha Thompson","35"
"31142ab3-690b-44d0-b5c9-980b6c77a1c6","global","2015-09-15T20:59:43","2015","bh","water","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Stats","Kingdom of Bahrain Electricity and Water Authority (https://www.mew.gov.bh/default.asp?action=category&id=65)","Yes","Yes","Since they are treating water there is data collection, they put up stats including if there has been water quality complaints. They are not putting the actual water quality data up. ","Bahrain has a Supreme Council for Environment, but no website for this organisation can be found and it is unknown if it collects or publishes any data on water quality.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Nisha Thompson","5"
"c03b80ba-bbd9-4d4d-a79f-bdff11cc5267","global","2015-09-28T18:45:13","2015","br","spending","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.transparencia.gov.br","CSV",,,"Despesas - Gastos Diretos","Secretaria do Tesouro Nacional - STN","Yes","Yes","Submission is correct.","Data till 2011 is published on the open data catalogue https://dados.gov.br
More recent data can be downloaded also from the Transparency Portal: https://www.transparencia.gov.br/downloads/ as bulk download per month (the size of each file is so big that this can be regarded as *bulk download*)
Neither the Transparency Portal nor the Open Data Catalogue specify the license of the data, Example: https://dados.gov.br/dataset/despesas-diretas-do-poder-executivo-federal-publicados-no-portal-da-transparencia/resource/a8eac0a2-7c69-42fe-95fb-4d1819beece1
Data on a certain type of spending (funds voluntarily transferred from federal to other levels of government or from federal government to non-profit organizations) is available on an open data RESTful API, updated daily: https://dados.gov.br/dataset/siconv . It is openly licensed. However, a bulk download is available only for an outdated version of the data.","Yes","No","Augusto Herrmann","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","70"
"324679e4-dc39-465d-95a2-5aed00ba24ff","global","2015-09-07T17:46:19","2015","kw","spending","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed","The ministry of finance publishes historical expense totals: https://www.mof.gov.kw/MOF_FI/default.aspx which indicates that the data exists. The last one is for fiscal year 2013/2014 so it seems that it isn't fully digital (no totals for last fiscal period).","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","5"
"d9cf3f20-a3de-4318-9a76-e930418ee5c0","global","2015-10-15T17:11:54","2015","ua","water","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"https://www.menr.gov.ua/index.php/monitoring","Ministry of Health","Yes","Yes","Several ministries are in charge of collecting the data but it isn't online.",,"Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Nisha Thompson","5"
"e90e5e72-85b2-45a2-b610-38219ab9844b","global","2015-09-28T13:38:28","2015","bf","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Dépenses publiques du Burkina Faso. This ","Direction Générale du Budget (www.dgb.gov.bf, down)","Yes","Yes","Submission fixed","The spending data are managed by a system named integrated system of the spending at the general direction of budget. The data are stored in a database and not published by default. To access the data, user must write to the ministry of finance, specifying which type of data he want, and also specify the format. If the requested data is not sensible, the direction that is responsible of the data extracts the needed dataset for the requester. Even if there is no license applied, the direction said that there is no restriction to the use of the dataset.
Hence the data exists and is in digital form but not publicly available as one has to go through a government official.","Yes","No","Idriss TINTO","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"8f810328-3f98-4515-ac2a-3dc7aeb0066f","global","2015-09-30T16:59:26","2015","tz","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed","The Ministry of Finance publishes very detailed and thorough reports about planned and actual spending four times a year at: https://www.mof.go.tz/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=24:budget-execution-reports&catid=67:budget-execution-reports&Itemid=38F
These reports include tables of aggregated spending data but not transactional data. However this indicates that the data exists and is in digital format.","Yes","No","Joachim Mangilima","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"7db7709d-7dbf-40c4-8641-25483bc6bdcf","global","2015-09-27T02:21:49","2015","cr","water","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Drinking water and health","Ministry of Health (https://www.ministeriodesalud.go.cr/index.php/tramites-ms/declarar-y-reportar-ms?id=791)","Yes","Yes","Found the decree that puts the Ministry of Health in charge of collecting water quality data, though no data is available online. ","No official resource offers this data to the public.","Yes","No","Alejandro Sanabria","Nisha Thompson","5"
"882269a0-9506-4627-9896-90c60e489937","global","2015-09-20T00:41:50","2015","bo","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,"Ministerio de Economía y Finanzas, a través de SIGMA","Yes","Yes","Submission fixed","Budget information is handled by [SIGMA system](https://www.sigma.gob.bo/php/estadisticas_presupuesto.php), which can be accessed partially by public servants depending on their field of work. Public only gets the pre-made reports.","Yes","No","Mariana Leyton","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"62bd237f-0df6-4c07-a9a6-2f859dc1d381","global","2015-09-28T19:00:44","2015","br","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"No","https://portalpnqa.ana.gov.br/avaliacao.aspx",,,,"Panorama da Qualidade das Águas Superficiais no Brasil","Agência Nacional de Águas","Yes","Yes","Approving submission, while there is national level data, it does look like most of the data might be at the local municipal level. ","Data is outdated as this is a report from the year 2004.
Other potential but unusable sources:
https://dados.saude.gov.br/dataset/situacao_de_saude/resource/6dda9432-5c16-4aa1-8e30-4114041378b1 (link is broken)
https://bvsms.saude.gov.br/bvs/publicacoes/vigilancia_controle_qualidade_agua.pdf (has only methodological information, but no measurements)
https://www.geoprocessamento.icict.fiocruz.br/svs/agua/atlas.htm (has no pollutant data)","Yes","No","Augusto Herrmann","Nisha Thompson","45"
"dc4aa2b9-57e2-4f3e-a9ef-e4f93ef620c9","global","2015-10-13T21:07:00","2015","tg","spending","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,"Site Republic Of Togo","Yes","Yes","Submission fixed, it showed the budget not the actual spending.","https://www.tresor-togo.org/index.php?m=r0b0t0d&c=r1b1t1d says the treasury collects this information but nothing is published. So the data should exist but there is no indication of it being digital.","Yes","No","anonymous","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","5"
"3f5fb9aa-93bd-4521-85a7-af77fdbb91eb","global","2015-10-03T07:56:18","2015","gn","spending","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed","The finance ministry has in the past published budget execution reports but the last one is from 2012. This indicates that the data exists but that it might not be digital (since it takes so long to publish).","Yes","No","anonymous","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","5"
"e6802744-8fac-4dbb-9d7f-2d667cee4666","global","2015-08-28T19:11:21","2015","tz","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Approving this submission, couldn't find any water quality data. ","After doing several background checks , i have not managed to see any official government data which includes all these items. ","Yes","No","Joachim Mangilima","Nisha Thompson","0"
"620989a0-904d-42e0-9bd5-549a13de8304","global","2015-10-01T22:07:34","2015","ci","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Budget Execution","Ministry of economy and finance","Yes","Yes","Submission is correct.","Some aggregated spending data is available in PDF from the Ministere Aupres du Premier Ministre Charge du Budget.
Detailed and up to date spending data exists and is in a digital format, even for free, but the requester have to write to the minister to ask for access.","Yes","No","anonymous","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"0d1d278e-a276-41b9-95d8-93ae4802701e","global","2015-09-28T10:54:47","2015","ge","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is correct.","The Ministry of Finance makes monthly revenue and spending reports available als XLS files, but these do not list individual items or transactions but list only aggregate expenditures for personell or purchased goods and services (https://mof.ge/en/4646). It's not clear if more detailed information is centrally collected and aggregated on a monthly basis.
On a side note: All government agencies use a centralized e-procurement system to purchase goods and services. Data on non-classified government contracts and bills/receipts is available at https://tenders.procurement.gov.ge. The data includes transactions from state bank accounts to suppliers for the implementation of contracts, but no bulk data is available. ","Yes","No","Eric Barrett","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"83a10430-bf2a-41d1-b353-23f44802beb2","global","2015-10-07T01:48:55","2015","cn","spending","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.","According to the IBP's [Open Budget Survey](https://survey.internationalbudget.org) China publishes the year end and audit reports which indicates the data exists. The [Open Budget Library](https://openbudgetlibrary.org) has a 2012 audit report so the data does not seem to be fully digital.","Yes","No","OKFN CN","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","5"
"76c4f273-7e53-4320-818d-272902c9e571","global","2015-09-23T06:32:21","2015","hk","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is correct","Theoretically this transaction-level spending data should exist since that is how the summarised annual revenue and expenditure reports, found at: https://www.censtatd.gov.hk/hkstat/sub/sp110.jsp can be created.","Yes","No","Rob Davidson","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"f369f6da-dc34-4c5d-80aa-7947d1d709be","global","2015-09-28T16:02:14","2015","py","water","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Approving submission, there isn't any information on water quality available publicly.","In Paraguay DIGESA [1] (General Direction of Environmental Sanitation, dependent of the Ministry of Public Health and Welfare) and
SENASA [2] (Servicio Nacional de Saneamiento Ambiental or National Environmental Sanitation Service) are the responsible for measuring water quality for all types of water, superficial and underground. Most drinking water (80%) in Paraguay comes from groundwater.
No public information is available on water quality measurements are publicly available, an after consultation public officials stated that the measurements are performed periodically, yearly or upon request.
The above mentioned information does not comply with the management and weakly publication of water quality measurements.
References:
- [1] https://www.mspbs.gov.py/digesa/
- [2] https://www.senasa.gov.py/ ","Yes","No","Juan Pane","Nisha Thompson","0"
"c708de6a-029a-4a55-854f-d6f4addedd36","global","2015-09-29T03:36:32","2015","tg","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Approving submission, can't find anything about water supply system or quality. ",,"Yes","No","Richard Komlan Folly","Nisha Thompson","0"
"5f1555d2-c6b2-4688-84bf-fbe4bc170c86","global","2015-09-22T19:07:27","2015","us","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,"USAspending.gov ","Yes","Yes","Submission fixed","The Bureau of the Fiscal Service relaunched [USAspending.gov](https://usaspending.gov) in March 2015 with data from October 1, 2008 to present. Agencies are required to submit data files within 30 days after making an award or after making a modification/transaction to an award, except for the DoD which delays its submission by 90 days. Download data in various formats at https://www.usaspending.gov/DownloadCenter/Pages/DataDownload.aspx
These still only represent contracts, grants, loans and other fiancial assistance.","Yes","No","anonymous","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"895b327f-7ad1-452a-acbe-5c72b66a93e4","global","2015-08-30T15:05:38","2015","np","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,"Ministry of Finance, Financial Comptroller General Office","Yes","Yes","Submission fixed (very unfortunate situation)","It is really unfortunate that the government of Nepal will not score higher as they provide a daily update of the budget execution status, albeit in aggregated form: https://www.fcgo.gov.np/report-publications/daily-budgetray-status/
The data is clearly there and in digital form.","Yes","No","Nikesh Balami","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"f9985795-7c33-45c1-a734-18d60a7111fd","global","2015-10-01T12:03:19","2015","ky","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed","No data was found but there is a cash management unit operated by the tresasury https://www.treasury.gov.ky/portal/page/portal/tsyhome/what-we-do/cash-management-unit and its collection is sent to the statistical office: https://www.eso.ky/fiscaloperations.html so the data exists and very likely in digital form because of the statistics data.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"6b7bfb23-70f7-4472-8ec2-6cced237f44a","global","2015-09-30T22:40:45","2015","tc","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Approving submission, couldn't find any water quality or mention of water treatment or monitoring.","it is uncertain if the data exists.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Nisha Thompson","0"
"c5cff156-326e-427b-b6c7-8783cf870590","global","2015-10-07T02:19:32","2015","cn","water","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Approving submission, couldn't find data or reference to national body that monitors water quality like the comment said.","The water quality data is currently not published at the national level. Besides, the current regulation only requires the Environment agency monitor and collect data on a monthly (at least) basis. So it does not meet the minimum criteria of the index","Yes","No","OKFN CN","Nisha Thompson","0"
"1ee881f9-79a3-4a82-919f-ab9fb05e2311","global","2015-09-28T11:49:12","2015","gg","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,"Treasury and Resources Department, treasury@gov.gg","Yes","Yes","Submission is correct"," The public accounts for the Island are published at https://www.gov.gg/CHttpHandler.ashx?id=96602&p=0 (accounts to 31 December 2014, published 30 June 2015). These are not transactional data but indicate that transactional data exists in digital form.","Yes","No","Marcus Ferbrache","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"8371c7e5-ebc0-4586-ab90-d6dfb6d8b24f","global","2015-10-01T09:14:20","2015","bj","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Exécution des dépenses","Direction Générale du Budget","Yes","Yes","Submisison fixed","The government spending is managed by the general direction of the budget. All the spending is stored in a database with restricted access. The stored data is about all kind of spending including salary payment. So there is some sensible data that cannot be published. Anyone can do a request for government spending, specifying clearly the type of spending that he need. The general direction of the budget analyses the request and decides if it will give the data or not.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"fae21460-b2bf-4224-8b40-2ceaa6e0e2f8","global","2015-10-04T14:49:10","2015","et","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","No",,"Yes","https://www.ethiomet.gov.et/stations/information",,,,"Meteorological Station Information","National Meterology Agency","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 5+ days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation, even though it is limited to textual descriptions. Historical data is also available. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Neal Bastek","45"
"2107b43c-14de-460c-b95a-43bfa78ec110","global","2015-09-27T19:42:22","2015","ec","spending","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.finanzas.gob.ec/ejecucion-presupuestaria/",,,,"Ejecucion presupuestaria","Ministerio de Finanzas","Yes","Yes","Submission largely correct. Minor fixed","Consolidated spending data from 2008 to 2015 can be queried through an online database.
Data is on transactional level and it is very detailed and in a monthly report - https://www.finanzas.gob.ec/transparencia/
","Yes","No","Julio Lopez","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","45"
"9ce4c1ab-18d9-49bd-8d0b-ccff8ca124b5","global","2015-09-30T18:59:11","2015","tc","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://myforecast.com/bin/expanded_forecast_15day.m?city=78507&metric=false",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I changed this submission to 'data does not exist' because the source provided was a private third party.","This is a 15-day forecast of Prvidenciales weather in Turks and Caicos.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Neal Bastek","0"
"764b7855-56a9-44ad-97fe-b886b4d51044","global","2015-09-29T00:09:03","2015","pa","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I changed this one from 'unsure' to 'data does not exist'.",,"Yes","No","HAMZAH HAJI","Neal Bastek","0"
"739b894e-ca8f-42ce-8af1-2763b6025b9c","global","2015-09-27T17:21:03","2015","ms","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I changed this submission to 'data does not exist' because the provided data was from a private source.","The weather forecast is found at this URL: https://www.timeanddate.com/weather/montserrat/brades","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Neal Bastek","0"
"b5d6074c-64eb-4dcf-a145-bfc0526f463b","global","2015-10-01T13:08:31","2015","ky","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.waterauthority.ky/upimages/pagebox/WaterAuthorityAnnualAnalysisData2014_1430925647.pdf",,,,"Laboratory Testing","Water Authority Cayman Islands","Yes","Yes","Found data up to 2014. Contains all the parameters.","It is uncertain if the data exists.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Nisha Thompson","35"
"13977549-c520-436d-8696-de0ff2fa95b3","global","2015-09-18T17:33:42","2015","kw","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.met.gov.kw/Forecasts/kuwait.php?lang=arb",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I changed this entry to 'data does exist' because there is at least 3 days of data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.","Kuwait Meteorological department has a 5 days forecast of temperature and wind, but it does not has a data about precipitation. The only data about precipitation is a daily data about Kuwait international airport.
No historical temperature data for the past year.
The data on a web page (https://www.met.gov.kw/Forecasts/kuwait.php?lang=arb)","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Neal Bastek","20"
"b259f8a8-425b-43d0-abc0-0fd49d69e8bc","global","2015-09-02T16:44:10","2015","gg","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.water.gg/your-water/water-quality",,,,"water quality results in detail for Guernsey","Guernsey Water customer.service@water.gg","Yes","Yes","Approving submission, data is the reports with all parameters","Can only see data up to 2013","Yes","No","Jason Magee","Nisha Thompson","35"
"9b43f7c8-63ec-4cce-bdca-7413ddfca6c4","global","2015-09-30T14:00:09","2015","ec","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.agua.gob.ec/biblioteca/",,,,,"Secretaría Nacional del Agua","Yes","Yes","Accepting this submission. The reports have water quality with the parameters.","Secretaría Nacional del Agua makes research studies about water quality like this one: https://www.agua.gob.ec/wp-content/uploads/downloads/2012/07/InformeCocaFinal1.pdf. A few of them, outdated in pdf format, are available at their website, https://www.agua.gob.ec/biblioteca/ (""Informes"").","Yes","No","Eduardo Bejar","Nisha Thompson","35"
"59d59bd2-2a1f-49df-94e0-a1ec486e548e","global","2015-08-27T13:25:59","2015","cl","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Budgetary information at national level, in pesos and dollars, broken down by institution and budget programs, based on budget implementation figures and glosses of the Finance Act 2015.","Office of Budget","Yes","Yes","Submission fixed","There is a detailed open dataset available at https://datos.gob.cl/datasets/ver/31930 with expenditures, broken down by government institution and budget programs but it is not transactional data.","Yes","No","Ahumada Abrigouis Alberto L","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"8d23c515-752d-4629-8b89-9813277f1aa0","global","2015-09-28T15:08:17","2015","fr","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,"DGFIP Bercy - Ministère des finances","Yes","Yes","Submission is correct.","Spending data at transnational level are collected and stored on the financial information system named CHORUS. Data is however not accessible online or offline to the public. ","Yes","No","Regards Citoyens","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"14a39b98-be98-41f8-ace1-dd54f5bf26b8","global","2015-09-06T17:09:17","2015","sa","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.pme.gov.sa/w5df.asp",,,,"Weather / 5 Days Forecast","Presidency of Meteorology and Environment","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 5 days of forecast data for temperature and precipitation.","As for the 5 days weather forecast, it is provided by the Saudi Presidency of Meteorology and Environment here (https://www.pme.gov.sa/w5df.asp), there is also radar readings from different stations (https://www.pme.gov.sa/Doppler.asp). The map here (https://jrcc.sa/as/) shows those stations. The forecast data includes temperature, wind speed, humidity and symbols for thunderstorms, rain and sunny, etc.
Historic data is a bit problematic here, the Saudi Open Data Portal (https://data.gov.sa/) provides datasets for temperature (https://data.gov.sa/dataset/temperature), wind (https://data.gov.sa/dataset/wind), humidity (https://data.gov.sa/dataset/relative-humidity), thunderstorms (https://data.gov.sa/dataset/thunderstorms), fog (https://data.gov.sa/dataset/fog-phenomena), etc. However, when accessed the most recent XLS files, they are of 2013.
Note, although the data on the Open Data portal is in bulk and openly licensed, that on the Presidency of Meteorology and Environment is copyrighted, and since we gave more weight to the latter as the former is not up to date. We answered the questions about licensing and machine readability according to how the information is presented in the Presidency of Meteorology and Environment","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Neal Bastek","45"
"c6fde049-8492-425f-8be7-5ba26960f8db","global","2015-09-27T23:23:23","2015","gy","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.hydromet.gov.gy/weather.html",,,,"Hydrometeorological Service (Hydromet)","Ministry of Agriculture, Guyana","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 3 days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.","Guyana has a 3-day weather forecast and not 5","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Neal Bastek","45"
"f418ba52-c097-4028-934b-21b5251facd3","global","2015-10-01T12:22:07","2015","bj","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes",,"xls",,,"Suivi de la qualité de l’eau","Société Nationale des Eau du Benin","Yes","Yes","Approving this submission","The quality of the water is analysed daily by the national water company. There is 4 laboratories in the country, each with his operating area. The data are available for free after a request at the company.
source:
1. https://www.soneb.com/soneb2/04-info-eau/qualite-eau.php","Yes","No","anonymous","Nisha Thompson","55"
"a591f3b3-629a-469d-9ac4-725b0080fa6f","global","2015-09-28T01:26:50","2015","ar","map","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","No","Yes","Unsure",,"Unsure",,"GIS",,,"National Geographic Institute of Argentina under the Ministry of Science and Technology (Ministry of Defence). The available information comes from data set 250 emerged GIS project, conducted by the Institute until 2000. The Institute constantly working on updating its geographic database and its adaptation to the different rules and standards. Email contact: contacto@ign.gob.ar.","IGN - National Geographic Institute of Argentina","Yes","Yes","After my review I changed a few things:
1. This is not a free service offered (it was set to not sure).
2. Since there isn't alot of clear information on the website I changed a few things to ""unsure"" status: public availability, downloadable in bulk, and updated timely.","There is a GIS map in 1 : 250,000, and even 1 : 50,000 from 2013 on the"" INSTITUTO GEOGRÁFICO NACIONAL DE LA REPÚBLICA ARGENTINA"" website. No license was found on the website, and therefore it is not openly licensed.
Information is not readily accessible and much information you have to pay","Yes","No","Yamila García","Gil Zaretzer","25"
"850b6f7c-4dba-4e20-94c0-20164b71194b","global","2015-09-15T16:55:25","2015","my","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I changed this submission to data does not exist because no national forecast data beyond a very brief description of condition could be found at the links provided.","In Malaysia, the Meteorological Department is responsible for providing public information that relates to weather forecast. However, there are some loopholes found by follow the 4 criterias for this category:
1. There are 3 types of weather forecast; general, states and districts. So, the 5-days forecast of temperature updated daily for districts only.
2. Generally, there are summaries provided on strong winds and rough seas (https://www.met.gov.my/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=4963). There are no 5-days forecast of wind updated daily.
3. Normally, there will be 5-days forecast of percipitation updated daily but this is only for states (https://www.met.gov.my/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=1304&Itemid=1749) and districts (https://www.met.gov.my/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=3406&Itemid=1930).
4. Unfortunately, there are limited historical temperature data provided. What was found from MetMalaysia website is data from 2014 until 2015. Normally, data was visualized in 4 types of figures; Rainfall Map for Malaysia, Mean Monthly Temperature, Mean Monthly Maximum Temperature & Mean Monthly Minimum Temperature. (https://www.met.gov.my/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=847&Itemid=1586)
In order for Malaysians or non-Malaysians to have access for complete data by follow these 4 criterias, the entrance fees may not required because there is Freedom of Information (FOI) Act takes place in the Selangor state territory. Therefore, it is possible for people to submit FOI request to the person in change in order to have access for the data.
Note: Freedom of Information FAQ for Selangor https://www.selangortimes.com/index.php?section=insight&permalink=20111215135936-freedom-of-information-faq","Yes","No","Hazwany Jamaluddin","Neal Bastek","0"
"c0b987a1-2e6e-40c1-a679-e9c23d8357af","global","2015-09-16T10:19:25","2015","kg","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://meteo.kg/","HTML",,,"Provides information on weather forecasts","State Ageny of Hydrometeorology, +996 312 316228 ","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as 3 days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation exists.","State Ageny of Hydrometeorology provides information on weather forecasts. A detailed version of forecasts are not free. Items listed in this lists https://meteo.kg/index.php?page=3 are provided only by paying for them. Additionally they provide information on air quality https://meteo.kg/environment_air.php, water quality https://meteo.kg/environment_water.php, radiation https://meteo.kg/index.php?page=8","Yes","No","Azamat Tokhtaev","Neal Bastek","60"
"5ae951ab-f766-4ff2-b1ae-9382ee8ae58f","global","2015-10-13T10:26:18","2015","cm","water","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Data on Water Quality","Camerounaise Des Eaux (CDE) - A public utility for water in Cameroon","Yes","Yes","Approving submission","La Camerounaise Des Eaux is a public utility in charge of water production and distribution to citizens in Cameroon. Data resulting from the analysis of water quality it undertakes, is not available to the public. It describes in its website the battery of analysis done periodically to assess if water quality matches regulations and norms, but no information on their findings is published;
https://www.la-cde.com/fr/espace-pro/qualite-de-leau.html
There are many official (Centre Pasteur du Cameroun) and private laboratories that undertake regularly analysis of water quality for various goals... but regularity is not given and results are not systematically published.
https://www.geofor.biz/index.php/fr/nos-services/forage-d-eau
","Yes","No","anonymous","Nisha Thompson","10"
"1073b081-ad96-43f8-9d5d-5b68a424a60c","global","2015-09-07T18:23:14","2015","qa","weather","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","No","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.qweather.gov.qa/Index.aspx",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 3 days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation. I altered the original submission only by changing the 'is the data available online' answer from no to yes and providing the url that I found by investigating the claims in the comment.","The Civil Aviation Authority has a dedicated website for the weather in Qatar. The website is up to date, but it only publishes to the public 3 days of data, therefore the question on availability to the public has been answered as ""No"" in accordance with the dataset requirements for this category.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Neal Bastek","25"
"cff66290-ebbe-49f5-9c09-baf5af1cd0f5","global","2015-08-27T14:24:52","2015","cl","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Changed to unsure. Found some information under the Ministry of Public Health, however, no data.
https://www.ispch.cl/prestacion/8322003
","There is a government platform of Water Quality which shows every sanitary control, but it does not include information about fecal coliform,
arsenic, fluoride levels, nitrates nor TDS (Total dissolved solids)","Yes","No","Ahumada Abrigouis Alberto L","Nisha Thompson","0"
"0d0ce985-0ea8-47a2-8ad4-5d3f662b85fa","global","2015-09-08T10:00:52","2015","kr","map","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Yes","No",,"Yes",,"Shapefile",,,,,"Yes","Yes","I have reviewed this entry and found it is correct. It is worth noting that there is also an online map viewer, open without registration, with limited PDF saving options, here: https://m1.juso.go.kr/eng/standardmap/MapIndex.do","Introducing the new address system called ""[Road Name Address][1]"", The [Ministry of Government Administration and Home Affairs (MOGAHA)][2] of Korea, Republic of have developed a new electronic map with the help of the [Korea Local Information Research & Development Institute (KLID)][3]. This map can be downloaded on the Website of the National Spatial Information Clearinghouse (NSIC) after the registration. The data is not open, but anyone can request and download it. Also, people can download daily updates of the address system and its corresponding map data on the [Korean Website][4] of ""Road Name Address"" after the separate registration.
[1]: https://www.juso.go.kr/openEngPage.do
[2]: https://www.mogaha.go.kr/eng/a01/engMain.do
[3]: https://www.mogaha.go.kr/eng/a01/engMain.do
[4]: https://www.juso.go.kr/","Yes","No","James G. Boram Kim","Gil Zaretzer","35"
"a12718ae-77f2-45a8-a979-ff63974aa0cb","global","2015-09-28T00:03:36","2015","bw","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.mewt.gov.bw/DMS/",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The original submission indicated that the data existed here https://www.mewt.gov.bw/DMS/ but there is only a single day forecast for temperature and rainfall. Extended forecast pages are out of date and/or not working. I changed the submission to data does not exist.","Bulk and Archive data most likely available on request","Yes","No","anonymous","Neal Bastek","0"
"d6d54c28-6195-4e7a-a94d-8a2c55245248","global","2015-09-15T16:01:12","2015","il","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.govmap.gov.il/","HTML",,,"The Governmental Map Website | אתר המפות הממשלתי","Survey of Israel (Israel Mappipng Center)","Yes","Yes","I have reviewed this entry and everything seems correct.","The Data is available but need a consent from the office for being use in other projects. It is replacing an old and disfunctional national map site. It is not clear when and how often it is being updated.
There are some layers which are clearly up-to-date (e.g. bus stations, lanes, routes), while others are clearly not - and there is no metadata to differentiate or even indicate which layer is up to date or not.
Moreover, the only export option available of the data is to export PNG (=image) files, and no textual/geospatial data is available for download.","Yes","No","ido ivri","Gil Zaretzer","35"
"64415df7-c14f-41b8-8c6b-c97ee9d496fc","global","2015-09-12T10:42:19","2015","tn","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Changed to unsure can't find any data on website but there is a water quality section under construction.","The National Water Distribution Utility website (https://www.sonede.com.tn/) has few information about water ressources and their projects. However, the minimum requirements are not satisfied (no information about the level of chemicals by water source)","Yes","No","Yosr Jouini","Nisha Thompson","0"
"88d1c146-0483-4763-9672-a162aec3af21","global","2015-10-03T13:41:16","2015","tj","water","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Approving submission. Can't find water quality readings at any level.","The quality of water is managed by different state agencies like the Standardization Agency, Sanitary Epidemic Station, and the Laboratory of the Department on Water quality under the local governments or municipalities.","Yes","No","Asomiddin Atoev","Nisha Thompson","0"
"5aacd7f8-405e-44f0-b909-b551cc27bb6b","global","2015-09-15T20:53:44","2015","sa","spending","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission clarified","It is unclear if the Saudi government collects the information required at a transactional level. According to IBP's [Open Budget Survey](https://survey.internationalbudget.org) Saudi Arabia only has internal documents or no documents so very likely the data does not exist or is not collected properly.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","0"
"e393f0e6-8dc2-4f17-816f-53fe689ff268","global","2015-09-27T22:23:34","2015","gy","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is correct","The People’s Progressive Party/Civic (PPP/C) says the David Granger administration appears to have created a parallel treasury as it expressed concern over the exorbitant spending that has been taking place without the apparent lawful and financial processes being followed.
The Party, on Saturday, called on Finance Minister Winston Jordan to release a full account of all the monetary and non-monetary contributions received by the Government during the past two weeks.
It stated that the recent spending by the Government since it took office lacks accountability and transparency as the PPP/C demanded clarification on several pressing issues.
The rest of the article can be found at: https://www.guyanatimesgy.com/2015/05/31/grangers-govt-has-created-parallel-treasury-pppc/
The data still seems to be collected given a mid year report published beginning of October which shows actual spending of 2014: https://www.finance.gov.gy/images/Docs/Mid%20Year%20Reports/Mid%20Year%202015.pdf","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"1a858d07-bf7d-4f1d-ac4e-daa33b31b893","global","2015-10-02T05:22:43","2015","it","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Unsure","https://www.igmi.org/download.php","shp, geotiff",,,"Military Geografy Institute","IGM - Istituto Geografico Militare","Yes","Yes","The Italian Military Geografy Institute offers a few free downloadable shape files in different versions which seem to fall in line with our criteria for free, public, online, machine readable and bulk, however licensing and updates seem unclear.","the Italian Military Geografy Institute has the [official mandate to manage spatial data][1]
There are other resources (eg. National Cartographic Portal), but the refresh of data is obsolete.
At present the Military Geografy Institute has an open data policy.
[1]: https://www.isprambiente.gov.it/files/sgn-legge-68.pdf","Yes","No","Maurizio Napolitano","Gil Zaretzer","60"
"9e6f3b49-6cd9-4745-822c-a253b8c1c9b1","global","2015-09-30T10:57:12","2015","tt","map","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The website of the government of Trinidad and Tobago does not seem to offer an official national map in any format. It is possible to order some maps from different Ministries, but it is not clear if this would meet our criteria. Thus I decided to mark the existance of data as unsure.","The website of the government of Trinidad and Tobago does not seem to offer an official national map in any format. It is possible to order some maps from different Ministries, but it is not clear if this would meet our criteria. Thus I decided to mark the existance of data as unsure.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Gil Zaretzer","0"
"1ea57556-39b4-4d4d-8558-185b37849841","global","2015-09-19T11:57:30","2015","ch","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Yes","No",,"Yes",,"XML",,,"Swiss cadastral system","Federal Directorate of Cadastral Surveying","Yes","Yes","ok","For more information see [Land register](https://www.cadastre.ch/internet/kataster/en/home/gb.html) of the Swiss cadastral system, as well as documentation of access to [electronic landownership data](https://www.egris.admin.ch/dam/data/egris/dokumente/definition/implementation-d.pdf) (eGRIS) and [Public-law Restrictions on landownership](https://www.cadastre.ch/internet/kataster/en/home/services/manual.html) (ÖREB-Kataster).","Yes","No","Oleg Lavrovsky","Codrina Maria Ilie","35"
"93f2ac64-cb58-4a08-9924-dced58109926","global","2015-09-21T11:26:33","2015","de","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Unsure","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Internet-Grundbucheinsicht","Justizportal des Bundes und der Länder","Yes","Yes","ok",,"Yes","No","walter palmetshofer","Codrina Maria Ilie","20"
"2b79b6c2-2ef3-4863-b7e2-92ccbc41001d","global","2015-08-31T17:20:14","2015","iq","spending","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.","According to IBP's [Open Budget Survey](https://survey.internationalbudget.org) Iraq only has internal documents or no documents so very likely the data does not exist or is not collected properly.","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","0"
"c23f35e3-d55d-4cd1-9470-a551628704ed","global","2015-09-18T14:23:58","2015","ro","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://geoportal.gov.ro/viewers/en_EN/index.html",,,,,"Romanian INSPIRE Geoportal","Yes","Yes","Romanian INSPIRE Geoportal offers an online viewer, the viewer is free to use and public without restrictions, however it only allows to saves pdfs and print, not actually download the data. The website does say you can register and get access to further data, but it does not specifify what kind of data, formats or fees, so I left the last few questions as ""unsure"". The website's disclaimer sayes the data is public for use and distribution but does not say anything about commercial use so I had left this as ""unsure"" as well.","Romanian INSPIRE Geoportal offers an online viewer, the viewer is free to use and public without restrictions, however it only allows to saves pdfs and print, not actually download the data. The website does say you can register and get access to further data, but it does not specifify what kind of data, formats or fees, so I left the last few questions as ""unsure"". The website's disclaimer sayes the data is public for use and distribution but does not say anything about commercial use so I had left this as ""unsure"" as well.","Yes","No","Ovidiu Voicu","Gil Zaretzer","35"
"fc77d6ac-ea6a-4103-a9bd-b286a0165168","global","2015-09-15T03:14:20","2015","tn","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed","Since this year's criterion requires Individual record of transactions, date of the transactions, government office which had the transaction and name of vendor, we do not think the data provided by the government meets such criterion.
See last year's comment below.
Some data annual expenditure data can also be accessed here: https://www.finances.gov.tn/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=127&Itemid=303&lang=fr
As yearly (high level) data is available, we can safely assume that the government has monthly data as well but this is not available online.
Via the Open Data Tunisia portal, the most recent budget/spending data is from 2012 (PDF) https://www.data.gov.tn/fr/index.php?option=com_mtree&task=viewlink&link_id=40&Itemid=187
This does however indicate that the data exists and the [Open Budget Library](https://openbudgetlibrary.org) has year end reports for 2014 which indicate digital form.","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"352953a6-9be3-4116-91a1-71de1d6f24a6","global","2015-09-09T16:10:57","2015","ir","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.irimo.ir/eng/index.php",,,,,"I.R. of Iran Meteorological Organization (IRIMO) ","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 4 days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation, as well as historical data.","When you click on the map on the homepage here (https://www.irimo.ir/eng/index.php), it gives you 4 days forecast (including current day) for each region, but only temperatures for upcoming days, while precipitation is only expressed in terms like, Thunder Shower. Wind speed is only available for current day, as well as wind direction and humidity. Check example here (https://www.irimo.ir/eng/wd/701-Weather-Forcast-Esfahan.html?id=17556)
You can search for historic data here (https://www.irimo.ir/eng/wd/720-Products-Services.html#report_builder_form), but you have to provide date, time and station, one by one. The result include, temperature, wind speed, wind direction, rainfall and pressure. With a resolution of 3 hours for each day.
","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Neal Bastek","45"
"cc89156f-2646-4a1c-9173-7397cb03954f","global","2015-09-11T15:19:50","2015","my","spending","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Annual Budget","Ministry of Finance Malaysia","Yes","Yes","Submission is correct","The data cannot be accessed by the Ministry of Finance (MoF) because there is no Freedom Information Act in federal state whereby MoF is part of the federal state territory.
Link: https://www.treasury.gov.my/?lang=en
","Yes","No","Hazwany Jamaluddin","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","5"
"3ae7f101-e104-44cd-b912-c002a2c01ce7","global","2015-10-23T12:43:14","2015","jo","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.jometeo.gov.jo/4days.aspx",,,,"Weather / Four Days Forecast","Jordan Meteorological Department","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 4 days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation, as well as historical data.","Here you can find 4 days forecast (https://www.jometeo.gov.jo/4days.aspx), however it only include temperatures, the rest is explained in text, using terms like mild wind speed and dry weather, without specifying actual numbers for wind speed and precipitation. Here is the current day's weather for the different cities, including wind speed and direction (https://www.jometeo.gov.jo/CountryWeather.aspx). And here you can request data for historical periods, and they said they will compile it based on the resolution and period you specify and be provide it via email (https://www.jometeo.gov.jo/OrderInfo.aspx), we haven't tested it though.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Neal Bastek","45"
"38ca7cd2-97bb-4630-8153-b69f3b058f0b","global","2015-09-25T10:02:53","2015","za","land","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Unsure","No",,"No",,,,,,"Dept of Rural Development and Land Reform","Yes","Yes","ok","The Dept completed a [land audit](https://www.ruraldevelopment.gov.za/phocadownload/Cadastral-Survey-management/Booklet/land%20audit%20booklet.pdf) in 2015 in which it states:
> The State Land Audit serves to underpin this. It has now been completed and the relevant data vetted and verified. We now know who owns what part of South Africa; what land the State owns and
where it is located.
However, this information does not appear to be available to the public.","Yes","No","Greg Kempe","Codrina Maria Ilie","10"
"61f05f13-5c7a-46c7-9577-8c8de306c8ad","global","2015-10-02T06:14:00","2015","ml","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The original submission claims that the data exists from the ""National agency of the weather"". I could not find this organization via a Google search and changed the submission to 'data does not exist'.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Neal Bastek","0"
"a6c18553-1b34-4ca7-90fc-158f349a9a38","global","2015-09-14T16:05:35","2015","dz","map","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,,"National Institute for Cartography and Remote Sensing ","Yes","Yes","After reviewing this submission I find that these conclusions are correct.","The National Institute for Cartography and Remote Sensing (https://www.inct.mdn.dz/) sells maps of Algeria. Both topographic and thematic maps. Maps are not available online, as they are being sold.
A list of maps is shown here (https://www.inct.mdn.dz/site%20anglais/web_inct_sim/style/images/cartes1_gene.gif), though most of them are not according to the required scale, there is one ""Carte d'Algerie et ses environs"" is at 1:200,000.
Here there are topographic maps of scales 1:50,000 and 1:200,000, https://www.inct.mdn.dz/site%20anglais/web_inct_sim/act-ctopographique.php - and here are spatial maps
Not sure how often the maps are updated.","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Gil Zaretzer","5"
"6f43987e-bc2c-4003-a63f-f473d25fed8b","global","2015-10-12T17:07:57","2015","tj","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed","[Ministry of Finance](https://minfin.tj) publishes quarterly reports on budget execution. Information is available in Tajik and Russian.
This is validated by IBP's [Open Budget Survey](https://survey.internationalbudget.org) which shows in year reports, but no year end report and only an internal audit report. So the data exists and is very likely digital but it may not be complete.","Yes","No","anonymous","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"843c480c-9772-48cb-9212-941506cab971","global","2015-09-10T06:21:13","2015","jp","land","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Unsure","No",,"Yes","https://www1.touki.or.jp/",,,,"登記情報提供サービス","一般財団法人 民事法務協会","Yes","Yes","ok","Cadaster ""地籍図, 公図"" data is managed by each Local Government. There is no description for area or distance information on this data set. Format is ""地籍フォーマット2000 (Cadaster format 2000)"" or SIMA.
Reading Cadaster is practicable at each local government office.
As similar data set, ""地積測量図 (Acreage Survey Drawing)"" is managed by Legal Affairs Bureau ""法務局"" on each local/region. Data format is combination of ""地図XML (Map XML)"" & ""登記CSV (Registration CSV. contains ownership information)"".
""地積測量図"" data is published by ""一般財団法人 民事法務協会"" with fee. Data format is PDF when published.
* https://www1.touki.or.jp/
* https://www1.touki.or.jp/service/index.html","Yes","No","Satoshi IIDA","Codrina Maria Ilie","30"
"1bf7f9c3-84fd-427f-88c6-f60aca7cc884","global","2015-09-25T18:00:57","2015","vc","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.myforecast.com/bin/expanded_forecast_15day.m?city=76741&metric=true",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The original submission listed a private source for the data. I can not find an official government source using Google. I changed the submission to 'data does not exist'.","The data is based on the capital city of Kingstown","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Neal Bastek","0"
"d3611f8c-a5d6-47c8-9b10-d8cee892a67f","global","2015-09-27T15:16:26","2015","kn","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.wunderground.com/weather-forecast/zmw:00000.1.78858",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The original submission listed a WeatherUnderground link. A Google search reveals that the St. Kitts weather may be supplied by the Antigua Met. Service here: https://www.antiguamet.com/ but that website is down at the time of review. The submission was changed to 'data does not exist'.",,"Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Neal Bastek","0"
"f02e7d51-06af-49b1-b043-f1a82b40e70b","global","2015-10-04T11:28:12","2015","az","spending","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed","The data seems to exist. The IBP's [Open Budget Survey](https://survey.internationalbudget.org) reports that there are Year end reports and audit reports public but looking through the [Open Budget Library](https://openbudgetlibrary.org) the [year end reports](https://docs.google.com/folderview?pli=1&id=0B_X6a0ijQSVHflFpUHJhdXFWdnZmUUhwcEpqSmlnTkNJNjd2M2I4OVJuLXVoMFhnNzJWd2c&tid=0ByA9wmvBrAnZN3ZrdzNzcS1JZzg) are fairly old (2013) so the data is possibly not completely digital.","Yes","No","Codrina Maria Ilie","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","5"
"39319a28-1175-4240-bdaf-749e8ea6e747","global","2015-09-19T15:11:09","2015","pr","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://www2.pr.gov/agencias/jca/areasprogramaticas/EvaluacionPlanificacionEstrategica/Pages/default.aspx",,,,"305(b)/303(d) Integrated Report","Junta de Calidad Ambiental de Puerto Rico / Puerto Rico Environmental Quality Board","Yes","Yes","Approving this submission, all parameters are listed in reports. ",,"Yes","No","Instituto de Estadísticas de Puerto Rico","Nisha Thompson","35"
"c9c4d241-ebec-4c51-a4cb-86b8a9318b2b","global","2015-09-22T16:06:42","2015","ru","map","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Everything seems correct.","Open geodata is still unavailable both for public and organizations.
Comment: Nothing changed since 2014","Yes","No","Ivan Begtin","Gil Zaretzer","10"
"27f5abc0-f4ab-408e-9e51-38b48ea0f3f8","global","2015-10-01T16:11:10","2015","bw","map","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","Yes",,"No",,"mostly GIS but also available as csv etc.",,,,,"Yes","Yes","Since the national atlas is an official source, and there is an EBook version, I'm changing the answer to ""Digital"" to ""Yes"", however the data is still not public, free, online, openly licensed, or updated timely. In addition, the Ebook version is a bulk download so I do believe it is better to mark it also as yes.","Submitter's comments: Some areas still require mapping, Data sets are in departmental silos and as such can be bureaucratic to get.
Reviewer's comments: It does not appear as if Botswana has a national map released officially, although I am sure it exists internally (which is also what the submitter is hinting at as far as I can tell). I'm marking this in existence, but not publicly available.
Comments from 2015: There is an atlas of Botswana in the following link: https://www.atlas.gov.bw/ However, it seems like the government website is not working. Therefore, we are submitting the same result from last year. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Gil Zaretzer","20"
"c44d2852-7b6a-4942-9108-31104a3539cc","global","2015-09-23T21:35:18","2015","bs","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.bahamasweather.org.bs/index.php?page=forcasts",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I changed this submission to 'data does not exist'. While the site was working when I checked it (https://www.bahamasweather.org.bs/index.php?page=forcasts), it only included forecast data for two days, and it was two days behind.","The Bahamas Meteorology Department has data on their website but upon clicking each link, there are currently down at the moment.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Neal Bastek","0"
"62bc18ea-20c4-496c-a4db-fefda6aa73cd","global","2015-09-28T06:01:16","2015","ua","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.cgo.kiev.ua/index.php?fn=k_meteo&f=kyiv&p=1",,,,"Weather forecasts and current tempratures","Central Observatory for Geophysics","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 3 days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation, as well as historical data.
","Central Observatory for Geophysics collects and publishes all key weather indicators online, but in an HTML webpage format.","Yes","No","anonymous","Neal Bastek","45"
"1a8290c7-207e-4990-8404-1dc04a612afe","global","2015-09-25T16:24:26","2015","do","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is accepted as is. Official site is here: https://www.onamet.gov.do/","Data exists, however it doesn't comply with all minimum requirements.","Yes","No","Eliaquín Encarnación","Neal Bastek","0"
"3f2770f5-bfe7-413f-ba93-a069c49f6b77","global","2015-10-02T08:47:26","2015","ne","budget","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Finance law 2015","National Institute of statistics","Yes","Yes","The bill on the statistics website does not define expenditure for departments or sub- departments. Therefore, I marked that the data exist, but is unavailable. ","The finance law is prepared by the ministry of finance, but his website is down. The budget is published as pdf document, and downloaded for free https://www.stat-niger.org/statistique/file/MF/LF2015.pdf","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"cf26f5d6-917f-4175-9df8-b09c1a766a4f","global","2015-09-28T16:18:11","2015","gh","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,"shapefiles",,,,,"Yes","Yes","The url provided to the data in the original submission is not working: https://maps.meteo.gov.gh:89/SOURCES/.Ghana/.ALL/
A one day forecast can be found here: https://www.meteo.gov.gh/website/index.php?option=com_content&view=category&id=42&Itemid=62
I've changed the submission to 'data does not exist'.","https://maps.meteo.gov.gh:89/SOURCES/.Ghana/.ALL/","Yes","No","Nehemiah Attigah","Neal Bastek","0"
"2b001bce-0f9f-44da-bfad-bb7990d8da39","global","2015-09-30T21:59:08","2015","tc","emissions","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","It is uncertain if data for pollutant emissions in Turks and Caicos exists","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","yar michl","0"
"d39a6869-858d-4eef-a332-1158f0de3358","global","2015-10-02T15:52:36","2015","ne","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","There is no evidence about the existance of a national level pollutant emissions data","Yes","No","anonymous","yar michl","0"
"a95c84d0-414a-4ec4-ae38-41b28163e293","global","2015-10-07T02:34:38","2015","cn","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as is. While there is no 5 day forecast there is a one day forecast and a three day forecast here https://en.weather.com.cn/","No 5 days forecast exists in China","Yes","No","OKFN CN","Neal Bastek","0"
"548885b8-a36e-45ed-825d-d715fbd2b129","global","2015-09-19T15:22:41","2015","pr","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://www.weather.gov/",,,,"National Weather Service","National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as is.",,"Yes","No","Instituto de Estadísticas de Puerto Rico","Neal Bastek","35"
"7950e2d7-679b-4d90-a4da-9e1ced442cd2","global","2015-09-28T21:05:04","2015","sv","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://www.cnr.gob.sv/geoportal-cnr/","shapefiles",,,"Descargas de Coberturas Geográfica. under this heading several shapefiles dataset on different themes are provided (boundaries, transportation, hidrography and elevation)","Centro Nacional de Registros - Instituto Geográfico y del Catastro Nacional - Geoportal CNR","Yes","Yes","Everything seems correct, I only changed the link to the download page directly instead of the homepage","Some spatial data sets are available for download through the Geoportal CNR Website (data sets are related to boundaries, transportation, hidrography and elevation).
To note that the data sets are free of charge bu cannot be used for commercial purposes without getting the authorization of the CNR.
Note that also webservices are available as WMS for viewing the information.
https://cloud.cnr.gob.sv/ArcGIS/services/SVWGS84/MapOficial/mapserver/WMSServer
https://cloud.cnr.gob.sv/ArcGIS/services/SVWGS84/RelieveOficial/mapserver/WMSServer
","Yes","No","anonymous","Gil Zaretzer","60"
"d1b74c3a-1e1c-4c53-bfcf-bdc673cf07d0","global","2015-09-24T10:33:32","2015","mk","map","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Yes","No",,"Yes",,"SHP, PDF",,,"Digital topographic map in scale 1: 25000","Agency for Real Estate Cadastre","Yes","Yes","Since the data offered for a fee is not online I'm changing the ""public"" to no, since this is a restriction on data, the rest seems correct.","The State Agency for Real Estate Registry also is responsible for organizing geospatial data. All available map products are listed here: https://www.katastar.gov.mk/en/Page.aspx?Id=459&m=1564
Data is currently offered in different formats for a small fee. Data can't be ordered and paid online.
An online map service is available here: https://gis.katastar.gov.mk/Arec/ Different layers can be selected but there is no download option available.","Yes","No","Metamorphosis Foundation","Gil Zaretzer","35"
"90e77c1a-141c-499e-9446-cb67cb5cfbcc","global","2015-09-25T12:32:26","2015","kz","map","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Since there is no evidance of official data that might exist, I'm changing it to no.","There are number of third party portals/projects (such as https://map.kz/) that show the information about national map, however, we could not find any evidences that they have been commissioned by government. Country has extremely large area, but very few populated areas and population density is one of the lowest, so the provision of such service could be very expensive and take a lot of time/effort. ","Yes","No","Nazerke Akhmetzhanova","Gil Zaretzer","0"
"57be987c-763a-4999-85c5-5600c70e4f25","global","2015-09-19T18:32:04","2015","pt","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.igeo.pt/DadosAbertos/Listagem.aspx","WMF, WMS, Shapefile",,,,"iGEO","Yes","Yes","Seems correct."," The new iGEO site provides full maps with 1:10000 resolution and clear open data terms.
However, this data is free for academic and research purposes, but sold for commercial purposes (e.g. companies). This is made clear in their FAQ (in Portuguese):
«A utilização da informação é gratuita para a Administração Pública e Academia, prevendo-se a cobrança de taxas justas para as empresas, com aplicação de descontos caso se tratem de entidades sem fins lucrativos.»","Yes","No","Miguel Laginha","Gil Zaretzer","55"
"118f74d5-4bca-4b1b-b779-5f9aec33bade","global","2015-09-30T22:52:35","2015","tc","budget","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"BUDGET 2015-2016","The Government of Turks and Caicos Islands","Yes","Yes","Data is not available. Budget speech does not meet the criteria. ","Approved budget plan is available online for period 2012-2015 but there is no pdf nor csv format for the data.
Reviewer's note - This is the budget speech, not the budget allocation. Data exist but not available. https://www.gov.tc/index.php/pressoffice/245-budget-statement-2015-16","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Mor Rubinstein","20"
"7dc1da27-aae3-44c5-9f6d-4effe400c43d","global","2015-10-23T08:48:11","2015","bo","budget","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Could not find the budget. Changed the submission to exist and unknown. ","Reviewer's note- There is a budget for Bolivia, but I could not find it in the website - https://www.economiayfinanzas.gob.bo/","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","5"
"dc048113-55f3-4a4f-9aa0-aaf86d089274","global","2015-09-18T10:01:17","2015","kh","budget","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Cambodian National Budget",,"Yes","Yes","Could not find an official resource of the data. Data therefore exists but not available. ","The data is only available up to 2013.
No new data for later years is available.
PDF version of the 2014 budget law is available online - https://cambodianbudget.org/userfiles/file/Left%20Menu/Budget%20Government%20Documents/Budget%20Law%20Series/The%20Law%20on%20Financial%20Management%202014.pdf
[Khmer language]
The data in this [site][1] does not seems to be from an official resource, but citizens initiative. The data therefore exist, but not publicly available.
[1]: https://www.cambodianbudget.org/budget_database.php","Yes","No","Vantharith Oum","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"59b7bc7f-4880-4a90-b584-b7cbdaa09619","global","2015-09-21T10:33:22","2015","im","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.gov.im/maps/","javascript HTML",,,"National Map","Information Systems Division, Cabinet Office","Yes","Yes","Seems correct.","(C) MANNGIS on visualisation but MannGIS is a government service and the Ts&Cs on the footer reference a new IM OGL open government licence .
ESRI ArcGIS also has a free tools for low end reuse.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Gil Zaretzer","45"
"55b9b64b-ce20-4b5b-8abd-87799b3b9b96","global","2015-10-02T13:12:35","2015","ag","budget","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"2015 BUDGET STATEMENT","Government of Antigua and Barbuda","Yes","Yes","Link was not working. Changed the data. ","Data is in pdf format and not machine readable.
During the review the link - https://cdn3.antiguaobserver.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/BUDGET-Statement-2015-FINAL-Print-Version.pdf?828426 was not working. I have changed data accordingly. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"e7bd7a5c-e140-4a05-a997-93c8aa4e1ac6","global","2015-09-26T20:33:27","2015","kn","map","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.google.com/maps/d/u/0/viewer?mid=zcVlEl3mdI0I.krwcEgUJS7lQ&hl=en_US","HTML",,,,,"Yes","Yes","Since there is only a google maps embedded map, I'm changing this to no.","only embedded Google maps ","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Gil Zaretzer","0"
"2268d403-2153-454f-87e3-26b703577b05","global","2015-09-17T11:07:17","2015","cz","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Unsure",,"Yes","https://vdp.cuzk.cz/vdp/ruian/vymennyformat/vyhledej","SHP, GML, DGN",,,,"Czech Office for Surveying, Mapping and Cadastre","Yes","Yes","seems correct","Borders and some of the rivers and lakes are available freely (RUIAN and DIBAVOD databases), downloadable via public remote access (Veřejný dálkový přístup).
The rest is a part of paid services (ZABAGED).","Yes","No","Michaela Rybičková","Gil Zaretzer","45"
"db68b489-c14a-4e25-8f74-a3fd924e5a5a","global","2015-09-21T22:32:30","2015","bs","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.bahamas.gov.bs/wps/portal/public/National%20Budget/Budget%20Documents/!ut/p/b1/vZTZkqIwFIafpR-A5oQ1XKICouyLEm4skUVkEdywefqxp6Zqlqq252J6kqtUfX_9Oec_CR3ThBMkJEosZumIjtvtrSy2l_LYbuv3cyxsWNBMWeawqfEggB46huyIc8ZG_AMgDwA-WDI81S-ZH_onwF_5fwRw8Jl-TUcBYaTZWS80ZZV37vlQrEhnq70VXE8llILWDtTynE6IcLMMgVqAeAbpzQ9TIfJ0QnWLkjrUaXvckapwlV6n8B2Kjj0796Cmdvvbmg-kPM71-5uae6NJLvi4Uc2s400_VvycI51rzio23SfpMYGq7zV7V5Mp6fdJ5ifirLycl1N0MUjWZPtYc91xA5FwpUg7vLw87h8_LfG9A9-BZxF9FpI1PzYZTR6Y-AsWrAB0BLLnIxewheiAjoDb-Ie3Th-r0TvAAP5MR9aYmihYI1M5-VZYgSXFllnhEU7hYCoX0w_sMVDOyLIiJ1154USeelnOtn8a2kwgPQynSFiGPPjAfbWhxtv40QgxcGSeAc1G_9uQ_a8t1RwbvrzC34aGc_99hgs6LpPmddg1r_CKJQHxIuYkLADHYZFeHYjAPx77oCjeZkGQce7FzpZdywNrD_3UIlxRR6zO7PK92C69yUr1bmm7rTRvMiRcO23auRZCX58a6G7rFb6YMTro-VHDJFksPTbU74YIBV80x7XOqcVmPkjOfGuM4sE-KHydri-rXe7NbtcRUymJFjakTWMkloC7mzEjmVQ7ZTqYG0BGf-WnPWNkajtU1qKWksQ1NUtlQnldpX2UAudwWze6M0PX2BpQyhINc_nxKTRxraqG4M0HhH_u4eUbCbZQAQ!!/dl4/d5/L2dBISEvZ0FBIS9nQSEh/","CSV; PDF",,,"Budget Communication 2015/2016","The Government of the Bahamas","Yes","Yes","I have changed the entry for the link. Data is correct. "," ","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"11e49b73-15ab-40f6-847c-8ba46698582a","global","2015-10-02T13:15:25","2015","rw","map","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Seems correct.","The National Institute of Statistics of Rwanda (NISR) provides a national map of Rwanda but this has not been updated since 2012 so does not satisfy the criteria for this dataset: https://www.statistics.gov.rw/publications/all/Map
NISR also provides GIS datasets and shapefiles for the country's national, provincial, district, sector and cell level boundaries on their website at https://www.statistics.gov.rw/geodata","Yes","No","anonymous","Gil Zaretzer","0"
"84660722-3281-420f-9657-af81277b9db0","global","2015-09-25T15:12:46","2015","do","map","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Unsure","No",,"Unsure",,,,,"Provincial and topographical maps ","Instituto Cartográfico Militar Dominicano","Yes","Yes","Seems correct.","We called the institution and they confirmed they have the data and are able to make it available to anyone at a price. For a list of services available you can check here: https://www.icm.mil.do/index.php/productos","Yes","No","Eliaquín Encarnación","Gil Zaretzer","10"
"a0def5b8-18c9-4844-ad78-7aa72526705e","global","2015-09-17T14:38:51","2015","ly","map","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Since there appears to be nothing official and the elections result map is a google maps embedded one, I'm changing this from unsure to no.","A search on the official governmental portal (gov.ly) did not yield any maps. However, the most accurate map can be found on the website of the High National Elections Commission, in which a detailed interactive map shows the poll stations in the country, broke down into districts, cities and areas within each city (https://centers.hnec.ly/) ","Yes","No","Maraim Elbadri","Gil Zaretzer","0"
"a1086e7d-a72b-4431-9ddc-5d46c4ca2682","global","2015-08-31T14:34:50","2015","jo","map","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://193.188.88.208/DlSweb/",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The link provided was not for maps but for documantion of address and/or permits, I couldn't find anything else so I'm changing this to no.","The data available at department of land and survey. The data format is TIF","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Gil Zaretzer","0"
"0ec69240-e42c-4530-bd19-96b958c36af9","global","2015-09-09T17:35:49","2015","lb","map","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The ministry of enviroment does offer a ""maps"" section on their website, but it is an online viewer that does not load probably and there is no actuall data to check, thus I am changing the status to not sure.","The ministry of environment is using an official map of Lebanon through an application, but i couldn't find the shape files of any other information on it. ","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Gil Zaretzer","0"
"646e6fb7-8afc-4875-9f72-9dfdec1b3dc4","global","2015-09-15T14:32:01","2015","be","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.begroting.be/FR/Documents/Copy%20of%20eBudget-Recettes-Budget2015.xls","xls",,,"Publicatie van de Middelenbegroting initieel 2015 (Excel) / Publication du Budget des Voies et Moyens initial 2015 (Excel)","Federal Public Service for Budget and Management Control (Service Public Fédéral Budget et Contrôle de la Gestion, SPF B&CG)","Yes","Yes","XLS is machine readable, the data is in bulk. I have changed the data. "," Budget Online webpage provides access to recent budget data in pdf and xls formats. ","Yes","No","Deraesara L","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"3097b399-6429-42f5-8d8f-0cc9ee2dfbc5","global","2015-08-31T15:54:42","2015","eg","map","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Since there is no link the only thing I could find was https://www.mcit.gov.eg/Egypt_Maps which apears to be down so I approve the unsure submission.","Map for Egypt governorates, villages and districts. Historic maps are also available. All maps are available for purchause upon request to the dedicated Authority. [No changes from 2013]
Final reviewer: I am unable to respond to most of the questions in a more precise way since the website is down at the time of review (28 November 2014). Yet, if the data is available for purchase, then the data exists (thus, 'unsure' -> 'yes'), is not available for free (thus, 'unsure' -> 'no') and is not openly licensed (thus, 'unsure' -> 'no').","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Gil Zaretzer","5"
"2db47be2-7694-4d09-89aa-e3467021c3d3","global","2015-09-30T13:31:27","2015","ng","map","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Since there are sections that should offer the map but nothing is available I'm changing this to not sure."," The official website of the National Boundary Commission that should release the digital maps is unavailable.
Their official website s now available at https://www.boundarycommission.gov.ng/ but the maps tab has no information yet.
Maybe the Office of the Surveyor General of the Federation as well at https://osgof.gov.ng/ They have aggregates of digital maps domiciled in their offices, and might make it available online soon
No Changes in 2015
","Yes","No","Oludotun Babayemi","Gil Zaretzer","0"
"c459167e-3815-46fa-9b66-ed398b51a7f3","global","2015-09-17T12:28:33","2015","be","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.ngi.be/topomapviewer/public","SHP",,,,"National Geografic Institute","Yes","Yes","Seems correct.","The NGI has provided a mapviewer application to show the different layers of their maps as requested in these global census. However it not yet available in a downloadable open format for the whole of Belgium, nor is it available for non-commercial use.
We do have to nuance that these maps are openly available for Flanders and Brussels on https://www.geopunt.be/catalogus thanks to the Open Data Policy of Flanders.
","Yes","No","Pieter-Jan Pauwels","Gil Zaretzer","60"
"9117f6ac-2996-44f2-9cb4-4d2630f4d021","global","2015-09-20T05:38:04","2015","pk","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.surveyofpakistan.gov.pk/downloads/pak3m.pdf","PDF",,,,"Survey of Pakistan, Government of Pakistan","Yes","Yes","Seems to be correct, I've changed the link to a one directly to their best PDF administrative map.","There is also GIS based maps present in form of shapelfiles with Districts and Thehsil level boundries and names at https://www.pakresponse.info/MapDataCenter/GISData.aspx
","Yes","No","Nouman Nazim","Gil Zaretzer","55"
"f277a7d6-a8a6-4cc6-911e-25237c7773cb","global","2015-09-28T06:57:35","2015","id","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://data.id/dataset/rupa-bumi-indonesia","geojson",,,"Rupa Bumi Indonesia","Badan Informasi Geospasial","Yes","Yes","Seems correct.","While the high resolution map is only available as paid product (https://big.go.id/peta-rupabumi/), there is WMS and GeoJSON access to the basemap.
Data did not change.","Yes","No","anonymous","Gil Zaretzer","60"
"6d7484a1-ac44-40d0-b92c-a8991e5ad30a","global","2015-09-25T13:38:39","2015","vc","map","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","This submission was of an unofficial source that didn't seem to meet the standards we are looking for, I couldn't find anything else myself, thus changed to no.","Based from the map of St. Vincent and the Grenadines, all of the name of cities, borders and rivers are shown for all of the cities in the country.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Gil Zaretzer","0"
"d2d54b19-cd19-4f7d-b35d-1c57f92c95e8","global","2015-10-02T17:47:43","2015","lc","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://204.188.173.139:9090/stats/index.php/statistics/2013-05-13-12-49-24/maps",,,,"The Mapping Unit of the Central Statistics Office (CSO) has been in existence for over ten years. The main funcitions of the unit are to provide mapping and spatial support to the other sections of the CSO and other agencies.","Central Statistics Office","Yes","Yes","Seems to be correct, worth noting that CSO also offers an online viewer with unclear save option for registered users.","Data is in pdf format and not machine readable.","Yes","No","anonymous","Gil Zaretzer","55"
"8803627e-7b6c-4c3c-b1b0-29fc8a2b61fb","global","2015-09-05T01:47:57","2015","jm","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.nla.gov.jm/map.asp","ArcGIS",,,"iMap Jamaica","The National Land Agency","Yes","Yes","Seems correct.","Map includes satellite imagery and annotation. Download does not appear to be possible and data is not openly licensed.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Gil Zaretzer","60"
"209a30ec-287f-4008-99fe-9bd23baa2bcc","global","2015-09-15T03:02:33","2015","gd","map","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","This submission offered a tourist map that I feel doesn't meet the standards of what we are looking for and I was not able to find anything else myself, so I've changed it to no.",,"Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Gil Zaretzer","0"
"69a26966-8202-4501-b082-73e2dab5dbb2","global","2015-09-20T05:47:38","2015","dm","map","Yes","Unsure","Yes","Unsure","Yes","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Seems correct, I've only changed the answer to updated timely to not sure because there is no proof that it is or isn't.","The government distributes copies of the map of Dominica at every entry point for free in Dominica. ","Yes","No","Veronne Nicholas","Gil Zaretzer","25"
"63aa74ee-e70f-42b1-9dd5-1e579d10f785","global","2015-09-28T03:31:21","2015","bm","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://landvaluation.bm/",,,,,"Land Valuation Department","Yes","Yes","Seems correct.","Seemingly no changes since 2013.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Gil Zaretzer","35"
"f1a7eaa5-20c5-40e8-9c38-b2506f814132","global","2015-09-27T15:30:27","2015","bb","map","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","As per other countries with no evidance of such data I've marked it no insted of unsure.","gov.bb search option does not yield any search results on ""map"", ""mapping"" or indeed any keywords!
google search with site:gov.bb map also does not yield any search results ","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Gil Zaretzer","0"
"86a16ba7-86ac-415d-937e-ef271dc7bc84","global","2015-09-23T02:43:12","2015","bs","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Yes","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,"The Bahamas National Geographic Information Systems (BNGIS)","Yes","Yes","The data exists, however it is currently unavailable. BNGIS's website has a section offering access to geographic data, but it is still a work in progress. Since they state that the service is free, public and digital, I've marked those as yes, but since nothing is available at the moment the rest is unsure.","The Bahamas National Geographic Information Systems (BNGIS) offers access to geographic maps [here][1], but at the moment it's still a work in progress and nothing is available.
[1]: https://www.bahamas.gov.bs/wps/portal/public/gov/government/services/!ut/p/b1/vZbbkqJIEIafZR6Aoao4XxaCnItjIXhDoKCtiCJKozz96u5MxOzsTvfNjOQFQcSf8UX-mVQlu2Qzdnks33fb8ro7HcvD83spFhwwPIx52TMEIAKLBi4OJBPJBD4E-a8FPg8-zJ8L7ILNzHyUtIu31fHiPWx8e96Sy8kbb9Is3128uS7sCPYzJTx3B-GWe0nSVaYZrdcHZ3Pf9OdYZZZqvbxdjHKzZO55haa1KNmx6a_euqBeYtytwpWLdpZ8XGjv_oBOuK7HScjuguhrpXYXz15OT84kJumu53Tp2qLyzi-sMeP0zmUCU2rIMVa-1Qp-8eBPa_3Qq6fgmR-qIIxdhcOG5ErASqREdCwNCOr3_A8En_RqwS4_kvgO-kTwbOffgo88-KgKMRTY_CGQfkAkKQAWBDiKYQjkSGATNgN8Ee_vnTU1U7SX4pFoEfEoP0GK7p5mZoQe3PhqE68nFkgoShLbI4k1Jg24x1UQVGlEVYx1TjlGPwN9lCgP4AyKDhVAbKA_DTQEX36YKCUBFhAAs5cD4Z8CGr4Xzp6WJurTUs40sehyMuBfDRR_O9Bml7tV-3Vct1_BV6QAQYYyJyIJyEhg044yt1XjvWnBmM7PUVsamg97sAldQt-GNdZbrCcH6a4Uhgt2UOt0gfO74uozgZcgd1ARgllVwSPHVarYl1l77ahyYUoyRzgsmaoKETXIZWXxwbrN9lcHAubInVG7UkGK84NjISN0XSvf52GzfGtiaXf27cWMy_P3uRkFcXzy5lSbrvH2bG2pWsR0K_fXyPEYte1ru_Ur8eJzj5evps2mJEJ_OTuboDZCpwNGeNNlRnA01dLFaaVrnVxcj9m8aHIomVXLb0A-HBjm3b8HCVXyLywxT239rUu_OqCi_47FFE9EP909fZzglLpJn1CS6DdCHBhrtgcomB4dvBHp0SUgON7V_N4lx06N-2dA4dVA6cVACb0aCF8N5F4MJK-eUiK-Gvj7f4t_nZa8CBESRVFAiOcRB9l0n4Pbc8PT9DTgJeMmIKmqeQzicaHPZwme99vDkMEIYgLqRilqVTlucJQOoaUqlXgsg6DxcXD1l9Sw7TQ7kcUJUE9ufH_3WFaHjrk7HtRaaXNcbWt762Zi7pYyPzsZ061QhqGvyPZc7KPHKRnn5L0VrYQCOAzWPlpbh0MuTMEq6NcryOCl-0Y_21HA_xgIE40C0tcAapTzaB8R2gKPVMTb2-7juoGXCY9eHwIvsS2v-m7gTJ-W69snOwoQ_jTw55WBezEw_v2W_msmORkqj1sciIIoQoWX2dRdj__MpJW9nQVNLQtt3YhR5TTdWh0bDZ8vzVVU0io7b4rBFKZKDmCWa6p9m_qhOZTiOKv104AlDQ7bYAhzUu9Dde_Sbl7UvkkLYDhBphTmBi_JxW2p668OWtHpb-imlruyTGb78-GuMdAC9HAaUVUfdsppW9g927X03XFcMdI35MfgS-bnWE3Zt8BfvvwF6rTtRA!!/dl4/d5/L2dBISEvZ0FBIS9nQSEh/","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Gil Zaretzer","30"
"ea35973a-9f3c-4349-a16b-b9673bd786b0","global","2015-09-27T23:28:56","2015","aw","map","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","since no evidance of such data can be found I'm changing it from ""unsure"" to ""no"" as other countries in similiar situation.","It is uncertain if the data exists","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Gil Zaretzer","0"
"424be0ad-658b-4d40-a126-b85eebd0aafd","global","2015-09-18T21:02:44","2015","ag","map","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://geonode.data.gov.ag/maps/59",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","A link was provided to https://geonode.data.gov.ag/maps/59 but geonode is a "" open source platform for sharing geospatial data and maps"" and the layers are user created, baselayers are mapquest, since this is not official data, and since I didn't find anything else on the official government website I'm changing this to data does not exist.",,"Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Gil Zaretzer","0"
"8b1a30e3-fb73-457f-acd0-7d9b38b2d9b8","global","2015-10-02T09:32:21","2015","ke","map","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Official map of Kenya- Map of Kenya detailing official National and County boundaries gazetted in February 2013.","Ministry of Land, Housing and Urban Development","Yes","Yes","Everything seems correct.","No map published by the government was found.
[According to Ahmed - No changes from 2013]. Maps must be BOUGHT from the Ministry of Land, Housing and Urban Development.
However, a lot of mapping data - shapefiles, json files exist and they are pretty accurate","Yes","No","anonymous","Gil Zaretzer","5"
"c83ef973-637a-4833-8506-eed4178d90be","global","2015-09-25T12:29:38","2015","al","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://gis.ceshtjetvendore.gov.al/","geojson",,,"The National Map","GIS- Ceshtjet Vendore","Yes","Yes","Since the data is not downloadable (for free) but only an online viewer with print capabilities I changed bulk to ""no"", other than that everything seems in order.","This is the updated map after the territorial administration reform.","Yes","No","Blerta Tuci","Gil Zaretzer","60"
"910c5020-59f4-4ba3-974f-cd79c51e4f2f","global","2015-09-27T11:05:35","2015","tl","map","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Seems correct.","There are no information about Timor-Leste found from the official website Government of Timor-Leste https://timor-leste.gov.tl/?lang=en nor dedicated department(s) that could publish such information.","Yes","No","anonymous","Gil Zaretzer","0"
"2be8124f-1b6a-4d39-8a38-f94ef5d7410b","global","2015-10-04T13:53:14","2015","az","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Approving submission. Can't find any reference to data. ","It doesn’t exist in the website of Azersu and Ministry of Ecology and Natural Resources of Azerbaijan Republic. And they don’t share information about this. But you can find it in different websites which is not updated information (https://sei.az/upload/files/azsustandart_final.pdf)","Yes","No","Codrina Maria Ilie","Nisha Thompson","0"
"20ec0b9a-1261-4976-9575-0c76df40a62f","global","2015-09-29T04:59:03","2015","tt","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Approving submission. Couldn't find any data or references to data collection online.","It is uncertain if the data exists.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Nisha Thompson","0"
"bb8183c2-36c2-4939-9451-250202091023","global","2015-09-24T12:45:59","2015","ko","water","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Water Quality","National Institute of Public Health","Yes","Yes","After some research found some references to water quality monitoring of rivers and water supply, but the data isn't available. ","They refer to water quality monitoring here.
https://www.niph-kosova.org/","Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Nisha Thompson","5"
"f10dd7b6-38b6-4524-9544-201427723d8a","global","2015-09-28T10:49:32","2015","ge","water","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Approving this submission. Also couldn't find any data or referrals to data collection","Unfortunately, information on water quality and pollutants in water is only available by the companies contracted to manage the water. JumpStart requested water quality data in the past and the company Georgia Water & Power made us jump through a lot of hoops to get the most meager of data in PDF format. ","Yes","No","Eric Barrett","Nisha Thompson","0"
"f71e6b31-07e1-4daa-964d-2ee43697afce","global","2015-10-22T22:53:21","2015","mm","spending","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.","No evidence showing from the President's Officer website that the data is exist. https://www.myanmarpresidentoffice.info/en/ and the dedicated webpage for the cabinet ministries is empty https://www.myanmarpresidentoffice.info/en/?q=cabinet/ministries so no way to find out who are the responsible minister involve.
Myanmar has an internal audit report according to IBP's [Open Budget Survey](https://survey.internationalbudget.org) which indicates that the data exists.","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","5"
"48c066e2-988f-4660-8fd1-9d29e7ce0dea","global","2015-10-22T22:49:41","2015","kh","spending","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.","No evidence of executed budget or audit reports.","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","0"
"ae6fae8a-2e06-4100-9ea7-3cd08abdc98a","global","2015-09-27T22:27:27","2015","md","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.meteo.md/monitor/monitor.htm",,,,"Department of Environmental Quality Monitoring","Ministry of the Environment","Yes","Yes","Environmental water quality testing is there. Couldn't find drinking water but the parameters are in the reports. ",,"Yes","No","Victoria Vlad","Nisha Thompson","35"
"ce761791-85e1-4e7e-9192-2292b02c22f0","global","2015-09-18T22:20:43","2015","is","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,"Fjársýsla ríkisins / The Financial Management Authority","Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.
Data seems to be digital.","Aggregated government spending is available at https://rikisreikningur.is
Delayed monthly expenditure is available at https://www.opingogn.is/dataset/gjold-eftir-manuoum
","Yes","No","Páll Hilmarsson","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"5c15bc7f-b6cc-4fc2-b262-cc847c0e8b1b","global","2015-09-15T05:53:21","2015","kg","spending","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.
Source showed information, not actual data, which indicates the data exists, but is not published.","The ministry of finance provides data on expenses as shown by budget execution reports: https://minfin.kg/ru/novosti/otchety-po-ispolneniyu-byudzheta/vedomstvoluk-klassifikatsiya-boyuncha-aylyk-chygas.html","Yes","No","Azamat Tokhtaev","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","5"
"ab837657-01b3-4509-af45-285bc169eaa4","global","2015-09-20T07:13:43","2015","ko","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,"Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","Submission is correct.
Added one proof.","A database of government spending exists, however it is not public. For example the statement of accounts for January - September 2014 is available: https://www.pak-ks.org/repository/docs/141031_Pasqyrat_Financiare_Te_hyrat_e_Dedikuara_Janar_-_Sep_2014_ANGLISHT.compressed.PDF ","Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"7d9cdacd-fcab-45aa-a2a2-fa1a763553be","global","2015-09-24T18:04:34","2015","dk","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is correct.
Data is available from a non-government source.","Not available under open license, since you'll have to make an FOI request to get it. Data that is up to date exists. See also https://www.information.dk/databloggen/460345 (Danish) on obtaining the data.
The data clearly exists in government ERP solutions (in multiple machinereadable formats). All expenditure data is transferred in a mandatory format for e-invoices, more at: https://www.digst.dk/Servicemenu/English/Digitisation/NemHandel/NemHandel-initiative-and-infrastructure
More on the format here: https://www.oioubl.info/classes/en/index.html","Yes","No","Niels Erik Kaaber Rasmussen","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"ff6e3732-2e7d-48b0-bb76-a0e3100f43bf","global","2015-10-11T14:03:17","2015","tr","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.
Answers were not in line with aggregated data.","Aggregated data on public finance is available and regularly updated at: https://www.treasury.gov.tr/default.aspx?nsw=EilDPQez15w=-SgKWD+pQItw=&mid=738&cid=12 &nm=684 but these do not include transactional spending data.
QA review: Change license to Not open, since it says at the footer: ©The information provided by the Undersecretariat of Treasury source is available.","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"0f6d3dc0-9f33-49e9-bcd9-02013a2bbc30","global","2015-09-07T17:48:02","2015","qa","spending","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.
Added clarification and data seems to exists, nothing else is known given the audit report is internal.","Qatar has an internal audit report according to IBP's [Open Budget Survey](https://survey.internationalbudget.org) which indicates that the data exists.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","5"
"17724fb5-fc24-41ae-b82b-fedd5583c6bf","global","2015-09-10T17:21:45","2015","om","spending","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is correct.","Oman does not appear to have a central collection of spending details as at an individual transaction level for the whole government. ","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","0"
"b1c47fec-0359-460c-afa1-f7027dbe27a4","global","2015-09-12T15:34:07","2015","ma","spending","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.
Linked dataset was the budget, not the enacted budget.","Transactional data is not available. Audit report publication on IBP's [Open Budget Survey](https://survey.internationalbudget.org) indicates that the data exists.","Yes","No","Chadi Nanaa","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","5"
"9b6975c3-6db0-488f-87e8-a78ca49831c4","global","2015-08-30T17:32:14","2015","om","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Data seems to not be public, but the Ministry of Regional Municipalities and Water Resources is tracking it.
https://mrmwr.gov.om/new/en/Search.aspx?q=water%20quality","The Ministry of Environment and Climatic Affairs ( https://moeca.gov.om/ ) is responsible for environment issues and violations of environmental laws and the Ministry of Regional Municipalities and Water Resources ( https://mrmwr.gov.om/ ) is responsible for regulate the use of water resources in the country. It is not clear which body has data on water pollution and/or if any of this information is available to the public. ","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Nisha Thompson","0"
"ac494236-1903-49e5-907e-39690f05a6ed","global","2015-09-25T15:03:45","2015","ma","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.water.gov.ma/userfiles/file/depliant%20francais.pdf",,,,,"Ministère environnement ","Yes","Yes","Approving submission. couldn't find any other water quality data. ","URL licence
https://www.water.gov.ma/userfiles/file/depliant%20francais.pdf","Yes","No","Chadi Nanaa","Nisha Thompson","35"
"de979e28-8470-4659-8fbb-19215fb76f92","global","2015-09-08T18:10:33","2015","ae","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Seems they do have regulations on water quality
https://rsb.gov.ae/en/publications/detail/the-water-quality-regulations-fourth-edition
The suppliers are in charge of meeting regulations and monitoring water quality. If it does exist it is at the local level. ","It is unknown if the UAE collects or publishes any data relating to water quality.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Nisha Thompson","0"
"de7a01c9-bfc2-4a8b-a695-c597f12eac4b","global","2015-10-02T16:16:25","2015","nl","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission correct.
Added clarification","The Ministry of Finance has stated that it will work the coming five years on publishing expenses as open data.
There is a payment system collecting all transactions of the central government in one place: https://www.dsta.nl/english/Subjects/Payment_systems","Yes","No","anonymous","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"9177be66-5d19-46b3-98fa-eb9ba656f572","global","2015-09-28T00:38:00","2015","ar","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,"XML",,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.
Original submission is aggregated data only.","Argentina has a very informative [financial data portal][1]. It shows many analysis for expenditure data in a machine-readable format and bulk download, albeit aggregated data.
[1]: https://sitiodelciudadano.mecon.gov.ar/sici/informacion_historica.html
The last update of the information was in July 2015 which indicates digital format.","Yes","No","Yamila García","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"dcdfa285-0d14-43c2-9d07-95dfb57a9a40","global","2015-09-01T14:04:29","2015","kr","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is correct.
Minor changes because dataset is not published.","In the same way with the government budget dataset, the government spending dataset is also available on the [Open Fiscal Data][1] site managed by the Ministry of Strategy and Finance of the Republic of Korea. However, the publicly available government spending dataset is only at high level, not at transaction-level.
Whenever a transaction occurs in the government, the Open Fiscal Data site is used to record it so we can say that the dataset with transaction-level data exists in the database of the system.
[1]: https://www.openfiscaldata.go.kr/portal/service/openInfPage.do","Yes","No","James G. Boram Kim","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"609359a1-628b-44e5-949e-1036147f132c","global","2015-08-19T07:30:28","2015","il","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"No","https://www.health.gov.il/Subjects/Environmental_Health/drinking_water/quality_assurance/Pages/Water_quality_testing.aspx","XLS",,,,"MInistry of health","Yes","Yes","Approving this submission","The measurements are done on a sporadical basis. Data is updated every 3 months. In addition, not all chemicals are assessed for each water source. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Nisha Thompson","50"
"f1b65bad-1adc-489b-9c4d-8136652b4edc","global","2015-10-07T15:41:52","2015","ie","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Databank","Department of Public Expenditure & Reform","Yes","Yes","Submission is correct.","The aggregated data that are publicly available at the program expenditure level but not available at the actual expenditure level, i.e. transactional level.
There was some dispute here, and it was dediced to assume that these do exist even though a link is not provided, as to get to the programme level actual expenditures are required. https://databank.per.gov.ie/Expenditure.aspx","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"2225e477-92a8-49d4-9458-065a0b0e7201","global","2015-09-17T10:13:56","2015","dm","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Unsure","No",,"Yes","https://www.weather.gov.dm/",,,,"Current Weather Data, Forecasts (3 days), Astronomical Data, and Climate Data are the titles of the data sets provided by publisher. ","Dominica Meteorological Service","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 4 days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation, as well as historical data.","The weather data is available online via web link: https://weather.gov.dm/current_conditions.php.
The weather forecasts are given not of a five day forecast but a three day forecast. Information is available via telephone as a weather hotline - (767) 447 5555.
Information is updated daily or more frequently especially when there is ' severe weather conditions approaching.Radio alerts are also recived.
All information is for free except for Climate Data which has to be requested from the Meteorological office. Here is the link as to the details of the fee structure. https://weather.gov.dm/climate_data_fees.php.
The data set is available in bulk for free only to government entities and students, otherwise a fee is charged.
To access bulk data, users are provided with an online form through which they can specify the data requirements. Inform
","Yes","No","anonymous","Neal Bastek","30"
"ce61eba5-d550-460c-892e-a952ca536c34","global","2015-09-18T14:17:56","2015","ro","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Budget execution","Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","Submission is correct.","Some aggregate indicators are published every 10 days at:
https://www.mfinante.ro/decadale.html?pagina=domenii
This indicates that the transactional data exists but it is not available.","Yes","No","Ovidiu Voicu","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"5e00d3b8-6472-4a97-b92b-8296e80a6c3f","global","2015-09-07T12:12:41","2015","bh","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.bahrainweather.gov.bh/",,,,"https://www.bahrainweather.gov.bh/","Ministry of Transport and Telecommunications","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 5 days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.","The Ministry of Transport and Telecommunications has a dedicated website for the weather in Bahrain ( https://www.bahrainweather.gov.bh/ ). The website provides a variety of weather and provides details of weather, wind, sea state, temperature and humidity for the next five days. ","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Neal Bastek","45"
"e56e52ad-7f4f-4c7c-a549-bff9853133bd","global","2015-10-01T14:46:59","2015","bj","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","This submission claims that data exists at the Direction Nationale De La Meteorologie du Bénin under the title Prévision météorologique hebdomadaire. I can find a facebook page under that name, but no website nor data and have changed the submission to data does not exist.","The national direction of the weather of benin produce weather data.","Yes","No","anonymous","Neal Bastek","0"
"68d79724-474a-4bd1-a2e0-0e5f586cc820","global","2015-10-04T14:05:27","2015","az","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.eco.gov.az/en/",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The initial submission stated the data existed at https://www.eco.gov.az/en/ There is only one day of forecast and no historical data so I changed it to does not exist.","The weather forecast for each day is on the official page of the Ministry of Ecology and Natural Resources, with a short description. I couldn't identify any database with historical temperature data. ","Yes","No","Codrina Maria Ilie","Neal Bastek","0"
"4b34e369-7511-4419-bd16-6a781e933e0d","global","2015-08-30T17:57:30","2015","om","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.met.gov.om/opencms/export/sites/default/dgman/ar/weather-chart/map-data/index.html",,,,"General forecast data such as temperature, wind, rainfall, etc.","Directorate General of Meteorology","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 3 days of forecast data for temperature and precipitation (though only in iconic form) and the current windspeed data. It also includes a years worth of historical data.","Directorate General of Meteorology provides a lot of climate data to the public. The website has a simple section for providing simple weather details for specific cities in Oman and shows the temperature changes for the next three days for each city. ( https://www.met.gov.om/opencms/export/sites/default/dgman/en/weather-chart/oman-cities/index.html ) The website also has a more elaborate interactive map that allows the user to overlay different weather layers and playback the predicted changes for several future days. ( https://www.met.gov.om/opencms/export/sites/default/dgman/en/weather-chart/map-data/ ) The website is difficult to navigate though and browsing by map is not intuitive and very slow. Also, the raw data does not appear to be available for download directly.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Neal Bastek","45"
"5c7dca50-46a0-46ae-ad63-5cd71e72894e","global","2015-09-21T20:35:04","2015","gt","weather","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"https://www.insivumeh.gob.gt/meteorologia.html","Instituto Nacional De Sismología, Vulcanologia, Meteorología E Hidrologia - Insivumeh","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 5 days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.","El INSIVUMEH es una institución técnico-científica altamente calificada que contribuye a la optimización de actividades del sector productivo de la República de Guatemala asociadas a las ciencias atmosféricas, geofísicas e hidrológicas, coordinando servicios con el sector privado y actuando como asesor técnico del gobierno en caso de desastres naturales; además planifica, diseña y ejecuta estudios y monitoreos sistematizados en la tecnología adecuada, enriqueciendo las bases de datos y sistemas de información Geográfica referencial del país, contribuyendo así con la modernización y especialización del sector educativo a todo nivel en el campo de su competencia. Y en delegación subsidiaría del estado, lo representa como miembro activo en organismos nacionales e internacionales.","Yes","No","Julio Herrera","Neal Bastek","20"
"7e51b07d-167c-4d89-be72-f8ab2d502e17","global","2015-10-02T00:42:03","2015","se","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure",,"Yes","https://www.scb.se/en_/Finding-statistics/Statistics-by-subject-area/Environment/State-of-the-environment/Air---environmental-quality/",,,,"Air - environmental quality","statistics sweden","Yes","Yes","checked","Air quality data on CC-zero license
from open data site of Sweden
The air pollutants that are commonly present in both urban and rural air come principally from traffic, combustion and industrial processes. Data from Swedish municipalities on particulate matter (PM10 and PM2,5), nitrogen dioxide, sulphur dioxide, benzene, carbon monoxide, benzo(a)pyrene and certain metals are reported annually to the European Commission under Directive 2008/50/EC and Directive 2004/107/EC. Measurements in rural air and precipitation (e.g. ozone, nitrogen oxides, sulphur dioxides) are conducted by the Swedish EPA.
in short the data is Exist but not main site of the Government make it
the is fond on each municipalities Available in bulk left in Unsure
in the statistics sweden site of Sweden shold be a file with all the data for a year but its not fond in During the visit of the site in 22-10-2015 so data is Is the data machine readable and
the data for can been see in this link of The Stockholm - Uppsala County-https://www.slb.nu/elvf/
","Yes","No","Asmen Gül","yar michl","45"
"8d1877a8-227c-44ea-8b17-fca64938df6a","global","2015-09-28T08:34:16","2015","it","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://www.sintai.sinanet.apat.it/view/index.faces","XML","https://www.dati.gov.it/iodl/2.0/",,,,"Yes","Yes","I rejected the submission because the data pointed to was waste water which didn't include the parameters specified. Italy manages water at the municipal level and they might have data locally. ","INSPRA presents data through the European portal on the water
In particular is some information on this tab.
https://cdr.eionet.europa.eu/it/eu/uwwt/envt1ogcg
The dataset is not updated since 2012.","Yes","No","Maurizio Napolitano","Nisha Thompson","0"
"d345bfd8-b398-4236-8e78-a17ba1c22f8e","global","2015-09-28T14:56:20","2015","ht","water","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Unsure","No",,"No",,,,,"National water quality monitoring system (SISKLOR)","Direction Nationale de l´Eau et de l'Assainissement (DINEPA)","Yes","Yes","Approving this submission. ","There is evidence that DINEPA, the public entity managing the water system in Haiti, was regularly publishing water quality collected through the information system SYSKLOR until the year 2013. (1)(2) There is, however, no evidence that such data is still regularly collected and published.
(1): https://www.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=520442004668424&id=267899689922658
(2): https://www.dinepa.gouv.ht/wash_cluster/index.php?option=com_rokdownloads&view=folder&Itemid=54","Yes","No","Pierre Chrzanowski","Nisha Thompson","10"
"4f474d7d-00ff-46ee-b9bf-95c1390eedee","global","2015-09-14T14:12:40","2015","gb","spending","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"No","https://www.gov.uk/government/publications?keywords=£25%2C000+spend","CSV","https://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open-government-licence/version/3/",,"Spend data over £25,000","Each department publishes it themselves, originally coordinated by HM Treasury","Yes","Yes","Submission is correct.","Central Government departments are required to regularly publish lists of all financial transactions spending over £25,000; some departments publish transactions down to £500 or lower. The business rules and the format is described at https://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/20130129110402/https://www.hm-treasury.gov.uk/psr_transparency_index.htm The data is re-usable under the UK's Open Government Licence.
In addition summarised spending information by month x department x type of goods/services is available quarterly from the Treasury (Ministry of Finance) COINS/OSCAR database - see for instance https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/hmt-oscar-publishing-from-the-database This is also available under the Open Government Licence. The data was last updated/released in September 2014.
2014 reviewer comment: The data in no longer available through COINS or 'Where does my money go'. It can be found on data.gov.uk platform. I added the correct link to the information and a link to the data license.
2015 reviewer comment: OSCAR is not sufficient - it is an aggregation of transactions by budget code, not the detail of the transactions themselves. The monthly spend by government departments is scattered across gov.uk and data.gov.uk and is frequently out of date. For example at the time of writing the Cabinet Office itself is 12 months out of date: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/cabinet-office-spend-data and https://data.gov.uk/dataset/financial-transactions-data-co (latest shown is August 2014, current date is September 2015.","Yes","Yes","David Read","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","80"
"c8ad5da1-a7e1-4a12-86df-08a1408d2141","global","2015-09-17T18:30:23","2015","kw","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Approving submission. ","We could not find any data about the quality of water on ministry of electricity and water official website (https://www.mew.gov.kw).","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Nisha Thompson","0"
"89501e87-6a4d-4ac6-a88d-566ad3df0c5c","global","2015-09-15T16:25:37","2015","th","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure",,"Yes","https://data.tmd.go.th/api/index1.php","json",,,"Thailand Meteorological Department API : TMDAPI","Thailand Meteorological Department","Yes","Yes","I cannot confirm that forecast data includes temperature, wind, and precipitation, but am accepting this submission on the basis that the daily and weekly forecast data is available, as well as some historical data.","Data/information service via the API
- 3 hours of detailed weather information and daily
- Information on daily and weekly weather forecast
- Weather statistics
- Weather data from automated systems.
- The information reported earthquakes in the country in Thailand and the region.
","Yes","No","Klaikong Vaidhyakarn","Neal Bastek","60"
"de3a7b34-9446-4241-a953-04db61a2d02a","global","2015-09-21T10:33:50","2015","im","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.gov.im/about-the-government/departments/environment-food-and-agriculture/environment-directorate/environmental-protection-unit/air-quality/","HTML, XLS, copy and paste to CSV and XLS","https://www.gov.im/about-this-site/open-government-licence/",,"Air Quality","Department of Environment Food Agriculture","Yes","Yes","checked","Air quality emissions testing stations discontinued in 2009 due to consistently low readings.
Survey data collated to publish carbon emissions reduction strategy report.
Some environmental sensors to monitor vehicle and waste incinerator emissions with published statistics.
","Yes","No","anonymous","yar michl","65"
"ad008d50-d8ee-42aa-b976-875ddc62a410","global","2015-10-01T13:32:01","2015","ky","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.weather.gov.ky/portal/page?_pageid=4421,1&_dad=portal&_schema=PORTAL",,,,"National Weather Service","Cayman Islands Government","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 5+ days of forecast data for temperature and precipitation.",,"Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Neal Bastek","45"
"82a1d4fa-a091-4e1a-bb15-ce2dd96b7a84","global","2015-09-28T05:57:57","2015","ph","map","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Unsure","Yes","Yes",,"Unsure","https://www.geoportal.gov.ph/viewer/","geojson, KML, CSV, SHP",,,,"National Mapping and Resource Information Authority","Yes","Yes","Downloading data in a machine readable way requires a key obtained from NAMRIA admin, so it is not public, also it is not clear if the key is free or when was this last updated so I changed free and updated to not sure","An interactive map viewer for the Philippines is available here: https://www.geoportal.gov.ph/viewer/
Layers can be selected and downloaded. Additionally the configured map can be downloaded as PDF. There is no terms of use or license statement.
p/s: data did not change","Yes","No","anonymous","Gil Zaretzer","40"
"733a6ad2-96b7-449a-becd-5b4d3d908249","global","2015-10-05T18:19:05","2015","ca","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure",,"Yes","https://www.ec.gc.ca/inrp-npri/",,,,,"the data for air pollution monitor is available and in timely up but its not give be the canadian federal Government","Yes","Yes","checked","the data for air pollution monitor is available and in timely up
but its not give be the canadian federal Government
its given by Environmental Protection Agency of ecah provinces
link to most of the air pollution monitor site of the provinces
https://aqm.enr.gov.nt.ca/-Northwest Territories
https://www.bcairquality.ca/-British Columbia
https://www.gov.mb.ca/conservation/envprograms/airquality/-Saskatchewa
https://www.mddelcc.gouv.qc.ca/air/iqa/index.htm-Newfoundland and Labrador
www.gov.mb.ca/conservation/envprograms/airquality/-
https://www.airqualityontario.com/-Ontario
https://esrd.alberta.ca/air/-alberta
The reviewed data of prior years can be downloaded in bulk. Environment Canada's website's terms of use prohibit commercial reproduction. However, data.gc.ca publishes many of the same datasets under an open license. The terms conflict, the url to the open licence is provided.
The Meteorological Service of Canada (MSC) HTTP data server is a source of several raw meteorological data types and forecast data. This service is aimed at specialized users with good meteorological and IT knowledge, and is mainly meant to be accessed in an automatic manner via the internet (e.g. with scripts). The server's URL is: https://dd.meteo.gc.ca/. Also, in Canada provinces and territories also have monitoring sensors, data would need to be acquired from them as well. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","yar michl","45"
"740f2843-e91a-47bf-8922-40da1f2fc1a7","global","2015-09-27T02:35:41","2015","cr","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.imn.ac.cr/IMN/MainAdmin.aspx?__EVENTTARGET=PronosticoExtendido",,,,"Pronostico del tiempo","Instituto Meteorológico Nacional","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 5+ days of forecast data for temperature and precipitation.","There is information about the weather forecast for five days but its not in a machine readable format. There is no historical data available in the website. ","Yes","No","camila salazar","Neal Bastek","45"
"c4413577-476a-4de2-b8ac-8927eb5e0b39","global","2015-08-30T07:31:16","2015","np","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.mfd.gov.np/weather/",,,,"Weather forecast of Nepal","Department of Hydrology and Meterology, Meteorological Forecasting Division ","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 3 days of forecast data for temperature and precipitation, and limited historical data.",,"Yes","No","Nikesh Balami","Neal Bastek","45"
"1c550487-2ccb-4c89-8e45-51535aa5f02e","global","2015-10-02T09:34:48","2015","ke","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.meteo.go.ke/",,,,"Weather Forecast Data by The Kenya Meteorological Department","Kenya Meteorological Department","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 5+ days of forecast data for temperature and precipitation.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Neal Bastek","55"
"4ddc26fe-18dc-43df-9d42-bf240deac323","global","2015-09-28T06:09:57","2015","kh","map","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Couldn't find anything official on Google either","No data found from the official website Ministry of Land Management, Urban Planning and Construction https://www.mlmupc.gov.kh/?page=&lg=en","Yes","No","anonymous","Gil Zaretzer","0"
"10fd4f89-3b24-4331-b49a-2c1684e28ca8","global","2015-09-16T09:36:11","2015","kg","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://nature.gov.kg/index.php/environment/air.html",,,,"It provides the data about environment in Kyrgyz Republic","State Agency on Environment Protection and Forestry","Yes","Yes","checked","State Agency on Environment Protection and Forestry provides information on pollution, nature, forests etc. Additionally it is possible to make a request for information from their web site. The form is located https://nature.gov.kg/index.php?Itemid=103
no data of PM seem to be Measured so its may be It is better to say that information does not exist","Yes","No","Azamat Tokhtaev","yar michl","35"
"55fb4691-9f2c-4db7-be4a-1e325abb9982","global","2015-10-04T13:13:17","2015","az","emissions","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"No",,,,,,"Azerbaijan Branch office of Regional Environmental Center for Caucasus ","Yes","Yes","checked","its seem Air Quality is been Measured but the data not fond in a Government Website
[link to a Report Improvement of Legislation on Assessment and Management of Ambient Air ][1]
from the Report
2.1. OVERVIEW OF AIR POLLUTANTS RELEVANT TO AZERBAIJAN
Monitoring of pollution of ambient air in Azerbaijan is conducted by the Department of National
Environmental Monitoring in accordance with the statute “On the rules of implementation of
state monitoring of the environment and natural resources” prepared by the Ministry of Ecology
and Natural Resources, and approved by the resolution No.90 of the Cabinet of Ministers of the
Republic of Azerbaijan dated 1 July, 2004.
There are 3 categories of observation and control stations in order to determine concentration of
sulphur dioxide, carbon monoxide, nitrogen dioxide, dust, phenol, and other noxious
substances. Observations on the pollution of ambient air are carried out at stationary and
mobile stations. Stationary and mobile stations are supposed to be established by taking into
account the area, landscape, industrial development, mobile pollution sources, and number of
population of each city (settlement) as follows:
50 000 inhabitants - 1 monitoring station;
50 000-100 000 inhabitants - 2 monitoring stations;
200 000-500 000 inhabitants - 2-3 monitoring stations, etc.
Monitoring and observation of pollution of ambient air is regularly conducted at 26 observation
stations located in eight big industrial cities of the Republic of Azerbaijan (Baku, Sumgayit,
Nakhchivan, Ganja, Mingachevir, Shirvan, Lankaran, Sheki),covering basic polluting ingredients
(dust, sulphur dioxide, nitrogen dioxide and carbon monoxide), and specific harmful substances
corresponding to the industrial profile of each city. The number of stations is compliant with the
above-mentioned criteria, except for Baku city, where there are fewer stations than it would be
necessary
[1]: https://capacity4dev.ec.europa.eu/airqualitygovernanceintheenpieastcountries/system/files/file/17/12/2014_-_1035/azerbaijan_npp_activity_3_report_draft_national_strategy_on_aqam_eng.pdf","Yes","No","Codrina Maria Ilie","yar michl","10"
"1a20e9aa-9e00-4b63-aa32-022653826d10","global","2015-09-28T05:36:13","2015","th","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://aqmthai.com",,,,,"Division of air quality data","Yes","Yes","checked","The data set is shown in https://aqmthai.com
Historical data can be query from https://aqmthai.com/public_report.php
Note: data did not change
add by yaron
all Air pollution is measured Apart from VOCs","Yes","No","anonymous","yar michl","45"
"5d76a29f-e71f-4b77-8448-ddb62310fbb5","global","2015-09-27T23:53:55","2015","aw","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.meteo.aw/marckforecast.php",,,,"Forecast for: Aruba","Departamento Meteorologico Aruba","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 4 days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.",,"Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Neal Bastek","45"
"a714ee5e-a085-4bff-86da-f2181632e5d8","global","2015-09-20T12:11:45","2015","ag","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.antiguamet.com/Antigua_Met_files/Antigua%20and%20Barbuda_4_dayforecast.html",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The original submission stated data is available at: https://www.antiguamet.com/Antigua_Met_files/Antigua%20and%20Barbuda_4_dayforecast.html This page is not accessible at the time of review, nor is anything at the main domain https://www.antiguamet.com I changed the submission to data does not exist.",,"Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Neal Bastek","0"
"2845e93a-b062-4501-b3a1-92ae9605aca3","global","2015-09-24T10:08:14","2015","mk","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Balance sheet/Annual account of the Budget. The Ministry provides the realization of the proposed budget as a final balance sheet with all the expenditures but not in detailed manner for transactions.","Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","Submission is correct.","The Ministry of Finance provides the balance sheet/annual accounts of each fiscal year: https://www.finance.gov.mk/mk/node/575, transactional data is not available to the public, also it is assumed that it exists, as the final accounts represent aggregated data. The report is provided in PDF format, the one for 2014 is available here: https://www.finance.gov.mk/files/u6/ZAVRSNA%20SMETKA%20NA%20BUDZETOT%20NA%20RM%20ZA%202014%20-%20_0.pdf","Yes","No","Metamorphosis Foundation","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"f53dd5a5-035d-48fb-aef9-94d25548281c","global","2015-09-24T17:16:17","2015","mm","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.dmh.gov.mm",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The initial submission indicated the data exists at https://www.dmh.gov.mm. There is a single day forecast and a ten day forecast, but neither include temperature or wind data. I've changed this entry to data does not exist.",,"Yes","No","YE HTUT WIN","Neal Bastek","0"
"84216865-4c67-4874-9431-de71799ba0d7","global","2015-09-15T13:06:37","2015","bd","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.bmd.gov.bd/",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The original submission claimed the data from the Bangladesh Meteorological Department existed here: https://www.bmd.gov.bd/
I can only see a single day of temperature, precipitation, and wind data. While they allude to a 2 day outlook and a five day outlook, there is no data associated with that claim other than a blanket statement on how the future weather relates to today's weather (e.g. ""little or no change"", ""no change"", etc."". Based on this, I've changed the submission to indicate the data does not exist since there is only one day of data.",,"Yes","No","Hasive Nur Chowdhury","Neal Bastek","0"
"eb6c0731-cdfe-4ea8-850f-b92549bd2ac9","global","2015-09-19T10:24:55","2015","au","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.ga.gov.au/products/servlet/controller?event=FILE_SELECTION&catno=63999","wms","https://www.ga.gov.au/metadata-gateway/metadata/record/gcat_a05f7892-c39f-7506-e044-00144fdd4fa6/Outline+map+of+Australia+%28with+state+borders+and+capital+city+locations%29",,"GEODATA TOPO 250K Series 3 - Packaged (Personal Geodatabase format)","Geoscience Australia","Yes","Yes","Everything seems correct, I changed the link to the dataset for a better one offereing vector data download instead of PDF.","1:250 000 scale Topographic vector data is also downloadable in full https://www.ga.gov.au/products/servlet/controller?event=FILE_SELECTION&catno=63999 One of the first government organisations to adopt open licencing, specifically Creative Commons. https://www.ga.gov.au/copyright.html Also provides WMS API https://www.ga.gov.au/mapconnect/wms.jsp ","Yes","Yes","Pia Waugh","Gil Zaretzer","100"
"eda119b3-0cd9-4d12-8321-5d54ebce69c7","global","2015-09-01T14:48:32","2015","gg","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.gov.je/Weather/Pages/Guernsey-forecast.aspx",,,,"Guernsey weather forecast for today and the next 5 days","Jersey Met enquiries@jerseymet.gov.je","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 5 days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation, as well as historical data.
","Forecasts for the Bailiwick of Guernsey are provided by the Jersey Meteorological Department to the States of Guernsey under a Service Level Agreement.","Yes","No","Marcus Ferbrache","Neal Bastek","45"
"43774f65-f29c-4490-88c2-b3b450a23d45","global","2015-09-28T03:46:25","2015","bm","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.weather.bm/",,,,"Bermuda Public Forecast","Bermuda Weather","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 5 days of forecast data for temperature and precipitation, as well as historical data.","To view each day forecast, you will click the image below each respective day.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Neal Bastek","45"
"3b620f44-26c6-462e-bfdc-80055d8467a2","global","2015-08-27T09:23:24","2015","je","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.gov.je/weather/Pages/Jersey-Forecast.aspx",,,,"Jersey Met 5-day forecast for Jersey","Jersey Met - John Searson j.searson@gov.je","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 5 days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.",,"Yes","No","Marcus Ferbrache","Neal Bastek","45"
"9cce994b-86e6-484b-8261-2c315ca09cea","global","2015-09-25T13:39:30","2015","rs","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.hidmet.gov.rs/ciril/prognoza/stanica.php?mp_id=13274",,,,"Prognoza vremena za Srbiju - 5 dana","Republički hidrometeorološki zavod","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 5 days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.",,"Yes","No","Stevan Gostojić","Neal Bastek","45"
"4823434b-6769-484f-a63f-242b0b82b66a","global","2015-09-25T14:18:53","2015","de","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.geodatenzentrum.de/geodaten/gdz_rahmen.gdz_div?gdz_spr=deu&gdz_akt_zeile=5&gdz_anz_zeile=1&gdz_unt_zeile=1&gdz_user_id=0#dok","PDF, WMS, Shape","https://www.geodatenzentrum.de/docpdf/geonutzv.pdf",,"Digitales Landschaftsmodell 1:250.000","Bundesamt für Kartographie und Geodäsie","Yes","Yes","The first link was a dead end so I replaced it with the link from the preview, other than that everything seems correct.","Digital maps at a scale of 1:250.000 are available here: https://www.geodatenzentrum.de/geodaten/gdz_rahmen.gdz_div?gdz_spr=deu&gdz_akt_zeile=5&gdz_anz_zeile=1&gdz_unt_zeile=1&gdz_user_id=0#dok The data is available via a WebMapService and as Shape-files. This map should be covered by the GeoNutzV. https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/geonutzv/index.html It is technically not a license but it is intended to allow for reuse with attribution requirements only. However compliance with the Open Definition has not been properly reviewed yet.
A list of all map products available for download can be found here: https://sg.geodatenzentrum.de/downloadPortal/
","Yes","Yes","walter palmetshofer","Gil Zaretzer","100"
"a048b3be-52f3-431c-9915-2f1c0375ddbe","global","2015-10-02T21:58:20","2015","sn","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","
The original submission claimed that the data existed at the National Agency of Civil Aviation and Meteorology website, which I found here: https://www.anacim.sn/
It appears to only include data for a single day (three days ago in the past in fact). I changed the submission to state that the data does not exist.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Neal Bastek","0"
"9b708d05-c57f-4359-9277-ef68b5587224","global","2015-09-28T04:20:31","2015","ar","weather","Yes","No","Yes","No","Yes","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,,"National Weather Service, Defense Ministry nation","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 5+ days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.","The information is available online but the data is not available to be re used in free formats
https://www.smn.gov.ar/?mod=pronografico&id=3","Yes","No","Yamila García","Neal Bastek","35"
"2b8eee92-d7b5-44f3-a1d5-4b585c7b6785","global","2015-09-28T11:38:15","2015","bf","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.meteoburkina.bf/previsions.html",,,,"Prévisions méthéorologiques. Weather forecast","Direction Générale de la Météorologie du Burkina","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 4 days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.","The weather forecast are available on the website of the general direction of the weather, but the forecast are broadcast from an other website(1). According to the general direction, they are collecting data but meteorama provide better tools for broadcasting.
Even if their data are not online, it can be requested for free. The Burkina Faso Open Data Initiative have funding from the world bank to work in the climate change field and they are planning to open up weather data.
1. https://www.meteorama.fr/","Yes","No","Idriss TINTO","Neal Bastek","55"
"658c8d66-acb9-462a-be36-ee28abbcea8f","global","2015-09-10T14:31:11","2015","at","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.basemap.at/","Web Map Tile Service 1.0.0 (WMTS)","https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/at/deed.de",,,"City of Vienna and the regional governments of Austria through https://www.basemap.at/","Yes","Yes","I have reviewed this entrey and everything seems correct.","Metadata for Basemap.at is available on the government's open data portal, https://www.data.gv.at/datensatz/?id=2c54f4d6-5712-4e5a-a025-b7f7a396c39b. ","Yes","Yes","Martin Kaltenböck","Gil Zaretzer","100"
"0acb847d-e468-4431-8db8-d31f8008b4a1","global","2015-09-12T14:57:20","2015","ly","budget","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I have accepted the submitter comment. Data is unsure. ","The site seems not to be updated for since June, and the latest budget mentioned is for 2014 here (https://www.mof.gov.ly/index.php/2012-11-21-22-39-31.html)
We will keep the status of this dataset unchanged, and below is last year's comment for your reference:
Impossible to find actual data on this although an announcement by the Libyan Ministry of Finance exists that the 2014 budget is being prepared (https://www.mof.gov.ly/index.php/homepage/136-%D9%85%D9%86%D8%B4%D9%88%D8%B1-%D8%A5%D8%B9%D8%AF%D8%A7%D8%AF-%D8%AA%D9%82%D8%AF%D9%8A%D8%B1%D8%A7%D8%AA-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%85%D9%8A%D8%B2%D8%A7%D9%86%D9%8A%D8%A9-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B9%D8%A7%D9%85%D8%A9-%D9%84%D9%84%D8%B3%D9%86%D8%A9-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%85%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%8A%D8%A9-2014-%D9%85%D9%8A%D9%84%D8%A7%D8%AF%D9%8A.html ). Legislation about budget is here https://www.mof.gov.ly/index.php/component/k2/item/22-%D9%84%D8%A7%D8%A6%D8%AD%D8%A9-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%85%D9%8A%D8%B2%D8%A7%D9%86%D9%8A%D8%A9.html. ","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"cdbad84b-b004-49cd-9055-0ef5b51a9cf5","global","2015-10-04T17:29:03","2015","tr","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.bumko.gov.tr/EN,2677/statistics.html",,,,,"General Directorate of Budget and Fiscal Control","Yes","Yes","COuld not changed the relevant excel. I have changed the submission. ","Reviewer's note: I could not find the data in Machine readable format on both [sites][1] mentioned here. I have changed the data accordingly.
[1]: https://www.muhasebat.gov.tr/","Yes","No","Pinar Dag","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"cb5ef19a-6d18-48b4-ae8a-ebaca59a6ee4","global","2015-09-25T16:51:56","2015","vc","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","The PDF source explains details of St. Vincent and the Grenadines, but data regarding carbon dioxide is updated up to 2008.
add by yaron
the data seem to be not considered available","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","yar michl","0"
"d20918b3-2967-4895-9b65-b76a84fc1a5a","global","2015-09-27T12:22:29","2015","kn","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","the data seem to be
not considered available","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","yar michl","0"
"c0c2c71b-076e-41b9-bb7e-cf7ac4683525","global","2015-09-17T15:14:16","2015","ir","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","it seem only the
https://air.tehran.ir/-its one city so data is considered available
from the usa epa site
https://www.tehran.ir/Default.aspx?tabid=12006
This site presents information on daily ambient air concentrations for carbon monoxide (CO), ozone (O3), sulfur dioxide (SO2), nitrogen dioxide (NO2), and particulate matter (PM-10) monitored in Tehran, Iran (overall and in twenty-two districts). The information is presented as good, moderate, unhealthy, very unhealthy, or hazardous, according to the Pollutant Standard Index formerly used by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.
the site didnt work at the 22-10-2015-date
","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","yar michl","0"
"a02bed20-f2fd-4941-9d60-a7a2e5996d04","global","2015-09-12T05:34:03","2015","jp","map","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","No","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.gsi.go.jp/kiban/index.html?link_id=linkB01","GML",,,"Base Map of Japan","Geospatial Information Authority of Japan","Yes","Yes","Users need to register in order to download, and a fee is requiered, thus it is neiter public nor free.","Data that can be downloaded is an XML document file or JPGIS2.x format, encoded in JPGIS2.x (GML) format. Data is provided timely (last update: 31/07/2015). Users need to register to download data. No terms of use are provided and the FAQ (https://fgd.gsi.go.jp/download/faq_download.html) also do not mention terms of use.
Basemap data is protected by Survey Law.","Yes","No","Satoshi IIDA","Gil Zaretzer","50"
"22a1b57f-5945-48b3-a6dc-83a6f4eccc9e","global","2015-09-27T19:10:38","2015","dk","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure",,"Yes","https://envs.au.dk/en/knowledge/air/monitoring/",,,,"AIR QUALITY MONITORING - RESULTS","DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE","Yes","Yes","checked",,"Yes","No","Niels Erik Kaaber Rasmussen","yar michl","45"
"92e1fd47-8bf2-4787-812a-39df7b6d6289","global","2015-09-18T17:14:07","2015","lc","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","no data exist ","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","yar michl","0"
"917862bf-c04f-46f7-83f9-9263f74d757d","global","2015-09-20T17:04:22","2015","dm","emissions","Yes","Yes","No","No","Yes","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","This information is not available to the general public via the internet however, it may be available on request from the Environmental Health Office.
add by yaron
a [link][1] to a Report on Air Quality and Meteorology Network in the Dominican Republic
from the Report
As part of a new Air Quality and
Meteorology Network in the Dominican
Republic, Pueblo Viejo Dominicana Corporation
(PVDC) have committed to implementing four
automated air quality data monitoring systems.
Three stations are already in place, with a
fourth to be added pending site location
approval. The stations are installed and
maintained by Golder Solutions, the successful
vendor following a recent RFP process.
[1]: https://www.earthsoft.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/08/Air-Quality-and-Meteorology-Network-in-the-Dominican-Republic.pdf","Yes","No","Veronne Nicholas","yar michl","25"
"a2c74b84-cd18-440c-b2ec-57b9ff42935e","global","2015-09-16T04:30:52","2015","gd","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","the data seem not bet Exist
no info was also fond on world health organization Report from 2014
on air quality Monitoring the world
see link (no data on the excel)
https://www.who.int/quantifying_ehimpacts/national/countryprofile/AAP_PM_database_May2014.xls","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","yar michl","0"
"18205c7f-6cbe-4bc9-a6ec-ad5d40c19bb1","global","2015-08-25T05:54:52","2015","my","emissions","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Air Pollutant Index of Malaysia","Department of Environment's ","Yes","Yes","checked","
the data is been been Monitor for PM CO AND SOx
no Monitor data for NOx exsit maybe the data shold be Considered not exist
but the raw data of air Pollutant is given so its Considered not Publicly available
the data online is here-https://apims.doe.gov.my/v2/
and its givs as a vale of Air Pollutant Index
----
Air Pollutant Index of Malaysia
Aggregate data about the emission of air pollutants especially those potentially harmful to human health (althoug
The Malaysian Air Quality Guidelines (MAAGs) which form the basis for calculating the API are presented in Table 1. These guidelines have been derived from available scientific and human health data, and basically represent ""safe levels"" below which no adverse health effects have been observed. The MAAGs are generally comparable to the corresponding air quality standards recommended by the World Health Organization and other countries.
The averaging time, which varies from 1 to 24 hours for the different air pollutants in MAAGs, represents the period of time over which measurements is monitored and reported for the assessment of human health impacts of specific air pollutants. As such, the air pollution indices are normally monitored and reported for the same averaging times as those employed for the air quality standards/guidelines.
The API values are reported for varying averaging time as follows:
a) PM10 and SO2 on 24-hour running averages.
b) CO on 8-hour running averages.
c) NO2 and O3 on 1-hour running averages.
The API for PM10 reflects specifically levels of particulate matter with a diameter of less than 10 micron pollution and it may not be linked directly to visibility factors, as visibility is often determined by results of semi-quantitative observations over relatively shorter time periods.
The API value reported for a given time period represents the highest API value among all the sub-APIs calculated during that particular time period. The predominant parameter contributing towards a particular API value is normally indicated alongside the API value. This approach is an effort to promote a uniform and comparable API system. Ideally, all sub-API values exceeding the API 100 threshold limit should also be reported in addition to the predominant API value per se.
To determine the API for a given time period, the sub-index values (sub-API) for all 5 air pollutants included in the API system are first calculated using the above mentioned sub-index functions for the air quality data collected from the Continuous Air Quality Monitoring Stations (CAQMs). The corresponding air quality data are subjected to the necessary quality control processes and quality assurance procedures, prior to the sub-index calculations.
Source of information -
---","Yes","No","Hazwany Jamaluddin","yar michl","20"
"a8c69d64-0161-4d43-b9c9-a4b259e923ad","global","2015-10-12T18:57:07","2015","iq","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.mof.gov.iq/pages/ar/FederalBudgetLaw.aspx",,,,"The Annual Budget","Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","I have reviewed the data and it is correct. Data is up to date. ","The data format is PDF
All copyright reserved by the Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Iraq, the Iraqi-© 2013","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"c2ab7b46-9305-4cf8-af5a-02636c702557","global","2015-09-27T20:11:20","2015","ms","emissions","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","It is uncertain if the data for pollutant emissions in Montserrat exists","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","yar michl","0"
"cdd7baff-4fd9-40b9-a20b-7dc2882bff8f","global","2015-09-12T09:25:10","2015","tn","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.finances.gov.tn/index.php?option=com_jdownloads&view=viewcategory&catid=1&Itemid=712&lang=fr","PDF",,,,"Ministère des Finances (Ministry of Finance)","Yes","Yes","I have reviewed the data and it is correct. Departmental budget is also available under the same URL but in separate files. . Data is therefore n bulk. ","Budget available for 2014 (Arabic) in PDF as well as a ""Circulaire de préparation du budget de l'état pour l'année 2015"". As it is unclear what the status of Tunisia's Open Data initiative is, solely the website of the data producer has been considered for this research.","Yes","No","Yosr Jouini","Mor Rubinstein","55"
"12dff86d-8001-43ae-961b-9ce11f97daf0","global","2015-09-26T05:01:15","2015","tt","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://finance.gov.tt/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/Expenditure-2015.pdf",,,,"Estimates Of Expenditure For the Financial Year 2015","Ministry Of Finance & The Economy","Yes","Yes","Changed data license to No. Data is correct and in sub department level. ",,"Yes","No","Matthew McNaughton","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"7a964dae-57dc-46ac-91a4-7fa5c48b421e","global","2015-09-01T13:45:42","2015","je","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.gov.je/SiteCollectionDocuments/Health%20and%20wellbeing/R%20Air%20Pollution%20in%20Jersey%202014%2020150805%20JB.pdf",,,,"Daily air quality monitoring results / Air Quality Monitoring in Jersey 2014","Environmental Health, eh@health.gov.je","Yes","Yes","checked","The Jersey government provides a live feed of air quality measured at two urban sites. There are 3 readings of levels of particulate matter: https://www.gov.je/environment/protectingenvironment/air/pages/airquality.aspx
In addition, an annual report commissioned by the Jersey government and compiled by a third party provides monthly levels of 6 types of pollution including PM, NOx, VOC but not CO or SOx.
The latest annual report (for 2014) was published on 4 August 2015.
","Yes","No","Marcus Ferbrache","yar michl","45"
"d3a3d20b-7301-4ac8-95a4-b531ee518840","global","2015-09-23T22:55:16","2015","bo","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://www.ine.gob.bo/indice/EstadisticaSocial.aspx?codigo=80101","Excel",,,"Concentración de dióxido de nitrógeno en el aire","Instituto Nacional de Estadística","Yes","Yes","checked ","yaron
its seem some data may exsit for the city of La Paz and Cochabamba
but even if the data exsit its not 3 city (Measured either at a national level by regions or at leasts in 3 big cities)
Source-world health organization Report -2014
the orgiel Submitter link to here the link didnt work When i try it
https://www.ine.gob.bo/indice/EstadisticaSocial.aspx?codigo=80101","Yes","No","Mariana Leyton","yar michl","60"
"7313f8a2-a9b6-4a89-8906-6a42fb0a6db6","global","2015-09-19T19:12:12","2015","pr","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www3.epa.gov/airdata/","CSV",,,"airdata","US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)","Yes","Yes","checked ","The Environmental Protection Agency of the United States montier the data of air Pollutants in in the same site with the USA data
from the USA
Another site of the epa only for pm vale
https://www3.epa.gov/airtrends/pm.html
i didnt see VOCs measurement but i think it shold be
in NATTS (National Air Toxics Trends Stations) that dont look to work in this time","Yes","No","Instituto de Estadísticas de Puerto Rico","yar michl","70"
"c2bcc3cd-2215-481f-ad35-1746a1458ff8","global","2015-09-18T21:57:45","2015","ag","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked ",,"Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","yar michl","0"
"2ea53eb3-b2a2-4652-af38-10ef0ed7281c","global","2015-09-07T18:19:49","2015","qa","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.qsa.gov.qa/eng/publication/Environment/Environment_Statistics_Annual_Report_2013_En.pdf",,,,"Greenhouse Gas Inventory (CO2, CH4, N20, NOx, NMVOC, and SO2) and Ozone Depleting Substances","Qatar Information Exchange ","Yes","Yes","checked","Qatar Information Exchange publishes some data about gas emissions, but this data is very old (2007).
It is worth noting that Qatar is a very small country and it is unlikely that a city level breakdown could be provided for such data.
add by yaron
one city is engeh for Enough for Qatar Because Qatar is a very small country -all air pollution is Monitor except VOCs
from the news
Amid ongoing concern about air pollution in Qatar, a new environmental report shows harmful airborne particles exceeded recommended levels for 159 days of the year in 2012.
The Environment Statistics Annual Report 2013, recently issued by the Ministry of Development, Planning and Statistics, breaks down Qatar’s air quality levels from 2008 until its latest figures in 2012.
It follows data released by the World Health Organization earlier this year, which suggested Doha’s air is among the most polluted in the world.
Pollution
The WHO’s ambient (outdoor) air pollution in cities database 2014 examined air pollution levels in 1,600 cities in 91 countries.
It measures particulate matter, which are small and large droplets in the air. It concluded that Doha had the 12th highest average levels of small and fine particles, known as PM2.5, which can penetrate the respiratory tract and increase the risk of respiratory infections, lung cancer, heart disease and stroke.
According to the US Environment Protection Agency, these particles – which often cannot be seen with the naked eye – are made up of heavy metals and toxic organic compounds, and originate from vehicle exhaust, smelting plants and the burning of organic materials.
Larger particles – PM10 – are mostly caused by dust and smoke. In this category, Doha ranked just outside the top 30.
Standards
While the ministry’s recent report didn’t benchmark Qatar against other countries, it showed that local air pollution levels frequently exceed the WHO’s recommendations as well as Qatar’s own targets, which are more lax than the international standards.
For example, Qatar’s national air quality standards for PM10 are 150 ug/m3 for 24 hours average concentration and 50 ug/m3 for the annual average concentration.
By comparison, the WHO’s standards for PM10 are 50 ug/m3 for the 24-hour average – one third of Qatar’s target – and 20 ug/m3 for the annual average concentration, which is less than half of the national figure.
The MDPS report uses statistics from the Ministry of Environment, which measures air quality at three monitoring stations in Doha – at Qatar University, Aspire Zone and the Mövenpick Hotel on the Corniche.
Levels highest at QU
All three monitoring stations recorded pollution levels above the recommended national and global levels. However, concentration levels of the larger particulates (PM10) were highest at QU station in the north of Doha. That location also recorded the most days when air quality levels did not meet international standards.
Air Quality study - fig14In 2012, the national quality standards were breached on 159 days, or 44 percent of the year
[https://dohanews.co/qatars-air-quality-fails-standards-159-days-year/][1]
[1]: https://dohanews.co/qatars-air-quality-fails-standards-159-days-year/","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","yar michl","35"
"1bf9ed88-b38f-4ba0-b02c-384c80bf1696","global","2015-09-02T16:22:59","2015","iq","emissions","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","There is a study dated to 2004 has some figures for CO, SO2, Pb, and TSP in air pollution in Baghdad published on Ministry of environment website. (https://www.moen.gov.iq/Portals/0/Studies/%D9%85%D8%AA%D8%A7%D8%A8%D8%B9%D8%A9%20%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%AD%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%A7%D8%AA%20%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%85%D8%B1%D8%B6%D9%8A%D8%A9%20%D8%B0%D8%A7%D8%AA%20%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B9%D9%84%D8%A7%D9%82%D8%A9%20%D8%A8%D9%85%D9%84%D9%88%D8%AB%D8%A7%D8%AA%20%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%87%D9%88%D8%A7%D8%A1.pdf)
add by yaron
it seem that some Monitoring may Exist
Enviro' & Industrial Solutions ME provided the Environment Directorate Karbala Governorate their Air Quality Monitoring Network. Ten (10) stations are installed in strategically identified zones as part of the Environment Directorate’s continuous, conscious effort and commitment to protect the environment
https://www.eis-me.com/index.php?id_news=63","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","yar michl","0"
"91335e65-b2f9-4fad-98a7-f2d7b295f220","global","2015-09-27T23:39:26","2015","gy","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","no data seem to be Exist
","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","yar michl","0"
"807c8ef5-129b-469a-9d00-dd36dfe7b83f","global","2015-09-27T11:58:19","2015","tl","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","There are no dedicated department(s) nor ministry found from the official website Government of Timor-Leste https://timor-leste.gov.tl/?lang=en# nor from the list of directories in the official website Ministry of State Administration https://www.estatal.gov.tl/English/Directorates/Director_main.html.","Yes","No","anonymous","yar michl","0"
"676ef2ae-e9c4-4b96-9811-227aac40c5de","global","2015-09-12T14:09:39","2015","dz","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","When we checked this year, the site for the Ministry of Environment was down (https://www.matet.dz/)
add by yaron
the the World Health Organization (WHO) also list Algeria is a Country with no data
[no data in a Survey of WHO from 2014][1]
[1]: https://www.who.int/quantifying_ehimpacts/national/countryprofile/AAP_PM_database_May2014.xls","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","yar michl","0"
"3d0a0b16-d7db-437b-b520-a83b80d00f55","global","2015-09-29T01:45:49","2015","tg","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","no data fond world health organization Survey from 2014
[link][1]
also no data on the net
[1]: https://www.who.int/quantifying_ehimpacts/national/countryprofile/AAP_PM_database_May2014.xls","Yes","No","Richard Komlan Folly","yar michl","0"
"2452ecfa-fff1-4096-acdf-a8ed4e208137","global","2015-10-15T17:11:30","2015","ua","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","its seem only Kiev have data
so the data in not exist-data in not -Measured either at a national level by regions or at leasts in 3 big cities
link][1]
On-going. Now validatating the data for Kiev is available on a daily basis from the Central Geophysical Observatory (ЦЕНТРАЛЬНА ГЕОФІЗИЧНА ОБСЕРВАТОРІЯ - КИЇВ)
[1]: https://aqicn.org/sources/","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","yar michl","0"
"020dcf1b-0fb7-40f7-bd8c-404f8856420c","global","2015-09-09T17:18:23","2015","kw","emissions","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,"Environment Public Authority ","Yes","Yes","checked","There is interactive map shows the air quality on Kuwait official environmental portal (https://www.beatona.net/CMS/index.php?lang=ar)
add by yaron
Air Pollution are Measured link but the data Air Pollution is not Exist What Exist is Air Pollution index(ICA) that is base on the raw data so the data is not Considered Exist Online in the usa the epa give the raw data and index data so the data is ope
link to data on the
https://www.kisr.edu.kw/en/research/environment-and-life-sciences/programs/air-quality-program
https://www.beatona.net/CMS/index.php?searchword=Air&ordering=&searchphrase=all&all=yes&option=com_search&Itemid=112&lang=en","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","yar michl","10"
"8935edc3-560a-4612-b9bb-171775facb25","global","2015-09-26T13:45:11","2015","sd","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","We could not find any data on Ministry Of Environment, Forestry and Physical Development website, also the links in the website are not working (https://www.mepd.gov.sd).
No data on Supreme Council for the Environment and Natural Resources website(https://www.hcenr.net).
","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","yar michl","0"
"c7f00fcc-b528-4d8f-900a-424287370491","global","2015-09-07T17:44:08","2015","qa","budget","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Can not find the data. Accepting the submission. ","The government of Qatar issues the budget through an Emiri decree ( https://www.alarabiya.net/ar/aswaq/economy/2014/03/31/%D9%82%D8%B7%D8%B1-%D8%AA%D8%B9%D8%AA%D9%85%D8%AF-%D8%A3%D8%B6%D8%AE%D9%85-%D9%85%D9%8A%D8%B2%D8%A7%D9%86%D9%8A%D8%A9-%D9%81%D9%8A-%D8%AA%D8%A7%D8%B1%D9%8A%D8%AE%D9%87%D8%A7-%D8%A8%D9%8062-%D9%85%D9%84%D9%8A%D8%A7%D8%B1-%D8%AF%D9%88%D9%84%D8%A7%D8%B1.html ) , however, the actual content of this Emiri decree is not published.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Mor Rubinstein","5"
"a2372a98-0ef5-4d4f-9f82-0accf358052c","global","2015-08-29T15:44:10","2015","om","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.mof.gov.om/https://www.mof.gov.om/",,"https://www.mola.gov.om/eng/websitepolicy.aspx",,"The annual budget of the government of the Sultanate of Oman as published in the official gazette.","Ministry of FinancesMinistry of Finances","Yes","Yes","The website was not working during the review due to technical problem, accepting the submitter submission. ","The annual budget is published in Arabic in the Official Gazette and can be accessed from the website of the Ministry of Finances and the website of the Ministry of Legal Affairs. The budget provides a sector and department level breakdown of estimated expenses and profits. The latest budget documents (2014 and 2015) are only found as PDF files, while previous documents are available in XLS format.
The Annual Budget is issued through a Royal Decree, which is exempt from copyright protection and is there available freely to use, reuse, or to distribute. This is confirmed in Article 4(A) of the Omani Copyright Law (found here: https://www.wipo.int/wipolex/en/text.jsp?file_id=180949 )
Additionally, the same budget document in PDF format could be downloaded from the website of the Ministry of Legal Affairs (Example: https://www.mola.gov.om/Download.aspx?Path=royal/1-2015.pdf ) and the terms and conditions of the website of the Ministry of Legal Affairs clearly state that:
""The website of the Ministry of Legal Affairs contains official documents such as Royal Decrees and Decisions and which are considered part of the public domain excluded from copyright protection and which may be reproduced, republished, and used without restrictions."" (Taken from https://www.mola.gov.om/eng/websitepolicy.aspx )
Note: Arabic is the only official language in Oman and like majority of websites of the Omani government, the English sections of websites are rarely updated and information here is based on the Arabic content.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Mor Rubinstein","75"
"1c1cfbd1-f765-4464-aad2-20b2be0c077a","global","2015-09-12T15:32:39","2015","ma","budget","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,"Ministère de l'économie et des finances","Yes","Yes","Data was sufficient for the criteria. No sub-departments. I have changed the data. ","There is an old data for 2012-2013 in the open data portal:
https://www.data.gov.ma/data/fr/dataset/budget-de-l-etat-des-annees-2012-et-2013
However, it does not have detailed expenditure for sub-departments. It seems like the data does exist but its not available. ","Yes","No","Chadi Nanaa","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"751731f2-a9f3-4176-8c0d-7867dfd7879d","global","2015-09-27T02:05:32","2015","cr","companies","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Unsure","No",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","This entry is uncomplete. There is not a link for checking the entry and not dataset could be found online. ","It can be accessed online but a password or permissions is required.","Yes","No","Alejandro Sanabria","Iris Palma","10"
"1ccaa6af-9fb7-48eb-b932-2297f6107e7d","global","2015-10-09T12:56:35","2015","ae","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.mof.gov.ae/Ar/OpenData/Pages/default.aspx","Excel",,,"Annual budget of the Government of the UAE","The Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","I have review the data that was suggested by the reviewer and it is correct. ","The Ministry of Finance is responsible for the annual budget ( https://www.mof.gov.ae/ ), however, the website does not publish the budget.
The annual budget is issued as a Federation Law which is published in the Official Gazette of the UAE. ( https://www.alittihad.ae/details.php?id=36283&y=2015 ) The Official Gazette can be purchased from the Ministry of Justice and is not available on the internet. ( https://gazette.moj.gov.ae/Introduction.aspx )
Reviewer's Comment:
I was able to find the data on the website for the Ministry of Finance on its Open Data section, it is available for online for free. It is in PDF and XLS format, though not openly licensed. Data is available both as balance and as functional (departments). The balance has expenses as ongoing expenses and assets, each with sub categories. The descriptions provided are very limited though.
https://www.mof.gov.ae/Ar/OpenData/Pages/default.aspx ","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"bc44091e-0363-4106-8173-c19543f3cd46","global","2015-09-17T23:19:02","2015","mx","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://sites.google.com/site/cnetuc/contrataciones","xlsx","https://datos.gob.mx/libreusomx/",,"COMPRANET - Data about contracts from procurement procedures","Ministry of Public Administration","Yes","Yes","Submission updated with link to Open Data license, alternative site to download the bulk file for 2015. ","Public procurement site is [Compranet][1].
Data from 2010 - 2015
https://sites.google.com/site/cnetuc/contrataciones
Data from 2002
https://sites.google.com/site/cnetuc/contratos_cnet_3
[1]: https://compranet.funcionpublica.gob.mx/web/login.html","Yes","Yes","Carlos cc","Georg Neumann","100"
"abdb59b8-f6b2-4d9f-9042-638844cce04e","global","2015-10-02T05:56:15","2015","ml","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.dgmp.gov.ml/index.php/consultations/liste-des-marches-passes/finish/68-liste-des-marches-passes/4499-liste-des-marches-au-03-septembre-2015/0",,,,"Procurement tenders","General Direction of Public Procurement","Yes","Yes","Submission updated. Available in bulk as PDF. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Georg Neumann","55"
"f5171a91-1d21-4a5f-a9f2-4f67be8f7328","global","2015-09-28T14:29:40","2015","ec","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.compraspublicas.gob.ec/ProcesoContratacion/compras/index.php","Proprietary format .ushay",,,,"Servicio Nacional de Contratación Pública","Yes","Yes","Submission correct.","The public procurement portal (Portal de Compras Públicas) gathers information about all procurement processes, budgets and contracts from all government offices. It is required to register as a supplier in order to get access to the data which is published in a proprietary format called Ushay and sometimes in pdf. The supplier agreement states that all rights to publish, reproduce, distribute and transform content from the portal belong to Servicio Nacional de Contratación Pública.","Yes","No","Eduardo Bejar","Georg Neumann","60"
"1935b23c-f6f8-4373-999a-af16711f8d41","global","2015-08-25T06:35:35","2015","my","procurement","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission updated to reflect that the data is not available in full publicly. ","From the ePerolehan official portal, the datasets are not available. Given that ePerolehan is under Ministry of Finance and the institution is in the Federal State territory, submitting for Freedom of Information request is impossible because there is no Freedom of Information Act for the Federal State Wilayah Persekutuan.
","Yes","No","Hazwany Jamaluddin","Georg Neumann","0"
"cd8a87c6-1b4c-4bf0-9fb5-25d5e5fe1f49","global","2015-08-26T21:33:27","2015","il","procurement","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission updated to reflect that award data is not published. ","- Tender RFPs are published but not the awards or the chosen supplier.
- Procurements that get exemption from using a tender (e.g. single supplier contracts etc) are published in a dedicated government website (but not in machine readable form). These kind of procurements make 80% of the total number of procurements.
- Other data (including actual amount executed and small-valued procurements) is not available online but only through FOIA requests. Some work is done in the government level to release a quarterly report of these records, but it remains to be seen if this gets implemented.","Yes","No","Adam Kariv","Georg Neumann","0"
"d38da7b8-ff5e-426e-98b6-1ee5ee994841","global","2015-09-17T15:42:28","2015","im","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.gov.im/media/383300/notification-of-tender-results-17-07-2015.pdf",,"https://www.gov.im/about-this-site/open-government-licence/",,"Notification of Tender Results","Procurement Division, Treasury","Yes","Yes","Submission correct.","The new government digital strategy debated and approved by parliament introduced an expectation that the Open Contracting Data Standard will be adopted, initially in the Department of Infrastructure and then cross-government.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Georg Neumann","75"
"d8972bff-2c12-4bc3-b489-c07514c54114","global","2015-09-27T21:51:30","2015","md","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://tender.gov.md/","XLS, CSV, XML",,,"Requests for offers","Ministry of Finance, Public Procurement Agency","Yes","Yes","Submission updated with information on awarded contracts that is available in machine-readable format. ",,"Yes","No","Victoria Vlad","Georg Neumann","60"
"ad4d4f97-c28d-4e40-a370-7e5192189ae4","global","2015-09-09T07:32:52","2015","kr","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.g2b.go.kr/",,"https://www.g2b.go.kr/gov/koneps/pt/policy/copyright.html",,"Korea ON-line E-Procurement System (KONEPS) - KONEPS is aiming to establish a nationwide web-based procurement system, dealing with whole procurement process including acquisition of all the information on the national procurement projects, procurement request, bids, contracting and payment for 37,000 public organizations and 120,000 private firms.","Public Procurement Service","Yes","Yes","Submission correct.","The Public Procurement Service (PPS) of Korea, Republic of has developed an electronic procurement system called Korea ON-line E-Procurement System (KONEPS). KONEPS is aiming to establish a nationwide web-based procurement system, dealing with whole procurement process including acquisition of all the information on the national procurement projects, procurement request, bids, contracting and payment for 37,000 public organizations and 120,000 private firms.
Although the data provided on the site meets the minimum criteria, it is not available in machine-readable formats, and not available in bulk. The data can only be accessed in HTML formats. Descriptions of tenders and awards are only provided by attached documents. There are [Web APIs][1] that can be used to access the data in machine-readable formats, but they require pre-registration so they are not publicly available.
[1]: https://www.data.go.kr/subMain.jsp#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","Yes","No","James G. Boram Kim","Georg Neumann","75"
"c22c57fd-8ef2-4a3e-bd75-fdb4180951d0","global","2015-09-08T13:57:49","2015","sa","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Approving submission. Can't find references to water quality data collection at national or local levels.","It is unknown if such data exists in Saudi. Saudi has a Ministry for Water and Electricity ( https://www.mowe.gov.sa/ ) who could be responsible for this matter, but no information in regard to water pollution could be found on its website.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Nisha Thompson","0"
"89a73bb5-7d42-4432-87f3-3ca42012bbec","global","2015-09-27T23:37:20","2015","gy","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Approving submission. Couldn't find any reference to water quality data being collected. ","It is uncertain if water quality data exists","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Nisha Thompson","0"
"b6e44857-213d-4035-8d23-d6dd51070077","global","2015-09-27T08:12:36","2015","bo","water","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Unsure","No",,"Unsure",,,,,"Control de calidad de agua","Autoridad de FIscalización y Control Social de Agua","Yes","Yes","Approving submission.","This is the site where the data is, not available to the public: https://www.aaps.gob.bo/?cat=136","Yes","No","Mariana Leyton","Nisha Thompson","10"
"c133fa61-68f9-4faa-99e8-90dab11d22f0","global","2015-08-25T06:51:31","2015","my","water","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Approving submission","There are no datasets available. In Malaysia, there is no centralized water quality management. For an example, there are private institutions such as Syabas Sdn Bhd that covers state level water quality for Selangor.","Yes","No","Hazwany Jamaluddin","Nisha Thompson","0"
"73f24b9e-ae7a-470d-a2ba-baf726bd5e77","global","2015-09-12T09:12:10","2015","iq","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Couldn't find any reference water quality data. Accepting submission.","We could not find anything on the Iraqi Ministry of Environment's website (https://www.moen.gov.iq/), and not on the eGov Portal (https://www.egov.gov.iq/)","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Nisha Thompson","0"
"6ef8a016-e5ea-4a0e-90b4-0909115f96ef","global","2015-09-30T14:16:54","2015","ng","companies","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Based on the information available, I am unsure that the data exists and have marked it as such.","Nigeria's company register is not open. There is a name search facility that allows you to check the availability of company names: https://services.cac.gov.ng/group/customer/name-search No other information is available about data held on companies or how to access it.","Yes","No","Oludotun Babayemi","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"c7d27b61-8197-464c-8f2a-14305e54f3d8","global","2015-09-08T13:34:33","2015","qa","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Accepting submission, site isn't working and couldn't find anything to validate data collection.","Qatar has a Ministry of Environment ( https://twitter.com/qatar_moe - official website does not work ), but it could not be verified if it collects or publishes any data on water quality.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Nisha Thompson","0"
"71b8e45f-5b87-48d3-9e1c-f4aae9ce58ad","global","2015-09-21T18:27:04","2015","us","companies","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,"Unavailable","Individual States","Yes","Yes","Good summary, I have no problem signing off on this. It's the best way of summing up a complex situation.","In the US, corporate registration happens at the state level. The timeliness, availability, and licensing of this data varies among all 50 states. There is no federal dataset that contains all corporate registrations. It would be possible to create a unified open registry for all US corporations (even if only via aggregation from state ones) but this does not exist at this time.
Across those states performance varies widely and in many cases data is not available in bulk, is not machine readable, is not openly licensed etc. For more detail, see the [per state summary on Open Corporates](https://registries.opencorporates.com/jurisdiction/average_us).
","Yes","No","Blessing Jee","Rebecca Sentance","10"
"6f1eec56-dc31-4172-a744-7d065f1a6540","global","2015-09-18T17:37:54","2015","pe","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://www.app.minsa.gob.pe/bsc/detalle_indiscipline?lcind=79&lcobj=15&lcper=12&lcfreg=8/9/2014","HTML",,,,,"Yes","Yes","Changed it to unsure, the link the submitter gave wasn't for water quality but for population that has access to water. Water supply is decentralized so data will be with the local municipals if it is collected. ","Población que cuenta con agua potable conectado a la Red Pública. En el siguiente cuadro estadístico encontraremos información sobre la proporción de hogares con acceso a agua potable por departamento correspondiente al año 2013. ","Yes","No","Victoria Meneses Carriónizette L","Nisha Thompson","0"
"f5030369-3af9-49c5-85db-c0baa331b439","global","2015-10-01T15:48:29","2015","gt","emissions","Yes","Yes","No","No","Yes","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Programa De Calidad Del Aire De INSIVUMEH Para La República De Guatemala","INSIVUMEH","Yes","Yes","checked","Air Pollution are Measured
[enter link description here][1]
but the raw data Air Pollution is not Exist
waht Exist is Air Pollution index(ICA) that is base on the raw data
so the data is not Considered Exist Online
in the usa the epa give the raw data and index data so the data is open
info on AIR QUALITY INDEX of Guatemala(google Translate)
AIR QUALITY INDEX (ICA)
The results are on the map of the country and in other sections of this website are referred to as Index Air Quality (ICA), which is an indicator of how clean or polluted the air at the site of measurement associated the health effects that people may experience in a few hours or days after breathing that air.
The ICA is calculated according to the established form of calculation for the AQI (Air Quality Index) of the EPA, and while not have a national law governing the matter, it will be based on the standards of air quality provided equally by EPA, considering the following parameters: ozone, particles, carbon monoxide, sulfur dioxide and nitrogen dioxide.
The ICA ranges from 0 to 500, where 500 represents the highest level of contamination and therefore the highest risk to health. Generally, a value of 100 corresponds to the Air Quality Limit, so the values less than 100 are considered satisfactory.
When the ICA reaches values above 100, the air quality in the place is considered unhealthy to start for certain sensitive groups of the population, and then for all citizens to the extent that the ICA increases. It is understood as sensitive groups for sick people (especially those with respiratory disease), elderly and children.
[https://www.insivumeh.gob.gt:8080/calidadaire/indiceconcepto.htm][2]
[1]: https://www.insivumeh.gob.gt:8080/calidadaire/red_monitoreo.htm
[2]: https://www.insivumeh.gob.gt:8080/calidadaire/indiceconcepto.htm","Yes","No","Julio Herrera","yar michl","35"
"fda6c664-2c27-4027-bf2f-d96bf0e64e17","global","2015-09-14T18:43:38","2015","sy","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Can't find any information on water quality. Accepting submission of unsure.",,"Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Nisha Thompson","0"
"c6f5456a-e76f-4c68-a360-0d53bb772e30","global","2015-09-12T14:11:00","2015","dz","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Sites are down so unsure. ","When we checked this year, the site for the Ministry of Environment was down (https://www.matet.dz/), so was that of the Ministry of Water Resources (https://www.mre.gov.dz/)","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Nisha Thompson","0"
"8f9a6723-a15a-4624-b913-55bc81254df9","global","2015-09-17T15:16:07","2015","ru","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Changed to unsure. The data is collected at the local level and there are national ministries that are supposed to monitor water quality both drinking and for the ecosystems. Hoowever, can't find data. ","Russia is a huge country and water quality is responsibility of regional governments. Thats why there is no centralized service or dataset for this type of data.","Yes","No","Ivan Begtin","Nisha Thompson","0"
"9aa99fd0-0853-4b5e-b4ed-26e8ea07d89a","global","2015-09-28T21:21:38","2015","sv","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Decentralized, local data collection water supply providers do look at quality.
i.e. https://www.anda.gob.sv/informes/. Can't find overall oversight or central data collection. ","There is a PDF report from 2009: https://www.snet.gob.sv/ver/hidrologia/monitoreo+hidrologico/calidad+de+agua/calidad+de+agua+2009/ but not complete information from the water quality is available. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Nisha Thompson","0"
"b6a7b273-71a2-4161-b48e-43c5b63d9b6e","global","2015-09-24T10:01:03","2015","mk","water","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Couldn't find any water quality data. Submission accepted.",,"Yes","No","Metamorphosis Foundation","Nisha Thompson","0"
"dd3ce226-89b2-4672-866c-6d37ac472e5b","global","2015-09-25T12:01:02","2015","kz","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Yes","Yes","Unsure",,"Yes",,"EXCEL (xls)",,,"Excel documents showing various information about the water: water usage, water quality, substances etc. in cities and regions","Statistics Committee of the Ministry of National Economics","Yes","Yes","Couldn't find actual data on any national sites or local sites but they do collect it. That is why this submission is accepted.
https://stat.gov.kz/faces/homePage/ecolog?_adf.ctrl-state=pzjbbiwke_17&_afrLoop=17329887463495832","Open Data Portal also contains information about Changes of complex index of water pollution in the rivers, reservoirs, lakes and canals of the Republic of Kazakhstan in json format: data.egov.kz. The information provided by government officials in Kazakhstan (by default) is open for reuse, publishing as cited by the law. ","Yes","No","Nazerke Akhmetzhanova","Nisha Thompson","55"
"9c13f02f-8b57-4263-9323-4c8d2d44ff99","global","2015-10-05T18:19:24","2015","ca","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://www.ec.gc.ca/eaudouce-freshwater/default.asp?lang=En&n=EFDA57C6-1","WMS, WFS",,,"Fresh Water Quality Monitoring & Surveillance","Environment Canada","Yes","Yes","Drinking water data is available at the municipal level, but all the variables are available for fresh water sources. This submissions is accurate.","Canada as a federation has divisions of powers and responsibilities. At the national level, at the national level Environment Canada has the following responsibilities:
""The Fresh Water Quality Monitoring & Surveillance Division focuses on regular monitoring, surveillance and reporting on fresh water quality, and aquatic ecosystem status and trends. These activities help to:
- Assess threats to fresh water quality and aquatic ecosystems in areas of national and international interest, including the Great Lakes-St. Lawrence River Basin, the Lake Winnipeg Basin, and the Lower Athabasca River (oil sands area)
-Meet federal commitments related to transboundary watersheds (rivers and lakes crossing international, inter-provincial and territorial borders)
- Support the development , implementation, and assessment of federal regulations including the Chemical Management Plan, the Clean Air Regulatory Agenda, and the Federal Sustainable Development Strategy.""
For other fresh water quality data, information seekers would need to contact provincial and municipal authorities.
The data that are available is of varying quality and formats and are made accessible through an interactive tool, GENIE:
https://genie.qc.ec.gc.ca/wqmsd_en.aspx
There are commercial restrictions on the re-use of data: https://ec.gc.ca/default.asp?lang=En&xml=5830C36B-1773-4E3E-AF8C-B21F54633E0A","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Nisha Thompson","60"
"61d075d8-ba6c-4aba-96ad-54e21beac041","global","2015-09-06T22:46:41","2015","pt","weather","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Yes",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The open license question was changed to 'no' based on the dataset not being available for commercial use.
Otherwise, the submission is accepted as is.
","[IPMA][1] is the entity responsible for weather monitoring.
10-day forecasts are available in the [Forecast page][2], fulfilling all requirements of this category for weather forecasts.
However, there is no apparent reference to a comprehensive historical temperature dataset. There are [monthly charts/maps][3] available, but not daily data. I've inquired on their website to see if there's anything.
The [license terms][4] forbid commercial use.
[1]: https://ipma.pt
[2]: https://www.ipma.pt/pt/otempo/prev.localidade/index.jsp
[3]: https://www.ipma.pt/en/oclima/monitorizacao/index.jsp?selTipo=m
[4]: https://www.ipma.pt/pt/siteinfo/index.html?page=index.xml","Yes","No","Ricardo Lafuente","Neal Bastek","20"
"6400b3bb-35d9-44ef-b5e6-292f03054480","global","2015-09-28T11:09:30","2015","ge","weather","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"https://meteo.gov.ge/","Ministry of Environment","Yes","Yes","The submission is accepted because the data does exist.","Only current data is available, and not in machine-readable format. Information going back a year is available for purchase only.
https://meteo.gov.ge/","Yes","No","Eric Barrett","Neal Bastek","20"
"ec700c84-0352-4d94-ae92-feb0e15197ab","global","2015-09-28T15:10:55","2015","py","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.meteorologia.gov.py/",,,,,"https://www.meteorologia.gov.py/","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 5 days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.","The data exists at the ""Dirección Nacional de Aeronautica Civil - Dirección de Meteorología e Hidrología""
They have several types of sensors distributed in the country [1] with several types of readings [2].
In the homepage of the agency [3], there is information about the current weather, and a 5-day weather forecast, in HTML format.
However, the Presidential Decree 8701/2012 establishes a payment for accessing this information. The current cost is 7,70 U$D [2] for
accessing the daily registry for each parameter by month by location.
References:
- [1] https://www.meteorologia.gov.py/adm/uploads/ESTACIONES.pdf
- [2] https://www.meteorologia.gov.py/serviciopublico.php
- [3] https://www.meteorologia.gov.py/","Yes","No","Juan Pane","Neal Bastek","30"
"0824fa48-a35d-4d1e-ae2c-069bb033dc6f","global","2015-09-17T15:08:07","2015","ru","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.meteoinfo.ru",,,,"Meteorology forecast ","Federal Service for Hydrometeorology and Environmental Monitoring of Russia (Roshydromet","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 3 days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.","Federal Service for Hydrometeorology and Environmental Monitoring of Russia (Roshydromet) is government agency responsible to collect and provide information about meteorology in Russian Federation.
They have subsidiary enterprise ""FGBU GVC Roshydromet"" that maintain website www.meteoinfo.ru with infromation about weather forecast.
This information is up to date, not openly licenced, not available for bulk download, is free, is public.
","Yes","No","Ivan Begtin","Neal Bastek","45"
"426be765-f0a1-4eeb-b1a7-c78432cdf5c1","global","2015-09-25T11:48:04","2015","kz","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked
its seem that Originally the The criticism is of incorrect information Pollution
What was originally written
There are datasets about level of pollution of settlements, radiation state of surface air, the density of radioactive fallout in the surface layer of the atmosphere, changes of complex index of water pollution in the rivers, reserviours, lakes and canals. The information provided by government officials in Kazakhstan (by default) is open for reuse, publishing as cited by the law. ","No data is available online for air pollution
but it seem the data is Measured -no pm data Exist so the data
is Considered non-existent
https://www.unece.org/fileadmin/DAM/env/epr/epr_studies/kazakhstan.pdf
The four basic pollutants (SO2, CO, NO2 and dust)
are monitored, as are some site-specific pollutants
such as heavy metals, HF, HCl, NH3, arsine,
phenol, formaldehyde and chlorine. There are no
ground-level ozone monitoring data available. Data
on lead and other heavy metals as well as
benzo(a)pyrene, which were monitored regularly in
the past, are scarce at present. No information on
PM 10 or PM 2.5 is available.
Air quality is assessed according to the so-called
IZA5 indexes, which record the exceeding of
maximum permissible concentrations (MPCs) of
five representative pollutants, together with their
toxicity classes. The air is considered polluted, if
this index is higher than 5. As shown in table 4.6,
air quality has improved slightly in recent years,
but still needs to be improved in most cities.
Moreover, due to a lack of money monitoring has
suffered some inconsistency over the past years,
reducing the number of monitoring sites as well as
the number of monitored pollutants. The indexes
are therefore not always calculated from the same
set of pollutants, and this may result in
inconsistency. For example, if in Almaty
benzo(a)pyrene, also in the highest toxicity class,
was included in calculations of the IZA5 index, it
would amount to 54. When benzo(a)pyrene was no
longer measured, the value of the index fell, but
this does not necessarily mean that air quality in
fact improved. ","Yes","No","Nazerke Akhmetzhanova","yar michl","0"
"804df1d2-6f16-4bcb-bfcf-2b997e7df52e","global","2015-09-27T22:24:28","2015","md","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.meteo.md/",,,,,"State Hydrometeorological Service","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 5+ days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.",,"Yes","No","Victoria Vlad","Neal Bastek","45"
"da784ecb-a5af-46cf-991e-1540161ab754","global","2015-09-16T18:23:37","2015","be","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.meteo.be/meteo/view/en/123492-Weather+Models.html",,,,"Forecast of temperature, wind and precipitation.","The Royal Meteorological Institute of Belgium","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 3+ days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.","For now, the RMI provides little information and only up to 36 hours in advance. There seems to be no historical temperature data.
In the nearby future, more data will be opened up since the RMI is a state owned company and thus should open it its data by default. (https://www.openknowledge.be/2015/07/24/green-light-for-the-belgian-federal-open-data-strategy/)","Yes","No","Deraesara L","Neal Bastek","45"
"197405f5-4edb-4974-bb14-aaa52912070c","global","2015-09-28T09:10:06","2015","it","weather","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Unsure","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Ministery of Defense - military aviation","Ministero della difesa","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 4 days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.","The data shall be available upon request, at this address.
https://www.meteoam.it/dati_in_tempo_reale
The issue is at the discretion of the service.
The data can not be used for profit.","Yes","No","Maurizio Napolitano","Neal Bastek","20"
"e51d4076-722c-4cc3-9f6b-b4be49ada364","global","2015-09-27T09:03:22","2015","lv","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.meteo.lv/laiks/?nid=557",,,,,"VSIA ","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 5+ days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.",,"Yes","No","Toms Ceļmillers","Neal Bastek","45"
"e9000be5-3dcc-47df-8815-d300fec73913","global","2015-10-01T09:02:02","2015","bj","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.finances.bj/IMG/pdf/loi_de_finances_2015.pdf",,,,"Loi de finance 2015. ","DIRECTION GENERALE du BUDGET / Ministère de l'Economie et des Finances","Yes","Yes","Data is correct. ","The budget is regularly published by the general director of budget. The published format is not machine readable, but the excel one can be requested from the publisher. The budget is accessible for free","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","55"
"5bd55598-e334-4479-b6d9-4d6f3baf01a9","global","2015-09-17T12:25:24","2015","ly","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","The government does not provide any information on the air quality and currently the website of the Ministry of Health and Environment is down (https://www.health.gov.ly/) ","Yes","No","Maraim Elbadri","yar michl","0"
"dfeb072a-05b3-44fd-9bc2-dba20f32b3b8","global","2015-09-28T13:13:10","2015","gg","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.gov.gg/CHttpHandler.ashx?id=92605&p=0","PDF",,,"2015 Budget","Treasury and Resources Department, treasury@gov.gg","Yes","Yes","Submission is correct. Approved. ","all budget documents:
https://www.gov.gg/article/1780/Search?q=budget&go=Search ","Yes","No","Marcus Ferbrache","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"8928640c-2340-4879-b915-4c168fe8c5a8","global","2015-09-25T12:57:50","2015","al","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.mjedisi.gov.al/al/programi/uje-dhe-ajer/ajri-dhe-zhurmat",,,,"Air Quality","Ministry of Environment","Yes","Yes","checked","This data is not provided on timely. It does not provide a whole view of the problematic areas.
add by yaron
for a site of eu its say in Albania air pollting is been monitor
[https://www.eea.europa.eu/soer/countries/al/air-pollution-state-and-impacts-albania][1]
also in next pdf its say the Six months report
[https://www.eionet.europa.eu/aqportal/pmeet/AQDspec1/Albania][2]
[1]: https://www.eea.europa.eu/soer/countries/al/air-pollution-state-and-impacts-albania
[2]: https://www.eionet.europa.eu/aqportal/pmeet/AQDspec1/Albania","Yes","No","Blerta Tuci","yar michl","35"
"043ca17b-1a32-49be-854e-1105d0207bd7","global","2015-09-30T12:04:00","2015","ky","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.mof.gov.ky/portal/page/portal/pfehome/publications/2015-16-Budget/2015-16-Budget-Address","PDF",,,"Ministry of Finance & Economic Development","Cayman Islands Government","Yes","Yes","The copyright is © Crown Copyright, therefore it is not open. Data is correct. "," ","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Mor Rubinstein","55"
"c9b0ba61-1221-4abc-9c14-69e524125140","global","2015-09-28T08:09:14","2015","mm","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","No evidence showing from the President's Officer website that the data is exist. https://www.myanmarpresidentoffice.info/en/ and the dedicated webpage for the cabinet ministries is empty https://www.myanmarpresidentoffice.info/en/?q=cabinet/ministries so no way to find out who are the responsible minister involve. I have found a 3rd party website https://www.ourweb.info/01/directory/myanmar/005/ that provide a list of ministries official websites but some of these websites are not found.
Kindly note that there is a high possibility that Myanmar government did not update each of these ministries websites so there is an error while trying to gain access to these websites.
add by yaron
its seem that in Yangon a city in Myanmar air pollution is measured
but its only in 1 city so the data dont exist
[https://www.mmtimes.com/index.php/national-news/yangon/15567-yangon-air-pollution-measured-just-above-who-guidelines.html][1]
[1]: https://www.mmtimes.com/index.php/national-news/yangon/15567-yangon-air-pollution-measured-just-above-who-guidelines.html","Yes","No","anonymous","yar michl","0"
"d4edf6c5-400e-4160-a95e-f3a21bd1f23d","global","2015-08-29T02:02:41","2015","np","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://mof.gov.np/uploads/document/file/Red%20Book%20FY%202014-15_20140917050612.pdf",,,,"National Budget of Nepal for the year 2072/73","Ministry of Finance ","Yes","Yes","The data is correct. Added the English version of the data. ",,"Yes","No","Nikesh Balami","Mor Rubinstein","55"
"4e6466ff-1082-45e7-a591-29ed8ba1585d","global","2015-10-07T01:47:19","2015","cn","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://yss.mof.gov.cn/2015czys/index.htm",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Data is correct. Approved.","The Ministry of Finance is responsible for publishing the central government's annual budget. Each central ministries and agencies is responsible for publishing own annual budget. For instance, the Ministry of Education's budget is here https://old.moe.gov.cn/publicfiles/business/htmlfiles/moe/s7499/201504/186043.html, the Ministry of Industry and Information Technology's budget is here https://www.miit.gov.cn/n11293472/n11505629/n11506258/n11965324/16721631.html","Yes","No","OKFN CN","Mor Rubinstein","55"
"e9737557-5f16-4f93-9ade-013588df1835","global","2015-10-21T17:02:35","2015","ge","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://mof.ge/GovBudget",,,,"Budgets and budget documents since 2004, including the 2014 budget approved by Parliament and the draft 2015 budget","Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","changed the bulk definition. Submission approved.","Most of the data is made available in PDF files, although some Excel files are available; therefore, the data is overall not machine-readable.
All government-generated data is legally public domain in Georgia, although the Ministry of Finance website specifies that it is Copyright 2015 the Ministry of Finance. No specific license for the dataset is provided, however.","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","55"
"df62d43f-1109-4697-bf7f-033874dafe0c","global","2015-10-13T14:23:50","2015","ci","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.budget.gouv.ci/fr/budget/budget-2015",,,,"La Loi de Finance Portant Budget d'Etat Pour l'Annee 2015","Ministere Aupres du Premier Ministre Charge de L'Economie et la Finance","Yes","Yes","Approved. There is data about sub-departments/programs expenditures. ","The attached PDF provides high level figures but no details. Additional data on the 2014 budget can be found in the following documents:
- Exécution budgétaire fin mars 2014 annexes: https://www.budget.gouv.ci/assets/files/ccm/2-execution-budgetaire-fin-mars-2014-annexes.pdf
- Exécution Budgétaire à fin juin 2014 https://www.budget.gouv.ci/assets/files/ccm/execution-budgetaire-a-fin-juin-2014.pdf
- CCM budget septembre 2014 https://www.budget.gouv.ci/assets/files/ccm/ccm-budget-septembre-2014.pdf
Additionally, I was able to find more granular budget data for 2015
- Budget 2015: https://www.budget.gouv.ci/assets/files/ccm/7-ccm-budget-2015.pdf","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"95dd814c-0c29-49f5-ab12-edce8b092c67","global","2015-10-03T07:48:47","2015","gn","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.finances.gov.gn/images/stories/Documents/LFI2015.pdf",,,,"finance law 2015","Ministry of finences","Yes","Yes","Approved this submission. The budget had data on sub departments. ","The budget is available online on the website of the ministry of finance as pdf document. there is no evidence about the availability in machine readable format or open license.
Note- the PDF is a scanned version of the budget.","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"062bb7b5-bd4c-4325-8ae1-08f02367ca5d","global","2015-10-13T21:00:37","2015","tg","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"No","https://finances.gouv.tg/images/Budget/Budget_Chap_2014.pdf",,,,"Adoption du budget 2015 : Le projet est équilibré en recettes et en dépenses à 806,193,192,000 Fcfa. Les ressources comme les dépenses, connaissent un accroissement de 11,5% par rapport au budget révisé de 2014.","Site Republic Of Togo","Yes","Yes","there is a budget, it is just not updated. I have changed the submission accordingly. ","QA review note - The budget on the government website was published in PDF and it is dated for 2014. No budget for 2015 was found -https://finances.gouv.tg/images/Budget/Budget_Chap_2014.pdf","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"5fe1c8b4-3e4d-4e2a-900d-e665a3bbed71","global","2015-09-10T08:56:48","2015","kr","weather","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Unsure","No","No",,"Yes","https://web.kma.go.kr/eng/weather/forecast/timeseries.jsp",,,,,"The Korea Meteorological Administration (KMA) ","Yes","Yes","This submission was altered to indicate that the data does in fact exist. It's accepted on the basis of the dataset containing 3 days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation. Historical data is also available for the previous year.
","The Korea Meteorological Administration (KMA) provides only [3 days forecast][1] of temperature, precipitation, and wind. For [5 days forecast][2], they only provide weather and temperature information. The same data is available in machine-readable formats via [Web APIs][3], but it requires the pre-registration step.
Recorded data for temperature, precipitation, and wind for the last year or so is available on the site called ""[National Climate Data Service System (NCDSS)][4],"" and it is publicly available in machine-readable formats.
All the datasets are not openly licensed, but copyrighted by KMA.
[1]: https://web.kma.go.kr/eng/weather/forecast/timeseries.jsp
[2]: https://web.kma.go.kr/eng/weather/forecast/mid-term.jsp
[3]: https://web.kma.go.kr/info_open/public_data/request.jsp
[4]: https://sts.kma.go.kr/eng/jsp/home/contents/main/main.do","Yes","No","James G. Boram Kim","Neal Bastek","25"
"2355da92-1c1b-4321-830e-d50806b31f75","global","2015-09-27T14:42:15","2015","id","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://data.go.id/dataset/prakiraan-cuaca-kota-kabupaten-di-indonesia-hari-ini-dan-esok","xml","https://opendefinition.org/licenses/cc-by/",,,,"Yes","Yes","This submission has been altered to state that the data does not exist on the basis that the dataset provided only includes 2 days of forecast data (today and tomorrow). https://data.go.id/dataset/prakiraan-cuaca-kota-kabupaten-di-indonesia-hari-ini-dan-esok",,"Yes","No","Farraz Theda","Neal Bastek","0"
"8dc84556-4be5-4702-a4ac-f5a5dcaa77d5","global","2015-09-17T15:47:45","2015","im","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.gov.im/weather/5-day-forecast/",,"https://www.gov.im/about-this-site/open-government-licence/",,"5 day forecast","Met Office, Ronaldsway Airport, Isle of Man Government","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 5 days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Neal Bastek","75"
"fa662920-13ed-46b0-a126-7d3d05088328","global","2015-10-03T14:05:14","2015","se","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Unsure",,"Yes","https://opendata-catalog.smhi.se/explore/","CSV, Excel, GRIB-format,",,,,"Swedish Meteorological and Hydrological Institute (SMHI)","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 10 days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.","SMHI is an authority under the Ministry of the Environment and Energy.
Is the data available for free?: I am not sure what parts are not free, however, on this link https://opendata-catalog.smhi.se/explore/, on the upper right corner you can press ""Beställningar""/Orders. Where you contact them with the sole purpose of purchasing data.
","Yes","No","Asmen Gül","Neal Bastek","45"
"480881c6-75ec-4910-a8d0-62664a9ac7fd","global","2015-09-28T13:48:17","2015","py","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.hacienda.gov.py/portalspir/","CSV,HTML,EXCEL,PDF,TSV","https://www.presidencia.gov.py/archivos/documentos/DECRETO4064_6b26wnlx.pdf",,"Portal de Reportes Financieros, Base de datos BOOST, Gastos - Administración Central y Entidades Descentralizadas","Ministerio de Hacienda - Sub Secretaría de Estado de Administración Financiera ,spir@hacienda.gov.py","Yes","Yes","I have checked the data and it is correct. ","The data available at the SPIR portal [1] is provided with low granular level, it not seems to be complete but it is up-to-date and well formatted. It is also easy to share. Howerver, it only works on Firefox.
There is another tools maintained by the Ministerio de Hacienda, called the Boost database [3] that contains budget information from 2003 until 2014.
About the license, the Paraguayan FOI law[3], and the presidential decree that regulares this law [4] establishes an open license for the budget data.
References:
[1] https://www.hacienda.gov.py/portalspir/
[2] https://isdatabank.info/boost_paraguay/
[3] Law 5282/2014. https://www.gacetaoficial.gov.py/uploads/pdf/2014/2014-09-19/gaceta_2549_EIIHKKDJCCCGFKKBGBGGBJAFIHIEIIIBGGJFGCDI.pdf
[4] https://www.presidencia.gov.py/archivos/documentos/DECRETO4064_6b26wnlx.pdf ","Yes","Yes","Juan Pane","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"71f8e975-5da9-4a77-8a53-7a00e428a525","global","2015-09-30T16:09:53","2015","tz","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.mof.go.tz/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=1050:executive-budget-proposal-2015-2016-as-passed-by-national-assembly&catid=20:budget-books&Itemid=205",,,,"Executive Budget Proposal 2015-2016","Ministry of Finance - Tanzania","Yes","Yes","Could not find machine readable version of this data. Data is correct and has detailed expenditure or sub departments. ","The dataset exists in the ministry of finance partially.","Yes","No","Joachim Mangilima","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"6dbf1a7f-4311-4e71-b730-ce518cda9840","global","2015-09-25T11:30:10","2015","fi","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://budjetti.vm.fi/indox/tae//2015/valtiovarainministerionKanta_taet_2015.jsp","CSV, xml","https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/",,,"Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","Amended link to data. The rest of the submission is correct. Data is in bulk since all data is in one link. ","The data is available since 2014 in CSV and XML. The data asset is also available on Finnish data portal Avoindata.fi.
On the page ( https://budjetti.vm.fi/indox/index.jsp ) data is available in PDF and HTML but not in CSV, XLS or neither through API. The page is hosted by Ministry of Finance. The main datasets are the ones Government proposes to the Parliament. The Parliament amends the budget perioidically. See the discussion in Finnish: https://avoindata.net/245/onko-valtion-budjettidata-saatavilla-avoimena-ja-milloin
Machine readable data for 2015 can be found here - https://budjetti.vm.fi/indox/opendata-csv.jsp","Yes","Yes","Margit Suurhasko","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"49f292f8-54dd-43b8-a090-21e6fa99008d","global","2015-09-07T17:42:12","2015","kw","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"No","https://www.mof.gov.kw/MofBudget/PDF/Report2015_2014.pdf",,,,"Explanatory note to the budget","Ministry of finance","Yes","Yes","I have checked this submission and it is correct. The data meet the criteria and has sub-departments estimates. The budget is not timely and relevant to 2014 mid 2015. ","The data format is PDF","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"4cead868-004d-4dad-ab19-789813aece3d","global","2015-09-26T12:56:38","2015","sd","budget","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Annual Budget of Sudan","Ministry of Finance and National Economy","Yes","Yes","I have added the comment about the budget resources. Links to the digital forms of the budget are not working, therefore I marked publicly available as 'NO'. ","There is evidence that Sudan has an annual budget that is prepared in a formal format and gets approved by the Cabinet ( https://www.sudan.gov.sd/index.php/ar/events/details/1/789/%D9%85%D8%AC%D9%84%D8%B3-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%88%D8%B2%D8%B1%D8%A7%D8%A1-%D9%8A%D8%AC%D9%8A%D8%B2-%D9%85%D8%B4%D8%B1%D9%88%D8%B9-%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%85%D9%88%D8%A7%D8%B2%D9%86%D8%A9-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B9%D8%A7%D9%85%D8%A9-%D9%84%D9%84%D8%B9%D8%A7%D9%85-2015%D9%85#.VgaVFo9Viko ), but it could not be determined in what format it is available or if available online at all. The website of the Ministry of Finance of Sudan could not be found and the website of the Central Bank of Sudan ( https://www.cbos.gov.sd/ ) is offline.
Budgets are supposed to be found here, https://www.mof.gov.sd/doc_view... but links not working.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Mor Rubinstein","20"
"ebbec1aa-c8be-4328-ba2b-849be9fad4f5","global","2015-10-14T15:50:12","2015","sy","budget","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,,"Prime Minister Office","Yes","Yes","It seems that there is a budget, but the details about departments and sub-departments expenditure is not available. ","Sadeek: The data published on web pages.
The data for 2013 and previous years can be fond at Ministry of finance website (https://www.syrianfinance.gov.sy/arabic/budget/q-and-a.html).
QA Reviewers comment
Since last budget was in 2013, I don't think this dataset meets the minimum requirements. Initial submission was by Sadeek
Sadeek later comment:
last data for 2014 on Presidency of the Council of Ministers website, pls take a look on the link i provided in my submission www.pministry.gov.sy/contents/... so the data meet the needed criteria . However the data for previous years can be fond at Ministry of finance website (https://www.syrianfinance.gov.s... as i mentioned.
QA Reviewer Comment:
It came up that data is available for this year, yet in textual format, and it wasn't clear at first if it is actually the whole budget .
Reviewer's notes - this does not meet the criteria since it does not specify sub departments expenditure. It seems from the websites that the data exist but is unavailable. ","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Mor Rubinstein","15"
"17dde8ea-93af-4889-8230-5764dd33664c","global","2015-09-22T16:00:52","2015","sn","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.dpee.sn/",,,,,"Direction Générale des Finance / Ministère de l'Economie et des Finances","Yes","Yes","Data is meeting the criteria and including sub departments budget. I have accepted the submission. "," According to Genova, no change from 2014. ","Yes","No","Mamadou Diagne","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"2f426b2c-1fd6-4ec3-8c68-80d5b5e51c9c","global","2015-09-27T16:22:45","2015","ms","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://finance.gov.ms/?p=879",,,,"Ministry of Finance","Government of Montserrat","Yes","Yes","I have checked the data and it is correct and meet the criteria, including sub departments budgeting. ",,"Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"4970dffd-373a-4625-a60f-ffe22d0634c6","global","2015-09-28T15:55:33","2015","es","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.aemet.es/","XML, HTML or PDF","https://www.aemet.es/es/nota_legal",,"Predicción por municipios: Weather forecast by locations includes: 7 days forecast of temperature, wind and precipitation updated daily: https://www.aemet.es/es/eltiempo/prediccion/municipios . Climatological summaries: https://www.aemet.es/es/serviciosclimaticos/vigilancia_clima/resumenes?w=0&datos=0. Historical temperatura average: https://www.aemet.es/es/conocermas/publicaciones/detalles/Valores_normales. Seasonal analysis: https://www.aemet.es/es/serviciosclimaticos/vigilancia_clima/analisis_estacional. Climate atlas: https://www.aemet.es/es/serviciosclimaticos/datosclimatologicos/atlas_climatico","Agencia Estatal de Meteorología (AEMET) - contact: https://sede.aemet.gob.es/AEMET/es/GestionPeticiones/NuevaConsulta","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 5+ days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.","Weather forecast by locations includes: 7 days forecast of temperature, wind and precipitation updated daily with XML download ","Yes","Yes","datosgob .","Neal Bastek","90"
"8d4b7c48-a8b7-4e1c-86fe-d55c8f2c4229","global","2015-10-14T18:15:50","2015","th","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.bb.go.th/bbhome/page.asp?option=content&dsc=ҳѧ%E0%A2%BB&folddsc=29001",,,,,"Bureau of the Budget","Yes","Yes","Changed to not openly licensed. The rest of the submission is correct and meets the criteria. ","Bureau of the Budget responsible on publishing the budget. The budget for year N will normally published in September or October of year N-1.
Data is not openly licensed © 2015 สำนักงบประมาณ. All Rights Reserved.","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"da59f1f2-e890-4b15-9721-68faed2269bf","global","2015-08-27T14:59:28","2015","cl","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.meteochile.gob.cl/inicio.php","HTML","https://www.dgac.gob.cl/portalweb/rest-portalweb/jcr/repository/collaboration/sites%20content/live/dgac/documents/DR-POL-PRIVA_web-20141215.pdf",,"Register of weather information: recorded and systematized data about weather conditions.","Chilean Meteorological Office","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 3 days of forecast data for temperature, wind and precipitation.","difficult access to historical climate data.","Yes","Yes","Diego Ignacio","Neal Bastek","90"
"4c88cecb-f5f7-4078-9fd0-83c3d672498b","global","2015-09-28T23:37:50","2015","pa","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.mef.gob.pa/es/informes/Documents/PQI%202011-2015.pdf",,,,"Five years investment plan","Ministry of Finance Panama","Yes","Yes","I have checked the data and it's fit the dataset definition. ","Various budget data are to be found on the Ministry of Finance website. There is no annual document with expenditures and revenues planned but you can find for instance yearly updated investment plan for next 5 years in pdf format. Data are quite aggregated though.","Yes","No","HAMZAH HAJI","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"2a7bddfc-0f8e-474e-a1f9-b8ee2b43a191","global","2015-09-28T06:07:43","2015","ua","budget","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,"National Budget of Ukraine 2015","Yes","Yes","I have changed the source of the data from the parliament to the ministry of finance. ","Reviewer's note - I have altered the original submission. The budget can be found on the ministry of finance website. It is in a high level and does not explain the sub department planned expenditure (Although is does states what are the sub department. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"fa8a3786-06e0-4b3f-9b90-a78b3218df4c","global","2015-09-20T19:45:50","2015","es","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.sepg.pap.minhap.gob.es/sitios/sepg/es-ES/Presupuestos/ProyectoPGE/Paginas/ProyectoPGE2016.aspx",,"https://datos.gob.es/?q=avisolegal_tipo",,"Proyecto Presupuestos Generales del Estado 2016","Ministerio de Hacienda y Administraciones Públicas","Yes","Yes","I have accepted the comment that the data has an open license. I recommend to put the license in a more prominent place on the budget website. "," The Government Budget for the upcoming year is freely available to download in bulk as a collection of PDF files from the [SEPG website][1].
There's no machine readable version either in the SEPG or in the [Spanish Open Data Portal][2].
A good example of what the open data version of the spanish national bugget would be is available to download as CSV on [dondevanmisimpuestos.es][4], a social project byt the NGO [Fundación Civio][3].
[1]: https://www.sepg.pap.minhap.gob.es/sitios/sepg/es-ES/Presupuestos/ProyectoPGE/Paginas/ProyectoPGE2016.aspx
[2]: https://datos.gob.es/catalogo/presupuesto?solrsort=ds_created%20desc&f%5B0%5D=im_field_organismo_propietario:1497&f%5B1%5D=im_field_conj_tema:125
[3]: https://civio.es
[4]: https://dondevanmisimpuestos.es","Yes","No","José Félix Ontañón","Mor Rubinstein","85"
"89115efe-1884-4387-bcb7-3fa69f66919c","global","2015-08-27T09:58:59","2015","je","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.vote.je/election-results-2014/",,,,"2014 general electoral results","States Greffe statesgreffe@gov.je","Yes","Yes"," Elections results in a poll station level is available only in HTML. Changed machine readable to no. ","The www.vote.je site is the official source of the election results and was set up by the States Greffe.
The main (horizontal) menu on the www.vote.je site also provides access to the 2011 and 2013 results (though they do not provide quite as much detail e.g. spoiled papers)
There have been no major elections in 2015 as the parliament has moved to a 4-year term of office for all its elected members and there have been no by-elections at the time of submission.","Yes","No","Marcus Ferbrache","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"202c9ffc-e776-45e5-a3cd-9448ed4a01cc","global","2015-08-27T09:20:26","2015","je","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.jerseylaw.je/",,,,"Jersey Law website","Jersey Legal Information Board, Sue du Feu s.dufeu@gov.je ","Yes","Yes","I have checked the data and it is correct. ","legislation as enacted and as amended ","Yes","No","Marcus Ferbrache","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"a1d2182d-a72e-4efd-9089-c045216c8df4","global","2015-08-27T09:48:25","2015","je","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.statesassembly.gov.je/AssemblyPropositions/2015/P.72-2015%20FULL%20PLAN.pdf",,,,"DRAFT MEDIUM TERM FINANCIAL PLAN 2016-2019","Treasury and Resources","Yes","Yes","I have checked the data and it is correct. ","The annual business plans are described at https://www.gov.je/government/planningperformance/strategicplanning/pages/statesannualbusinessplan.aspx
The link to the data is to the plan for 2016-2019, with only 2016 broken down in detail.
The web page also provides access to the 2013-2015 plan.
The copyright catchall and the terms and conditions do not encourage commercial and non-commercial reuse at present but the data *may* become available under an open licence in 2016 as part of an open data strategy.
","Yes","No","Marcus Ferbrache","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"f432ebcc-1c54-4602-ba5c-99093ca39712","global","2015-09-28T09:05:12","2015","bf","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Unsure","Yes",,"Yes",,,,,"Proposition budgétaire, gestion 2016. This represente the budget for 2016 proposed but the ministry of finance, but not yet adopted by the parliament","Direction Générale du Budget","Yes","Yes","Website is down. Accepted data from submitter. ","The budget is prepared by the ministry of finance (through the general direction of budget) that submit it to the adoption of the national assembly. For now, the budget have been prepared by the ministry of finance but not yet adopted by the national assembly. Normally, even if it is not yet adopted, it is available on the website of the general direction, but the website is down for now.","Yes","No","Idriss TINTO","Mor Rubinstein","50"
"0140dbef-4e3a-4da6-99ee-7ddb24d9da03","global","2015-09-12T12:48:08","2015","dz","budget","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Rapport de presentation de la loi de finances pour 2015","Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","Could not find sub department expenditure data. Marked data as publicly unavailable. ","The budget can be found in the annex of this document (https://www.dgpp-mf.gov.dz/images/stories/PDF/RPLF/RPLF2015.pdf), previous years' budgets are also available on ""INFORMATIONS > Documentation > Publications et Rapports > Rapports""
Reviewer's note: The budge above is only in departmental level and does not show department budget. This does not meet the criteria of this dataset. Therefore - data exist but it is not publicly available. ","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Mor Rubinstein","20"
"d3d9918b-d136-4152-9986-5bf6ad635cac","global","2015-09-24T09:44:37","2015","mk","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.finance.gov.mk/mk/node/575","XML",,,"Budget","Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","Machine readable version was working. Changed the answer to Yes. ","PDF files that contain information on the government's budget for a given year can be found on the website of the Ministry of Finance. Data is available since 2008. A link to an XML file of the Budget exists but it's broken.
Reviewer's note - I was able to access the XML file in this address - https://www.finance.gov.mk/files/u6/budzet%202015.xml Therefore I changed the machine readable section to Yes. ","Yes","No","Metamorphosis Foundation","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"fd0f2d50-3816-46c7-bda5-42734d712ac9","global","2015-10-21T09:12:20","2015","kz","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.minfin.gov.kz/irj/portal/anonymous?NavigationTarget=ROLES://portal_content/mf/kz.ecc.roles/kz.ecc.anonymous/kz.ecc.anonymous/kz.ecc.anonym_budgeting/budgeting/planing_fldr","EXCEL (xls)",,,"Word and excel files of planned expenditure for upcoming year, updated when changes are made. The expenditures are divided by sections and administrators (Ministries and local officials). Usually published at Fall and updated within 2 weeks after being published.","The Ministry of Finance of Republic of Kazakhstan","Yes","Yes","I have reviewed the data and it is correct. ","The information provided by government officials in Kazakhstan (by default) is open for reuse, publishing as cited by the law. The website provides information about approved law of budget spending for upcoming years as well as project of such law.
Reviewer's note - the site has the following text in the bottom -
All rights reserved
© 2001-2015 by the Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Kazakhsta
Therefore, we marked the data as not openly licensed. Data is available in bulk. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"5c0a4d35-6947-4494-a95f-6040d98ea52d","global","2015-10-04T14:44:27","2015","et","budget","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"FEDERAL GOVERNMENT BUDGET PROCLAMATION","Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia , Ministry of Finance and Economic Development ( https://www.mofed.gov.et)","Yes","Yes","Data is not publicly available. I have changed the data.","Reviewer's note: This is the budget speech, not the budget itself. It seems like there is such data, but it is not publicly available. The site of the finance ministry was also blocked and I used an Ethiopian IP to access it.
The budget speech can be found here: https://www.mofed.gov.et/English/Resources/Documents/Federal%20Governemnt%20Budget%20Proclamation%202008-II.doc","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","5"
"8917ceb0-1bd9-4e34-9949-6acbf99fe787","global","2015-09-09T15:07:30","2015","pt","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.ersar.pt/xCelcius/ShowXCelcius_PopUp.aspx?FileName=/lib/12/1117957194E5E6C5D5FDCD7DB0D195D36E100.swf",,,,"Entidade Reguladora dos Serviços de Águas e Resíduos","ERSAR","Yes","Yes","Data is collected at local level, municipal organizations seem to have data and it is up to date also in PDF.
https://www.aguasdoalgarve.pt/relatorios.php",,"Yes","No","Aurelio Pires","Nisha Thompson","35"
"6c5f0460-0051-4285-946e-27aba5e209d0","global","2015-09-09T14:46:41","2015","iq","procurement","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission correct.","We were not able to find aggregates for the whole country. Some local governorate-level websites, such as this (https://www.maysan.gov.iq/sensa/viewmove.php) and this (https://basra.gov.iq/ar/178/index.1.html), but data is either not complete or links not working. And there are no updates for more than a year. ","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Georg Neumann","0"
"00004d8b-826d-484c-920a-af2c6899bc8c","global","2015-09-12T14:41:50","2015","ir","procurement","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","There does not seem to exist a common platform for tenders/awards.","We could not find this data","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Georg Neumann","0"
"97efa430-a556-4f2e-94e0-efbcd4a797ec","global","2015-09-27T08:30:36","2015","lv","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.meteo.lv/lapas/vide/udens/udens-kvalitate/udens-kvalitate?id=1100&nid=433",,,,"Water Quality","Latvijas Vides,Geologijas un Meteorologijas Centrs","Yes","Yes","Data is available in reports. ","There are several institutions monitoring water quality. VSIA ""Latvijas Vides, ģeoloģijas un meteoroloģijas centrs"" (https://www.meteo.lv) gathers most of the data: https://parissrv.lvgmc.lv/#viewType=home_view
There is no protocol for data to be updated on weekly basis. Some of the chemicals for example ""fecal coliform"" only is tested if there is a request for it. ","Yes","No","Toms Ceļmillers","Nisha Thompson","35"
"fca14835-2084-4861-808c-23e308eb62e0","global","2015-09-18T10:39:20","2015","im","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","No","No",,"Yes",,,"https://www.gov.im/about-this-site/open-government-licence/",,"Water Quality","Manx Utilities, Isle of Man Government","Yes","Yes","This submission is correct.","https://www.gov.im/categories/the-environment-and-greener-living/isle-of-man-government-laboratory/drinking-water-quality/
all government website sub-domains and statutory bodies websites are actually subject to the standardised national OGL (with the potential exception of maps and postcodes due to contractual uncertainty over dataset supply to Royal Mail PAF and Ordnance Survey despite copyright holder status) but not all website footers have been amended -- and simply not the highest priority in any overloaded and staff capped public sector IT department
area specific water quality results are available on demand by telephone or email
extensive data on equally important bathing water quality:
https://www.gov.im/categories/the-environment-and-greener-living/isle-of-man-government-laboratory/bathing-water-quality/
","Yes","No","Graeme Jones","Nisha Thompson","70"
"fb9c3794-d019-4575-9eee-a81d9de768f5","global","2015-09-17T13:20:20","2015","ly","water","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Can't find an online presence for water resources","No available dataset on water quality. The Ministry of Water Resources has a website, but it is not up yet. Most of its updates are streamed through its Facebook page (https://goo.gl/YyDGN3)","Yes","No","Maraim Elbadri","Nisha Thompson","0"
"e07060c8-c08a-4abd-ac28-e87691a2af9a","global","2015-09-21T10:32:12","2015","im","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is correct.","The reports on https://financereports.gov.im include aggregated expenditures and revenues but do not include transactional data.
Extensive discussions took place with the Treasury in 2014; Feedback was submitted on public beta and data upload commitments; agreement in principle to include website analytics to quantify interest, to share with CSOs, developers and other governments on open data path; some discussions with open government lead at Microsoft Europe on shift from quarter end to month end to day end to real time open banking and extensive discussions with https://openbankproject.com","Yes","No","anonymous","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"a5eaa062-f612-49f7-83ab-d81f2df9fc3d","global","2015-09-28T06:46:10","2015","id","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://data.id/dataset/belanja-pemerintah-indonesia-berdasarkan-apbn","CSV","https://data.id/lisensi-dan-atribusi",,,"Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","No updated data for 2015. Marked timely as no. ","Indonesia government budget (APBN) is spread over several resources as published in Indonesia Data Portal https://data.go.id/dataset under Bank Indonesia https://data.go.id/dataset?_organization_limit=0&organization=bank-indonesia
Data is not timely. Could not find data for 2015. ","Yes","Yes","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","90"
"f9cc1aa2-b63d-48d9-8623-6a0386fabbed","global","2015-09-12T05:36:50","2015","jp","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.mof.go.jp/budget/reference/statistics/data.htm","Excel",,,,"The Ministry of Finance Japan","Yes","Yes","i have update the link to the source of the data. Data is correct. ","The license of the e-Stat data is available at https://www.e-stat.go.jp/estat/html/spec_en.html. And MoF's license is here: https://www.mof.go.jp/english/notice.htm
Section 3 in the license ""Prohibited use"" makes the data non-open.","Yes","No","Satoshi IIDA","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"63c07e74-469f-4a4b-bc20-05de75520698","global","2015-10-04T14:44:40","2015","et","spending","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.","The [website of the ministry of finance](https://www.mofed.gov.et) lists a few budget documents, i.e. annual budget reports, fiscal information pages etc. but they all date back to 2004-2005. That indicates that the data does not exist today.","Yes","No","anonymous","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","0"
"a009c5e5-773b-47e9-bd59-7705900b4654","global","2015-09-12T14:58:13","2015","ly","spending","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is correct","We were not able to find this data. Even the site for the [ministry of finance](https://www.pm.gov.ly/component/k2/item/67-ministry-of-finance.html) is empty.","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","0"
"9148a842-d071-47ed-bfd7-0cd20af9dc2c","global","2015-09-12T09:59:54","2015","ir","spending","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.
Move from unsure to no.","We could not find the date on the website for the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Finance (https://www.mefa.ir/) or related sites.","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","0"
"29d1bec1-1ff2-4633-b334-fb4700d686f1","global","2015-09-25T17:46:18","2015","be","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Initial and adjusted budgets","The federal service for budget and management control","Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.
No transactional data available.","Begroting.be has .xls and .pdf files of the periodic reporting to the EU, summary tables of the government spending in PDF and XLS + PDF files of the detailled government spending of 2015. There is also an indication of a comprehensive dataset that should according to its description contain all transactions: https://www.begroting.be/NL/figures/Pages/databank.aspx","Yes","No","anonymous","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"709f6e69-7dcd-4baf-b5f2-607ca79b68f1","global","2015-09-28T19:39:55","2015","br","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://tempo.cptec.inpe.br/",,,,"Previsão de tempo - CPTEC/INPE","Instituto Nacional de Metereologia (Inmet), Instituto Nacional de Pesquisas Espaciais (Inpe)","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 5+ days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.","Weather forecast for the next 5 days is only available in non-machine-readable websites, both by Inmet and INPE:
* https://www.inmet.gov.br/portal/index.php?r=tempo2/previsaoPorTipo&type=capitais
* https://tempo.cptec.inpe.br/
Both have temperature and wind information but not precipitation forecasts.
Historical data is made available by Inmet in two separate ways:
1. https://www.inmet.gov.br/portal/index.php?r=bdmep/bdmep
Historical data on temperature, wind and precipitation. Said to be updated daily. Data sits behind user registration and access control.
2. https://www.inmet.gov.br/portal/index.php?r=estacoes/estacoesAutomaticas
Historical data on temperature, wind and precipitation from automatic weather stations. Updated hourly. Available in CSV but users have to fill in a captcha.","Yes","No","Augusto Herrmann","Neal Bastek","45"
"7c17c790-2890-4f13-a7ad-ad26d07a0aa8","global","2015-09-14T11:40:11","2015","at","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.zamg.ac.at/cms/en/weather/weather-forecast",,,,"Weather Forecast","ZAMG - Zentralanstalt für Meteorologie und Geodynamik (Research Institute of Ministry of Science)","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 5+ days of forecast data for temperature and precipitation.","ZAMG provides this data - at the moment only as HTML and Map-based but there are intense discussions going on at the moment to provide this data as open data very soon!
An alternative are providers as Austro Control: https://www.austrocontrol.at/wetter/wetter_fuer_alle/wettervorhersage/oesterreich_3_tage or commercial platforms like https://www.wetter.at/.","Yes","No","Martin Kaltenböck","Neal Bastek","20"
"929e01fb-8c79-4274-9ff3-deb407bb7f3a","global","2015-09-10T11:07:35","2015","nl","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.knmi.nl/nederland-nu/weer/verwachtingen","CSV","https://www.knmi.nl/copyright",,,"Koninklijk Nederlands Meteorologisch Instituut","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 5+ days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.","Here (https://www.knmi.nl/nederland-nu/weer/verwachtingen) you can find 5 days forecast, including temperature, precipitation and wind direction. As for historic data, you can get it from here (https://www.knmi.nl/nederland-nu/klimatologie/daggegevens), either per station, or all stations combined for the current year. The data is in CSV format, with some headers and meta data in the beginning of the file. ","Yes","Yes","Tarek Amr","Neal Bastek","100"
"7f4be7c9-34a3-46b2-aa5a-11070a463896","global","2015-09-20T03:11:30","2015","uy","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","No",,"Yes","https://www.meteorologia.com.uy",,,,"Several","Instituto Uruguayo de Meteorología","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 4 days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.",,"Yes","No","Daniel Carranza","Neal Bastek","45"
"0828de5b-127b-4868-b7b0-a5bcbbca865a","global","2015-08-27T14:37:56","2015","cz","weather","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Unsure","No",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as is. Even though it's not publicly available, the dataset contains 5+ days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Neal Bastek","10"
"53a4a744-b992-4b6f-939a-6f1f0f690ed1","global","2015-09-29T19:09:01","2015","fi","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://en.ilmatieteenlaitos.fi/open-data-manual","wms","https://en.ilmatieteenlaitos.fi/open-data-licence",,"Weather data","Finnish Meteorological Institute","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 2 days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.","FMI has decided to publish a major part of it's meteorological and oceanographic datasets as Open Data using open standard web service interfaces for geospatial data. This evolving documentation is intended to give a good head start on developing applications using weather and oceanographic data through the FMI's open data web services.","Yes","Yes","Jaakko Korhonen","Neal Bastek","100"
"26cbbde0-eeec-4dae-b680-86b7cd7b90e4","global","2015-09-16T10:14:59","2015","au","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","ftp://ftp.bom.gov.au/anon/sample/catalogue/ADFD/","GRIB, NetCDF",,,"Weather Grids - Australia - Bundle","Bureau of Meteorology","Yes","Yes","This submission is accepted as the dataset contains 5+ days of forecast data for temperature, wind, and precipitation.","Full details about the dataset including charge details are at https://reg.bom.gov.au/other/charges.shtml. Historical weather data is available at https://www.bom.gov.au/climate/data-services/station-data.shtml for free.","Yes","No","Pia Waugh","Neal Bastek","55"
"958c72a5-20fc-4288-adb8-13a7ee822cb9","global","2015-10-01T12:48:21","2015","ky","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","no data is Exist in a According to the document next from 2015
Air Quality Report For EIA of The Cayman Islands Berthing Facility
1.1.2 Baseline Air Quality Environment
The Terms of Reference (ToR) calls for focus on certain pollutants: nitrogen dioxide
(NO2), sulphur dioxide (SO2), and the finer size fraction of airborne particles (PM10). The
ToR also calls for quantification of Greenhouse Gas emissions (GHGs) focusing on carbon
dioxide (CO2). Together, in this assessment, these four substances are termed compounds
of potential concern (COPC).
Air quality monitoring is not routinely undertaken on the Cayman Islands, and no
data is publicly available on existing levels of air pollutants. Due to the lack of existing
ambient air quality monitoring data available within the study area, a three month survey
for nitrogen dioxide (NO2) and sulphur dioxide (SO2) was carried out using passive sampling
devices (PSDs) as called for in the ToR. Use of the small, portable and passive monitors
provided readily deployable methods without requirements for local power, and thus
allowed for flexibility in sampling site selection. The objective of the air monitoring
program was to determine an initial indication of background (baseline) levels of target
contaminants.
[https://www.doe.ky/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/App_G_AirQuality_FinalDraft.pdf][1]
[1]: https://www.doe.ky/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/App_G_AirQuality_FinalDraft.pdf","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","yar michl","0"
"b432b8f2-9b10-4c19-ad1c-f99dd3e78af1","global","2015-09-08T18:28:17","2015","ae","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure",,"Yes","https://fdc.ead.ae/network/#LiveData",,,,"Air Quality Monitoring System","Environment Agency – Abu Dhabi","Yes","Yes","checked","seem the data is exist
but During the visit to the website there was a Malfunction in the Part of the presentation of information of live data","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","yar michl","45"
"53c14a4d-e465-4c0e-9277-491e5c64a1bc","global","2015-09-28T12:12:41","2015","gg","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://guernseyair.ricardo-aea.com/",,,,"Air Pollution in Guernsey","Office of Environmental Health and Pollution Regulation","Yes","Yes","checked
maybe need to change the data to not a existent
Because of no measurements for Particulate matter ","The home page for air quality sampling is at https://www.gov.gg/sampling
The latest annual report on air quality ""Air quality Screening and Assessement Document 2015"", published on 21 July 2015, containing data for 2014 is at https://www.gov.gg/CHttpHandler.ashx?id=97049&p=0
data is not existent for PM and VOCs
the data is only existent for city one because of the country smoll territory
","Yes","No","Marcus Ferbrache","yar michl","45"
"ff6a285a-7495-4e83-afc8-01ca552e13f6","global","2015-09-08T18:39:23","2015","kw","companies","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Marked data as unavailable as no evidence has been found; updated details field with information on non-governmental register.","The Kuwait Government Online website (https://www.e.gov.kw/) does not have any evidence of a register of companies data. However, there are some companies of different types - hospitals, banks, airlines - listed along with their contact numbers in the Kuwait Statistical Review 2013, which is the closest the website comes to providing a directory. https://www.e.gov.kw/Documents/English/Forms/CSB/Statistical_Review_2013.pdf It is unlikely this is a comprehensive list.
The Kuwait Chamber of Commerce (non-governmental) has a searchable companies and institutions registry which features names, dates of registration, addresses and registration numbers. https://www.kuwaitchamber.org.kw/echamber/website/index.jsp#:searchListReport@1
","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"11d58566-8c21-44eb-9dfa-49a7512d3de3","global","2015-10-02T08:32:28","2015","ne","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Unsure","https://www.stat-niger.org/statistique/pages/repentreprise/entreprise_list.php?lng=fr","XLS, CSV, XML, DOC",,,"Companies Directory","National Institute of Statistics (Institut National de la Statistique)","Yes","Yes","Looks good!","The companies directory is made available by the national institute of statistics on their website. The data are available on the webpage and the user can search within it. The data can also be exported in a range of formats.","Yes","No","anonymous","Rebecca Sentance","60"
"92a74597-55ff-4eb0-a3e8-db85a3902ca6","global","2015-10-02T16:54:01","2015","dk","companies","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://datacvr.virk.dk/","XML",,,"Central Business Register (CVR) - The state registry of business information, which contains information on all registered companies in Denmark.","Virk Data","Yes","Yes","A few corrections made with the help of submitter. Looks good!","A log in and password is needed, which is why the data is not available. Bulk data is available for payment.
Update 2015:
It is still the case that you need to log in using your Danish citizen ""NemID"" (social security number-based digital identification system) in order to access the data. Once you've done that you have access also to bulk download, although the maximum number of records extractable per download is 50,000 (and total number of records as per Oct 2 is 1,173,015).","Yes","No","Christian Villum","Rebecca Sentance","65"
"1ee14bb0-c23b-4499-8f21-1b825d5504f4","global","2015-09-17T01:23:32","2015","lc","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.rocip.gov.lc/stlucia/default.aspx?UR=https://www.govt.lc/press-releases",,,,"Registry of Companies and Intellectual Property","Government of Saint Lucia","Yes","Yes","Added a bit of extra detail on how to browse the full database.","When using the website, you can enter the name of a company to search. A record of places will appear and the year the company has begun. However the data is not able to be downloaded in PDF or CSV format.
Entering a space as the search term can bring up the whole database, although small search terms such as one character tend to interfere with the CSS/HTML styling of search results.
It is also difficult to make multiple searches in one session without refreshing the page in between.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Rebecca Sentance","45"
"dd11095a-e1ad-45c2-9ceb-8f26d1aa707b","global","2015-10-01T09:33:46","2015","bj","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"No","https://www.ccibenin.org/index.php/repertoire-entreprises.html",,,,"Directory of Businesses in the CCIB","Bénin Chamber of Commerce and Industry (CCIB)","Yes","Yes","All checks out!","The chamber of trade and industry of Benin is responsible for companies data collection and publishing. The data are registered at the creation of a company and updated when the company notifies a change.
The data is available on the website of the chamber, but in PDF format and not updated (appears to be current to 2013).","Yes","No","anonymous","Rebecca Sentance","45"
"a8de28ab-fffa-4a27-b0e0-434946817b62","global","2015-09-28T11:41:06","2015","ge","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://geostat.ge/index.php?action=page&p_id=116&lang=eng","Excel, CSV",,,,"Sakstat info@geostat.ge","Yes","Yes","No open license found but data are available. ","Sakstat / Geostat makes numerous national indicators available on their website for free.
Geostat has adopted the PC-Axis platform and all its public data is available via Axis and can be downloaded in public in a number of machine-readable formats.
https://pc-axis.geostat.ge/Menu.aspx?rxid=c8ca81e9-2824-4c5b-a46a-c80202913531&px_db=Database&px_type=PX&px_language=en
Sakstat / Geostat provides foundational statistics for free, such as population, GDP, unemployment, etc. However, the agency collects more detailed statistics which are not freely available. The freely-available statistics are sufficiently detailed that I believe the dataset qualifies as freely available even though not all statistics collected by the agency are available for free.
All government-generated data in Georgia is legally in the public domain.","Yes","No","Eric Barrett","Zach Christensen","70"
"04eb208d-3902-4e87-b47d-773455eaf907","global","2015-09-28T06:08:12","2015","kh","companies","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,"Company Search","Ministry of Commerce","Yes","Yes","Data does exist, but I am marking other categories as ""no"" due to the inability to browse the database without a search term. Details on how to search the database are included.","The Ministry of Commerce has a Company Search feature: https://www.moc.gov.kh/en-us/company-search which allows users to look up the name of a company if they know it (minimum search input is 3 characters), its director and contact number. Clicking on the name also reveals registration number and registered address. However, there is no option to browse the whole database freely or download its contents. It is unclear how frequently the dataset is updated.","Yes","No","anonymous","Rebecca Sentance","5"
"36a7d3e5-e2f7-4d9d-842a-015d79072bb0","global","2015-09-27T11:19:18","2015","tl","statistics","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Missing data.","There are no information found from the official website Government of Timor-Leste https://timor-leste.gov.tl/?lang=en nor from the official website Timor-Leste Government Result Portal https://www.governmentresults.gov.tl/publicResults/index?&lang=en.
The information provided from Timor-Leste Government Result Portal does not follow the criteria above. No unemployment, GDP, or population data that are more recent than 2010. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Zach Christensen","0"
"703c0ff3-4fdd-4454-be57-59ab853f2ab3","global","2015-09-07T18:09:16","2015","qa","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.gsdp.gov.qa/portal/page/portal/gsdp_en/statistics_en/key_indicators_en",,,,"Statistical information about a variety of topics including GDP, enrolment in schools, exports, etc.","Ministry of Development Planning and Statistics","Yes","Yes","Website difficult to navigate but basic data are there if not regularly updated. No open license. ","The Ministry of Development Planning and Statistics publishes a variety of statistics on its website including population, GDP, and unemployment. However, this data is scattered over many different pages, For example, the latest key indicators for all statistics can be viewed on this page ( https://www.gsdp.gov.qa/portal/page/portal/gsdp_en/statistics_en/key_indicators_en ), while the archival monthly and annual reports are available on separate pages and much more difficult to find. Some data appears to be very up to date, such as population ( https://www.mdps.gov.qa/portal/page/portal/gsdp_en/statistics_en/monthly_preliminary_figures_on_population_en ), but for other topics they appear to be published many months ago ( such as those in they key indicators page ).
Qatar also has a data portal ( https://www.qalm.gov.qa/ ), but it appears to be extremely out of date and very buggy.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Zach Christensen","35"
"c84348c5-c8cf-46eb-84df-37d91948a1d0","global","2015-10-02T11:20:17","2015","ne","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.stat-niger.org/statistique/",,,,"General statistique","Institut National de la Statistique","Yes","Yes","Some data, not openly licensed. ","The statistics data are published regularly by the national institute of statistics on their website. It is in html and pdf format and no reference on a licence is made.
[GDP][1] up to 2013
[Population][2] up to 2011.
No unemployment data found.
[1]: https://www.stat-niger.org/statistique/file/Annuaires_Statistiques/INS_2014/AS2009-2013_COMPTANAT.pdf
[2]: https://www.stat-niger.org/statistique/file/Annuaires_Statistiques/INS_2012/AS2007-2011POPULATION.pdf","Yes","No","anonymous","Zach Christensen","45"
"9c6ff1c6-4fbb-4453-9c82-bc5065a197d2","global","2015-09-17T13:42:14","2015","ly","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://bsc.ly/?P=5&sec_Id=7&dep_Id=6",,,,"Data about employment and population in Libya - Data are uploaded as part of pdf report. ","Bureau of Statistics and Census - Libya ","Yes","Yes","Not much data available and not open. ","[Unemployment][1] data for 2012.
Population data for 2012.
No GDP figures found.
[1]: https://bsc.ly/?P=5&sec_Id=7&dep_Id=6","Yes","No","Maraim Elbadri","Zach Christensen","35"
"7e98b1d8-6abd-4b42-bfa6-863af0247369","global","2015-09-25T11:02:36","2015","kz","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"No","https://taldau.stat.kz","EXCEL (xls), however, the data is also available in JSON format on other resource. ",,,"Tables and infographics about various types of statistics shown by categories (economic, social, healthcare etc.). The information about GDP, unemployment and population are present). However, the information is usually formed annually. However, the information is usually formed annually. ","Statistics Committee of the Ministry of National Economics","Yes","Yes","Data not openly licensed but available. ","The data can be downloaded in bulk for each statistics, however, all the data available can not be downloaded as single file. The data is formed annually according to government plan. The information provided by government officials in Kazakhstan (by default) is open for reuse, publishing as cited by the law.","Yes","No","Nazerke Akhmetzhanova","Zach Christensen","50"
"e0323751-24fe-4a23-b699-cfe7c2e04e48","global","2015-09-28T07:55:13","2015","mm","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://dica.gov.mm.x-aas.net/",,,,"Company Search","Directorate of Investment and Company Administration","Yes","Yes","Data is very much available - have filled in all fields accordingly.","The DICA Company Search feature allows the public to search through a database of Myanmar companies, their names, registration numbers and license expiration dates. Further information including address, type of business and director names can be accessed by clicking on an individual name. It is also possible to browse through all companies in the database by entering a space as the search term.
The data is copyrighted and it is unclear how frequently the database is updated.","Yes","No","anonymous","Rebecca Sentance","35"
"e5d9e5c2-ed5d-4176-9f51-485ab3ea574e","global","2015-09-17T14:52:34","2015","ly","companies","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I agree, no data seems to be available for this country.","No data is available.","Yes","No","Maraim Elbadri","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"773c5b77-66d6-4ca4-b171-b312cac4cfe8","global","2015-09-28T10:54:54","2015","md","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://date.gov.md/ckan/ro/dataset/11736-date-din-registrul-de-stat-al-unitatilor-de-drept-privind-intreprinderile-inregistrate-in-repu","Excel (.xslx)","https://date.gov.md/en/terms-and-conditions",,"Open Company Registry","Ministry of Information Technology","Yes","Yes","Added details field. Looks good!","The Ministry of Information Technology offers regularly (roughly once a month) updated datasets which can be freely downloaded in .xlsx file format. Previous datasets are also available spanning the past year.","Yes","Yes","Victoria Vlad","Rebecca Sentance","100"
"48364a1c-9ee4-4e55-acc3-b1d44268ebc5","global","2015-09-18T10:20:39","2015","au","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.gov.au/dataset/asic-companies-register","CSV, MDB","https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/au/",,"ASIC - Company Register","Australian Securities and Investments Commission","Yes","Yes","All fine!","Basic registered company data is published monthly to the Federal open data catalogue, where it can be used in bulk or via API.
There is also a dataset for the Australian Business Register at https://data.gov.au/dataset/abn-bulk-extract
Includes:
- Name of company
- Unique identifier of the company
- Updated at least once a month.
Does not include company address.","Yes","Yes","Stephen Gates","Rebecca Sentance","100"
"fac33961-0b7b-43d1-9016-1e97f951e3ce","global","2015-09-18T13:57:35","2015","ro","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.gov.ro/organization/onrc","CSV, xls","https://data.gov.ro/base/images/logoinst/OGL-ROU-1.0.pdf",,"Company Register","National Office of Trade Registry (Oficiul Național Registrul Comerțului)","Yes","Yes","No problems here.","Data is provided via national open data repository. It includes name, identification number, fiscal registration number, areas of activity and locality (state and town, not full address).
Data is updated quarterly. Old versions of the dataset remain available. ","Yes","Yes","Ovidiu Voicu","Rebecca Sentance","100"
"0ec2fd05-1e99-489d-851a-03082d21020a","global","2015-09-28T11:05:20","2015","md","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://legis.md/",,"https://legis.md/cautare/rezultate/22449",,,"Ministry of Justice","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct."," ","Yes","No","Victoria Vlad","Kamil Gregor","75"
"ac560f95-cdba-47b2-b91e-9653812d9477","global","2015-10-02T00:27:17","2015","se","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.riksdagen.se/sv/Dokument-Lagar/Lagar/",,,,"Svensk författningssamling (SFS)","The Riksdag (More specifically Svensk författningssamling (SFS))","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Unstructured text data for now. Plans to release linked open data has been around for years but not turned into practice.
It is not possible to open this link: https://62.95.69.15/sfs/sfst_form2.html
","Yes","No","Asmen Gül","Kamil Gregor","45"
"858c5fb4-6289-45bb-b6c8-af22e5e598e1","global","2015-09-07T12:02:33","2015","bh","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.legalaffairs.gov.bh/71.aspx?cms=iQRpheuphYtJ6pyXUGiNqkizO3w1IVEN",,,,"Legislation","Legislation and Legal Opinions Commission","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The Legislation and Legal Opinions Directorate posts the latest laws on its websites as soon as they get published in the Official Gazette. ( https://www.legalaffairs.gov.bh/71.aspx?cms=iQRpheuphYtJ6pyXUGiNqkizO3w1IVEN ) The website also provides an advanced law search engine ( https://www.legalaffairs.gov.bh/AdvancedSearch.aspx ).","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Kamil Gregor","45"
"c7376263-a8e2-40b2-9e96-d732690c6cd3","global","2015-10-14T22:05:39","2015","pr","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.oslpr.org/v2/leyespuertorico.aspx",,,,"Leyes de Puerto Rico","Oficina de Servicios Legislativos de Puerto Rico / Puerto Rico Legislative Services Office","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The site is continuously updated.
QA reviewer - Bills are available in Spanish and English. There is a copyright notice on the website's terms of use. Lastly, the bills available in PDF and Word format, and are not machine readable. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","45"
"51530253-abd7-4727-a2d4-bcbc9a9b60b2","global","2015-09-27T01:46:54","2015","cr","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.pgrweb.go.cr/scij/main.aspx",,,,,"Procuraduria Nacional de la República","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","All information of laws and other valid legislation is avalilable there. Lawyers use this information daily.","Yes","No","Alejandro Sanabria","Kamil Gregor","45"
"762493db-0972-4715-82ea-30746575235c","global","2015-09-21T20:36:39","2015","gt","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://congreso.gob.gt/legislaturas.php",,,," Congreso de la República de Guatemala"," Congreso de la República -https://congreso.gob.gt/index.php","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Unable to tell if open - not clearly licensed","Yes","No","Julio Herrera","Kamil Gregor","45"
"89f258df-f800-4f0c-896e-75a9bd66d5ab","global","2015-09-29T00:02:15","2015","pa","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://infojuridica.procuraduria-admon.gob.pa/Infojuridica/",,,,,"Procuraduría de la Administración (Infojurídica)","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Most statues, resolutions and regulations are available either from government websites such as Infojurídica or third parties. The problem lies in the quality of the documents, which for some reason are sometimes printed, then scanned into PDFs and uploaded, rendering them unsearchable (document quality is also sometimes an issue).","Yes","No","HAMZAH HAJI","Kamil Gregor","35"
"585ae211-7f03-4389-8e12-5f9cb74944bf","global","2015-09-28T05:35:34","2015","th","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.ratchakitcha.soc.go.th/RKJ/special/search.jsp",,,,"Ratchakitchanubeksa","The Secretariat of The Cabinet","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Thailand's Legislation will be announce on the Royal Gazette (ราชกิจจุนุเบกษา) which can be accessible through The Secretariat of The Cabinet's website.
Note: Data did not change","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","45"
"10945c9e-1e27-4d50-943e-271f051bc822","global","2015-10-14T17:59:22","2015","fi","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.ldf.fi/semantic-finlex.html","RDF","https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/",,,"Ministry of Justice","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","No changes since 2013
The up-to-date legislation is available in web portal, but it was not not possible to download. See discussion (in Finnish) https://avoindata.net/210/saako-lainsaadannon-eli-finlexin-avoimena
Now it has been published as linked data. The semantic structure is still work in progress but data is now there and fully open.
OM on ollut viime vuodesta lähtien mukana Aalto-yliopiston Linked Data Finland - hankkeessa. Yhtenä hankkeen osana on lainsäädännön koneluettavan aineiston tuottaminen ja verkkopalvelun valmistelu. Hankkeen rahoitus ei ollut riittävä koko Finlexin uudistetun palvelun tuottamiseen, minkä vuoksi meillä on parhaillaan lisärahoitusta koskeva selvittely meneillään VM:n Avoimen hallinnon toimintaohjelman kanssa. Jotain on jo saatu julkiseen verkkoon ikäänkuin näyteaineistona. Viime viikon lopussa julkaistiin lainsäädäntö- ja oikeuskäytäntöaineistoista ensimmäinen aineistopaketti Linked Data Finland -hankkeen verkkosivuilla www.ldf.fi - osion nimi on hienosti Semantic Finlex ja sen tarkka osoite on https://www.ldf.fi/semantic-finlex.html Semanttista Finlexiä on siis tarkoitus viimeistellä lähikuukausien aikana.
No changes from 2014.
QA review - Data is in open license - https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/","Yes","Yes","Mor Rubinstein","Kamil Gregor","100"
"10d159cf-3f1f-4551-86b6-f527d6687e2d","global","2015-09-27T19:34:19","2015","ms","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://agc.gov.ms/?page_id=379",,,,"Attorney General's Chambers","Government of Montserrat","Yes","Yes","The data is not available in bulk.",,"Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Kamil Gregor","45"
"c26a741d-0df7-4f67-8de0-358c31f5e7ef","global","2015-10-02T21:01:54","2015","sn","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.gouv.sn/-Lois-et-reglements-.html",,,,,"secrétariat général du gouvernement","Yes","Yes","The data is not available in bulk.","The laws registre is made available on the website of the government. All the data can be queried and downloaded","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","45"
"d0a582c5-eb03-47f9-ac28-780c028b1d47","global","2015-09-12T00:43:36","2015","sy","legislation","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,"The Official Gazette",,"Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","All legislations are published as bulletin ""the Official Gazette"". it is nowhere to be found online.
There is web page for Syrian decrees and laws on Syrian e-Gov Web Portal official website, but we are not sure if all legislations are available there, and how often is updated (https://portal.egov.sy/law.ar_law/en/0/0/module.page.html).","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Kamil Gregor","5"
"380e8456-acda-4786-9178-a646d37e83f4","global","2015-09-24T15:28:10","2015","sd","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://moj.gov.sd/index.php",,,,"Primary legislation of Sudan","Ministry of Justice","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The website of the Ministry of Justice ( https://moj.gov.sd/index.php ) has a search engine on the top right corner that allows users to search for Sudanese laws. The laws can be viewed only on web pages as text and cannot be downloaded in bulk. When searching for some keywords, such as ""companies"" (شركات) all additions of the companies law appear including one which was issued in 2015, which suggest that the content appears to be up to date.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Kamil Gregor","45"
"fcb55ec4-beb8-4534-960c-ecbbbdf1c055","global","2015-10-14T13:54:27","2015","kw","legislation","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","No","No","No",,"Yes","https://kuwaitalyawm.media.gov.kw/",,,,"the Official Gazette (Kuwait today)","Ministry of information","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","You need to need to loge-in in order to see the legislations.
The data format is PDF.
Reviewer's comment:
According to original submitter, you need to login, thus, changed publicly available to no. (Technical Glitch, while re submitting, the system forced me to set the available for free question to false)","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Kamil Gregor","25"
"6b2c9822-9de3-4a68-b3c4-1f4e90c3f24f","global","2015-09-27T16:07:13","2015","bf","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://assembleenationale.bf/spip.php?rubrique15","HTML",,,"Lois adoptées","Assemblée Nationale","Yes","Yes","The data is not available online.","When the parliament adopt a law, they publish the document on their website, and transfers it to the secretary of the government. This organisation have developed a dedicated website (1) to publish the legislative document but the website is offline for the moment.
1. https://www.legiburkina.bf","Yes","No","Idriss TINTO","Kamil Gregor","45"
"dcc26aaf-8bae-45ff-ae34-8dbd14f8bd34","global","2015-10-01T14:38:28","2015","tz","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.parliament.go.tz/index.php/documents/acts/all/all/",,,,"ACTS OF THE PARLIAMENT ","Parliament of Tanzania","Yes","Yes","The data is not available online.","Parliament of Tanzania is the law making body , before they are signed by the president. in most cases , the president signs all bills turning them into laws.","Yes","No","Joachim Mangilima","Kamil Gregor","45"
"b15fb702-742e-4c01-8f83-6ea6db7f0192","global","2015-09-23T22:26:12","2015","bo","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://silep.vicepresidencia.gob.bo/SILEP/inicio",,,,"Sistema de Información Legal del Estado Plurinacional","Vicepresidencia del Estado Plurinacional","Yes","Yes","The data is not available in bulk.",,"Yes","No","Mariana Leyton","Kamil Gregor","35"
"813a3626-b31e-49b5-ac68-e0209da594c7","global","2015-09-26T14:09:56","2015","sd","statistics","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Little data after 2008 can be found.","The data on Central Bureau of Statistics website is outdated, last data about population was in 2008 , and last report about national statistics such as demographic and economic indicators was published
in 2014 (https://cbs.gov.sd/files/S%20in%20F%202009-2013%281%29.pdf). the report does not include data about unemployment.
The format of data on Central Bureau of Statistics website are XLSX and PDF.","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Zach Christensen","0"
"baab27df-ee55-447e-bd7f-5cb6beca2bc0","global","2015-09-27T21:33:47","2015","uy","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.impo.com.uy/cgi-bin/bases/consultaBases.cgi","HTML",,,,"IMPO","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Registration requirement from last year eliminated.","Yes","No","Daniel Carranza","Kamil Gregor","45"
"0694f3e0-5126-4bbf-b99a-834b7e9b1427","global","2015-09-28T14:10:49","2015","py","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://digesto.senado.gov.py/index.php","HTML, DOC, PDF","https://digesto.senado.gov.py/ups/leyes/7003ley%201328-1998.doc",,,"Congress of the Nation","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The Quality of the data is very well in respect of Content, because you can find the documents with a high level of granularity, this is, who proposed the law, when did it, the content of the documents, etc.
About the structure, there are no structure of the data, there are not tabular format at all.
There is another link where the data is placed with more information about the actual status of the documents that are processed for subsequent enactment: https://sil2py.senado.gov.py/
Considering the license, all the Paraguayan laws are not subject to the Copyright law (Art. 8 Law 1328 [1]), which means that the content of the laws are public, and as by Art. 8, it requires attribution.
Information about technical and administrative contact:
Name: Marcelo Ferreira
Email: jmferreira@senado.gov.py
Phone number: (595) 21 414 5817
Another contacts:
Email: silpy@diputados.gov.py, asilva@senado.gov.py
Phone number: (595) 21 414 4122, (595) 21 414.5901, (595) 21 414.5905
Reference:
[1] https://digesto.senado.gov.py/ups/leyes/7003ley%201328-1998.doc","Yes","No","Juan Pane","Kamil Gregor","75"
"18299e02-bf99-4267-8596-d46f47e3ac21","global","2015-10-13T21:45:41","2015","tg","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.legitogo.gouv.tg/",,,,"LOIS, REGLEMENTS ET JURIPRUDENCE DU TOGO : Accès à 2.591 journaux officiels parus entre 1920 et 2014 soit 56.149 pages de Journal Officiel ; Accès direct à la version intégrale des 11.022 textes à portée générale parus au Journal officiel entre le 01 Octobre 1920 et le 31 Décembre 2014 ; Accès à 764 arrêts de la Cour Suprême et à 149 décisions et avis de la Cour Constitutionnelle parus entre le 04 Mars 1963 et le 31 Décembre 2014","Présidence de la République & Ministère de la Justice du Togo","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Laws available in PDF. Not available in bulk. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","45"
"f56d379d-8129-48da-b0d3-bd75d904a644","global","2015-10-03T08:28:31","2015","gn","legislation","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,"list of laws","National Assembly","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","10"
"f35d196c-6575-441e-ac2b-085e85d181e1","global","2015-10-02T04:09:03","2015","ci","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Yes","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,"Adopted laws","National assembly","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The National Assembly website does have a ""Travaux Parlementiares"" tab under which it would appear, national legislation is suppose to be published. Unfortunately, most links are either dead or do not navigate to anything.
- Website: https://www.assnat.ci/
Important texts and legislation can be found:
- https://www.gouv.ci/ci_texte_1.php","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","30"
"5a10c8de-4668-431b-af2d-c1ffd981cc76","global","2015-09-28T11:26:28","2015","ge","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://matsne.gov.ge/",,,,,"Legislative Herald of Georgia","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The legislation of Georgia is made available online by the Legislative Herald of Georgia, a ""Legal Entity of Public Law"" which is subordinate to the Ministry of Justice.
Laws and other legal documents are available via a search interface. The format of the documents is HTML; there is also a PDF download link. Neither of these qualifies as machine-readable because they would need to be scraped in order to extract the text of laws.
An offline version of the data is available for download, but only for paying users; therefore, this does not qualify as making the information available in bulk. Likewise, this downloadable version could potentially be disassembled to extract machine-readable versions of the documents, but this also doesn't qualify as machine-readable.
All government-generated information in Georgia is legally in the public domain, but the Legislative Herald Website specifies ""All Rights Reserved"" which could lead uneducated users to believe that the information was copyrighted. Thus, I marked this dataset as not openly licensed.
The data is updated regularly and frequently; the site is a valuable resource used by practicing lawyers in Georgia in the course of their work.","Yes","No","Eric Barrett","Kamil Gregor","45"
"1b0da46a-67e2-42ed-a3d3-d2b491fd7d5f","global","2015-10-07T02:01:28","2015","cn","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.gov.cn/flfg/index.htm",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The data is not available in bulk."," nothing changed in 2015","Yes","No","OKFN CN","Kamil Gregor","45"
"91797d3e-92c2-418a-b532-3dddbfefb6e5","global","2015-09-14T18:35:46","2015","sy","statistics","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","No data are more current than 2010/11.","The data of Central Bureau Of Statistics official website is outdated (https://www.cbssyr.sy/).","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Zach Christensen","0"
"c915a6ed-494c-4652-bb66-69753b49e6b2","global","2015-09-17T19:14:21","2015","us","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/bulkdata/BILLS","XML","https://www.congress.gov/legal/#copyright",,"The U.S. Government Printing Office (GPO) is the Federal Government’s official, digital, secure resource for producing, procuring, cataloging, indexing, authenticating, disseminating, and preserving the official information products of the U.S. Government.","US Government Printing Office ","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The link provided is to bulk XML data for United States Code provided by Office of the Law Revision Counsel for US House of Representatives. Data made available since July 2013 (see this announce https://www.speaker.gov/press-release/opengov-house-representatives-makes-us-code-available-bulk-xml).
Regarding open licensing we assume that the US Code is public domain. In addition no copyright assertion is mentioned on the site and the congress.gov site is run by the Library of Congress and one would anticipate is subject to standard public domain provisions (though there is a legal section whose copyright portion is unfortunately rather unenlightening - https://beta.congress.gov/legal/#copyright).
There is a variety of additional (machine-readable) data from a variety of sources not least the new Congress.gov website (which will be completely replacing https://thomas.loc.gov/ from November 2013). Other resources include: - Bulk data from the GPO in XML format including Congressional Bills, Commerce Business Daily etc. (Does not seem to be updated since Jan 2013). Announced Jan 10 2013 - see https://www.gpo.gov/pdfs/news-media/press/13news01.pdf
- The full US Code on the GPO at: https://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/browse/collectionUScode.action?collectionCode=USCODE (PDF)
- The Federal Register https://www.federalregister.gov/ which includes ""Regulations are issued by federal agencies, boards, or commissions [which] explain how [an] agency intends to carry out a law."" (Data is provided in HTML, CSV and JSON and there is a full API - see https://www.federalregister.gov/developers/api/v1 and https://www.federalregister.gov/blog/learn/developers)
- Resources listed on https://speaker.gov/open including https://docs.house.gov/ (which includes XML versions of laws being considered) and House floor activities at https://clerk.house.gov/floorsummary/floor-download.aspx In addition it is worth noting various unofficial sites that provide excellent material such as: - https://www.govtrack.us/
- https://opencongress.org/ It may also be interesting to read how expensive some of this material once was, see e.g. Carl Malamud's comments in https://radar.oreilly.com/2009/03/bulk-data-downloads-government-transparency-breakthrough.html ","Yes","Yes","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","100"
"8333d7dd-a5f3-41d4-bbdb-ab1323d9071c","global","2015-08-30T10:17:55","2015","np","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.dop.gov.np/downloads.phphttps://www.dop.gov.np/downloads.php",,,,,"Ministry of Information and Communication, Department of PrintingMinistry of Information and Communication, Department of Printing","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Ministry of Law, Justice, Constituent Assembly and Parliamentary Affairs are responsive to these data. ","Yes","No","Nikesh Balami","Kamil Gregor","55"
"e8308384-ea0e-4cca-91d9-feb7e2d4b761","global","2015-10-01T12:22:54","2015","ky","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.legislativeassembly.ky/portal/page?_pageid=4242,1&_dad=portal&_schema=PORTAL",,,,"Legislative Assembly","Cayman Islands Government","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.",,"Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Kamil Gregor","45"
"58960cd8-5449-4562-83a8-12aed8dc690e","global","2015-09-28T12:34:00","2015","gg","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.guernseylegalresources.gg/article/90615/Laws","HTML; PDF",,,"Guernsey Legal Resources website","Office of H M Greffier, help@guernseylegalresources.gg","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Guernsey Legal Resources website: https://www.guernseylegalresources.gg/","Yes","No","Marcus Ferbrache","Kamil Gregor","45"
"38fd1f58-e2cc-452f-89b7-0773c4caeb93","global","2015-10-01T10:03:09","2015","bj","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://legibenin.net/index.php?option=com_weblinks&view=category&id=14&Itemid=503",,,,"Base de données des textes de lois en vigueur au Bénin","Ministère en charge de la Justice","Yes","Yes","The data is not available in bulk.","The national laws are made available by a collaboration between the Ministry of justice, the Abomey-Calavi University and the national school of administration and magistrate. This collaboration have lead to a website (1) where many law can be queried and downloaded.","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","35"
"7d20ed3f-b5b1-490d-90c5-1cf64e6c7c08","global","2015-09-27T23:48:36","2015","ec","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.registroficial.gob.ec/",,,,,"Registro Oficial","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Subscription to Registro Oficial currently costs USD 140 per semester for digital version including taxes. It includes all laws, statutes and regulations since 2009. Many laws are available online for free, but only Registro Oficial includes all published and valid laws, regulations from every government office. ","Yes","No","Eduardo Bejar","Kamil Gregor","30"
"7b26a1ff-d115-4d95-ae98-b30c6c71869e","global","2015-08-27T15:08:50","2015","cl","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://datos.bcn.cl/","HTML, XML, json, RDF, sparql","https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/cl/",,"Legislative Linked Open Data: provide free access to different datasets that allow manipulation and reuse in software development. In addition, applications to visualize relationships between laws and municipal ordinances.","National Congress Library ","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The information about all the national laws and statutes can easily be find in https://www.leychile.cl/Consulta ","Yes","Yes","Diego Ignacio","Kamil Gregor","90"
"7ab2fb09-8d06-4b79-8364-13d96dedfba6","global","2015-09-28T17:08:21","2015","fr","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.data.gouv.fr/fr/datasets/legi-codes-lois-et-reglements-consolides/","XML",,,"LEGI (Versionned law database) + JORF (Official Gazette)","DILA","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Data are now available online and for free. Regarding the license, it is now openly licensed but still subject to the 2002-1064 decree which, in theory, authorize the data owner to refuse to grant the license to a reuser. See https://rip.journal-officiel.gouv.fr/index.php/pages/juridiques","Yes","No","Regards Citoyens","Kamil Gregor","70"
"e2a4ba6b-ad44-4398-b8d7-9cc6753b9daf","global","2015-09-08T13:47:27","2015","sa","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.uqn.gov.sa/Pages/Default.aspx","HTML",,,"Saudi legislation as published in the Official Gazette of Saudi.","Um Al Qura","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","All legislation in Saudi is published in the Official Gazette of Saudi - Um Al Qura. This publication can be downloaded for free from its official website ( https://www.uqn.gov.sa/Pages/Default.aspx ). The most recent laws and royal orders can be easily accessed through the upper menu of the website. There is no comprehensive legal search engine on the website as the Official Gazette also publishes other information besides legislation.
It is worth noting that the Bureau of Experts at the Council of Ministers has a search engine on its website for primary legislation ( https://www.boe.gov.sa/search.aspx?lang=ar ) which could be easier to use, but it is difficult to verify if this database includes all the legislation and whether or not it is up to date.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Kamil Gregor","45"
"0bd22db6-d688-4c99-82f6-e7aa426e5bfd","global","2015-09-02T15:26:51","2015","iq","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.moj.gov.iq/iraqmag/",,,,"The Official Gazette (Al-Waqa)","Ministry Of Justice","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.",,"Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Kamil Gregor","45"
"21233846-5120-4334-8ae5-47c454a38f1e","global","2015-09-09T15:40:34","2015","tn","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.e-justice.tn/index.php?id=36","HTML; PDF",,,,"Justie Portal en Tunisie","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Update: The site for the Tunisian Official Gazette seems to be down (https://www.iort.gov.tn/), however we found the list of laws in PDF's here, https://www.e-justice.tn/index.php?id=36 (Ministry of Justice web portal, https://www.e-justice.tn/).
As stated below, recent laws projects are published in the Constituent Assembly's official website (currently, Assembly of the Representatives of the People), and we were able to find recent laws here from August 2015, (https://www.arp.tn/site/loi/AR/index.jsp), thus we assume data is timely and up to date.
Last year's comment below:
Data is available on the Tunisian Official Gazette website. Also, since 2012, recent laws projects are published in the Constituent Assembly's official website: https://www.anc.tn/site/main/AR/docs/projets/liste_projets.jsp On this website, documents are available in PDF formats. ","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Kamil Gregor","45"
"1b764438-17e3-4dfe-8e57-5067d814828a","global","2015-10-12T18:26:28","2015","my","legislation","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","From the Attorney General’s Chambers of Malaysia official portal, there datasets are not available. Given that the institution is in the Federal State territory, submitting for Freedom of Information request is impossible because there is no Freedom of Information Act for the Federal State Wilayah Persekutuan.","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","5"
"8b110813-bf96-437c-bc4e-268ca52ba2be","global","2015-10-12T17:47:12","2015","tj","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://mmk.tj/",,,,"Website of the organization. National Centre on Legislation under the President of Tajikistan is a state entity focused on scientific research and analysis of legislation of Tajikistan.","National Centre on Legislation under the President of Tajikistsan","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Though most of the legal and normative acts are available in this website on a timely manner and free of charge, files are not in machine-readable format. Format used in the website are .doc and archived (zip, rar).
We think it is public data. Although it is proceed that published information is public information, there is no clear statements about intellectual property rights attached to the government information. There is also no clear statement for the terms and conditions of reuse, e.g. for license.
In addition, there are available proprietary information systems like ""Adliya"" and ""Pravo Consultant"" in machine readable format in the market. It is expected that Adliya will be available online and free of charge in the future. However, it is the privilege of civil servants only.","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","45"
"102e18f2-4cf6-4acb-a7df-26a6ee014a00","global","2015-10-12T16:33:10","2015","az","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.lexadin.nl/wlg/legis/nofr/oeur/lxweaze.htm",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","It seems to be openly licensed, but I can't find the URL.
QA review - Doc files are not machine readable. Change the question from Yes to No. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Kamil Gregor","45"
"80cb5e90-d894-4201-a3ff-43f091c3bc9e","global","2015-09-18T20:58:15","2015","is","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.althingi.is/vefur/lagasafn.html","HTML",,,"Lagasafn Alþingis","Alþingi","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Legislation by law is exempt from copyright but that is not explicitly stated and therefore it cannot be considered openly licensed. Statutes are not available in bulk nor can be accessed easily. The bulk version of the legislation is only updated 2-3 times a year.
Statutes are available at https://reglugerd.is","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Kamil Gregor","35"
"5fc149ea-3dd8-4839-996e-5b153cb26264","global","2015-09-16T09:12:25","2015","kg","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://kenesh.kg/RU/Folders/3571-Rezultaty_golosovaniya.aspx","PDF",,,,"Parliament of the Kyrgyz Republic","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The parliament of the Kyrgyz Republic provides all the results of the voting on the laws ans current status of the laws. Additionally it is possible to see who voted for or against the new law. ","Yes","No","Azamat Tokhtaev","Kamil Gregor","70"
"738db35a-2df6-482c-bf98-22ffb56c6226","global","2015-09-15T12:52:33","2015","ko","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://gzk.rks-gov.net/default.aspx",,"https://gzk.rks-gov.net/ActDetail.aspx?ActID=2445",,"Official Gazette of the Republic of Kosovo","https://gzk.rks-gov.net/","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Article 12 of Law No. 04/L-065 on copyright and related rights places public documents including laws in the public domain.","Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Kamil Gregor","75"
"5bbfd86d-17b6-49ab-a00b-b97e1811fa82","global","2015-09-27T19:16:29","2015","dk","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.retsinformation.dk/",,,,,"Retsinformation","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The site contains no ""term and conditions"" and are therefore not open, however you should be able to safely reuse it.
Metadata is available in machine readable format and for bulk download:
When you perform a search through Retsinformation.dk you can chose the option ""Eksporter søgeresultatet"" which gives you the search result in CSV - you can search for all documents to get a full CSV bulk download of the *metadata* of all legislation (although with 77,000 entries this sometimes over-stresses the server - if so make several queries).
Content of laws available in html-format and not as bulk-download:
The section on the Lex Dania project (https://www.retsinformation.dk/Forms/R0500.aspx?page=5) outlines that all legislation is available in XML format as of 2007. So, data can be considered machine readable. But this data is not online.","Yes","No","Niels Erik Kaaber Rasmussen","Kamil Gregor","45"
"3228b9a1-8d1a-4221-824a-5a1e4cbee4af","global","2015-10-11T14:24:08","2015","tr","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://mevzuat.basbakanlik.gov.tr/KHK.aspx",,,,"Prime Ministry ","Prime Ministry mevzuat@basbakanlik.gov.tr ","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","QA review - Data does not available in bulk. Data was is in PDF and not machine readable. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Kamil Gregor","45"
"f0f067ec-2eff-4d34-8711-375a92ca757e","global","2015-09-07T18:12:32","2015","qa","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.almeezan.qa/","HTML","https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/deed.ar",,"A comprehensive database of Qatari legislation, court decisions, and records of membership to international treaties.","Ministry of Justice","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Al Meezan is the official legislation portal of Qatar. It provides timely updates of passed legislation in HTML and word format. The website uses a CC-BY licence. However, data cannot be downloaded in bulk.","Yes","Yes","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Kamil Gregor","90"
"6bff5102-8163-4e64-beef-e3b64f872b5d","global","2015-08-29T16:50:33","2015","om","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.mola.gov.om/",,"https://www.mola.gov.om/eng/websitepolicy.aspx",,,"Ministry of Legal Affairs","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The data is available through a search engine in the Arabic language. Alternatively, the most recent laws can be accessed from the website of the Ministry of Legal Affairs of Oman at https://www.mola.gov.om/ Legal texts can be read in a PDF format, and can be accessed for free.
Laws in Oman are exempt from copyright protection, the second bullet point in the terms and conditions page confirm this. The terms and conditions can be viewed at this link: https://www.mola.gov.om/eng/websitepolicy.aspx","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Kamil Gregor","75"
"40363ac6-3751-4736-a95e-dc8ba1dcaf11","global","2015-09-25T13:45:49","2015","ma","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.sgg.gov.ma/L%C3%A9gislation.aspx",,,,"The Constitution, Financial and Budget laws, Labour law, Family law","General Secretariat of the Government, web site : www.sgg.gov.ma ","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","In addition to last year's comment, the Morocco official Gazette publishes the legalisations, and it seems to be updated
https://en.io.gov.mo/Legis/default.aspx
Previous year's comment:
The General Secretariat of the Govt has several texts of existing/promulgated laws (The Constitution, Financial and Budget laws, Labour law, Family law, etc.) and many more of draft bills (""Projets de textes diffusés aux membres du gouvernement"", https://www.sgg.gov.ma/Projetsdetextesl%C3%A9gislatifsetr%C3%A9glementaires.aspx ).
I was not able to identify such documentation on the Ministry of Justice website (www.justice.gov.ma ), yet the ADALA (https://adala.justice.gov.ma/AR/home.aspx) database seems to be the focal point where legislation content is published.
The legislative documents do not seem published on a timely basis: many of the recently adopted laws are not featured on any of these websites. This is for ex. the case for the widely discussed ""rape law"" (the Penal Code provision which used to allow the aggressor to marry the victim in order to avoid jail sentence) which was amended in January 2014 (https://www.lefigaro.fr/flash-actu/2014/01/22/97001-20140122FILWWW00619-maroc-loi-sur-le-viol-amendee.php).","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Kamil Gregor","45"
"90763173-d9f4-4878-a2bf-46bfd05d0605","global","2015-09-08T17:49:58","2015","ae","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.elaws.gov.ae/DefaultAr.aspx",,,,"Federal legislation of the UAE","The Ministry of Justice","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The Ministry of Justice has a website for accessing federal UAE laws, supreme court judgements, and official legal opinions. ( https://www.elaws.gov.ae/DefaultAr.aspx ).
This website does not appear to be up to date and does not include some core laws such as the laws relating to the annual budget.
The primary platform for publishing legislation in the UAE is the Official Gazette, which is available offline for a fee.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Kamil Gregor","35"
"dbaf6515-0bd8-4330-b62f-6a5a856ba3b5","global","2015-09-27T21:42:06","2015","bg","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://parliament.bg/bg/bills",,,,,"The National Assembly ","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The complete legislation is available mostly via a free web interface to proprietary legal information systems.
The State gazette provides pdfs (and some htmls) to the newly promulgated and amended laws and state ordinances. Also, RTF is an available format most of the time.
The laws are not subject to copyright in Bulgaria but the website does not carry a clear mention, thus preferrably error by stringency -- the data was considered non-open.","Yes","No","Boyan Yurukov","Kamil Gregor","55"
"1919f62b-c8b2-4650-b0e2-2cae892afdf4","global","2015-10-09T15:14:39","2015","nl","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://data.overheid.nl/data/dataset/basis-wetten-bestand","Webservice, XML","https://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/",,,"Kennis- en Exploitatiecentrum Officiële Overheidspublicaties","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Although the data download page at data.overheid.nl states the date of the data set is 26 March 2015, in reality if you download the metdata XML file, it will have a generation date of today. The data is updated daily. Only a dump of metadata is available in bulk, the actual legislative documents must be requested one-by-one. No historical revisions are available, only the latest consolidation.
Laws are also available through a web interface at https://wetten.overheid.nl/zoeken/
Update 2015: no changes apart from the date advertised on the data download page.","Yes","Yes","Sander van der Waal","Kamil Gregor","90"
"7d83a13e-43bb-4b76-a7c8-814d21a60946","global","2015-09-08T10:54:05","2015","kr","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.law.go.kr/","XML, HTML, HWP, DOC, and PDF","https://www.law.go.kr/lawPetitionForm.do?menuId=5&p1=&subMenu=4&nwYn=1",,"Korea Law Information Center - an office of the Ministry of Government Legislation that provides information on Korean laws and regulations including administrative rules, local laws and regulations, and legal precedents, as well as laws in force and their histories","Ministry of Government Legislation","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The [Korea Law Information Center (KLIC)][1] provides information on Korean laws and regulations including administrative rules, local laws and regulations, and legal precedents, as well as laws in force and their histories. The data on the site is only available in DOC, PDF, and HWP (a file format for Korean word processor called Hangul), and it is not available in bulk. The KLIC provides [Web APIs][2] so I answered ""yes"" to the question regarding machine-readability. However, the Web APIs are only accessible after the registration so in terms of the Web APIs, the data is not publicly available.
[1]: https://www.law.go.kr/
[2]: https://open.law.go.kr/","Yes","Yes","James G. Boram Kim","Kamil Gregor","90"
"23677904-1934-4675-afa8-e5c6eaa28000","global","2015-09-19T10:06:40","2015","il","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://main.knesset.gov.il/Activity/Legislation/Laws/Pages/LawHome.aspx",,,,"חוקי מדינת ישראל | Laws of the State of Israel","The Knesset, the Israeli Parliament","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","All the law data is now up, starting from British Mandate times (pre-state Israel) - although pre-1948 data is partial and will be completed in the future.
There are also plans to publish all protocols, legislation proposals (including amendments), and protocols of Knesset Committees.
Data about progress of these can be found (in Hebrew only), in this link:
https://main.knesset.gov.il/Activity/Legislation/Laws/Pages/LawAboutSite.aspx","Yes","No","ido ivri","Kamil Gregor","45"
"e70b40c0-e419-41d1-bbe5-4bfccd43c79f","global","2015-09-20T21:00:04","2015","es","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.boe.es/legislacion/","XML","https://www.boe.es/sede_electronica/informacion/aviso_legal.php",,"Legislación Vigente Consolidada","Ministerio de la Presidencia","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The *Law Seach facility* on [Boletin Oficial del Estado website][1] allow to search for all the legislation available.
Each law entry could be downloaded in machine readable format (XML) but not in bulks. The data is provided timely and with with a license which allows re-use in the terms of the open definition.
[1]: https://www.boe.es/legislacion/legislacion.php","Yes","Yes","José Félix Ontañón","Kamil Gregor","90"
"20bcf43c-f857-4d00-97fe-7babcea71f51","global","2015-10-08T09:47:10","2015","no","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://lovdata.no",,,,,"Lovdata","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Editor: For private use, the data is available free of charge. However,
commercial use requires a angreement ( read: subscription )
https://www.lovdata.no/info/lovavtale.html
No changes since 2013.
Reviewer-note 2014: Lovdata mentions an API on their webpage:
https://lovdata.no/info/api
Plans for the future?
QA review 2015: The website mention that the data is for non commercial use - ""Some of the legal documents are available free of charge to all non-subscribers; and such documents may be used on a personal basis as long as such use is for a non-profit and/or non-commercial purpose."" Changed license to not open. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Kamil Gregor","45"
"bfa68e8c-7503-40c8-8d99-a0294818835d","global","2015-10-01T22:01:17","2015","it","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.normattiva.it/","XML","https://www.agid.gov.it/sites/default/files/linee_guida/patrimoniopubblicolg2014_v0.7finale.pdf",,,"Istituto Poligrafico Zecca dello Stato","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The official repository of the law is [Gazzetta Ufficiale][1] but this is content format.
An access in data format is available at [Normattiva][2]
The web site offer the laws in xml format.
There is no directly reference for a license, but, the owner of the service is ""Istituto Poligrafico Zecca dello Stato"" and this is in the list of the PAs.
Therefore, because in the terms of the code of civil administration (CAD), if a PA publishes a dataset without reference to any license, this is considered open data by default.
The kind of license is specified on the guidelines for the public sector information made by the digital agency for italy (AgID).
The default license is ""cc-by 4.0""
[1]: https://www.gazzettaufficiale.it/
[2]: https://normattiva.it","Yes","Yes","Francesca De Chiara","Kamil Gregor","90"
"0c40b240-343f-4db4-b550-e2cfa4f3d950","global","2015-10-07T15:43:24","2015","ie","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.irishstatutebook.ie/","HTML, PDF",,,,"Electronic Irish Statute Book (eISB)","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","I have sent another note regarding bulk download and the licence. They did not get back to me last year so I have chanced bulk download to no.
YES - MACHINE READABLE, the data are available in PDF format and also html.
UNSURE: AVAILABLE IN BULK I have sent them a question, they now have mobile apps, which means it may possible via some sort of API? I have sent them a question. isb@propylon.com
NO: Open Licence, I have sent them a question, in the footer of the site the following is indicated ""© Government of Ireland. Oireachtas Copyright Material is reproduced with the permission of the Houses of the Oireachtas"". There is no licence information on the site.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","60"
"78bc99db-91fc-4c41-8991-f2b0ea691a46","global","2015-10-07T16:11:18","2015","tt","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.legalaffairs.gov.tt/lrcREVISED.html",,,,"Revised Laws of Trinidad & Tobago","Ministry Of Legal Affairs","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Ministry of Legal Affairs publishes the constitution, revised laws and other acts on their website. These documents are available as a PDF online. Other versions are available for purchase.","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Kamil Gregor","35"
"06275160-83d2-4200-be1d-6da8ae89870c","global","2015-09-12T13:12:15","2015","dz","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.joradp.dz/HAR/Codes.htm",,,,"Codes","Algerian Official Gazette ","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The Algerian Official Gazette publishes the laws here (https://www.joradp.dz/HAR/Codes.htm). They are categorised and divided into separation PDF files accordingly.
Here is an example for one of the documents, https://www.joradp.dz/TRV/APPenal.pdf , you can see a table in the end with amendments and dates.
Note: We couldn't tell when the PDF files with legal articles are updates, though, the most recent issues of gazette are available, which might indicate an up to date laws. (We marked the timely question as unsure)
Here you can see issued gazettes (https://www.joradp.dz/JRN/ZA2015.htm), the latest when we checked was on August 23, 2015. And here you can search (https://www.joradp.dz/SCRIPTS/JOA_Div.dll/RecGet)","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Kamil Gregor","35"
"8cb126ae-08c1-46bd-af10-e4ef6b9a1c56","global","2015-09-22T16:07:57","2015","ru","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://pravo.gov.ru","HTML, PDF",,,"Russian legislation database","Federal Security Service","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Brief Description: All Russian laws and other official documents that came from government ministries, agencies and federal services published using a few government websites. Base website is https://pravo.gov.ru - this project is being maintained by Federal Security Service (FSS) and this website is keystone for Russian laws disclosure. A few serious issues exists with Russian laws:
1. No machine readable data
2. No bulk download
3. No open licenses for laws
4. Government websites not integrated with pravo.gov.ru instead they provide links to the commercial providers of laws information like Russian companies ""Consultant"" (https://consultant.ru) and ""Garant"" (https://www.garant.ru).
5. Laws published on many of government websites available as ""high quality scanned images"". Step by step explanation
1. Does the data exist? Yes, at https://pravo.gov.ru
2. Is data in digital form? Yes, data available via website pravo.gov.ru
3. Publicly available? Yes, this data is publicly available. We don't need FOI request to get it.
4. Is the data available for free? Yes, this data is available for free. No payment is required.
5. Is the data available online? Yes. Data available at https://pravo.gov.ru
6. Is the data machine readable? No, it's only HTML pages.
7. Available in bulk? No, data is not available for bulk download
8. Openly licensed? No, this data is public domain data but no open license available.
9. Is the data provided on a timely and up to date basis?
Yes, this information updated frequently, on daily basis.
Comment: No updates since 2013 year
Comment: No updates since 2014 year","Yes","No","Ivan Begtin","Kamil Gregor","45"
"390efb42-5735-4e1e-b5d8-6b9253d00b30","global","2015-09-28T21:14:47","2015","sv","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.jurisprudencia.gob.sv/VisorMLX/Documento/BusquedaLibre.aspx?baseId=2",,,,,"Corte Suprema de Justicia - CENTRO DE DOCUMENTACIÓN JUDICIAL","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","It is not allowed to use the data of the website for commercial uses. The legislation is available in PDF format","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","35"
"9cb8e434-70a9-425f-93e7-61115fd67d97","global","2015-08-29T19:49:28","2015","ye","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Yes",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The Ministry of Legal Affairs of Yemen is the body responsible for publishing laws through the Official Gazette. The Gazette is required to be published by law, but the website of the Ministry of Legal Affairs ( https://www.legal-affairs.gov.ye/ ) appears to be offline.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Kamil Gregor","25"
"1789c345-c26c-479d-a708-5a5c19d4f41f","global","2015-09-10T14:20:42","2015","at","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.ris.bka.gv.at/defaultEn.aspx","HTML, PDF, DOC, asmx, wsdl, xsd","https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/at/deed.de",,"Legal Information System of the Republic of Austria (Rechts Informations System, RIS)","Federal Chancellery ","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Federal laws, regional laws, some regulation issued by municipalities, decisions of several regulators and governmental agencies and decisions of high-level courts are available at https://www.ris.bka.gv.at in HTML, PDF and Word format.
Aggregate data for bulk download of all federal law is made available through the government's open data portal: [RIS - Bundesrecht konsolidiert][1]. However, this archive is now several months behind the latest laws available on the RIS website, which is under Copyright and [charges fees][2] on some data extracts.
[1]: https://www.data.gv.at/datensatz/?id=31430a9f-c8ba-4654-ab68-c9c3dff0361b
[2]: https://www.ris.bka.gv.at/UI/Info.aspx","Yes","Yes","Martin Kaltenböck","Kamil Gregor","90"
"6c5c4ea3-f4d1-40c9-b691-38699565749e","global","2015-10-04T14:44:52","2015","et","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.electionethiopia.org/en/",,,,"THE NATIONAL ELECTORAL BOARD OF ETHIOPIA A summary of final results of the 2015 General Elections","National Electoral Board of Ethiopia","Yes","Yes","The submission does not meet the definition. The data is only available in regional summaries and, although at https://www.electionethiopia.org/en/images/stories/mapp.swf there is a ""map"" linking to some constituency-level (not polling station) data, much of it is missing, and access to the map via the website is broken anyway.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","45"
"c57b311a-1305-4099-9d0a-ed9c42ada25b","global","2015-09-20T05:19:56","2015","dm","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://electoraloffice.gov.dm/past-general-elections",,"https://electoraloffice.gov.dm/privacy-copyright-notices",,,"https://electoraloffice.gov.dm/","Yes","Yes","The data is in HTML.","Did not find any link which allowed users to download the data freely, however, it is available in HTML format.","Yes","No","Veronne Nicholas","Kamil Gregor","75"
"d6a1a0f3-c6c0-4cd2-80cc-b9063e4dbc15","global","2015-10-01T23:56:07","2015","se","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.val.se/tidigare_val/","XML and Excel","https://www.val.se/om_webbplatsen/",,,"Election Authority (Valmyndigheten)","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Detailed data in XML format available from the Swedish Election Authority. Edit: If one drills down through the pages, one can find XML and Excel files detailing the results.
Eg. the following page is of the previous (2010) general elections' results in data files https://www.val.se/val/val2010/statistik/index.html
https://www.val.se/tidigare_val/ (actually up to date, considering the date of the last election)","Yes","Yes","Asmen Gül","Kamil Gregor","100"
"b16becf1-eb1a-4848-a377-4cc58a9c1bea","global","2015-09-02T19:13:36","2015","au","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://results.aec.gov.au/","CSV, XML","https://www.aec.gov.au/footer/Copyright.htm",,"Australian Electoral Commission - Election Results Archive","Australian Electoral Commission","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Data only became openly licenced on the 1st of February 2012 because it was the first disclosure date of political donations after Creative Commons Attribution became the default licence of PSI for the Commonwealth of Australia. This led to statement informing users that all other data from the electoral commission being licenced openly: https://www.aec.gov.au/footer/copyright.htm Otherwise, machine readable data (CSV overviews and XML for finest granularity) is provided minute-by-minute on election dates for media organisations to use in their reporting and now this access is provided to citizens. ","Yes","Yes","Stephen Gates","Kamil Gregor","100"
"dfc33ef1-22e3-45cd-afb7-e4f1a72c9880","global","2015-10-07T15:38:48","2015","pr","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Yes","https://ceepur.org/es-pr/Webmaster/Paginas/Eventos-Electorales.aspx",,,,"Eventos electorales / Electoral Events","Comisión Estatal de Elecciones de Puerto Rico / Puerto Rico State Elections Commission","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Electoral results are published right away on the website of the Comision Estatal de Elecciones.","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Kamil Gregor","30"
"19ab95a0-48ab-4b58-8c21-010c8baef2eb","global","2015-09-15T06:40:26","2015","kg","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"No","https://www.shailoo.gov.kg/","PDF",,,,"Central Election Commision","Yes","Yes","The submission does not meet the definition since it is not available on the polling station level.","The Central Election Commission is a governmental main body for committing elections in a country. ","Yes","No","Azamat Tokhtaev","Kamil Gregor","50"
"20a90de3-dead-4643-b58f-6bb111098090","global","2015-10-20T08:08:19","2015","do","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://beta.jce.gob.do/Resultados-Electorales",,,,"Resultados electorales","Junta Central Electoral","Yes","Yes","The submission does not meet the definition. The results are published only for fairly large municipalities (up to 360.000 people), nowhere near polling station level of detail.","Last elections were in 2012. That's why even though the data doesn't belong to this year, we can say it's current.","Yes","No","Kamil Gregor","Kamil Gregor","45"
"24c83d9b-a598-4cc6-93dc-a488667e9679","global","2015-08-31T14:51:23","2015","jo","budget","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"General budget data","Ministry Of Finance ","Yes","Yes","Data exist (there is a budget speech), but it is not publicly available. ","There is a [budget speech][1] for 2014, however, it does not contains estimates for sub departments.
[1]: https://www.mof.gov.jo/ar-jo/%D9%85%D8%B1%D9%83%D8%B2%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%85%D8%B9%D9%84%D9%88%D9%85%D8%A7%D8%AA/%D8%AE%D8%B7%D8%A7%D8%A8%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%85%D9%88%D8%A7%D8%B2%D9%86%D8%A9%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B9%D8%A7%D9%85%D8%A9/%D8%A7%D8%B1%D8%B4%D9%8A%D9%81%D8%AE%D8%B7%D8%A7%D8%A8%D8%A7%D8%AA%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%85%D9%88%D8%A7%D8%B2%D9%86%D8%A9%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B9%D8%A7%D9%85%D8%A9.aspx","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Mor Rubinstein","5"
"04be563e-ec31-4dad-bca4-ae0285874976","global","2015-09-07T11:40:10","2015","bh","elections","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Bahrain solely holds elections for the Chamber of Deputies (lower Chamber of the bicameral Bahraini Parliament, the Shura Council members being appointed by the King).
The website of the Directorate of Election and Referendum ( https://www.vote.bh ) provides details relating to the candidates and the number of votes they each acquired in each voting round. The data available on the website does not include the total number of registered voters or the number of invalid votes - therefore it has been considered as not being available online for the purpose of the index.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Kamil Gregor","5"
"a64aa375-fa23-49ff-a68b-15b761bb4f79","global","2015-09-28T06:03:58","2015","ua","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://cvk.gov.ua/","HTML",,,"Results of elections","Central Election Committee","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The web-site reports presidential and parliament elections results and do not those of local elections. The web-interface is interactive, though it's not easy to extract data in bulk.","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","45"
"3f0059ee-c4c9-4b13-8701-c072300218c0","global","2015-09-28T23:42:35","2015","pa","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.tribunal-electoral.gob.pa/html/index.php?id=841",,,,,"Tribunal Electoral","Yes","Yes","The submission does not meet the definition. There is machine-readable data, but it is only available at the level of municipalities, aggregating for up to 80.000 voters.","If there is any machine-readable data available, I was not able to find it.
The website is very confusing.","Yes","No","HAMZAH HAJI","Kamil Gregor","45"
"acbeae4d-5c67-430d-8b90-0981119988eb","global","2015-10-14T18:14:54","2015","th","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.ect.go.th/th/?page_id=494",,,,"Election Statistics","Office of The Election Commission of Thailand","Yes","Yes","The submission does not meet the definition. Data is only available at a relatively high level, aggregating often for 100.000 people or more.","Elections in Thailand are responsible by Office of The Election Commission of Thailand. They have provided National and Local election statistics, but in PDF format.
National Election statistics is available for year 2005, 2007 and 2011.","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","35"
"93155d5e-7efe-41b4-994d-e0f7908d1d3e","global","2015-10-02T10:27:30","2015","fi","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://pxweb2.stat.fi/database/StatFin/databasetree_en.asp","csv, PC-Axis","https://www.stat.fi/org/lainsaadanto/yleiset_kayttoehdot_en.html",,,"Statistics Finland","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","There are no changes from 2015","Yes","Yes","Mor Rubinstein","Kamil Gregor","100"
"aab6abca-a5eb-4b7c-b7dd-ed1dfc647534","global","2015-09-27T16:48:48","2015","ms","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.elections.ms/",,,,,"Government of Montserrat","Yes","Yes","The election commission publishes results at https://www.elections.ms/. The website may not seem very official, but people are referred to it by the one government website in Montserrat (https://bit.ly/1hNjYuA).","The general elections were done on September 11, 2014 and was won by the People's Democratic Movement. ","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Kamil Gregor","45"
"6c5abe42-fe3a-411d-b045-1d43f7811c81","global","2015-10-02T19:59:13","2015","sn","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://cour-appel-dakar.sn/?p=544","xls",,,"Results of local elections of June 29, 2014","Court of Appeal of Dakar","Yes","Yes","The data is from the local elections. No national (presidential, parliamentary) results seem to be available.","Some of the published results are in pdf format and others in excel. But the court of appeal said that when requested, excel format data can be given.","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","70"
"2bcb4bec-f699-4168-81f8-933fc2d3c9f8","global","2015-09-12T00:22:13","2015","sy","elections","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission says results exist, but mentions neither 1) any evidence for their existence, nor 2) whether they meet the definition.","The results of presidential election and parliament election and other elections are existed, but we could find it online on any official websites.
The Supreme Constitutional Court in Syria supervised the presidential election and announce its results (https://ar.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%85%D8%AD%D9%83%D9%85%D8%A9_%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%AF%D8%B3%D8%AA%D9%88%D8%B1%D9%8A%D8%A9_%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B9%D9%84%D9%8A%D8%A7_%28%D8%B3%D9%88%D8%B1%D9%8A%D8%A7%29).
Supreme Judicial Committee for Elections is the body to announce parliament election results (https://www.hce.gov.sy/).
","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Kamil Gregor","5"
"56e14156-9cfb-41cc-9872-0d48c7d9fb20","global","2015-09-24T15:36:56","2015","sd","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://nec.org.sd/%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%A7%D9%86%D8%AA%D8%AE%D8%A7%D8%A8%D8%A7%D8%AA-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B3%D8%A7%D8%A8%D9%82%D8%A9/%D9%86%D8%AA%D8%A7%D8%A6%D8%AC-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%A7%D9%86%D8%AA%D8%AE%D8%A7%D8%A8%D8%A7%D8%AA-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B3%D8%A7%D8%A8%D9%82%D8%A9/",,,,"Election results including presidential election results and parliament results","National Election Commission","Yes","Yes","The submission does not meet the definition. Data is only available at the level of states, aggregating for up to 5.000.000 people.","The website of the National Election Commission has a page dedicated for previous election results ( https://nec.org.sd/%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%A7%D9%86%D8%AA%D8%AE%D8%A7%D8%A8%D8%A7%D8%AA-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B3%D8%A7%D8%A8%D9%82%D8%A9/%D9%86%D8%AA%D8%A7%D8%A6%D8%AC-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%A7%D9%86%D8%AA%D8%AE%D8%A7%D8%A8%D8%A7%D8%AA-%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B3%D8%A7%D8%A8%D9%82%D8%A9/ ) and includes data for a variety of contests (presidential elections, parliament elections, etc). The results are available in PDF files that contain details such as the number of candidates and registered votes in each region in addition the voting results provided through an area-by-area breakdown for each region. ","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Kamil Gregor","35"
"11a49dae-6d4e-4ab6-82d7-39794f9690f0","global","2015-09-07T18:09:11","2015","kw","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The data probably does not exist. I see no mention of detailed data.","There is a data about parliament election in 2013 on the internet but on official website (https://ar.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D8%A7%D9%86%D8%AA%D8%AE%D8%A7%D8%A8%D8%A7%D8%AA_%D9%85%D8%AC%D9%84%D8%B3_%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%A3%D9%85%D8%A9_%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%83%D9%88%D9%8A%D8%AA%D9%8A_2013). There are parliament election results for previous years on Kuwait National Assembly official website (https://www.kna.kw/clt/run.asp?id=334#sthash.cJbifVe1.dpbs) ","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Kamil Gregor","0"
"88e3d21a-0147-467b-832f-a0c3096f2ba2","global","2015-09-24T07:50:15","2015","bf","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.conseil-constitutionnel.gov.bf/index.php/les-elections/les-resultats-definitifs/resultats-definitifs-legislatifs/legislatives-2012","PDF",,,"Final results of the legislative election of december 2012","Constitutional Council","Yes","Yes","The submission does not meet the definition. Data is only available at the level of provinces, aggregating for up to 800.000 people.","The elections are organised by the national electoral commission, that publish on his website the provisional results. After that, the results are transmitted to the constitutional council who validates and publishes the final results on their website. Even if the published result are in PDF, the reusable one can be requested for free at from the publisher. Even if there is no open license applied, the publisher answers us that the user can use it as he want.","Yes","No","Idriss TINTO","Kamil Gregor","55"
"8cdc5d58-c1aa-406d-9215-f3b335598db2","global","2015-09-11T14:08:17","2015","ir","budget","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Could not find the data. Since the submitter was not able to find the data, we marked this question as no. ","When checking for this year, the site for the ministry of finance redirects us to this https://www.mefa.gov.ir:4443/ which needs credentials to log in. ","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"ca86ddfc-8ff9-4127-af17-02418eb3ab3a","global","2015-09-07T14:12:17","2015","lb","budget","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is correct. Could not find a version of a budget. Latest version is from 2013. ","There is no data since 2013, I believe the Lebanese government didn't issue an official budget for the last few years anyway.
Link: https://www.finance.gov.lb/en-US/finance/BudgetInformation/Pages/AnnualBudgetDocumentsandProcess.aspx","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"af6b7dc2-dfbc-4f8e-b524-091f48140e69","global","2015-09-25T14:08:14","2015","vc","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://www.stats.gov.vc/","PDF, CSV",,,"Statistical Office - Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning","Statistical Office of St. Vincent and the Grenadines","Yes","Yes","Data largely available but not current.","For each category in the National Statistics: GDP, Unemployment statistics are mostly updated up to 2013.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Zach Christensen","60"
"4324ecc1-d5ef-4133-9142-73d0037fcbee","global","2015-09-30T19:35:29","2015","tc","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.sppdtci.com/#!welcome/mainPage",,,,,"Turks and Caicos Statistics","Yes","Yes","Some data but not much.","The website is currently still under maintenance and last updated data was from 2014.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Zach Christensen","35"
"b12f7faa-0156-46d8-90f1-5fda532a6253","global","2015-09-18T17:26:23","2015","pe","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://inei.gob.pe","HTML, xls",,,,"Institutio Nacional de Estadistica e Informatico","Yes","Yes","Data for three indicators available but not regular and no open license.",,"Yes","No","Victoria Meneses Carriónizette L","Zach Christensen","60"
"ecf0d027-cac7-4cc8-8119-752add9056c1","global","2015-09-27T18:07:03","2015","ms","statistics","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://country-facts.findthedata.com/l/228/Montserrat",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Virtually no data available.","The Statistics Department has little info published online https://gov.ms. Only includes population for 2011.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Zach Christensen","0"
"a9eeba18-2528-4c33-8ecd-71b223600c02","global","2015-09-09T16:43:37","2015","kw","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://csb.gov.kw",,,,,"Kuwait Central Statistical Bureau ","Yes","Yes","Some limited data. Not open.","Population data up to 2005
Gdp up to 2012
Unemployment up to 2013
","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Zach Christensen","35"
"77dd6b54-9bcb-48ce-802f-91605bee6307","global","2015-09-27T01:01:29","2015","kn","statistics","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","No data found.","Ministry of Finance has links for data but they don't work.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Zach Christensen","0"
"eb4d79d1-8f88-4f2b-9b9e-d73c9b8aaeba","global","2015-09-15T07:59:46","2015","kg","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"No","https://www.stat.kg/","PDF, excel",,,"National Statistical Committee of the Kyrgyz Republic provides the statistical data about the country","National Statistical Committee of the Kyrgyz Republic https://www.stat.kg/ ","Yes","Yes","Data not as current or open as possible but available in xls","National Statistical Committee of the Kyrgyz Republic provides most of the statistics about the country's different fields, population, economics, etc
Gdp and unemployment up to 2013.
Population figures for 2015.","Yes","No","Azamat Tokhtaev","Zach Christensen","50"
"4e41463a-b502-42c5-9411-411cbb42a1f2","global","2015-09-09T09:02:31","2015","nl","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://aanbestedingskalender.nl/aankondigingen",,,,"Aanbestedingskalender",,"Yes","Yes","Submission updated.","All Dutch tender information that is also on TED is available on this website. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Georg Neumann","45"
"c40045e7-2bf3-4af2-91ed-751e2455df40","global","2015-08-29T17:13:11","2015","om","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://tenderboard.gov.om/arb/tendersBrowsing.aspx?reset=0",,,,"Tender and awards data for all major government contracts.","The Tender Board","Yes","Yes","Submission correct.","The website of the Tender Board, the body responsible for awarding government contracts, provides a comprehensive database that provides extensive data on government tenders. The data includes information about the project, the value of the tender documents, the names of all companies that bought the documents, the names of all companies that submitted proposals with the cost of each proposal. There is also information regarding the date the tender was floated, the date envelopes were opened, and the date the tender was awarded. There appears to be a bug with the page for displaying the award document, but it is easy to identify the awarded company as the information page shows the award amount (which could be cross referenced with the proposal cost).","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Georg Neumann","45"
"039f220b-6d42-41e5-a8e8-dbd320f8ef42","global","2015-08-28T10:01:52","2015","ru","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","ftp://free:free@ftp.zakupki.gov.ru","XML",,,"The official website of the Russian Federation on the Internet for posting information about placing orders for goods, works and services","Procurement Portal","Yes","Yes","Submission correct.","All russian procurement data including customers, suppliers and tenders database is available for free since 2005 year. It's published at ftp://free:free@ftp.zakupki.gov.ru FTP server for developers and provided free for regular users via https://zakupki.gov.ru website.
","Yes","No","Ivan Begtin","Georg Neumann","70"
"eb20215f-18ec-435d-a968-69b63f68ed56","global","2015-09-12T23:57:35","2015","jo","water","Yes","Unsure","No","Yes","Unsure","No","No",,"No","https://www.miyahuna.com.jo/DrinkWater.aspx",,,,"Miyahuna","Water Authority of Jordon","Yes","Yes","Seems that the regional level does collect data and it then goes to the Water Authority though I couldn't find aggregated data on the main site. The data is there and has been collected. Unclear what the timing of it is. ","This data couldn't be found on the Jordanian Ministry of Environment's website, https://www.moenv.gov.jo/Ar/Pages/default.aspx","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Nisha Thompson","10"
"9c0cbf0c-314e-40d4-b6a9-9dcd41f39dae","global","2015-09-15T09:36:29","2015","lb","water","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Can't find any online reports of water quality. ","There is no data whatsoever about water quality.","Yes","No","Chafic Najjar","Nisha Thompson","0"
"ac353eee-3add-4492-907b-e19c5bf63a01","global","2015-09-04T19:42:55","2015","eg","water","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","There seems to be no data online regarding water quality in Egypt. ","We found this site but it has no recent data, just old reports
https://www.eeaa.gov.eg/arabic/main/env_water.asp
And the water section of new site of the ministry is still under construction
https://www.eeaa.gov.eg:8080/en-us/topics/water/freshwater.aspx","Yes","No","anonymous","Nisha Thompson","0"
"ff015129-a47a-4149-a48e-a68432ec7661","global","2015-08-24T15:31:55","2015","ng","water","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","There is no water quality reports online seems they are not pushing the information online, if it there.","The [Federal Ministry of Water Resources][1] should have been the agency responsible for publishing water quality in the control, but it has not yet been available. While not sure if this is done by paper works, it is still far fetched as no reports has been published on water quality in Nigeria.
An alternative government portal that should have addressed water quality indicators in the country could have been the [Nigeria Millennium Development Goals Information System][2] but water quality described in their data only states physical structures of water source and not chemical components.
[1]: https://www.waterresources.gov.ng/
[2]: https://nmis.mdgs.gov.ng/","Yes","No","Oludotun Babayemi","Nisha Thompson","0"
"5508361c-c59d-47c8-808a-a4af7f27f240","global","2015-09-17T11:15:01","2015","be","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.milieurapport.be/Upload/main/AG2010_oppervlaktewater_def_TW.pdf",,,,"Divided over multiple datasources","Flemish Environmental Service, La société wallonne des eaux, Vivaqua & HydroBru in Brussels","Yes","Yes","Water quality is monitored regionally and in Belgium there is no Federal oversight. So data will be at the regional level and not consistently represented or available. ","I had two issues in my search for this data.
1. Water quality is a regional, not federal, matter. The global census prevents me to link to more than one source for the data, which is in this case hard to do.
2. Lack of definition of the dataset. Is this about water surfaces? Of water ways or watercourses? Of also of lakes, the seashore, etc?
Or is it about ground water? Potable water, sewage water,...
Data is very dispersed. The Walloon region has a good tool to search the quality of potable water in your street, with levels of hardness and chemicals. Flanders also has a seperate webpage with data on swimming water quality. In lakes, swimming pools and the sea.
They also have extensive reports and different datasets on water quality of measuring on the OpenDataForum.
So although a lot is going on water quality data in our regional governments, there is no easy way of measuring this on a national scale. ","Yes","No","Pieter-Jan Pauwels","Nisha Thompson","35"
"0ea6685d-e821-466c-94c5-01c51477b00a","global","2015-09-26T13:32:27","2015","sd","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Can't find any online resources for water quality in Sudan",,"Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Nisha Thompson","0"
"3a138c1d-77d0-4741-a77b-4461171d00c9","global","2015-09-20T06:01:55","2015","pk","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.mocc.gov.pk/gop/index.php?q=aHR0cDovLzE5Mi4xNjguNzAuMTM2L21vY2xjLy4vZnJtRGV0YWlscy5hc3B4P29wdD1taXNjbGlua3MmYW1wO2lkPTEy",,,,,"Government of Pakistan, Ministry of Climate Change","Yes","Yes","Only partial data, not raw data, just reports. ","Only partial data for some cities is available.","Yes","No","Nouman Nazim","Nisha Thompson","35"
"652ad00e-0862-4383-b2cd-a441ce80c67f","global","2015-09-25T16:25:58","2015","vc","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Unfortunately the Central Water & Sewage Authority in charge of water supply does not have any water quality or mention that they treat the water.
https://www.cwsasvg.com/wrmu.html",,"Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Nisha Thompson","0"
"b5b4b9b7-ce19-4620-aedb-00b0acee11b9","global","2015-10-02T05:14:55","2015","ml","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Budget execution ","General Direction of the budget","Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.
Added a link to budget documents and switched from unsure to ""no""","The aggregated spending data are [published monthly](https://www.finances.gouv.ml/index.php/2015-04-13-09-34-22/documents-budget) to show how the budget is executed. That mean that the detailed data are available, but there is no evidence if it is publicly available.","Yes","No","anonymous","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"8666ebed-05d8-468e-a2a3-4ccf8dd196c7","global","2015-09-18T16:41:09","2015","lc","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","There is no mention of water quality data on the water & sewage company that is in charge of water supply delivery. https://www.wascosaintlucia.com/departments","It is uncertain if the data for water quality exists. In fact, Saint Lucia does experience a lot of drought issues every months due to mainly pipelines burst on the roads.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Nisha Thompson","0"
"a8cddf3f-2268-4817-b549-57b43b60867c","global","2015-09-27T14:49:13","2015","kn","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Websites don't seem to be working. I can't find any information on water.","It is uncertain if water quality in St. Kitts and Nevis exists","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Nisha Thompson","0"
"1c8790c0-87b0-44e8-96a3-b4eb1adc087c","global","2015-08-21T20:29:31","2015","jm","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.nwcjamaica.com/WATER_TREATMENT.asp",,,,"Main service provider of water","National Water Commission","Yes","Yes","Data is not available on the site. So you don't know if it available in a timely manner or in bulk.","The National Water Commission (NWC), as Jamaica’s premier
water service provider, distributes more than 90%
of the potable water in the country, serving more
than 2,000,000 persons daily through more than
400,000 legal customer accounts. More than
500,000 Jamaicans are also served by sewerage
services provided by the NWC.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Nisha Thompson","35"
"5e52c92a-cef1-473b-b43b-85457b5f1d4b","global","2015-09-16T04:12:30","2015","gd","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.nawasa.gd/resources/water-treatment",,,,"NAWASA is responsible to the Ministry of Communications, Works, Physical Development, Public Utilities & ICT.","National Water and Sewage Authority (NAWASA)","Yes","Yes","While there is no data, they are treating water, which means they are collecting data. It is not available online. ",,"Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Nisha Thompson","35"
"ab682ec2-18ac-4f5a-a350-b3f32f3e2d15","global","2015-09-20T16:01:23","2015","dm","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Seems the Environmental Health Department is responsible for monitoring water quality
https://health.gov.dm/index.php/departments
Can't find any information about this on the website or any reports. ","Unsure if data exists, but there is no information online as to the quality of the water. The authority that directly responsible for water and its quality is DOWASCO (Dominica Water and Sewerage company). The website is https://www.dowasco.dm/.
The only information about water quality can be found at the link: https://www.dowasco.dm/index.php/water-quality. Again not in the format that this survey requires.
","Yes","No","Veronne Nicholas","Nisha Thompson","0"
"7ac587f4-d7f7-4d1f-9406-3b8f837e0cab","global","2015-09-28T05:18:17","2015","bm","water","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Safe Tank Water","Department of Health","Yes","Yes","They do collect data
https://www.gov.bm/portal/server..pt/components/com_joomlalib/gateway/PTARGS_0_2_5481_511_1994_43/http%3B/ptpublisher.gov.bm%3B7087/publishedcontent/publish/ministry_of_health_and_family_services/new_health/dept___health___safety_and_health___useful_information/content_items/safe_water_final.pdf
Just not available online. ","It is uncertain if data exists","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Nisha Thompson","5"
"517518a6-f3d4-4f0d-9849-841db84189ca","global","2015-10-20T00:19:24","2015","om","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","Oman does not use a postcodes/zipcode system that translates into a physical address. The postal system in Oman uses PO Boxes which are based at postal offices in each city and which the users have to visit to collect their mail.","Yes","No","Codrina Maria Ilie","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"dfe0ec69-70c9-44db-891d-4c0e13b9efbb","global","2015-09-20T14:55:55","2015","bb","water","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Water Quality","Barbados Water Authority","Yes","Yes","I have found mentions of the fact they are collecting water quality data
https://apps.unep.org/publications/pmtdocuments/-Report%20on%20Integrating%20Management%20of%20Watersheds%20and%20Coastal%20Areas%20in%20Small%20Island%20Developing%20States%20of%20the%20Caribbean:%20The%20Barbados%20National%20Report-2001Report%20on%20Integrating%20Management%20of%20Watersheds%20and%20Coastal%20Areas%20-%20Barbados%20National%20Report.pdf
Also they have a report listing water quality as important to know and are treating water.
https://barbadoswaterauthority.com/?page_id=58
So they have the data it is just not available online.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Nisha Thompson","5"
"ba6bc43a-3a02-4ce6-8fc6-2e67e8e1a41a","global","2015-09-25T17:17:17","2015","be","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The dataset is available from a third party, at charge https://www.geopostcodes.com/Belgium. ","There is no geospatial link for the postcodes. All that's available is the postcodes themselves with corresponding place names on the Belgian Postal Office (bpost) which is partially owned by the Belgian government (privatised public office). (https://www.bpost.be/site/nl/residential/customerservice/search/postal_codes.html). Unchanged since review in 2014.","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"f51fe059-be71-4549-b598-94c3a6cc9c3b","global","2015-09-23T10:47:57","2015","bs","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Can't find any evidence they are collecting water quality data. ","It is uncertain if water quality data exists in the Bahamas","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Nisha Thompson","0"
"c9e83357-bd9e-424e-95ee-a25be81e4abc","global","2015-09-28T00:02:20","2015","aw","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Can't find any government data. They do have water treatment plants which means they are collecting the data. https://www.waterworld.com/articles/2010/02/aruba-drinking-water-wastewater-disinfection-to-be-provided-by-berson-uv.html
Unclear if it is the government's data though. ","it is uncertain if water quality data in Aruba exists.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Nisha Thompson","0"
"92a5a12f-6863-48b3-8ea3-cfcbd1f87dd4","global","2015-09-20T22:37:13","2015","ag","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Can't find any proof of data collection or a gov body in charge of water supply.",,"Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Nisha Thompson","0"
"558dabc4-ddeb-4917-9e5d-5f5c9bb0745f","global","2015-09-27T23:32:20","2015","bw","postcodes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Unsure","No",,"Unsure",,,,,,"Ministry of lasnds and housing","Yes","Yes","ok","Botswanna does not have nor use Postal Codes.
Botswana is in the process of establishing postcodes and a street based addressing system, Land parcels (plots) are identified by a number which is allocated at the land board.
Unchanged since 2013.","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","10"
"9de22afe-847e-4913-b9a3-27717f9854b6","global","2015-08-29T16:30:37","2015","sv","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","El Salvador seems to have defined the following post code system https://www.upu.int/fileadmin/documentsFiles/activities/addressingUnit/slvEn.pdf.","In El Salvador we don´t use zipcodes for adresses or geographic distribution. And if it exists it´s not avaible by the public.","Yes","No","Iris Palma","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"4ac36e7c-3201-44e7-ac0b-b577398a22cf","global","2015-09-24T10:47:20","2015","mk","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Post code search service is not compliant with 2015 index requirements. ","The Postal Agency of Republic of Macedonia (https://www.ap.mk/) provides а free and easy to use search option (https://www.ap.mk/mk/griza-korisnici/postenski-kodovi), that lists the postal codes in the country, or lists the exact location (nearest city or village) if the postal code itself is entered. No latitudes or longitudes are provided.","Yes","No","Metamorphosis Foundation","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"0e00980d-26ee-4453-9d0d-0e1dbc6ba9fb","global","2015-09-17T09:53:06","2015","cz","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://nahlizenidokn.cuzk.cz/StahniAdresniMistaRUIAN.aspx","CSV",,,"https://vdp.cuzk.cz/vymenny_format/csv/ad-csv-struktura.pdf","Czech Office for Surveying, Mapping and Cadastre","Yes","Yes","ok","Data are part of basic register of territorial identification RUIAN.
There is no licence.
","Yes","No","Michaela Rybičková","Codrina Maria Ilie","70"
"dded178d-1df1-4bfb-92bb-41dc6562d5c1","global","2015-09-25T11:35:36","2015","kz","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.egov.kz/","JSON, xml",,,"The information about zipcodes is available on National Post Office website, whereas the rest of the information is available on Open Data Portal. Open Data Portal is certified and approved by government officials. ","National Post Office and Open Data Portal","Yes","Yes","ok","The address and coordinates are shown in most of the open data where possible. It is not accessible in bulk form yet. The information on Open Data Portal is provided by government officials. The information provided by government officials in Kazakhstan (by default) is open for reuse, publishing as cited by the law. ","Yes","No","Nazerke Akhmetzhanova","Codrina Maria Ilie","70"
"af347274-6e44-43c8-960e-da96609c70d6","global","2015-09-20T22:27:32","2015","pt","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.ctt.pt/feapl_2/app/open/tools.jspx?tool=1","CSV also arcview, kml, pdf",,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","The Portuguese postcodes/zipcodes data is [made available by CTT][1] (registration required)
CTT was the Portuguese national public mail service until 9 September 2014. Since this date it became a private company and there is no other public portal where the same data is made publicly available.
[1]: https://www.ctt.pt/feapl_2/app/open/postalCodeSearch/postalCodeSearch.jspx","Yes","No","Ricardo Lafuente","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"7ee7c120-6ef4-41f8-b3a3-02f94d5e0b2d","global","2015-09-27T12:14:17","2015","tl","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Can't find evidence of water quality data being collected, or who is in charge of monitoring water. https://apps.searo.who.int/PDS_DOCS/B4636.pdf","There are no dedicated department(s) nor ministry found from the official website Government of Timor-Leste https://timor-leste.gov.tl/?lang=en nor from the list of directories in the the official website Ministry of State Administration https://www.estatal.gov.tl/English/Directorates/Director_main.html that would cover the water quality at national level for Timor-Leste.","Yes","No","anonymous","Nisha Thompson","0"
"ea00d240-d07c-4d05-9431-90bd5cf620c5","global","2015-10-04T14:47:29","2015","et","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Ethiopia has a post code system as described https://www.upu.int/fileadmin/documentsFiles/activities/addressingUnit/ethEn.pdf
Third party dataset available https://eth.postcodebase.com/ ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"a9dffce3-fbef-4c8b-9d1c-0d2e455ff534","global","2015-08-31T14:54:10","2015","jo","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Jordan has post code system as described https://www.upu.int/fileadmin/documentsFiles/activities/addressingUnit/jorEn.pdf . ",,"Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"36121c5f-3759-41fa-9591-45e0b0d2f462","global","2015-09-09T07:57:06","2015","ph","water","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,"Local Water Utility Association","Department of Health","Yes","Yes","In the Philippines water is a local issue and water quality is measured at that level https://www.lwua.gov.ph/
Who has a groundwater database
https://122.54.214.222/
Water quality is mentioned but I can't find the parameters. But they generate reports with water quality so they do have the data.
",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Nisha Thompson","5"
"37330481-c107-4705-8ddb-e0d4b42c58ca","global","2015-09-09T18:38:40","2015","lb","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Lebanon uses post code system as described https://www.upu.int/fileadmin/documentsFiles/activities/addressingUnit/lbnEn.pdf . No available official data has been identified. ",,"Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"21ce31b4-4790-4104-a691-2f24395415c0","global","2015-08-31T15:37:31","2015","eg","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Egypt has a post code system as described https://www.upu.int/fileadmin/documentsFiles/activities/addressingUnit/egyEn.pdf. No official data has been identified. ","The website of the postal service has details about the location of postal offices, but does not provide any details on postal codes and their correspondence geospatial locations. It is suspected that Egypt does not use an address system that links postal addresses to physical locations. ","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"e68730ed-227f-4952-9b91-0b874a302e4f","global","2015-09-30T14:42:49","2015","ng","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Post code search service does not comply with 2015 index requirements. There is no indication that the dataset used in the post code search is geo-coded. Considering that the post code structure takes into consideration streets, the geo-coding operation is not a simple task.","The data cannot be downloaded in bulk.
The post code search service https://www.nigeriapostcodes.com/index.php/welcome/getUrbanPostCode returns a post code and zooms in at city level using Google Maps, but no geolocation specific information.
","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"1387ab80-4c32-4946-9ead-a9f0ed17aa22","global","2015-09-28T08:13:40","2015","mm","water","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","No information found. Though the filler page for the Environment issue speaks about water.
https://www.myanmarpresidentoffice.info/en/?q=issues/environment
It is unclear if they are collecting any data or processing any water. ","No evidence showing from the President's Officer website that the data is exist. https://www.myanmarpresidentoffice.info/en/ and the dedicated webpage for the cabinet ministries is empty https://www.myanmarpresidentoffice.info/en/?q=cabinet/ministries so no way to find out who are the responsible minister involve. I have found a 3rd party website https://www.ourweb.info/01/directory/myanmar/005/ that provide a list of ministries official websites but some of these websites are not found.
Kindly note that there is a high possibility that Myanmar government did not update each of these ministries websites so there is an error while trying to gain access to these websites.","Yes","No","anonymous","Nisha Thompson","0"
"6ca3be10-cc22-4e42-9c61-2950ddf601d1","global","2015-09-12T14:26:21","2015","dz","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","In Algeria, the postal codes of province capitals are composed of the province code as in ISO 3166-2:DZ and three zeros, for example: 16000 for Algiers, while the postal codes of other cities, towns, and villages in the province are the provincial code followed by three numerals. [Wikipedia]
The Algerian Post website (https://www.poste.dz/) has a link to search for postal codes ""Rechercher Un Code Postal"", but it is not working. The link is removed from most of the pages now, though, we found it on this page (https://www.poste.dz/Actualite/actua.php#) which seems to be an older version of the site that was not updated.
","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"e2825815-9f04-4dbc-8c9f-807e87fe1ba3","global","2015-09-28T07:06:12","2015","id","water","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Couldn't find any data or reference to data. ","No data found under this category","Yes","No","anonymous","Nisha Thompson","0"
"5dce89c2-7679-47ee-8fa5-441c6bb63dd4","global","2015-09-18T14:30:50","2015","ro","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The post code dataset does not comply with the 2015 index requirements, as there is no lat-long association to post codes, nor is there an fast easy way to do it, due to the structure of the post codes spatial distribution. ","The national open data portal provides in open format:
- the postcodes dataset
- the administrative boundaries dataset
But no connection between the two. ","Yes","No","Ovidiu Voicu","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"38e52bfd-56dc-44c3-9340-9e9296a8a569","global","2015-10-09T14:10:02","2015","qa","companies","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","No evidence that the dataset exists, but I have updated the details section with information on two non-governmental directories.","The Ministry of Economy and Commerce (https://www.mec.gov.qa/en) is responsible for the registration of companies in Qatar, but there is no evidence of any data on its website or elsewhere.
However, the Qatar Chamber of Commerce (a non-government organisation) has a searchable companies directory: https://qatarchamber.com/2311 as does the Qatar Financial Centre Authority: https://www.qfc.qa/company-register/Pages/cro-search.aspx The QFC register includes information on date of registration and licence status, and has the ability to search by company director. It does not contain address information, but the Chamber of Commerce directory does.","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"69604795-c129-4a76-8ce6-c96df9662d79","global","2015-09-27T02:33:59","2015","tt","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Unsure that the data compliant to the 2015 index requirements exists (post code with lat-long)","In 2012 Trinidad implemented a postal code system. The Trinidad & Tobago Postal Corporation is responsible for managing its implementation. The Corporation's website provides information about the implementation of the programme, its benefits and the coding system.
However, it does not currently provide information to assist a person finding out a specific postal code if they know the address. The website states that ""When we are ready, TTPost will provide a Postal Code Finder on our website. Customers can also find out their postal code by contacting any TTPost outlet."".","Yes","No","Matthew McNaughton","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"4296c211-b438-4397-97d6-b6aeeb133dd7","global","2015-09-28T06:34:59","2015","kh","water","Yes","Unsure","No","No","Unsure","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Water Quality","Ministry of Water Resources and Meteorology","Yes","Yes","They do collect water quality data and the MOWRAM is responsible to collect.
https://www.dhrw-cam.org/water_map_picture.php
They have stations and data (data table link not working), so it is there, just not available.
","The directory over the list of ministries available in Cambodia can be found from here https://www.cdc-crdb.gov.kh/cdc/other_link/ministry.htm and no data found from Ministry of Water Resources and Meteorology https://www.mowram.gov.kh/","Yes","No","anonymous","Nisha Thompson","5"
"1257c59d-f754-41af-adfa-6e38a2367e14","global","2015-09-30T20:16:50","2015","tz","companies","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Company name search feature appears to have gone, so I have updated the details accordingly.","The Business Registrations and Licencing Agency (BRELA) is the government agency that has started recently to list registered companies in Tanzania. (https://www.brela.go.tz/) Previously there was a company name search feature available on its website, but this appears to have gone, and there is no other form of company data in evidence.","Yes","No","Joachim Mangilima","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"b5d1532e-7726-48d1-9b2d-02efc6c50e58","global","2015-09-25T17:15:07","2015","de","water","Yes","Yes","Unsure","No","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,"Umweltbundesamt","Yes","Yes","Drinking water is the responsibility of the municipality so it makes sense that the data will be with local open data portals. It also seems that water has no overall regulatory body so there isn't a reason for the data to be aggregated to a national level.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Water_supply_and_sanitation_in_Germany#Policy_and_regulation","Data exist, but didn't found it as open data
see https://www.umweltbundesamt.de/themen/wasser/trinkwasser/trinkwasserqualitaet/daten-zur-trinkwasserqualitaet
""Die EG-Trinkwasserrichtlinie verpflichtet die Mitgliedstaaten, der EU-Kommission alle drei Jahre über die Trinkwasserbeschaffenheit zu berichten. Der jüngste Bericht von BMG und UBA an die EU-Kommission berücksichtigt die Jahre 2008 bis 2010. Die Qualität des Trinkwassers ist exzellent - über 99 Prozent der Proben hält Grenzwerte ein.""
For Hamburg another dataset exists (other indicators as mentionend above)
https://gateway.hamburg.de/hamburggateway/fvp/fv/BSU/wasserguete/wfWassergueteAnfrageListe.aspx?sid=37#
but requesting the data didn't work as of 25/09/15
No dataset for Germany found on opengovdata.de but for the city of Bonn https://opendata.bonn.de/dataset/trinkwasseranalyse
","Yes","No","walter palmetshofer","Nisha Thompson","10"
"365ec7bf-1451-4aff-99b6-129d3d0828c9","global","2015-10-02T05:35:37","2015","ml","companies","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I am marking the dataset is non-existent as we don't have any direct evidence that it exists. Assuming the data must exist somewhere is not the same as knowing it exists, where or in what form.","The Investment Promotion Agency gives advice on how to start a business in Mali: https://www.apimali.gov.ml/api/en/index.php?page=start-a-business and has a step-by-step registration procedure on its eRegulations portal: https://mali.eregulations.org/procedure/2/4?l=fr but does not indicate where company registry data is held or how to access it.","Yes","No","anonymous","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"efb31c64-2047-4db2-a091-96b6bfe2b0fa","global","2015-09-14T11:09:35","2015","at","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.trinkwasserinfo.at/",,,,"Trinkwasserinfo (Info on Drinking Water) and Wasser Informationssystem Austria (Water Information System Austria)","Lebensministerium (The Austrian Federal Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry, Environment and Water Management) ","Yes","Yes","Report is correct, covers correct parameters. ","There are 2 main sources on this indicator - A) Drinking Water Info Portal by Austrian Environment Agency (https://www.trinkwasserinfo.at/, see also more infos here: https://www.umweltbundesamt.at/umweltsituation/wasser/trinkwasser/) and B) Water Quality info & data by The Austrian Federal Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry, Environment and Water Management (see: https://gis.bmlfuw.gv.at/at.lfrz.wisadwh/Home.html = water information system Austria).
As often in environmental area the data is not fully open but caught in maps and reports etc - but its available timely and updated continuously.","Yes","No","Martin Kaltenböck","Nisha Thompson","30"
"578f8641-4023-4427-9cc6-39315e159980","global","2015-09-15T16:45:48","2015","il","postcodes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,"Survey of Israel ","Yes","Yes","ok","There is a zipcode address map, but it is up-do-date to 2012 and it's updated to the old zipcode system in Israel and cost 30,000 shekels. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Codrina Maria Ilie","5"
"fc603613-18a5-4208-8d6d-853bf69b93f3","global","2015-10-12T11:14:56","2015","tr","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","Data does not include geo location data and therefore the dataset doesn't exist. Link to current data - https://postakodu.ptt.gov.tr/","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"7d83671b-bec7-4e2a-9a17-f2d8578a6b5d","global","2015-09-09T06:20:19","2015","kr","postcodes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Yes","No",,"Yes",,"Shapefile",,,,,"Yes","Yes","The webpage does not seem to work from outside Rep of Korea. ""National Spatial Data Distribution System is only available in Korea.""","Short after introducing the new address system called ""Road Name Address,"" the Republic of Korea has also reformed the postal code system into the so-called ""[State Basic District System][1]."" Addresses with the new postal codes are freely available in bulk on the [site][2] of ""Road Name Address,"" but the dataset does not include coordinates.
The dataset which meets the minimum criteria can be found on the Website of the [National Spatial Information Clearinghouse (NSIC)][3]. However, the dataset is not publicly available requesting the registration. However, people can freely download in bulk daily changes of address data with its coordinates on the Korean Website of ""Road Name Address.""
[1]: https://www.koreapost.go.kr/notice/eview.action?contId=e3010000&agencyCode=kpost&order=regDt%20desc&page=1&pagesize=10¬iIdx=24114
[2]: https://www.juso.go.kr/support/AddressBuild.do
[3]: https://www.nsic.go.kr/","Yes","No","James G. Boram Kim","Codrina Maria Ilie","35"
"50a630c1-738e-449d-bc7a-31cfb7819244","global","2015-09-25T09:48:53","2015","za","water","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Unsure","No",,"Unsure",,,,,"Blue Drop System","Water and Sanitation","Yes","Yes","Municipalities are responsible for data collection but the Blue Drop System is supposed to monitor them. Despite Blue Drop System giving ratings and assessing that water was ""safe"" https://www.dwa.gov.za/dir_ws/DWQR/Default.asp?Pageid=21&WSID=797&WSACode=TSH
https://www.dwa.gov.za/dir_ws/DWQR/Default.asp?Pageid=40&PageHeading=Compliance%20Overview&Prov=0&wsa=0
The actual water quality reports are not anywhere to be seen. It seems the municipalities send the data to this system and then it is assessed as safe or not. No sharing or opening up of data. ","The department of water and sanitation monitors the quality of South African water through programs such as the [Blue Drop System](https://www.dwaf.gov.za/dir_ws/DWQR/). It is not clear how to get at the data or in what form it is available. ","Yes","No","Greg Kempe","Nisha Thompson","10"
"697516ff-50c4-47e5-8bc7-26c440425c1c","global","2015-09-27T17:13:31","2015","ms","companies","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I have marked the dataset as non-existent as there is no evidence of it on any official government portal.","The Monserrat Development Unit has a guide to creating and registering companies: https://www.devunit.gov.ms/company.htm but there is no evidence where that data is held, what it is, or how to access it.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"ea027eeb-2eef-44e9-82fb-e17a3dcfdf92","global","2015-10-09T15:30:50","2015","nl","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://geodata.nationaalgeoregister.nl/inspireadressen/extract/inspireadressen.zip","xml","https://www.pdok.nl/nl/over-pdok/uw-speciale-aandacht/copyright",,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","As part of the ""BAG"" data which contains all addresses and buildings in the Netherlands. The data set is most likely public domain (In this https://geodata.nationaalgeoregister.nl/inspireadressen/atom/inspireadressen.xml the description link yields an XML that specifies public domain), and the national data portal lists the BAG as public domain (although provides faulty links) https://data.overheid.nl/data/dataset/basisregistratie-adressen-en-gebouwen-bag-. The downloaded data set does not contain licensing info.
Cadastre is the data holder but they provide no direct mention of the data set on their own site, just a reference to their paid for services. They are however listed as data holder and contact info in the links above as well.
The data dump is a 1.4 GB zip file, that contains 7 other zip files, yielding over 30GB of data when unpacked, split up in 21MB xml files. This is the full BAG data set, containing all addresses and buildings for all of the Netherlands. From this dataset you need to combine several subsets to get to a full postcode list: The ‘NUM’ files give you address index numbers, its georeferences, the house number and the postcode, and a number that corresponds with a street. The ‘OPR’ files give you the corresponding street name, and the number of the place it is in. The ‘WPL’ files give you the place name, and through a separate table also the municipality it is in. (Do note that is does not include postcodes that are not connected to geolocations, such as PO Boxes) See for a detailed description of the search for the Dutch postcode data; https://www.zylstra.org/blog/2013/10/theoretically-open-post-codes-not-so-much-in-practice/
[No changes from 2013]
Update 2015: The opacity described above remains, but same link to data still valid.
","Yes","Yes","Sander van der Waal","Codrina Maria Ilie","100"
"ae9f8c81-829e-4ff2-a57d-6da1d797f7a8","global","2015-09-27T06:09:52","2015","jp","water","Yes","Yes","No","No","Unsure","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Living Environment - https://www.mhlw.go.jp/english/wp/wp-hw8/dl/03e.pdf","Ministry of Health, Labour, and Welfare","Yes","Yes","The reason I changed the answer to Yes the data exists. Is because the government is collecting it as referenced by the Ministry of Health https://www.mhlw.go.jp/english/wp/wp-hw8/dl/03e.pdf
It is their responsibility to monitor it.
However, water quality data itself is in the hands of the municipal and local utilities. So yes the data exists, is being collected by government, is send to the central ministry for reports, but the real time useful data is not at the national level.
I.e Tokyo's water quality data - https://www.waterworks.metro.tokyo.jp/suigen/kekka/today.html#suishitu","Water Quality data is available on this page. Yearly published.
* Publish
* https://www.nies.go.jp/igreen/
* Data Column details
* https://www.nies.go.jp/igreen/explain/water/content_w.html
Comparizon with minimum requirement and this dataset.
* fecal coliform 大腸菌 < OK
* arsenic ヒ素 < OK
* fluoride levels フッ素 < OK
* nitrates 硝酸 < OK
* TDS (Total dissolved solids) 総溶解固形分 < Not available
Also, each prefectures publish their own inspects from their web page.
Some of those data are available monthly/yearly, not Open.","Yes","No","Satoshi IIDA","Nisha Thompson","10"
"803694da-86ab-47ff-b4d8-c8319582f19b","global","2015-09-08T17:50:35","2015","ae","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","The UAE does not use a postcode/zip code system. It is unknown if the required data under this category is available in the UAE.
No official admin boundaries shapes have been identified.
Admin boundaries can be downloaded from different third parties:
https://www.gadm.org/download
https://uaeugis.blogspot.ro/2015/04/uae-admin-boundaries.html","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"01f918ea-91cc-4694-af03-5b006d80fb88","global","2015-09-25T15:48:49","2015","ma","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.data.gov.ma/data/fr/group/cartographie","Excel","https://www.data.gov.ma/fr/licence",,"Liste des agences de Poste Maroc avec coordonnées spatiales ","Poste Maroc","Yes","Yes","ok","https://www.data.gov.ma/data/fr/group/cartographie","Yes","Yes","Chadi Nanaa","Codrina Maria Ilie","100"
"3d0989b1-0fa7-4bd9-9dfa-f177615e5aab","global","2015-10-06T12:32:31","2015","sv","companies","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","All fine!","It was not available on the research for the Open Data Global Index 2015. National Registration Centre website is under construction, data is not available. Address: https://www.cnr.gob.sv/","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"eacb8887-c075-4b36-87be-45fb0b724c67","global","2015-09-07T18:14:48","2015","qa","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","admin boundaries https://www.gadm.org/download","Qatar does not use a postcode/zip code system. It is unknown if there is a dataset of administrative borders with the required descriptions is available.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"87e4412f-07c0-4f0c-8ff8-98cd464a3552","global","2015-01-21T21:50:27","2015","mx","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://busca.datos.gob.mx/#/conjuntos/ubicacion-de-codigos-postales-en-mexico","KML","https://datos.gob.mx/libreusomx/",,"Postal codes national catalog is delivered by Correos de Mexico and is published by free for personal use, it is not allowed to be sold, entirely or partially, or third party distribution","SEPOMEX (Correos de Mexico)","Yes","Yes","ok","SEPOMEX (Mexico Postal Service) provides up to date information about postal codes, last update being on Jan.15, 2015.","Yes","Yes","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","90"
"3384fd3a-a312-4aa9-ae9f-7cbba14e2f9d","global","2015-09-20T06:51:04","2015","ko","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","Kosovo uses a post code system but no official data was found. https://www.upu.int/fileadmin/documentsFiles/activities/addressingUnit/xskEn.pdf
The administrative boundaries can be downloaded from https://www.gadm.org/download. The shapefile is not officially endorsed. ","Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"513310a7-c3d5-4ee5-ad79-b2d9caca891a","global","2015-10-02T23:16:05","2015","uy","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","No","No",,"No","https://www.ose.com.uy/calidad_del_agua/calidad_del_agua.html",,,,"Water Quality","Obras Sanitarias del Estado","Yes","Yes","Seems there is data for the from the national water utility. Most of the parameters are covered. The only problem is that I'm not sure on the location of the testing. If they are doing it at access points or out of the processing plant","Sparse information from specific studies has been compiled by an NGO (https://vidasilvestre.org.uy/wp-content/uploads/2013/09/informeaguafinalcm1.pdf) but no official source for national-level water quality data.
On a local level, updated and quality information can be found for the capital (Montevideo): https://www.montevideo.gub.uy/ciudad-y-cultura/deportes-y-playas/playasciudad-y-cultura/deportes-y-playas/playasciudad-y-cultura/deportes-y-playas/playas/metodologia-de/informes","Yes","No","Daniel Carranza","Nisha Thompson","20"
"aafe9c2c-4117-4069-91a9-f085570f5a6d","global","2015-09-18T21:29:49","2015","is","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.skra.is/lisalib/getfile.aspx?itemid=8424","DSV SHP","https://www.skra.is/?PageId=401e3483-e1ac-48c9-aec0-5159581d2222",,,"Þjóðskrá Íslands / Landmælingar Íslands","Yes","Yes","ok","The data comes from two different public bodies. Access address registry is available from Þjóðskrá Íslands (National registry). Border polygons come from Landmælingar Íslands (National land survey).
National land survey's website requires registration where a link (which expires in 2 days) is emailed to the user. However the national open data portal, https://opingogn.is contains a direct link to the data without registration. That can be regarded as an official source for this index.
Links to data and license are restricted to the access address registry. Boundaries are available at https://opingogn.is/dataset/is-50v-mork-isn93 under this license https://www.lmi.is/wp-content/uploads/2013/10/Almskilm.pdf","Yes","Yes","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Codrina Maria Ilie","100"
"47a32641-0b0d-4478-9ee5-6e3029155afd","global","2015-10-02T04:52:06","2015","ci","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","no data seem to be existent","Yes","No","anonymous","yar michl","0"
"996cfc15-22f2-4a45-b4ad-dbdfead27da2","global","2015-09-20T07:44:06","2015","gr","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","You can search for a postal code : https://www.elta.gr/en-us/findapostcode.aspx But that does not give you the corresponding geospatial location of that postal code. Unsure if that data exists.
The dataset can be downloaded at charge from GeoData
https://www.geopostcodes.com/Greece","Yes","No","Charalampos Bratsas","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"73d61094-5ab2-48b6-a23f-80bc4eb84e1f","global","2015-10-04T13:36:48","2015","az","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","Azerbaijan has a post code system https://www.upu.int/fileadmin/documentsFiles/activities/addressingUnit/azeEn.pdf but no official data is available.
Post code data is available at charge here https://www.geopostcodes.com/Azerbaijan","Yes","No","Codrina Maria Ilie","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"d363e50f-59f5-4eb1-90e9-1cc1b6701421","global","2015-09-27T23:53:07","2015","ec","emissions","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","seem the data only exist for the city of Quito for all Pollutant
[link][1]
because the data is only existent for one city
its may need to change the data dosnt exist
[1]: https://www.cleanairinstitute.org/calidaddelaireamericalatina/cai-report-english.pdf","Yes","No","Eduardo Bejar","yar michl","10"
"9e6675d7-6d15-4a48-9853-6d746ed58b6c","global","2015-08-24T03:46:58","2015","my","postcodes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","From the Department of Statistics Malaysia official portal, there datasets are not available. Given that the institution is in the Federal State territory, submitting for Freedom of Information request is impossible because there is no Freedom of Information Act for the Federal State Wilayah Persekutuan.","Yes","No","Hazwany Jamaluddin","Codrina Maria Ilie","5"
"7fe12b15-fe64-43fe-a2cb-397c2ac47927","global","2015-09-13T10:13:10","2015","tn","postcodes","Yes","Yes","No","No","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,,"La Poste Tunisienne ","Yes","Yes","Post code search service is no longer compliant with 2015 index requirements. ","Same as last year. Previous year's comment follows:
The website https://www.poste.tn/codes.php allows to map a locality to a zip code, but the data is not open (according to the Open Definition).
It is also possible to map a locality with latitude/longitude in this official government web site https://interieur.gov.tn/projects/geodata/# This second website is under Creative Commons by 3.0 licence (https://opendata.interieur.gov.tn/ar/catalog/coordonnees-des-chefs-lieux-des-gouvernorats-de-la-republique-tunisienne). ","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Codrina Maria Ilie","25"
"32efe0a4-c4c2-4fc8-92a9-f77280007548","global","2015-09-02T15:49:40","2015","iq","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","It seems Iraq has a database of postcodes (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_postal_codes_in_Iraq), but it is not georeferenced. We could not find the data on official website of postal service (https://www.iraqipost.net/).
","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"03fe4c6a-de0b-496c-984d-fc76ca3fde17","global","2015-09-27T23:19:40","2015","gy","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","postcodes/zipcodes do not exist
Administrative boundaries are available https://www.gadm.org/download. We have not identified any official datasets of administrative boundaries. ","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"7742539f-3c7d-4b86-9a43-a7794f6cab8e","global","2015-09-08T13:43:09","2015","sa","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","Saudi Arabia uses 2 post code systems: https://www.upu.int/fileadmin/documentsFiles/activities/addressingUnit/sauEn.pdf
No dataset has been identified.
","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"00028a40-6bfe-45d9-838b-c324bf43a43f","global","2015-08-27T13:52:11","2015","cl","companies","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I've added details of an official government company name search tool by the Ministry of Economy, Development and Tourism, which would tend to indicate that the Ministry holds other more detailed information, but there is no direct evidence of it.","The Ministry of Economy, Development and Tourism has a facility for checking whether company names are registered, which doubles as a search engine of sorts for registered companies and their ID numbers: https://www.empresaen1dia.cl/res.verificamarcasmp.aspx
However, there is no evidence of more detailed company data being available.
There is also an unofficial online directory of Chilean companies current to 2012, provided by the non-profit SOFOFA, which can be freely browsed. https://www.sofofa.cl/Net/DirectorioIndustrial/Consulta/WebForms/Buscar.aspx","Yes","No","Ahumada Abrigouis Alberto L","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"42877b33-d204-46c2-af66-1d133f76ed59","global","2015-10-12T17:49:35","2015","tj","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,"https://meteo.tj/",,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","no data seem to be existent","Yes","No","anonymous","yar michl","0"
"58d08f1b-f751-4845-9603-87660321a05d","global","2015-09-27T23:50:01","2015","ec","postcodes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,,"Agencia Nacional Postal","Yes","Yes","post code search service does not comply with 2015 index requirements. I didn't find any way to download the data. ","Postcodes were launched in Ecuador in 2013.","Yes","No","Eduardo Bejar","Codrina Maria Ilie","20"
"56a32a15-3fb6-43e7-ba8b-59b158703822","global","2015-09-28T15:30:56","2015","gh","emissions","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","
its seem the data is but to the public
Fortunately, the World Health Organization (WHO) has been doing a very good work at making the updated 2014
inventory of the Outdoor Air Quality, available from who.int/phe/health_topics/outdoorair/en/. From
their inventory, it appears that except from the Republics of Senegal and South Africa which we already inventoried on aqicn.org,
4 other countries are also providing readings, namely: **Ghana,** Liberia, Tanzania and Mauritius
[link][1]
[1]: https://aqicn.org/faq/2015-04-08/air-quality-in-africa-and-middle-east/
","Yes","No","Nehemiah Attigah","yar michl","5"
"a5114e53-fd87-4434-b920-4e0f97c8377d","global","2015-09-21T19:07:07","2015","ko","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"No","https://www.ammk-rks.net/?page=1,21","word",,,,"Kosovo Environmental Protection Agency","Yes","Yes","checked","seem to have Monthly Report in word
all Pollutant are measured except of VOCs
more data on the air Development of an Air Quality Monitoring Network
for Kosovo can been fond in this [link][1]
[1]: https://aqicn.org/aqicn/view/faq/images/balkans/VisareHoxha_CapstoneProject_Report_12-13-2010.pdf","Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","yar michl","50"
"54d9f618-8f87-46f6-bf84-3be94ffaf300","global","2015-10-01T10:18:42","2015","bj","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","Yes","Unsure",,"No",,"shp",,,"Carte administrative après la décentralisation","Institut géographique national","Yes","Yes","Benin does not have a post code system. ","There is a administrative map managed by the national geographic institute. This data contain the administrative borders of each administrative area. The data is not available online and must be paid when requested.","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","30"
"18c24011-76a7-4167-a37c-30539247e8f1","global","2015-09-28T12:28:39","2015","gg","postcodes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,,"Guernsey Post","Yes","Yes","Post Code finder does not comply to 2015 index requirements. ","ad hoc postcode search free on official Guernsey Post website
bulk dataset only available with a commercial use fee from suppliers such as Guernsey Post, PostcodePal, etc.
Administrative boundaries can be found here, published by Digimap: https://sog.maps.arcgis.com/apps/Viewer/index.html?appid=6cda1f29554b417ab2193c4f2092f65e or
https://www.gadm.org/download
Post code data is available at charge: https://www.geopostcodes.com/Guernsey","Yes","No","Marcus Ferbrache","Codrina Maria Ilie","20"
"ceae2891-d7b1-4d22-8a43-f6d02cd2dc70","global","2015-09-27T22:48:56","2015","gy","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"No","https://www.statisticsguyana.gov.gy/census.html",,,,"2012 Population & Housing Census ","Bureau of Statistics","Yes","Yes","Most data are reasonably current. No open license. ","Annual [GDP][1] up to 2014 in PDF Download.
[Population][2] up to 2013 in PDF.
No unemployment data found.
[1]: https://www.statisticsguyana.gov.gy/download.php?file=17
[2]: https://www.statisticsguyana.gov.gy/demo.html","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Zach Christensen","45"
"c1a5c538-54a4-4349-b403-b717c73be8d1","global","2015-10-01T12:13:40","2015","ky","postcodes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,,"Cayman Islands Postal Service","Yes","Yes","Post code finder service does not comply with 2015 index requirements. ","The post code data is available at charge here https://www.geopostcodes.com/goto_Cayman_Islands","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Codrina Maria Ilie","20"
"44b53d12-12d8-47e4-a225-bc5c5509d086","global","2015-09-24T15:42:18","2015","sd","companies","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","There is not enough evidence that the dataset exists in the form that OKF requires, but the details provided about the company name database are good. ","The Ministry of Justice of Sudan is responsible for the commercial register. Its website has a feature to look for registered company names, to help users in applying for names which are not taken already (https://www.crd.gov.sd/searchtst22sql.php). This search engine does not provide any details about the companies themselves and no other information appears to be available on the internet about this dataset.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"11c77f5a-593f-47ad-8c7b-32e868aa4609","global","2015-08-30T15:42:52","2015","np","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://www.gpo.gov.np/postalcode.aspx",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The dataset does not comply with the 2015 index requirements.I have been unable to find official administrative boundaries that would allow an attribute join. ","Data is under the GPO of Nepal. No geolocation - https://www.gpo.gov.np/postalcode.aspx","Yes","No","Nikesh Balami","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"e63736bc-0e56-4c64-864b-16e741703fc5","global","2015-09-15T09:40:24","2015","dz","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.ons.dz/",,,,,"Office National des Statistiques","Yes","Yes","Data aren't regular, no open licensing.","[Unemployment][1] up to 2013.
[Population][2] up to 2008.
[1]: https://www.ons.dz/-EMPLOI-ET-CHOMAGE-au-Quatrieme,56-.html
[2]: https://www.ons.dz/-EMPLOI-ET-CHOMAGE-au-Quatrieme,56-.html","Yes","No","Aldja Computer","Zach Christensen","35"
"d1a1ad9a-e41a-4fb8-8ca2-9f10d794cb98","global","2015-09-20T15:00:11","2015","dm","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"No","https://www.finance.gov.dm/index.php/statistics",,"https://www.finance.gov.dm/index.php/copyright-privacy-notices",,"2011 population and housing census, (preliminary report); a summary report of 2005 census","Ministry of Finance, Statistical Division","Yes","Yes","Data are not very recent but there is some openness. ","The census report is available online in pdf format only. Additional information may have to requested from the department.
The reports however, are not timely. There is none available for previous years online and none available post 2011 population and housing census report.
","Yes","No","Veronne Nicholas","Zach Christensen","75"
"9f868765-a823-490c-996b-b82a1e60133b","global","2015-09-22T02:43:16","2015","bo","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure",,"No","https://www.ine.gob.bo/default.aspx","Excel, html",,,,"Instituto Nacional de Estadística","Yes","Yes","Data are available but not very current and no with open license. ","[GDP][1] up to 2015
[Unemployment][2] up to 2010.
[Population][3] up to 2011.
[1]: https://www.ine.gob.bo/indice/general.aspx?codigo=40204
[2]: https://www.ine.gob.bo/indice/EstadisticaSocial.aspx?codigo=30406
[3]: https://www.ine.gob.bo/indice/EstadisticaSocial.aspx?codigo=30801","Yes","No","Mariana Leyton","Zach Christensen","50"
"be5cb135-f945-498f-b2f7-03343ac5dd52","global","2015-10-07T01:50:37","2015","cn","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.saic.gov.cn/ywbl/zxcx/djqyxxcx/index.html",,,,"Corporate Information Search","State Administration for Industry & Commerce of the People's Republic of China","Yes","Yes","Changes made, publisher and title added, more details added in description.","Database can be browsed by submitting a blank search query (though only from this page: https://gzhd.saic.gov.cn:8281/other/chaxun/listQyName.jsp), but only 10 results display at a time. The limit to the number of results displayed is a severe logistical limitation to using the database.
The data available at national level might not include certain companies which are registered at city/province level.
There is also a browseable government list of enterprises available here: https://zxjg.saic.gov.cn/saicmrktout/etpsPublish.do?method=toEtpsList&infoType=1# though it is unclear how comprehensive it is.","Yes","No","OKFN CN","Rebecca Sentance","35"
"9ba61048-0abd-4cfd-9587-23fa40a2f4c2","global","2015-09-17T19:34:33","2015","us","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Unsure","https://www.census.gov/geo/maps-data/data/gazetteer2015.html","txt","https://ask.census.gov/faq.php?id=5000&faqId=431",,"Zip-Code Tabulation Areas (ZCTA)","US Census Bureau","Yes","Yes","ok","This dataset in the US presents some challenges as there is a mixture of data available.
The US Census provide zip-code centroids as part of their 2010 Gazetteer located at https://www.census.gov/geo/maps-data/data/gazetteer2010.html in the form of the Zip-Code Tabulation Areas:
https://www.census.gov/geo/maps-data/data/docs/gazetteer/Gaz_zcta_national.zip
This data is open data (openly licensed, and machine readable etc).
However, there are some limitations of this data as it is based off the census, the last of which was in 2010. Thus, over time this database gets out of date versus the authoritative data held by the USPS. Given this, the data is marked as not timely.
In addition, the ZCTA isn’t as complete as the USPS zip-code list as it focused on geographical areas and so its coverage of e.g. PO boxes is more limited. However, given the specifications of this dataset this should not be considered a major limitation and so we have not docked points anywhere else.
### More on Zip-Codes and the USPS
The full database of zip codes from the USPS has not yet been found although it looks like products are available for sale, and they are multiple datasets that can help to provide a whole picture.
The ZCTA file produced by the US Census Bureau is useful but is not the full USPS Database of Zip Codes and lookup tables. Instead, this is a census related product produced every 10 years.
""You may have noticed that Census Bureau products refer to “ZIP Code tabulation areas (ZCTAs)” and not simply to ZIP Codes™. The reason that we cannot tabulate data for ZIP Codes is that they do not have distinct geographic boundaries. Designed by the U.S. Postal Service for use in mail delivery, ZIP Codes represent carrier routes made up of individual addresses. A true representation of ZIP Codes would separate out individual housing units and releasing data for them would risk disclosing personally identifiable information"". https://ask.census.gov/faq.php?id=5000&faqId=10488
The ZCTAs are not the same as the (regularly updated) USPS postal code lookup files or the postal code database with addresses and Lat Long. Those data are for sale and a number of USPS services are resold.
There is an USPS API for companies to integrate their their systems - https://www.usps.com/business/web-tools-apis/address-information-api.htm
Some date exchange for companies - https://www.usps.com/postalone/program.htm
Segmentation direct mail tools https://www.usps.com/business/pdf/Segmentation_WP.pdf
Lots of info about databases and services - https://about.usps.com/publications/pub32/pub32_terms.htm
and lots of private sector tools such as https://www.zip-codes.com/zip-code-database.asp?gclid=CLG5_NWPncICFWSK2wodgIQAnA
In addition, there are also some crosswalk files made by HUDs and posted on data.gov https://catalog.data.gov/dataset/hud-usps-zip-code-crosswalk-files","Yes","Yes","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","90"
"e3c604b5-49b6-40f8-a244-9816c678c7fc","global","2015-09-27T22:01:38","2015","az","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.stat.gov.az/indexen.php",".xls","https://www.stat.gov.az/source/others/sahibkar2013.pdf",,"Statistical database","The State Statistical Committee of the Republic of Azerbaijan","Yes","Yes","Data are current and machine readable. ",,"Yes","Yes","Codrina Maria Ilie","Zach Christensen","100"
"42934456-0011-4dad-924c-f16cf95c5ae5","global","2015-10-07T01:59:59","2015","cn","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","No single data source meets the minimum criteria set by index (2015 version)","Yes","No","OKFN CN","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"79386821-d464-4494-8fba-1413c747ebef","global","2015-09-28T11:48:17","2015","ge","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The data is not geocoded. There is no simple task to geo-reference the available information. Does not comply. ","There is a database of postal codes available online, but it only provides street information, without geospatial coordinates.
https://www.gpost.ge/?site-lang=ka&site-path=help/zipcodes/&letter=%E1%83%99
The National Agency of Public registry is the maintainer of postal codes, but does not make this information public for free. ","Yes","No","Eric Barrett","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"64732491-dcc1-410d-9384-c94766630cf6","global","2015-10-02T04:13:58","2015","ci","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","There is no zipcodes system,however the administrative boundaries data seems to be available, but there is no evidence
Unofficial administrative boundaries available https://www.gadm.org/","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"f9640332-5297-41d3-9769-52484b94e75f","global","2015-10-03T08:32:11","2015","gn","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","Guinea has a postal code system https://www.upu.int/fileadmin/documentsFiles/activities/addressingUnit/ginEn.pdf
but we were unable to identified any post code dataset available. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"562cead6-321c-4184-85c9-bdc174878af8","global","2015-09-27T21:37:39","2015","uy","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://catalogodatos.gub.uy/dataset/codigo-postal","KML, SHP","https://datos.gub.uy/wps/wcm/connect/856cc1804db0463baa8bea01b72d8394/terminos-catalogodatos.pdf?MOD=AJPERES&ContentCache=NONE&CACHEID=856cc1804db0463baa8bea01b72d8394",,"Código Postal","Correo Uruguayo","Yes","Yes","ok",,"Yes","Yes","Daniel Carranza","Codrina Maria Ilie","100"
"ad620ca5-9603-45f0-b010-9995b6a51661","global","2015-09-19T18:00:32","2015","aw","statistics","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.overheid.aw/actueel/rapporten-en-documenten_43353/",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Little data is available and not openly licensed or machine readable. ","National Statistical Yearbook available for [2012][1] but it has limited data on GDP, Unemployment, and Population.
[1]: https://www.overheid.aw/news/reports-and-documents_43370/","Yes","No","Kimberly Soares","Zach Christensen","0"
"0879b544-1861-4d6f-9e97-a5e81312a308","global","2015-09-23T22:46:06","2015","bo","postcodes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Unsure","Yes","Yes",,"Unsure","https://geo.gob.bo/mapfishapp/",,,,"Infraestructura de Datos Espaciales del Estado Plurinacional de Bolivia (IDE-EPB)","Vicepresidencia del Estado Plurinacional de Bolivi","Yes","Yes","Apparently, Bolivia does not have a post code system https://www.upu.int/fileadmin/documentsFiles/activities/addressingUnit/bolEn.pdf.",,"Yes","No","Mariana Leyton","Codrina Maria Ilie","40"
"e9d750ba-a6bc-44de-a139-0696b4b755c0","global","2015-09-08T11:45:09","2015","am","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"No","https://armstat.am/en/",,"https://armstat.am/en/",,,"National Statistical Service of the Republic of Armenia","Yes","Yes","Data not fully timely but open license.","[GDP][1] up to 2015.
[Population][2] up to 2015.
[Unemployment][3] up to 2014.
[1]: https://armstat.am/en/?nid=126&id=01001
[2]: https://armstat.am/en/?nid=126&id=11001
[3]: https://armstat.am/en/?nid=126&id=08010","Yes","No","Abraham Artashesyan","Zach Christensen","75"
"f13613bf-db66-4cf0-917e-a27cbecd8a6a","global","2015-10-01T15:07:30","2015","tz","postcodes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Unsure","https://www.tcra.go.tz/images/documents/postcode/tzPostcodeList.pdf",,,,"Post Code list","Tanzania Communications Regulatory Authority (TCRA)","Yes","Yes","ok. Through an attribute join, one might have the geometry for post codes at ward level. ","The official list of post codes has the values for all administrative divisions (region, ward, villages).
The official administrative boundaries are freely available from the
National Bureau of Statistics(NBS) at ward level. https://www.nbs.go.tz/nbs/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=526:shapefiles&catid=117:shapefiles
","Yes","No","Joachim Mangilima","Codrina Maria Ilie","40"
"387d1c22-e752-46db-a237-98aff605e3ed","global","2015-08-29T00:04:41","2015","br","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://www.buscacep.correios.com.br","free webservice (JSON, etc.) for individual items, copyrighted (must pay) database as both, .mdb and .txt",,,,,"Yes","Yes","The post code dataset is available, at a cost from GeoData company https://www.geopostcodes.com/Brazil. ","The [Brazilian postcode is named CEP][1]. It is an hierarchical code with 8 digits. The [partial 5-digit CEP have map and polygonal representation][2], but full 8-digit CEP not (it is used today as a logistic non-spatial information), is only a street segment attribute.
Individual CEPs are supplied free, but a *full-copy* of all CEPs aren't free (**not available in bulk**)... The access to database queries is [free as Internet-webservice][3]: CEP-to-address, and address-to-CEP, human and machine resolution services... So this is a cause of *ambiguity in this form: CEP is individually free, but must pay to access on bulk*.
The CEP, as a postcode-list, is copyrighted and sold by the public company ""Empresa Brasileira de Correios e Telégrafos - Correios"" (Brazilian mail service). It is a non-spatial database, with no coordinates in the dataset: https://www.correios.com.br/para-voce/correios-de-a-a-z/dne
The postcode copyright monopoly by Correios company exist since 1978, with the [Federal Law 6538][4].
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/C%C3%B3digo_de_Endere%C3%A7amento_Postal
[2]: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/0/0e/MAPA_DAS_REGI%C3%95ES_DE_CEP.JPG
[3]: https://www.buscacep.correios.com.br/
[4]: https://www.lexml.gov.br/urn/urn:lex:br:federal:lei:1978-06-22;6538
","Yes","No","Peter Krauss","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"989ac8ad-5109-4c93-aeb9-70765ff38f19","global","2015-09-25T12:35:26","2015","al","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://www.instat.gov.al/en/themes.aspx","Excel",,,"National Statistics ","INSTAT","Yes","Yes","Data could be more current and openly licensed.","[GDP][1] up to 2013
[Unemployment][2] up to 2015
[Population][3] up to 2015.
[1]: https://www.instat.gov.al/en/themes/national-accounts.aspx
[2]: https://www.instat.gov.al/en/themes/labour-market.aspx
[3]: https://www.instat.gov.al/en/themes/population.aspx","Yes","No","Blerta Tuci","Zach Christensen","60"
"276eaf93-8a98-488b-bd6e-c53591119129","global","2015-09-18T21:27:59","2015","ag","statistics","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.ab.gov.ag/article_details.php?id=65",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Data aren't available from official website. ","Official data listed [here][1] but none listed for the indicators we are looking for within the past several years.
[1]: https://www.ab.gov.ag/article_details.php?id=65","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Zach Christensen","0"
"322ad2a1-3682-4bb4-b3df-29e71ed4fa27","global","2015-08-29T16:49:03","2015","om","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"No","https://www.data.gov.om/","xlsx, PDF, PPT","https://www.data.gov.om/Content/Oman/en/TermsOfUse.html",,"National statistics such as population, housing, foreign trade, national accounts and more.","National Centre for Statistics and Information","Yes","Yes","Data are licensed open but not very strong coverage. ","Annual [GDP][1] up to 2013.
[Population][2] up to 2014 (note that the dashboard seems to label the total population ""expatriates"")
No unemployment data.
[1]: https://www.data.gov.om/en/Dashboards
[2]: https://www.data.gov.om/en/Dashboards/","Yes","Yes","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Zach Christensen","80"
"6feb8a93-7919-4239-b007-b54f4f1bb476","global","2015-09-28T09:24:29","2015","bf","postcodes","Yes","Yes","No","No","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes",,"shp",,,"Découpage administratif du Burkina Faso. This represents the administrative bundaries representing departments, provinces and regions of Burkina Faso","Institut géographique du Burkina","Yes","Yes","ok","The administrative boundaries is managed by the geographic institute of Burkina Faso. The data is not available online but it can be request and granted for free by the institute. It is available as shapefiles and there is no license applied even if the institute said that it can be used as the requester desire. ","Yes","No","Idriss TINTO","Codrina Maria Ilie","60"
"bbb33ee0-ee4b-4d49-816a-f3373e3595ac","global","2015-09-09T17:01:16","2015","kw","postcodes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","It seems Kuwait has a postcodes/zipcodes service but we could find any data on Kuwait postal official websites (https://moc.kw/post1/index.htm)
The data can be found here (https://kuwait-post.com/)","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Codrina Maria Ilie","5"
"5556abb4-d042-4e28-8398-ee19eb2e6be0","global","2015-09-27T14:28:30","2015","my","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.statistics.gov.my/index.php",,,,"The dataset(s) available under Statistics > By Themes. ","Department of Statistics Malaysia","Yes","Yes","Data not open but mostly up to date if not regular.","Unemployment data up to 2015 in [PDF][1] (up to 2012 in [excel][2])
GDP data up to 2015 in [PDF][3] (up to 2012 in [excel][4])
Population up to 2010 in [PDF][5]
[1]: https://www.statistics.gov.my/index.php?r=column/cthemeByCat&cat=124&bul_id=dVRYQ21MNlZoSlVoZjRxLzRTcGRRZz09&menu_id=U3VPMldoYUxzVzFaYmNkWXZteGduZz09
[2]: https://www.statistics.gov.my/index.php?r=column/ctimeseries&menu_id=NHJlaGc2Rlg4ZXlGTjh1SU1kaWY5UT09
[3]: https://www.statistics.gov.my/index.php?r=column/cthemeByCat&cat=100&bul_id=UnVOTXdoMW1EeTBldWQrS0pYcFNYdz09&menu_id=TE5CRUZCblh4ZTZMODZIbmk2aWRRQT09
[4]: https://www.statistics.gov.my/index.php?r=column/ctimeseries&menu_id=NHJlaGc2Rlg4ZXlGTjh1SU1kaWY5UT09
[5]: https://www.statistics.gov.my/index.php?r=column/cthemeByCat&cat=117&bul_id=cUxSKzBHRktuRGJqajFQK2RiRHpKUT09&menu_id=L0pheU43NWJwRWVSZklWdzQ4TlhUUT09","Yes","No","Hazwany Jamaluddin","Zach Christensen","35"
"896a160e-af15-4ca3-a090-990b1b787801","global","2015-09-26T12:59:48","2015","sd","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","Sudan postal codes do not represent actual locations but postal offices, it is unknown if Sudan collects the required location dataset.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"9f81d908-b0cb-4a91-8ed4-d1e3e466c971","global","2015-09-12T00:44:10","2015","sy","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","https://www.upu.int/fileadmin/documentsFiles/activities/addressingUnit/syrEn.pdf ","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"f574896b-3354-48d4-a57a-23996c676af6","global","2015-10-02T21:09:06","2015","sn","postcodes","Yes","Unsure","No","No","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"No",,,,,"Carte administrative","Government of Senegal","Yes","Yes","The website is not working. ","The government have published information about the data on their website (1). And it is said that the machine readable data can be requested
1. https://www.gouv.sn/Cartes.html","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","5"
"72322ac1-233f-4d13-90b1-49b9ed111c79","global","2015-09-27T15:37:37","2015","bb","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.barstats.gov.bb/",,,,,"Barbados Statistical Service","Yes","Yes","Data not current or open but some are there.","[Unemployment][1] up to 2015 in PDF.
[GDP][2] up to 2009 in PDF.
[Population][3] up to 2010 in PDF.
[1]: https://www.barstats.gov.bb/files/documents/LFS_Bulletin_1Q2015.pdf
[2]: https://www.barstats.gov.bb/files/documents/Revised_Series_of_Gross_Domestic_Product_at_Current_Prices_combined.pdf
[3]: https://www.barstats.gov.bb/files/documents/PHC_2010_Census_Volume_1.pdf","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Zach Christensen","35"
"8704ae99-d609-45ad-946b-de08004b651e","global","2015-09-27T19:45:44","2015","ms","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Haven't been able to find any other source of postcode data. I believe it has not been implemented yet.","Montserrat now has a postcode system which will go into effect April 1, 2014 https://www.upu.int/fileadmin/documentsFiles/activities/addressingUnit/msrEn.pdf.
The official Government Montserrat postcode page is not working https://www.gov.ms/postcode. ","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"b3070b17-8536-4029-a530-d73faefcbb43","global","2015-10-07T16:09:30","2015","tt","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://cso.gov.tt/data/?productID=66-Gross-Domestic-Product,-At-Market-Prices-(Millions-of-dollars)",,,,"Data is given on the all the sectors of the country and what percentage make up the GDP.","Central Statistical office","Yes","Yes","Some data available but not in open format. ","[Population][1] as of 2011.
[GDP][2] up to 2014.
[Employment status][3], but not unemployment, up to 2012.
Copyright© 2015 Ministry of Planning and Sustainable Development. All Rights Reserved.
[1]: https://cso.gov.tt/latest-indicators/
[2]: https://cso.gov.tt/data/?productID=66-Gross-Domestic-Product,-At-Market-Prices-(Millions-of-dollars)
[3]: https://cso.gov.tt/data/?productID=16-Employment-Status-by-Occupational-Group","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Zach Christensen","35"
"09f7b977-339a-4eb0-857a-5fcb494d4699","global","2015-09-25T14:58:58","2015","do","postcodes","Yes","Unsure","No","No","No","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,"ZIP code search, Dominican Republic","Instituto Postal Dominicano (INPOSDOM)","Yes","Yes","The link is not functional at this time. ","The official link is not available https://inposdom.gob.do/codigo-postal/","Yes","No","Eliaquín Encarnación","Codrina Maria Ilie","5"
"645e0e1e-c554-4c60-8cca-2d99bdcee69f","global","2015-09-28T18:13:25","2015","py","statistics","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.dgeec.gov.py/","PDF",,,,,"Yes","Yes","Only population data are more current than 2010. ","Population in [PDF][1] and [Excel][2] (relying on macro)
[Unemployment][3] up to 2010 in PDF
Links to GDP don't work.
[1]: https://www.dgeec.gov.py/Publicaciones/Biblioteca/proyeccion%20nacional/Estimacion%20y%20proyeccion%20Nacional.pdf
[2]: https://www.dgeec.gov.py/Publicaciones/Biblioteca/proyeccion%20nacional/Cuadros%20anexos%20TP-Urbana-Rural.xlsm
[3]: https://www.dgeec.gov.py/sub_index/Pobreza/tasa%20de%20actividad/index.php","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Zach Christensen","0"
"0347e110-4c11-4bd8-bb00-9f76f551b147","global","2015-09-30T13:01:01","2015","fi","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://tilastokeskus.fi/tup/rajapintapalvelut/paavo_en.html","GML, JPEG, GeoTiff, PNG, SVG","https://tilastokeskus.fi/org/lainsaadanto/yleiset_kayttoehdot_en.html",,"Postal number code areas","Statistics Finland","Yes","Yes","ok","Zipcodes now include location data i.e. coordinates and boundaries of the Zip-code areas. https://tilastokeskus.fi/tup/karttaaineistot/postinumeroalueet.html
The datasets is available through web mapping services, WMS and WFS.
","Yes","Yes","Jaakko Korhonen","Codrina Maria Ilie","100"
"965f6de3-9da8-409c-90ae-f17fedddb20a","global","2015-10-07T15:39:32","2015","pr","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.mercadolaboral.pr.gov/",,,,"Various sources","US Census Bureau, Junta de Planificación de Puerto Rico, Departamento del Trabajo y Recursos Humanos de Puerto Rico","Yes","Yes","Current data but not openly licensed. ","Annual GDP is available from Junta de Planificación de Puerto Rico / Puerto Rico Planning Board:
https://www.jp.pr.gov/portal_jp/ActividadEconómicaEconomicActivity/Apéndice/tabid/184/Default.aspx
Monthly Unemployment Rate is available from Departamento del Trabajo y Recursos Humanos de Puerto Rico / Puerto Rico Departament of Labor and Human Resources:
https://www.mercadolaboral.pr.gov/
Annual Population Estimate is available from the U.S. Census Bureau:
https://www.census.gov/popest/index.html","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Zach Christensen","55"
"d275a0d4-18f2-410d-8e0e-2a208f46aed9","global","2015-09-15T15:11:14","2015","th","postcodes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","Thailand has a post code system [https://www.upu.int/fileadmin/documentsFiles/activities/addressingUnit/thaEn.pdf]. The data is available from GeoData company here https://www.geopostcodes.com/Central_Thailand at charge.
The official Post offers a search service https://www.thailandpost.com/zipcode.php.
Coordinate (latitude longitude) of provinces, districts and sub-district https://data.go.th/DatasetDetail.aspx?id=c6d42e1b-3219-47e1-b6b7-dfe914f27910","Yes","No","Klaikong Vaidhyakarn","Codrina Maria Ilie","10"
"0e89081b-517c-4876-89da-11a951f87de7","global","2015-09-28T16:34:34","2015","ml","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.instat-mali.org/",,,,,"Institut National de la Statistique (INSTAT)","Yes","Yes","Some relatively recent data but no regular updates, open licensing, or machine readable formatting. ","[GDP][1] up to 2013.
[Population][2] up to 2009.
[Unemployment][3] in 2013.
[1]: https://www.instat-mali.org/index.php/2014-06-05-15-00-18/statistiques-conjoncturelles/comptes-nationaux
[2]: https://www.instat-mali.org/index.php/2014-06-05-15-00-18/2014-10-23-11-38-30/demographie
[3]: https://www.instat-mali.org/index.php/2014-06-05-15-00-18/2014-10-23-11-38-30/emploi","Yes","No","Ousmane Ly","Zach Christensen","35"
"51a48470-9380-425d-bcc8-9125e377ff8c","global","2015-09-29T00:03:09","2015","pa","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Panama does not have post codes https://www.upu.int/fileadmin/documentsFiles/activities/addressingUnit/panEn.pdf. No official administrative boundaries have been identified. ","Our postal service is mediocre at best.
Their link is: https://www.correospanama.gob.pa/
However, Panama does not have a post code system https://www.upu.int/fileadmin/documentsFiles/activities/addressingUnit/panEn.pdf.
ANATI, the national agency for land administration, has a geospatial viewer but it's accessible only through registration. https://www.anati.gob.pa/
ANATI publishes PDF maps. ","Yes","No","HAMZAH HAJI","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"4ba99527-40d8-4e75-bf11-e76d543152d6","global","2015-09-25T13:52:28","2015","al","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","It seems like there is no such official data. ","Reviewer's note:
The data that was submitted by the original submitter was this link - https://80.78.68.65/moti/ This measure current weather but does not give projections for the future. We tried to look for alternative official source but didnt find it online. Therefore, submission was changed to NO - data does not exist. ","Yes","No","Blerta Tuci","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"d2d37775-bd68-429f-82bd-c2c6e7e0e949","global","2015-08-31T15:56:40","2015","eg","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.mof.gov.eg/Arabic/%D8%B9%D9%86%D8%A7%D9%88%D9%8A%D9%86%20%D8%B1%D8%A6%D9%8A%D8%B3%D9%8A%D9%87/PE/Pages/budget14-15.aspx",,,,"The Annual Budget","Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","I could not find a machine readable version of the data. Submission was accepted. ","The Egyptian financial year starts in the beginning of July each year, thus this is the budget for the period between 1 July 2014 and 30 June 2015. The budget is available in a PDF format.
","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Mor Rubinstein","55"
"635c930a-c31f-4e07-99eb-317c2b8fcba7","global","2015-09-30T10:37:19","2015","ng","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"No","https://www.budgetoffice.gov.ng/index.php/component/content/article?layout=edit&id=101",,,,,"Budget Office of the Federation ","Yes","Yes","Could not find a machine readable version of the data. Submission accepted. ","It is the National Budget Portal and the data is always available on the official Budget Office of the Federation website. Budget Implementation Documents are not released on a timely basis.
","Yes","No","Oludotun Babayemi","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"adbd555d-412d-4a11-a88a-c03f6f78c36c","global","2015-09-25T11:28:20","2015","ml","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.finances.gouv.ml/loi_des_finances_2015/index.html",,,,"Loi des finances 2015","Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","Data is in bulk. I could not find a machine readable version of the data. ","Please note this file is only about in income budget and not expenditure budget.
Reviewer's note: More documents can be found here - https://www.finances.gouv.ml/index.php/2015-04-13-09-34-22/documents-budget","Yes","No","Tidiane Ball","Mor Rubinstein","55"
"4e0b4599-bb91-4447-93fc-50a5ff6521e7","global","2015-09-20T05:10:23","2015","pk","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://finance.gov.pk/budget/abs_2015_16.pdf",,,,,"Government of Pakistan, Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","I could not find machine readable format of the data. Submission is correct. ","Revised Estimates 2014-15 may be treated as Expenditure during 2014-15.","Yes","No","Nouman Nazim","Mor Rubinstein","55"
"40efd50b-015a-46bd-9f01-a2c2bd321ae2","global","2015-09-20T18:01:06","2015","no","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.norge.no/data/posten-norge/postnummer-i-norge","tab-separated, Excel, Shape, SOSI","https://data.norge.no/nlod/en/1.0",,"Postal codes in Norway and geodata about the area covered by each","Posten Norge AS","Yes","Yes","ok","Postal codes are distributed by Posten Norge AS, while the borders for each postal code is distributed by The Norwegian Mapping Authority.
The Norwegian Mapping Authority also have administrative borders for download:
https://data.kartverket.no/download/content/geodataprodukter?korttype=3594&aktualitet=All&datastruktur=All&dataskema=All","Yes","Yes","Bergheimivar L","Codrina Maria Ilie","100"
"88dfd46c-754f-4c21-95e5-940a6ff27c17","global","2015-09-30T19:06:07","2015","tz","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The data does exist, but according to the law , The National electoral council is the sole custodian of this information. So it's is not accessible by the general public and a very few know anything about it, especially after elections.","Yes","No","Joachim Mangilima","Kamil Gregor","0"
"d66cd968-752e-4611-a21b-a22667752a96","global","2015-09-20T01:54:23","2015","bo","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","How does the submitter know that the data exists? Nothing here suggests that they have data over municipality level (which is available at https://bit.ly/1GlWrfN).","Election information is provided as aggregated results, but the raw data is not available. For example, the report with the results of the last election is available here as PDF: https://tse.oep.org.bo/images/elecciones_2014/Resultado%20de%20las%20elcciones%20generales%202014/FINALISIMA%20RESULTADOS.pdf
","Yes","No","Fabián Soria","Kamil Gregor","0"
"5b0c9cc5-95c5-4c4c-95e1-65e41191aea2","global","2015-09-27T19:23:38","2015","uy","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.corteelectoral.gub.uy/gxpsites/page.aspx?3,26,453,O,S,0,","Excel",,,"Elecciones Nacionales 2014","Corte Electoral","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Lots of information beyond votes published (including campaign financing, government programmes, and more): https://www.corteelectoral.gub.uy/gxpsites/page.aspx?3,26,453,O,S,0,
This URL correspond to national elections, but the site has information for local, ballotagge and other.","Yes","No","Daniel Carranza","Kamil Gregor","70"
"eac7ca0d-cac7-4b7b-9f02-d3aeebf37be5","global","2015-09-28T17:37:53","2015","py","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://datosabiertos.tsje.gov.py/",,"https://datosabiertos.tsje.gov.py/about",,,"Tribunal Superior de Justicia Electoral","Yes","Yes","The data is not machine readable. The detailed (mesa-level) data are only available in html and pdf, one piece at a time. Also the correct link is in the Comment - https://tsje.gov.py/e2013/trep/consulta-certificados.html","Existen datos de Elecciones Generales para los años 2013, 2008 y 2003, Elecciones Municipales para los años 2001 y 2006.
Contenido: Los datos no están completos, existen columnas en los archivos CSV que no tienen valor, necesita un nivel de especifidad mayor, se puede obtener cantidad de votos por; departamento, distrito y local de votación para los diferentes cargos, pero no se especifica cantidad de votos por mesas.
La certificados de votación (Elecciones Generales) para el año 2013 están disponibles en https://tsje.gov.py/e2013/trep/consulta-certificados.html (accedido 29/Agosto/2014). Se puede obtener por departamento, distrito, zona, local y mesa, estos certificados están en formato JPG, también existe una tabla HTML que refleja los datos que aparecen en los mismos. Se especifica votos obtenidos por lista, votos nulos y votos en blanco. Ofrece opción de descargar certificado en formato PDF.
Elecciones Municipales para los años 1996 y 2010, están disponibles en https://tsje.gov.py/elecciones-municipales.html (accedido 29/Agosto/2014). Para el año 2010 se puede descargar; Intendentes Electos por departamento y distrito, en formato XLS. Para el año 1996 existe formato JPG.
Elecciones Generales para los años 2000 y 1998 están disponibles en https://tsje.gov.py/elecciones-generales.html (accedido 29/Agosto/2014), año 2000 en formato HTML y año 1998 en formato JPG.
Estructura: Los datos que existen en formato CSV, no tienen metadatos, lo que hace difícil la comprensión de los mismos. Existen columnas que se pueden eliminar, ya que pueden ser calculadas en base a los datos y cabeceras que no son necesarias.
Existen muchos datos en formato PDF, JPG, PNG y HTML en https://tsje.gov.py/ (accedido 29/Agosto/2014).
According to Juan, did not changed from last year.","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Kamil Gregor","75"
"ae177def-89bc-4223-8c71-bf0fc6bcd707","global","2015-10-13T21:07:58","2015","tg","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.ceni-tg.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/Rapport-general-du-scrutin-du-2-5-avril-2015_3%C3%A8me-partie_3.pdf",,,,"Rapport Général du Scrutin du 25 avril 2015 : ","Commission Electorale Nationale Indépendante CENI-Togo","Yes","Yes","The submission does not meet the definition. Data is only available at the level of districts, aggregating for up to 800.000 people.","QA notes: Data is in PDF, changed to not machine readable. I believe this is not in a poll station level. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","45"
"42f42c8f-e1c1-4aa0-929f-e5f3c0cb7119","global","2015-10-03T08:04:09","2015","gn","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.ceniguinee.org/index.php/2015-06-21-20-22-13/legislatives-2013",,,,"Results of the legislative elections of 2013","Independent National Electoral Commission","Yes","Yes","The submission does not meet the definition. Data is only available at the level of prefectures, aggregating for up to 1.500.000 people.","The results of the legislative and presidential elections are available on the website of the independent national electoral commission. The data is in pdf format, and there is no evidence about the availability machine readable ones.","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","45"
"a56c1adb-b8b0-4044-8138-d789d93aa2ee","global","2015-10-01T14:59:08","2015","ci","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.ceici.org/elections/ci/index.php",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission does not meet the definition. Data is only available at the level of communes, aggregating for up to 450.000 people."," - MUNICIPALES 2013 - https://www.ceici.org/elections/ci/mun2013.pdf
- REGIONALES 2013 - https://www.ceici.org/elections/ci/reg2013.pdf
- LEGISLATIVES 2012 - https://www.ceici.org/elections/ci/edan2013.pdf
- PRESIDENTIELLES 2010 (1st Tour) - https://www.ceici.org/elections/docs/EPR_31102010_RESUL_PROVI_CEI_03112010_A4.pdf
- PRESIDENTIELLES 2010 ((2nd Tour) - https://www.ceici.org/elections/docs/EPR2010_2T_RESULTATS_VALEURS_02122010.pdf
","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","0"
"8eb3afe5-f411-4bcb-9e02-eab6afe28bcc","global","2015-10-19T12:29:08","2015","ge","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://results2014.cec.gov.ge/",,,,,"Election Administration of Georgia","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Information about the 2014 Municipal Elections (which were centrally administered) is available at https://results2014.cec.gov.ge/ with a nice interface and precinct level results as both HTML tables and scanned PDFs of the original documents. Results for past elections are displayed under the Archive section of the website (https://www.cesko.ge/en/arqivi-6), data for the historically important 2012 Parliamentary Elections is available at https://results2012.cec.gov.ge/.
Although precinct-level data is provided in HTML tables, API calls to the interactive portion of the website return Javascript / HTML snippets which are designed to be directly inserted into the website DOM, making them effectively not machine-readable without significant effort. This also means that the data is not available in bulk, because individual precinct results would need to be downloaded manually.
In addition, precinct level data is incomplete and not available upon request. Only district level data is. This makes it difficult to conduct many kinds of analyses on the data.
Finally, administrative boundaries change regularly and the CEC does not make geographic shape files available to the public that officially delineate the boundaries of precincts from one year to the next.
All government-generated data in Georgia is legally in the public domain, although no particular license is provided with the online data.","Yes","No","Kamil Gregor","Kamil Gregor","45"
"6ecff235-174c-419a-b29a-85eaaea39e4d","global","2015-10-07T01:49:14","2015","cn","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission is correct."," nothing changed in 2015","Yes","No","OKFN CN","Kamil Gregor","0"
"f9461e6b-45bc-4b2a-9630-e98d7a9d4070","global","2015-08-30T13:41:18","2015","np","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure",,"Yes","https://www.election.gov.np/election/np","Xml",,,"Election Commission Nepal provides CA Election Reports and Results of Nepal.","Election Commission Nepal","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct. Data is only available at the level of constituencies of up to 50.000 people.","This data is completely available in open format. Election Commission maintains the data.","Yes","No","Nikesh Balami","Kamil Gregor","60"
"127d497c-e590-455f-ba84-0c37c6472e4a","global","2015-10-01T12:08:59","2015","ky","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.electionsoffice.ky/index.php/election-results-and-statistics","PDF",,,"Election Results and Statistics","Cayman Islands Elections Office","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct."," ","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Kamil Gregor","45"
"b6d521cb-5041-4322-9e42-46a1663d258f","global","2015-09-28T11:55:03","2015","gg","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://gov.gg/elections","HTML; PDF",,,"2012 General Election Results","States Assembly and Constitution Committee, assemblycom@gov.gg","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct."," A general election takes place in Guernsey every four years. The last was in 2012, the results of which can be found at https://gov.gg/CHttpHandler.ashx?id=75784&p=0
","Yes","No","Marcus Ferbrache","Kamil Gregor","45"
"99da980e-3e15-40bb-be11-8119ea3224a5","global","2015-10-01T09:23:19","2015","bj","elections","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.cenabenin.org/",,,,"Résultats des élections locales","Commission Electorale Nationale Autonome (CENA)","Yes","Yes","At this point (website is under construction) there are no results, i.e. numbers of votes, at Data Locationat all.","The Autonomous Electoral National Commission CENA is mandated by the law to share the results data with the press, government, the Constitutional court and other third parties like political parties or groups of political parties. The website of the publisher in under construction, so all data are not available","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","30"
"1ee088b7-16de-4a4b-b2f5-96040949ef6b","global","2015-08-30T14:07:11","2015","sa","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Saudi does not have an elected legislative or executive governmental body. Previous editions of the index have reported on the data of ""municipal"" elections which are only concerned with the activities of the municipality and are not 'national'.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Kamil Gregor","0"
"d3cbad2c-68a9-4711-a26e-9c2102e0ff04","global","2015-09-27T22:26:20","2015","gy","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.gecom.org.gy/results2015.html",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","It is available, but the submission contains unofficial results with limited detail. Official and detailed results are available (for the last election) here: https://www.gecom.org.gy/results2015.html in PDFs.",,"Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Kamil Gregor","45"
"be03bd11-1d69-4d42-816f-afa5b452f362","global","2015-09-01T18:28:58","2015","iq","elections","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission does not meet the definition. Results are only available at the level of regions.","The data about parliament and governorates elections can be found at The Independent High Electoral Commission website (https://www.ihec.iq/ar/). the data on the website lacks the required information like number of registered votes,number of invalid votes, and number of spoiled ballots.
You have to search on the website to find some data, for example the parliament election for 2014(https://www.ihec.iq/ar/index.php/news-archive/6075.html).
The format of the data is PDF.","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Kamil Gregor","0"
"6261c59f-a46a-4151-b334-5d5f1355f203","global","2015-09-08T19:30:44","2015","tn","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.isie.tn/",,,,,"Independent High Authority for Elections","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","**Disclaimer:**
Parliamentary Elections were held on Oct 26th, 2014 and the Presidential election is scheduled on November 23rd 2014 - This submission to the Open Data Index was made on November 20th, 2014
Preliminary results from the Oct 2014 election are available here: https://www.isie.tn/documents/arrete-resultats-preliminaires.pdf
Data on the 2011 elections is available from the Instance supérieure independante pour les élections (in Arabic). This data, not available in machine readable formats, was scrapped and used to build: https://tunisiaelectiondata.org/# (Mourakiboun, Development Seed, Democracy International). However, the links from Tunisia Election Data and from the 2013 Global Open Data Index to 2011 election data are now dead.
Reviewer: When surveyed after the parliamentary elections and after the first round of the presidential (on Nov 26), the ISIE website provided preliminary results from the presidential elections and additional information and data on the parliamentary elections. See:
https://www.isie.tn/documents/%D9%82%D8%B1%D8%A7%D8%B1%20%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%AA%D8%B5%D8%B1%D9%8A%D8%AD%20%D8%A8%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%86%D8%AA%D8%A7%D8%A6%D8%AC%20%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%A3%D9%88%D9%84%D9%8A%D8%A9%20%D9%84%D9%84%D8%AF%D9%88%D8%B1%D8%A9%20%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%A3%D9%88%D9%84%D9%89%20%D9%84%D9%84%D8%A7%D9%86%D8%AA%D8%AE%D8%A7%D8%A8%D8%A7%D8%AA%20%D8%A7%D9%84%D8%B1%D8%A6%D8%A7%D8%B3%D9%8A%D8%A9.pdf
I would thus consider information to be released on a timely basis -- even if the ""data"" is print-out, manually signed and then re-scanned PDF.","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Kamil Gregor","45"
"7680a766-9988-4a6d-b85f-393206db3af5","global","2015-09-11T15:33:15","2015","my","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission does not meet the definition. The site referred to in Comments only contains country-level results.","From the Election Commission of Malaysia official portal (link: https://www.spr.gov.my/index.php/component/content/article?layout=edit&id=74%20target=), the datasets provided were incomplete. There were only 2 elections results provided which is the results for the 13th (2013-current) and 12th (2008-2013) Parliament of Malaysia. In order to get complete information, the public have to make a request to the Election Commission of Malaysia. Given that the institution is in the Federal State territory, submitting for Freedom of Information request is impossible because there is no Freedom of Information Act for the Federal State Wilayah Persekutuan. Therefore, the public can refer to 3rd party who did published these datasets online https://everypolitician.org/malaysia/.","Yes","No","Hazwany Jamaluddin","Kamil Gregor","0"
"101c6ec1-31aa-4b71-ad6d-716536c6b99b","global","2015-10-12T17:08:51","2015","tj","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The website of the Central Election and Referenda of the Republic of Tajikistan - https://www.kmir.tj/en/ - does not contain the final result of the Parliamentary Election of 2015. The final report of the OSCE ODIHR reflects the outcome of the election. The official information was disseminated by the accredited local and international mass media.","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","0"
"ac3411d5-bb6f-4ba5-a921-83bc1803eaf0","global","2015-09-27T22:16:14","2015","az","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.msk.gov.az/en/elections/",,,,,"Central Election Commission of the Republic of Azerbaijan","Yes","Yes","The submission does not meet the definition. The Data Location only contains total results for the whole country. Local turnout is available elsewhere, but not results.
","It is openly licensed but I can't find the link to the license.","Yes","No","Codrina Maria Ilie","Kamil Gregor","45"
"4d1a77fd-d14b-4878-8fb7-cb3d6be44d30","global","2015-10-19T12:11:33","2015","ko","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.kqz-ks.org/en/zgjedhjet-komunale-2013",,"https://gzk.rks-gov.net/ActDocumentDetail.aspx?ActID=2787",,,"Central Election Commission ","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The submission is correct.","Yes","No","Kamil Gregor","Kamil Gregor","75"
"d29c32d6-b895-453f-ae40-8e6a13d6a3d3","global","2015-09-18T20:50:35","2015","is","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.hagstofa.is/?PageID=829&src=https://rannsokn.hagstofa.is/pxis/Dialog/varval.asp?ma=KOS02120%26ti=%DArslit+al%FEingiskosninga+eftir+kj%F6rd%E6mum+2013+++++++%26path=../Database/kosningar/althurslit/%26lang=3%26units=Fj%F6ldi/hlutfall","CSV, Excel, HTML, XML",,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission does not meet the definition. Final results are only available at the level of 6 relatively large constituencies.
","Election results are available via a special web form to tailor the output. The National Electoral Committee links to the dataset on Hagstofa Íslands' page from their own page at https://landskjor.is/
More national election result data can be found at: https://www.hagstofa.is/Hagtolur/Kosningar/Althingiskosningar
Municipal election results are at:
https://hagstofan.is/Hagtolur/Kosningar/Sveitarstjornarkosningar","Yes","No","Páll Hilmarsson","Kamil Gregor","0"
"3c7653b8-12a0-490f-940a-aed980bc5dc1","global","2015-09-27T03:00:29","2015","cr","postcodes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","The postal codes are made up of province, canton and districts (each assigned a number) and made available via an interactive form, one at a time. The map data, available at https://www.snitcr.go.cr/ does include the breakdown of provinces, cantons and districts so the data can be found and merged together but it is not easily accessible.
Geolocation is no sufficient for this dataset type. ","Yes","No","Alejandro Sanabria","Codrina Maria Ilie","10"
"a0b129a3-a636-468f-892e-d77ec52af471","global","2015-10-14T22:17:36","2015","pr","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Puerto Rico follows the United States of America postal system. Its state code is PR and its postal codes range from 00601 to 00799 and from 00901 to 00999. ","Puerto Rico follows the United States of America postal system. Its state code is PR and its postal codes range from 00601 to 00799 and from 00901 to 00999. Official available geodata has not been discovered on the governmental official portal [https://www2.pr.gov/agencias/gis/descargaGeodatos/Pages/default.aspx].
Boundaries are here- https://www2.pr.gov/agencias/gis/descargaGeodatos/Delimitaciones/Pages/Limites-legales.aspx [Data is not open - see terms of use here - https://www2.pr.gov/Pages/NormasdeUso.aspx, shapefile format]
Post codes dataset available from GeoData https://www.geopostcodes.com/goto_Puerto_Rico, at charge. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"e2596264-0d81-4b61-8971-58507db574f4","global","2015-09-07T17:54:16","2015","qa","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Members of the parliament as well as heads of the executive branch of the government are appointed by the Emir of Qatar - there are currently no elections for such posts.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Kamil Gregor","0"
"512efb05-a3b7-4c6b-bb1b-8d168a11125c","global","2015-10-09T13:08:34","2015","ae","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The National Committee for Elections is responsible for conducting the elections of the National Federation Council, the Emirati parliamentary body. The website of the National Committee has information about previous elections ( https://www.uaenec.ae/ar/about-us/about-fnc-elections ) that include information such as names of candidates and the numbers votes they each acquired. The data includes the number of candidates and the number of votes each person acquired with a state level breakdown. There is no polling station break down because there was one polling station in each state.
Reviewer's Comment:
The data on the website doesn't have the Number of Invalid/Spoiled votes, thus, I think I will mark the whole dataset as unavailable since it doesn't meet the requirements","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Kamil Gregor","0"
"dce62020-36ea-4133-a0f2-36187eeded34","global","2015-08-29T17:03:33","2015","om","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://election.gov.om/shura/index.php",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The data either does not exist or is not available online. The submission says that election results have been removed from the Data Location.","The Ministry of Interior ( https://www.moi.gov.om/ ) has a website dedicated to Municipal Councils Elections ( https://election.gov.om/shura/index.php/ ) that provides details of the candidates and live voting results. Unfortunately, it appears that historic data about previous Parliamentary sessions have been removed from the website and the current version of the website focuses on the elections that about to start in the country. The current website provides the details of all the candidates as well as the names of every single registered voter.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Kamil Gregor","0"
"78343a69-ad3c-4e36-8e50-3794780c9bc8","global","2015-10-10T14:16:58","2015","ma","elections","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The Ministry of Interior is responsible for this information and for the collection of this data. This website is run by them, elections.ma, though it in the results pages (example, https://www.elections.ma/elections/communales/resultats.aspx and https://www.elections.ma/elections/regionales/resultats.aspx) we could only find names for winners, MP's, breakdown of seats per political parties, and percentage of participation of voters. We, however, could not find number of registered voters per polling station, number for participation, invalid and spoiled votes. We were not able to access the Moroccan Open Data portal, data.gov.ma, during this reviewing process to check if such missing data is available there. We thus, will mark the existance of this dataset as unsure
Previous year's review below:
The Ministry of Interior is responsible for this information and for the collection of this data. It has no website (yet ?). Also, the Ministry of Interior is not a producer of Data at the Open Data portal (www.data.gov.ma). The Ministry of Interior thus collects data but does not share it, neither on the data.gov. ma nor elsewhere.
No data exists online at all. The conditions according to which the data may be released are unknown. It is unknown how the data is handled. Thus, questions about pricing policy and timeliness have been marked 'Unsure' to reflect this reality.","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Kamil Gregor","0"
"970ba4ce-56e9-4fa3-8f1a-ebce87f20658","global","2015-10-15T17:11:10","2015","ua","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://services.ukrposhta.com/postindex_new/",,,,,"Ukrposhta","Yes","Yes","ok","One got to run a query to get needed postcode, therefore no option to get data in bulk. No information on postcode boundaries is given, though Google-maps are available for every post office serving respective zipcode.
Re-submit from 2014
Dataset available at https://www.geopostcodes.com/Ukraine, at charge. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Codrina Maria Ilie","45"
"85d2f3ac-c435-4f08-a5c4-88038161f410","global","2015-10-02T00:32:29","2015","se","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.postnummerservice.se/utbud/referensdata","CSV",,,,"Postnummerservice Norden AB","Yes","Yes","ok","Available for a fee (approx EUR 2000 for weekly updates per year). No plans to make it available as open data. National postal company sent takedown notice to entrepreneurs that scraped and republished some of the data.
This link could not be found: https://www.postnummerservice.se/filer/postnummerfiler/postnummerfilen/","Yes","No","Asmen Gül","Codrina Maria Ilie","55"
"b1656884-31d2-4278-b6ff-29dff79dc93a","global","2015-10-19T10:51:35","2015","md","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Although Posta Moldovei has this discovery service https://www.posta.md/ro/postal_code.html it shows only post office with their respective codes. ","I have not identified if the official Posta Moldovei has the dataset. However the Moldavian postal codes dataset is available on GeoNames, free of charge
https://download.geonames.org/export/zip/, or from GeoData https://www.geopostcodes.com/Moldova with charge. ","Yes","No","Codrina Maria Ilie","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"a1c603e6-a159-4a10-95c3-5c542c06747f","global","2015-10-02T17:59:06","2015","vc","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.pmoffice.gov.vc/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=74&Itemid=97",,,,"Office of the Prime Minister","Government of St. Vincent and the Grenadines","Yes","Yes","I have reviewed this submission and it is correct.","Data is in pdf format and not machine readable.","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","55"
"70137ebd-d9f9-42fa-b794-977d3f96ecbc","global","2015-10-02T05:44:38","2015","ml","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Administrative boundaries are accepted only if there is no post code system. In Maliit seems there is one, no official endorsement though. GeoData company sells this dataset. ","The National Geographical Institute has administrative boundaries data. But there is no evidence about the availability.
Mali has a mailing system with post codes but we were unable to find reference regarding what national agency is responsible. The Mali Post is down for maintenance. The post codes dataset is available, at a cost, from GeoData company https://www.geopostcodes.com/Mali","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"698d5f9d-b646-4630-abb0-b72ec6b3e381","global","2015-10-02T17:45:47","2015","lc","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.finance.gov.lc/resources/",,,,,"Ministry of Finance, Economic Affairs, Planning and Social Security","Yes","Yes","I have checked the data and it is correct. ","From the URL link for the source, you click the fourth PDF file and it will be downloaded easily to your computer.
Data is in pdf format and not machine readable.","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","55"
"ad69018d-0fab-43ce-83d4-d3cf79547e7d","global","2015-09-25T18:39:12","2015","kn","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://mof.gov.kn/sites/mof.gov.kn/files/documents/2015%20Budget%20Address.pdf",,,,"2015 Budget Address","Government of St. Christopher (Kitts) and Nevis","Yes","Yes","I have reviewed the data and it is correct. Could not find Machine readable data. ","Budget estimates can be found in this link in PDF format, by department and sub department - https://mof.gov.kn/?q=publications","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Mor Rubinstein","55"
"33e3f76f-b26c-4229-ac35-fa365dcc2936","global","2015-10-02T17:03:18","2015","jm","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.mof.gov.jm/opening-budget-speeches/file/951-opening-budget-speech-2015-2016.html",,,,"Budgets - The Minister presents Government’s expenditure and revenue estimates for parliamentary approval at the start of each financial year (April to March of the following year). ","Ministry of Finance and Planning","Yes","Yes","I have review the data and it is correct. ","Data including budgets, budget memoranda, presentations to parliament and revenue measures are all available from the site. There is no clear license within the PDF documents and a copyright (all rights reserved) statement on the website itself.
Data is in pdf format and not machine readable.
Estimates by department can be found here - https://www.mof.gov.jm/budgets/estimates-of-revenue-expenditure/file/935-estimates-of-revenue-and-expenditure-for-the-year-ending-march-2015.html","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","55"
"79d714aa-5ce7-4f93-881e-1ce00b6e811c","global","2015-10-12T18:29:09","2015","my","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.treasury.gov.my/?lang=en",,,,,"Ministry of Finance Malaysia","Yes","Yes","Could not find machine readable data. Data is correct. ","The data cannot be accessed by the Ministry of Finance (MoF) because there is no Freedom Information Act in federal state whereby MoF is part of the federal state territory.
Link: Link: https://www.treasury.gov.my/?lang=en
QA review - Changed the submission according to the comment section. Data exist in a PDF format.
Reviewer's note - Budget speech is here - https://www.treasury.gov.my/pdf/budget/speech/bs15.pdf
Estimates are here:
https://www.treasury.gov.my/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=4298:2015-estimated-federal-expenditure&catid=447&Itemid=2473&lang=en","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"1f293a06-f6a8-4889-98c4-7438274d5ab6","global","2015-09-20T05:46:42","2015","pk","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.pakpost.gov.pk/postcode/national_post%20code_directory.XLS","Microsoft Excel (.XLS)",,,"National Post Code Directory","Government of Pakistan, Pakistan Post","Yes","Yes","ok","Updated the download link for file.
Geocoded postal code dataset can be obtained by attribute join by province name. ","Yes","No","Nouman Nazim","Codrina Maria Ilie","70"
"a759fef1-3f30-4a27-aa6c-035db1323b1e","global","2015-09-25T14:51:23","2015","vc","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","it is uncertain if official data for location datasets exist.
Point dataset with locality is available free of charge form GeoData company https://www.geopostcodes.com/St_Vincent_and_Grenadines, but the postal code attribute is NA.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"24f5f225-3913-4bac-aa7c-5fe492cc2311","global","2015-09-27T15:28:24","2015","lc","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","postcodes/zipcodes not used ","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"86a770b5-ff52-47d3-97d9-8d6740295a92","global","2015-09-27T02:13:49","2015","kn","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","postcodes/zipcodes not used ","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"5ff66462-ddc0-4d22-9ff5-ccd7029be961","global","2015-09-05T00:35:27","2015","jm","postcodes","Yes","Unsure","No","No","No","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,,"The Post and Telecommunications Department (Jamaica Post) - Postal Corporation of Jamaica (Post Corp.) ","Yes","Yes","https://jam.postcodebase.com/ is not an official website and there is no reference that what they have published is officially endorsed. ","The postcode team built the website extensively throughout the world. The website currently provides postcode inquiry service around hundreds of countries in 50+ languages. There are more than 40,000,000 postcode / ZIP code data in https://PostCodeBase.com.
The postcode information for Jamaica are clearly stated but cannot be downloaded on the computer due to not being machine readable (PDF, CSV, etc).","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Codrina Maria Ilie","5"
"1b47ce44-d27a-4d5a-bea8-fc41b626d6fd","global","2015-09-28T03:51:52","2015","bm","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Postal Codes","Bermuda Post Office","Yes","Yes","ok","The official page for the postal codes is: https://www.bpo.bm/postalcodes.aspx?activemenu=40&sub=27
On that page you can online find a PDF download: https://www.bpo.bm/Lists/Postal%20Codes/Attachments/1/Bermuda%20Postal%20Codes%20and%20Parishes%202013.pdf
No geolocation with the zipcodes.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Codrina Maria Ilie","15"
"cfcdb776-3735-42f6-a837-abe4ed719c56","global","2015-09-28T08:08:30","2015","mm","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","No evidence showing from the President's Officer website that the data exists. I have found a 3rd party website https://www.ourweb.info/01/directory/myanmar/005/ that provides a list of ministries official websites but some of these websites are not found.
Kindly note that there is a high possibility that Myanmar government did not update each of these ministries websites so there is an error while trying to gain access to these websites.
Myanma Posts and Telecommunications (Burmese: မြန်မာ့ဆက်သွယ်ရေးလုပ်ငန်း), abbreviated MPT) is a state owned enterprise in Myanmar under the supervision of Ministry of Communications and Information Technology. MPT operates the country's postal system. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"fa43c998-849e-49ae-bc6a-92c147c60007","global","2015-09-21T19:34:35","2015","bb","postcodes","Yes","Unsure","No","No","No","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","There is no reference on what ministry/agency is in charge with postal code database, if there is a unified and official one. Post codes are available at a cost through the GeoData company service:
https://www.geopostcodes.com/Barbados
","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Codrina Maria Ilie","5"
"902e9d77-ef37-47e3-8b7b-60dc50e1c75f","global","2015-09-20T05:58:33","2015","pk","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.ppra.org.pk",,,,,"Public Procurement Regulatory Authority","Yes","Yes","Submission updated to reflect comment including tenders and awards.","List of current tenders by Government Organizations is available at following link:- https://www.ppra.org.pk/","Yes","No","Nouman Nazim","Georg Neumann","45"
"37c5917e-9763-4b58-af38-05b375b39950","global","2015-09-28T14:55:43","2015","py","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.contrataciones.gov.py/datos/data","JSON, CSV","https://www.contrataciones.gov.py/sicp/download/getFile?cid=5540&fileName=OAwkXiYNi6QOh%2BTIKqR3782C1d%2Fp2D6FmxEIfxpwY1aLVin1WtzvGeKt7M%2FkWC6UT3I3th3g6f814u3HhiOtZK6rQ3nGAAVa9CGPr2ziq%2B4UDoOqYjDqbTGeiXcWmka5%2F5bqZD7cLCdw1CVjAOOPww%3D%3D",,"Open Data portal for DNCP","Dirección Nacional de Contrataciones Públicas (DNCP)","Yes","Yes","Submission correct.","The DNCP is in charge of maintaining the national e-procurement platform. The system contains information about all the procurement phases are: planning, tender, award, contract, amendment.
All this information is available at the open data platform from the DNCP, where the user can:
- Browse information about each phase [1][2][3][4][5]
- Download this information for each phase for each year since 2010 in csv format. The files are updated daily. [6][7][8][9][10]
- Use the API to create new Apps [11]
- Visualize the information in a user friendly manner [12]
References:
- [1] https://www.contrataciones.gov.py/datos/data/planificaciones
- [2] https://www.contrataciones.gov.py/datos/data/convocatorias
- [3] https://www.contrataciones.gov.py/datos/data/adjudicaciones
- [4] https://www.contrataciones.gov.py/datos/data/contratos
- [5] https://www.contrataciones.gov.py/datos/data/modificaciones
- [6] https://www.contrataciones.gov.py/datos/planificaciones
- [7] https://www.contrataciones.gov.py/datos/convocatorias
- [8] https://www.contrataciones.gov.py/datos/adjudicaciones
- [9] https://www.contrataciones.gov.py/datos/contratos
- [10] https://www.contrataciones.gov.py/datos/modificaciones
- [11] https://www.contrataciones.gov.py/datos/api/
- [12] https://www.contrataciones.gov.py/datos/visualizaciones
","Yes","Yes","Juan Pane","Georg Neumann","100"
"20ad70e4-448d-48d5-8d92-097e85bbe57b","global","2015-09-29T03:08:47","2015","tt","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://finance.gov.tt/services/central-tenders-board/",,,,"Central Tenders Board","Government of the Republic of Trinidad and Tobago","Yes","Yes","Submission updated.","Awarded contracts are available here: https://finance.gov.tt/category/awarded-contracts/","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Georg Neumann","45"
"e8fc9b06-204a-41c0-8af5-187eaa99dfa4","global","2015-09-15T03:07:02","2015","tn","procurement","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission correct. Award information is not posted.","This site lists ongoing tenders (https://www.marchespublics.gov.tn/) but we were not able to find awards.","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Georg Neumann","0"
"4bea84cf-e85e-4c84-92f1-3f3e2b50661d","global","2015-10-13T21:59:36","2015","tg","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.marchespublics-togo.com",,,,"Direction National du Contrôle des Marchés Publics","Ministère de l'Economie et des Finances","Yes","Yes","Submission updated with link to tender information. ","Information on awards is not timely. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Georg Neumann","35"
"49e9095c-9a1d-4e94-8347-1701ae2f08f4","global","2015-09-20T02:41:04","2015","uy","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://catalogodatos.gub.uy/dataset/compras-estatales","RSS, XML","https://www.comprasestatales.gub.uy/inicio/datos-abiertos/",,"Publicaciones realizadas en el sitio web de Compras Estatales","Agencia de Compras y Contrataciones Estatales","Yes","Yes","Submission correct.",,"Yes","Yes","Daniel Carranza","Georg Neumann","100"
"75d933e2-1e01-4c05-b9cf-8e67c25d79a0","global","2015-09-25T17:09:56","2015","vc","procurement","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://svgedfpmcu.com/","DOC",,,,,"Yes","Yes","Updated. Data not available through government.","The data for procurement tenders is only available through third parties.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Georg Neumann","0"
"f8c2be48-6bdf-4357-9e40-4b5616f9ec97","global","2015-09-18T10:22:38","2015","kh","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.mef.gov.kh/old/procurement/bid-advertisement.php",,,,"Procurement - Bid Advertisement","Ministry of Economy & Finance","Yes","Yes","Submission updated on machine readability, bulk availability and license.",,"Yes","No","Vantharith Oum","Georg Neumann","45"
"d761296e-fb8b-4444-a4d1-fb88ba564797","global","2015-09-27T13:33:08","2015","kn","procurement","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.publictenders.net/node/2390641",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Information on tenders is not available through a government website.",,"Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Georg Neumann","0"
"2ae79adf-54a5-489d-9a91-30f5adcf3263","global","2015-09-20T14:40:17","2015","id","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://tender.pengadaan.com/",,,,"Data Pengadaan dari Lelang e-Procurement","Lembaga Kebijakan Pengadaan Barang/Jasa Pemerintah (LKPP)","Yes","Yes","Submission changed to official database of tenders by the Information Center of the National Procurement rather than the Open Data download.","Bulk dataset is available at https://data.go.id/dataset/data-pengadaan-dari-lelang-e-procurement, under open license https://opendefinition.org/licenses/cc-by/, but last updated on 2013","Yes","No","Farraz Theda","Georg Neumann","45"
"191d6809-0605-4f8d-a07f-1e9db575ec01","global","2015-09-27T10:33:04","2015","hu","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.kozbeszerzes.hu/adatbazis/keres/hirdetmeny/",,,,,"Public Procurement Authority","Yes","Yes","Submission correct.","Procurement data and information on contracts below the public procurement threshold shall be available on the procuring institution's website. ","Yes","No","sandor lederer","Georg Neumann","45"
"e7815716-386c-42a9-bf2c-0c14e3d2b01b","global","2015-10-03T08:52:44","2015","gn","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.finances.gov.gn/index.php/avis-dappel-doffres",,,,"Results of Procurement Tenders","Ministry of Finances","Yes","Yes","Information is available online, but completely out of date. ","A synthesis of the data are available on the website of the Ministry of Finances.","Yes","No","anonymous","Georg Neumann","35"
"308b2774-db54-45e4-974c-17e88d6f8491","global","2015-09-28T16:11:26","2015","gh","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.ppaghana.org/biddingmain.asp",,,,,"Public Procurement Authority","Yes","Yes","Submission updated. Not machine readable.","This website provides open Government tenders by Ministry, Region, District or Agency. Simply make your selection and press the 'search' button.
[enter link description here][1]
[1]: https://www.ppaghana.org/tendermain.asp","Yes","No","Nehemiah Attigah","Georg Neumann","45"
"9131f811-0b38-4fde-b948-c1c73ee90f75","global","2015-09-16T05:52:13","2015","gd","procurement","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.wttc.org/-/media/files/reports/economic%20impact%20research/country%20reports/grenada2014.pdf","PDF",,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission updated.","The government publishes [tenders][1], but no awards.
[1]: https://www.gov.gd/vacancies.html","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Georg Neumann","0"
"f7ef1982-41db-446c-8605-9a2c25ebb2ba","global","2015-09-28T10:21:42","2015","bf","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Résultats des appels d'offres. This dataset represent the result of tenders for the current year.","La Direction générale du contrôle des marchés publics et des engagements financiers (www.dcmp.bf, website down for now)","Yes","Yes","Submission correct.","The tenders begin with the publication of the public procurement plan. Following this plan, the tenders are launched and managed by the general direction of public procurement control. After the recount, the results are stored in a database and published in a paper magazine. The data in the database are accessible by demand but not yet opened by default. There is a process to make the data openly available initiated by the Burkina Faso Open Data Initiative","Yes","No","Idriss TINTO","Georg Neumann","40"
"486d62b5-6a81-4513-9ff2-98b6b707ee5c","global","2015-09-25T06:33:48","2015","jp","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.kantei.go.jp/jp/kanbou/20tyoutatu/1_buppin/1_buppin_pdf.html",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission correct.","Tender for purchase information is aggregated at following page.
* https://www.kantei.go.jp/jp/kanbou/20tyoutatu/1_buppin/1_buppin_pdf.html
* https://www.jetro.go.jp/gov_procurement.html
Each Ministry publishes their tender on their own webpage. In those webpages, all the required information are concluded.
* 衆議院 /House of Representatives
* https://www.shugiin.go.jp/internet/itdb_annai.nsf/html/statics/choutatsu/chotatsujoho.htm
* 参議院 /House of Councillors
* https://www.sangiin.go.jp/japanese/annai/choutatu/21buppin-ekimu/21seifuchoutatu.html
* https://www.sangiin.go.jp/japanese/annai/choutatu/index.html
* 最高裁判所 /Supreme Court
* https://www.courts.go.jp/tyotatu/
* 会計検査院 /Board of Audit of Japan
* https://www.jbaudit.go.jp/proc/info/index.html
* 内閣 /Cabinet
* https://www.cao.go.jp/chotatsu/geps_link/geps_link.html#kanbou
* 人事院 /National Personnel Authority
* https://www.jinji.go.jp/tyoutatu/index14.4.1.htm
* 内閣府 /Cabinet Office
* https://www.cao.go.jp/chotatsu/
* 宮内庁 /Imperial Household Agency
* https://www.kunaicho.go.jp/kunaicho/chotatsu/chotatsu.html
* 国家公安委員会(警察庁) /National Public Safety Commission
* https://www.npa.go.jp/chotatu/chotatsu/newmainmenu2.htm
* 防衛省 /Ministry of Defence
* https://www.mod.go.jp/j/procurement/chotatsu/index.html
* 総務省 /Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications
* https://www.geps.go.jp/
* 法務省 /Ministry of Justice
* https://www.moj.go.jp/chotatsu_index.html
* 外務省 /Ministry of Foreign Affairs
* https://www.mofa.go.jp/mofaj/annai/shocho/chotatsu/
* 財務省 /Ministry of Finance
* https://www.mof.go.jp/procurement/
* 文部科学省 /Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology
* https://www-gpo3.mext.go.jp/kanpo/gpoindex.asp
* 厚生労働省 /Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare
* https://www.mhlw.go.jp/shinsei_boshu/choutatsujouhou/
* 農林水産省 /Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries
* https://www.maff.go.jp/j/supply/
* 経済産業省 /Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry
* https://www.meti.go.jp/information_2/publicoffer/00_bid_news_list.html
* 国土交通省 /Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism
* https://www.i-ppi.jp/Search/Web/Index.htm
","Yes","No","Satoshi IIDA","Georg Neumann","45"
"2b3bb814-a0ae-404a-80c1-f371818b037d","global","2015-10-18T03:37:58","2015","pe","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.perucontrata.com.pe",,,,"Perú Contrata: Portal de Contrataciones del Estado","Ministerio de Economía y Finanzas: Organismo Supervisor de las Contrataciones del Estado","Yes","Yes","Submission correct.",,"Yes","No","Georg Neumann","Georg Neumann","45"
"adb624dc-deb7-4782-9ab1-882362abed52","global","2015-09-27T15:16:06","2015","ma","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.marchespublics.gov.ma/pmmp/",,,,"Portal Marocain des Marchés Publics","Gouvernement","Yes","Yes","Submission correct.",,"Yes","No","Chadi Nanaa","Georg Neumann","45"
"e8607431-115a-4f09-a3b7-79a5a9345f44","global","2015-09-17T16:20:05","2015","ly","procurement","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission correct.",,"Yes","No","Maraim Elbadri","Georg Neumann","0"
"8e9b1762-d4f7-429e-b33d-6bd6388aaf17","global","2015-09-27T06:58:20","2015","lv","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.iub.gov.lv/lv/iubsearch/pt/_pr/",,,,,"Iepirkumu uzraudzības birojs (Procurement Monitoring Bureau)","Yes","Yes","Submission updated. Data is not machine readable.","There are plans for making the data available in machine readable form.","Yes","No","Toms Ceļmillers","Georg Neumann","45"
"c04fb67a-27d9-473b-bb2d-2ebf7286f942","global","2015-09-17T16:41:00","2015","lc","procurement","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.dgmarket.com/tenders/list.do?sub=tenders-in-Saint-Lucia&locationISO=lc","PDF",,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission updated. The government does not publish full tender and award information. ","The government makes active tenders available online through its[enter link description here][1] website. However, awards are not published.
[1]: https://www.govt.lc/tenders","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Georg Neumann","0"
"5172c680-f8ea-49e8-b420-508ee0f9025d","global","2015-09-25T12:08:14","2015","kz","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://goszakup.gov.kz/",,,,"e-Commerce Center. The portal shows information about tenders, awards, reports.","Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","Submission correct.","In order to download files with necessary information it is required that you log in, there are a lot of other statistics regarding the procurements on portal. The information provided by government officials in Kazakhstan (by default) is open for reuse, publishing as cited by the law. ","Yes","No","Nazerke Akhmetzhanova","Georg Neumann","45"
"aa5d00ea-a756-4ae0-95af-9811beea3811","global","2015-09-15T03:20:06","2015","lb","procurement","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission correct.","Was not able to find this data. Some government bodies list their tenders (https://www.cdr.gov.lb/arabic/select_procurement.asp and https://www.isf.gov.lb/ar/auctions) but there is no general database and no listings for awards","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Georg Neumann","0"
"7c4f8346-b772-4610-a529-4f94a33f811f","global","2015-10-01T12:55:31","2015","ky","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.centraltenders.gov.ky/",,,,"Central Tenders Committee","Cayman Islands Government","Yes","Yes","Submission updated. ","Information on awards is not up-to-date. ","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Georg Neumann","35"
"c1d94bc4-8637-4b36-8ca0-4682fed2b2d5","global","2015-09-17T18:22:42","2015","kw","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.ctc.gov.kw/",,,,"Tenders and awards","Central Tender Committee","Yes","Yes","Submission updated with information on timely tenders.",,"Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Georg Neumann","45"
"1a1c4956-2c55-440c-a6be-43d461dced05","global","2015-09-15T13:45:12","2015","ko","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://krpp.rks-gov.net",,"https://gzk.rks-gov.net/ActDocumentDetail.aspx?ActID=2787",,,"Public Procurement Regulatory Commission ","Yes","Yes","Submission correct.","Article 12 of Law No. 04/L-065 on copyright and related rights places public documents in the public domain.","Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Georg Neumann","75"
"2d1b4e9e-6179-46a9-9d68-99435d48273b","global","2015-09-27T02:48:11","2015","pk","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Annual Budget Statement","Ministry of Finance, Government of Pakistan","Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.
Budget statement is not applicable in this case but the PIFRA system indicates that these are collected digitally.","There are digital systems to auditing which shows transactions: https://www.pifra.gov.pk/fabs.html which indicates that the transactional spending data exists. The data is however not public.","Yes","No","Nouman Nazim","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"6d458988-620c-49e5-9c5b-5ae2b83f34fa","global","2015-09-23T03:12:09","2015","bs","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","postcodes/zipcodes not used ","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"2bc4edce-6a1f-4e49-a3f1-00ca13a95e9e","global","2015-09-27T23:55:00","2015","aw","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","postcodes/zipcodes not found","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"cec51e3b-7642-49c5-bb11-f4ad71b568cc","global","2015-10-02T13:19:35","2015","ag","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://www.geopostcodes.com/Antigua_and_Barbuda",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The subdivision for post code data is available from GeoData company, free of charge: https://www.geopostcodes.com/Antigua_and_Barbuda, but the post codes are missing from the dataset.","We could not identify on any official website reference that a datasets with geocoded postal codes exists. The subdivision for post code data is available from GeoData company, free of charge: https://www.geopostcodes.com/Antigua_and_Barbuda, but the post codes are missing from the dataset.","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"36015294-e615-4b3e-855c-683a679ac699","global","2015-10-06T12:18:52","2015","sv","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.transparenciafiscal.gob.sv/portal/page/portal/PTF/","Excel",,,"Report Different reports on budget for income and expenditure data","Ministerio de Hacienda - Portal de Transparencia Fiscal - transparencia.fiscal@mh.gob.sv","Yes","Yes","I have changed openly license to NO, since we could not find the license. ","The data is not available in bulk in the sense that you have to download budget information for expenditure and incomes separately.
No explicit notice or information has been found explaining the terms of use of the data set.
QA comment - change to bulk, because the files are available under the same link (as we accepted in other countries). The data does not have a license or any terms of use. i have changed it to now. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"de490520-cb2f-472a-aef3-51d49307926c","global","2015-10-07T15:38:13","2015","pr","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.presupuesto.pr.gov/",,,,,"Oficina de Gerencia y Presupuesto (OGP) de Puerto Rico / Puerto Rico Office of Management and Budget","Yes","Yes","I have made changes in machine readable, bulk and license according to the link the submitter gave. ","Budget information is updated and published annually on this website as part of the regular budgetary process. The Executive presents a budget recommendation on this website (between March and May of every year), and after Legislative review and approval of the budget, the website is updated with the final approved budget numbers by the end of June, for the Fiscal Year that begins on July 1st.
Reviewer's note: Data is PDF. Could not find a machine readable version of the data. License suggest that the data is copyright of the government of Puerto Rico. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","55"
"37400200-48ae-44ac-811f-e40d79f875af","global","2015-09-25T13:38:01","2015","ma","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.hcp.ma/",,,,,"Haut Commissariat au Plan","Yes","Yes","Data are reasonably current but not up to date or openly licensed.","Unemployment rate is here, but no updates since last year (2014)
https://www.hcp.ma/Taux-de-Chomage-selon-le-sexe_a256.html
The population is published here
https://www.hcp.ma/Projections-de-la-population-totale-par-groupe-d-age-et-sexe-en-milliers-et-au-milieu-de-l-annee-1960-2050_a676.html
However it is mainly projections based on the results of the census of 2004 and 2009/2010. No traces of more recent census.
We found more updated version for the population on the Open Data portal in XLS format (for 2014)
https://www.data.gov.ma/data/fr/dataset/population-legale
We found GDP data here, but not up to date
https://www.data.gov.ma/data/fr/dataset/comptes-nationaux-pib-en-volume-et-contribution-a-la-croissance
The question about licensing is tricky to answer: when it boils down to the HCP, the data and content it provides are property of the institution. The Open Data portal has an unclear status: each dataset here is individually licensed under the ODbL yet the website itself and all its content are copyrighted by the eGov unit (data.gov.ma has no indication whatsoever on its 'License' page: https://www.data.gov.ma/fr/licence). Thus, the copyright mention has priority and the data is considered non-open.","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Zach Christensen","35"
"2e63ebe2-13bf-4e34-bd46-734f4ebf550e","global","2015-09-25T15:24:02","2015","do","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.digepres.gob.do/wp-content/uploads/2015/06/Informe-Ejecucion-Enero-Marzo-2015.pdf",,,,"Informe de Ejecución Presupuestaria","Dirección General de Presupuesto","Yes","Yes","There is no machine readable version of the data. Submission is correct. Data is in bulk. ",,"Yes","No","Eliaquín Encarnación","Mor Rubinstein","55"
"844a70fd-b040-4631-b9b2-c082de4da5d8","global","2015-10-04T14:48:36","2015","md","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"No","https://www.mf.gov.md/reports?y=2014&m=y",,,,,"Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","Data used to be published in XLS, but now its in PDF. I have changed the submission accordingly. ","The data for 2015 is not published yet, only for 2014. ","Yes","No","Codrina Maria Ilie","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"f63ffa5a-efb0-47dd-9b26-342ce2346269","global","2015-09-27T11:53:15","2015","tl","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Unsure","https://timoragri.fhost.com.au/ta500/ta551%20district%20boundaries.jpg",,,," Maps of Timor Leste - East Timor District Boundaries","Timor Leste Ministry of Agriculture and Fisheries ","Yes","Yes","Apparently Timor-Leste does not use postal codes. The administrative boundaries can be downloaded from Global Administrative Areas [https://www.gadm.org/download] up to subdistrict level. The smallest political division is the village (suco). License: ""This dataset is freely available for academic use and other non-commercial use. Redistribution, or commercial use is not allowed without prior permission."" ","I can't confirm the existence for Location Datasets because there are no dedicated department(s) nor ministry that focuses storing a database for postcodes/zipcodes in Timor-Leste. However, there are some generic information about districts in Timor-Leste from the official website Ministry of State Administration https://www.estatal.gov.tl/English/Municipal/Municipal_main.html but that doesn't meet the above criteria.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","45"
"93135eac-dafc-49a1-b460-c801365ec551","global","2015-09-26T10:46:14","2015","cm","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://armp.cm/Download_JDM.php#tzM8",,,,"Data on Contracts Awarded - Ministry of Public Contracts","Ministry of Public Contracts","Yes","Yes","Could not verify the link www.minmap.cm/ but the information is available in the journal. ","The Ministry of public contracts published on its website all the contracts awarded (www.minmap.cm/). The Public Contract Regulatory Agency publishes regularly a Public Contract Journal, on a monthly basis including call for tenders and results of the calls (https://armp.cm/Home.php#tzA2).
The Ministry of public contracts has just build an eProcurement platform that will be launched as soon as January 1st 2016. Testing and training are underway. The goal will be to provide procurement datasets for all public contracts processes in Cameroon.
","Yes","No","Charlie Martial NGOUNOU","Georg Neumann","45"
"bab8aeed-0ee4-4c90-b2d1-31efe7bcd560","global","2015-10-01T21:51:00","2015","ci","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://marchespublics.ci/fr/c_approbations.php",,,,"Liste des marchés approuvés","Direction des Marchés Publics","Yes","Yes","Submission updated. There is no bulk data download available.","The procurements tenders are managed by the direction of public procurement, that publish the data on his website.","Yes","No","anonymous","Georg Neumann","45"
"caff1835-d3a7-43c7-9515-409a0923d369","global","2015-10-04T11:10:17","2015","lb","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://cas.gov.lb/index.php/demographic-and-social-en/laborforce-en",,,,,"Central Administration of Statistics","Yes","Yes","Data not recent or openly licensed. ","Data is copyrighted under 2013 - Central Administration of Statistics
The data on Central Administration of Statistics (CAS) is outdated. (https://www.cas.gov.lb)
[Population][1] up to 2009 in excel.
[Unemployment][2] up to 2009 in excel.
[National Accounts][3] up to 2013 in excel.
[1]: https://cas.gov.lb/index.php/demographic-and-social-en/population-en
[2]: https://cas.gov.lb/index.php/demographic-and-social-en/laborforce-en
[3]: https://cas.gov.lb/index.php/demographic-and-social-en/laborforce-en","Yes","No","anonymous","Zach Christensen","35"
"e46aeccc-7947-481e-ad9c-8b9686d525a0","global","2015-10-04T14:46:06","2015","et","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.csa.gov.et/index.php/2013-02-20-13-43-35/national-statistics-abstract",,,,"National Statistics-Abstract (2003-2012)","Central Statstical Agency","Yes","Yes","Data not openly licensed mostly in PDF.","[Population][1] up to 2015.
[National accounts][2] up to 2013.
Some unemployment data listed.
[1]: https://www.csa.gov.et/images/documents/pdf_files/nationalstatisticsabstract/2006/total.pdf
[2]: https://www.csa.gov.et/images/documents/pdf_files/nationalstatisticsabstract/2004/total.pdf","Yes","No","anonymous","Zach Christensen","35"
"0f19b42c-aac3-4bed-9cee-a1ea9b2618d0","global","2015-10-02T14:27:29","2015","bs","statistics","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://statistics.bahamas.gov.bs/key.php?cat=13",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Data exist but not regularly or recent enough to count. No open license and in PDF.","Data is in pdf format and not machine readable.
[Unemployment][1] up to 2015.
[Population][2] up to 2010 in PDF.
[GDP][3] up to 2006.
[1]: https://statistics.bahamas.gov.bs/download/001454300.pdf
[2]: https://statistics.bahamas.gov.bs/key.php?cat=13
[3]: https://statistics.bahamas.gov.bs/download/042732700.pdf","Yes","No","anonymous","Zach Christensen","0"
"618b1e0a-ed1f-484f-95b6-ca175fdfd61f","global","2015-10-04T14:31:29","2015","do","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://redatam.one.gob.do/cgibin/RpWebEngine.exe/PortalAction?&MODE=MAIN&BASE=CPV2010&MAIN=WebServerMain.inl",,,,,"Various institutions: Oficina Nacional de Estadística, Banco Central de la República Dominicana","Yes","Yes","Data are not relatively current but not open. ","Other URLs to consider:
https://censo2010.one.gob.do/volumenes_censo_2010/vol1.pdf;
https://www.one.gob.do/Estadisticas/169/empleo-y-seguridad-social
https://www.bancentral.gov.do/estadisticas_economicas/mercado_trabajo/
[Annual unemployment][1] up to 2014.
[Population][2] up to 2015.
[GDP][3] up to 2013.
[1]: https://www.one.gob.do/Estadisticas/9/mercado-de-trabajo-
[2]: https://www.one.gob.do/Estadisticas/8/proyecciones-de-poblacion
[3]: https://sinid.one.gob.do/","Yes","No","anonymous","Zach Christensen","35"
"39388991-6382-4534-924a-c98f2fe5c048","global","2015-09-28T06:15:44","2015","kh","statistics","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Data on NSO website are outdated or not present. ","National Institute of Statistics has some old data on GDP but no population. https://www.nis.gov.kh/index.php/en/","Yes","No","anonymous","Zach Christensen","0"
"cab2b451-876c-45f2-bad8-9c18028ddada","global","2015-09-28T03:36:45","2015","bm","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.govsubportal.com/ministries/2012-02-10-14-05-02/cabinet-office/statistics/",,,,,"Department of Statistics","Yes","Yes","Data are relatively current but not updated and no open license.","The Department of Statistics provides census data as a report. As for the digest of statistics this seems to be spread over a number of different reports per category and reporting period.
[GDP][1] in PDF
[Population][2] in PDF
Annual [unemployment][3] figures in PDF.
There is also data on 2015 Labour Force Survey Preliminary Report.
[1]: https://www.govsubportal.com/images/Cabinet_Office/Dept_of_Statistics/Docs/GrossDomesticproduct/GDPQ12015.PDF
[2]: https://www.govsubportal.com/images/Cabinet_Office/Dept_of_Statistics/Docs/population/Population%20Projections%202010-2020%20-%20released%202014.pdf
[3]: https://www.govsubportal.com/images/Cabinet_Office/Dept_of_Statistics/Docs/LFS/2015%20LFS%20Preliminary%20Report.pdf","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Zach Christensen","35"
"21bf1cb9-6f20-4ff0-9829-fb6464873b23","global","2015-09-07T11:58:20","2015","bh","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"No","https://www.data.gov.bh/en/DataAnalysis/","PDF, JPG, Excel, JSON, XML","https://www.data.gov.bh/en/ODPolicy",,,"Central Informatics Organization","Yes","Yes","No unemployment data found but open license.","Bahrain has a data portal that provides a variety of statistics ( https://www.data.gov.bh/ ). However, this website is very buggy and it is difficult to verify if the data is available.
GDP up to 2014.
Population up to 2014.
","Yes","Yes","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Zach Christensen","80"
"1369eaab-44d5-4c28-a9f4-2bc31eada6eb","global","2015-09-08T18:17:23","2015","ae","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://dataportal.nbs.gov.ae/en/Dashboards","Excel",,,"Official statistics of the UAE.","National Bureau of Statistics","Yes","Yes","Data not up to date or openly licensed.","The UAE has a data portal that provides data on a variety of issues including GDP, foreign investment, etc.
The data does not appear to be up to date though and there is no updates after January 2014.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Zach Christensen","60"
"266dab42-c76c-41da-b1cb-871a752418bb","global","2015-10-01T13:10:39","2015","tz","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"No","https://nbs.go.tz/tnada/index.php/catalog",,,," Central Data Catalog","National Bureau of Statics -Tanzania","Yes","Yes","Some recent data but not openly licensed.",,"Yes","No","Joachim Mangilima","Zach Christensen","45"
"cc0a72e6-a2b0-4ff2-8998-cf95d4032b70","global","2015-09-07T14:18:24","2015","tn","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://dataportal.ins.tn","HTML,PDF,XLS,TXT,CSV,XML,JSON,MDB,DBF","https://www.ins.tn/indexfr.php",,,"National Institute of Statistics Tunisia ","Yes","Yes","Data not fully up to date.","Population up to 2014.
Unemployment up to 2012.
GDP up to 2013 on this [data][1] portal.
[1]: https://dataportal.ins.tn/fr/Map","Yes","Yes","Kamel Abdellaoui","Zach Christensen","90"
"d25a6f15-ccbd-42ae-a7cb-c18dcffcf0de","global","2015-10-13T21:41:54","2015","tg","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.stat-togo.org/index.php/component/tags/tag/11-statistique",,,,"Bulletins Mensuelles de la Statistiques : Publications mensuelles de données statistiques, démographiques et autres études sur le Togo","Institut National de la Statistique et des Etudes Economiques et Démographiques","Yes","Yes","Not openly licensed.","Data is not available in machine readable format","Yes","No","anonymous","Zach Christensen","45"
"3c7f2391-617f-44bc-8f16-bb0a82f87d22","global","2015-09-20T05:40:18","2015","pk","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.pbs.gov.pk/","HTML, PDF",,,,"Government of Pakistan, Pakistan Bureau of Statistics","Yes","Yes","Not openly licensed, data options are limited.","[Population][1] up to 2014
[Unemployment][2] up to 2014.
[GDP][3] up to 2014.
[1]: https://www.pbs.gov.pk/sites/default/files//Labour%20Force/publications/lfs2013-14/t01-pak-fin.pdf
[2]: https://www.pbs.gov.pk/sites/default/files//Labour%20Force/publications/lfs2013-14/t18-pak-fin.pdf
[3]: https://www.pbs.gov.pk/national-accounts-publications","Yes","No","Nouman Nazim","Zach Christensen","45"
"719c7d2a-70f4-40cc-af9a-78f42a378522","global","2015-09-20T22:13:50","2015","pt","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.dgo.pt/politicaorcamental/Paginas/OEpagina.aspx?Ano=2012&TipoOE=Or%C3%A7amento%20Estado%20Aprovado&TipoDocumentos=Lei%20/%20Mapas%20Lei%20/%20Relat%C3%B3rio",,,,"Orçamento do Estado","Direção Geral do Orçamento","Yes","Yes","I have checked this submission and it is correct. ","The complete budget is available in a series of PDF's, from 1836 on.
(No changes from 2014.)","Yes","No","Ricardo Lafuente","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"4e2939c6-c5f7-4d07-9987-9242050564b9","global","2015-09-07T11:35:08","2015","bh","budget","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Annual budget for the government of Bahrain on a department level breakdown.","Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","Data from this source lack sub department level. I have changed the submission accordingly. ","The annual budget can be downloaded from the website of the Ministry of Finance ( https://www.mof.gov.bh/arb/categorylist.asp?ctype=budget ). The report available provides review and expediter with a department level breakdown. The website provides a link for downloading the report in Excel or PDF formats, but currently only the PDF link works.
The Ministry of Finance website has an archive for previous years going back to 2003.
Reviewer's note - data is available only in department level. This does not meet the criteria for the budget data. It seems as the data exist but it in not available to the public. ","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"28c81e0b-bbcf-439c-9bd4-dc91c1d80874","global","2015-08-30T14:08:14","2015","np","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://cbs.gov.np/",,,,,"Central Bureau of Statistics","Yes","Yes","Current GDP and Population figures. No unemployment figures found. ","This is the official source of government data, This is handled by Nepal Planning Commission Secretariats, Government of Nepal. ","Yes","No","Nikesh Balami","Zach Christensen","55"
"8f1b7564-9e0d-4f99-9a85-71cc9859b3f8","global","2015-09-27T00:41:07","2015","cr","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://cgrweb.cgr.go.cr/apex/f?p=10263:2:0:::::","CSV",,,,"Contraloría General de la República","Yes","Yes","I have checked this submission and it is correct. ","The budget most of all public institutions is accessible and downloadable in the Contraloría General de la República (CGR) Website via an interface as a CSV file. Nevertheless the system is not friendly and to find the detailed budget is complicated and for some institutions is not available. The Central Goverment Budget it is also available in the Ministry of Finance website https://www.hacienda.go.cr/contenido/424-leyes-de-presupuestos but in a PDF format. ","Yes","No","camila salazar","Mor Rubinstein","60"
"2a8f5708-f458-4291-960c-1582f4d56345","global","2015-10-02T09:32:36","2015","ke","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.knbs.or.ke/",,,,"Kenya National Bureau of Statistics is a semi-autonomous Government agency that is responsible for/mandated to collect, compile analyze, publish and disseminate official statistics for public use. In addition, KNBS coordinates, monitors and supervises the National Statistical System (NSS).","https://www.knbs.or.ke/ - directorgeneral@knbs.or.ke, datarequest@knbs.or.ke","Yes","Yes","Data fairly regular without open licensing. ","The Kenya National Bureau of statistics which is the central government agency that collects data has statistics on census, economic activities, demographics. It has many channels through which the some of the data is distributed, with links for these pages on their website, one of which is the Kenya Open Data Initiative (KODI). However there seems to be no standard for distributing data. Some are available and open e.g. KODI but some are available on the KNBS website itself but not open. Some of these are not charged while others are. KNBS applies a statistics act and a form has to be submitted for data requests. On the plus side some include metadata, background information, data description. On the Kenya Open Data portal, the datasets are mostly from KNBS but not up to date.
[According to Ahmed ]
Other areas i.e. Consumer Price Indices have regularly updated data within the site, the Statistics section has data between 2006 and 2012 which is pretty outdated at present.","Yes","No","anonymous","Zach Christensen","45"
"b3a9855d-0b92-4f6b-bd76-92d267216565","global","2015-09-28T05:31:51","2015","sa","budget","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","There is no detailed budget available to the public. The data on the government portal is no sufficient and not updated. Link to the portal -https://www.data.gov.sa/dataset?query=budget&sort_by=changed&sort_order=DESC","The Ministry of Finance is the body responsible for preparing the budget. It publishes a report for the annual budget that includes general income and expenses for Saudi. However, these reports ( https://www.mof.gov.sa/Arabic/DownloadsCenter/Pages/Budget.aspx ) do not include a government department level breakdown and therefore do not qualify as being available for the purpose of this index.
The data published by the Ministry of Finance is in the form of textual document (see this years budget here: https://www.mof.gov.sa/Arabic/DownloadsCenter/DocLib/%D8%A8%D9%8A%D8%A7%D9%86%20%D9%88%D8%B2%D8%A7%D8%B1%D8%A9%20%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%85%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%8A%D8%A9%202015%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%86%D8%B3%D8%AE%D8%A9%D8%A7%D9%84%D9%86%D9%87%D8%A7%D8%A6%D9%8A%D8%A9.pdf), where numbers are approximate and mentioned in the form of ""about so and so"". The document has section for the total budget, and sections for department, but because the data is not in a table, it is not clear if all departments are mentioned or not, numbers doesn't seem to sum up. As mentioned by the submitted, the data doesn't qualify for the index this year, thus I'd rather set the data existence question to no. Furthermore, the Saudi Data Portal (https://www.data.gov.sa/) doesn't seem to have an updated data for the budget. Only budget from 2 years ago (see here: https://www.data.gov.sa/dataset/government-budget-budget-allocations-first-chapter)","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"0116492e-3ddd-4a03-ae1a-48b7eb330372","global","2015-10-07T15:41:35","2015","ie","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://budget.gov.ie",,,,"Annual Budget documents and data for the Republic of Ireland","Department of Finance and the Department of Public Expenditure and Reform","Yes","Yes","No changes from 2014. Data is only available in PDF files. ","Data could be more granular. I sent a question to the Dept. of Finance regarding the availability of the data in a bulk download and did not receive an answer. I will therefore leave it as a NO.
(same as 2014)","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"8cb46fe7-6bdc-41ad-bbfd-d8ff09be5709","global","2015-10-02T13:13:57","2015","rw","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.minecofin.gov.rw/fileadmin/templates/documents/BUdget_Management_and_Reporting_Unit/Annual_State_Finance_Laws/2015-2016_Original_Finance_Law/2015-2016_Original_Finance_Law_Official_Gazette_no_Special_of_30_06_20.pdf",,,,,"Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning - Republic of Rwanda","Yes","Yes","I have reviewed the data and it is correct. Could not find machine readable version of the file. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"18450c87-331c-4293-a567-b9b5d57c2c53","global","2015-10-03T08:22:33","2015","gn","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.stat-guinee.org/index.php/le-pays-en-bref/indicateurs-cles",,,,"Keys indicators","Institut National De La Statistique","Yes","Yes","Data are not regularly updated or licensed to be open. ","Some GDP data available for 2015 but not regularly.
No unemployment data found.
some population data found. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Zach Christensen","35"
"429fb4ae-25dd-4562-83de-fb7bfa3b8ab2","global","2015-09-28T13:07:10","2015","gg","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.gov.gg/pru","PDF",,,"Facts & Figures","Policy & Research Unit, policy.research@gov.gg","Yes","Yes","Data are not current, no open license."," GDP - see ""National accounts"" https://www.gov.gg/gdp (latest figure is an estimate for 2014, published August 2015) https://www.gov.gg/CHttpHandler.ashx?id=97340&p=
Unemployment - see ""Labout market"" https://www.gov.gg/lmb (latest figures are for June 2015, published September 2015) https://www.gov.gg/CHttpHandler.ashx?id=97595&p=0
Population - see https://www.gov.gg/population
Latest reports (for 2015) should be at https://www.gov.gg/article/116644/2015 but the page has no entries as at 28 September 2015.","Yes","No","Marcus Ferbrache","Zach Christensen","35"
"4c672c8d-4f60-47e5-ac2a-9306e076b782","global","2015-09-27T23:44:45","2015","ec","statistics","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://inec.gob.ec/estadisticas/",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Data for major indicators not found for most recent five years.","Available data is now not current. The last census was on 2010. There are also datasets from 2011 and 2012. Other data does not show clearly its date.
See https://inec.gob.ec/estadisticas/","Yes","No","Eduardo Bejar","Zach Christensen","0"
"33b0d713-201f-446c-8527-0c0f1c17aa25","global","2015-09-27T23:30:05","2015","bw","statistics","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.cso.gov.bw/",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","No unemployment data found, population only projections since 2001.","Reviewer's comments: Extensive statistics available (economic, social), divided in a series of sub-divisions. Submission appears correct.
[GDP][1] in PDF
[Population][2] in PDF
no unemployment data found.
[1]: https://www.cso.gov.bw/index.php/summary-statistics/189-gdp-second-quarter-2015
[2]: https://www.cso.gov.bw/templates/cso/file/File/Web-Population_Projection-2001-2031.pdf","Yes","No","anonymous","Zach Christensen","0"
"79f9ee7f-7585-45b2-b719-003558c7c246","global","2015-09-28T02:38:39","2015","ar","statistics","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.indec.gov.ar/index.asp",,,,,"Instituto Nacional de Estadistica y Censos","Yes","Yes","Not openly licensed, some but not all data available.","[population][1] (up to 2010)
[GDP][2] in PDF
The National Institute of Statistics and Census (INDEC) Provide an up-to-date downloadable datasets for research in various format. However, This process Involves a registration to the website. No license was found on the website.
But the data do not meet the requirements of the census:
GDP for the whole country updated at least quarterly
Unemployment statistics updated at least every month
Population updated at least once a year
","Yes","No","Yamila García","Zach Christensen","30"
"c49dfbb5-cb4b-4a96-829f-6747d39c1bc9","global","2015-09-28T05:35:06","2015","th","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"No","https://service.nso.go.th/nso/nso_center/project/search_center/23project-th.htm","Excel",,,"ตารางสถิติจากสำนักงานสถิติแห่งชาติ","National Statistical Office","Yes","Yes","Not current or openly licensed.","National Statistical Office responsible for National Statistics. Their data focuses on:
- Census data (สำมะโน)
- Society Survey (สำรวจด้านสังคม)
- Economy Survey (สำรวจด้านเศรษฐกิจ)
- Information and Communication Technology Survey (สำรวจด้านเศรษฐกิจ)
[Unemployment][1] in PDF and [Excel][2]
[Population][3] (up to 2030)
[GDP][4] up to 2012
[1]: https://web.nso.go.th/
[2]: https://service.nso.go.th/nso/nso_center/project/search_center/23project-en.htm
[3]: https://service.nso.go.th/nso/nso_center/project/search_center/23project-en.htm
[4]: https://service.nso.go.th/nso/nso_center/project/search_center/23project-en.htm","Yes","No","anonymous","Zach Christensen","50"
"955b03f9-897e-45e0-9a29-07e7cb11b96c","global","2015-10-12T22:24:38","2015","sa","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"No","https://www.cdsi.gov.sa/english/","xls",,,,"Central Department of Statistics and Information","Yes","Yes","No open license, not regularly published. ","The data is published by the Saudi Central Dept. of Statistics and Information, https://www.cdsi.gov.sa/
We have population here in XLS format, till 2014, https://www.cdsi.gov.sa/english/index.php?option=com_docman&Itemid=160
Here you can find GDP, also in XLS, but it is not updated quarterly as required, only yearly till 2014, https://www.cdsi.gov.sa/english/index.php?option=com_docman&Itemid=151
Here is labor force data, for 1st half of 2015, in PDF file, https://www.cdsi.gov.sa/english/index.php?option=com_docman&task=cat_view&gid=296&Itemid=162
As mentioned above, although the data exists, the GDP and Labour Data doesn't meet the above criterion of being updated Quarterly and Monthly respectively ","Yes","No","anonymous","Zach Christensen","50"
"277ef9fc-a1eb-430f-b27c-0c906d95d6ec","global","2015-09-28T05:59:58","2015","ph","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"No","https://web0.psa.gov.ph/nsoda/index.php/catalog","CSV, RDF, XLS, PDF, HTML",,,,"National Statistics Office - NSO","Yes","Yes","Data aren't all current or openly licensed.","[Unemployment][1] in PDF
[Population][2] in excel (up to 2010)
[GDP][3] in html, pdf, excel.
See also this data catalogue: https://web0.psa.gov.ph/nsoda/index.php/about-the-data
Data is not timely - the last update of the website is from 2010.
[1]: https://psa.gov.ph/content/employment-rate-estimated-935-percent-july-2015
[2]: https://psa.gov.ph/statistics/quickstat/national-quickstat/2015/%2A
[3]: https://nap.psa.gov.ph/sna/DataCharts.asp","Yes","No","anonymous","Zach Christensen","50"
"37388641-1263-4016-98e2-8540ba73995b","global","2015-10-02T15:16:28","2015","gd","statistics","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.theodora.com/wfbcurrent/grenada/grenada_economy.html",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","All data found online was hosted by a third party or cited a third party as its source. ","No official source of data found online, all data hosted by third party. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Zach Christensen","0"
"f982b473-cf15-48f7-89ab-3addbe911d2e","global","2015-10-01T22:24:18","2015","se","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.regeringen.se/rattsdokument/proposition/2015/09/prop.-2015161/","PDF, XLS",,,,"Department of Finance (Finansdepartementet)","Yes","Yes","I have checked this submission and it is correct. ","Available in Excel format. No explicit license information.
URL of data online: ""https://www.regeringen.se/sb/d/2548/a/199285"" has been deleted for unknown reasons, however, it has been replaced by an updated version.
","Yes","No","Asmen Gül","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"ab572396-8354-43ca-af8b-2fecf3b52fbf","global","2015-09-28T19:13:41","2015","br","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"No","https://dados.gov.br/dataset/compras-publicas-do-governo-federal","csv, xml, json","https://opendatacommons.org/licenses/dbcl/1.0/",,"Compras públicas do governo federal","Ministério do Planejamento, Orçamento e Gestão","Yes","Yes","Submission correct. ","Has data on tenders, participants, suppliers, contracts, bids, values, etc. Available as a RESTful open data API. Possible to browse data in html format as well. Sources: Sistema Integrado de Administração e Serviços Gerais (SIASG), SICAF (suppliers registry), CatMat (material types catalog), CatSer (service types catalog) and Comprasnet (online tender bidding system).
Does not qualify the minimum criteria because the data us not up-to-date (last update: January 2015).","Yes","Yes","Augusto Herrmann","Georg Neumann","80"
"f0da7a05-cfd1-41f4-a7f9-279599b1e198","global","2015-08-27T14:13:54","2015","cl","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.mercadopublico.cl/",,,,"MercadoPublico.cl is the platform Tenders ChileCompra space supply and demand with common rules and tools, managed by the ChileCompra Office","ChileCompra Office","Yes","Yes","Submission updated. ","The data is on a Government Platform called MercadoPublico.cl which facilitates the contact between supply and demand. Only ongoing procurement process are available in bulk as XLS archives. ","Yes","No","Ahumada Abrigouis Alberto L","Georg Neumann","45"
"63f38287-82c9-42aa-9d4f-4aa71169a618","global","2015-09-24T10:36:06","2015","mk","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"No","https://www.stat.gov.mk/Default_en.aspx","Excel, PC-Axis",,,,"State Statistical Office","Yes","Yes","Data not all timely, not licensed for open. ","The major issue related to the work of the State Statistical Office is that there is no recent census.
Data is not available in bulk. Every indicator must be downloaded separately. Example here: https://makstat.stat.gov.mk/pxweb2007bazi/Database/StatistikaPoOblasti/BDP/BDPInvesGodisni/BDPsporedESS2010/BDPsporedESS2010.asp","Yes","No","Metamorphosis Foundation","Zach Christensen","50"
"5c147153-f8a9-4222-b442-56d635c7271a","global","2015-09-13T11:22:55","2015","jo","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://web.dos.gov.jo/?lang=en",,,,,"Department of Statistics","Yes","Yes","Data not fully current, no open license. ","Jordan Department for Statistics, has the following data in its homepage (https://web.dos.gov.jo/?lang=en):
* Unemployment (until last quarter, Q2 2015)
* GDP (Q1 2015)
Populations Census (https://www.dos.gov.jo/dos_home_e/main/Demograghy/pop_index.htm), has the following:
* Population (until 2012)
However, there is ongoing census for 2015 population here, https://census.dos.gov.jo/?lang=en
The data in Jordan's Open Data Portal (https://www.jordan.gov.jo/wps/portal/) is not up to date. Thus, we will base our submission here on the Department of Statistics. ","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Zach Christensen","35"
"0debff07-ecdd-4a41-a34a-1f1ccbaf67a1","global","2015-10-07T02:11:45","2015","cn","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.ccgp.gov.cn/",,,,"The publisher set up a central information portal ccgp.gov.cn to provide both national and local level tender and award information","Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","Submission correct.","The ccgp.gov.cn is the central information portal publishing tender and award information at both national and local level.
For tender, you can find all national tender information here: https://www.ccgp.gov.cn/cggg/zygg/gkzb/
For award, you can find all national award information here: https://www.ccgp.gov.cn/cggg/zygg/zbgg/
data are available in HTML table. Some data such as the name of the supplier is available in a word document. ","Yes","No","OKFN CN","Georg Neumann","45"
"eff0264e-0daf-4e3b-bea4-f8cc2da0ad82","global","2015-09-05T20:42:16","2015","eg","procurement","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission correct.","The website [etenders.gov.eg][1] is meant to aggregate all tenders and awards of the Egyptian national government. It divides tenders into ongoing, submitted and awarded ones. The section for the ongoing ones seems to be up to date with tenders' names, description and status. The submitted and awarded section have the latest tenders from 2009 and 2010 respectively. For the awarded tenders it doesn't list the suppliers the tenders were awarded too. For each tender there are two links for ""technical"" and ""financial"" evaluations, but they require login.
[1]: https://etenders.gov.eg","Yes","No","anonymous","Georg Neumann","0"
"5cec25fd-06c1-454b-8a10-5a8bbdef43d8","global","2015-09-24T06:13:36","2015","sg","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.tablebuilder.singstat.gov.sg/publicfacing/mainMenu.action","CSV, PDF, XLS, HTML",,,"Singstat Table Builder","Department of Statistics Singapore","Yes","Yes","Data current, accessible but no currency. ","All datasets can be exported in machine-readable format using table builder.","Yes","No","Zhi Yuan Lim","Zach Christensen","70"
"5fc933a8-6e76-4e02-b6e4-54c474716fb0","global","2015-09-27T02:17:38","2015","cr","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.hacienda.go.cr/rp/ca/ConsultaTramites.aspx",,,,"Comprared - Sistema de Compras Publicas","Ministerio de Hacienda ","Yes","Yes","Updated with the link to the official public procurement platform.",,"Yes","No","Alejandro Sanabria","Georg Neumann","45"
"8240a1f3-c21f-46ff-b64a-d32bd0303b67","global","2015-10-02T17:49:02","2015","lc","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://204.188.173.139:9090/stats/index.php/publications",,,,"The Statistical Digests contain tables of the main Social and Economic Statistics of Saint Lucia.","Central Statistics Office","Yes","Yes","Some PDFs with some of the data up to 2012. ","The data found are updated to the year 2012
Data is in pdf format and not machine readable.","Yes","No","anonymous","Zach Christensen","35"
"6b7300dc-afe9-4277-a289-39cf8431d074","global","2015-09-24T06:42:44","2015","bf","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"No","https://cns.bf/spip.php?id_rubrique=10&page=publication",,,,,"Institut National de la statistique et de la démographie","Yes","Yes","Data are missing in many cases, not licensed to be open.","In Burkina Faso, the agency that is responsible of the statistics is INSD (National Institute of Statistics and Demography). According to the type of statistics, there are annual and quarterly publication.
[GDP][1] (pdf)
Most data missing.
[1]: https://cns.bf/spip.php?id_rubrique=114&page=publdetails","Yes","No","Idriss TINTO","Zach Christensen","45"
"481dacc3-11eb-4a00-bd0a-49ebdf21ee65","global","2015-10-02T16:34:59","2015","ne","procurement","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I could not verify that any information is available online. Data availability set to no.","The general direction of public procurements control is in charge of the tenders data. Normally, the data must be online, but their website is down. The data is in pdf format and available for free","Yes","No","anonymous","Georg Neumann","0"
"0c9b5664-83a7-4b19-b1bc-856a971e7b46","global","2015-09-27T23:49:58","2015","gy","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.npta.gov.gy/tender_awards.html",,,,"List of NPTA Tender Awards","National Procurement and Tender Administration","Yes","Yes","Submission correct.",,"Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Georg Neumann","45"
"f8baf0f3-5c92-4923-b431-edb9e4c0b537","global","2015-09-27T08:09:38","2015","bo","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.sicoes.gob.bo/general/frames.php?direccion=../contrat/procesos.php",,,,"Sistema de Contrataciones Estatales","Ministerio de Economía y Finanzas Públicas","Yes","Yes","There is no indication that the data is openly licensed. ",,"Yes","No","Mariana Leyton","Georg Neumann","45"
"20013d94-c7c6-4347-8178-e820ca52d4e3","global","2015-09-12T13:41:28","2015","dz","procurement","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is correct. ","We were not able to find this data","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Georg Neumann","0"
"b3684356-7dcc-4281-946a-7f9ace4f48e7","global","2015-09-23T14:24:44","2015","sd","procurement","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The assessment seems to be correct. No public national tender information seems to be available. ","It seems that Sudan does not have data about its public procurement. We only found some examples for data about the tenders in some official websites like the website of Sudanese Electricity Transmission Co. Ltd, and the data seems outdated (https://setco-sd.com/index.php/ar/tenders). ","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Georg Neumann","0"
"70cbdf24-eabd-4d11-bcf7-b5cb3dc77967","global","2015-09-21T01:55:44","2015","ph","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.gov.ph/catalogue/dataset/philgeps-public-data?TSPD_101_R0=e79d4f09941f0064a740f3ef371e100fivM00000000000000003bbd126cffff00000000000000000000000000005622f66c00838a05d8","CSV","https://data.gov.ph",,"Opportunities and Award Notices","Philippine Government Electronic Procurement System","Yes","Yes","Updated the entry with the links to the procurement data. ","The official tender and award notices are available at [Philgeps][1]. The data is available for download through the [Open Data portal][2]. The data on the portal is in the public domain.
[1]: https://www.philgeps.gov.ph/
[2]: https://data.gov.ph","Yes","Yes","anonymous","Georg Neumann","100"
"567940fe-4e4d-4054-b0d9-04078b5af9db","global","2015-09-28T08:10:14","2015","mm","procurement","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission correct.","No evidence showing from the President's Officer website that the data is exist. https://www.myanmarpresidentoffice.info/en/ and the dedicated webpage for the cabinet ministries is empty https://www.myanmarpresidentoffice.info/en/?q=cabinet/ministries so no way to find out who are the responsible minister involve. I have found a 3rd party website https://www.ourweb.info/01/directory/myanmar/005/ that provide a list of ministries official websites but some of these websites are not found.
Kindly note that there is a high possibility that Myanmar government did not update each of these ministries websites so there is an error while trying to gain access to these websites.","Yes","No","anonymous","Georg Neumann","0"
"0642909f-df84-4b82-b514-18ba3199794f","global","2015-09-25T07:24:33","2015","za","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.statssa.gov.za/default.asp","Excel, PDF, ASCII",,,,"Statistics South Africa info@statssa.gov.za ","Yes","Yes","Data not in open format.","Some of it is available only in PDF files, but some datasets are available in Excel and ASCII formats under the 'interactive data' heading. ","Yes","No","Greg Kempe","Zach Christensen","60"
"1320d214-6302-4f36-b3bc-dd6ec316ea5b","global","2015-09-28T21:13:30","2015","sv","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://www.digestyc.gob.sv/index.php/servicios/descarga-de-documentos.html","Excel, PDF",,,,"DIRECCION GENERAL DE ESTADISTICA Y CENSOS (DIGESTYC) ","Yes","Yes","No open license or regular updates. ","There are different data sets available, but not always with in a homogeneous temporal series. Not license nor terms of use of the information has been found","Yes","No","anonymous","Zach Christensen","60"
"86e2df29-1fc9-4cca-bf6d-28d98bcac098","global","2015-09-22T16:07:03","2015","ru","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"No","https://fedstat.ru, www.gks.ru","SDMX, XML, CSV, html",,,"Unified statistical system (EMISS)","Russian Statistical Service","Yes","Yes","Not openly licensed or updated past 2014.","[population][1] in html
[unemployment][2] up to 2014 in html
[GDP][3] up to 2014 in html
[1]: https://www.gks.ru/bgd/regl/b15_12/IssWWW.exe/stg/d01/05-01.htm
[2]: https://www.gks.ru/bgd/regl/b15_12/IssWWW.exe/stg/d01/06-12.htm
[3]: https://www.gks.ru/bgd/regl/b15_12/IssWWW.exe/stg/d01/07-01.htm","Yes","No","Ivan Begtin","Zach Christensen","50"
"0a2c5c32-141d-4ac9-8c46-34c5538bdc5c","global","2015-08-24T11:34:15","2015","ng","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://nigerianstat.gov.ng/","json, PDF, PPTX, GIF, XLS",,,,"National Bureau of Statistics","Yes","Yes","Some data listed, not openly licensed ","[GDP][1] data (in PDF)
[Unemployment][2] data (PDF)
[Prognoz][3] portal doesn't seem to have been updated since 2012.
[1]: https://nigerianstat.gov.ng/nbslibrary/economic-statistics/gross-domestic-product
[2]: https://nigerianstat.gov.ng/nbslibrary/social-economic-statistics/labour
[3]: https://nigeria.prognoz.com/","Yes","No","Oludotun Babayemi","Zach Christensen","60"
"a8fc0a6a-722d-4a31-8852-8bda2b596469","global","2015-09-28T11:01:20","2015","md","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://www.statistica.md/","HTML, PX, CSV, TXT, XLS, DBF","https://date.gov.md/en/terms-and-conditions",,,"National Bureau of Statistics of the Republic of Moldova","Yes","Yes","Data are mostly open and regularly updated, but not all.","[Population][1] data.
[Unemployment][2] data
[GDP][3] data (up to 2013)
[1]: https://www.statistica.md/category.php?l=en&idc=103&
[2]: https://www.statistica.md/category.php?l=en&idc=107&
[3]: https://statbank.statistica.md/pxweb/Dialog/varval.asp?ma=CNT0101_en&ti=Volume%20of%20goods%20and%20services%2C%201995-2013%20%20%20%20&path=../Database/EN/13%20CNT/CNT01/&lang=3","Yes","Yes","Victoria Vlad","Zach Christensen","90"
"28ac2f57-8565-4c2d-aad4-5b2efe122eda","global","2015-10-01T12:24:43","2015","ky","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"No","https://www.eso.ky/#2","XLS; PDF",,,,"Economics and Statistics Office","Yes","Yes","Data aren't open or current.","Data on [GDP][1] (last for 2014)
[Unemployment][2] data for 2015 (in PDF)
[Population][3] (up to 2012) in XLS.
[1]: https://www.eso.ky/indicators_page.html#1
[2]: https://www.eso.ky/UserFiles/page_docums/files/uploads/cayman_islands_labour_force_survey_repor-2.pdf
[3]: https://www.eso.ky/indicators_page.html#3","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Zach Christensen","50"
"b8a81a33-15d6-44c0-89fd-93ea34a076dc","global","2015-09-08T10:27:07","2015","kr","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.index.go.kr","Excel",,,"e-Narajipyo - e-Narajipyo provides about 825 national indicators to show every aspect of our nation.","Statistics Korea (index@korea.kr)","Yes","Yes","Data are current but largely not open.","[e-Narajipyo][1] is a service provided by the Statistics Korea, the national statistical office of the Rep. of Korea. This service provides about 825 national indicators to show every aspect of our nation. Although the data available on this site meets all the minimum criteria, the data is not openly licensed. The service is copyrighted, and the license for data is unclear. e-Narajipyo provides [Web APIs][2], but its terms of use restrict commercial use.
[1]: https://www.index.go.kr/
[2]: https://www.index.go.kr/openApi/openApiIntro.do","Yes","No","James G. Boram Kim","Zach Christensen","70"
"fda56cc4-aa85-4d88-9cd0-41852281b8aa","global","2015-09-05T04:28:54","2015","jm","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"No","https://statinja.gov.jm/Default.aspx","HTML, XLS, CSV, TXT, TSV, QCSV",,,,"Statistical Institute of Jamaica -STATIN","Yes","Yes","Data not as timely as possible, not openly licensed.","[GDP][1] data
[Unemployment][2] (only up to 2014)
[Population][3] (only up to 2014)
[1]: https://statinja.gov.jm/NationalAccounting/Quarterly/NewQuarterlyGDP.aspx
[2]: https://statinja.gov.jm/LabourForce/UnemploymentRatesByAgeGroup.aspx
[3]: https://statinja.gov.jm/Demo_SocialStats/Newpopulation.aspx","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Zach Christensen","50"
"b50d0859-a071-4a1b-9ba2-5da66b07fcdb","global","2015-10-02T13:53:42","2015","eg","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://www.capmas.gov.eg/HomePage.aspx","XLS, PDF",,,"Population, Foreign Trade, Labour, Wages, Agriculture, etc","Central Agency for Public Mobilization and Statistics","Yes","Yes","Some timeliness issues with updates. ","The CAPMAS (Central Agency for Public Mobilization and Statistics) is the national authority responsible for collecting, curating and releasing the country's data on demographics, wages, agriculture, tourism, etc. The website and the data are available in Arabic and English.
Majority of are in PDF format, but some others are in XLS. There are also some broken links on the website.
Final reviewer: The majority of information is available as PDF embedded in a flash reader. The data overall is available in a non-readable format and is not available in bulk. Yet these criteria were marked as 'unsure' since one can filter and download quite some data through the CensusInfo database, incl. in a machine-readable format.
Regarding the timeliness of data, it is marked as outdated:
https://www.censusinfo.capmas.gov.eg/DivInfo/ and https://www.censusinfo.capmas.gov.eg/DivInfo/DIWizard/DIWizardHome.aspx are the CAPMAS database; they seem to provided data from either 1980 or 2012 (unclear). Indeed, some summary numbers are provided for 2014 (e.g., https://www.capmas.gov.eg/Pepo/lab_e.pdf). Lastly, it is unknown what the release mechanism is and how often the data is updated.
QA reviewer comment - different data can be downloaded in XLS and in bulk, as seen in the link here- https://www.capmas.gov.eg/Pages/IndicatorsPage.aspx?Ind_id=1104
Data however, is not timely updated. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Zach Christensen","60"
"f597de89-f971-4e19-9924-325e4c6d9e2c","global","2015-10-07T02:04:49","2015","cn","statistics","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Data not regularly produced.","https://data.stats.gov.cn/ is the data portal managed by the National Statistics Bureau.
It provides:
1. Quarterly and Yearly GDP for the whole country
2. Yearly Unemployment statistics
3. Yearly population data
However, based upon the new minimum criteria set by index (2015 version), that means China does not have the right statistic data opened up by the government.","Yes","No","OKFN CN","Zach Christensen","0"
"4cf5b364-0ca8-48e8-8b37-cb518f3cce8b","global","2015-08-27T15:16:15","2015","cl","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.observatorioregional.cl/buscador, https://www.ine.cl/canales/chile_estadistico/familias/laborales.php","XLS",,,"Regional Observatory: provides data regarding the economic, social, environmental and territorial situation of each region.","Instituto Nacional de Estadisticos, Undersecretary of Regional Development","Yes","Yes","Data not published with open license. ","[Population][1] in XLS.
Those are grouped in three variables (Economic, Social, Environment) and these into 16 categories that can be accessed through an index.
[1]: https://www.ine.cl/canales/chile_estadistico/familias/demograficas_vitales.php","Yes","No","Diego Ignacio","Zach Christensen","70"
"44833c2b-086b-4e45-94b0-9cf0d4ce6e82","global","2015-09-21T02:31:47","2015","ph","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","No","No","Yes","Yes",,"Yes",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The geoportal contains geodata on the territory of the Philippines, however we were unable to locate geocoded postal code information. The PhlPost offers only a web service of identifying the postal code at city level. ","There is a query system database of Philippine Postal to check the local zip codes - https://www.phlpost.gov.ph/zip-code-search.php Zipcodes do exist, but they have not been geocoded.
NAMRIA updated their Geoportal providing access to updated shapefiles up to the barangay level. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","45"
"a6b34cc6-9434-4340-8b36-5d382c785938","global","2015-09-28T20:34:17","2015","br","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.ibge.gov.br/english/, https://seriesestatisticas.ibge.gov.br/, www.ipeadata.gov.br","csv, tsv, xls","https://www.ipeadata.gov.br/iframe_direitouso.aspx?width=1009&height=767",,"Ipeadata","Instituto Brasileiro de Geografia e Estatística, Instituto de Pesquisa Econômica Aplicada","Yes","Yes","Data are openly licensed in variety of formats, with open licensing. ","Since 2009 the Brazilian Federal Institute for Geography and Statistics realizes regular research about economic activity on a monthly base. Data is available for different economic activities and per state. Every ten years the institute realizes a demographic census. Data can be accessed via online services: https://www.sidra.ibge.gov.br/, is presented in time series: https://seriesestatisticas.ibge.gov.br/lista_tema.aspx?op=0&no=8 or can be downloaded: https://downloads.ibge.gov.br/downloads_estatisticas.htm
Statistics are also provided by the federal Institute of Applied Economic Research (IPEA), many of which are reproduced from another source. Some series are regularly updated, others are not. Licensing information is similar to CC-BY, allowing copying and reuse but requiring attibution. So it should be considered open. Data is not linkable to, as the machine-readable versions (csv or Excel) require clicking an ""export"" button on the interface, and there is no direct access URL for the files.","Yes","Yes","Augusto Herrmann","Zach Christensen","100"
"a3adad20-5648-4270-b96d-5eb82f05fc0c","global","2015-09-27T21:41:30","2015","bg","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.nsi.bg/","Excel, PDF, HTML",,,,"The National Statistics Institute","Yes","Yes","Current data available in XLS ","[GDP][1] in XLS.
[Unemployment][2] in XLS.
[Population][3] in XLS.
[1]: https://www.nsi.bg/en/content/12588/quarterly-data
[2]: https://www.nsi.bg/en/content/6481/unemployed-and-unemployment-rates-national-level-statistical-regions
[3]: https://www.nsi.bg/en/content/6704/population-districts-municipalities-place-residence-and-sex","Yes","No","Boyan Yurukov","Zach Christensen","70"
"5cdfe7fa-2ba5-4c2e-a26c-311f9e0b9975","global","2015-09-21T03:50:29","2015","id","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.bps.go.id/website/pdf_publikasi/Statistik-Indonesia-2015.pdf",,"https://bps.go.id",,"Statistik Indonesia 2015 (Statistical Yearbook 2015)","Badan Pusat Statistik (BPS)","Yes","Yes","Current data in multiple formats but no open license.","According to Law number 16 of 1997 on statistics, basic statistics and sectoral statistics are available for public use unless it is specified otherwise in prevailing legislation. Basic statistics being defined as statistics utilized for a broad range of (both government and community) purposes, which have cross-sectoral characteristics, are on a national and macro scale, and will be the responsibility of the Statistics Agency.
","Yes","No","Farraz Theda","Zach Christensen","75"
"adf63a28-92ee-4561-8885-57e9dc963128","global","2015-10-11T14:20:57","2015","tr","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://www.officialstatistics.gov.tr/?q=en","Excel, CSV, HTML, PDF",,,"Turkish Statistical Institute","TurkStat- Turkish Statistical Institute - info@tuik.gov.tr","Yes","Yes","Data not openly licensed. Some data current, some not. ","Population data only up to 2014
GDP and unemployment up to 2015.","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Zach Christensen","60"
"ac61767e-6220-48a8-8b9f-9a5407984af3","global","2015-10-02T13:16:02","2015","rw","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.statistics.gov.rw/publications","CSV","https://statistics.gov.rw/about-us/terms-use",,,"National Institute of Statistics of Rwanda","Yes","Yes","Some current data, openly licensed.","[GDP][1]
The National Institute of Statistics of Rwanda is the main provider of official statistics for the country and the majority of datasets are available on their website: https://www.statistics.gov.rw/publications
But there are also several other websites/services where you can find or request Rwandan data: https://www.devinfo.statistics.gov.rw/di7web/libraries/aspx/Home.aspx
https://www.devinfo.statistics.gov.rw/di7web/libraries/aspx/RegStructure.aspx
https://www.devinfo.org/devinforwanda/libraries/aspx/Home.aspx
https://data.gov.rw/ (under development)
https://data.un.org/countryData/Data/Show/RWA
https://data.worldbank.org/country/rwanda
[1]: https://statistics.gov.rw/publications/gdp-national-accounts-second-quarter-2015","Yes","Yes","anonymous","Zach Christensen","100"
"19eeb2a5-e2ef-4555-810a-788cbb314799","global","2015-09-17T17:23:11","2015","lc","spending","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is correct.
Added clarification text.","There is no indication that the data exists. The [2014-2015 budget summary](https://www.govt.lc/media.govt.lc/www/resources/publications/Budget-Brochure-2.pdf) only show a very highly aggregated expenditure statement but by no means does that justify the existence of transactional data.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","0"
"6a716429-e189-466b-835d-70df423e73d7","global","2015-09-25T18:45:52","2015","kn","spending","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.
It does not seem to be collected systematically.","Data does not seem to be systematically collected. There are some budget news at the [government site](https://sknis.info/?s=budget) but no documents that indicate collection of the data.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","0"
"69e3a443-22b7-4c2e-babd-484e18a45dae","global","2015-09-20T22:26:18","2015","pt","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.ine.pt","Excel, CSV",,,,"Statistics Portugal","Yes","Yes","Data current and available in multiple formats but not openly licensed. ","Data current and available in many formats.
No mention of the data's license.
","Yes","No","Ricardo Lafuente","Zach Christensen","70"
"ece935b9-0612-4ff9-ab48-62310eee9829","global","2015-09-27T15:24:08","2015","jm","spending","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://jis.gov.jm/government-spends-114m-content-tablet-computers/",,,,,"Jamaica Information Service","Yes","Yes","Submission is correct.
Added a minor addition to show where documents could be.","No data available at a detailed transactional level.
Also, there is no evidence that the data is being collected except for a few government entities if one looks through: https://jis.gov.jm/government/documents/","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","0"
"e87c1808-bec1-42db-a39d-73c6e5aac253","global","2015-09-12T23:35:39","2015","jp","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.e-stat.go.jp/SG1/estat/eStatTopPortalE.do","CSV, PDF, Excel",,,,"Statistics Japan","Yes","Yes","Data are recent but not always open and not always in csv.","This so-called ""e-stat"" is the one-stop government stat data site of Japan. Most of data are available in Excel, some even CSV (unfortunately some are still PDF). You may use them basically free of charge.
""3) Prohibited use"" makes the data non-open.
Restrictions on use found [here][1].
[1]: https://www.stat.go.jp/english/info/riyou.htm","Yes","No","Satoshi IIDA","Zach Christensen","70"
"cec33f7f-4669-4fb5-aafc-79359c486b04","global","2015-09-18T21:04:18","2015","is","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.hagstofa.is/Hagtolur","CSV, Excel, HTML, XML, PX-Axis",,,,"Hagstofa Íslands (Statistics Iceland)","Yes","Yes","Current data available in many formats, not openly licensed."," Web interface allows users to select what data they want, but does not limit the amount of data retrieved (unless user asks for a subset).
","Yes","No","Páll Hilmarsson","Zach Christensen","70"
"1acf18c9-eea5-4d10-b163-7f98f3b6bc05","global","2015-09-19T09:35:37","2015","il","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://cbs.gov.il/reader/mainind/indhebnew.html","Excel, PDF",,,"אינדיקטורים עיקריים | Main Indicators","Central Bureau of Statistics","Yes","Yes","Regular data but not openly licensed.","Some of the above mentioned indicators are updated monthly, and not quarterly.
The page is also available in English on
https://cbs.gov.il/reader/mainind/indengnew.html","Yes","No","ido ivri","Zach Christensen","70"
"2bb29bf5-947e-413a-b58f-7c2224d45585","global","2015-09-19T11:26:56","2015","ch","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.bfs.admin.ch/bfs/portal/en/index/infothek/onlinedb/stattab.html","HTML,CSV,XLS",,,"Online statistical data about Switzerland","Swiss Statistics- Federal Statistical Office","Yes","Yes","Data available, regular but not openly licensed.","Commercial users need to obtain written permission, as per [Liability and copyright page][1].
[1]: https://www.bfs.admin.ch/bfs/portal/en/index/dienstleistungen/premiere_visite/02/02_03/copy.html","Yes","No","Oleg Lavrovsky","Zach Christensen","70"
"1938b92e-e692-4d16-bbbf-14efd040c228","global","2015-09-28T23:56:23","2015","pa","emissions","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","
Panama: The article from la estrella de Panama indicates that several monitoring stations are setup in Panama. However, there is no clear infomration about the measured data from the Ministerio de Ambiente or the SINIA system.
source-https://aqicn.org/faq/2015-05-10/a-comparison-of-latin-american-air-quality-scales/
","Yes","No","HAMZAH HAJI","yar michl","5"
"59fba043-6d39-4e2d-be6b-e98f13170e33","global","2015-09-28T07:59:49","2015","mm","map","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The closest post code data available for Myanmar is offered by the Myanmar Information Management Unit. MiMU is a service to the UN Country Team and Humanitarian Country Team, under the management of the UN Resident and Humanitarian Coordinator. The data can be accessed here :https://www.themimu.info/place-codes. The dataset is in a proprietary format .accdb (Microsoft 2007+). In order to get geospatial dataset, an attribute-based join should be performed, by city name. We could not identify any reference that would show that the Myanmar government is officially recognizing these datasets. ","No evidence showing from the President's Officer website that the data is exist. https://www.myanmarpresidentoffice.info/en/ and the dedicated webpage for the cabinet ministries is empty https://www.myanmarpresidentoffice.info/en/?q=cabinet/ministries so no way to find out who are the responsible minister involve. I have found a 3rd party website https://www.ourweb.info/01/directory/myanmar/005/ that provide a list of ministries official websites but some of these websites are not found.
![enter image description here][1]
[1]: https://s11.postimg.org/nni4jur83/Screen_Shot_2015_09_28_at_3_58_48_PM.png","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"9c246696-811b-4567-90ec-f48193163606","global","2015-10-01T09:50:22","2015","bj","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://www.insae-bj.org/statistiques.html","xls, PDF",,,"Statistiques générales","Institut National de la Statistique et de l’Analyse Economique","Yes","Yes","Data in various formats available, some as recent as 2014.","The National Institute of Statistics and Economic Analysis on their website(1) provides information on national statistics.
Population data listed [here][1].
GDP up to 2014 in XLS [here][2].
Unemployment up to 2011 in PDF [here][3].
[1]: https://www.insae-bj.org/population.html
[2]: https://www.insae-bj.org/produit-interieur.html
[3]: https://www.insae-bj.org/emploi-chomage.html","Yes","No","anonymous","Zach Christensen","60"
"2dbadb29-2122-43a3-8ff8-de1ae77596ed","global","2015-09-17T16:01:57","2015","be","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://stat.nbb.be/Index.aspx?ThemeTreeId=8&lang=en","Excel, CSV, PDF",,,"Composition and identity GDP, Harmonised unemployment rate, Average population ","National Bank of Belgium, Statistics Belgium","Yes","Yes","Data current but do not appear to be openly licensed.","Many separate spreadsheets available, although some data is only available when making a selection using online report builder.
More data is available at https://www.census2011.be/.
Note that all statistics are also published by Eurostat. Where they are available in bulk. See https://ec.europa.eu/CensusHub2/query.do?step=selectHyperCube&qhc=false&countrycode=be
This holds for every European Union Member state.
","Yes","No","Deraesara L","Zach Christensen","70"
"5ab5a90e-1e5c-467b-9b0e-3cc08a61479d","global","2015-09-20T14:30:50","2015","dm","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Unsure","https://www.finance.gov.dm/index.php",,,,"Budget details by Ministry or department; Minister's national budget address; national statistics as of 2011; national development strategies from 2014 - 2018","Ministry of Finance, Government of Dominica","Yes","Yes","I have changed the license to NO. The rest of the data is correct. ","Files are in PDF format downloadable format. However, it is not in any machine readable format.
The terms of use given under the Copyright explanation indicates that users have the right to download the information but use it in its unaltered form. Its free and available for anyone to use.
Reviewer's note - The data only allowed to use for non-commercial use. I have changed the license to no - https://www.finance.gov.dm/index.php/copyright-privacy-notices
The budget is broken into departments.","Yes","No","Veronne Nicholas","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"afb6b003-d568-4a63-aa36-71ea9d2c9a47","global","2015-09-28T03:09:43","2015","bm","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.gov.bm/portal/server.pt?open=512&objID=935&&PageID=233635&activetab=TabCTRL_DropDownTabsGovernment1&mode=2&in_hi_userid=2&cached=true",,,,"Estimates of Revenue and Expenditure for the Year 2014/15","Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","I have checked the data and it is correct. ","Budget data are up to date and available in pdf format. No evidence of an open data license.
For historical records available back 20 years Bermuda.io (non-gov/third party source) has worked to make these available online: https://bermuda.io/dataset/budget-book-estimates-of-revenue-and-expenditure-for-the-year","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Mor Rubinstein","55"
"99aa8a49-f82f-4765-b48c-4839232b7cc8","global","2015-10-02T14:41:19","2015","bb","budget","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Financial Statement & Budgetary Proposal 2015","Barbados PDF News Update","Yes","Yes","I have found the official budget proposal and enter the link. It does not have figures or sub departments budget proposal. Therefore, the budget exist, but not publicly available. ","Data is in pdf format and not machine readable. The data does not explain about sub department budgets.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","5"
"820d3d06-4b0d-406b-a2ab-5d29b1723f95","global","2015-09-10T14:27:04","2015","at","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.statistik.gv.at/web/","PDF, HTML, XLS, CSV, JSON","https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/at/deed.de",,"population, education, research, environment, economy and tourismus statistics","Statistik Austria","Yes","Yes","Recent data available in open format. ","Statistics Austria has launched an open data sub-section of its website, https://data.statistik.gv.at/. However, it only offers about a dozen datasets there under open data standards. The datasets released there include data on the total population of Austria, but not on its GDP.
Numerous datasets are released by Statistik Austria on its main website in PDF and some also in HTML and other formats. Data can also be access through access to a web-based free but captcha protected database, that allows for download of selected data in various formats, including CSV and XLS. Statistik Austria retains a strict copyright on the data (except the few datasets released on its open data sub-website) and charges for many data sets, including municipal budget data. ","Yes","Yes","Martin Kaltenböck","Zach Christensen","100"
"9be8ee3e-d8aa-4b04-8e15-c71cde318c19","global","2015-09-19T19:27:39","2015","aw","budget","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Reports and Documents","Ministry of finance","Yes","Yes","I could not find a current version of the budget. Since the last budget the is published is from 2011, I changed the submission to data exist, but is not publicly available . ","The Ministry of Finance, Communication, Utilities and Energy of Aruba provides yearly insight into the financial affairs of the country by making the actual and budgeted financial statements of each Ministry and department of Government available online for download in PDF format via the Government of Aruba's website.
The latest publication provided was for the year 2011 and is accessible via the following link : [Annual Country Statements Aruba 2011][1]
[1]: https://www.overheid.aw/document.php?m=5&fileid=9985&f=88221c8a745624f4fefbe493b23781f2&attachment=0&c=14297
https://www.overheid.aw/actueel/rapporten-en-documenten_43353/","Yes","No","Kimberly Soares","Mor Rubinstein","5"
"c4ecb694-2a80-49f6-89b6-bf56bd50371c","global","2015-09-28T06:22:54","2015","ua","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://ukrstat.gov.ua/","HTML, PDF, Navidata","https://ukrstat.gov.ua/",,,"State Statistics Service of Ukraine ","Yes","Yes","Some data are open, most are not. ","The website indicates that data have been added apparently in files formatted for navidata but little information was shown about this. See [here][1].
Population figures are available in HTML format.
Unemployment figures are [here][2].
[1]: https://ukrstat.gov.ua/operativ/operativ2015/vvp/kvnr/kvnr_02_15_e.zip
[2]: https://ukrstat.gov.ua/operativ/operativ2013/rp/sz_br/sz_br_e/piprs_2015_e.htm","Yes","No","anonymous","Zach Christensen","75"
"15a0ebec-a4e6-4ef5-9133-ec249438e8b5","global","2015-10-02T15:12:14","2015","gd","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.gov.gd/egov/docs/budget_speech/budget2015.pdf",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I have checked the data and it is correct. Could not find machine readable format. ","Data is in pdf format and not machine readable.","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","55"
"6f6073e5-1a57-4f0a-9090-89adb247f5c2","global","2015-09-01T13:06:52","2015","kr","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.openfiscaldata.go.kr/portal/service/openInfPage.do","XML, JSON, Excel, CSV, Text","https://www.openfiscaldata.go.kr/portal/user/psnCollector.do?code=login",,"Open Fiscal Data - Digital Budget and Accounting System of Korea","Ministry of Strategy and Finance","Yes","Yes","I have reviewed the data and it is accurate. ","The government budget dataset is available on the [Open Fiscal Data][1] site managed by the Ministry of Strategy and Finance of the Republic of Korea. The dataset is available in bulk, in various formats including XML, JSON, Excel, CSV, and Text. The site also provides Web APIs which can be used to harness data programatically on the Web.
Actually, this dataset does not include descriptions regarding the different budget sections, but the budget in the dataset is well divided by government departments, ledgers, accounts, sectors, parts, programs, and sub-programs so general citizens can easily understand where the money goes without explicit descriptions. In this regards, I think the dataset meets the minimum criteria of the dataset definition.
[1]: https://www.openfiscaldata.go.kr/","Yes","Yes","James G. Boram Kim","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"f58aa504-e947-4db2-b4dc-b8c3a4088062","global","2015-09-22T16:08:57","2015","ru","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.feerc.obninsk.org:8080/geoss/rasaqm/index.php","xls",,,"Russian report on pollution emission","Federal Service for Hydrometeorology and Environmental Monitoring (Rosgidromet)","Yes","Yes","checked","Brief Description
We tried to find this data many times but it's not centralized and most likely unavailable as unified dataset. Russian government delegates ecological issues and pollution monitoring to regional level of the executive government branch. But regional government rarely publish pollution monitoring information and pollution sources. I know only a few public data sources available like Mosecomonitoring (Moscow ecological survey). But even whose data source do not publish source of pollutants, they publish only level of pollutants measured by monitoring stations. Even this information rarely available as datasets, most often this is only ""images"" and ""graphics"". So availability of pollutants data for Russian Federation is about 80% - for ""No"", and only about 20% for ""yes"". The only available sources: - https://dynamic.igce.ru/ (not up to date) - pollution monitoring and radiation monitoring (by Rosatom) - https://www.russianatom.ru/ I suggest this dataset for following review.
Overview in PDF (2012): https://www.mnr.gov.ru/upload/iblock/96e/gosdoklad%2020_07_2013.pdf
Overview in PDF (2013): https://www.meteorf.ru/upload/iblock/23f/Obzor_2013_by_Chernogaeva_16072014.pdf
Step by step explanation
1. Does the data exist?
Yes.
2. Is data in digital form?
Yes, data available via website(-s)
3. Publicly available?
Yes, this data is publicly available. We don't need FOI request to get it.
4. Is the data available for free?
Yes, this data is available for free. No payment is required.
5. Is the data available online?
Yes.
6. Is the data machine readable?
No, it's not machine readable. Only PDF file.
7. Available in bulk?
No, data is not in bulk
8. Openly licensed?
No.
9. Is the data provided on a timely and up to date basis?
Yes
Comment: Nothing changed since 2014 year
update by Reviewer 2015
it seem the data is existent from-Research Production Association ""Typhoon""Russian Participation in GEOSS
also form the site of The Regional Environmental Center for Central and Eastern Europe
he Federal Service for Hydrometeorology and Environmental Monitoring in the Russian Federation (Roshydromet) is responsible for the operation and development of the state system of environmental pollution monitoring, and for maintaining the Uniform State Databank on the State of Natural Environment and its Pollution. Roshydromet operates a system for the prompt identification and investigation of dangerous ecotoxicological consequences of emergencies. A system of global baseline environmental monitoring is maintained in Russia, and six integrated monitoring stations are located in biosphere reserves. Air quality monitoring is undertaken by the Institute for Global Climate and Ecology, which prepares the annual Survey of the Pollution of the Natural Environment in the Russian Federation https://www.igce.comcor.ru; and the Russian Aerospace Agency (Rosaviakosmos), which developed a system for environmental monitoring in space https://www/rosaviakosmos.ru. Air pollution monitoring is carried out in more than 350 Russian cities. It covers all major industrial centres and almost all cities with a population of over 100,000. The system includes 1,200 stations for monitoring air pollution in cities and other settlements. Around 4 million samples are analysed annually for more than 20 air pollutants. According to long-term observations, in more than 75 percent of Russian cities maximum concentrations of air pollutants (dust, CO, NO2, ammonia, hydrogen sulphide, phenol) exceed established limits. Thus air quality in most Russian cities does not comply with established sanitary and hygienic norms. - See more at: https://www.greenpackonline.org/english/environmental-components.php?id=01-06-07-04#sthash.2EJ4mckw.dpuf
its seem the google map is not working to see the monitor site
also the city of Moscow have Air Quality monitoring system
https://www.mosecom.ru/air/air-today/","Yes","No","Ivan Begtin","yar michl","70"
"01e2af70-21c5-4a68-86ea-e563a9cbf879","global","2015-09-21T10:34:17","2015","im","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.gov.im/media/219326/isle-of-man-in-numbers-2015-web-version.pdf","PDF","https://www.gov.im/about-this-site/open-government-licence/",,"National Statistics","Treasury Economic Affairs / Isle of Man Government","Yes","Yes","Data in PDFs available up to 2014.","Data up to 2014 posted in PDF [here][1].
More information about national accounts available [here][2].
Census information available [here][3].
[1]: https://www.gov.im/about-the-government/offices/cabinet-office/economic-affairs-division/
[2]: https://www.gov.im/categories/tax-vat-and-your-money/national-income/
[3]: https://www.gov.im/categories/home-and-neighbourhood/census/","Yes","No","anonymous","Zach Christensen","65"
"ab19c590-e327-44b1-961a-c1cb065ebaec","global","2015-09-18T14:14:08","2015","ro","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.mfinante.ro/buget2015.html?pagina=domenii","XML, PDF",,,"National Budget","Minister of Finance","Yes","Yes","I have reviewed the data and it is correct. ","The state budget is published as soon as it is approved by the Parliament on a special page maintained by the Ministry of Public Finance. The budget is presented as a set of PDF documents, and, starting with 2014, also in XML format (scroll down to the bottom of the budget page for the link).
However, the XML format does not include the budget rectifications, which are only available in separate PDF files. Also, there is no updated version of the budget after rectifications, which means that one should take the provisions from the rectification bills and apply them to the original budget.
The data are under the Copyright of the Ministerul Finantelor Publice -DGTI but there is no reference to a licence nor terms of use.","Yes","No","Ovidiu Voicu","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"ea8f22a0-fdf6-4259-b3ee-b8c2fe3c9fe8","global","2015-09-15T12:49:28","2015","ko","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"No","https://askdata.rks-gov.net/PXWeb/pxweb/en/askdata/?rxid=0b4e087e-8b00-47ba-b7cf-1ea158040712/","Excel, CSV, PC-Axis","https://www.kuvendikosoves.org/common/docs/ligjet/Law%20on%20copyright%20and%20related%20rights.pdf",,,"Kosovo Agency of Statistics","Yes","Yes","Data available in open formats but only until 2014.","No data available after 2014.
Article 12 of Law No. 04/L-065 on copyright and related rights places public documents in the public domain.","Yes","Yes","Arianit Dobroshi","Zach Christensen","80"
"70bcdeeb-b7b4-4c00-9b79-9072445ca558","global","2015-09-30T22:06:42","2015","gb","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.ons.gov.uk/ons/datasets-and-tables/index.html","CSV, Excel, XML","https://www.ons.gov.uk/ons/site-information/information/terms-and-conditions/index.html",,,"Office for National Statistics ","Yes","Yes","Data available in multiple formats in open format.","The UK's Office for National Statistics has primary responsibility for maintaining and publishing national economic and demographic information (including the Census). ONS material is re-usable under the terms of the Open Government Licence and UK Government Licensing Framework. Each of the datasets is downloadable in full, machine-readable formats (mainly Excel, but some also available in CSV and XML).
","Yes","Yes","Mor Rubinstein","Zach Christensen","100"
"12046db7-1450-46e7-801a-0a03ac0b612d","global","2015-09-25T07:46:11","2015","dk","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.statistikbanken.dk/statbank5a/default.asp?w=1680","PC-AXIS (*.px), Excel (*.xlsx), Excel (*.xls), DBase (*.dbf), DBase in rows (*.dbf), SAS program (*.sas), Semicolon sep. (*.csv), Tab. sep. (*.csv), Comma sep. (*.csv), Matrix (*.csv), Text with layout (*.txt), Text matrix (*.txt), Time series (*.tsd), Time series batch (*.asb)","https://www.dst.dk/da/omds/omweb.aspx",,,"Statistics Denmark","Yes","Yes","Current data available in many formats, open formatting.","Each dataset (eg. population, GDP, detailed employment and unemployment etc.) can be downloaded in bulk using the interactive interface (just select all options in the dropdown).","Yes","Yes","Niels Erik Kaaber Rasmussen","Zach Christensen","100"
"c0426f85-1d6f-4670-8c08-5ab61a80942d","global","2015-09-17T09:26:17","2015","cz","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://vdb2.czso.cz/vdbvo2/faces/en/index.jsf","xls, xml, csv, dbf, pdf, docx","https://www.czso.cz/csu/czso/conditions_for_use_and_further_dissemination",,,"Czech Statistical Office","Yes","Yes","Current data available in open format. ","New feature was introduced - a search interface that shows simple grahps and allows to export selected data (XLS, XML, PDF).
GDP - updated quaterly https://www.czso.cz/csu/czso/hdp_cr
Population - updated monthly https://www.czso.cz/csu/czso/oby_ts
Unemployment - updated monthly https://www.czso.cz/csu/czso/ari/rates-of-employment-unemployment-and-economic-activity-july-2015","Yes","Yes","Michaela Rybičková","Zach Christensen","100"
"fa8e9dfd-459d-43af-b4a1-29bacb056b19","global","2015-09-28T07:05:41","2015","id","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Pos Indonesia offers access to an online form to search post codes, without lat-long info, without any possibility of download. ","No change from 2013
The data is available via search form, but no corresponding geolocations (which must be manually referenced to another separate subdistrict geolocation databases which are non-free)
Data did not change until 2015","Yes","No","anonymous","Codrina Maria Ilie","0"
"bfb2f51d-f5f4-477b-91ad-814767305201","global","2015-09-17T19:08:24","2015","us","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.census.gov/","XLS, CSV, PDF, HTML, RTF","https://ask.census.gov/faq.php?id=5000&faqId=537",,,"US Census Bureau","Yes","Yes","Data are current and open. ","Census.gov has data on a wide variety of national statistics including all major demographic and economic indicators (population, GDP etc etc). Tabular data is generally provided in machine-readable formats such as Excel (an open format such as CSV would be preferable but we still consider this acceptable). The data is also available ""in bulk"" in the sense that ther e are complete files plus data is available via automated access on an FTP site at https://www2.census.gov/ (where CSV files are often available). One point to note is that there are other sources of such data within the US government including the Bureau of Economic Analysis (https://bea.gov), the Bureau of Labor Statistics (https://bls.gov/) etc.
The data are openly licensed.","Yes","Yes","anonymous","Zach Christensen","100"
"5fa93361-9339-4519-96ac-2f5b4064d69c","global","2015-09-10T12:03:02","2015","cz","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://monitor.statnipokladna.cz/analyza","CSV","https://monitor.statnipokladna.cz/en/2015/zdrojova-data/",,,"Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","The 2015 was not in the sources link. I have changed the link to the application link. The application does allow to download all of the data in a CSV format. ","Budgets for years 2010 - 2015 are available. The current budget is published in 3 phases (estimates, changes, actual expenditure) and updated quaterly.
Czech national budget for 2016 has not been approved by the parliament and therefore not published (not even a framework).
The license says, that data can be shared freely and integrated into computer programs or databases and other works. However, it also mentions, that the data can't be edited - I think this is just unfortunate definition, that means that the cannot be used in a misleading way, but I'm not 100% sure about it.
The terms of use: https://monitor.statnipokladna.cz/en/2014/data/
","Yes","Yes","Jiří Táborský","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"a0da3bb1-dabe-4dc5-bd62-e79c2e3ba0bb","global","2015-09-18T10:32:44","2015","kh","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://db.ncdd.gov.kh/gazetteer/view/index.castle",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The Cambodian gazetteer offers access to postal codes in tabular format, without any lat-long info. The map available in the gazetteer is a non-georeferenced image in JPG format.","The data is updated and reflected on the latest changes of administrative boundary changes including Phnom Penh, Kandal, Kampong Cham.
","Yes","No","Vantharith Oum","Codrina Maria Ilie","35"
"41fbbb51-c8ab-4ce4-8382-c50de2b25a1a","global","2015-10-01T21:35:33","2015","it","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.rgs.mef.gov.it/VERSIONE-I/Dati/OPENDATA/SpeseBS/","CSV, Excel ","https://www.dati.gov.it/iodl/2.0/",,,"Ragioneria Generale dello Stato","Yes","Yes","Since it state open data in the site, it can be linked to the dati site license. However, the whole website was protected by copyright - https://www.rgs.mef.gov.it/VERSIONE-I/Note-Legal/Copyright/index.html
The better possibility would be to fix the copyright of the whole site. I did left the submission as is and marked License as open. ","The General Accounting Office publishes data on central government spending of the state in time series from 2007 and processable format. The data allow to follow the evolution of resources allocated, committed and paid from the state budget, broken down into the public policy goals (missions and programs), the economic nature of the expenditure (by title and economic category), the nature of 'legislative authorization (by type of authorization) and the administration responsible for the implementation and management (accounting). [amended: it is possible to download state 2013 budget as xls from https://www.rgs.mef.gov.it/_Documenti/VERSIONE-I/Servizio-s/Studi-e-do/La-spesa-d/Tavole/1-BP-2013.xls under IODL2 as well as other documents mentioned above] ","Yes","Yes","Francesca De Chiara","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"5735e1da-97ec-478b-8518-de3d832fef29","global","2015-10-02T00:21:34","2015","se","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.scb.se/api/","JSON, XLS, CSV, SCB, PC-Axis","https://www.scb.se/sv_/Om-SCB/Oppna-data-API/Vanliga-fragor/, https://www.scb.se/en_/Topmeny/About-the-website/Terms-of-use/",,,"Statistics Sweden (Statistiska Centralbyrån)","Yes","Yes","Current data available in a range of formats with open license.","JSON API for large amounts of statistical data. The API is rate limited but possible to use to retrieve large amounts of data. License terms comparable to CC-BY (but CC-BY not explicitly stated).
GDP also available [here][1].
Population available [here][2].
Unemployment available [here.][3]
[1]: https://www.scb.se/en_/Finding-statistics/Statistics-by-subject-area/National-Accounts/National-Accounts/National-Accounts-quarterly-and-annual-estimates/
[2]: https://www.scb.se/en_/Finding-statistics/Statistics-by-subject-area/Population/
[3]: https://www.scb.se/en_/Finding-statistics/Statistics-by-subject-area/Labour-market/Labour-force-surveys/Labour-Force-Survey-LFS/","Yes","Yes","Asmen Gül","Zach Christensen","100"
"b8805db3-31be-48ff-b5da-8abc86ef89fd","global","2015-09-20T09:17:47","2015","no","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.ssb.no/","json-stat, csv, tsb, xml, pc-axis, excel","https://www.ssb.no/en/omssb/tjenester-og-verktoy/api",,"Open data API from Statistics Norway","Statistics Norway","Yes","Yes","Current, openly licensed data are available.","License/terms for other data from ssb, not in data.ssb.no:
Data is freely available as long as the source is referenced. See https://ssb.no/en/informasjon/copyright
For example data from the statistics bank, where you can create your own tables:
https://statbank.ssb.no/statistikkbanken/?PLanguage=1
Previous editor's note: But I've been corresponding with Statistics Norway ( the home of the statistics ) and they've said the same. Their license is essentially the same as the Norwegian License for Open Government Data ( NLOD - https://data.norge.no/nlod/en/1.0 ), but they can't yet write this, though they're working on it. That is, their license is CC BA compatible.","Yes","Yes","Bergheimivar L","Zach Christensen","100"
"9c55122f-6e60-45f7-a99d-e47d76d68234","global","2015-09-21T10:31:45","2015","im","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.gov.im/media/1346060/pink_book_2014-15-xls-.xlsx","Excel","https://www.gov.im/about-this-site/open-government-licence/",,"National Budget 2014-15 (Pink Book)","Treasury / Isle of Man Government","Yes","Yes","I have checked this submission and it is correct. ","PDF:
https://www.gov.im/media/1031671/pink_book_2014-15.pdf
XLSX:
https://www.gov.im/media/1346060/pink_book_2014-15-xls-.xlsx
Other national statistics are available from the Treasury Economic Affairs Division (generally equivalent to Office of National Statistics):
https://www.gov.im/about-the-government/departments/treasury/economic-affairs-division/
There is also a well organised independent apolitical CSO/PMO Positive Action Group with topical analysis:
https://positiveactiongroup.org/index.php?option=com_attachments&task=download&id=74
","Yes","Yes","Graeme Jones","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"8bea1300-6484-4b63-9211-9f2e5185b99d","global","2015-10-07T15:42:54","2015","ie","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.cso.ie/en/databases/","CSV, TSV, px, txt, xls, html, Beyond 20/20, ","https://cso.ie/en/aboutus/copyrightpolicy/",,,"Central Statistics Office (CSO)","Yes","Yes","Many formats available for data that are current and open.","There are multiple databases provided. Multiple data variables are selected from drop down menus and are then downloadable in mulitple formats.
Data pivot tables are also available in beyond 20/20 which is a norm for data users in this domain.
Data are also available as **linked data** https://data.cso.ie/
The data are available under two IP regimes and an access policy,
- ""Statistics disseminated on this site are **copyright of The Government of Ireland**"" https://www.cso.ie/en/aboutus/copyrightpolicy/ and ""
- **The statistics and other information provided on this site are accessible free of charge and licensed under Creative Commons Attribution (version 4.0 cc-by)**"" https://cso.ie/en/aboutus/copyrightpolicy/
- **Publication on the Web Policy** https://www.cso.ie/en/aboutus/dissemination/publicationpolicyontheweb/","Yes","Yes","anonymous","Zach Christensen","100"
"6c5e19dc-a7af-4c5e-8230-9a46a882c490","global","2015-09-08T09:12:47","2015","nl","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://opendata.rijksbegroting.nl/begrotingsstaten.csv","csv","https://opendefinition.org/licenses/cc-zero/",,"Opendata sets","Rijksbegroting","Yes","Yes","I have checked this data and it is correct. ","No changes from last year. Data is published here (https://opendata.rijksbegroting.nl/), and is available as CSV, under Creative Commons CC Zero license. It has an overview of expenses, liabilities by departmental budgets.
See last year's comment below:
De begrotingsstaten van het Rijk worden op of rond prinsjesdag als open data ontsloten. Deze staten bevatten een artikelsgewijsuitsplitsing van de geraamde verplichtingen,uitgaven en ontvangsten van een begroting. Deze staten worden geregeld bijgewerkt.
[No changes from 2013]","Yes","Yes","Tarek Amr","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"e07635b7-a4da-4a5f-9230-1fd4f86c5013","global","2015-09-17T17:57:12","2015","us","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/budget/","XLS, CSV, PDF","https://www.whitehouse.gov/copyright",,"Budget of the United States Government, Fiscal Year 2016","White House Office of Management and Budget","Yes","Yes","I have checked this submission and it is correct. ","Current budget is available at https://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/budget/. Formal budget documents are in PDF format and are on https://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/budget/Overview. Machine-readable data in Excel and CSV files can be found in the supplemental material at https://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/budget/Supplemental.
Furthermore, the Whitehouse.gov copyright notice states all material is **CC-By** (see https://www.whitehouse.gov/copyright).
Bulk: Whilst the data is split across multiple files there is a good core set of data in the ""Public Budget Database"" which consists of only 3 substantial CSV files. As such, have marked Bulk as ""Yes""
- Machine-readable: whilst formal budget is PDF we believe that all relevant data is contained in the Excel and CSV files so Machine-readable is ""Yes"" (note also that the CSV files are well formatted)
- Older budgets: the OMB budget site only contains data for the latest budget with past budgets available on the GPO website at: https://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/browse/collectionGPO.action?collectionCode=BUDGET. The GPO site only provides PDFs. However, the OMB site does contain a historical tables section at https://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/budget/Historicals and the Public Budget Database contains data back to 1962. ","Yes","Yes","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"3aa4a49f-0070-4877-a44c-3b1f72ee41ae","global","2015-10-12T17:18:44","2015","tj","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://stat.tj/; https://www.tojikinfo.tj/libraries/aspx/Home.aspx","Excel",,,"Database","TajStat, Statistics Agency under the President of Tajikistan","Yes","Yes","Data could be more current and needs to be licensed open.","QA review - the Laws of statistics does not mentioned use by other parties. https://stat.tj/en/agency/regulations/ therefore, I marked license as ""unsure""
GDP, Unemployment, or Population figures only up to 2014.
Tables found [here][1].
Tojikinfo has more data [here][2] but the platform has some problems.
[1]: https://www.stat.tj/en/macroeconomic-indicators/
[2]: https://www.tojikinfo.tj/libraries/aspx/Home.aspx","Yes","No","anonymous","Zach Christensen","60"
"ae45ddbd-96f7-451a-9413-82c79eed464d","global","2015-10-05T09:54:13","2015","is","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.ust.is/einstaklingar/loftgaedi/maelingar",,,,"Air Quality Measurements in Iceland","Hagstofa Íslands (Statistics Iceland)","Yes","Yes","checked","English descriptions: https://www.ust.is/the-environment-agency-of-iceland/
Additionally national data available is for years 1990-2012, last updated in 2015:
https://hagstofan.is/Hagtolur/Land-og-umhverfi/Losun-lofttegunda
dont seem to be co and VOCs measurement","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","yar michl","45"
"922415ae-7783-43ea-b0f0-ec8818e8bd96","global","2015-09-01T07:36:57","2015","au","postcodes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Yes","No",,"Yes",,"CSV, PDF",,,,"Australian Post","Yes","Yes","The Australian Post free non-commercial use PDF does not provide any lat-long info.
On the Australian Bureau of Statistics at the Postal Codes page it is stated:""Allocations have been determined using the best available information on postcode boundaries. Unfortunately, official postcode boundaries have not been updated since the early 1990s and none of the more recent interpretations have been endorsed by Australia Post."" ","Australian Post provides postcode data as a [free PDF][1] that enables you to look up postcodes for non-commercial use only.
You need a license to use the Australian postcode data for commercial or business purposes. Standard and complementary CSV data files can be purchased at https://auspost.com.au/business-solutions/postcode-data.html
Data is updated monthly.
[Postal Areas](https://www.abs.gov.au/websitedbs/censushome.nsf/home/factsheetspoa?opendocument&navpos=450), the Australian Bureau of Statistics approximation of Australia Post postcodes, are described [here](https://www.abs.gov.au/AUSSTATS/abs@.nsf/DetailsPage/1270.0.55.003July%202011?OpenDocument) and the data is available in a [zip file](https://www.abs.gov.au/AUSSTATS/subscriber.nsf/log?openagent&1270055003_poa_2011_aust_shape.zip&1270.0.55.003&Data%20Cubes&71B4572D909B934ECA2578D40012FE0D&0&July%202011&22.07.2011&Previous).
This has the *areas* of postal areas (and shapefiles for their boundaries). This data is machine-readable, available in bulk, [openly licensed with Creative Commons Attribution 2.5 Australia licence](https://www.abs.gov.au/websitedbs/D3310114.nsf/Home/%A9+Copyright?opendocument#from-banner=GB).
[1]:https://postcode.auspost.com.au/free_display.html?id=1
The Australian Bureau of Statistics data is only updated every 5 years.","Yes","No","Stephen Gates","Codrina Maria Ilie","35"
"16a763a0-f041-463e-b169-f416cb0e26a6","global","2015-10-09T15:09:49","2015","nl","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://opendata.cbs.nl/dataportaal/portal.html#_la=nl","CSV, Excel, SPSS","https://data.overheid.nl/data/dataset/datasets-van-het-centraal-bureau-voor-de-statistiek",,,"Centraal Bureau voor Statistiek (CBS)","Yes","Yes","Data regularly updated, downloadable in many formats, and openly licensed.","CBS Portal has online search and display of data with download options.
Regarding the specific datasets requested:
GDP is updated quarterly:
https://statline.cbs.nl/Statweb/publication/?DM=SLNL&PA=82602ned&D1=0-17&D2=0-1&D3=96-101&HDR=G1%2cG2&STB=T&VW=D
Unemployment updated monthly:
https://statline.cbs.nl/Statweb/publication/?DM=SLNL&PA=37789ksz&D1=7-8&D2=(l-16)-l&VW=T
Population count updated monthly:
https://statline.cbs.nl/Statweb/publication/?DM=SLNL&PA=37943ned&D1=7&D2=295,297-298,312,314-315,329,331-332,346,348-349&VW=T
","Yes","Yes","Sander van der Waal","Zach Christensen","100"
"a6fd5910-e5c3-440e-82b8-335c53074418","global","2015-10-01T21:59:09","2015","it","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://dati.istat.it/","XLS, RDF, CSV, SDMX","https://www.istat.it/en/legal-notice",,,"Istituto Nazionale di Statistica (ISTAT)","Yes","Yes","Data available in open licensed format.","Data most easily found at dashboard [here][1].
[1]: https://dati.istat.it/","Yes","Yes","Francesca De Chiara","Zach Christensen","100"
"83f40dd8-c02b-408a-ae7b-fd0e0cb38dff","global","2015-09-29T11:00:42","2015","gb","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/public-expenditure-statistical-analyses-2015","xls","https://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open-government-licence/version/3/",,"Public Expenditure Statistical Analyses 2015","HM Treasury","Yes","Yes","Data is in bulk, but it would be better if it would been on one spreadsheet. ","2015 - The budget breakdown can be found under PESA- Public Expenditure Statistical Analyses . However, it is not clear if one can see budget breakdown for sub-departments. Moreover, it was hard to find the dataset, and it was not available on data.gov.uk, but on the gov.uk website. In addition, there was no link from the treasury webpage to this dataset.
All the data is one place, but it would be better if it was in one spreadsheet.
The budget book can be find under the name [Main Supply Estimates 2015 to 2016][1], and it is not publish in a Machine readable format, nor it does not linked from the treasury website.
[1]: https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/441360/PU_1815_Main_Estimates_book_WEB.pdf","Yes","Yes","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"7961704f-a03e-40d4-9ce6-1a974f799943","global","2015-10-08T09:36:44","2015","no","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.norge.no/data/finansdepartementet/revidert-statsbudsjett-2015-kapittel-2-de-%C3%B8konomiske-utsiktene ","Excel, HTML","https://data.norge.no/nlod/no",,,"Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","Added the relevant link. Submission is correct. ","Entry in national open data portal (data.norge.no) states license as NLDO (https://data.norge.no/nlod/en/1.0).
Ministry webpage - https://www.statsbudsjettet.no/
","Yes","Yes","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"6b78f9da-d8b3-4125-8587-af6100cbb296","global","2015-09-20T02:14:33","2015","uy","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://catalogodatos.gub.uy/dataset/credito-presupuestal-asignado-y-ejecutado","CSV, TXT, XLS","https://datos.gub.uy/wps/wcm/connect/856cc1804db0463baa8bea01b72d8394/terminos-catalogodatos.pdf?MOD=AJPERES&ContentCache=NONE&CACHEID=856cc1804db0463baa8bea01b72d8394",,"Assigned and executed budget","AGEV - OPP","Yes","Yes","Data is correct. ","Metadata on the contents is provided, as a TXT file that describes each of the fields in the CSV files (description in Spanish)","Yes","Yes","Daniel Carranza","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"7b18206a-2d3c-402a-840c-272ed669a559","global","2015-09-28T16:48:55","2015","fr","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.data.gouv.fr/fr/datasets/?sort=-created&organization=534fff81a3a7292c64a77e5c","CSV, XLS","https://wiki.data.gouv.fr/wiki/Licence_Ouverte_/_Open_Licence",,"Population, Employment, GDP","Institut National de la Statistique et des Etudes Economic (INSEE)","Yes","Yes","All three datasets are available on INSEE website. No bulk downloads found.","INSEE (national statistics institute) is quite a complex website that is somewhat difficult to navigate
- annual [population][1]
- quarterly [GDP][2]
- monthly [unemployment][3]
[1]: https://:%20https://www.bdm.insee.fr/bdm2/affichageSeries?idbank=000067670&page=export&codeGroupe=62&recherche=criteres
[2]: https://www.bdm.insee.fr/bdm2/affichageSeries?idbank=001690223&page=export&codeGroupe=1541&recherche=criteres
[3]: https://www.bdm.insee.fr/bdm2/affichageSeries?idbank=001688527&idbank=001688529&idbank=001688531&idbank=001688537&page=export&codeGroupe=1533&recherche=criteres","Yes","Yes","Regards Citoyens","Zach Christensen","90"
"79e69cd5-ea20-4b60-bda1-0afb56d3a7ff","global","2015-09-16T13:10:44","2015","cl","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://datos.gob.cl/datasets/ver/31132","CSV, XML","https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/cl/",,"(as 2014 Public Sector Budget: Law Nº 20.713 approved by the National Congress, and taken-over by the General Comptroller Office Republic of Chile. published by Undersecretary of Treasury, Department of Budget and Management.",,"Yes","Yes","Updated the dataset for 2015. Submission approved. ",,"Yes","Yes","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"aec3836f-f44f-49d4-b679-2b1c805e0017","global","2015-10-05T18:30:53","2015","fi","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.ilmanlaatu.fi/index.php",,"https://github.com/mikkohei13/airquality-finland",,"Air quality in Finland","Ministry of the Environment's","Yes","Yes","checked","update for air Pollutant in 2015
no donwload of data is Available or donwload data in bulk
also it seem in that in github a code for- API that scrapes air quality data from https://www.ilmanlaatuportaali.fi -portal, and presents it as a RESTful JSON API.
https://github.com/mikkohei13/airquality-finland
Data terms of use
According to the portal, you are free to
Use the data for non-commercial purposes, research and teaching
Publish the data for public communication
...provided you credit the https://www.ilmanlaatuportaali.fi as the source.","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","yar michl","75"
"fe20d99f-fbf3-40f2-8f54-011948a8fa03","global","2015-09-19T11:30:21","2015","ch","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://opendata.admin.ch/en/dataset/ch-swisstopo-vd-ortschaftenverzeichnis-plz","PDF,XML,SHP,CSV",,,"ZIP and locations, postal codes and localities of the official Cadastral Survey","Federal Office of Topography swisstopo","Yes","Yes","ok","SwissTopo offers various geodata information on the territory through [web mapping services][2], including the postal codes (layer name PLZ und Ortschaften).
[Licence for free geodata][1] applies.
[1]: https://www.toposhop.admin.ch/en/shop/terms/use/finished_products
[2]: https://wms.geo.admin.ch/","Yes","No","Oleg Lavrovsky","Codrina Maria Ilie","70"
"74ca316b-faa7-404d-bef7-c3bfafdb99d3","global","2015-10-02T10:36:35","2015","fi","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://tilastokeskus.fi/org/lainsaadanto/avoin_data_en.html","CSV, JSON, XLS (non-binary)","https://www.stat.fi/org/lainsaadanto/copyright_en.html",,,"Statistics Finland (e-mail info@statistics.fi, contact person Heli Mikkelä)","Yes","Yes","Data are available, current, and open.","All the data produced by Statistics Finland as official national and regional statistics is available free of charge and by open data principles in the StatFin database.
In addition, Statistics Finland hosts some charged information services tailored for user-specific or other special needs. The charge is based on the amount of work needed for building the service and checking for quality matters such as data protection issues.
No changes from 2014 ","Yes","Yes","Mor Rubinstein","Zach Christensen","100"
"3d903bae-9ae0-498e-8710-6dbb12360667","global","2015-09-24T17:38:11","2015","dk","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://statistikbanken.dk/statbank5a/SelectVarVal/Define.asp?MainTable=OFF3B&PLanguage=1&PXSId=0&wsid=cftree","PC-AXIS (*.px), Excel (*.xlsx), Excel (*.xls), DBase (*.dbf), DBase in rows (*.dbf), SAS program (*.sas), Semicolon sep. (*.csv), Tab. sep. (*.csv), Comma sep. (*.csv), Matrix (*.csv), Text with layout (*.txt), Text matrix (*.txt), Time series (*.tsd), Time series batch (*.asb)","https://www.dst.dk/en/OmDS/omweb.aspx",,"Classification of functions of government by function (budget)","Danmarks statistik (Statistics Denmark-Authority)","Yes","Yes","Data is correct. Submission was approved. ","StatBank Denmark contains detailed statistical information on the Danish society.
The database is free of charge and data can be exported in several file formats and presented as diagrams or maps. The website offers a data selector where users can configure specific indicators and export the result in different machine-readable formats. All the items and years can be selected in the selector and then data can be downloaded in bulk.
https://www.dst.dk/en/OmDS/omweb.aspx (English version, instead of Danish)
Responsible for the page "" https://www.dst.dk/en/OmDS/omweb.aspx ""
under ""URL to license or terms of use"" is databanker@dst.dk
","Yes","Yes","Niels Erik Kaaber Rasmussen","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"21dd520b-e4b1-4e22-81b3-a62e027a72c0","global","2015-09-15T12:10:41","2015","ko","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://mf.rks-gov.net/en-us/Budget/Budget-of-Republic-of-Kosovo/Central-Budget",,,,"TABLES OF BUDGET OF KOSOVA FOR YEAR 2015","Republic of Kosovo Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","License is not clearly marked. Changed it to Unsure. ","Article 12 of Law No. 04/L-065 on copyright and related rights places public documents including laws such as the Law on Budget in the public domain.
Reviewer's note: By law, all government data does not have any copyrights (https://gzk.rks-gov.net/ActDetail.aspx?ActID=2787). However, the ministry of Kosovo has the following footnote at it site - Copyright (c) 2014 Ministry of Finance
I have changed the License to unsure. ","Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Mor Rubinstein","55"
"9ad2d20c-c47b-4f2c-b17a-2253eaf369fa","global","2015-09-28T14:29:47","2015","py","emissions","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,"Secretaría del Ambiente","Yes","Yes","checked","There is no official information about availability, howerver, the ""Secretaría del Ambiente"" is, by Law 5211 [1] responsible for monitoring and protect the quality of the air in Paraguay.
The are other unofficial sites that publish reports on air quality for Paraguay, for example [2], [3]
References:
[1] https://digesto.senado.gov.py/ups/leyes/8573%20.pdf
[2] https://www.mercosurambiental.net/MD_upload/Archivos/7/File/biblioteca/agua/PY_informe_final_%20sobre_%20el_rio_paraguay_y_lago_ypacarai.pdf
[3] https://www.paho.org/par/index2.php?option=com_docman&task=doc_view&gid=268&Itemid=253","Yes","No","Juan Pane","yar michl","5"
"3a7f163e-b955-4fd6-a680-46f3715400e7","global","2015-10-12T16:27:32","2015","az","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.maliyye.gov.az/sites/default/files/Budget_law_2015.pdf",,,,," The Ministry of Finance of the Republic of Azerbaijan","Yes","Yes","The reviewer found this notice in the finance ministry website -All rights reserved © 2011 Therefore, left the submitter original comment about the license and left it as not open. Submission was approved. ","Sometimes the changes happens in the budget in the middle of the year and budget information of next year published in the end of past year. The data seems to be openly licensed but I can't find a link to the license.
","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","55"
"fc94f1ec-3be0-4ade-bd7c-bbce82c38a33","global","2015-10-12T17:01:15","2015","tj","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://minfin.tj/index.php?do=static&page=norm#zakrt",,,,"Law on State budget of the Republic of Tajikistan approved annually. It identifies general income, sources of income, expenditures, deficit, and other details of the state budget.","Ministry of Finance of Tajikistan, www.minfin.tj","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct. ","Tajikistan is member to Open Budget Initiative. The first and last assessment was conducted in 2012, which found OBI as 17%. Though it is low in rank, it is encouraging that OBI-oriented actions have been taken in the level of the Ministry.
As ODRA interviewees believe the published information public data or information. However, there is no clear statement about intellectual property rights attached to the government information. There is also no clear statement for the terms and conditions of reuse, e.g. license.","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"c6ede2ed-c922-42fb-92da-454e81d92f11","global","2015-09-15T05:49:08","2015","kg","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://minfin.kg/","Excel",,,"Provides information on budget, internal and external loans, budget implementation, plans and expenses across governmental bodies ","Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","I have accepted the original submission. The website does not have a license or terms and conditions, therefore I left license status as unsure. ","The web site of Ministry Of Finance https://minfin.kg/ provides Provides information on budget, internal and external loans, budget implementation, plans and expenses across governmental bodies.
The data is divided into categories. The data is available in following formats xls, doc, pdf","Yes","No","Azamat Tokhtaev","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"6167809f-8d61-4034-a68d-a9429d7b962f","global","2015-08-30T17:24:22","2015","om","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","The body responsible for environmental issues in Oman is the Ministry of Environment and Climatic Affairs. The Ministry of required by law to regulate a variety of activities relating to pollution (e.g. Ministerial Decision 107 / 2013 requires keeping records of private sector equipment and activities that could deplete ozone - link https://www.mola.gov.om/Download.aspx?Path=decision/107-2013.pdf ) However, it does not appear that the Ministry makes any of the information it collects available to the public.
data is only measured for 1 city -Sohar
so its not sufficient to be exist data
from-https://aqicn.org/sources/(look for Oman)
","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","yar michl","0"
"f4cbbbd7-3926-47d3-ae30-7d35aed2652a","global","2015-09-12T20:14:26","2015","gd","spending","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.
The submission mentioned UNESCO which is only educational spending. The submission also mentioned property taxes news article which is only a small section of revenues. The data seems to exists because of annual audit reports, it may not be digital though since it takes about a year to do the audit.","The audit reports published by the ministry of finance indicate that the data exists but given that the audit reports published in 2015 cover the financial year 2013 there is no clear indication that the data is digital.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","5"
"f2655f1e-d712-40e9-b1e3-f70139feb280","global","2015-09-28T03:24:59","2015","bm","companies","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.roc.gov.bm/roc/rocweb.nsf/ReviewPublicRegA-Z?OpenForm",,,,"Companies Register A-Z","Bermuda Registrar of Companies","Yes","Yes","Changed ""publicly available?"" from Yes to No because login is required to view details. All other fields are fine!","Only change since 2013 entry is 'updated in a timely manner' being changed from 'Yes' to 'Unsure' because there are no indications of the frequency of updates.
The register is free to browse but viewing company details requires a login, which must be applied for. Therefore the only details that can be viewed without an account are name, incorporation date and registration number.
Another version of the public register may be found at Open Corporates (non-gov/third party source) and is downloadable as open data via API. https://assets.opencorporates.com/companies/bm
They presumably obtained this dataset from scraping the registry.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Rebecca Sentance","30"
"0a37bb2e-6643-4077-a223-bbccb7fd3e3b","global","2015-10-05T09:42:55","2015","is","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://hamar.stjr.is/","Excel",,,,"Fjármála- og efnahgasráðuneytið / Ministry of finance and economic affairs","Yes","Yes","I have checked the submission and it is correct.","The government budget is made available via an interactive website (and also as a printed version). A downloadable Excel file is available at:
https://hamar.stjr.is/Fjarlagavefur-Hluti-II/Fjarreiduyfirlit/Tofluyfirlit/2016/efni.htm
The budget can be regarded as laws and should therefore be exempt from copyright but as there is no explicit statement on copyright exemption the budget cannot be regarded as openly licensed.","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"530f0970-3d3c-481e-aa0d-552eb55c9929","global","2015-09-25T14:19:29","2015","de","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.destatis.de/DE/Publikationen/Thematisch/ThematischeVeroeffentlichungen.html","XLS, CSV, HTML, PDF","https://www.govdata.de/dl-de/by-1-0",,"GDP, Unemployment, Population. ","Statistisches Bundesamt","Yes","Yes","Data are available, regular, and open. ","The national statistics office publishes statistics at https://www.destatis.de/DE/Publikationen/Publikationen.html and statistical data at https://www-genesis.destatis.de/genesis/online/data is available in XLS and other formats, however the quality of the machine readable data is abysmal.
The general Copyright statement is essentially saying that you can reuse the data provided attribution is given, but you are not allowed to change or manipulate the information: ""© Statistisches Bundesamt, Wiesbaden 2013. Sie können Informationen speichern, (auch auszugsweise) mit Quellenangabe weitergeben, vervielfältigen und verbreiten sowie Links zur Homepage des Statistischen Bundesamtes legen. Die Informationen dürfen im Übrigen nicht verändert oder verfälscht werden."" which would make it not openly licensed. At https://www.govdata.de the same data is available under the German ""Datenlizenz Deutschland"" which has been reviewed and considered not compliant with the Open Definition in Version 1.0. However, this non-compliance was due to the fact that there is the option to apply the Datenlizenz Deutschland with an NC component. However, non of the data sets on govdata.de published by the National Statistics Agency carry the NC component. Thereby the data is openly licensed. Furthermore the Datenlizenz 2.0 has been approved by the Open Definition Advisory Council recently and it can be assumed that it will replace the 1,0 version shortly to erase and ambiguities about openness.","Yes","Yes","walter palmetshofer","Zach Christensen","100"
"903b9943-3592-4422-96e9-9deabf660a7a","global","2015-09-21T10:33:01","2015","im","companies","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","No","Unsure","No",,"Yes","https://services.gov.im/companies-registry/",,,,"Companies Registry","Department of Economic Development","Yes","Yes","Old URL seems to be defunct, so I added the new one and updated fields based on the new information.","The Isle of Man Companies Registry can be searched online for free, but any other data requires payment to obtain and is not made available in bulk. An account is also required to view company documents and purchase them. The registry appears to be updated monthly.
The website content is available under an Open Government License (https://www.gov.im/about-this-site/open-government-licence/) except where otherwise stated, but it is not clear whether this applies to any purchased documents, or what form those might be in (machine readable or not, digital or not).","Yes","No","anonymous","Rebecca Sentance","25"
"9097d4e2-d542-4bd5-9c8e-a9ddef7d8117","global","2015-09-26T23:53:25","2015","cr","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://datos.inec.go.cr","CSV, Excel",,,"Population, employment, and economic statistics. They also have some national surveys available and other indicators. ","Instituto Nacional de Estadística y Censos","Yes","Yes","Data are available in regular, mostly open formats. ","Data is available and downloadable in tabular data format. They have a copyright notice. Besides the ""open data portal"", INEC has another data tabulated in different parts of the site available for download in Excel format (https://www.inec.go.cr/Web/Home/pagPrincipal.aspx). And they have a system to tabulate your own data from surveys https://www.inec.go.cr/Web/Home/GeneradorPagina.aspx.
They also have a microdata site when the databases of some of the surveys they make are available for download https://www.inec.go.cr/anda4/index.php/catalog. Nevertheless, the surveys are in .sav format (SPSS format). ","Yes","No","camila salazar","Zach Christensen","60"
"b6381fbe-dfd0-4fa3-b43b-b126671888ed","global","2015-10-01T22:35:09","2015","ci","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"No","https://www.ins.ci/n/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=19&Itemid=27",,,,"Quelques Indicateurs Cles de l'economie, Population","Institut National de la Statistique","Yes","Yes","NSO has little data none of which is particularly open. Africa Open Data website is out of date.","Some economic indicators available in a PDF [here][1].
[cotedivoire.africadata.org][2] has some open data on population but is outdated.
[1]: https://www.ins.ci/n/index.php?view=article&id=9:millions-of-smiles&format=pdf
[2]: https://cotedivoire.africadata.org","Yes","No","anonymous","Zach Christensen","45"
"d15a7a5c-72e7-41f3-bc40-4960ebe973fe","global","2015-09-14T19:17:05","2015","il","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.gov.il/data?title=%D7%AA%D7%A7%D7%A6%D7%99%D7%91&category=All&type=All&ministry=40&file_type=All","PDF, word, excel",,,,"Ministry of Finance, Budgets Department","Yes","Yes","I have check the data and it is correct","The data is also available graphically in
- https://bit.ly/mofbudget (Government Site)
- https://www.obudget.org (3rd party)","Yes","No","Adam Kariv","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"f6c07ce9-56a4-4bf9-9f34-84836b2d86b6","global","2015-09-27T23:10:29","2015","bw","budget","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Functional Classification of Expenditure-2015-2016","Ministry of Finance and Development Planning","Yes","Yes","Data only exist in department level, and not in sub-depratment / program level. Therefore, data exist but it is not publicly available. ","Submitters comment: Budget speech is available from various sources including bank of Botswana https://www.bob.bw/
From the government website - https://www.finance.gov.bw/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=117&catid=23&Itemid=109
Reviewers comment: It appears that the Ministry of Finance and Development Planning offers budget data at general level (https://www.finance.gov.bw/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=89&catid=23&Itemid=109), where pdf-downloads are available. The numbers are divided by sectors, but not very granular and does not contain sub department level.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","15"
"fb7486a8-ff3e-4419-9488-414e3d68d0b4","global","2015-10-02T09:29:59","2015","ke","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://treasury.go.ke/index.php/downloads/category/34-budget-2015",,,,"Budget 2015 - The National Treasury has published, in PDF format, the recurrent, final and development budget for the year 2015/2016","The National Treasury (Ministry of Finance) - ps@treasury.go.ke","Yes","Yes","I have checked the data and it is correct","Data is available in pdf-format and seemingly also exists on the Kenya Open Data (KODI) portal as well as the International Budget Partnership website (https://internationalbudget.org/budget-work-by-country/ibps-work-in-countries/kenya/), with more details (sector, county) but level of detail is varied and IBP provides analysis on the information provided.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","55"
"1a28b55f-596f-459e-a0d2-645cef6d2dea","global","2015-09-25T11:54:05","2015","al","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.financa.gov.al/al/raportime/buxheti/buxheti-ne-vite/buxheti-2015","Excel",,,"Plan Budget and Fact Budget","Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","I have checked the data and it is correct. ",,"Yes","No","Blerta Tuci","Mor Rubinstein","60"
"58e623e8-fc5f-42dd-8ca0-1b2951b5074e","global","2015-09-27T10:15:39","2015","tl","budget","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://budgettransparency.gov.tl/publicTransparency","XML, XLS",,,"Budget & Spending consist of 5 categories; budget transparency portal, the budget process, petroleum fund of timor-leste, budget execution reporting and budget & spending documents.","Timor-Leste Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","The data on the Transparency portal allows to download data about the budget in machine readable format. Therefore, the data is also online. "," 1. Timor-Leste Ministry of Finance official portal https://www.mof.gov.tl
2. Budget & Spending webpage https://www.mof.gov.tl/budget-spending/?lang=en
3. Timor-Leste transparency portal https://www.transparency.gov.tl/english.html (introductory of what info does https://www.mof.gov.tl/budget-spending/budget-transparency-portal/?lang=en)
4. Budget & Spending documents https://www.mof.gov.tl/budget-spending/budget-treasury-documents/?lang=en
Budget data seems to be updated to 2015. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","55"
"13d0609e-058d-40b1-ad1c-18284248b50a","global","2015-10-03T08:10:06","2015","gn","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.apiguinee.gov.gn/annonces-legales",,,,"Legal Notices","Agency for the Promotion of Private Investment (APIP)","Yes","Yes","Data is not available in bulk since it can only be viewed page by page (and there are 231 pages!) and can't be downloaded. All else is good!","The data is made available in an online register that can be browsed through but is not machine readable or downloadable in any way. The site's search function can also be used to search for individual companies. The majority of companies on the register do not list addresses, but a small handful do.","Yes","No","anonymous","Rebecca Sentance","35"
"00e6a6ba-96d7-4ec4-844e-18e881d3f7cf","global","2015-09-28T18:54:52","2015","br","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"No","https://www.mma.gov.br/images/arquivo/80060/Diagnostico_Rede_de_Monitoramento_da_Qualidade_do_Ar.pdf",".xls",,," Diagnóstico da rede de monitoramento da qualidade do ar no Brasil","Ministério do Meio Ambiente","Yes","Yes","checked","The Brazilian Federal Institute for Geography and Statistics - IBGE produced time series between 1992 and 2009/2010 referring to the air pollution in metropolitan areas. However, these data is not being updated anymore. The data does only cover some Brazilian cities. Additionally to this the Instituto Nacional de Pesquisas Espaciais publishes green house effects based on changes to land coverage in Amazon region: https://inpe-em.ccst.inpe.br/downloads.html. Apart from this data on air quality falls under the authority of the state government. It is provided for the state of São Paulo here: https://www.cetesb.sp.gov.br/ar/qualidade-do-ar/31-publicacoes-e-relatorios
The evaluation was made for the air quality data of São Paulo. No (daily) microdata is provided but the report shows a lot of details on the data collection and data for each point of measurement although aggregated over the year.
https://www.mma.gov.br/images/arquivo/80060/Diagnostico_Rede_de_Monitoramento_da_Qualidade_do_Ar.pdf
A national level report with data for the following metropolitan regions.
- Distrito Federal
- Vitória
- Belo Horizonte
- Curitiba
- Rio de Janeiro
- Salvador
- Porto Alegre
- São Paulo
- Santos
- Campinas
It contais measurements for PM, SOx, NOx and CO, but not VOCs. Report produced in 2013.
Some state-level environment agencies do have more up to date reports, for instance
Distrito Federal:
https://www.ibram.df.gov.br/informacoes/meio-ambiente/qualidade-do-ar.html
None of these do measure Volatile organic compounds (VOCs), however.
Air Quality:
https://meioambiente.cptec.inpe.br/index.php?lang=pt
- Carbon monoxide (CO)
- Ozone (O3)
- Nitrogen oxides (NOx)
- Volatile organic compounds (VOCs)
- Particulate matter (PM) Levels
","Yes","No","Rodrigo Brito","yar michl","45"
"1bf4e6af-6a64-40b7-ad59-1bfe1a1c45f8","global","2015-09-28T05:39:12","2015","ph","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.dbm.gov.ph/?page_id=10006","xls",,,,"Department of Budget and Management","Yes","Yes","I have found a machine readable format of the data on the department of budget and management website. I have change the submission accordingly. ","The Department of Budget and Management provides detailed information on the budget. Budget is presented by department/agency, sector and certain projects.
Data is offered in a non-machine readable format (PDF). It also can't be downloaded in bulk (only one section of the budget at a time).
Data is presented timely - current information is of 2015.
There is not explicit license on the website, therefore the data is not compliant with the open definition.
Proposed Expenditure data can be found in bulk and machine readable formate here - https://www.dbm.gov.ph/?page_id=10006 ","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"b0f3f46b-baf7-4db3-80c4-86417e3ed62f","global","2015-09-27T10:57:18","2015","tl","companies","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Found a slightly better link, but ultimately the data still doesn't exist as per our criteria and the registry lacks a lot of basic info.","The Institute for Business Enterprise, an official government website, has what appears to be a comprehensive list of businesses in Timor-Leste. https://www.iade.gov.tl/en/tis/enterprises/ However, it does not provide address details for companies - only district - and has no unique identification numbers. It is also unclear how often it is updated.","Yes","No","anonymous","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"ad9cf339-9ffa-4c7e-9893-949bb8967722","global","2015-09-30T19:24:48","2015","tc","companies","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Given that it's not even clear whether the registry meets our minimum criteria, I changed the first answer to ""Unsure"". There's just no way to answer the other questions without proof that the register exists or a way to examine it.","The website is https://www.tcifsc.tc/departments/registries/companies but it is unclear what data it contains and there is no way to access or search it.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Rebecca Sentance","0"
"acf49ae3-ff45-4121-9caf-a70678eeb5df","global","2015-09-28T07:41:07","2015","mm","budget","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Could not find any data about the budget. IBP initiative show it does exist, but it is not show projected expenditure to departments. https://survey.internationalbudget.org/#profile/MM","No data found from the Myanmar President Office website https://www.myanmarpresidentoffice.info/en/ and the cabinet ministers webpage is empty https://www.myanmarpresidentoffice.info/en/?q=cabinet/ministries","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"e7407dbe-279c-4ff9-9b20-7bcfa9e73d00","global","2015-09-18T20:11:54","2015","au","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.gov.au/dataset/budget-2015-16-tables-and-data","CSV, XLSX","https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/au/",,"Budget 2015-16 Tables and Data","Department of Finance","Yes","Yes","Data is correct. ","Data from the 2015-16 Budget are provided to assist those who wish to analyse, visualise and programmatically access the 2015-16 Budget.","Yes","Yes","Stephen Gates","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"6f0ad943-f1c2-480b-bb8a-23dbaa8463c0","global","2015-09-19T11:01:39","2015","ch","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.efv.admin.ch/f/dokumentation/finanzberichterstattung/budget.php","PDF",,,"Financial status reports, including the current and past national budgets, details on administrative units and statistical tables","Federal Finance Administration","Yes","Yes","Submission is correct. Could not find the data in machine readable format. ","PDF reports of the federal budget, containing data extracts, can be freely downloaded in French, German and Italian. An overview in English of next year's budget is also [available online][1].
[1]: https://www.efv.admin.ch/e/index.php","Yes","No","Oleg Lavrovsky","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"da4bf1e3-bee0-4556-b738-83b0d6b1a34e","global","2015-09-25T17:21:12","2015","de","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.govdata.de/daten/-/details/bundeshaushalt-2015","xls, csv, xml","https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/urhg/__5.html",,,,"Yes","Yes","Changed the link to the data to the 2015 budget. ","It has to be said that the granularity of the data is not satisfying. The budget data is available as XLS in bulk and free to use as an ""amtliches Werk"" according to §5 Abs 1. UrhG
No change from 2014.","Yes","Yes","walter palmetshofer","Mor Rubinstein","100"
"9b9be997-3c58-4a62-a348-65ee6192ac72","global","2015-09-14T10:17:19","2015","at","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.bmf.gv.at/budget/das-budget/budget-2014-2015.html","xls",,,"Budget 2014/2015","Federal Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","The Data available, but not in bulk. ","https://www.bmf.gv.at/budget/das-budget/budget-2014-2015.html provides links to the budgets for 2014 and 2015 in PDF files. Numerous relevant datasets with various statistics and payments are available as XLS files, however there appears to be no machine readable file with all data from the budget. More than a dozen XLS files are available for download, most of them with tens of worksheets, but all this data combined still does not appear to cover all the data contained in the PDF files of the budgets. The Ministry of Finance appears to claim a Copyright on all content on its website.
The Austrian Parliament has a department for budget analysis. The analysis and data produced by this department is only available online, mostly as PDF and DOCX files, a couple of relevant XLS files are available as well, but no fully machine-readable budget data set (https://www.parlament.gv.at/PAKT/BUDG/Budget/).
Furthermore more granular data of regions and cities and communities are available for lots of regions in Austria; and the project Offener Haushalt opens up budget data of communities and regions etc, see: https://www.offenerhaushalt.at/","Yes","No","Martin Kaltenböck","Mor Rubinstein","60"
"97d0009c-c290-4921-bcf5-e9d944a77661","global","2015-10-16T19:42:25","2015","za","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.treasury.gov.za/documents/national%20budget/2015/enebooklets/ENE%202015%20Summary%20tables.xls","XLS",,,"F and Excel format with accompanying information / speeches, key documents)","National Treasury of South Africa","Yes","Yes","I have reviewed the data and it is correct.","Government budgets are standardised across government departments allowing for easy comparisons. Historic budgets are also available in various forms back to 1993. 2013 onwards seem the most comprehensive. Planned expenditure data is available in PDF and XLS. The data is copyright under the National Treasury.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"e01353b3-3b76-4fd3-a9b9-e702c25e95a3","global","2015-10-05T18:16:42","2015","ca","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.statcan.gc.ca/start-debut-eng.html","CSV, HTML, PDF, XML, Beyond 20/20","https://www.statcan.gc.ca/eng/reference/licence-eng",,"Census, Population Estimates, Unemployment and GDP","Statistics Canada","Yes","Yes","Data are available in multiple formats, current, and open. ","The National Statistical Agency is Statistics Canada publishes these data https://www.statcan.gc.ca/start-debut-eng.html. Some of the data it produces are free and under and open licence, many are not and are under a cost recovery program. The data under this category are freely available at not cost.
The Census of Canada is conducted every 5 years. Statistics Canada produces quarterly population estimates. https://www23.statcan.gc.ca/imdb/p2SV.pl?Function=getSurvey&SDDS=3601.
In the 2011 Census, the mandatory long-form census was eliminated and a voluntary National Household Survey was created. This voluntary survey provides lower quality data with less granularity and has cause much concern for cities and analysts.
Unemployment statistics are provided here and are updated monthly - https://www5.statcan.gc.ca/olc-cel/olc.action?objId=71-001-X&objType=2&lang=en&limit=0
GDP data are published here and are updated monthly https://www.statcan.gc.ca/tables-tableaux/sum-som/l01/cst01/gdps04a-eng.htm
There are many kinds of demographic data. Statistical data are also available from many federal agencies and they are released intermittently. Administrative health data are available from the Canadian Institute of Health Information (CIHI). Health, education and so on are administered by provinces and territories and these are available by contacting all 13 jurisdictions. Revenue data are available from the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) while housing data are available from the Canadian Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC). Unemployment and bankruptcy data are available from Human Resources and Development Services Canada (HRSDC), immigration from Citizen Immigration Canada, and so on. Some data are for fee, some are for free, some are difficult to find as there is no central repository, many of the agencies are not well organized and not all are in the open data portal. Also some of these are administrative data while others are official national statistics. ","Yes","Yes","Mor Rubinstein","Zach Christensen","100"
"02629555-f17b-4df0-a29d-d91ddcd82cc1","global","2015-09-18T20:51:58","2015","au","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.abs.gov.au","xls","https://www.abs.gov.au/websitedbs/D3310114.nsf/Home/%A9+Copyright?opendocument#from-banner=GB",,"Statistics - the full range of ABS statistical and reference information. ","Australian Bureau of Statistics","Yes","Yes","Data are available, current, openly licensed, and available in XLS format. ","Location of census minimum criteria datasets:
- [GDP for the whole country updated at least quarterly](https://www.abs.gov.au/AUSSTATS/abs@.nsf/DetailsPage/5206.0Jun%202015?OpenDocument)
- [Unemployment statistics updated at least monthly](https://www.abs.gov.au/AUSSTATS/abs@.nsf/DetailsPage/6202.0Aug%202015?OpenDocument)
- [Population updated at least once a year](https://www.abs.gov.au/AUSSTATS/abs@.nsf/DetailsPage/3101.0Dec%202014?OpenDocument)
Unless otherwise noted, all material on this website – except the ABS logo, the Commonwealth Coat of Arms, and any material protected by a trade mark – is licensed under a [Creative Commons Attribution 2.5 Australia licence](https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.5/au/). Read the [Copyright page](https://www.abs.gov.au/websitedbs/D3310114.nsf/Home/%A9+Copyright?opendocument#from-banner=GB) for information on attribution and exceptions.","Yes","Yes","Stephen Gates","Zach Christensen","100"
"ed1dd9cd-70ea-466d-9138-db94f8616e42","global","2015-10-02T17:09:25","2015","jm","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"No","https://www.nepa.gov.jm/new/services_products/subsites/air_quality/reports.php",,,,"Air Quality Management Programme","National Environment and Planning Agency","Yes","Yes","checked
it may worth to email airquality@nepa.gov.jm for more data
","
it seem data is Exists for 2010-2012 in the
from a Regional Workshop on Metrology and Technology
Challenges of Climate Science and Renewable
Energy pdf
it seem the data is been continuous to be Measurements for all the type of Pollution","Yes","No","anonymous","yar michl","45"
"b9089f5f-fcbe-4d97-871a-f6b5db226e56","global","2015-09-19T12:02:54","2015","ch","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.simap.ch",,,,"Electronic platform of public procurement (Simap.ch)","The simap.ch Association","Yes","Yes","Updated machine readability. ","Tenders and bits conforming to GATT/WTO regulations are also published on [Tenders Electronic Daily](https://ted.europa.eu/) (TED).","Yes","No","Oleg Lavrovsky","Georg Neumann","45"
"1e64a35a-3e0e-4bc5-a8ef-40ce30ee6a1d","global","2015-09-23T18:28:53","2015","bs","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked ","It is uncertain if the data exists.
16-10-2015
from this webnews its seem the data dont exists
Group To Launch Monitoring Of Air Quality Around New Providence
https://www.tribune242.com/news/2015/may/20/group-launch-monitoring-air-quality-around-new-pro/","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","yar michl","0"
"9b822d9a-a6f6-4f0c-82d3-ecbdb485da6d","global","2015-09-28T10:46:33","2015","ge","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://tenders.procurement.gov.ge/public/?lang=en","HTML",,,"State Procurement Database","State Procurement Agency","Yes","Yes","Submission correct.","While the data is available online, it is not available in bulk in a machine readable format. The only way to access the data in this way is by scraping it. TI Georgia and JumpStart Georgia have both unsuccessfully requested bulk format and API access.","Yes","No","Eric Barrett","Georg Neumann","60"
"1191221b-527a-4bfa-b79d-7b5bcfca880c","global","2015-09-21T02:23:33","2015","dm","procurement","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Information on tenders is available through the Government Information Service, but no information on awards. ","This information is not available at any of the government based websites. It is unclear as to which department that deals with procurement, currently each government department is in charge of its own purchasing. ","Yes","No","Veronne Nicholas","Georg Neumann","0"
"7c411e35-3fe5-4e7a-879b-1d30f0550568","global","2015-10-02T22:21:04","2015","uy","emissions","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked ","
it seem the data exist for one city -Montevideo
it was mentioned in two document
Air Quality in Latin America: An Overview Produced by the Clean Air Institute
https://www.cleanairinstitute.org/calidaddelaireamericalatina/cai-report-english.pdf
World Health Organization
https://www.who.int/quantifying_ehimpacts/national/countryprofile/aap_pm_database_may2014.xls?ua=1","Yes","No","Daniel Carranza","yar michl","10"
"8a4e01ae-3511-4679-8b0b-6a5238c115c2","global","2015-09-25T16:26:45","2015","do","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.comprasdominicana.gov.do/","XLS ",,,"Compras Dominicana","Ministerio de Hacienda de la República Dominicana","Yes","Yes","Updated the entry with the information of the portal. ","The historic data is [available for download][1] on the transparency portal of the contracting authority.
[1]: https://www.dgcp.gob.do/transparencia/index.php/compras-y-contrataciones/licitaciones-publicas","Yes","No","Eliaquín Encarnación","Georg Neumann","60"
"7f1986fa-a13d-4f1e-abe5-0983a66bee2d","global","2015-09-21T13:14:56","2015","de","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.bund.de/Content/DE/Ausschreibungen/Suche/Formular.html?nn=4641482&resourceId=4641464&input_=4641482&pageLocale=de&type=0&templateQueryString=&city_zipcode=&ambit_distance=&submit=Finden","XML ",,,"Ausschreibungen","bund.de – Verwaltung Online","Yes","Yes","While the data is far from complete, it is open and available. Updated the entry to that regard. ","Germany does not have a unified set of public procurement regulations for tenders that fall below the EU thresholds. As a result, the publication and monitoring is decentralised at the federal state level and different local procurement portals exist. Bund.de is the main access point to the electronic information and administrative services of the German public administration and contains tenders from the federal, state and local governments as well as of vacancies in the public administration.
","Yes","No","Mara Mendes","Georg Neumann","60"
"07e030a8-1b32-4139-b33b-36fa6f2e9dd8","global","2015-09-28T04:53:42","2015","bm","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.gov.bm/portal/server.pt?open=512&objID=945&&PageID=235506&mode=2&in_hi_userid=2&cached=true",,,,"Ministry of Finance Office of Project Management & Procurement ","Government of Bermuda","Yes","Yes","Updated link to tender and contracts award database.",,"Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Georg Neumann","45"
"0f666f34-3fa4-46b7-a907-e411b8766c36","global","2015-09-07T12:07:39","2015","bh","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.tenderboard.gov.bh/Default.aspx",,,,"Open tender data and tender award data.","Tender Board","Yes","Yes","Submission correct.","The Bahraini Tender Board provides details about current tenders and the latest awards. The data includes the project name, number of bids, winning company, and the value of the contract. The tender data appears to be up to date, but the latest awarded data [is available up to June 2014 only][1].
[1]: https://www.tenderboard.gov.bh/Tendering/AwardedTenders.aspx","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Georg Neumann","35"
"c6db4156-6c07-4ae4-8647-a644e69fb54c","global","2015-08-30T10:31:21","2015","np","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"No","https://www.climatenepal.org.np/main/?p=research&sp=database_profile",,,,,"Minisrty of Science, Technology and Evironment, Nepal Climate Change & Development Portal","Yes","Yes","checked","Central Bureau of Statistics, Nepal maintains the statistics about different sectors of Nepal. This dataset is found in the report called ""Environment Statistics of Nepal"". The data is available in a pdf document, and not in a machine readable format. The data is not updated yearly. ","Yes","No","Nikesh Balami","yar michl","45"
"fc53bc84-c642-48b0-96f2-5a5e300545e7","global","2015-09-26T15:05:35","2015","sa","emissions","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","it seem the government is Collect information of air quality monitoring
https://www.environnement-sa.com/historical-order-received-for-saudi-arabia-2/
In the continuity of the setup of the National air quality monitoring system of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia delivered in 2007, the PME- Presidency of Meteorology and Environment, has renewed its confidence by placing a PO of 300 analysers !
29 stations will be shortly being integrated locally by our experimented long term Partners duly trained and skilled. Those stations will be deployed as fixed and mobile laboratories in the provinces of Medina, Makka and Al Qasim fleshing out the National Network.
","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","yar michl","5"
"d34d43fb-2dbb-4ad5-9b41-984de96734ca","global","2015-09-12T12:04:09","2015","ir","health","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I could not find the data either. Left data as unsure. ","The Iran Portal has a section for health here (https://eservices.iran.ir/), which has some link to list of hospitals in Tehran here (https://www.tehran.ir/Default.aspx?tabid=171), however it only has hospital names, address and telephone, no geo-location or opening hours; nevertheless it provides links to some hospitals where you can see their schedules.
We were not able to find data on infectious diseases rates in a country","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"50d9605b-7237-4e54-9858-f8365fdb75b3","global","2015-09-20T21:30:08","2015","es","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://contrataciondelestado.es","XML, HTML, PDF","https://contrataciondelestado.es/wps/portal/!ut/p/b1/04_Sj9Q1NDczsrA0MzIx0Y_Qj8pLLMtMTyzJzM9LzAHxo8zinYItLBydDB0NDIxDLQwczQIDnS1dDIwMLI2BCiKBCgxwAEcDQvrD9aPASkyNnU3CvMICzII93Q0MPD3cXHxCDU0N3I3MoArwWOHnkZ-bqp8blWPpqeuoCACviVe5/dl4/d5/L2dJQSEvUUt3QS80SmtFL1o2X0FWRVFBSTkzME8xS0MwMkJOMFNHTUgzMFEz/",,"Plataforma de Contratación del Sector Público","Ministerio de Hacienda y Administraciones Públicas","Yes","Yes",,"The Procurement Tenders dataset matches the evaluation criteria.
It does not provide a bulk download but an an electronic mechanism to allow companies to [integrate the tenders with their systems][1] (with the [CODICE specification][2]) and [a set of RSS feeds.][3]
[1]: https://contrataciondelestado.es/wps/portal/!ut/p/b1/jZHLboMwEEW_pR8QeTx-gJfmZYxIA3GhjTcViyhCymNT9ftLEFmkUd3MbqRzPOO5xJPdikYSYyWRc_JB_Hn4Hg_D13g5D8dr7-Vn4uJYJ1RDnHIOWirVt_qNAhcTsJsAwVLeV30jnTUAtiyyuqMCDMrnfPijNNz7xq3p5OdMCgRqHC5-ALj6us9bbRUDs21ywGQbSV5sGMDNDwD3-0dJtjzfUgQQv-c_AqH_G_qwf1UJ0GvgtWkogxyfu19gwD_-O_EzwvNNmhYlQuxYBlhnXSfLqTW4AKGIZyCUYTiFGxC4wmt5Oe3JyR-LuZQd7Uq__AA6Ulhv/dl4/d5/L2dJQSEvUUt3QS80SmtFL1o2X0JTODhBQjFBMDhDNDQwQTY5OVZRQVQxMDQw/
[2]: https://contrataciondelestado.es/wps/portal/!ut/p/b1/jZLJboMwEIafKPLv8QIczWZApIFQSMOl4hBFSFkuVZ-_JCWHNKqTuY30fZ7Fw3q2XXBPkx9okpJ9sP40fI_74Ws8n4bDJe_1Z9j4vgm5gR9JCaODoKvNO4fEBGwnQIlIdkVX6Sa3QJ6lcdlyBUv6NR__hMG9b5sln_xEaEXgtqHZdwAX33RJbfJAwK6rBBSuPS3TlQBuvgO4798L4_n5mhOg_tZ_BFzzW_7Qf1EomCVkaSsukNBr-3MUcPrqiS_Vs_ob1l8RmayiKM0IfiNiUBm3rc6m1NIMuE7kCrhuwP2LN8CxxbfsfNyxY39IfyPIx3xhfgBd1IZ6/dl4/d5/L2dJQSEvUUt3QS80SmtFL1o2X0JTODhBQjFBMDhDNDQwQTY5OVZRQVQxMDQ1/
[3]: https://contrataciondelestado.es/wps/portal/info/rss2/!ut/p/b1/pZLLboMwEEW_KPK1PTawNC8DIg2EQhs2FYsqQspjE_X7SylZpFGdSp3daM7RXcxlPdutuKeFH2hBxF5Zfxo-xv1wGc-n4fC19_otbHzfhNzANmsOoxOplQC3jZiA3QQoGVFXdJVucgvkWRqXLVewQv_Nxy9jMPumS2qTBxJ2WyUQ4dbTlG4kcPUdwE2-74Xxkl9zAajFdwC3fkQ0nYOgq80zh-U_fVsUCmYNKm3FJRLh9Ok-_y7A6eOBT_hfPqlH_3th_YxQsomiNBPwGxlDlHHb6mxarVgAV0VmwNUBdwuugOMLT9n5-M6O_SH9niAf85X5BKz-hsc!/dl4/d5/L2dJQSEvUUt3QS80SmtFL1o2X0cwNjRDSTkzME9BU0QwSThVT1VDRTAwMDE1/","Yes","Yes","José Félix Ontañón","Georg Neumann","90"
"c9658b25-1e20-40f3-b945-0744ffba90fb","global","2015-09-25T17:29:59","2015","be","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://enot.publicprocurement.be/enot-war/home.do","XML ",,,"e-Procurement portal of the Agency was established in the second half of 2013 as part of the Program on e-procurement in the Tajikistan for 2013-2015 approved by the Decision of Government No.769 of December 29 2012.","Federal Public Service Personnel and Organisation ","Yes","Yes",,"Current and closed tender notices are available. Contract notices are available, but information on companies is not included. It is only searchable in a search engine, not available in bulk or aggregating datasheets.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Georg Neumann","60"
"b87d40f4-9a6f-4285-95ad-0c9a910cafd7","global","2015-09-15T12:58:04","2015","bd","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.eprocure.gov.bd/",,,,"National e-Government Procurement (e-GP) ","Central Procurement Technical Unit (CPTU), IME Division of Ministry of Planning","Yes","Yes","Submission updated.","National e-Government Procurement (e-GP) active in Bangladesh ","Yes","No","Hasive Nur Chowdhury","Georg Neumann","45"
"2cd976ca-69e6-4e9f-920b-2123dc60f5a2","global","2015-10-02T11:09:04","2015","ba","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.ejn.gov.ba/",,,,"Public Procurement Portal","Agencija za javne nabavke BiH: kontakt@javnenabavke.gov.ba","Yes","Yes","Submission is correct.","The Agency did a really good job by making this website. However, there are still a few flaws. The tenders are published in PDF, but the PDF-s are not actually machine readable (e.g. if you would like to build a crawler which was supposed to go through these documents and index them, it would be impossible). There is also no option for bulk download of data. Other than that, good effort and an improvment on the situation of a few years ago.","Yes","No","Damir Dajanovic","Georg Neumann","45"
"f82cbae1-ea79-4235-98ba-12a7dd32b45a","global","2015-09-20T14:41:30","2015","bb","procurement","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"Tenders [are available][1] on the Barbados Integrated Government website. Awards are not.
[1]: https://www.gov.bb/bigportal/big/tenders/tenderindex.php","Yes","No","anonymous","Georg Neumann","0"
"5bdf9f87-55f4-47a7-9b84-37e9a7379ecd","global","2015-10-04T13:51:12","2015","az","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://tender.gov.az/new/?lan=en",".xlsx",,,"Information about competitions held ","State Procurement Agency of the Republic of Azerbaijan","Yes","Yes","Submission correct. License is not stated as open. ",,"Yes","No","Codrina Maria Ilie","Georg Neumann","60"
"dac84af4-d451-4859-8141-6510d2812a52","global","2015-09-27T23:44:45","2015","aw","procurement","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Only Tenders are available. ","Public tenders [are available][1] on the Aruba government website. However, awards are not made online.
[1]: https://www.overheid.aw/news/public-tenders_44442/","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Georg Neumann","0"
"dfdbdd2c-d5d9-4b77-a4a4-3d5be527769e","global","2015-09-14T10:37:21","2015","at","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.auftrag.at/WZOnlineSearch.aspx",,,,"Online-Ausgabe des Amtlichen Lieferungsanzeigers","Federal Procurement Agency and/or Wiener Zeitung","Yes","Yes","Updated that data is available for free. ","There are several sources for such data - on EU level it is TED: https://ted.europa.eu/TED/browse/browseByBO.do and on national level data can be found freely available on the system of the Wiener Zeitung (Newspaper owned by the Austrian federal Gov) under: https://www.auftrag.at/WZOnlineSearch.aspx (but listed and not very user-friendly) and/or via the Federal Procurement Agency: https://www.bbg.gv.at/. ","Yes","No","Martin Kaltenböck","Georg Neumann","45"
"213f6598-cd7f-47cc-b1de-e4f2b02e7c7d","global","2015-09-25T14:33:41","2015","de","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","We have not identified any significant change in access to postal data in Germany for 2015. ","The Postcodes are provide by Deutsche Post AG, a formal state owned, now private Company. The Postcodes can be accessed via an online Service https://www.postdirekt.de/plzserver/
However the underling datasets are not available for download and are not free of charge.
Geospatial data (polygon vectors) are available from unofficial sources: here https://datahub.io/dataset/postal-codes-de/resource/1f25cb5a-8810-40f1-9fc1-5cef0163ebd3 or here
https://download.geonames.org/export/zip/
","Yes","No","walter palmetshofer","Codrina Maria Ilie","25"
"9c5e95c7-a3d2-4bf2-b94a-403533f8dc30","global","2015-09-14T10:59:39","2015","at","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"Postleitzahlen Österreich","Österreichische Post AG","Yes","Yes","We were unable to identify if a geocoded postal code datasets exists within any governmental agency. Moreover, the datasets found had only city level post codes. We were unable to identify if the Austrian Post Service has city-district or street level post codes. ","A tabular datasets with ZIP codes at city level is available on the government's open data portal, but this dataset does not contain geo-coordinates, https://www.post.at/geschaeftlich_werben_produkte_und_services_adressen_postlexikon.php
No dataset that meets the description of this survey appears to be publicly available at this point.
*Further observation:* The Statistical Agency Austria holds related ZIP code data, also without coordinates.
On the webpage of the Austrian Postal Service user can search for a postal code, but no geospatial information is provided. more info: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Postleitzahl_%28%C3%96sterreich%29","Yes","No","Martin Kaltenböck","Codrina Maria Ilie","25"
"c3acec4a-7e10-4410-a305-c806a9d45a0e","global","2015-09-16T11:28:25","2015","tn","emissions","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,"National Agency for Environmental Protection","Yes","Yes","checked
mybe somebdoey can Contact Hassen KCHIH(National Agency for Environmental Protection)
to see if the data is open To the public
","PDF Reports published in the official website of the National Agency for Environment Protection from 2005 to 2008. No more updates since then. The website and the information it contains are the property of the Agency, thus data is considered non-open.
(No change from 2013)
2015:
The agency website is no longer accessible
16.10.2015 :
it seem National Agency for Environmental Protection is Monitoring Air Quality data
from a CONFERENCE PAPER of Hassen Kchih from the Agency
Tunisian Air Quality Monitoring Network Presentation
no data was fond in their web site
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/274076911_Tunisian_Air_Quality_Monitoring_Network_Presentation
ABSTRACT
It is among the basic missions of the National Agency for Environmental Protection (NAEP) to preserve and improve the quality of our nation's air. In order to accomplish this mission, the Agency must be able to evaluate the status of the atmosphere compared to clean air standards and historical informations. That's why the NAEP established since 1996 an Air Quality Monitoring Network (AQMN) composed by thirteen permanent monitoring stations, two mobiles laboratories and a data elaboration centre with the aim of characterizing human health exposure and public impacts of conventional pollutants. In Tunisia, that extends over 163900 km² and includes 24 metropolitans towns, there are several permanent monitoring stations located in many towns like Tunis, Sfax, Sousse, Gabès Tozeur, Kef. In this paper, some stations of Tunisia and its monitoring networks have been selected as representative sites of the investigated area. In Tunis, the selected monitoring stations were located in Traffic area (Bab Saadoun), in urban area (El Mourouj) and in a suburban area (Nahli). Each station is provided with automatic analyzers of O 3 , NOx, SO 2 , PM10, CO and with meteorological sensors such as temperature, barometric pressure, relative humidity, solar radiation, wind speed and direction. Nitrogen oxides, NO and NO 2 , were analysed using the chemiluminescence method. The measurement of ozone is based on the capacity of such gases to absorb ultraviolet rays with opportune wavelengths, generated by built-in lamp. Carbon monoxide CO is analyzed infrared rays absorption (IR). The measurement of PM10 is based on the beta ray attenuation method while SO 2 is analysed using a fluorescence method. For all parameters, the data are collected by the monitoring network every hour. The data were validated according to this protocol: first, a preliminary validation was carried out by the software, which invalidated all the data occurred in calibration hours and the data identified as artifacts then a manual calibration was carried out by the operators, considering the relations among the parameters. This way it is possible to verify that eventual critical data are related to real pollution situations. Moreover, meteorological data (wind speed and direction) were used to investigate about the influence of natural events on high or low concentration situations
","Yes","No","Yosr Jouini","yar michl","5"
"bb603114-af36-4258-9814-2375f1f60230","global","2015-09-12T05:17:27","2015","jp","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.post.japanpost.jp/zipcode/download.html","CSV","https://www.post.japanpost.jp/zipcode/dl/readme.html",,,"Japan Post","Yes","Yes","ok","JP Post does not claim copyright on zip code data.
Additionally, a data set linking postal addresses with geo-coordinates are separate, but publicly available online, free of charge, in bulk, without much usage restriction, in digital, machine-readable format,
in a timely manner (updated yearly).
https://nlftp.mlit.go.jp/isj/index.html
The license for the geocoded postal data can be found here https://nlftp.mlit.go.jp/isj/agreement.html.
","Yes","Yes","Satoshi IIDA","Codrina Maria Ilie","100"
"5a4da5c9-ffba-4c5d-b94e-d543dd8eabe0","global","2015-09-18T20:38:26","2015","ag","procurement","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.caribank.org/procurement-notices/general-procurement-notices/strengthening-private-sector-participation-in-the-csme-antigua-and-barbuda","HTML",,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission updated. ","The Government of Antigua & Barbuda does not have a tender and award database. Notices are distributed via the Government's website https://www.ab.gov.ag ","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Georg Neumann","0"
"ee02013f-a668-4358-bd4d-bf848d6d675c","global","2015-10-09T13:37:45","2015","ae","procurement","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission correct. Only if award information is available as well, the data should be classified as existing.","The Ministry of Finance publishes the latest data about tenders on a timely manner on its website. ( https://www.mof.gov.ae/ar/publication/pages/tenders.aspx ). Details relating to awards do not appear to be online.
Not to editor: I am facing a problem whenever I try to answer ""no"" the question ""publicly available"". I had this same problem with many of my submissions, the form gets accepted only if I set the answer as ""unsure"".
Reviewer's comment:
Since the data for awardees is not available, I'd mark this entity as unavailable since it doesn't meet the minimum requirements","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Georg Neumann","0"
"1a05e0c5-3c00-4c21-bddb-e87266562ceb","global","2015-10-04T14:39:59","2015","rw","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://pps.rppa.gov.rw",,,,"Tender System","Rwanda Public Procurement Authority","Yes","Yes","Updated link and availability of tender and award information.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Georg Neumann","45"
"8c324025-f1dc-4ee0-9c4b-705a5e251e93","global","2015-10-02T14:32:25","2015","bs","procurement","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.bahamas.gov.bs/wps/portal/public/Government%20Tender%20and%20Tender%20Notices/!ut/p/b1/vZPJcqMwFEW_JR_gIMkCiSXGTDHzZMOGYvLAYLBjB5uvb9LVVT1UxelFp6WVVOfV1X1Xj4mZCHM8JPyczpkNEx_Tt8MuvRy6Y9q8n2MumQPFEARMDYUFHNACWxdsoiILshMQTQD4YAngYf0K_ah_APyV_kcABp_Vr5lNFoGbSLVBkrLE61NDy1QU7aEMpKa4nj19r1_HqljoaWQlc7gY8uRc4gFtyRrZ9TWnqOYImtl3W9y-6HJL1mrk6hfPOq9IH6AxvR_5te683bpOd5Yz2rszN7Tg5cpWwkDdTkXOUKGc3ZTicojFkx1ZfeGYFrbjOt2JPRZ8Y0sKj_pwhmpFkaY3xw9tvbv-DjyK5bNgTLVrSyaaMPIL5ocAaBAIrgcdQE3I-MwG4MSr7r021qNbjc7oVbFt-KEO_ODujVlo-rLhmyk0lgtruruZAbgZNRj9AJqXwreL0A0WgliLmmj-KWghn58ERcitAhZ4AH-1oMJadGoE8W2BRUCx4P8WnP_Xliq2Bb7c4W-fBjv_PsMXJj5k7fOQt8_gmfIcZAnFPOUAxpQwYRVhsnwfcM2eBjzPuHXYOuAwUHnHNSLufAc3QcOuKi6jJacdzF3UbkmkKvMrVcoULBzl0Jh6CrL8VO5FvUCSWG_0QNPd-p7ykiY7hq_Jt7Ui74mk5Ge8JUlvLV_lcOykU9GVUcTOzhS9jW1_snYrP79zIl9qzUUu3DEpYdEdX1b7jTVrWrnlTq-Ju47DujkSUQtqpNxeS2l7SfYX1ex5kG1kOJs7T09MGzeyrHOuOkD6cw9P3wB-N4mQ/dl4/d5/L2dBISEvZ0FBIS9nQSEh/",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Because Awards are not available, the overall data availability question has been set to no. ","Tender notices [are available in PDF format and not machine readable][1]. Award notices are not available.
[1]: https://www.bahamas.gov.bs/wps/portal/public/Government%20Tender%20and%20Tender%20Notices/!ut/p/b1/vZPJcqMwFEW_JR_gIMkCiSXGTDHzZMOGYvLAYLBjB5uvb9LVVT1UxelFp6WVVOfV1X1Xj4mZCHM8JPyczpkNEx_Tt8MuvRy6Y9q8n2MumQPFEARMDYUFHNACWxdsoiILshMQTQD4YAngYf0K_ah_APyV_kcABp_Vr5lNFoGbSLVBkrLE61NDy1QU7aEMpKa4nj19r1_HqljoaWQlc7gY8uRc4gFtyRrZ9TWnqOYImtl3W9y-6HJL1mrk6hfPOq9IH6AxvR_5te683bpOd5Yz2rszN7Tg5cpWwkDdTkXOUKGc3ZTicojFkx1ZfeGYFrbjOt2JPRZ8Y0sKj_pwhmpFkaY3xw9tvbv-DjyK5bNgTLVrSyaaMPIL5ocAaBAIrgcdQE3I-MwG4MSr7r021qNbjc7oVbFt-KEO_ODujVlo-rLhmyk0lgtruruZAbgZNRj9AJqXwreL0A0WgliLmmj-KWghn58ERcitAhZ4AH-1oMJadGoE8W2BRUCx4P8WnP_Xliq2Bb7c4W-fBjv_PsMXJj5k7fOQt8_gmfIcZAnFPOUAxpQwYRVhsnwfcM2eBjzPuHXYOuAwUHnHNSLufAc3QcOuKi6jJacdzF3UbkmkKvMrVcoULBzl0Jh6CrL8VO5FvUCSWG_0QNPd-p7ykiY7hq_Jt7Ui74mk5Ge8JUlvLV_lcOykU9GVUcTOzhS9jW1_snYrP79zIl9qzUUu3DEpYdEdX1b7jTVrWrnlTq-Ju47DujkSUQtqpNxeS2l7SfYX1ex5kG1kOJs7T09MGzeyrHOuOkD6cw9P3wB-N4mQ/dl4/d5/L2dBISEvZ0FBIS9nQSEh/","Yes","No","anonymous","Georg Neumann","0"
"8b6e0e44-aabb-47bc-95d7-704179711710","global","2015-10-04T14:48:00","2015","et","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.ppa.gov.et/index.php?option=com_ppa&view=procurement&layout=tender&Itemid=85&lang=en",,,,"Tenders","The FDRE Public Procurement and Property Administration Agency","Yes","Yes","Submitted with added note on awards.","Tender notices are up-to-date. Award notices do not seem to be complete. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Georg Neumann","35"
"bc1ef8f0-89c7-4e42-87f8-ae8eed4f6664","global","2015-10-02T09:33:37","2015","ke","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://supplier.treasury.go.ke/site/tenders.go/index.php/public/tenders",,,,"Tenders and Contract Awards","National Treasury of Kenya","Yes","Yes","Submission correct. There is no explicit open license used, so put this category on No.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Georg Neumann","45"
"dbcc3b13-a78d-458a-8e7d-307fa67aa1ec","global","2015-10-15T20:48:57","2015","jm","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://jis.gov.jm/information/procurements/",,,,"Government of Jamaica Procurements Page.","The National Contracts Commission","Yes","Yes","Submission correct.","Tenders are invited from appropriately qualified contractors registered with the National Contracts Commission (NCC) for the provision of Goods, Services and Works. For the provision of Insurance Services, in addition to the foregoing requirements, Brokers/Insurers must also be registered and pre-qualified by the Financial Services Commission (FSC). Upon the submission of tenders, Contractors must submit valid Tax Compliance Certificates (TCCs) and National Contracts Commission (NCC) Certificates. Procurement opportunities offered by way of International Competitive Bidding are not subject to the above. However, NCC and TCC Certificates are required prior to the award of contract(s). Awarded contracts [are listed seperately][1].
Data is in pdf format and not machine readable.
[1]: https://www.ncc.gov.jm/ncc/ncc_listing.php","Yes","No","Georg Neumann","Georg Neumann","45"
"bb04732d-d2a4-4f04-8dbc-f3e40e1d87d3","global","2015-10-07T15:44:08","2015","ie","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://etenders.gov.ie/",,,,"Web-based listing of all government tenders","Office of Government Procurement","Yes","Yes","Submission correct.","The Tender Advisory Service (TAS) is being piloted to assist suppliers who have issues or concerns with a procurement process carried out by the Office of Government Procurement (OGP) or other public sector contracting body (excluding the commercial semi-state bodies). The pilot will cover all procurement processes and will be subject to review after the first twelve months. TAS will operate through the OGP’s Customer Service Section.","Yes","No","anonymous","Georg Neumann","45"
"ecc7ca1f-670b-4957-860e-26f7e526e847","global","2015-10-02T17:40:09","2015","ms","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.gov.ms/tenders/",,,,"Tenders","Government of Montserrat","Yes","Yes","Submission updated. Only awards are available in bulk.","Data is available as individual pdf and docx formats and not machine readable.","Yes","No","anonymous","Georg Neumann","45"
"f84faf0c-d078-4e7f-acba-37ce727a5e87","global","2015-10-02T21:20:44","2015","sn","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.air-dakar.org/bulletins/bulletins-mensuels.html",,,,,"CENTRE DE GESTION DE LA QUALITE DE L’AIR","Yes","Yes","checked","The government have adopted a standard(1) related to the atmospheric pollution surveillance, and that standard precise that the mesures will be done by quaterly. But there is no evidence that the mesures are effectively done.
For the city of dakar, there is a website where polluttants data are published(2).
1. https://www.denv.gouv.sn/index.php?option=com_joomdoc&task=doc_download&gid=27&Itemid=59
2. https://www.air-dakar.org/images/pdf/bulletins/bulletin_dec_2014.pdf
add by Reviewer
3.it now seem the data is Measured the last data is from 02 octobre 2015 its stil not Is provided on a timely and up to date basis of a week
4,and the Detailled readings, for each pollutants and expressed in mg/m3 is not available. Instead, only 4 levels are provided (good, moderate, unhealyhy and very unhealthy) without much information about the dominent pollutants and thresholds.
https://aqicn.org/country/senegal/
also it seem the data is only for the city of dakar
","Yes","No","anonymous","yar michl","35"
"42d95fe8-ac63-4375-9a1c-9d7ee45e4ea5","global","2015-10-01T15:13:55","2015","tz","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","There is no indication that data set containing all of these items exists anywhere within Tanzanian government agencies or ministries.
it seem data of air Pollutant maybe in the past was Dar es Salaam
city in Tanzania
https://www.unep.org/transport/pcfv/PDF/DART-OVERVIEWAIRPOLLUTION.pdf","Yes","No","Joachim Mangilima","yar michl","0"
"d1fe8254-0a72-4d2d-98f5-fd74ec95908b","global","2015-10-03T08:45:31","2015","gn","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","No evidcence","Yes","No","anonymous","yar michl","0"
"9192c592-b3f6-485d-9832-d4150297832b","global","2015-09-16T04:58:36","2015","lb","health","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Data exist, but it is not accessible. Changed the submission accordingly. ","There is this list for public hospitals (https://www.moph.gov.lb/MedicalCare/PublicHospitals/Documents/publicHospitalsDirectory.pdf) and this for private ones (https://www.moph.gov.lb/MedicalCare/Documents/NorthPrivateHospitals.pdf). Both do not contain location (lat/long or exact addresses) nor opening hours.
Here is health news (https://www.moph.gov.lb/Media/Pages/HealthNews.aspx) but it wasn't updated since 2012
Data about infectious diseases can also be found in this report in English - https://www.moph.gov.lb/Statistics/Documents/StatisticalBulletin2013.pdf
Reviewer's note -
We know that the data exist. However, in the case of locations, it is not displayed. Int he case of diseases, the data is not up-to-date or in machine readable format.
I have changed the data accordingly. ","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Mor Rubinstein","5"
"57f280c9-f5c9-4314-b12e-a2f006f40c21","global","2015-09-15T14:00:33","2015","be","health","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://www.health.belgium.be/eportal/Healthcare/Healthcarefacilities/index.htm?fodnlang=nl#.VfgeKRHtmkr",,,,"Health Care Institutions: List of hospitals, nursing homes for the elderly and emergency services & Epistat: Belgian Infectious Diseases ","Federal Public Service Health, Food Chain Safety and Environment & The Scientific Institute of Public Health","Yes","Yes","Added raw source for infectious diseases.","The data regarding hospitals and healthcare services is available in bulk and is updated on a regular basis. The Epistat website (https://epistat.wiv-isp.be/) does provide information regarding infectious diseases in Belgium, but the data can't be downloaded and it's unsure how regular the website is being updated.
Machine readable data for infectious diseases can be found here - https://youtu.be/12mfbJdUKQk - data updated for 2012 and is in bulk. ","Yes","No","Deraesara L","Mor Rubinstein","35"
"0d5531b7-8734-4331-99ab-57862275aa15","global","2015-10-02T06:11:09","2015","ml","health","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Changed submission to NO. Could not find data from an official source online. ","Reviewer's note: I could not find the data on the Ministry of Health website - https://www.sante.gov.ml/","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"62c371bf-b7a5-40fd-8656-00af3120b795","global","2015-09-20T06:05:53","2015","pk","health","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,"Department of Health ","Yes","Yes","Changed data to exist, yet it is not available. ","Reviewer's notes:
From the [department of health website][1] it is clear that the information is gathered for Policy and research, but it is not available on the site. In addition, there is aggregated data about facilities, which indicated that there is data about locations on facilities. However, this data can not be found on the site.
[1]: https://health.punjab.gov.pk/Services_Package","Yes","No","Nouman Nazim","Mor Rubinstein","5"
"59de9080-e568-43b0-9a53-3b82160b80e6","global","2015-09-25T17:14:23","2015","vc","health","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.www.gov.vc/health/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=250:the-ministry-of-health-wellness-and-the-environment-is-embarking-on-the-development-of-a-comprehensive-water-safety-plan&catid=38:latest-news&Itemid=65",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Changed data to NO. Could not find the relevant data. ","Reviewer's note - The Health ministry website doesn't contain the information that was requested. https://www.www.gov.vc/health/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=250:the-ministry-of-health-wellness-and-the-environment-is-embarking-on-the-development-of-a-comprehensive-water-safety-plan&catid=38:latest-news&Itemid=65","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"41de5071-6ee0-4c33-bd6a-24cbdf7bdf02","global","2015-09-18T02:08:40","2015","lc","health","Yes","Yes","Unsure","No","Unsure","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,"St Lucia Medical - Living and Staying Healthy in St Lucia","RediscoverStLucia.com","Yes","Yes","The submitter data was from an unofficial source. I changed it to the official source. ","There is an infectious disease department - https://health.govt.lc/ministries/health-wellness-human-services-and-gender-relations/infectious-diseases
However, the data is not published online. Facilities data exist but not published. ","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Mor Rubinstein","20"
"114c43d3-9745-49d0-98a5-80efd9ac8e79","global","2015-09-25T23:06:34","2015","kn","health","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is correct. ","The official government page is down and no site relating the the ministry of health can be found.
Reviewer's note - The website was live during the review. There was no relevant health data. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"bd2914a5-2be8-415c-ae81-e801d55eb32a","global","2015-09-05T07:53:30","2015","jm","health","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.moh.gov.jm/",,,,"The Ministry of Health (MOH) is the pre-eminent Government organization whose mandate is ","Ministry of Health","Yes","Yes","Submission is correct. Added specific links. ","Data on infectious diseases can be found in the bulletins - https://moh.gov.jm/bulletins/ The data is in PDF.
Locations of facilities can be found on a Google map in this link - https://moh.gov.jm/location-of-hospitals-and-health-centres/
","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"09094165-6d31-458b-8e9a-10175f7a1654","global","2015-10-02T15:21:11","2015","gd","health","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://health.gov.gd/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=194&Itemid=485&lang=en",,,,"Health Statistics ","Ministry of Health The Grenada Electronic Network for Integrated Health Care","Yes","Yes","Changed bulk data. ","The information is location on the Ministry of Health website provided by The Grenada Electronic Network for Integrated Health Care.
Data is in pdf format and not machine readable.
Reviewer's note - On paper, Granada should have an e-health map for health facilities. De facto, this map is not available. Data on location can be found on the website in HTML. Data is not available in bulk.
Data for both location and diseases is updated for 2014. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"4a6b4b15-e503-40f5-b3a5-5f155d8e6eb6","global","2015-09-20T18:43:12","2015","dm","health","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,"Ministry of health","Yes","Yes","Change data to exist, but not in digital form. ","Location of public hospitals and clinics are available via radio infomercials and printed media, however not online. Information on data on infectious diseases rates are normally posted to the radio or television when there is an outbreak. However, currently that data is not available online. It may however, be available through the Ministry of Health and Environment.
Contact information:
Ministry of Health
4th Floor, Government Headquarters
Kennedy Avenue
Roseau, Dominica
Phone: (767) 266 3437
Fax: (767) 448 6086
a form can also be filled out at: https://health.gov.dm/index.php/contact-us OR at
healthpromotion@dominica.gov.dm
(767) 266 3469/3470
Fax: (767) 448 6086
reviewer's note: By this submission, data seems to exist, but not online. Therefore I changed the submission from Unsure To data exist. According to the submitter, this is not in digital form. ","Yes","No","Veronne Nicholas","Mor Rubinstein","5"
"2c525c58-058b-4909-a703-4cdcaba3628f","global","2015-10-01T21:15:44","2015","bj","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","There is some data collected, but not at the national level.","Yes","No","anonymous","yar michl","0"
"18c08ed2-62d9-4264-8eb5-6798ded12c6c","global","2015-09-28T05:58:48","2015","bm","health","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.health.gov.bm/portal/server.pt",,,,,"Department of health ","Yes","Yes","Added available information. ","Uncertain if the data exists.
Reviewer's note -
Past reports on infectious disease can be found here -
https://www.gov.bm/portal/server..pt/components/com_joomlalib?open=512&objID=506&mode=2&in_hi_userid=2&cached=true
The last report on the website is from 2012, but it seems that the data is collected regularly, and there are forms on the site.
Location data is one the home page of the health ministry - https://www.health.gov.bm/portal/server.pt","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Mor Rubinstein","35"
"b560f22a-f0e8-4a67-bdc0-33172bfb2d0c","global","2015-09-20T15:15:52","2015","bb","health","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Added location data","Reviewers note - Health Care facilities list is available here- https://www.health.gov.bb/index.php/ministry_of_health/health_care_facilities
Could not find infectious disease report.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"39068561-fa21-40e0-8d93-605d7fb3e23f","global","2015-09-30T15:05:39","2015","gb","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://download.companieshouse.gov.uk/en_output.html","CSV","https://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open-government-licence/version/3/",,"Free Company Data Product - A downloadable data snapshot containing basic company data of live companies on the register.","Companies House","Yes","Yes","All fields satisfied, no issues. Updated title and short description and details fields.","Companies House, the public body responsible for maintaining company registers in the UK, has since June 2012 made available a subset of the fields of the register for all companies for bulk download as monthly 'snapshot', at no charge and on an open basis. The specifications for the data are documented at https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/370248/CompanyDataProductDataset.pdf and meets the minimum requirements of the definition of this element of the OKFN Census 2013. Additionally, full information from individual company registers is no longer subject to payment. Data is timely and was last updated on Oct 1st, 2015.","Yes","Yes","Mor Rubinstein","Rebecca Sentance","100"
"28044c21-2e4b-48bd-b6b8-50e18e1804c4","global","2015-09-25T08:58:50","2015","za","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.etenders.gov.za",,,,"eTender Publication ","National Treasury","Yes","Yes","Updated the link to the eTender platform. ","Most, if not all, government departments publish tender information online, generally in PDF format. There is no single, machine-readable source of information across all of government.","Yes","No","Greg Kempe","Georg Neumann","45"
"37a96f63-cabd-4f77-8ed7-98c30d9ad765","global","2015-08-28T18:55:19","2015","ar","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.argentinacompra.gov.ar",,,,"Argentina Compra","Oficina Nacional de Contrataciones - Secretaría de Coordinación Administrativa Y Evaluación Presupuestaria","Yes","Yes","Submission correct.","Custom licence here:
https://www.argentinacompra.gov.ar/prod/onc/sitio/Paginas/Contenido/FrontEnd/index2.asp","Yes","No","Martín Szyszlican","Georg Neumann","45"
"66597d61-c497-4dcf-92b1-5b02be64485b","global","2015-09-27T14:26:03","2015","cm","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","Link to data portal of the ministry of environment: https://www.minep.gov.cm/index.php?option=com_content&view=category&id=27&Itemid=72&lang=fr
Comment: “Data on environment are not available from the Ministry of environment. Few years ago The Cameroon’s National Institute of Statistics did a study on the pollution of surface and ground water in Yaoundé and its impact on population health.. https://www.statistics-cameroon.org/fr5/downloads/EPESS_Note_synthese_version_12_juillet_2013.pdf (this study is not available).”
","Yes","No","Charlie Martial NGOUNOU","yar michl","0"
"515fac51-b42a-4857-99f9-8817d7879264","global","2015-10-11T14:33:55","2015","tr","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://ekap.kik.gov.tr/EKAP/Ortak/KSP/KSPIhaleArama.aspx",,,,"Procurement Statistics","Public Procurement Authority","Yes","Yes",,"QA review - Data was not machine readable since it is in PDF.
License in this link https://ihale.gov.tr/sikca_sorulan_sorular-8-1.html is not sufficient.
There are several ways to access current and archived tenders. Here: https://ekap.kik.gov.tr/EKAP/Ortak/KSP/KSPIhaleArama.aspx and here: https://ekap.kik.gov.tr/EKAP/Ilan/BultenIndirme.aspx. None is truely available in bulk though. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Georg Neumann","45"
"212d4dac-cb79-48c7-b83d-f2462c156f37","global","2015-09-28T10:27:05","2015","bf","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","The data about pollutants emissions have been collected and managed by the Department of Sanitation and Prevention of Environmental Risks.
The data have been collected the first time in 2007 with the funding from the worldbank, the Belgium Development cooperation and EuropeAid and concern only the city of ouagadougou. The collection have been realised under the ""clean air initiative"" of the world bank.
Since 2007, an other data collection have not been realised yet, due to unavailability of funding.
The data is available in the study report that is available at the direction.
There is a project initiated by the Burkina Faso Open Data Initiative to use sensors on arduino, to collect pollutants emissions. This will lower the cost and make available real time data.","Yes","No","Idriss TINTO","yar michl","0"
"1ce840fe-6568-4741-9c24-8bdba0e4ccce","global","2015-09-26T10:57:20","2015","tj","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://zakupki.gov.tj/",,,,"E-procurement portal of the Agency was established in the second half of 2013 as part of the Program on e-procurement in the Tajikistan for 2013-2015 approved by the Decision of Government No.769 of December 29 2012.","Agency on State Procurement of goods, works and services under the Government of Tajikistan, https://zakupki.gov.tj/","Yes","Yes","Updated the submission indicating that while the data appears to be up-to-date, the data on awards and contracts is not available in machine readable format, in bulk or openly licensed. ","In comparison to 2014 registry of procurement that contained mostly tenders on gasoline, tenders in 2015 contain also pharmaceutical goods. All available data is in HTML format. Although the portal contains disclaimer on copyrights belonging to the Agency, it does not specify in details the rights of users.","Yes","No","Asomiddin Atoev","Georg Neumann","45"
"c1958017-6b37-4393-9d3f-00de686c1347","global","2015-09-21T01:58:43","2015","dm","spending","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.
The data seems to be non-existent given that it hasn't been published even in aggregated form since 2010 (5 years ago).","The Dominica government expenditure used to be collected and published in aggregated form via the auditor's report for each financial year.
However that data has not been updated since 2010 (see Audit of the Public Accounts on the [government website](https://www.dominica.gov.dm/resources)) and it therefore cannot be confirmed if the data exists or not. Therefore this will get marked as non-existing.
","Yes","No","Veronne Nicholas","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","0"
"86a9f7bf-e3da-479d-aed1-7a34bc700014","global","2014-11-27T06:07:43","2014","br","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://appweb.antt.gov.br/sgp/src.br.gov.antt/apresentacao/consultas/Transp.aspx",".asp database",,,,,"Yes","Yes","Data quality hasn't improved since 2013.","ANTT theoretically offers timetable data for interstatual bus lines. In order to access the data, users have to fill out a form and can only consult one connection at a time. In Brazil there is no significant public transport on a national level by train. The answers are related to bus transport. ","Yes","No","Daniela Mattern","Daniela Mattern","45"
"e97afc0c-f3e2-4fd9-800b-1d6a0603bc7c","global","2015-09-28T03:15:08","2015","bm","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is correct.
Fixed link to login page but even without login access, it seems to be correct that the data exists, if investigated via third party bermuda.io: https://bermuda.io/dataset/consolidated-fund-audited-financials","No transactional data is available.
Aggregated spending data is available at: https://www.gov.bm/portal/server.pt?open=512&objID=235&&PageID=352&mode=2 (Consolidated Fund audited financials) but requires login authentication.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"3107282c-4605-42ea-858d-a16bc6f868b0","global","2015-10-02T14:44:34","2015","bb","spending","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.
The government seems to have collected the information in the past and published in aggregated form but is two fiscal periods behind with no indication of collecting the data now.","In the past the government of Barbados seems to have collected the required information but the financial statements on the [government website](https://treasury.gov.bb/node/28) have not been updated since 2013.
It is therefore not possible to say if the data exists or not, but given that it's two fiscal periods behind this gets marked as non-existing.","Yes","No","anonymous","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","0"
"f5fffdda-d9f0-4759-a369-f6c178711ad1","global","2015-09-22T10:46:15","2015","bs","spending","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Ministry of Finance Treasury Department ","The Government of the Bahamas ","Yes","Yes","Fixed submission.
There are some budget documents on the budget website but they are not very detailed so it's hard to say if the transactional data is digital or not.","The data is hard to find at the [government's budget website](https://www.bahamas.gov.bs/wps/portal/public/National%20Budget/Budget%20Documents/!ut/p/b1/vZbZjqNGFIafpR-AcRU7l5jNYCj29QYZY2OzGWwMNk8fupVJMkqmOxczpiSkEufo1__V-UusklW0StrdeC52w_nS7ur3fUKnBFAMnidZQ6EADVTf0nmL2eAmpJaCeCkAP3l48Gn_Fl-Fq8iLcU68qYUiBcfOvpVFEHem3CPvfj2DM620E7a95euYHpFOYxpgboB7un5OR44aY512xso6by_7uCpsqVcx9gGKjrhZD6_G9qcxpDzumBzVx1M-OrMRD-wllY1DRxluIrlHMu5sQ6yI_JTllwxUfa-Y-zoW4v6UHdyMEc_DbSvAQY8PzeGUKLY9pyCi71jcTm9vf_r_xOCHf8U0bGH5zFq8BFTomciGOjTXxBf9JPh__D8R-KJfWyVFfcmWow6i-PIQC_Uk8UJaFGE9cA6eFvog14UlNbymm8pBJ5scuvbMP5KDv7O5AcnNNfKrYGIsJ7lfKbEHu4QQ9bujnDmnEzBaOEQm3W5msWwi_k5vpAN9Oa7PdyeQAi0SpStikcaPyUbOS8uufQW32Lpl00wmqJZ1_LdlRpJPbbxT-ij4bAy_GkS0uTSHVbyUMT_F6eArbxUBMnXLZ6fO1eyUYIKGqMxIDAGQAHCl2UF-rbu5jG6lo4EyJAwJ4MgftkaZqDfOs_LA8de8YOFd2n0lSLxYkAGvFqRfLfhqpOjXI11Ce86ab9O--Qa-4QSBQxbg1PKGJCBXQRkDZrlQJ4kPR_tq1PiO6Gix4d3YwOdq96C09KbZNPEAmurLa3vMpWsyiEUeREh7CgUcrkVXirGsijipGPLzHCFbNK7009ArCTqa25s6VwRisFafGMHxTINp_qXlRsruwtl0T0dNZL2UrvCmqfedlXCef0w4hkIEaq2Tv9kYV3N0Hm54wiItBQoWsQ90rrGg_Q7zr6B6AVhgAt5xoQ1YBP8DJnBFFaI5N6AXQkO6usivAOISZFTsDK7-ZEiD4Xrm7Ek3iFD0HaZzOBL_EjRxj1sEBUhvfQq4C8_fLKhQJrtcRYxn8RQOFBO-WpB4KVLFMsFvd_jD0JD2rz_DHxLIcjSkGJbkWBqQJMu8J5CmPhIoOakWQ_3WM53J28gB6AR6AcVkUUeEiu-PJ6bdOutAdsa83VWKs54yshWadqP4oK-vDejGMGAHI4GlerwobJxpW4fw1YfOgIIqmkuoknKRbibO2uz0mSnNUqLqPByC_dERx_vMYnkcaSbIm0bPEM12oy7GB662zvlkpADq_Z0Selw_yO1UIa3mssw2FCTjPh9WeR_lgLTInR098KlrTAVg0hZOG3759ekaf9xudWp0VUwZm78XC_-xprc_AOIn4xw!/dl4/d5/L2dBISEvZ0FBIS9nQSEh/#) but the [mid-year report for fiscal year 2014/2015](https://www.bahamas.gov.bs/wps/wcm/connect/7bd14810-5b94-493a-9465-b643776590e9/MYCapitalBlock20142015.pdf?MOD=AJPERES) indicates that the data exists but the level of aggregation does not indicate it to be digital (it's very likely but further proof is lacking).","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","5"
"212c1419-66f1-403e-ba7b-3e5d76e7d997","global","2015-09-19T19:06:35","2015","aw","spending","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.
There is no indication that the government has expenditure data for recent years.
","The Ministry of Finance, Communication, Utilities and Energy of Aruba provides yearly insight into the financial affairs of the country by making the actual and budgeted financial statements of each Ministry and department of Government available online for download in PDF format via the [Government of Aruba's website][1].
The latest publication provided was for the year 2011 and is accessible as [Jaarrekening Land Aruba 2011.pdf (Annual Country Statements Aruba 2011)][2].
However, this is is aggregated data, not transactional data, and obviously old. Given that the government does not seem to publish aggregated data for recent years, the transactional spending data must be marked as non-existing.
[1]: https://www.overheid.aw/actueel/rapporten-en-documenten_43353/
[2]: https://www.overheid.aw/document.php?m=5&fileid=9985&f=88221c8a745624f4fefbe493b23781f2&attachment=0&c=14297","Yes","No","Kimberly Soares","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","0"
"b5178132-74c0-4b2f-b33c-c09e3b1c0174","global","2015-09-18T18:13:46","2015","ag","spending","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission fixed.
IMF report is aggregated and as the report itself says, based on incomplete data.","IMF has published a report with aggregated government expenditure: https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/scr/2015/cr1527.pdf
However as the report states:
>""[A] significant share of extra-budgetary expenditures (other than donor funded projects) remains unreported""
Which indicates that detailed transactional expenditure data does not exists except for maybe a subset of the data (although the IMF still finds this comprehensive). Without anything but an IMF report we cannot claim that this data exists.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","0"
"0c3f7177-a712-40b2-90ba-5d09155be388","global","2015-09-25T11:57:34","2015","al","spending","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.financa.gov.al/al/raportime/thesari/pagesa-te-kryera-nga-drejtoria-e-pergjithshme-e-sherbimeve-financiare/pagesat-e-kryera-2015","Excel",,,"Treasury Transactions","Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","Submission is correct.
Congratulations Albania!","This data is updated every day.","Yes","No","Blerta Tuci","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","60"
"c8ed3162-cb30-4706-a5b9-58a3f3f51c4e","global","2015-09-28T05:41:29","2015","ph","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is correct.","There is a dataset on the Philippines open data portal https://data.gov.ph/catalogue/dataset/table-b-1-2010-budget-of-expenditures-and-sources-of-financing that shows aggregated data by type (in a non-machine friendly setup in a machine readable format).","Yes","No","anonymous","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"522cae61-23b1-464d-9b70-82f43fa9bbc8","global","2015-09-20T14:31:41","2015","id","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Belanja Pemerintah Indonesia berdasarkan Realisasi APBN","Bank Indonesia","Yes","Yes","Fixed submission.
Only aggregated data was available. Not transactional.","Transactional data is unfortunately not available but aggregated data exists at https://data.go.id/dataset/belanja-pemerintah-indonesia-berdasarkan-realisasi-apbn published under a [Creative Commons Attribution license](https://opendefinition.org/licenses/cc-by/)","Yes","No","Farraz Theda","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"68a8e11c-55eb-4770-9cb4-341cfc72143b","global","2015-09-16T08:59:49","2015","au","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.gov.au/dataset/austender-contract-notice-export","Excel","https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/au/",,"AusTender Contract Notice Export","Department of Finance","Yes","Yes","Submission is correct.","All metadata available from the dataset at https://data.gov.au/dataset/austender-contract-notice-export. This dataset lists the weekly contract notice updates but also links to historical contract data back to 1999.","Yes","Yes","Pia Waugh","Georg Neumann","100"
"41224948-0d01-45e8-a8d1-0c617f7e3d5a","global","2015-09-27T12:02:40","2015","tl","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.eprocurement.gov.tl/public/index","XML, XLS",,,"eProcurement Portal","Timor-Leste Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","The correct e-Procurement portal including tenders and awards seem to be this: https://www.mof.gov.tl/government-procurement/eprocurement-portal/?lang=en.
While the license is fairly open (https://www.eprocurement.gov.tl/publicPage/showPage/4) it is not open under our definition. ","There is a dedicated ministry that covers Procurement in Timor-Leste which is the Ministry of Finance https://www.mof.gov.tl/?lang=en. However, following the list of Current Tenders https://www.mof.gov.tl/category/current-tenders/?lang=en provided by the Ministry of Finance, the information does not meet the above criteria. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Georg Neumann","70"
"6e0d622c-4775-4c2f-b211-ec332aa48a2d","global","2015-09-21T18:32:04","2015","us","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://catalog.data.gov/dataset/federal-business-opportunities-data","XML","https://opendefinition.org/licenses/cc-zero/",,"Federal Business Opportunities Data - FedBizOpps is the single government point-of-entry for solicitations of any dollar amount and for required synopsis over $25,000, allowing commercial business suppliers and government buyers to post, search, monitor, and retrieve opportunities in federal government markets. FBO now includes the functionality of the Federal Technical Data Solutions (FedTeDS) which allows agencies to securely disseminate sensitive acquisition-related technical data for solicitations to approved business partners. This dataset contains current active notices and is updated weekly.","General Services Administration","Yes","Yes","Revised and confirmed.","In addition, here is the [link][1] to the GSA eLibrary that provides contract award / acquisition information. Here is the [link][2] to System of Award Management (SAM)’s public data access page that shows who is registered to do business with the federal government.
[1]: https://www.gsaelibrary.gsa.gov/ElibMain/home.do
[2]: https://www.sam.gov/portal/SAM/?portal:componentId=290e7118-9386-4239-a33d-8a3a1439207c&interactionstate=JBPNS_rO0ABXc0ABBfanNmQnJpZGdlVmlld0lkAAAAAQATL2pzZi9uYXZpZ2F0aW9uLmpzcAAHX19FT0ZfXw**&portal:type=action##11","Yes","Yes","anonymous","Georg Neumann","100"
"45ac6989-a490-4139-b1f4-2141f02385e4","global","2015-09-28T11:28:41","2015","no","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.doffin.no/",,,,"Norwegian national notification database for public procurement","www.difi.no","Yes","Yes","The entry has been updated from Unsure to No for machine readability, availability and license according to the Terms of Use published here: https://www.doffin.no/en/Home/BuyerTermOfUse#Opphavsrettmv
Also, the Doffin database does inclue information on the awards as well. ","Tenders are found at www.doffin.no, while awards are found at www.OEP.no.","Yes","No","Elianne Eggum","Georg Neumann","45"
"145a9674-4cbc-4e5c-bc2d-971d9406471a","global","2015-10-13T18:13:14","2015","ca","procurement","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://buyandsell.gc.ca/procurement-data/tenders/download-tenders-data","CSV, XML, JSON","https://open.canada.ca/en/open-government-licence-canada",,"Buyandsell.gc.ca","Public Works and Government Services Canada","Yes","Yes","I agree that the comments on the Tender Notice page don't impact the review. ","There are different data products available here - https://buyandsell.gc.ca/procurement-data/about-procurement-data
While they don't impact the status of this review, there are some public comments worth noting on the Tender Notices page in the open data portal: https://open.canada.ca/data/en/dataset/ffd38960-1853-4c19-ba26-e50bea2cb2d5
","Yes","Yes","Georg Neumann","Georg Neumann","100"
"96995d38-0385-4850-9e94-cf10163ac4dd","global","2015-09-20T00:34:33","2015","bo","timetables","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Bolivia doesn´t have a national system of public transport and open data.
link: https://sionet.oopp.gob.bo/Default.aspx?ReturnUrl=%2fSeguimiento%2ffrmDefault.aspx","In Bolivia transport is private and unionized, and there is no urban public transport company, except the Cable (Teleférico) and PumaKatari bus in La Paz. The long-distance transport (buses interdepartmental) and airlines are supervised by the Transport and Telecommunications Authority (ATT).","Yes","No","Mariana Leyton","Yamila García","0"
"8e5b5469-807e-4069-a516-8e48892c22fd","global","2015-09-28T01:26:50","2015","aw","health","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Marked NO, since the resource is not an official resource.","Th list of hospitals and health care institutions can be found at https://www.aruba.com/the-island/medical-facilities
Reviewer's notes- The link in the submission is not an official source. An official source was not found. ","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"432f496b-fb9f-451d-9ce8-aff43a82a447","global","2015-09-20T13:17:21","2015","ag","health","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","At the time of the review the ministry of health website was done. Data does not seems to exist. ",,"Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"65f46711-f937-4d32-be8e-076fc1a5ad10","global","2015-09-19T11:50:34","2015","ch","health","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://opendata.admin.ch/de/dataset/kennzahlen-der-schweizer-spitaler-2013","XLS, XLSX",,,"Key statistics of Swiss hospitals","Federal Office of Public Health","Yes","Yes","Added data for infectious diseases, changed license to no since on of the datasets is not openly licensed. ","Data is provided with 1-2 years delay. The same datasets are [first published](https://www.bag.admin.ch/hospital/index.html) on the Federal Office of Public Health website.
Reviewer's notes: Data for Infectious disease can be found in this link - https://www.bfs.admin.ch/bfs/portal/de/index/themen/14/02/01/key/05.html It is machine readable and in bulk, but it is not openly licensed or timely. Therefore, we marked NO to both datasets in the license question. ","Yes","No","Oleg Lavrovsky","Mor Rubinstein","60"
"149eb8e5-6a49-4d53-a615-fa52806ae2dd","global","2015-09-27T12:24:11","2015","tl","health","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I could not find data on health in Timor Leste. Data is seems correct. ","Maria do Céu Sarmento Pina da Costa is the current Ministry of Health in Timor-Leste https://www.moh.gov.tl/. However, there are no information found that meet the above criteria.","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"ef08c3c7-e44e-4cc6-8ea0-aed0bee6458b","global","2015-09-24T06:45:37","2015","sg","health","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure",,"Yes","https://www.moh.gov.sg/content/moh_web/home/statistics/infectiousDiseasesStatistics.html","xls",,,,,"Yes","Yes","Resubmitted because the data exist in the country. ","No official data on location of public hospitals and clinics. There are data on number of infectious diseases cases on Ministry of Health Infectious Diseases Bulletin: https://www.moh.gov.sg/content/moh_web/home/statistics/infectiousDiseasesStatistics/weekly_infectiousdiseasesbulletin.html
Reviewers note - The link above it the infectious disease report, and it is available in bulk, and machine readable format.
There is partial geo data in this link - https://hcidirectory.sg/hcidirectory/hospital.do
Unlike the disease dataset, it is not machine readable","Yes","No","Zhi Yuan Lim","Mor Rubinstein","60"
"8552c6a2-f1ba-4ca5-a56b-ae93e1452865","global","2015-09-21T02:14:31","2015","ph","health","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.maps.doh.gov.ph/",,,,"Philippine Health Atlas","Department of Health","Yes","Yes","Data does exist. Changed the submission accordingly to data is in Digital form, publicly available, free and online. ","The Health Facility map is publicly available but cannot be downloaded into a digital format for further analysis.
The FHSIS which shows all health-related indicators is always in PDF and reporting is delayed by 2 years.
https://nec.doh.gov.ph/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=59&Itemid=78
Reviewers comments:
Infectious disease reports can be found in this link - https://nec.doh.gov.ph/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=68&Itemid=92 they are up-to-date, but in PDF format and available by week, and not in bulk.
Health facilities locations can be found in this link -
https://www.maps.doh.gov.ph/ It is Google based map.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"df08b3cb-0c4c-42d5-adf5-2d191a599e40","global","2015-09-20T05:11:44","2015","au","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,"The Treasury","Yes","Yes","Submission is correct.
Added links to budget site and open data portal which is more comprehensive and understandable than the statistics data.","The Treasury does not publish Government Spending data as defined by this census.
Some government expenditure data is available at the [government's budget site](https://budget.gov.au/), [the government's open data portal](https://data.gov.au/dataset/budget-2014-15-tables-and-data), and [the national statistics website](https://www.abs.gov.au/AUSSTATS/abs@.nsf/ViewContent?readform&view=ProductsbyTopic&Action=Expand&Num=1.8.1) but only in aggregated form.","Yes","No","anonymous","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"ef517c63-ce44-411b-b646-aec476879dcf","global","2015-09-28T08:14:45","2015","mm","health","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I could not find any evidence as well for such official reports or location datasets on the web. Therefore, I approved the submission. ","No evidence showing from the President's Officer website that the data is exist. https://www.myanmarpresidentoffice.info/en/ and the dedicated webpage for the cabinet ministries is empty https://www.myanmarpresidentoffice.info/en/?q=cabinet/ministries so no way to find out who are the responsible minister involve. I have found a 3rd party website https://www.ourweb.info/01/directory/myanmar/005/ that provide a list of ministries official websites but some of these websites are not found.
Kindly note that there is a high possibility that Myanmar government did not update each of these ministries websites so there is an error while trying to gain access to these websites.","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"936da401-cd21-451f-a56a-ea4afeba7851","global","2015-09-19T11:19:55","2015","ch","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Harmonisierten Rechnungslegungsmodell der Kantone und Gemeinden (HRM2), a standardised accounting system of the Swiss cantons and communes","Federal Finance Administration","Yes","Yes","Submission is correct.","Annual spending data can be obtained ([English](https://www.efv.admin.ch/e/dokumentation/finanzberichterstattung/staatsrechnungen.php), [French](https://www.efv.admin.ch/f/dokumentation/finanzberichterstattung/staatsrechnungen.php), [German](https://www.efv.admin.ch/d/dokumentation/finanzberichterstattung/staatsrechnungen.php), [Italian](https://www.efv.admin.ch/i/dokumentation/finanzberichterstattung/staatsrechnungen.php)), but not at a transactional level. Detailed extracts of the yearly reports can also be [downloaded in machine-readable form](https://www.bfs.admin.ch/bfs/portal/de/index/themen/18/03/blank/key/ausgaben_nach_sachgruppen/bund.html) from the Swiss Federal Statistics Office.","Yes","No","Oleg Lavrovsky","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"22f266c6-81ba-477a-bf97-28c74cfc3bb0","global","2015-09-28T06:37:54","2015","kh","health","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","During the review the website was down again. Couldn't find the data from an official source through Google. I have therefore change the submission for Unsure to No. ","The list of ministries can be found from here https://www.cdc-crdb.gov.kh/cdc/other_link/ministry.htm
The Ministry of Health official website is suspended.
![enter image description here][1]
[1]: https://s24.postimg.org/jw08krrtx/Screen_Shot_2015_09_28_at_2_35_56_PM.png","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"e608146e-b828-4958-bd38-7abd3d92e0b9","global","2015-09-16T09:20:21","2015","au","health","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www9.health.gov.au/cda/source/cda-index.cfm",,,,"National Notifiable Diseases Surveillance System and the National Health Services Directory","Department of Health","Yes","Yes","Submission is correct. ","There are two datasets that meet this criteria. Both have the same responses to the questions above. The link provided above provides the data on infectious diseases rates in the country. The Location of public hospitals and clinics can be found through https://www.nhsd.com.au/ which is a government funded service using government and non-government data.","Yes","No","Pia Waugh","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"d3beea96-a51a-444e-9229-68d4aa216269","global","2015-09-27T19:33:07","2015","ec","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://app.sni.gob.ec/visorseguimiento/multimedia/seguimiento/portal/reportes/indexg.htm",,,,"Geographic information","National Secretary of Planning https://app.sni.gob.ec/visorseguimiento/multimedia/seguimiento/portal/reportes/indexg.htm","Yes","Yes","All survey questions seem appropiately answered, but the comment at the end belongs to the Transport category. Please kindly modify as needed.","Public transport services in Ecuador are privately managed. There are no national-level government operated public transport services. Trains are operated by the government, though these are used only for tourism services and not for public transportation. There are other city-level public transport services operated or commissioned by local governments, like Metrovía in Guayaquil and Trolebus in Quito. This question was answered considering privately operated national-level public transport services (interprovincial buses). Most timetables are available in printed form, and some bus companies have it published on their websites.","Yes","No","Julio Lopez","Paula Alzualde","35"
"9a9de438-a6b9-4af2-bddd-d6ed7ec59fbb","global","2015-09-29T16:38:57","2015","gb","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://geoportal.statistics.gov.uk/geoportal/catalog/main/home","CSV","https://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open-government-licence/version/3/",,,"Office for National Statistics ","Yes","Yes","OK!","Update: While you need to fill out a form in order to get access to the Ordnance Survey's Code-Point Open dataset, the Office for National Statistics publishes postcode data under an open licence publicly on the web.
Revision: you need to fill a form to get access to this dataset. Then you get a link by email.
Open postcode data which meets the specification here (postcodes and corresponding geospatial locations - lat/long or equivalent) is available via the Ordnance Survey's Code-Point Open dataset, which contains the 1.4m GB post codes each with a UK national grid reference of the postcode's location in eastings and northings (convertable to lat/long by published formulae) and with the administrative area (country/county/district/ward, plus National Health Service Region and Authority) in which it is located. This is updated quarterly. Similar Postcode data for the devolved province of Northern Ireland is *not* available as Open Data. The main UK *address* database (~24m individual addresses) is confusing called the Postcode Address File. This is a subscription-only database privately owned by the Royal Mail. The Open Data User Group have been pressing for its release too - see https://data.gov.uk/blog/dont-sell-our-postcodes-odug-on-why-we-should-have-open-addressing-in-the-uk
The Postcode data as of August 2014 is available here: https://geoportal.statistics.gov.uk/Docs/PostCodes/ONSPD_AUG_2014_csv.zip
The geographic coverage is United Kingdom (including Northern Ireland). More detailed information on the dataset can be found here: https://geoportal.statistics.gov.uk/geoportal/catalog/search/resource/details.page?uuid={473A5770-FB1B-4C1A-AEEC-5DC056E5EC7F}
Comment 2015: Didn't change from 2014. Link to products is here - https://www.ons.gov.uk/ons/guide-method/geography/products/postcode-directories/index.html","Yes","Yes","Mor Rubinstein","Codrina Maria Ilie","100"
"d0bd9342-ce0f-4c16-91c6-1cc1630ac1f5","global","2015-09-11T14:55:16","2015","my","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.myrapid.com.my/rail/train-frequency",,,,"https://www.myrapid.com.my/","Prasarana Malaysia Berhad","Yes","Yes","Timetable can be found online. Changed the submission accordingly. ","Even though Prasarana Malaysia Berhad is 100% government owned company which was set up by Ministry of Finance, the data cannot be accessed by the public. Freedom of Information request is not possible because the company is owned by the federal government. At present, in Malaysia, the Freedom of Information Act is available in 2 states in Peninsular Malaysia; Penang and Selangor.
Link: https://www.myrapid.com.my/
QA review - Train timetable can be found in HTML format in this link - https://www.myrapid.com.my/rail/train-frequency","Yes","No","Hazwany Jamaluddin","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"19329c97-ad27-47c6-b8b2-dc0e59afd6dc","global","2015-10-04T18:24:14","2015","tr","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.havaizleme.gov.tr/Default.ltr.aspx","Excel","https://www.havaizleme.gov.tr/Default.ltr.aspx",,"Ministry of Environment and Urban Planning","Ministry of Environment and Urban Planning - webadmin@csb.gov.tr","Yes","Yes","checked
","not seem to be VOCs measurement","Yes","Yes","Pinar Dag","yar michl","100"
"7dcf8173-2f90-45c6-9208-5963f8da018b","global","2015-09-10T06:01:46","2015","ma","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","Maroc Meteo (marocmeteo.m), has air quality measurements in this page (https://www.marocmeteo.ma/aircasa/public/), you can see the forecast for the current day, and two days ahead, and measurements for previous dates; all shown on a map and you need to hover to get the values (not machine readable). The following pollutants are being measured, PM10, Sulphur Dioxide, Nitrogen Dioxide, Ozone and IQA (Air Quality Index), which according to this (https://www.marocmeteo.ma/?q=fr/indice_atmo) includes the aforementioned pollutants. Volatile organic compounds (VOCs, e.g. Chemicals containing hydrogen (H), carbon (C) and possibly other elements, that evaporate easily, Organic Carbon and Aerosol) and Carbon monoxide (CO) are not measured/reported.
Previous year's comment below:
The agencies responsible for this data are The High Commissioner for Water, Forests and Desertification Control and the Ministry of Environment. No data exists at all. The rare details in reports are all non machine-readable (PDFs or static webpage with a chart as JPG or PNG). They do not appear to be up-to-date. Lastly, the reports are not openly licensed (instead, they are property of the institutions that publish them).","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","yar michl","0"
"17780d1b-3e8f-417c-81b8-030fe0ba02bb","global","2015-04-16T14:57:05","2015","tj","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is correct and verified. A further comment shell be added about this case.",,"Yes","No","Asomiddin Atoev","Daniel Dietrich","0"
"995345e0-7d9d-4963-ad17-51088c4469b9","global","2015-09-25T17:19:58","2015","de","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,"pdf",,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is correct.
I have removed names and direct messages to those individuals from the comments.","The granularity of the spending data is not satisfying:
https://www.bundesfinanzministerium.de/Web/DE/Themen/Oeffentliche_Finanzen/Bundeshaushalt/Haushalts_und_Vermoegensrechnungen_des_Bundes/haushalts_vermoegensrechnungen_des_bundes.html
No changes from 2013. No changes from 2014.","Yes","No","walter palmetshofer","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"7272b0ff-e256-46e2-8103-20bcac164d67","global","2015-09-21T15:15:35","2015","de","health","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","After a google search and research of the website of the Federal health ministry, I could not find the data. Therefore, I accepted the submission. ","**There is no health performance data** **incluiding geo location of public hospitals and health facilities with opening hours and infectious diseases rate, updated at least once a year.** Health Datasets of the statstical office temporarily available
https://www.gbe-bund.de/gbe10/hrecherche.prc_datenquellen?p_aid=67649880&p_uid=gast&p_sprache=D&p_knoten=STBA&tk=51310&tk2=51311&cnt_ut=1&ut=51311
The ' Robert Koch-Institut' (RKI) specifically the Aqua-Institut (works under the directive of the Ministry of Health) does evaluations of which some are available upon request at the institute.
https://www.healthdatanavigator.eu/germany/80-data-source/132-germany-data-source and via several unofficial searchengines i.e. https://www.weisse-liste.de/de/krankenhaus/krankenhaussuche/ or other insurance companies websites. **The data is existing as it is mandatory for individual hospitals to publish external quality audits.** In the future the newly founded (01/2015) 'Institut für Transparenz und Qualitätssicherung im Gesundheitswesen' will be responsible: https://www.iqtig.org/index According to the department for the health monitoring (Gesunheitsmonitoring) in the RKI the topic is currently given more and more priority.","Yes","No","Johanna zum Felde","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"9670b458-900a-4191-9394-fcc540a62811","global","2015-09-14T10:42:36","2015","at","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Budget 2014/2015 and/or Einnahmen-Ausgaben 2014 (2015 partly)","Ministry of Finance and Statistik Austria","Yes","Yes","Submission has been modified. Even if the statistics office provides expenditure data, it is not at a transactional level and therefore does not count. However this is a good addition in the comment section.","The Ministry of Finance releases monthly, regularly updated datasets on the implemented budget (XLS). These datasets contain the monthly aggregate spending of Ministries and other major State bodies of the federal level (EUR 100k). However, these break-downs do not show what these entities spend the money on, no itemized spending data is available. Thus, the level of detail required by this survey is not met.
https://service.bmf.gv.at/budget/akthh/2014/_start.htm
Also Statistik Austria (national statistical office) publishes income and expenses on a quarterly basis machine-readable in xls and html and pdf format, see: https://www.statistik.at/web_de/statistiken/wirtschaft/oeffentliche_finanzen_und_steuern/oeffentliche_finanzen/einnahmen_und_ausgaben_des_staates/index.html","Yes","No","Martin Kaltenböck","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"5dc8bc66-e1b0-4720-8f8d-2ca52ec9d8d2","global","2015-09-25T08:53:56","2015","za","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","This looks correct.
Comparing this to the results of IBP's Open Budget Survey: https://survey.internationalbudget.org and the publication of the enacted budgets in aggregated form on https://openbudgetlibrary.org - direct copy here: https://drive.google.com/a/okfn.org/file/d/0ByA9wmvBrAnZWlkxMGZTdnJ6T0U/view - this information (transactional expenditure) is collected but not published.","According to the Ministry of Finance: https://www.treasury.gov.za/ is collecting this data but it appears not to be accessible publically from an official source.","Yes","No","Greg Kempe","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"abd1b78e-584a-48fb-9e74-b2f27ec4ae99","global","2015-09-14T11:25:52","2015","at","health","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.spitalskompass.at/Spitaeler/Listenansicht",,,,"Österreichischer Spitalskompass","Gesundheit Österreich GmbH (GÖG)","Yes","Yes","Data is not up to date. Changed to not timely. The rest of the submission is correct and relevant. ","There is the Austrian Spitalskompass that offers up-to-dat information on all hospitals with very comprehensive detail informations BUT not as machine-readable data and not under an open license. Publisher is the GÖG: Gesundheit Österreich GmbH.
Regarding statistics on diseases Statistic Austria provides some good datasets (BUT NO open license): https://www.statistik.at/web_de/statistiken/menschen_und_gesellschaft/gesundheit/gesundheitszustand/chronische_krankheiten/index.html","Yes","No","Martin Kaltenböck","Mor Rubinstein","35"
"cc63f21e-bcb6-40ee-a7eb-b0ac53e41081","global","2015-09-25T12:50:27","2015","za","health","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Yes","No",,"Unsure",,"Excel",,,,"Department of Health","Yes","Yes","Could not find this information on the ministry of health website. Submission is correct. ","The Department of Health has full information on all public health facilities. It is not clear if this includes infectious diseases. The data has been accessed through a PAIA (FOIA) request and is not made publicly available.","Yes","No","Greg Kempe","Mor Rubinstein","25"
"3ff3a1f9-ecae-4f7b-8308-e9abe85bc5e4","global","2015-09-25T06:53:11","2015","jp","health","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.mhlw.go.jp/bunya/kenkou/kekkaku-kansenshou15/02.html","shapefiles, CSV",,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is correct. Data available in bulk only for geographical data. ","Location data of Public Health facilities is available from Kokudo-Suuchi-Joho, MLIT.
* https://nlftp.mlit.go.jp/ksj/gml/datalist/KsjTmplt-P02-v4_0.html
* https://nlftp.mlit.go.jp/ksj/gml/codelist/PubFacMiclassCd.html (Code 1700* are hospital and other health facilities.)
""Infectious Diseases Weekly Report"" is downloadable at webpage of Infectious Disease Surveillance Center.
* https://www.mhlw.go.jp/bunya/kenkou/kekkaku-kansenshou15/02.html
Also available from National Institute of Infectious Diseases
* https://www.nih.go.jp/niid/en/survaillance-data-table-english.html
All the data is not Open.","Yes","No","Satoshi IIDA","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"c92cc002-1ec2-4988-9197-bd31f927b369","global","2015-09-12T23:48:58","2015","jp","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","This looks correct.
It is worth mentioning the great work done at https://spending.jp/ which is based on aggregated spending data published by municipalities.","Annual aggregated expenditure data on specific items (financial statistics) is available from Ministry of Finance.
* https://www.mof.go.jp/budget/budger_workflow/account/fy2014/index.html
* Balance (Monthly): https://www.mof.go.jp/budget/report/revenue_and_expenditure/index.htm
* Stat of expenditure (Quarterly): https://www.mof.go.jp/budget/report/budget_use/index.htm
The phrase: *""3) Prohibited use""* makes the data non-open.","Yes","No","Satoshi IIDA","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","10"
"4e9e8399-fcd2-4fb9-a8a2-acd4ecadd27c","global","2015-09-24T17:08:20","2015","dk","water","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://data.geus.dk/geusmap/?mapname=grundvand#zoom=1.9792993958313527&lat=6263000&lon=691500&visiblelayers=Topografisk&filter=&layers=&mapname=grundvand&filter=&epsg=25832&mode=map&map_imagetype=png&wkt=","PC Jupiter / PC Jupiter XL",,,"Tjek din vandkvalitet","GEUS - De Nationale Geologiske Undersøgelser for Danmark og Grønland","Yes","Yes","Denmark gets most of its drinking water from groundwater so this data is valid for multiple purposes. They don't seem to be testing for fecal coliform, they might not have to but might be using a different test or testing it at a different stage not sure.
However, the data is there and available. ","The data is released as ""publicly available and free"", but there is no license specified. The data is accessible in three ways: Via an interactive map, via search engine and via Google Earth - as well as in bulk download.","Yes","No","Christian Villum","Nisha Thompson","60"
"ba75db32-e60a-4b1a-bf1a-b9bd7d6e7639","global","2015-09-08T08:20:37","2015","cz","water","Yes","Yes","No","No","Unsure","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Systém monitorování zdravotního stavu obyvatelstva ČR ve vztahu k životnímu prostředí","The National Institute of Public Health (NIPH)","Yes","Yes","They do collect water quality data, while there is no TDS, they are following standards this is acceptable. However, data is not available in a timely manner and only in an aggregated report format.","The National Institute of Public Health publishes a report every year, it's a quite thorough one, but in pdf only. However, there is no information about TDS (all the other chemicals are monitored), therefore I'm marking this dataset as non-existing","Yes","No","Michaela Rybičková","Nisha Thompson","10"
"222d5687-31fa-482f-8e47-c42f60c66182","global","2015-09-16T23:28:51","2015","au","water","Yes","Unsure","Yes","Unsure","Yes","Unsure","Unsure",,"Yes",,,,,"Drinking water quality indicators","Each individual water authority around the country","Yes","Yes","Publish","It appears that there is no national aggregation of this data, except at a high level (https://www.nwc.gov.au/nwi/biennial-assessments), but individual water authorities around the country, of which there are many, publish water quality data in their annual reports. There are national guidelines and requirements that all water authorities publish data on drinking water quality, however all this data with very few exceptions was only available in PDF reports, and nowhere centrally discoverable. Some examples below:
Overall report with some indicators at https://www.nwc.gov.au/publications/topic/nprs/npr-2013-urban
Sydney - https://www.sydneywater.com.au/SW/water-the-environment/how-we-manage-sydney-s-water/waterquality/our-monitoring-program/index.htm
NSW - https://www.health.nsw.gov.au/environment/water/Pages/Drinking-Water-Quality-and-Incidents.aspx
NT - https://www.health.nt.gov.au/Environmental_Health/Water_Quality/
SA - could only find https://www.pay.sawater.sa.gov.au/NR/rdonlyres/A9EDDE34-3A8E-40EA-9914-64441C7721AE/0/DrinkingWaterQualityReport201314.pdf","Yes","No","Pia Waugh","Nisha Thompson","35"
"80136d1a-6f0c-4664-8794-642062e2fd1d","global","2015-09-18T22:25:27","2015","is","water","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Water quality is collected locally","Local municipalities","Yes","Yes","Searched national and local sites couldn't find any water quality data, language was also an issue. ","There is several reports listing water quality issues in Iceland and a gov presentation stating they collect it:
https://www.unece.org/fileadmin/DAM/env/documents/2012/wat/workshops/Nordic_Baltic_Seminar_Oslo/7.Iceland_-_Presentation_Water_and_saniation.pdf
However it seems it is a local responsibility and the data is not public.","Yes","No","Páll Hilmarsson","Nisha Thompson","5"
"30397ebe-2ace-4f49-bc4f-0ce528cefc31","global","2015-09-01T14:39:30","2015","kr","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://info.nec.go.kr/",,,,"Election Statistics System - Statisctics of previous presidential, congressional, and various local elections","National Election Commission","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The [Election Statistics System][1] of the National Election Commission in the Republic of Korea provides data on the Web regarding statistical results of presidential, congressional, and various local elections. However, the dataset is not downloadable, and there is no way to access the data programatically. Even though there is one WebAPI only for accessing real-time results during the election, it cannot be utilized without the appropriate permission.
All the data in the system are copyrighted and cannot be published or used for profit purposes.
[1]: https://info.nec.go.kr/","Yes","No","James G. Boram Kim","Kamil Gregor","45"
"fa999e16-05f8-4779-a8e0-0549104ba82f","global","2015-09-14T19:19:42","2015","il","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.votes20.gov.il/nationalresults","XLS, HTML",,,,"The 19th Knesset Central Elections Committee","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","No explicit license is indicated, thus data is considered non-open. ","Yes","No","Adam Kariv","Kamil Gregor","70"
"67934bad-0781-40a5-852f-8117d661f0dc","global","2015-09-20T20:33:16","2015","es","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.infoelectoral.interior.es/min/areaDescarga.html?method=inicio","Excel","https://www.interior.gob.es/web/interior/aviso-legal",,"Consulta de resultados electorales","Ministerio del Interior","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The dataset matches all the evaluation criteria. Bulk download of all information can only be requested by email (see footer of website). The terms and conditions refers to the 37/2007 law which could be considered an open license.","Yes","Yes","José Félix Ontañón","Kamil Gregor","90"
"ae003e04-f240-41cf-a4c3-9f2de6a2fb9b","global","2015-10-01T21:49:15","2015","it","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://elezioni.interno.it/opendata.html","CSV","https://www.agid.gov.it/sites/default/files/linee_guida/patrimoniopubblicolg2014_v0.7finale.pdf",,,"Ministero dell'Interno","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","National election results are available as open data through the portal Eligendo. Following the amendments to the Code of eGovernment in Italy, where there is no any information about the license of one of the public service, the content is released into the open data.
The default license is CC-by 4.0 (this is defined in the National Guidelines released by Agid - The Digital Agency of Italy)","Yes","Yes","Francesca De Chiara","Kamil Gregor","100"
"8b8b5e8d-a477-44cf-bba0-1e16707a24ed","global","2015-09-12T13:35:34","2015","dz","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The Ministry of Interior publishes the elections results. You can see the results for the most recent presidential elections here (https://www.interieur.gov.dz/Dynamics/frmItem.aspx?html=140&s=23). The results is only in totals, no results per district or polling stations.
For the parliamentary elections, no results were found when we checked here, https://www.interieur.gov.dz/Dynamics/frmCategories.aspx?htmls=13&s=23","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Kamil Gregor","0"
"a00efe76-3e37-498c-ae90-1660875685a9","global","2015-09-28T17:05:32","2015","gb","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.electoralcommission.org.uk/our-work/our-research/electoral-data","CSV, EXCEL","https://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open-government-licence/version/2/",,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission does not meet the definition. There is no detailed data below the constituency level (up to a 100.000 people).","The UK's Electoral Commission publishes an authoritative collection of electoral results (including general elections, local council elections and EU Parliament elections). The results are collected from local returning officers by a third party on behalf of the Electoral Commission. The Electoral Commission makes the bulk data available for download in CSV and Excel spreadsheet formats. In October 2013 the Electoral Commission updated the terms on its website to make it clear that the electoral data was re-usable under the Open Government Licence. Data is provided timely.
The data was last updated in May 2015 with results of the latest national elections. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Kamil Gregor","0"
"ec82b0f8-7adb-4b29-a4ee-a2cb52b7dc21","global","2015-09-27T23:13:47","2015","bw","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.iec.gov.bw/index.php/election-results",,,,"General Elections 2014 Parliamentary Results","www.iec.gov.bw","Yes","Yes","The submission does not meet the criteria. They only published results at the level of constituencies of up to 20.000 people. The same webpage contains seemingly more granular data, but these are from the local elections that took place at the same time as the national one.","Reviewers comments: Submission seems correct, have made only a single change: Noted 'machine readable' as 'No' instead of 'Unsure' since release format is pdf.","Yes","No","danny wilson","Kamil Gregor","55"
"2dfa3608-cf26-451f-87e8-efaec3306a9a","global","2015-09-24T10:22:20","2015","mk","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://rezultati.sec.mk/Parliamentary/Results?cs=en-US&r=2&rd=r&eu=All&m=All",,,,"Parliamentary and Presidential elections Results","State Election Commission","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The State Election Commission provides the data: https://rezultati.sec.mk/
Data is online available for 2014.
Interactive graphics are provided but data is in html and download options do not exist.","Yes","No","Metamorphosis Foundation","Kamil Gregor","45"
"c9421f8d-84b5-4521-90d8-4e83b453c76b","global","2015-09-28T20:37:25","2015","sv","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.tse.gob.sv/resultados2015/",,,,"Resultados de los escrutinios finales","Tribunal Supremo Electoral","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The information on Election results is available trough a HTML tables and graphs for 2012 and 2015. Not a download option has being found. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","45"
"fae5aad8-d40e-4c74-afd6-95252486fdb0","global","2015-09-25T10:18:04","2015","kz","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://election.kz/portal/page?_pageid=73,1584918&_dad=portal&_schema=PORTAL",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission does not meet the definition. Results are aggregated for up to 750.000 voters in the country's regions.","CEC is a public official. The information provided by government officials in Kazakhstan (by default) is open for reuse, publishing as cited by the law. ","Yes","No","Nazerke Akhmetzhanova","Kamil Gregor","0"
"2248ac3b-8817-4950-b94f-5c31e7b5434e","global","2015-09-20T22:19:03","2015","pt","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://eleicoes.cne.pt/","Excel, HTML, PDF",,,,,"Yes","Yes","The sumbission does not meet the definition. Results are aggregated for up to a million voters in the country's regions.","The main URL from CNE does not have the most recent elections. Those can be found at the [Ministry of Internal Affairs][1] website, which unlike CNE does not provide bulk datasets.
There are many bulk datasets missing from the CNE site as well. The results are insufficiently granular, with most featuring only general results at the national level.
[1]: https://www.eleicoes.mai.gov.pt","Yes","No","Ricardo Lafuente","Kamil Gregor","0"
"2621e4a7-ae3a-4a19-9104-aae7135c69f4","global","2015-09-21T10:32:37","2015","im","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.gov.im/categories/home-and-neighbourhood/electoral-register/election-information/election-results/","PDF","https://www.gov.im/about-this-site/open-government-licence/",,"Election Results","Office of the Chief Secretary","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","independent https://iomelections.com/ maintained by a techy at a local data hosting company","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","75"
"462e1fc6-c768-4ee6-b903-eb08fcd14bce","global","2015-09-12T15:08:41","2015","ly","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://hnec.ly/",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","In this page (https://results.hnec.ly/cor/) you can find results for parliamentary elections, though date (e.g. https://results.hnec.ly/cor/ballot/2/6) doesn't comply with aforementioned criterion, such as the presence of invalid votes and number of registered voters.
Last year's comment below:
The most recent elections in Libya were held in July 2012. At that time, results were made available shortly after voting ended. However, the website of the national authority for elections, the High National Election Commission, does not contain any information whatsoever about reports and statistics from these last elections. ","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Kamil Gregor","0"
"632cbc3f-7902-4068-ab2c-850288839af4","global","2015-09-28T06:56:17","2015","id","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://mediacenter.kpu.go.id/hasil-pemilu-2009.html","PDF",,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission is probably not legitimate. The link at the Data Location does not work, at least right now. I found data on the 2014 elections, but just province totals (millions of votes aggregated) that do not meet the definition.","The data only covers the last election (2009) with no detailed records on other election results further in the past.
Data did not change until 2015.","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","0"
"6271a7bb-a3ba-4493-907c-e67a989a2884","global","2015-09-20T22:38:20","2015","pt","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://qualar.apambiente.pt/index.php?page=1","XLS",,,"European Pollutant Release and Transfer Register","European Commission","Yes","Yes","checked
","all Pollutant are measured
data can be download with web interface in xls format
VOCs = C6H6(Benzene)","Yes","No","Ricardo Lafuente","yar michl","70"
"ad1add0e-95ce-4d1e-a99a-72c659bfadd7","global","2015-09-28T04:25:11","2015","bm","emissions","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Unsure","No",,"Unsure",,,,,"Air Quality Program","Bermuda Institute of Ocean Sciences","Yes","Yes","checked","Funded by the Government of Bermuda's Department of Environmental Protection, the Air Quality Program undertakes routine measurements at sites around the island (BIOS, Fort Prospect, East Broadway, and BELCO) to quantify the presence of various pollutants, including:
Airborne particulate matter (TSP, PM10, and PM2.5);
Toxic gases (SO2 and NOx);
Rain and aerosol chemistry (major ions, conductivity, and pH);
Meteorological data (e.g., wind speed and direction)
https://www.bios.edu/research/projects/air-quality-program/
The data are, however, not publicly available.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","yar michl","10"
"3b5808fa-249a-41ff-89aa-d7b42459c66d","global","2015-09-09T06:56:08","2015","kr","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.airkorea.or.kr/index","XML",,,".airkorea","South Air Korea Environment Corporation","Yes","Yes","checked
is xml to be considered bulk donwnload?","The Ministry Of Environment (MOE) of Korea, Republic of has released the air quailty level of 16 areas nearby the World Cup Stadium on a real-time basis since April, 2002. The general public have gained access to the urban air pollution data on the website since December, 2005. The data is available on the Web site called [Air Korea][1], but data about VOCs is not publicly available. The real-time data about pollutants SO2, CO, O3, NO2, PM10 can be freely accessed on the site, but to read it in a machine-readable format, you need to use the [Web API][2] after the registration. The dataset is licensed under the KOGL Type 2, which is similar to CC-BY-ND, so it's not openly licensed.
[1]: https://www.airkorea.or.kr/
[2]: https://www.data.go.kr/subMain.jsp#/L3B1YnIvdXNlL3ByaS9Jcm9zT3BlbkFwaURldGFpbC9vcGVuQXBpTGlzdFBhZ2UkQF4wMTJtMTMkQF5wdWJsaWNEYXRhUGs9MTUwMDA1ODEkQF5icm1DZD1PQzAwMTIkQF5yZXF1ZXN0Q291bnQ9OTYyJEBeb3JnSW5kZXg9T1BFTkFQSQ==","Yes","No","James G. Boram Kim","yar michl","60"
"e30cd829-9931-4a39-866f-afe770050a77","global","2015-10-09T16:01:23","2015","nl","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.luchtmeetnet.nl/",,,,"Validated data is made available monthly as an Excel download. Real-time data only via online interface.","National Institute for Public Health and the Environment (RIVM)","Yes","Yes","checked ","Data is made available as monthly Excel downloads on SO2, PM10, PM2.5, NH3, CO, O3, NO, NO2, ZWR and BC also toluene and benzene that are VOCs .
data is also existent in this site https://www.lml.rivm.nl/
https://www.lml.rivm.nl/
License not clear.","Yes","No","Sander van der Waal","yar michl","55"
"03b7a8a9-d3f2-4505-87af-735199910bc3","global","2015-09-22T16:04:58","2015","ru","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.izbirkom.ru/region/izbirkom","HTML",,,"Russian election results","Central Election Commission of Russia (Центральная избирательная комиссия Российской Федерации)","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Brief description:
Actually Russian level of electoral data openness is quite high. Since we have unified federal information system for registration of elections results so all results collected and available via website https://www.izbirkom.ru/region/izbirkom It allows to select specific election and to view results with details up to election district.
At the same time a few issues exists:
1. No machine readable data
2. No bulk download
3. No open licenses
4. No geodata for election comissions and electoral districs locations Step by step explanation: 1. Does the data exist? Yes, data exists here - https://www.izbirkom.ru/region/izbirkom 2. Is data in digital form? Yes, data available via website ahttps://www.izbirkom.ru/region/izbirkom and has digital form. 3. Publicly available? Yes, this data is publicly available. We don't need FOI request to get it. 4. Is the data available for free? Yes, this data is available for free. No payment is required. 5. Is the data available online? Yes. Data available at https://www.izbirkom.ru/region/izbirkom 6. Is the data machine readable? No, data is not machine readable, only HTML. 7. Available in bulk? No, only HTML form of data available 8. Openly licensed? No, this data is public domain data but no open license available. 9. Is the data provided on a timely and up to date basis?
Yes, this information updated frequently, on daily basis.
Comment: Nothing changed since 2014","Yes","No","Ivan Begtin","Kamil Gregor","45"
"811bab72-cf38-4cfe-abcc-e47aee275413","global","2015-08-31T14:16:27","2015","jo","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.entikhabat.jo",,,,,"Independent Election Committee","Yes","Yes","The data is updated timely. The most recent data is avaliable and seems to have been posted soon after the election.","The data is published on independent election committee website. The data about parliament elections. The format of is PDF embodied in website farm. The last was from 2013.
","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Kamil Gregor","45"
"ef882821-0f0d-4ce6-a618-8a103469a4ca","global","2015-09-17T09:12:15","2015","cz","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://volby.cz/opendata/opendata.htm","xml","https://www.czso.cz/csu/redakce.nsf/i/podminky_pro_vyuzivani_a_dalsi_zverejnovani_statistickych_udaju_csu",,,"Czech Statistical Office","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct."," Data is available for various election - nationwide, municipial, local etc.","Yes","Yes","Michaela Rybičková","Kamil Gregor","100"
"a5a408d9-e3cf-41a1-bb50-d46f38dc7b58","global","2015-09-15T09:05:41","2015","lb","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.elections.gov.lb/",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Election results data can be obtained from the [official elections website][1] managed by the Ministry of Interior and Municipalities. The data is available in PDF format.
There is also data available from an unofficial source (Lebanese Association for Democratic Elections) because of FOIA. The data can be accessed on [Github][2].
[1]: https://www.elections.gov.lb/
[2]: https://github.com/ladeleb/platform/releases/tag/v2.0","Yes","No","Chafic Najjar","Kamil Gregor","45"
"09c2bc15-f0ba-4091-a419-dff5f847262b","global","2015-09-30T13:19:27","2015","ng","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.inecnigeria.org/?page_id=31",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission does not meet the definition at all. The source data is just country-wide totals. No detailed stats below state level (millions of votes aggregated) seem to exist.","The data on INEC official website is in an HTML format. There is a direct link to the data page now but the data is not available in bulk for previous elections.
No Changes in 2015","Yes","No","Oludotun Babayemi","Kamil Gregor","0"
"3787dda3-4cae-4168-b289-811714e200cc","global","2015-09-17T11:45:14","2015","be","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.elections.fgov.be/index.php?id=3265&L=1","XLSX",,,"Naamstemmen per lijst en per kanton / Votes nominatifs par liste et par canton / Preference votes per list and per canton, divided for every electoral district. ","Federal Public Services Home Affairs - Directory of the elections","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Up-to-date XLSX files of the European, federal and regional results for the elections of 2014. No license to be found, so not sure if openly licensed or available. The website https://polling2014.belgium.be/en/index.html contains all the info in tables, the one mentioned above has als the xlsx files that can even be downloaded in one zip file, so bulk applies.","Yes","No","Pieter-Jan Pauwels","Kamil Gregor","70"
"a348bafc-f4bb-4e88-8d80-b5a05b3fc73d","global","2015-10-02T05:27:07","2015","ml","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Unsure","Unsure",,"Yes",,,,,"Results of the 2013 presidential election","Constitutional Court","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The National and Independent Commission for Elections (CENI) of Mali is responsible for the organisation of elections and does not have any website. The Constitutional Court is responsible for the legality and publication of the results but its website (https://www.cc.insti.ml/) does not work and there is no evidence the results have been published online.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","40"
"af05ee5c-fb11-4247-a893-eb678ce5e9a0","global","2015-09-24T19:34:38","2015","vc","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.caribbeanelections.com/vc/results/default.asp",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","No relevant official data exists. The data is sourced from a media website owned and operated by a private company.","The data was dated from 2010. Elections will be done this year 2015 but not until a further date after this submission.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Kamil Gregor","0"
"564ce9a9-050a-4d1b-9d17-bd448cd0477e","global","2015-09-27T15:28:05","2015","lc","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.electoral.gov.lc/past-results/2011-election-results","HTML",,,"2011 Election Results","Saint Lucia Electoral Portal","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The last general elections was dated in the year 2011","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Kamil Gregor","45"
"63543e77-a484-4678-9ed6-5544e04be698","global","2015-09-26T21:04:48","2015","kn","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.caribbeanelections.com/blog/?p=4598",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","No relevant official data exists. The data is sourced from a media website owned and operated by a private company.","very limited content on government website
latest and archive election results on the Inter Parliamentary Union website and third party regional and local websites:
https://www.ipu.org/parline/reports/2267_E.htm
https://www.ipu.org/parline/reports/2267_arc.htm
https://www.sknvibes.com/politics/elections_results_new.cfm
The general elections was dated from February 16, 2015.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Kamil Gregor","0"
"a6671881-8a37-4098-92a2-0e32b6b8b403","global","2015-09-27T15:19:27","2015","jm","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.eoj.com.jm/content-183-179.htm",,,,"Parliamentary Elections","Electoral Commission of Jamaica","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Data on parliamentary election results is available in detail as a PDF and in summary as PDF and HTML. Elections are dated from 2011. The new elections will be in the year 2016.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Kamil Gregor","55"
"2f1b8430-77c8-4826-a438-4f37d9b7bfe8","global","2015-09-28T03:20:31","2015","bm","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.elections.gov.bm/results.html",,,,,"Parliamentary Registry ","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The current website contains the results of all general elections since 1963. However, many by-elections and municipal elections are missing.
The website also contains downloadable maps of the current constituency boundaries.
The last general elections was in the year 2012.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Kamil Gregor","45"
"1691fa69-3a23-4ea0-a264-aaa3517a4456","global","2015-09-22T21:27:48","2015","bs","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.bahamaslocal.com/bahamaselections",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The Data Location is not an official website. However, the Organization of American States publishes reports - by request of the Government of The Bahamas - containing the results at the same level of detail. Last election's report: https://www.oas.org/es/sap/deco/MOE_informe/Bahamas2012.pdf","The information is linked to a third party website and data was for the year 2012. ","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Kamil Gregor","0"
"5aa390ff-45c7-4dea-b2e7-6e692a7e02b6","global","2015-09-19T20:36:12","2015","aw","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.overheid.aw/bestuur-organisatie/verkiezingen_41139/",,,,"Elections (Verkiezingen)","The Government of Aruba (Gobierno di Aruba)","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The results of elections in Aruba are available in a tabular format on the Government of Aruba's website for the years 2013, 2009 and 2005.","Yes","No","Kimberly Soares","Kamil Gregor","55"
"6c80004d-6ee8-4859-8f7d-00bac472f692","global","2015-09-25T12:07:07","2015","al","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes"," https://results.cec.org.al/Results/LocalMayor?cs=sq-AL&r=r&rd=r1 ",,,,"Election Results","Central Electoral Commission","Yes","Yes","The Data Location only contains the results of the current election, so it does not work as a source. The actual results at the polling station level are published at cec.org.al/sq-al/elections in a few hundred Excel sheets.","They were public during the election process, but now they've been removed.","Yes","No","Blerta Tuci","Kamil Gregor","45"
"96d959f6-9321-4e18-89f0-fe43a196f33b","global","2015-09-27T10:46:10","2015","tl","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","There are no election results found from the official website Government of Timor-Leste. There is only a brief introductory about Timor-Leste political system https://timor-leste.gov.tl/?p=33&lang=en","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","0"
"c575a8e9-bb76-4561-a225-fb51ec9d6bc8","global","2015-09-24T06:01:12","2015","sg","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.eld.gov.sg/elections_past_results.html","HTML",,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission absolutely does not meet the definition. The ""data"" is just country totals - who won with how many votes.","Results for presidential and parliamentary elections. However data is just in form of tables in HTML (with not especially good structuring). As such marking machine-readable and bulk as No.
Not openly licensed as terms of use page (https://www.eld.gov.sg/terms.html) has non-commercial restriction: ""Materials, including source code, pages, documents and online graphics, audio and video in The Website are protected by law. The intellectual property rights in the materials is owned by or licensed to the Government of the Republic of Singapore. All our rights are reserved. You may download, display, print and reproduce The Website’s information or material in unaltered form only for your personal, non-commercial use or use within your organization. (Please ensure that this is your intention.) You are, however, not permitted to re-transmit, distribute or commercialise the information or material without seeking prior written approval from the Government of the Republic of Singapore. You are not permitted to use The Website to sell a product or service or to increase traffic to your website. ""
*Data didn't change*","Yes","No","Zhi Yuan Lim","Kamil Gregor","0"
"0a69cc7d-16d7-4a62-86d3-1de70a8164b8","global","2015-09-28T05:50:59","2015","ph","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission does not meeth the definition. The link in Comments leads to official results, but these are just regional totals, not polling level or any other low level data.","The election results can be found from https://www.comelec.gov.ph/?r=References/Results and its outdated.","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","0"
"6f5a49d9-f906-4ac2-a51f-efae1c9ad1c7","global","2015-09-28T06:04:55","2015","kh","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://necelect.org.kh/nec_khmer/",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The data does exist. The data is available at the Khmer language version of the official website ( https://necelect.org.kh/nec_khmer/ ), not the English one. At bit.ly/1Lbaa5T there are results on the polling station level, in large PDFs.","Data not found from The National Election Committee (NEC) website https://necelect.org.kh/nec_english/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=218&Itemid=250","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","35"
"45f6df4c-8e4a-4217-aaff-514748722483","global","2015-09-19T11:21:45","2015","ch","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://opendata.admin.ch/de/dataset?groups=politik&tags=abstimmungen","ODS, CSV",,,"Open datasets on election results from all levels of government","Swiss Federal Statistical Office","Yes","Yes","The submission does not meet the definition. A whole bunch of confusing stats at the Data Location, but for the Federal Assembly, there is no low-level data (polling station or at least municipality). Just Canton or district totals.","Information can be used for non-commercial purposes with attribution, as per [Liability and copyright][1].
[1]: https://www.bfs.admin.ch/bfs/portal/en/index/dienstleistungen/premiere_visite/02/02_03/copy.html","Yes","No","Oleg Lavrovsky","Kamil Gregor","70"
"6b7b2f48-e509-446d-8c24-441b01c3564f","global","2015-09-21T12:29:30","2015","de","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.govdata.de/suchen/-/details/de-bundestagswahl-2013","csv","https://www.govdata.de/suchen/-/details/de-bundestagswahl-2013",,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission does not meet the definiition. The 2013 results at the Data Location are available only at the level of very large municipalities (over 100.000 people each) and all the other data there is nowhere close to polling station level results.","Original source and results for past years at https://www.bundeswahlleiter.de
Data published on govdata.de with 'Freie Nutzung' terms of use but no real license listed.","Yes","No","walter palmetshofer","Kamil Gregor","0"
"8e994c1f-f90f-441c-80f3-be72c202f133","global","2015-09-10T14:51:15","2015","at","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.data.gv.at/nrw2013","CSV","https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/at/deed.de",,"Results of the parliamentary election 2013","Federal Ministry of Interior (BMI)","Yes","Yes","The data is broken down to the municipality level, not to the district level as the submission says.","The Ministry of Interior releases federal election data broken down to district level. The data is published on the government's open data portal, https://data.gv.at under a Creative Commons license (CC-BY).
The dataset for the 2013 parliamentary elections is available as a CSV file, https://www.data.gv.at/datensatz/?id=09716341-2bea-4298-9525-e936d8247d19.
The Austrian results of the 2014 elections of the European Parliament are available in XLSX, CSV and HTML format, https://www.data.gv.at/datensatz/?id=2b10a91b-51d5-4e34-b992-8fd3a3121f0d.
Precinct-level election data is only released by the City of Vienna and not available in the other eight regions of Austria. ","Yes","Yes","Martin Kaltenböck","Kamil Gregor","100"
"3664328c-0083-4137-87f3-086c441c8636","global","2015-09-25T07:13:07","2015","za","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.elections.org.za/content/Elections/Results/2014-National-and-Provincial-Elections--National-results/","xls",,,,"Independent Electoral Commission","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","In my experience, the electoral commission is one of the few South Africa entities that make such datasets so easily available for public use (and providing information that is machine readable). The standard licence is restrictive, only allowing for personal use.","Yes","No","Greg Kempe","Kamil Gregor","70"
"4185070d-0054-4df9-abbf-0ead05c8e2b9","global","2015-09-12T23:52:13","2015","jp","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.soumu.go.jp/senkyo/senkyo_s/data/shugiin46/index.html","Excel",,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission does not fit the definition, as far as I can tell. The English version of the website did not display the data, but even using Translate, I am pretty sure that this is prefecture-level data, aggregating for millions of people. I did not find any large datasets there with polling station results, or any other detailed stats.","Most of data is now available in Excel format. Some minor data is still in PDF, though.
Other dataset could be seen from here.
* https://www.soumu.go.jp/senkyo/senkyo_s/data/index.html#chapter1
""3) Prohibited use"" makes the data non-open.
* https://www.soumu.go.jp/menu_kyotsuu/policy/tyosaku.html","Yes","No","Satoshi IIDA","Kamil Gregor","0"
"fd2a0027-c1fc-47dc-a853-c6323c447164","global","2015-10-02T13:14:57","2015","rw","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.nec.gov.rw/details/?tx_ttnews%5Btt_news%5D=99&cHash=f7c29edd39e64ce9d2dd738a5e341942","Excel",,,,"National Electoral Commission, Rwanda","Yes","Yes","The data for the last election is available in about 30 chunks, but these can be quickly merged, as they contain the same variables and differ only in format.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","70"
"13b362f2-0651-4d3c-ba00-223cbfffcd47","global","2015-09-27T21:23:33","2015","bg","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://geonames.cadastre.bg/","arcgis, geojson",,,"National map","Geodesy, Cartography and Cadastre Agency","Yes","Yes","Changed data license from unsure to no. ","The data is maintained by the national cadastre. There are several other localized cartography services that add detail. The maps are not available in bulk though.
QA review - Data is © 2014 АГКК. Changed from Unsure to No. ","Yes","No","Boyan Yurukov","Mor Rubinstein","60"
"9740b362-5c70-4c41-abfa-4177040bd148","global","2015-09-09T16:35:17","2015","ir","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.raja.ir/dorsapax/userfiles/file/barnameharkat/tabestan94-1.pdf",,,,,"Raja passenger train","Yes","Yes","Found a PDF format. Changed the submission to the following submission. ","However, The Raja Passenger Train Company (https://www.raja.ir/) is an associate of the IR (Islamic Republic of Iran Railways), and manages its passenger trains. On their webpage, you can search for trains, but we couldn't find the data in bulk. We couldn't tell whether the data provided is up to date or not, no meta-data, but we managed to do recent searches and got results back. Results include data, departure time, ticket prices, but not arrival time, thus we did not consider the data to meet the above criterion.
Reviewer's addition -
Timetables can be found here for Raja train in a PDF format. Changed the submission source. ","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Mor Rubinstein","35"
"9215196e-f880-4fad-a371-2163dbaef7e6","global","2015-09-27T23:33:10","2015","bw","emissions","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","The Environment department does take care of pollutions level, yet it is unclear is there is any information regarding the subject on a national level.
it seem the government have measurement of Air Pollution
from data form APIAN for SO2,NOx, NO2, O3, carbon monoxide (CO),hydrocarbons (HCs)
https://www.sei-international.org/rapidc/pdfs/botswana.pdf","Yes","No","anonymous","yar michl","5"
"a5fd2772-3557-4219-9223-56b05402c4b1","global","2015-09-08T13:12:41","2015","qa","land","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Reviewer's comment:
Since the basic data such as owner's name and land border are not available, I will change this dataset into unavailable ","All real property is registered in Qatar in the Real Estate Register at the Ministry of Justice ( https://www.moj.gov.qa/d-4.php ). The register issues monthly reports on sales (such as this one https://www.moj.gov.qa/realissus/2015-08-27-2015-08-23.pdf ), but the the majority of information needed for the index dataset category (such as land borders and owner's name) is not available in these reports.
Reviewer's comment:
Since the basic data such as owner's name and land border are not available, I will change this dataset into unavailable ","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Tarek Amr","0"
"4aa17da2-5c0f-4072-b867-9ead2213bdba","global","2015-09-28T03:46:46","2015","ar","emissions","Yes","No","Yes","No","Unsure","No","No",,"No",,,,,,"Secretary of Environment and Sustainable Development","Yes","Yes","checked
","By [law][1], the government should supply and monitor this data. In practice, I couldn't find it online but notice you can apply for the data through email. I could find other environmental data on this map - https://mapas.ambiente.gob.ar/
[1]: https://www.ambiente.gov.ar/?idarticulo=12192
it see that in Buenos Aires and
Bahía Blanca Air Pollution is montier not by the federal government
Bahía Blanca
https://www.bahiablanca.gov.ar/areas-de-gobierno/medio-ambiente/comite-tecnico-ejecutivo/estacion-de-monitoreo-de-calidad-de-aire/
Buenos Aires
https://www.buenosaires.gob.ar/agenciaambiental/monitoreoambiental/calidadaire
","Yes","No","Yamila García","yar michl","10"
"9ae42120-a8e4-4910-9cc9-b562380c2fec","global","2015-10-08T09:24:23","2015","it","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.brace.sinanet.apat.it/web/struttura.html?p_livello_1=3&p_main=web/sh_dg.inizio&p_scroll=yes","XLS, CSV",,,,"Istituto superiore per la protezione e la ricerca ambientale","Yes","Yes","checked","Services for the donwload of the data are available. There is no license, but the copyright notice states that commercial use of the information is available only under written authorization (https://www.isprambiente.gov.it/it/copyright) Not all the data are available [reviewed URL specifically for air pollutants]
Reviewer Comments (22.10.2014):
- general DB about air pollution available at https://www.isprambiente.gov.it/it/banche-dati/aria-ed-emissioni-in-atmosfera
- the only open licensed data are those contained in this page https://www.isprambiente.gov.it/it/amministrazione-trasparente/altri-contenuti/g8-open-data/open-data-ispra
QA review - Changed license to not open. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","yar michl","60"
"a7a36dff-8a7b-4234-aba7-ca88135544e9","global","2015-09-08T21:20:53","2015","ly","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Ok","Nothing new compared to last year could be found on the Libyan Ministry of Transportation (https://mot.gov.ly/) and the website of the Roads Agency and Road Transportation is down (https://www.raba.ly/). Railroads don't exist, this website states it is still in planing phase (https://www.railroads.org.ly/)
Previous year's comment below:
Railway used to exist in Libya but Gaddhafi simply left it unmaintained and it hasn't functionned for decades. There's no national bus service to connect towns, there's no national service for buses inside a city. Privately-operated microbuses function in the cities but they don't have online timetables; their timetables are known by people. Finally, flights link the big three cities but unsure about who owns them and anyway they don't have online timetables.","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Pieter Colpaert","0"
"f521a629-dbe6-4cd1-baf2-080ac3ca903f","global","2015-08-31T12:25:34","2015","jo","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Ok","Although Jordan Hejaz railway website exist, there is no sing in how you can book trip from city to another, let alone finding data about the trips. It is not clear if Jordan have railway train service between the cities
Source:
https://jhr.gov.jo
It appears Jordan does not have a national service for bus. We could not find any data at all of such a service when we searched on website of transportation regulatory commission .
Source:
https://www.ltrc.gov.jo/","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Pieter Colpaert","0"
"b1215239-8ab8-448a-9b63-bf4fac72ec56","global","2015-09-07T14:46:58","2015","lb","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Ok","Nothing in the minister of transportation's website (https://www.transportation.gov.lb/), and the site reported last year is still down
See last year's comment below:
https://www.public-works.gov.lb/ This was linked through the MOIM website. It is not working or (maybe) never has. Need to look for other possible sources. ","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Pieter Colpaert","0"
"847cec98-f65c-43a4-a3c7-66c1cb918dbf","global","2015-08-30T12:11:34","2015","eg","timetables","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,"Train Schedule and Prices","Egyptian National Railways Authority - Email: support@enr.gov.eg","Yes","Yes","The websites that the submitter gave are route planner, not the actual time table. Therefore, the data exist, but its not publicly available. Route planner are not acceptable in this review. ","The trains time schedule is available online on the website of the Egyptian National Railways Authority. You can only search with specific data and start/stop stations, no way to download data in bulk. The search boxed are not user friendly.
In addition to trains, timetable for buses going from one city to the other are available on the website of the Holding Company for Maritime and Land Transport: https://www.bus.com.eg/EBus/OnlineServices/Home/index.aspx [The website is down, and was not able to access it while updating the index, 30 September 2015]
Cairo International Airport flights timetable are available here: https://www.cairo-airport.com/flight_schedule.asp and https://www.egyptair.com/English/Pages/Default.aspx (Cairo Airport and the EgyptAir companies are government-owned).
Final reviewer: On none of the websites a clear mention of update procedure was identified. However, searching for trains returned results for the upcoming dates within the next month, but not further in the future , which might mean that the data is most likely up to date. However, since the data is not available for download and no meta-data is available whatsoever, we decided to mark this aspect of the data as unsure. The three websites carry a 'copyright' mention at the bottom: the information is thus the property of the respective institution. Lastly, as the data is solely queriable through a web-based interface, it is admitted that the data is not provided in a machine-readable format; there is no way to easily download the whole dataset, therefore data is not available for download in bulk.
Reviewer's note: The websites that the submitter gave are route planner, not the actual time table. Therefore, the data exist, but its not publicly available. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"ddf0d1e5-283f-4a4c-87ef-be4abf377019","global","2015-09-30T10:28:35","2015","ng","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","No data on Nigeria could be found indeed"," The Data is not available.
No changes for 2014
No changes for 2015","Yes","No","Oludotun Babayemi","Pieter Colpaert","0"
"5fea5605-7bd2-4420-a808-6103a483c937","global","2015-09-25T16:39:55","2015","be","timetables","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Yes","No",,"Yes",,"GTFS",,,"Timetables","Belgian Rail","Yes","Yes","Accepted submission. Data is available upon request, therefore it is not publicly available. ","National rail company (NMBS/ SNCB) have made their static traindata (timetables) available as shared data. You need to follow procedure and sign of on a one on one contract before being able to use it. See: https://www.belgianrail.be/nl/klantendienst/faq/public-data.aspx
However a 3rd party group iRail has made this data available for the general public, machine readable as well as in bulk, both GTFS and GTFS-RT (real-time) under an open license. Thanks to the European database law, public transit schedules are not copyrighted. Therefore the data is free for anyone to use, reuse and redistribute.
Review note: data is available upon request, therefore it is not publicly available. ","Yes","No","Pieter-Jan Pauwels","Mor Rubinstein","35"
"c211d566-a869-4d39-acdf-190665d3854e","global","2015-09-22T13:18:46","2015","ml","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","No public transport in Mali.","Urban transportation is provided entirely by the informal sector. No public transport at national level or capital level.","Yes","No","Renaud Gaudin","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"2e5d4c92-0234-4c8a-a2a9-e6f188b6cb98","global","2015-09-25T02:18:54","2015","vc","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://jadeninc.com/fast-ferry-schedule/",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Change to NO, since the data was not from an official source.","There is not public transport in St. Vincent & the Grenadines. There is a ferry service, but it's not an official gov source. https://jadeninc.com/fast-ferry-schedule/","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"27da7f54-6296-4d5d-8149-8c6a7ef0024d","global","2015-09-18T17:00:08","2015","lc","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Ok: unsure whether there's public transit at all...","It is uncertain whether there is data for transportation timetables for any transport vehicles.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Pieter Colpaert","0"
"7ffcebc2-a812-4509-97b5-7edc355b5380","global","2015-09-25T18:31:33","2015","kn","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Changed from unsure to no. ","Privately owned minibuses, complete with music and unusual names, provide inexpensive, though sporadic, service around St. Kitts and Nevis.
Bus transportation on St. Kitts and Nevis is unscheduled and sometimes unreliable, but buses are plentiful in the capitals. Buses near the ferry terminal in Basseterre will generally take you to the South and West of St. Kitts, while buses found at Baker's Corner will take you east and north. Another fun way of catching the bus outside the city is by flagging it down. Buses do not generally do full circles on either island and may run in one direction. Service to areas close to hotels will be limited, so consider whether a taxi would be a better option if you are staying in those areas.
Buses are easiest to catch in the busy mornings and during the afternoon but may be difficult to find past 7 p.m. or 8 p.m. on a weekday. Fares will usually be around $1(USD).
Look for buses such as the ""Rude Boy,"" ""Zion Train,"" ""Dem Say,"" and ""Reggae Master"" with their green license plates for an adventurous experience while on St. Kitts and Nevis. ","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"e52e7074-189c-4758-8ca0-6eba39d74f3e","global","2015-10-02T17:01:23","2015","jm","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://jutc.com/timetables.php",,,,"Time Tables - Below is a complete list of our weekly schedules","Jamaica Urban Transit Company Limited","Yes","Yes","Ok","Jamaica Urban Transit Company Limited is a government agency managing public transport system.
The dataset for transport timetables are all available online. The numbers can be found on https://jutc.com/busterminals.php and you go to https://jutc.com/timetables.php and enter the bus number shown from the first link. When you click go, you will be shown details regarding that bus and a link that has its time schedule. Click the link and you will go to a PDF file showing details for the selected destination port.
Data is in html format and not machine readable.","Yes","No","anonymous","Pieter Colpaert","35"
"f829eff8-641e-42d9-b1ce-0a82bd678a48","global","2015-09-16T06:20:21","2015","gd","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Accepted submission","There is no official public transport data in Grenada. ","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"c59deab1-53c3-4663-8a26-519b49a86c6c","global","2015-09-28T03:02:41","2015","bm","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.bermudabuses.bm/portal/server.pt/gateway/PTARGS_0_2_20064_959_235551_43/http%3B/ptpublisher.gov.bm%3B7087/publishedcontent/publish/ministry_of_tourism_and_transport/department_of_public_transportation_2014/downloads/bus_schedule_april_2015.pdf",,,,"Department of Public Transportation Bus Schedule","Government of Bermuda","Yes","Yes","Ok","In July 2014, The Department of Public Transportation published a PATI (Public Access to Information) Information statement. It can be found here:
[PTB PATI Information Statement](https://www.gov.bm/portal/server.pt/gateway/PTARGS_0_2_20086_959_235565_43/http%3B/ptpublisher.gov.bm%3B7087/publishedcontent/publish/ministry_of_tourism_and_transport/department_of_public_transportation_2014/downloads/71514dpt_pati_information_statement.pdf)
","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Pieter Colpaert","45"
"98b1d47d-e9b4-4cb5-bfa7-b18664a39052","global","2015-09-17T07:04:54","2015","dm","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Accepted submission","There is no government controlled public transportation system. All transportation systems are managed by private entities. There is a government controlled school bus system for selected schools. However, data as to operating schedule is not readily available to the general public.","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"55a246f1-2ed4-45f5-b042-8a41a1b7b65f","global","2015-09-21T17:19:44","2015","bb","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.transportboard.com/","HTML",,,"Route Finder | Transport Board","Transport Board Barbados","Yes","Yes","This is a very nice website, but can be improved. "," ","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"c648e563-1f64-4c61-84a9-a60dde190751","global","2015-10-02T14:19:58","2015","bs","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.bahamas.gov.bs/wps/wcm/connect/ee780aaf-f343-4352-a6c9-d95ca89cd7ae/RT+Dept.Official+Bus+Routes.pdf?MOD=AJPERES",,,,"Official Bus Routes","The Government of the Bahamas","Yes","Yes","Not timely","Official bus routes and bus stops listed on the government website
Data is in pdf format and not machine readable.","Yes","No","anonymous","Pieter Colpaert","35"
"1e656935-15e9-4a70-a7a2-ae48fa292beb","global","2015-10-02T13:15:12","2015","ag","timetables","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,"Bus Stop Antigua","Yes","Yes","Change the entry, data was not from an official government source.","Upon going on the website for the bus transportation, they do not have a scheduled time for each destination port. They do, however, have information regarding prices to go on the bus.
Data is in html format and not machine readable.
Reviewer note: The data is not from an official government source, but citizen initiative. Therefore, data exist, didn't include the bus stop initiative .","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","5"
"9782c79c-b3c8-4dda-954b-a365d40c8ff4","global","2015-09-18T15:20:02","2015","aw","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://arubus.com/schedules/",,,,"Weekly & Sunday Lines Schedule","Arubus N.V.","Yes","Yes","Ok!","Arubus N.V. is the major public transportation of Aruba owned by the Government of Aruba. They provide public transportation, public school busses and private charters over major areas of the island.
Maps showing the different routes are also made available and can be viewed at [https://arubus.com/routes/][1]
[1]: https://arubus.com/routes/","Yes","No","Kimberly Soares","Pieter Colpaert","45"
"4cefb8cf-8d0d-4ceb-9265-e6d7c7eaced9","global","2015-10-02T09:29:38","2015","ke","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://africaopendata.org/dataset/rift-valley-railways-data/resource/723ce2ff-4bcd-4648-bb08-8b1816a7bb67","json",,,,"Nairobi Mobility Team through a collaboration between University of Nairobi School of Computing & Informatics, Columbia University CSUD, MIT Civic Data Design Lab and Groupshot, and has been supported by The Rockefeller Foundation","Yes","Yes","Ok","The Kenyan public transport system is mostly run by the private sector. Some long distance buses will have travel timetables pinned on the wall in their offices or posted on their websites. The Railway is owned by a private company - Rift Valley Railyway. The only government affiliated public transport system is a railway service but this only serves a section of Nairobi (from Syokimau to Nairobi). [Unchanged since 2013]","Yes","No","anonymous","Pieter Colpaert","0"
"f198aec0-4893-4f84-8e3e-c82c93f5b594","global","2015-09-27T10:03:06","2015","tl","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission is correct. No public transport in Timor-Leste","Government of Timor-Leste official portal: https://timor-leste.gov.tl/?lang=en","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"8178634d-2f2e-4501-81a5-79dbb67121b8","global","2015-09-25T11:37:02","2015","al","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Seems ok","This data does not exist and is not available anywhere in the National Level","Yes","No","Blerta Tuci","Pieter Colpaert","0"
"4aa8727c-03dd-41d4-a9b5-53967ddaa135","global","2015-09-28T05:38:45","2015","ph","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.pnr.gov.ph/index.php/northbound-southbound-timetable",,,,"JPEG of timetables","Light Rail Transit Authority, Metro Rail Transit Authority","Yes","Yes","Is available at https://www.pnr.gov.ph/index.php/northbound-southbound-timetable in a.o. GIF","The Department of Transport and Communications published open GTFS data regarding the transport in the metropolitan area of Manila: https://www.dotc.gov.ph/index.php?option=com_k2&view=item&layout=item&id=704&Itemid=167
Apart from this train times are published on the website of the Philippine National Railway: https://www.pnr.gov.ph/schedules.htm The data is published in JPG and HTML.
There is no consolidated data on time tables of regional and interregional bus lines.
p/s: data didn't change","Yes","No","anonymous","Pieter Colpaert","35"
"b52a0d3a-d7c4-4ebe-86c4-ad57bf4f9868","global","2015-09-28T07:30:20","2015","mm","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Changed from Unsure to NO- Reviewer's note: Website was available, there was no official time table data on these website - https://evisa.moip.gov.mm/government.aspx
or https://www.mot.gov.mm/dot/index.html
","No data found under this category. The only government website that is still working is the President's Officer website https://www.myanmarpresidentoffice.info/en/
I can't access to https://www.president-office.gov.mm/en/ and https://evisa.moip.gov.mm/government.aspx to find list of ministries.
Reviewer's note: Website was available, there was no official time table data on these website - https://evisa.moip.gov.mm/government.aspx
or https://www.mot.gov.mm/dot/index.html
","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"00de69d1-8461-4c7d-9fbc-0fdcf9e995ad","global","2015-09-20T14:25:08","2015","id","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.go.id/dataset/jadwal-krl-jabodetabek","CSV","https://opendefinition.org/licenses/cc-by/",,"Jadwal KRL Jabodetabek","PT Kereta Api Indonesia","Yes","Yes","At the time of the review, the website was available","The CSV contains a self-defined header and doesn't follow any standard, yet it's openly licensed and machine readable.","Yes","Yes","Farraz Theda","Pieter Colpaert","100"
"90e36a60-2f9d-4f14-a568-516658147e41","global","2015-09-08T13:40:35","2015","sa","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.saudirailways.org/portal/page/portal/PRTS/root/Home/02_Passengers_Services/02Train%20Schedule",,,,"Train time schedule and inter-city bus time schedule.","Saudi Railways and Saptco","Yes","Yes","Is correct!","Trains in Saudi are operated by the Saudi Railways Organisation - their website provides a time schedule ( https://www.saudirailways.org/portal/page/portal/PRTS/root/Home/02_Passengers_Services/02Train%20Schedule ) that was last updated in July 2015.
Inter-city buses are operated by Saptco ( https://www.saptco.com.sa/ ), the website does not have an easy way to check the timetable, but querying the booking form to check a specific trip provides the user with available timings for the departure and arrival.","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Pieter Colpaert","45"
"134633ce-ff8c-496f-9e6c-3719d787e3ed","global","2015-09-18T09:55:20","2015","kh","timetables","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Phnom Penh City Bus Service","Phnom Penh Municipality","Yes","Yes","Since this only refers to Phnom Penh and to national traffic routes. There is no data from national government about the transport data. ","This is not a timetable, but rather the bus route.
The bus system in Phnom Penh just emerge recently as an effort to solve a traffic congestion by providing an alternative of public transportation.
UPDATE:
There is plan to increase the number of routes and buses.
But no further info is available.
The FB Page is not longer up-to-date (https://www.facebook.com/សេវារថយន្តក្រុងសាធារណៈ-Phnom-Penh-City-Bus-295942053918276/timeline/)
Since this only refer to Phnom Penh and to national traffic routes. There is no data from national government about the transport data. ","Yes","No","Vantharith Oum","Mor Rubinstein","5"
"d6cde2fa-c7e9-48f0-bb46-ab8393b6e993","global","2015-09-18T21:28:17","2015","au","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.railaustralia.com.au/faresTimetables.php","HTML",,,"Fares & Timetables","Rail Australia alliance partners","Yes","Yes"," * Links are broken, therefore I've put ""no"" to timely.
* A good next step for Australia would be to ""oblige"" the different companies to publish e.g., a GTFS file, and link these files from this aggregator website as well.
","Australia is limited in the presence of *national* public transport as most public transport operates at the city or state level. State level data can be found via [Australia's Regional Open Data Census](https://australia.census.okfn.org). Much national transport is privately provided - for example buses via [Greyhound Australia](https://www.greyhound.com.au/).
Looking at rail where there is an interstate system, similar to the UK, Australia has a nationally supported rail system in which the actual service is provided by private operators (but track is publicly owned and maintained). Similar to the UK, there are therefore good public interest grounds for the government to require provision of timetable data.
There is no consolidated database of rail timetable information. From [Rail Australia](https://www.railaustralia.com.au/faresTimetables.php) you are directed off to each rail companies website where you must do your own lookup using a classic HTML interface.
As such it is clear that:
- the data exists
- is online
- is not machine-readable
- not available in bulk
- and is not openly licensed (e.g. Transwa's [copyright notice](https://www.transwa.wa.gov.au/Default.aspx?tabid=113)).","Yes","No","Stephen Gates","Pieter Colpaert","35"
"0ecb16d1-d951-49e8-8c14-03cf985b5005","global","2015-10-07T15:42:06","2015","ie","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.environ.ie/en/LocalGovernment/Voting/",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission does not fit the definition. The data is only available at the constituency (electoral district) level, not for each polling station.","I have sent this office an email to see if the licence may have changed and if by chance they have a plan to have their data shared in .xls
Election referendum results from (2002 - 20145 are available online for local, county, national and European by constituency per candidate, per count. Bye-election results are also available.
Data are available in pdf documents, so not machine-readable.
The data are under Government Copyright and therefore not open see here - https://www.environ.ie/en/Tools/TermsandConditions/ and also under a PSI Re-Use licence https://www.environ.ie/en/AboutUs/Re-useofPublicSectorInformation/
National Election data are also available here - https://www.oireachtas.ie/ViewDoc.asp?DocId=-1&CatID=71 and those data are under this licence Re-Use of Public Sector Information Regulations (S.I. 279/2005) https://www.oireachtas.ie/parliament/about/copyrightandre-use/ which differs from the Copyright note above, in essense election results are on different sites and fall under different intellectual property regimes.","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","0"
"c6528f3e-53c7-443c-bc9f-6ec58cb4fbf9","global","2015-10-07T16:02:40","2015","tt","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.ebctt.com/data/voter-turnout/",,,,"Voter Turnout","Elections & Boundaries Commission","Yes","Yes","The submission describes constituency-level data (at ebctt.com/data, without the voter turnout), so this data does not fit the definition. Polling station data for previous elections have been released in huge PDFs, each time a few months after the election: ebctt.com/publications-and-reports/?_sft_category=parliamentary-election-reports There has been an election a few weeks back, so the format might change in a few days.","Data published using visualization interface. User can select specific year and hover through to see the records.","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Kamil Gregor","45"
"3c5a472d-5ce3-4707-a233-97f5b3cd42f1","global","2015-09-28T11:36:16","2015","pk","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://ecp.gov.pk/GE.aspx","HTML, PDF",,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission does not fit the definition. The data is available only for constituencies, aggregating tens of thousands of people. This is nowhere near the polling station level.","No Changes for 2015.
Coordinator review notes: The site mentions Copyright © ECP 2013 - Election Commission of Pakistan.
Changed Openly licensed to 'NO'. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","0"
"146c089b-aed3-4af9-95ef-f3384571c63e","global","2015-10-02T15:14:33","2015","gd","elections","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://nowgrenada.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/03/Election-Results-Presentation.pdf",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission is not about an official data source. It is just an analysis by some guy called Wayne. Also, it does not contain results at the polling station level. The government has published results in a PDF, but not yet for the last election: https://www.gov.gd/departments/parliamentary_election_office.html . These are constituency-level results, not polling station, but constituencies in Grenada are really small, so it is close.","Data is in pdf format and not machine readable.","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","0"
"d0cef110-e53f-4583-9779-2e33faf21e4b","global","2015-10-02T14:45:54","2015","bb","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.barbadosparliament.com/htmlarea/uploaded/File/Report%20of%20Barbados%20General%20Election%202013laid%20HOA%201st%20Nov%202013.pdf",,,,"REPORT ON THE BARBADOS GENERAL ELECTION 2013","Government of Barbados","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","Based from the elections in 2013
Data is in pdf format and not machine readable.","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","55"
"865e571e-ad69-48e3-87dd-6d31bbeddd34","global","2015-10-02T13:16:30","2015","ag","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.caribbeanelections.com/ag/results2014.asp",,,,"Antigua and Barbuda Election Centre 2014","Caribbean Elections","Yes","Yes","Technically, the data does not meet the definition since only consituency-level data are available. The constituencies are however so small that this basically corresponds to pooling station data.","Data is in html format and not machine readable.","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","45"
"0e4e5a6a-f044-4b7f-b872-02b01b9a3b62","global","2015-10-02T09:31:33","2015","ke","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.iebc.or.ke/index.php/resources/downloads/item/summary-of-2013-presidential-results-declared-on-932013","PDF",,,"SUMMARY OF 2013 PRESIDENTIAL RESULTS DECLARED ON 9/3/2013","IEBC","Yes","Yes","The submission doesn't match the definition since the data is not available by pooling stations. There's however a map at vote.iebc.or.ke that displays pooling station data. I corrected the submission accordingly.","Some of the other results were published later for example on county elections, women representatives and so on but still timely (July 2013).
Contains information on by-elections and referendums which is a great plus.
Copyright statement on site - non-open (Sander van der Waal, 20/10/2013) [Unchanged since 2013]","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","45"
"2d443aa9-2a9c-4c42-afd3-db75de9a6e77","global","2015-09-25T14:32:23","2015","de","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Ok","The transport timetables of the Deutsche Bahn are available via an App at https://www.dbfahrplan.com but the data it sefe is not available online. The data is not provided in bulk nor is it not machine readable and openly licensed. The transport timetables are available as PDF via https://kursbuch.bahn.com and on CD rom and have been reverse-engineered at https://github.com/MichaelKreil/openPlanB
No change from 2013 and 2014.","Yes","No","walter palmetshofer","Pieter Colpaert","25"
"b2678371-12aa-4084-a01b-165ed0ce43e5","global","2015-09-10T15:23:50","2015","at","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.oebb.at/de/Reiseplanung/Fahrplanauskunft/Fahrplanbilder/index.jsp",,,,"Timetable information train and bus Austrian Railways","Austrian Federal Railways (ÖBB), oebb.at ","Yes","Yes","Too bad and flabbergasting that Austria doesn't have machine readable timetables. Review is correct","The state-owned Austrian Railways (ÖBB) makes the schedules of its trains available in PDF files but retains the full copyright. The links to the PDF files can be found on a single page, the data is updated twice a year as schedules change.
There are open datasets for schedules by the City of Vienna (https://www.data.gv.at/katalog/dataset/add66f20-d033-4eee-b9a0-47019828e698) and the City of Linz (https://www.data.gv.at/katalog/dataset/9faa1734-607f-4bfd-b8c9-c5692bf37d55) as well as by the region Steiermark available (data with CC-BY license) - but these are regional datasets not national ones.","Yes","No","Martin Kaltenböck","Pieter Colpaert","45"
"42e91835-b62d-41e4-bba3-9ef4fc3c8fc1","global","2015-09-25T07:57:48","2015","za","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.shosholozameyl.co.za/train-routes.html","Images",,,"Train routes, arrival and departure times for the national passenger rail service.","Shosholoza Meyl","Yes","Yes","Checked with the link and looks correct!","The data provided above is for Shosholoza Meyl, the national train operator. There is no government-owned national bus service.","Yes","No","Greg Kempe","Pieter Colpaert","45"
"b288c85c-3042-47c7-8c72-e53802fb5e49","global","2015-09-11T01:37:59","2015","jp","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://english.jr-central.co.jp/info/timetable/","PDF, HTML",,,,,"Yes","Yes","Reviewed and is good. ","Timetables are available at their webpage, but in most cases you should web-scrape them by yourself. JR-Central timetables are in PDF on https://english.jr-central.co.jp/info/timetable/
JR-West timetables are in PDF on https://www.westjr.co.jp/global/en/travel-information/timetable/
JR-East timetables are in multi-page plain HTML https://www.jreast.co.jp/e/timetables/index.html
Therefore Japan Timetables should get a 'no' to machine readable (see notes above on HTML) JR-Central T&Cs (https://english.jr-central.co.jp/policy/index.html) reserves all rights.
JR-West T&Cs (https://www.westjr.co.jp/global/en/terms-of-use/) only allow personal use.
JR-East T&Cs (https://www.jreast.co.jp/e/termsofuse/index.html) reserves all rights.
Therefore Japan Timetables should get a ""no"" for Open Licence.","Yes","No","Satoshi IIDA","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"bf895ed3-3c21-4b99-90af-c0658ffa9f62","global","2015-10-07T15:43:55","2015","ie","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.epa.ie/air/quality/data/","xlsx, JSON",,,,"Environmental Protection Agency","Yes","Yes","checked
from i understand its look like open sorce data
but i see that note was send to To examine the issue
his data is open data and is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0).
This means you are free to: Share — copy and redistribute the data in any medium or format; Adapt — remix, transform, and build upon the data for any purpose, even commercially. However you MUST provide Attribution for use of this data. You must give appropriate credit, provide a link to the license, and indicate if changes were made. You may do so in any reasonable manner, but not in any way that suggests the EPA endorses you or your use of this data. You can read more about Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0) ","I have sent them a note with regards to the licence.
Last Data are available as discussed here **Access to Information on the Environment** https://www.epa.ie/about/info/aie/#.VGvoE2f-s9N, also read the SAFER **Conditions of Download and Access** https://erc.epa.ie/safer/downloadValidityCheck.jsp.
The data are available in Bulk see here https://www.epa.ie/air/quality/dev/#.VGvpC2f-s9O
also downloadable from the viewer https://gis.epa.ie/Envision/","Yes","No","anonymous","yar michl","70"
"cdda737c-9b44-423c-80cf-456cb30d1a3a","global","2015-09-09T18:34:12","2015","lb","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.pcm.gov.lb/arabic/landing.aspx?pageid=6",,,,"The Official Gazette","President of the council of ministers","Yes","Yes","The submission is correct.","The format of data is GIF.","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Kamil Gregor","45"
"6ff1c284-d1c2-4d3c-aaff-9c52df04c237","global","2015-10-05T16:10:04","2015","ie","health","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure",,"Yes","https://www.hse.ie/eng/services/maps/",,,,"Services near you","HSE Health Services","Yes","Yes","Notes have been sent to the HSE and to the HPSC, however licences and data were not found on the website except for the map.","HSE health services data are available in map form here - https://www.hse.ie/eng/services/maps/. Because they are provided here it is presumed that data are available.
A note has been sent to the HSE to clarify access and the licence.
In terms of infectious disease reporting, data would be available as part of the Computerised Infectious Disease Reporting as part of Health Protection Surveillance Centre https://www.hpsc.ie/CIDR/FrequentlyAskedQuestions/ . I have sent them a question asking about the availability of the data.
Seeking clarifications from HSE CIO: https://twitter.com/OKFirl/status/650972227526086656","Yes","No","Denis Parfenov","Tracey P. Lauriault","60"
"14062e10-ecf9-45ea-b945-57fe5c0179c1","global","2015-09-18T14:35:05","2015","ro","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.calitateaer.ro/valori.php","HTML",,,"This site is dedicated to informing the public in real time on air quality parameters, monitored more than 100 stations all over Romania that make up the National Network for Air Quality Monitoring ( RNMCA ) .","Ministerul Mediului și Pădurilor, Agenția Națională pentru Protecția Mediului","Yes","Yes","checked
have voc benzene","The values of the air pollutants are available online on a special website of the National Agency for the Protection of the Environment. These values are updated daily and are displayed on an hourly basis for the two days before the current day. They can be read by accessing one or more of the 142 stations in Romania that continuously monitor the air quality.
The data can be access only through the interface provided. Raw data is not available.
There was no intellectual property information available.","Yes","No","Ovidiu Voicu","yar michl","45"
"46f259b2-9118-4464-a42c-febba06856c9","global","2015-09-27T02:39:55","2015","tt","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.metoffice.gov.tt/extended-forecast",,,,"Forecase","Trinidad and Tobago Meteorological Services","Yes","Yes","The publications are in PDF. Changed to non machine readable","The Trinidad & Tobago Met Office provides both forecast (3 days) information and historic weather information. Links below provide context.
https://www.metoffice.gov.tt/extended-forecast
https://190.58.130.190/web/daily_data/piarco.html","Yes","No","Matthew McNaughton","Mor Rubinstein","55"
"3a4eebf9-c0f5-4aef-a0f7-789e80351e96","global","2015-09-07T02:44:34","2015","tt","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://www.ptsc.co.tt/City_Service_.html","HTML",,,"Information is given on the time the buses leave destinations.","Public Transport Service Corporation","Yes","Yes","I've changed the entry to the current public agency. ","Schedules published online on the Government website. There are different public transportation types for rural, urban and water services. Each are published as tables on the website.","Yes","No","anonymous","Matthew McNaughton","60"
"a2ac475b-5272-42c3-8465-784221ef6b95","global","2015-10-05T21:04:24","2015","ie","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.transportforireland.ie/transitData/PT_Data.html","GTFS",,,"Transport for Ireland, Bus and Rail","National Transport Authority","Yes","Yes","accept","MACHINE READABLE: YES, the files are in GTFS and some in TransXChange format.
AVAILABLE IN BULK: YES, as of mid 2014.
OPENLY LICENSED: PSI https://psi.gov.ie/files/2010/03/PSI-Licence.pdf
Based on the OKF definition the license is considered 'CLOSED' it is a RE-USE of PUBLIC SECTOR INFORMATION UNDER THE EUROPEAN COMMUNITIES (RE-USE OF PUBLIC SECTOR INFORMATION) REGULATIONS 2005 (SI 279/2005) Licence (https://www.transportforireland.ie/terms-conditions/). The problem areas for the licence are:
(4) not using the document:
(a) for the principal purpose of advertising or promoting a particular product or service; (***Interpreted by some as being non commercial purposes***)
(b) for an illegal, *immoral*, fraudulent or dishonest purpose or in support of the aforementioned purposes (***immoral is the problem as who gets to decide what is and is not immoral***)
5.Sub-Licensing
5.1.The benefit of this License may not be sub-licensed. (***impedes interoperability***)","Yes","No","Tracey P. Lauriault","Tracey P. Lauriault","70"
"f62dac25-f5b3-4601-aab9-87a0fd11a544","global","2015-09-26T21:17:08","2015","pr","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","No",,"Yes","https://www.dtop.gov.pr/det_content.asp?cn_id=374",,,,,"Departamento de Transportación y Obras Públicas","Yes","Yes","I checked the link that was provide and confirm that the data exists, is available for free and has limitations as mentioned (not open licensed, not machine readable). ","File format: png","Yes","No","anonymous","Iris Palma","45"
"a4d5975f-fb33-4237-b7fa-397f21c82913","global","2015-09-17T11:37:09","2015","cz","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://portal.chmi.cz/portal/dt?action=content&provider=JSPTabContainer&menu=JSPTabContainer/P1_0_Home&nc=1&portal_lang=en#PP_TabbedWeather",,,,"Information about air quality in the Czech Republic","Czech Hydrometeorological Office","Yes","Yes","checked","Data is available for a monthly period, but apparently they are updated more often (probably daily, automatic import from measuring stations). This is valid for all the pollutants except VOCs.
VOCs are published every year (monthly data) for 2 measuring stations https://portal.chmi.cz/files/portal/docs/uoco/isko/tab_roc/2014_enh/pollution_month/month_VOC_CZ.html
Both in HTML.
The licence is CC BY-NC-ND.","Yes","No","Michaela Rybičková","yar michl","45"
"58edfb62-c12a-4d5e-8c9f-f6930a148e64","global","2015-09-30T22:01:55","2015","gb","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://uk-air.defra.gov.uk/data/","CSV, HTML, RSS","https://uk-air.defra.gov.uk/data/",,"UK-Air Database","Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs","Yes","Yes","checked","Realtime and recent historical data about *observed* levels of air pollutants and particulates at 128 automatic observing stations across the UK are at https://uk-air.defra.gov.uk. Pollutants covered include Ozone, Nitric oxide, Nitrogen dioxide, Nitrogen oxides as nitrogen dioxide, Sulphur dioxide, Carbon monoxide, PM10 particulate matter, Non-volatile PM10, Volatile PM10, PM2.5 particulate matter, Non-volatile PM2.5, and Volatile PM2.5. All this data is under the Open Government Licence. An RSS feed of latest data is available at https://uk-air.defra.gov.uk/rss/current_site_levels.xml , although this points to HTML pages such as https://uk-air.defra.gov.uk/data/site-data?f_site_id=ACTH&view=last_hour . The Data Selector https://uk-air.defra.gov.uk/data/data_selector allows a custom table to be constructed and either viewed or sent to the requestor as a CSV file. However there is a limit on the extent of the query (one test-drive for the Census gave ""The selection you requested will return 1176 rows of data in 770 columns. This exceeds our limit of 256 columns.""). This meets the Census requirement, apart from bulk download. In addition national estimates of annual *emissions* of 36 air pollutants from 1971-2011 are downloadable in CSV format under the Open Government Licence from https://naei.defra.gov.uk/data/data-selector, but again this is in the form of a table-builder and it does not seem possible to download all the data in bulk. Further public environmental data for the UK is maintained by several public bodies (mainly the Environment Agency for England and Wales, the Scottish Environmental Protection Agency, the Northern Ireland Environment Agency, plus Defra and DECC). Broadly speaking, data on major sources of pollutants is readily available via Government websites and public mapping applications. Some complete datasets are available as open data, notably from Defra: https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/department-for-environment-food-rural-affairs/series/air-quality-and-emissions-statistics. Some environmental data is subject to additional licensing arrangements - see for instance https://www.geostore.com/environment-agency/WebStore?xml=environment-agency/xml/ogcDataDownload.xml
Reviewer 2014 - Data continues not to be available in bulk. Added link to the license.
2015: No changes from 2014. ","Yes","Yes","Mor Rubinstein","yar michl","90"
"e1f605b0-a8fa-4b35-abda-9f1b0839249f","global","2015-09-24T10:46:24","2015","mk","legislation","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.justice.gov.mk/LDBISReader/default.aspx",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission seems to be correct.","The Ministry of Justice maintains a data base of all the legal documents: https://www.justice.gov.mk/LDBISReader/SearchLawRegulation.aspx
Users can perform a search. Unfortunately, only the first 30 results are shown (currently there are 38 081 documents in the database).
There is no bulk download available.","Yes","No","Metamorphosis Foundation","Kamil Gregor","5"
"d4f9ee4f-55c6-4f5d-8ab5-b80abb9fe031","global","2015-09-25T11:17:56","2015","kz","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://adilet.zan.kz/eng",,,,"Legal information system of Regulatory Legal Acts of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Contains all legal information sorted by legal relations area and years of approval. ","Republican Center of Legal Information of the Ministry of Justice ","Yes","Yes","The submission seems to be correct.","The information provided satisfies minimum eligibility criterias. The data is not machine readable and can be downloaded in pdf and docx. The information provided by government officials in Kazakhstan (by default) is open for reuse, publishing as cited by the law. ","Yes","No","Nazerke Akhmetzhanova","Kamil Gregor","45"
"74341775-75da-4ac6-9387-5fdb86c679af","global","2015-09-20T22:10:27","2015","pt","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://dre.pt/index.html","PDF",,,,"Diário da República","Yes","Yes","The submission seems to be correct.","The new DRE portal, published in 2014, has the same limitations as the previous one. Access to text versions (not PDF) and full-text search are only available through a paid subscription.","Yes","No","Ricardo Lafuente","Kamil Gregor","45"
"7e0c0320-f535-4a0e-89f8-37d1a01ee48a","global","2015-09-27T20:27:45","2015","lv","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://likumi.lv",,,,,"Latvijas Vēstnesis","Yes","Yes","The submission seems to be correct.","Likumi.lv is a legislation website ensuring free access to systematized (consolidated) legislation of the Republic of Latvia. Its operation is regulated by the Law on Official Publications and Legal Information. - https://likumi.lv/about.php
- likumi.lv is for systematized, consolidated laws and other legislative acts (complete texts) while https://www.vestnesis.lv/ publishes official decisions which are incremental (you may have separate publications for the initial law and tens of amendments. - if there are any inconsistencies between these two sources, what was published in Latvijas Vēstnesis is the official version. That's why the law states that Latvijas Vēstnesis is the official publication and likumi.lv is for ""informative purposes"".
The official publisher Latvijas Vestnesis does not receive budget funding for maintenance of Likumi.lv. It is maintained from the earnings of Latvijas Vestnesis (the costs are covered from the charge for the official publication paid by the information submitter, unless otherwise provided by a law or Cabinet Regulations).
Regarding information reuse Likumi.lv points to the legislation that determines how this information can be reused and sets the fee for reuse (however, it is not clear what is meant by reuse and if, e.g., publishing law excerpts on a website requires paying the fee or not):
- https://likumi.lv/doc.php?id=254491
- https://likumi.lv/doc.php?id=249322#p18
See also:
- The State of Open Data in Latvia: 2014. Baltic J. Modern Computing, Vol. 2 (2014), No. 3, 160-170 - https://arxiv.org/abs/1406.5052
Update (2015): the situation is the same as in 2014. This data is free to read but definitely not openly licensed as its terms of use state that:
- there is a fee for data reuse
- you may publish links to its entries (i.e. deep links to the website) provided that you attribute the data source","Yes","No","Uldis Bojars","Kamil Gregor","45"
"fef7fc93-22bd-4207-963e-850f77907dc6","global","2015-09-10T10:33:03","2015","cz","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://portal.gov.cz/app/zakony/?path=/portal/obcan/","TXT",,,,"Ministry of the Interior of the Czech Republic","Yes","Yes","Corrected the answer to the machine readability question since TXT is considered machine readable.","The data are accessible online via a web browser and downloadable in PDF and TXT format. The acts can be only downloaded separately one at the time.
The licensing is a problem, since there is no license provision available. On one hand, texts of legislation are exempted from the copyright protection by law and are therefore free to be used. On the other hand, the administration is not a creator of consolidated versions of acts, which are later published online. New acts are valid only after they are published in the official Collection, which is official and binding only in the printed paper offline form. When an amendment of an act is enacted, it is a new act which only enumerates changes in the older act. The consolidated versions of acts are in the Czech Republic unofficial and created by private companies. As can be seen from the downloadable PDF files, the consolidated versions of acts for this dataset are provided by a company Wolters Kluwer Česká Republika. There probably are some sui generis database rights of Wolters Kluwer Česká Republika. The legal relationship between the administration and Walters Kluwer when it comes to this issue is not described. The current situation is therefore that anyone can access this unofficial online version of legislation, but this data set probably cannot be harvested due to the database rights.","Yes","No","Jakub Míšek","Kamil Gregor","60"
"7dd4a529-9ed2-44a5-abba-90e8f236b13c","global","2015-10-04T14:47:02","2015","et","legislation","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.fsc.gov.et/faces/indexPages/FCHomePage.jsp",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission only covers very outdated laws.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","0"
"4d20be4b-59ca-4e8a-b920-8c3206ee9321","global","2015-10-04T14:37:49","2015","rw","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.primature.gov.rw/index.php?id=54&tx-filelist-pi1-39%5Bpath%5D=2015%20Official%20Gazettes&cHash=88657e9fbf9142cc7c803e3c0dbe6617",,,,,"Office of the Prime Minister","Yes","Yes","The submission seems to be correct.","All new laws passed by the Rwandan parliament are 'gazetted' and then published on the website of the Office of the Prime Minister in PDF form. Unfortunately the gazettes can each contain several laws passed on a single date so this can make it more complicated to find the correct law that you are looking for as they are indexed by the date of the gazette rather than by the title of the legislation.
Rwandan legislation is published in all three of the official national languages: English, French and Kinyarwanda.","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","45"
"096b6e5f-2b47-44bc-849d-1f74c9ce2bcd","global","2015-09-17T14:22:30","2015","ly","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://itcadel.gov.ly/decision/",,,,,"https://itcadel.gov.ly/decision/","Yes","Yes","Changed the answer to the bulk download question to ""No"".","As Libya has been in political chaos since February 2014. The legislation data are published by two bodies. Tripoli-based government, managed by the General National Congress, and Cyrenaica-based government, controlled by the Libyan House of Representatives. Each publishes their own legislation separately through (https://www.gnc.gov.ly/legislation_page.aspx) and (https://www.libyan-parliament.org/) respectfully. The laws are published in Arabic. An English version of some laws can be found in this non-governmental website (https://www.security-legislation.ly/).
Also, the Ministry of Justice, the Information and Documentation Center (https://itcadel.gov.ly/decision/), and its official magazine (https://www.log.gov.ly/home/) list the laws and legislation but not in a timely manner.","Yes","No","Maraim Elbadri","Kamil Gregor","45"
"25dcf0c9-c372-4615-aa3e-e427f75f575f","global","2015-09-12T11:13:58","2015","ir","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Unsure",,"Yes","https://dotic.ir/",,,,,"Laws and Regulations Portal of Islamic Republic of Iran","Yes","Yes","The submission seems to be correct.","This site (https://dotic.ir/ also https://www.qavanin.ir/) provides a list of laws in Iran with search capabilities. Data can also be acquired from there on a CD, but not sure how the format is there. We found laws with 1394 as their date-stamp, 1394 is the current year in the Iranian calendar. Thus, we think data provided is up to date. ","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Kamil Gregor","45"
"76c35be4-58fc-4ff9-9a6e-5ac743718bc4","global","2015-09-30T13:35:44","2015","ng","legislation","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://www.nassnig.org/nass/legislation.php",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Links to the files with laws provided in the submission do not work.","The data is available for free as you can download it from their website, likewise it is now available via a legislative databank at https://www.legislativedatabank.nassnig.org/
No Changes in 2015","Yes","No","Oludotun Babayemi","Kamil Gregor","0"
"2ed6969e-55e7-4cdf-ae2a-63a0dde3e078","global","2015-09-25T17:20:40","2015","be","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.belgielex.be",,,,,"The central databank of legislation","Yes","Yes","The submission seems to be correct.","Structure of laws / law books could be improved: most legislation is available in HTML, but it misses semantic markup.
Jurisprudence can be searched / viewed in a flash-based application. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","45"
"40945e37-a22f-4633-93fd-860da9973a58","global","2015-09-20T05:42:02","2015","pk","legislation","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.punjablaws.gov.pk/","HTML, PDF",,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission is on the province of Punjab, not on the country of Pakistan.","The data is provided by Provincial Government instead of Federal Government of Pakistan.","Yes","No","Nouman Nazim","Kamil Gregor","0"
"d97eacd6-6541-450b-bbe9-3006d64c62ab","global","2015-09-27T02:02:40","2015","kn","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.gov.kn/","PDF",,,,"Government of St. Kitts and Nevis","Yes","Yes","The submission seems to be correct.","Currently the government website is currently under maintenance.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Kamil Gregor","35"
"97da792b-c7bf-4142-ad13-20f264e8b3b0","global","2015-09-25T14:47:11","2015","do","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.consultoria.gov.do/consulta/Default.aspx",,,,"Online database of all laws and decrees in Dominican Republic","Consultor Jurídico del Poder Ejecutivo","Yes","Yes","The submission seems to be correct.","We can say the data is provided on a timely and up to date basis because you can find legislation made in 2015.","Yes","No","Eliaquín Encarnación","Kamil Gregor","45"
"f4b78ba9-472d-4106-a4e9-f70a0e485aaa","global","2015-09-21T20:17:34","2015","bb","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.investbarbados.org/legislation.php","PDF",,,,"Invest Barbados","Yes","Yes","The submission seems to be correct.","selected business legislation on the inward investment section:
https://www.investbarbados.org/legislation.php only draft legislation on Barbados Parliament website:
https://barbadosparliament.com/ ","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Kamil Gregor","35"
"2f4a444c-c1fd-45ca-81ce-d8168d9d5dc8","global","2015-09-23T03:40:38","2015","bs","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://laws.bahamas.gov.bs/cms/","PDF",,,"Office of the Attorney General & MInistry of Legal Affairs","The Government of the Bahamas","Yes","Yes","The submission seems to be correct.","consolidated up to 31 December 2009 + 2010 but no reference to 2011, 2012 or 2013 ","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Kamil Gregor","35"
"f4bfc679-e669-4a53-9e3b-4e858b8fdd3b","global","2015-09-28T08:06:29","2015","mm","legislation","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission seems to be correct.","No evidence showing from the President's Officer website that the data is exist. https://www.myanmarpresidentoffice.info/en/ and the dedicated webpage for the cabinet ministries is empty https://www.myanmarpresidentoffice.info/en/?q=cabinet/ministries so no way to find out who are the responsible minister involve. I have found a 3rd party website https://www.ourweb.info/01/directory/myanmar/005/ that provide a list of ministries official websites but some of these websites are not found.","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","0"
"515f7b1d-f9c7-4f8f-a54a-f7dbbbf87e01","global","2015-09-28T06:20:44","2015","kh","legislation","Yes","No","Yes","No","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,,"National Assembly","Yes","Yes","The submission seems to be correct.","Data found from the official website The National Assembly of The Kingdom of Cambodia https://en.nac-kh.org/httpdocs/naweb/english/group-law/53. Data found not in digital format. All data are in PDF format.","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","25"
"498b65c5-ba3f-4bd2-9c11-144f2f3763bd","global","2015-09-18T20:28:12","2015","au","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.comlaw.gov.au/","HTML, PDF, Word",,,"ComLaw has the most complete and up-to-date collection of Commonwealth legislation and includes notices from the Commonwealth Government Notices Gazette from 1 October 2012.","Office of Parliamentary Counsel","Yes","Yes","The submission seems to be correct.","Legislation is not openly licensed. According to https://www.comlaw.gov.au/Content/Copyright, legislation is licenced under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike licence Australia v3.0 (which is not open).
Data is not machine-readable as data is either PDF or (poorly structured HTML) and is not bulk as you can only access one item at a time. ","Yes","No","Stephen Gates","Kamil Gregor","45"
"9e69a565-4847-4e5c-9cf8-75deb1ab39d7","global","2015-09-19T11:28:55","2015","ch","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.admin.ch/ch/d/as/index.html","PDF",,,"Official Compilation of Federal Legislation","Federal Chancellery","Yes","Yes","The submission seems to be correct.","Reproduction requires prior written consent, as per [Terms and Conditions][1] of the Federal Authorities. See [Official Compilation of Federal Legislation](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Official_Compilation_of_Federal_Legislation) (Wikipedia) for additional background in English.
[1]: https://www.disclaimer.admin.ch/terms_and_conditions.html","Yes","No","Oleg Lavrovsky","Kamil Gregor","45"
"318543b7-185a-4019-babe-89e65c270060","global","2015-09-25T08:30:32","2015","za","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.gov.za/documents/acts","PDF",,,"Acts - Promulgated Acts and amendments, but not consolidated legislation.",,"Yes","Yes","The submission seems to be correct.","The government makes available all promulgated acts, including amendments. Consolidated legislation is not available. Users must consolidate the legislation themselves.
There are aggregators of legislation making this data available in HTML and PDF formats. See https://www.acts.co.za/index.html, https://www.lawsofsouthafrica.up.ac.za/, https://www.saflii.org/za/legis/num_act/ ","Yes","No","Greg Kempe","Kamil Gregor","45"
"e3185111-4a13-4b37-a497-4f3be5625e71","global","2015-09-21T18:40:56","2015","us","water","Yes","No","No","No","Yes","Unsure","Unsure",,"No",,,"https://ofmpub.epa.gov/apex/safewater/f?p=136:103:0::NO:::",," Annual Drinking Water Quality Reports","Environmental Protection Agency","Yes","Yes","In the US two major agencies look at water data. The US Geological Survey has an incredible amount of water quality of data, however, not all of it is for drinking water, a small subset of the groundwater data can be considered drinking water. The EPA is in charge of monitoring drinking water and the local body is in charge of testing water which they are then required to send to the EPA those reports are supposed to be online but rarely are.","On openly-licensed: ""USGS-authored or produced data and information are considered to be in the U.S. public domain. While the content of most USGS Web pages is in the U.S. public domain, not all information, illustrations, or photographs on our site are. Some non USGS photographs, images, and/or graphics that appear on USGS Web sites are used by the USGS with permission from the copyright holder. These materials are generally marked as being copyrighted. To use these copyrighted materials, you must obtain permission from the copyright holder under the copyright law.""
This website also does not seem to show fecal coliform, arsenic levels, nor total dissolved solids.
Some data sets were downloadable (in .txt) but others weren't. Not sure if they were in bulk because I had to use a search engine rather than download a complete data set.","Yes","No","anonymous","Nisha Thompson","50"
"1635f25f-9e7d-4fa3-8083-f7149c501db9","global","2015-10-06T10:27:49","2015","fi","water","Yes","Unsure","No","No","No","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,"Quality and monitoring of drinking water distributed by large waterworks in Finland in 2002. National Public Health Institute of Finland. Finland","https://stm.fi/en/frontpage","Yes","Yes","There is data but it is not public. ","In Finland local bodies are responsible for water quality testing. Every year the data is sent to the Ministry of Social Affairs and Health which then compiles it and sends it to the EU.
https://www.samk.fi/download/27214_Summary.pdf
These reports don't seem to be public, but robust data collection seems to be happening as Finland is renown for high water quality standards. They also measure radioactivity of water.
https://www.stuk.fi/web/en/topics/food-and-drinking-water/radioactivity-in-drinking-water","Yes","No","anonymous","Nisha Thompson","5"
"c8aed68f-c2ec-4c46-9edc-dbb89865471f","global","2014-10-28T08:59:56","2014","cn","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.12306.cn/mormhweb/kyfw/lcskbcx/",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","consulted the community and finalize the submission now","Only Train services is ran and managed at national level in China so the dataset mentioned here only covers the timetable of train service. The online data is available in a web service on national train service website 12306.cn which is mainly used to book tickets.
nothing changed in 2014","Yes","No","FENG GAO","FENG GAO","45"
"120f53cb-a6bd-4816-9631-993e81215c2d","global","2015-09-28T21:10:56","2015","sv","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.snet.gob.sv/googlemaps/calidadaire/monitoreo.php",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","The data is in a PDF file from 1994. There is not more data published by the Minister. I am not sure if the data is update, I should request the info to the Minister.
For the ODGI I asked the Ministry of Enviroment and they mentioned that the data is not available anymore, because they got money from international cooperation to do the first reports, but they don´t do it any more.
2015 update
data for Air Quality is for one city and only for pm 2.5 the data is updata and is by The Ministry of Environment and Natural Resources
raw pm 2.5 data is in this link
https://www.snet.gob.sv/googlemaps/calidadaire/monitoreo.php
for data that of Air Quality Index (ICCA)-
https://www.snet.gob.sv/ver/meteorologia/monitoreo/calidad+del+aire/","Yes","No","anonymous","yar michl","0"
"fb6b7f0b-0298-4cb0-bbb5-60a8720fa29d","global","2015-09-12T18:23:44","2015","gd","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://laws.gov.gd/",,,,"Laws of Grenada Caribbean - Grenada Legislation","Ministry of Legal Affairs Grenada powered by Lexis Nexis","Yes","Yes","Changed values of the ""Openly licensed?"" and the ""Is the data provided on a timely and up to date basis?"" in line with the comment of the submitter.","The site did not provide any explicit licencing to indicate whether it was Open licensed or not. Also it did not indicate the frequency to which it was updated. The copyright was however dated 2013. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","35"
"5c701e84-56e3-4b7e-a7dd-21e0bc59ae36","global","2015-09-28T04:26:46","2015","bm","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.bermudalaws.bm/default.aspx?ID=1",,,,"Bermuda Laws Online","Legislative Database Manager Attorney-General’s Chambers Global House 43 Church Street Hamilton HM 12 Bermuda ","Yes","Yes","Added the Title and short description.","Seemingly no changes since 2013 submission.","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","Kamil Gregor","45"
"26c73fe4-1760-473a-86c9-6b196a58c25e","global","2015-09-25T14:32:34","2015","al","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.qbz.gov.al/botime/botimetf15.htm",,,,"Legislation","Qendra e Botimeve Zyrtare","Yes","Yes","The submitter says it's unsure whether the data is timely or not.","These data do exist , there are laws that are published by the Center of Official Publications, but still there are laws and acts that are missing.
Also previous studies made from non-profit organisation has shown that very often there is a delay in making public the court decisions and amendments, this does not help the updating process.
Another problematic issue is the comparative explanation from law to law, that makes very difficult for the public to easily understand the meaning of legal consequences.","Yes","No","Blerta Tuci","Kamil Gregor","35"
"ace6cd7d-7179-40a1-b8e1-4386b93e54a1","global","2015-09-24T06:15:24","2015","sg","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://statutes.agc.gov.sg/","HTML, PDF (sometimes)",,,"Singapore Statutes Online","Legislation Division of the Attorney-General's Chambers of Singapore","Yes","Yes","So laws are available in PDFs.","The site contains up-to-date information on legislation but is not bulk or machine-readable (simple HTML). On open license terms and conditions at https://statutes.agc.gov.sg/aol/page.w3p;paId=AOL_PUBLIC_TERMS_CONDITIONS states ""(5) Except as otherwise provided, the Contents of this Web Site shall not be reproduced, republished, uploaded, posted, transmitted or otherwise distributed in any way, without the prior written permission of AGC.""
*Data didn't change*","Yes","No","Zhi Yuan Lim","Kamil Gregor","45"
"921c422d-ae04-46a7-bcdb-a4887fc8eb70","global","2015-09-28T05:45:39","2015","ph","legislation","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://www.congress.gov.ph/legis/index.php","TXT",,,,"House of Representatives","Yes","Yes","The submission is about intra-parliamentary bills and not about laws.","There is a query system database of Legislative Information System
p/s: data didn't change","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","0"
"f3cbcb3a-9993-4398-8d0c-67f358e3a7f5","global","2015-09-28T07:03:30","2015","id","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://ditjenpp.kemenkumham.go.id/database-peraturan.html",,"https://ditjenpp.kemenkumham.go.id/database-peraturan.html",,,"Kementerian Hukum dan Hak Asasi Manusia Republik Indonesia","Yes","Yes","Added a name of the data publisher.","Data can be found from official website Kementerian Hukum dan Hak Asasi Manusia Republik Indonesia https://ditjenpp.kemenkumham.go.id/ and all data are in PDF/HTML format so its not in digital format https://peraturan.go.id/search/cari.html?tahun[2015]=2015&tahun[2014]=2014&order_by=tahun_desc
","Yes","No","anonymous","Kamil Gregor","75"
"49f3a1db-a03d-4421-9dcf-816468b44be5","global","2015-09-25T14:21:37","2015","de","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/","HTML, PDF, XML, EPUB","https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/hinweise.html",,"Gesetze im Internet",,"Yes","Yes","Only a table of contents is available in bulk and not the whole dataset.","Laws are not subject to copyright as per §5 UrhG (German copyright act). According to the homepage of gesetze-im-internet.de and to govdata.de, the data can be used free of charge. ""Die bereitgestellten Rechtsnormen sind in allen zur Verfügung gestellten Formaten zur freien Nutzung und Weiterverwendung zugänglich gemacht"". The table of contents of gesetze-im-internet.de is available in bulk from https://www.govdata.de/suchen/-/details/gesetze-im-internet as one XML-file. https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/gii-toc.xml Not all laws are provided timely, see https://www.google.com/search?q=site:gesetze-im-internet.de+%22noch+nicht+ber%C3%BCcksichtigt%22&espv=213&es_sm=93&biw=1920&bih=1043&ei=N6KEUqXBM8mYtAbP74G4DQ&start=0&sa=N","Yes","Yes","walter palmetshofer","Kamil Gregor","90"
"034678e1-f97a-47d7-9fa7-749495752ba8","global","2015-09-16T04:44:40","2015","kh","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://cambodiameteo.com/forecast?menu=116&lang=en&areaid=18",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Data marked as not existing due to missing data and short forecast range.
Thank you for your submission to the 2015 Global Open Data Census. ","The Dept. of Meteorology, Ministry of Water Resources & Meteorology publishes weather data at https://cambodiameteo.com. The weather forecast is visualized on a map. You can click through the map to a 3 day forecast (today + 2 days) for each city showing temperature, wind, weather and humidity. There is no precipitation forecast. ([Example city forecast][1])
There is no archive of past weather data.
The data is not machine readable, available in bulk nor openly licensed but is up-to-date.
[1]: https://cambodiameteo.com/forecast?menu=116&lang=en&areaid=18","Yes","No","Vantharith Oum","Stephen Gates","0"
"2cef194b-c2ed-4384-bc2b-4351fb1b3f84","global","2015-09-19T12:06:04","2015","ch","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.meteoswiss.admin.ch/home/weather/forecasts.html",,,,"Forecasts","Federal Office of Meteorology and Climatology MeteoSwiss","Yes","Yes","Submission is valid.
Thank you for your submission to the 2015 Global Open Data Census. ","See [Data management](https://www.meteoswiss.admin.ch/home/measurement-and-forecasting-systems/datenmanagement.html) for some background on how data is collected and distributed at MeteoSchweiz.
[Example Forecast page][1].
[1]: https://www.meteosuisse.admin.ch/home.html?tab=rain","Yes","No","Oleg Lavrovsky","Stephen Gates","45"
"cd00747c-d0fb-4f59-8348-d2440716866a","global","2015-10-02T16:43:42","2015","dk","timetables","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,"Rejseplanen Labs","Rejseplanen","Yes","Yes","Changed to not publicly available, because in order to access the open API, you need to email a request to labs@rejseplanen.dk.","More timetables at https://www.moviatrafik.dk/dinrejse/koreplaner/Pages/Koreplaner.aspx
Timetables in pdf: https://www.dsb.dk/find-og-kob/indland/koreplaner/?station=1samlet The Terms of Use at https://labs.rejseplanen.dk/labs/data_brug/retningslinijer_for_databrug/ make clear that the Travel Plan data is licensed under Creative Commons BY-ND 3.0 license and that the data cannot be changed. This is not an Open Licence under the Open Definition. Thanks to Andrew Stott for license correction.
Update 2015: It could be argued that the data is NOT publicly available (by the Index help text definition) because in order to access the open API, you need to email a request to labs@rejseplanen.dk.","Yes","No","Christian Villum","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"46296f52-4dda-4324-9df0-7f55c99544a8","global","2015-09-04T11:08:09","2015","za","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.weathersa.co.za/",,,,"Forecast","South African Weather Service ","Yes","Yes","Submission is valid.
Thank you for your submission to the 2015 Global Open Data Census. ","The [South African Weather Service][1] does offer a machine-readable api, but only to paying customers, despite being [a public entity under the Ministry of Water and Environmental Affairs][2]. These data are available for free through APIs from international weather sites, such as Weather Underground and yr.no.
Data is © 2015 South African Weather Service
[1]: https://www.weathersa.co.za/
[2]: https://www.weathersa.co.za/about-us/overview","Yes","No","Jason Norwood-Young","Stephen Gates","45"
"5a67f138-0553-44af-9a17-8468bf62d966","global","2015-09-05T07:51:39","2015","tr","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.mgm.gov.tr/tahmin/turkiye.aspx#sfU","HTML","https://www.mgm.gov.tr/",,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission corrected
Thank you for your submission to the 2015 Global Open Data Census.
","Five day temperature forecast is presented as images at https://www.mgm.gov.tr/tahmin/turkiye.aspx#sfU and for cities e.g. https://www.mgm.gov.tr/en-US/forecast-cities.aspx
No wind forecast data is provided. A weather condition icon is displayed but there is no precipitation data.","Yes","No","Ayşegül Engür","Stephen Gates","0"
"0ad0f270-386a-430c-9386-f1cff603c0a4","global","2015-09-15T10:08:53","2015","dz","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Without evidence of the data I am changing ""Does the data exist?"" from ""Unsure"" to ""No"".
This is supported by the World Meteorological Organization World Weather Information Service - https://worldweather.wmo.int/en/country.html?countryCode=DZA
Thank you for your submission to the 2015 Global Open Data Census. ","Official website of the Office National de la Météorologie (ONM)
Link : https://www.meteo.dz/
All the data are in a non-Open Data format.
Weather forecast is for 4 days and only at a country level - not by city.
A sub domain (buggy one) offers data but not useful one.
Link : https://rcc-network.meteo.dz/index.php","Yes","No","Aldja Computer","Stephen Gates","0"
"bdf229da-5f14-4d21-a553-51846b4410a3","global","2015-09-11T18:46:29","2015","sy","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is valid.
Thank you for your submission to the 2015 Global Open Data Census. ","Site is giving lots of errors. Only 2 days forecast, for temperatures only. Couldn't find historical data. See example here (https://www.meteo.sy/modules.php?op=modload&name=pages&file=view3d)","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Stephen Gates","0"
"c7b622a8-f262-4a28-9d1c-2bd1f6299839","global","2015-09-29T06:10:05","2015","tg","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.tv5monde.com/cms/chaine-francophone/meteo/p-176-lg0-Lome.htm?id_ville=1497",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The official Togo Direction de la Météorologie Nationale website https://www.meteo-togo.net/ is down.
Commercial data is available at https://www.tv5monde.com/cms/chaine-francophone/meteo/p-176-lg0-Lome.htm?id_ville=1497
","The official Togo Direction de la Météorologie Nationale website https://www.meteo-togo.net/ is down.
Official Government data could not be located.
Commercial data is available at https://www.tv5monde.com/cms/chaine-francophone/meteo/p-176-lg0-Lome.htm?id_ville=1497
","Yes","No","Richard Komlan Folly","Stephen Gates","0"
"0cf7c725-3193-45c7-b57a-5dc1055dfd46","global","2015-09-24T10:46:24","2015","mk","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://airquality.moepp.gov.mk/",,,,"Measurements of Air Quality","Ministry of Environment and Physical Planning","Yes","Yes","checked","The measured concentrations of six pollutants from 17 monitoring stations are collected every hour by Ministry of Environment and Physical Planning. Measurements are available here: https://airquality.moepp.gov.mk/?page_id=4 and there are interactive visualization tools available. There is no download option, though.","Yes","No","Metamorphosis Foundation","yar michl","45"
"5a9c1037-fcf5-4686-8efc-906c00013138","global","2015-10-04T09:23:21","2015","ie","map","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","No","Unsure","No",,"Yes","https://www.osi.ie/",,,,"There are many framework data, core or foundational datasets available from the OSI, here is a description of what constitutes Boundary Data https://www.osi.ie/Products/Professional-Mapping/Boundary-Data.aspx","Ordinance Survey of Ireland (OSI)","Yes","Yes","This is still under review. I have a note out to the OSi re-roads and water features. The OSi may be the distributor but they may not be the data owners. SOme data are also available on GeoDirectory.","**Political Boundaries** are available here - https://www.osi.ie/products/professional-mapping/boundary-data/
""The County, ED’s and Townlands are digitised from OSi large scale data at 1:1,000, 1:2,500 and 1:5,000 scale and are available on a county or national basis (Republic Only) in DXF, SHP and TAB formats. All boundaries are available in both Irish National Grid (IG) and Irish Transverse Mercator (ITM) projections.
Small Areas are a national boundary dataset, which subdivides the existing Electoral Districts (ED) boundaries into substantially smaller units, with each small area having a minimum of 65 households.""
The OSI is governed by the ORDNANCE SURVEY IRELAND ACT, 2001 https://www.irishstatutebook.ie/2001/en/act/pub/0043/, which means that it is the states NMO but also a commercial enterprise.
There is an **interactive map Viewer** https://maps.osi.ie/publicviewer/#V1,588882,739883,0,10 that allows the public to visualize the data.
Data are available via **webmapping service called MapGenie** https://www.osi.ie/Services/MapGenie.aspx with additional information provided here https://www.osi.ie/Services/MapGenie-Learn-More.aspx. Data are accessed this way via an institutional agreements between clients and OSI. MapGenie is not open to the public on a free basis.
The data are machine readable as just explained but for a fee and the same is true for data available in bulk.
In terms of **Intellectual Property** OSI data are protected under the **Copyright and related Act 2000** as discussed here it data are not available under an OPEN LICENCE, all OSI data are protected under the Copyright and related Act 2000 as discussed here https://www.osi.ie/Services/Copyright.aspx, and **Copyright Permit CP1** and there are **Licence Fees**. For example ""copyright Ordnance Survey Ireland and Government of Ireland and are protected under the terms of the Copyright Acts. Anyone wishing to reproduce OSi material, or use it as a basis for their own publications, must obtain prior permission from OSi. The permit covers reproduction of OSi mapping data in facsimile form and also the use of copyright material in a new compilation based on OSi mapping. The permit requires that an acknowledgement to Ordnance Survey Ireland and Government of Ireland copyright and a permit number must appear on the final reproduction"".
The OSI has allowed some academic institions to display and use their data via MapGenie here is one example (https://airo.maynoothuniversity.ie/datastore/private-households-t5-sa) however this is for non commercial use only","Yes","No","Dave Corley","Tracey P. Lauriault","25"
"11bbd427-9f95-4337-bd37-7f20ec80f2bf","global","2015-10-05T19:06:29","2015","ca","weather","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://weather.gc.ca/canada_e.html","xml, csv, html",,,"nadian Weather and Digital Archive of Canadian Climatological Data (Surface) ","Environment Canada","Yes","Yes","The data were updated from the original submission.","There are a number of sources for these data.
The weather forecast data are available here - https://weather.gc.ca/canada_e.html
Historical climate data available here - https://climate.weather.gc.ca/links/index_e.html#tools
Archived data here - https://climate.weather.gc.ca/prods_servs/documentation_index_e.html
Customized data can be purchased for a fee.
Data do not seem to be available under an open licence, https://climate.weather.gc.ca/prods_servs/attachment1_e.html","Yes","No","Tracey P. Lauriault","Tracey P. Lauriault","70"
"bb709930-eab0-4200-916f-af6045b66a2b","global","2015-10-01T15:58:43","2015","ca","health","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Yes","Yes",,"Yes",,"multiple",,,"Agency specific","Public Health Agency of Canada, Health Canada, Canadian Institute for Health Information","Yes","Yes","Health is a provincial and territorial matter in Canada, much of the data for this category are provided but by different agencies, some are free and open and others are not. The information has been provided in the preview section.","Canada as a federation has divisions of power, In Canada health is paid for via transfer payments from the Federal government but administered by the provinces and territories. The health data being requested in this category come from a number of sources, and some would have open licences and some would not.
Some data are free some are not.
The Public Health Agency of Canada disseminate some infections disease data via their health surveillance page
https://www.phac-aspc.gc.ca/surveillance-eng.php
Statistics Canada also disseminates health data here - https://www.statcan.gc.ca/eng/health/index
A non-governmental organization, the Canadian Institute for Health Information, manages and disseminates provincial data supplied by the provinces and territories on the administration of the health case system.
https://www.cihi.ca/en/about-cihi
https://www.cihi.ca/en/data-and-standards
The provinces and territories have the rest.
","Yes","No","Neal Bastek","Tracey P. Lauriault","50"
"8d5f0034-6e05-49b7-8550-98fa1da5d14e","global","2015-09-28T21:06:20","2015","lv","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://www.csb.gov.lv/en/statistikas-temas/metodologija/weather-conditions-and-air-quality-latvia-38299.html","CSV, XSLX or PX-Axis files",,,"Weather conditions and air quality in Latvia","Central Statistical Bureau","Yes","Yes","checked
","Air polution monitoring data is published once a month. Queries can be made for custom time periods. Measurements include the maximum concentration of carbon dioxide, nitrogen dioxide, ozone and particulate matter.
Air quality measurements are taken by automatic DOAS OPSIS stations ensuring continuous registration of polluting substances.
Update (2015):
- Not sure if we should consider this dataset timely or not. Changed the answer to ""unsure"" for now. While the dataset is published regularly and in a timely manner, each location has just one measurement set per month.
- This dataset has 3 types of measurements out of 5 listed in the census criteria. It does not include measurements for Volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and Carbon monoxide (CO).
---
See also:
- The State of Open Data in Latvia: 2014. Baltic J. Modern Computing, Vol. 2 (2014), No. 3, 160-170 - https://arxiv.org/abs/1406.5052","Yes","No","Uldis Bojars","yar michl","60"
"a6bbb508-ee93-4d86-b8f6-6adeaaea8ed1","global","2015-10-04T14:47:45","2015","et","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","from 2012 news that
https://allafrica.com/stories/201206271027.html
Ethiopian Meteorological Agency (EMA) is planning to establish an air pollution monitoring station to measure the air quality of Addis Abeba
in the EMA no info on air pollution monitoring was find
also in EthiopianEPA","Yes","No","anonymous","yar michl","0"
"6d12f870-3af9-4add-aee3-591c749a5faa","global","2015-09-27T15:36:17","2015","bb","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.barstats.gov.bb/",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked
","UN summary information:
https://unfccc.int/files/ghg_data/ghg_data_unfccc/ghg_profiles/application/pdf/brb_ghg_profile.pdf https://www.energy.gov.bb/web/energy-smart-fund green economy - regional strategy:
https://gisbarbados.gov.bb/index.php?categoryid=3&p2_articleid=10380 ","Yes","No","Bruce Hoo Fung","yar michl","0"
"fc3707b6-86ce-4726-8a34-78021aa11742","global","2015-09-18T20:46:57","2015","is","timetables","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.straeto.is/um-straeto/utgefid-efni/rauntimaupplysingar/","XML","https://www.straeto.is/um-straeto/utgefid-efni/rauntimaupplysingar/skilmalar",,,"Strætó bs.","Yes","Yes","There are restrictions on access (you have to register) so the dataset is not publicly available.","These are timetables for the public bus system in Iceland's capital region and any public bus routes connecting the capital region and other municipalities.
In order to use the data, each user must register an IP address from which to access the data (for intermediate server caching and to get contact persons).","Yes","No","Páll Hilmarsson","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","95"
"6cea28fc-cd15-4cd5-92c5-eac9ee1a15a3","global","2015-09-28T05:44:51","2015","ph","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","pm 10 and pm 2.5 is air quality monitoring data is give online in number city https://airquality-embdenr.com/
no NOx and other Pollutant is provide so no data
","Yes","No","anonymous","yar michl","0"
"33590fe5-9670-480e-97bf-26a1b1de619d","global","2015-10-02T05:47:53","2015","ml","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked
I checked again https://www.environnement.gov.ml/
its not working","There is a website dedicated to sanitation and pollution (https://bd.stp.gov.ml/donnenviron/assainis.php) managed by the Ministry of Environment and Sanitation (https://www.environnement.gov.ml/) but it is empty. bd.stp.gov.ml","Yes","No","anonymous","yar michl","0"
"577cabd5-ba17-46a6-aea1-e94380239888","global","2015-08-24T12:16:18","2015","ng","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is valid.
Thank you for your submission to the 2015 Global Open Data Census. ","[Nigeria Meteorological Agency][1] (NMA) is responsible for the release of weather forecast for selected cities in the country via their website, but presently largely on a daily basis.
As seen from their [numerical weather portal][2] they have a plan of making it available in more days, but presently non - functional.
Historical information is published on behalf of the NMA by the [World Meteorological Organization][3] (WMO) World Weather Information Service at https://worldweather.wmo.int/en/country.html?countryCode=75
[1]: https://nimet.gov.ng/
[2]: https://nimet.gov.ng/nwp
[3]: https://www.wmo.int/pages/index_en.html","Yes","No","Oludotun Babayemi","Stephen Gates","0"
"5c553ce3-76c8-43e8-8cc8-ee378072fe73","global","2015-09-26T13:28:17","2015","sd","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","No evidence the data matching the the minimum requirements for this category exists.
Thank you for your submission to the 2015 Global Open Data Census. ","Sudan Meteorological Authority website has data about weather, but we could not find data about the wind, some links, like the link for 5 days forecast of temperature, is not working. Also we could not find historical data about temperature for the past year on Sudan Meteorological Authority website.(https://www.ersad.gov.sd)","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","Stephen Gates","0"
"1e62c5b3-d0ac-45e8-a918-a41bcd8e0236","global","2015-09-28T21:36:57","2015","sv","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Thank you for your submission to the 2015 Global Open Data Census. ","Weather data is available at https://www.snet.gob.sv/ver/meteorologia.
Two day forecasts are provided as textual descriptions and an image. No historical data is available.
Some data is available for purchase https://www.snet.gob.sv/ver/snet/productos+y+servicios/ ","Yes","No","anonymous","Stephen Gates","0"
"b9beb6a4-207f-4524-b68f-c2215c99d0a2","global","2015-09-08T13:03:00","2015","tn","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is valid.
Thank you for your submission to the 2015 Global Open Data Census. ","Two day forecasts are available including min, max temperature, wind speed and direction, and an icon representing precipitation (https://www.meteo.tn/htmlar/donnees/observation.php and
https://www.meteo.tn/listear/previsions/previsions.php).
Historic monthly statistics are available (e.g. https://www.meteo.tn/htmlar/donnees/janv.html).","Yes","No","anonymous","Stephen Gates","0"
"d1f0696f-23bf-4868-b39d-e8c0bd95238d","global","2015-09-09T14:08:33","2015","ye","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","There is no evidence of weather forecast data.
Thank you for your submission to the 2015 Global Open Data Census.
","The [Civil Aviation and Meteorology Authority][1] is responsible for weather forecast in Yemen. However, their website only publishes the forecast for the next day only. No five day forecast or historical records are available to the public.
There is a [facility to request selected historical data][2] but this may be restricted to Government and Educational use.
[1]: https://yms.gov.ye/en
[2]: https://yms.gov.ye/en/ssss","Yes","No","Riyadh Al-Balushi","Stephen Gates","0"
"28e9de83-d4ae-48a1-ba78-0c39a96c841e","global","2015-09-24T10:25:49","2015","mk","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is valid.
Thank you for your submission to the 2015 Global Open Data Census. ","The web location https://www.meteo.gov.mk/ offers some weather forecasts, as well as wind conditions, air temperature, humidity - but it is very poorly executed and often missing data.
The site does have [a page dedicated to open data][1] in line with the initiative of the government of the Republic of Macedonia on free access to information.
[1]: https://www.meteo.gov.mk/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=84&Itemid=90&lang=mk","Yes","No","Metamorphosis Foundation","Stephen Gates","0"
"a4e5702b-29af-439e-9b69-ff4822c9e38d","global","2015-09-10T08:55:01","2015","ma","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is valid.
Thank you for your submission to the 2015 Global Open Data Census. ","Maroc Meteo (https://www.marocmeteo.ma/) provides forecast for only 2 days, with only min/max temperature (https://www.marocmeteo.ma/?q=fr/tempsprevu/villes), no wind speed or precipitation available.
Data is available for purchase but it is unclear what is provided (https://www.marocmeteo.ma/?q=fr/formulaire_acquisition).
This website (https://meteomaroc.com/) does provide 5 days forecast with temperature, wind speed and precipitation, though it is not an official governmental website, and it is not clear where it gets its data from.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Stephen Gates","0"
"47e7d2dd-f7f3-477c-8582-00de6cfcb840","global","2015-09-30T09:36:54","2015","ly","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is valid.
Thank you for your submission to the 2015 Global Open Data Census. ","The [National Centre for Meteorology][1] is [affiliated with the Ministry of Transport][2]. The website of the Libyan National Centere for Meteorology is currently down.
[1]: https://lnmc.ly/
[2]: https://mot.gov.ly/site/index.php/en/2014-03-30-17-53-61/2014-03-30-17-53-61","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Stephen Gates","0"
"0ce6a9ba-f059-47a8-b565-42f6798503cc","global","2015-10-05T01:12:28","2015","ae","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is valid. Corrected Markdown formatting
Thank you for your submission to the 2015 Global Open Data Census. ","The [National Center of Meteorology and Seismology][1] is responsible for weather data in the UAE. It has an interactive website that allows the user to access various weather data. However, it only allows the user to display weather data for the current day and a few previous days.
Monthly statistical history is available per station (e.g. https://www.ncms.ae/en/climate-reports-yearly.html?id=102)
[1]: https://www.ncms.ae/en/index.html","Yes","No","anonymous","Stephen Gates","0"
"91edd4e2-cc47-45e1-afb8-7333475867a2","global","2015-09-03T21:38:17","2015","lb","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is valid.
Thank you for your submission to the 2015 Global Open Data Census. ","The Meteorological Department of the Lebanese Directorate General of Civil Aviation publishes daily weather forecast in the form of a widget here (https://www.dgca.gov.lb/index.php/en/meteo-en), however, wind speed is only available for the current day, and we could not find historical data. Precipitation is not available, only equivalent icons and humidity is shown for the current day only.","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Stephen Gates","0"
"939b69fe-e2cd-4abb-b4e9-e94db7747d58","global","2015-10-04T14:39:36","2015","rw","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked
it seem that dont have any measurement of air pollution
https://climatecolab.org/plans/-/plans/contestId/1301418/planId/1319614",,"Yes","No","anonymous","yar michl","0"
"3d38a2e4-84ae-492a-82b9-7fa18365d886","global","2014-10-25T11:37:55","2014","tr","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.iett.gov.tr/en/main/pages/public-transport-fare-schedule/317","text",,,,"IETT","Yes","Yes","Submission adequately fulfills the requirements, is correct and understood to be thoroughly checked and examined by the sender. ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","berkin Akkocaoglu","70"
"0b18d526-8f6f-47eb-b73f-3a927d1cb7bf","global","2015-09-20T05:55:37","2015","pk","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure",,"No","https://www.environment.gov.pk/PRO_PDF/AmbientAirQtyPakistan.pdf",,,,"AMBIENT AIR QUALITY IN PAKISTAN","Government of Pakistan, Ministry of Climate Change","Yes","Yes","checked","Link Updated.","Yes","No","Nouman Nazim","yar michl","35"
"fb7a864a-d8a5-427c-b7ca-798adc8caf29","global","2015-09-09T08:27:51","2015","et","health","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.moh.gov.et/resources",,,,"Health related indicators","The Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia, Ministry of Health","Yes","Yes","Submission acceptable",,"Yes","No","Solomon Mekonnen","Bruce Hoo Fung","45"
"9e065908-92a5-4a02-9d0c-ee8ccbd9f968","global","2015-09-09T08:45:42","2015","et","land","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Data Publisher & Title and short description are missing.",,"Yes","No","Solomon Mekonnen","Bruce Hoo Fung","0"
"ce31ba31-846d-419c-bc47-be216335a1a6","global","2015-09-16T14:06:04","2015","rw","health","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://facilities.moh.gov.rw/collections?collection_id=424&lat=-2.0683904552333576&lng=29.91166045532226&z=9","RSS, JSON, CSV",,,,"Ministry of Health","Yes","Yes","Submission complete",,"Yes","No","Stephen Abbott Pugh","Bruce Hoo Fung","70"
"0ee26b24-bc77-4b30-9e04-3ca7cd22e553","global","2014-11-29T19:35:26","2014","md","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.autogara.md/orar/",,,,,"I. S. „Gările și Stațiile Auto”, autogara@mtc.md","Yes","Yes","Data is in HTML and therefore is not machine readable. Changed submission. ","https://www.autogara.md/orar/
https://www.railway.md/ro/schedule/ ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"6f03b6ab-5760-448c-9f75-c41d8fe469ca","global","2015-09-09T18:51:56","2015","lb","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure",,"Yes","https://erml.moe.gov.lb/AQIPage.aspx?menuId=9",,,,"Lebanon's Air Quality Index","Environmental Resources Monitoring in Lebanon","Yes","Yes","checked","The ERML(Environmental Resources Monitoring in Lebanon) initiative is monitoring air quality in Lebanon.
The project is copyrighted under ERML. The data is updated regular. Users can't download the data or get it in bulk.
The ERM is one of Ministry of Environment projects.
The data does not provide any information PM Levels, SOx
NOx, VOCs, and CO pollutants.","Yes","No","Sadeek Hasna","yar michl","45"
"0fbed99e-36a8-4162-9cc9-ab959fb51e3e","global","2015-10-04T11:28:22","2015","jo","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked
data in not Updated -and dont have measurement of PM and another Pollutant","The data available at ministry of environment it is air pollution, there data about CO2,CH4 and N2O. The data available through a pdf report dived for 6 files.
The last report from 2009 and the data included in that report from years 1996 or older.
","Yes","No","anonymous","yar michl","0"
"865af5ad-71f6-4f22-a9d7-a07b15f53e41","global","2015-09-24T12:46:19","2015","ko","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is valid.
Thank you for your submission to the 2015 Global Open Data Census. ","The [Kosovo Ministry of Environment and Spatial Planning](https://mmph-rks.org/en-us/Background-and-Scope) has responsibility for the [Hydrometeorology Institute](https://mmph-rks.org/en-us/Hydrometeorology-Institute-of-Kosovo). No data is available online.","Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Stephen Gates","0"
"4458a961-4cd1-4a22-b6c9-153df6ab7701","global","2015-09-08T20:57:58","2015","iq","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is valid.
Thank you for your submission to the 2015 Global Open Data Census. ","Iraqi Meteorological Organization (https://meteoseism.gov.iq/) is part of the Ministry of Transportation. On the home page, there is a map for stations and when you click on one it gives you a two day forecast.
An example forecast is at https://meteoseism.gov.iq/index.php?name=Pages&op=page&pid=118. No precipitation data nor wind speed shown, only wind direction. A separate page for precipitation here (https://meteoseism.gov.iq/index.php?name=Pages&op=page&pid=155), but it only shows one day.
Historical statistical data has not been updated since March 2015, https://meteoseism.gov.iq/index.php?name=Pages&op=page&pid=169. No data for more recent months.","Yes","No","Tarek Amr","Stephen Gates","0"
"8bd5d75a-6cca-443d-813e-886659bfbca2","global","2015-10-03T09:07:19","2015","gn","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is valid.
Thank you for your submission to the 2015 Global Open Data Census. ","Although Guinea's Direction Nationale de la Météorologie is listed as a member of the [World Meteorological Organization](https://www.wmo.int/pages/members/region1_en.html) the [link provided](https://www.meteo-guinee-conakry.net/) and other web searches resulted in finding no evidence that the data is available online.","Yes","No","anonymous","Stephen Gates","0"
"6c1417a0-775e-491d-94ba-ac48bde17145","global","2015-10-02T09:33:20","2015","ke","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","There is no data available online but this does not rule out the possibility that the data may be available in paper or digitally but just not online on government websites and sources.
The Ministry of Environment and Natural Resources just launched real-time air pollution monitoring (September 1, 2015)
Hopefully, the data that's collected will be made available in the coming months.","Yes","No","anonymous","yar michl","0"
"9a76867d-fa65-4ebe-b1b6-cdb8df9dce15","global","2015-09-25T09:05:58","2015","za","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.saaqis.org.za/NAAQM.aspx",,,,"Air Quality Monitoring Overview","Department of Environmental Affairs","Yes","Yes","checked","Data on Air pollution is available on the website in a non machine readable format and is shown in Graph or a Map view . The raw data is only available on request from the agency in a XLS format.
","Yes","No","Greg Kempe","yar michl","45"
"78abd80e-dd07-469a-9fea-59f56695edd0","global","2015-09-30T13:49:55","2015","ng","emissions","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked","
it seem that National Environmental Standards and Regulations Enforcement Agency is making monitoring programme on Air Pollution
https://www.nesrea.gov.ng/news/air-quality.php","Yes","No","Oludotun Babayemi","yar michl","5"
"1a639a00-3991-430f-88d8-3e707387f0bd","global","2015-09-25T17:31:32","2015","be","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.irceline.be/",,,,"Current Air Quality Measurements","Irceline","Yes","Yes","checked
I thinek the have and api that dont list in this site
https://github.com/irceline
","Air quality: https://www.irceline.be/ (data from services embedded in HTML pages), licensed under CC-BY-NC-ND
Radiation: https://telerad.fgov.be/ (flash based) Since environment is a Other data probably fed to https://www.eea.europa.eu/data-and-maps
Unchanged since 2014.","Yes","No","anonymous","yar michl","45"
"c25fd82a-5dc0-4f4e-a96c-d12a54d90246","global","2015-09-12T05:16:18","2015","jp","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://soramame.taiki.go.jp/",,,," Atmospheric Environmental Regional Observation System","National Institute for Environmental Studies (of Japan)","Yes","Yes","checked
it seem japean use to measure VOCs by NMHC vale or THC vale","As stated in https://www.nies.go.jp/igreen/index.html, re-distribution and modification are not allowed.
data from year 1981 -2012 is Available in bulk to download from
https://www.nies.go.jp/igreen/index.html
how to use the Atmospheric Environmental Regional Observation System in can be see in this link
https://soramame.taiki.go.jp/dss/kosa/en/document/3how%20to%20see%20PM%20map.pdf","Yes","No","Satoshi IIDA","yar michl","55"
"b8746f24-b3a1-4f98-8244-0733497a1a71","global","2015-09-14T10:48:30","2015","at","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.umweltbundesamt.at/umweltsituation/luft/luftguete_aktuell/",,,,"Luftgüte aktuell","Umweltbundesamt = Environment Agency Austria","Yes","Yes","checked
no VOCs measurement,","The federal government makes only data on Ozone measurements available through an open data format (JSON), released by the Federal Environmental Agency, https://www.umweltbundesamt.at/umweltsituation/umweltinfo/opendata/oed_luft/.
Specific data on air pollutants such as carbon monoxides, nitrogen oxides, particulate matter is available on a timely basis here: https://www.umweltbundesamt.at/umweltsituation/luft/luftguete_aktuell/tgl_bericht/ These daily measurements are currently not provided for downloaded and data is only made available for the current date. There is a contact provided and no implication that the Umweltbundesamt charges for the dataset.","Yes","No","Martin Kaltenböck","yar michl","30"
"e6864666-bdd4-423e-9ddd-462966add01e","global","2015-08-28T19:19:31","2015","tz","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is valid.
Thank you for your submission to the 2015 Global Open Data Census. ","The existing official data from [Tanzania Meteorological Agency](https://meteo.go.tz/index.php) does not include all these items and it is not updated daily.","Yes","No","Joachim Mangilima","Stephen Gates","0"
"1a615a4b-09f1-4a3a-ba62-c520f2706bae","global","2014-10-31T17:07:58","2014","gn","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Agree",,"Yes","No","DIAAboubacarLO L","Pierre Chrzanowski","0"
"a4dbad75-e28e-40bc-9836-5f83f2349254","global","2015-10-03T07:41:08","2015","ht","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is valid.
Thank you for your submission to the 2015 Global Open Data Census. ","There is a National Weather Forecast Center in the Country named Centre national de météorologie (CNM) but there is no evidence that weather forecast data is available online. (1)
Sources
(1): https://www.meteo-haiti.gouv.ht/previsions.php","Yes","No","anonymous","Stephen Gates","0"
"38e893a3-80d2-45ff-bed9-30446c8b7c6d","global","2015-09-27T19:36:50","2015","ec","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is valid.
Thank you for your submission to the 2015 Global Open Data Census. ",,"Yes","No","Julio Lopez","Stephen Gates","0"
"f2b996a2-7dc9-4951-a95d-3e117ab73ad1","global","2015-09-27T12:37:40","2015","tl","weather","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is valid. Thank you for your submission to the 2015 Global Open Data Census.","Gastão de Sousa is the Minister of Public Works, Transport and Communications. One of his job scope:
> maintain and develop the national systems of weather and seismological information and monitoring, including the construction and maintenance of its infrastructure, and promote and coordinate scientific research and technological development in the fields of civilian land, air and maritime transport
The generic information is found from the official website Government of Timor-Leste. However, there is no dedicated website under the Ministry of Public Works, Transport and Communications. Therefore, it does not meet the criteria mentioned above.","Yes","No","anonymous","Stephen Gates","0"
"bacaf38c-bef0-4c06-8910-b93abf450791","global","2015-10-01T14:38:33","2015","ca","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://geogratis.gc.ca/api/en/nrcan-rncan/ess-sst/$categories?scheme=&q=GeoBase","Multiple - SHP (English), SHP (French), GML (English), GML (French), KML (English), KML (French), PDF","https://open.canada.ca/en/open-government-licence-canada",,"Data: different datasets available on administrative boundaries, hydro network, roads, railways, etc.","GeoBase series published on GeoGratis","Yes","Yes","I have updated the URL, the series, provided comments and updated the licence as it is now an open licence.","Multiple national scale framework data are available from Natural Resources Canada in the following portal: https://geogratis.gc.ca/api/en/nrcan-rncan/ess-sst/$categories?scheme=&q=GeoBase
The frequency of updates is uncertain, for examples roads may be updated more frequently than lets say political borders since they do not change, the same can be said for water features. An examination of the full metadata for the road network of the province of British Columbia indicates that it is updated annually https://geogratis.gc.ca/api/en/nrcan-rncan/ess-sst/0e497e59-b9d0-4794-aef9-59b52b448c2b.html
The following are the data which constitute the national map.
Geobase 2.0 2
GeoBase - Aboriginal Lands of Canada 14
GeoBase - Canadian Digital Elevation Data 1
GeoBase - Canadian Geodetic Network - Canadian Base Network 1
GeoBase - Canadian Geodetic Network - Federal 2-D Densification Network 1
GeoBase - Canadian Geodetic Network - Federal 3-D Densification Network 1
GeoBase - Canadian Geodetic Network - Primary Vertical Bench Marks 1
GeoBase - Canadian Geographical Names 37
GeoBase - Canadian Geopolitical Boundaries 1
GeoBase - Control Points for Landsat 7 Imagery 1
GeoBase - Federal Electoral Districts 2
GeoBase - GeoBase Orthoimage 2005-2010 5,344
GeoBase - Land Cover, circa 2000-Vector (LCC2000-V) 969
GeoBase - Municipal Boundaries 8
GeoBase - National Hydro Network (NHN) 1,843
GeoBase - National Railway Network (NRWN) 11
GeoBase - National Road Network (NRN) 13
GeoBase - RADARSAT-1 Orthorectified Imagery 5
GeoBase - Raw Imagery GeoBase 2005-2010 5,27","Yes","Yes","Neal Bastek","Tracey P. Lauriault","100"
"01ec6de5-1a9d-4c5e-8b94-f470e28fcc92","global","2015-08-28T10:10:43","2015","ar","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure",,"Yes","https://datospublicos.gov.ar",,,,"Horarios 2015","Trenes Argentinos, through diff commissioners and diff websites.","Yes","Yes","Data is not easy to be found. Data avialable is in pdf.
Some cities have developed apps to read their own data sets in a more friendly way.","Update 2015 - The site of the Nacional Secretary of Transport doesn´t have timetables in open data - https://www.transporte.gov.ar or in the national open data portal:
https://datospublicos.gov.ar.
There is an app to track the line Sarmiento (train) in Buenos Aires
(City and Province) but the data doesn't see to be available to the
public. The application is available at the Ministry of Internal
Affairs: https://www.mininterior.gob.ar/tramitesyservicios/apps.php
Update 2015 - There are different websites for each line (commissioned) with the time table. Trains are regulated by National Interior Minitstery.
https://www.google.com.ar/webhp?sourceid=chrome-instant&ion=1&espv=2&ie=UTF-8#q=horarios%20de%20trenes
There is also a site & timetable for long distance trains: https://www.sateliteferroviario.com.ar/horarios/
(This is a submission by Yamila Garcia)
","Yes","No","Paula Alzualde","Paula Alzualde","45"
"5ca021c4-d5c6-4d89-92b7-ec0d4bf5b9e0","global","2015-09-24T06:22:14","2015","sg","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.nea.gov.sg/anti-pollution-radiation-protection/air-pollution-control/psi/trend-charts-by-pollutants",,,,"trend Charts by Pollutants","National Environment Agency","Yes","Yes","checked
the dont have Monitoring station Volatile organic compounds (VOCs) ","The URL does not lead directly to the data, it is required to manually locate the Air Pollution data (for instance via the site map). Pollutants data seems to only be available in simple html, and is therefore not machine readable nor available in bulk. Some entries (for instance Sulphur Dioxide SO2 Emission Inventory) show numbers from 2010, so not deemed up-to-date either.
*Data didn't change*","Yes","No","Zhi Yuan Lim","yar michl","45"
"d1a343e6-55ca-46d9-8529-599a702f7a67","global","2015-09-28T06:24:11","2015","kh","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","checked
in document fromt 2006 from https://theasthmafiles.org/node/741 (https://theasthmafiles.org/) it say that in Cambodia thare is one Air Quality Monitoring station only through requests or as a component of presentations and reports on environmental
management
","Data not found from Ministry of Environment website https://www.moe.gov.kh/ and translation in English is empty. Foreign visitors need to have someone who can speak Khmer in order to find something from the website.","Yes","No","anonymous","yar michl","0"
"9a053ce0-30fb-489f-9809-2d554a1791ed","global","2015-09-24T05:41:57","2015","id","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.bmkg.go.id/BMKG_Pusat/Kualitas_Udara/Informasi_Partikulat.bmkg",,"https://data.go.id/persyaratan-penggunaan.html",,"Informasi Partikulat (PM10)","Indonesian Department of Meteorology, Climatology and Geophysics.","Yes","Yes","checked
the orgnil link was for data from the
https://data.go.id/dataset/data-indeks-kualitas-lingkungan-hidup Ministry of Environment and Forestry and was in excal Excel for year 2009-2011","Data aggregated into national environmental index and published annually with 1 year delay (e.g. 2011 report published on December 2012)
add by yaron
https://www.bmkg.go.id/BMKG_Pusat/Default.bmkg
10 stations located in major cities across Indonesia are measuring in real-time PM10 pollution
the user cna see the data but not to donwload in a data machine readable
the data is by the Indonesian Department of Meteorology, Climatology and Geophysics.","Yes","No","Yefta Sutanto","yar michl","65"
"656d746e-b1fd-4715-8edb-430619627afa","global","2015-09-19T11:35:01","2015","ch","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.bafu.admin.ch/luft/luftbelastung/blick_zurueck/datenabfrage/index.html?lang=en","CSV,HTML,PNG",,,"Data of the National Air Pollution Monitoring Network","Federal Office for the Environment","Yes","Yes","checked","Any reproduction requires prior written consent, as per [Terms and Conditions][1] of the Federal Authorities. The [Swiss Federal Geoportal](https://www.geo.admin.ch/internet/geoportal/en/home.html) provides other pollutant geo-datasets, some of which are also indexed in the Federal Open Government Data Portal, such as waterway [Catchment data](https://opendata.admin.ch/en/dataset/ch-bafu-wasser-entnahme).
[1]: https://www.disclaimer.admin.ch/terms_and_conditions.html","Yes","No","Oleg Lavrovsky","yar michl","60"
"8f635455-4882-40e0-b127-0ad0172150d8","global","2015-09-25T14:17:44","2015","de","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.umweltbundesamt.de/en/data/current-concentrations-of-air-pollutants-in-germany","CSV","https://www.thru.de/nutzungsbedingungen/?L=de",,"Current concentrations of air pollutants in Germany","Federal environment agency","Yes","Yes","checked
the Monitoring stations dont have data on on VOCs
it was origin link to data of emissions from factory https://www.thru.de/ations no data for
","PortalU is a central portal for environment data including sources at the national and the federal state level. The portal aggregates metadata and links to decentralized datasets and services: https://www.portalu.de - however, the cooperation between the federal states and national government has been terminated, PortalU will go offline on December 31, 2014.
Data on air and water pollution can be found at the the German version of the European Pollutant Release and Transfer Register, https://www.thru.de. It allows searching for a specific site, company or field of industry (https://www.thru.de/search/?no_cache=1) as well as downloading the entire database in bulk (https://www.thru.de/fileadmin/SITE_MASTER/content/Dokumente/Downloads/PRTR-Bundle_Herbst-2014_rev1.zip). Searches can be stored as PDF or Excel files, map features can be obtained via WMS. The database is updated twice per year, every April and October. The database covers 2012 as the most recent year, which is due to the rather complicated European reporting system. The most recent update was in October 2014.
The terms and conditions are a bit unclear, as they mainly refer to general use of the site (https://www.thru.de/nutzungsbedingungen/). The terms also state that any use of the data is okay as long as the source is attributed and content is not altered or manipulated. I would interpret this as: ""You shall not change values in the database, but everything else is alright"", especially because thru.de has an own article on its site claiming they are open data (https://www.thru.de/thrude/auswertung/top-thema/thrude-ist-open-data/).","Yes","Yes","walter palmetshofer","yar michl","100"
"f07833c0-fed7-42fb-9aa7-313b8e378f10","global","2014-10-19T09:52:22","2014","ba","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.izbori.ba/Default.aspx?CategoryID=48&Lang=3&Mod=0",,,,,"Centralna izborna komisija","Yes","Yes","Submission accepted with minor corrections (publisher name, dataset name, URL, available in bulk). Comment not timely anymore.",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Stevan Gostojić","45"
"88cfc655-514d-4ce4-ae87-25db2e91218a","global","2014-11-26T22:41:28","2014","ba","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.sllist.ba/pretraga_simple_1.htm",,,,,"JP NIO Službeni list Bosne i Hercegovine","Yes","Yes","See comments for details.","The data (actually, PDF files) does not seem available on a timely basis: indeed, the website seems to provide legislative texts for 2013 latest. The website does not have a clearly stated intellectual property framework, therefore the informaiton is not considered openly licensed.","Yes","No","Rayna St","Rayna St","35"
"01c307e9-510c-4b64-ba0b-9470bd4118d0","global","2015-09-15T16:29:55","2015","il","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.svivaaqm.net/api/stations?type=json","XML, JSON",,,"National air monitoring array | מערך ניטור אויר ארצי","Israel Ministry of Envirunmental Protection","Yes","Yes","correct","There is a description of the API for developers
https://www.sviva.gov.il/subjectsEnv/SvivaAir/AirQualityData/NationalAirMonitoing/Pages/Developers.aspx
There are two options for the API -
XML: www.svivaaqm.net/api/stations
JSON: https://www.svivaaqm.net/api/stations?type=json
In addition, The Israeli Ministry for Environment Protection provides a fairly primitive system (in Hebrew) for displaying aggregated emissions' data on a map. The website and the data it contains are property of the Ministry of Environmental Protection and the State of Israel:
https://www.sviva.gov.il/PRTRIsrael/Pages/default.aspx","Yes","No","ido ivri","yar michl","70"
"c93ebc76-cec0-49f5-8e20-e6c0b5e43532","global","2014-10-19T10:10:09","2014","ba","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.sllist.ba/glasnik/glavni%20meni2014.htm",,,,,"Private web dev/design company from Serbia","Yes","Yes","The submission is accepted. As far as the reviewer knows, the official list of postcodes and the corresponding geospatial locations is not available.","The official data is not available. However, the list of postcodes without corresponding geospatial locations is available at https://www.post.ba/download/popis_ureda.pdf.","Yes","No","anonymous","Stevan Gostojić","0"
"924f8443-b3f0-441a-b62b-9f58e5fc413c","global","2014-10-19T09:47:31","2014","ba","spending","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The submission is accepted. As far as the reviewer knows, no data on transaction-level government spending is available. ","There is no detailed data about government spending.","Yes","No","anonymous","Stevan Gostojić","0"
"a61369e9-5060-49f0-a2ae-0da493bcce3d","global","2014-11-07T07:49:03","2014","it","timetables","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","accepted","The situation of public transport in Italy is not homogeneous
Each agency is working on a regional level and with its policies
Many of them publish on google transit, but do not release as open date.
The only national coverage is given to transport by train, but the data are not open.","Yes","No","Maurizio Napolitano","Maurizio Napolitano","0"
"fa6baa50-acec-40ae-a417-caef522018f6","global","2014-10-29T15:47:00","2014","bj","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Information was verified and validated, no information on data find.","No public transportation system at national level or in the capital.","Yes","No","Pierre Chrzanowski","Mamadou Diagne","0"
"0c3bb45f-438e-4e12-a28e-7e040794a9ed","global","2014-11-19T22:17:09","2014","gt","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","NO DATA","As per wikitravel:
There is a rail network but, aside from the occasional steam charter aimed at tourist groups, no trains - neither freight nor passenger - have run since 2007.
https://wikitravel.org/en/Guatemala
There seem to be no major government operated or commissioned bus services, timetables are found on private company websites.","Yes","No","anonymous","Oscar Montiel","0"
"04e785b8-ff52-47f2-9d15-56451b9633b2","global","2014-11-19T11:11:18","2014","ci","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.sntri.com.tn/html_fr/tarif_horaire_sntri.php",,,,"La Société Nationale de Transport Interurbain est une entreprise publique placée sous la tutelle du Ministère du Transport","Société Nationale de Transport Interurbai","Yes","Yes","Research is thorough. Approved. ","I have done a significant amount of investigation and these are my conclusions:
- No data appears to be available directly from the Ministry of Transport - https://www.transports.gouv.ci/
- Data would most like be available from the ""STRUCTURES SOUS TUTELLES"" (Independent Bodies over which the government has authority)
- Itinerary information is available from the Société Nationale de Transport Interurbain's website: https://www.sntri.com.tn/html_fr/presentation_sntri.php
- Itinerary Information is available from the Société de Transport Abidjanais website https://www.sotra.ci/www/index.php?rub=itin
","Yes","No","Katelyn Rogers","Mor Rubinstein","35"
"82305fa4-9224-44c0-bf3b-98e378d1339a","global","2015-07-22T07:58:06","2013","tc","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"There is no public transport of any kind in the Turks & Caicos Is.. ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","0"
"1a696535-d090-4344-8da9-54303972ad4b","global","2014-10-20T13:30:34","2014","tz","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Correct",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Joachim Mangilima","0"
"fb9e77d3-0a77-4417-8d50-6b4b9875fdbe","global","2013-10-09T15:16:40","2013","ky","timetables","Yes","Unsure","Yes","No","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.caymanislands.ky/planatrip/transportation.aspx",,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"only bus routes and start time listed on government tourism website:
https://www.caymanislands.ky/planatrip/transportation.aspx Buses are mainly used by islanders going to and from work, although visitors who have endless patience and plenty of time to get around also take advantage of them. George Town has had bus service since 1998. A modern terminal adjacent to the Public Library on Edward Street in the center of George Town serves as the dispatch point for buses to all districts. In total, there are 38 minibuses serving eight routes. The most useful line runs from George Town along Seven Mile Beach every 20 minutes during the day. Bus service runs daily from 6am to midnight, with most fares costing CI$1.50 to CI$3. https://www.frommers.com/destinations/caymanislands/0177020156.html#ixzz2hEpbMysl
Buses serve all the main points on the island, including Seven Mile Beach, West Bay, Bodden Town, East End, and North Side. There is no central number to call, since most of the buses are independently operated. For complaints and feedback, call tel. 345/945-5100, though often you'll get only a recording. ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","25"
"0ce1d814-d9bf-4beb-96a8-91a7010d76fe","global","2014-11-26T22:26:24","2014","ba","budget","Yes","Unsure","Yes","Unsure","Yes","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,,"JP NIO Službeni list Bosne i Hercegovine","Yes","Yes","Accepted.","No data per se was identified. The numbers available (https://www.sluzbenilist.ba/page/akt/kIUxjdNqytk=) are inscribed in a legal text and thus do not constitute a dataset as there is not even a table associated. I thus suggest the indicator to be revised as suggested in order to reflect these considerations.","Yes","No","Rayna St","Rayna St","35"
"f9dd0966-d86b-4314-ac3b-a418208db0a7","global","2014-10-30T15:29:56","2014","pa","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"The metropolitan bus service MiBus, https://www.mibus.com.pa/, only contain routes without times.
The Website for the national Bus Transport System is under construction.
https://www.grantnt.com/","Yes","No","Carlos Raul Piad T","Mariel García M","0"
"421645b3-53ec-4dc3-920d-9c1b5bc72ec7","global","2014-08-06T21:53:19","2014","py","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.mca.gov.py/toa1.htm","HTML",,"2009",,"Municipalidad de Asunción - Terminal de Ómnibus de Asunción","Yes","Yes",,"This refers only to Intercity Bus timetables, which are regulated at national level, but the timetibles are pubished by the Central Bus Station at Asuncion
Data Quality [Content] (4): The data is not complete, only long distance trips are listed (more than 20km). Metropolitan area data are missing, only the older versions from the dataset are complete. A full list of all transports is needed.
Data Quality [Structure] (4): The data is not well structured, and is very difficult to process due to the irregular syntax.
Contacts:
Terminal de Ómnibus de Asunción - +595 21 551740 - +595 21 551741
Setama - +595 21 664 077 - https://www.setama.gov.py
Dinatran - +595 21 582 145 - +595 21 582 990 - https://www.dinatran.gov.py/
","Yes","No","Julio Daniel Reyes","Juan Pane","35"
"fc2372b7-c0b4-4128-b98d-1b73f30f3bb5","global","2014-12-14T20:09:27","2014","gb","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.atoc.org/rail-industry-data",,"https://data.atoc.org/licence-restrictions",,"Timetable Data","Translink NI Railways, Association of Train Operating Companies","Yes","Yes",,"Generally public transport in the UK is run by private companies, with some government or municipality regulation. Great Britain (England, Scotland and Wales) national passenger rail timetable information is available on https://data.atoc.org/rail-industry-data and updated weekly; registration is required but free, and once registered the data can be downloaded in bulk under CC-BY UK ported (checked 20 Oct 2013). Fares data is available from the same source under the same licence. Daily schedules of all trains and real-time running information (down to individual signalling events) is available on https://datafeeds.networkrail.co.uk under a licence based on UK OGL v1.
Public transport timetables for bus, light rail, tram and ferry services in Great Britain (but not national rail or coach services) is at https://data.gov.uk/dataset/traveline-national-dataset; this dataset is updated weekly, can be downloaded in bulk and is licensed under the UK OGL v2. An open data source for (privately operated) national coach services or for rail and bus services in the devolved province of Northern Ireland is not known. Data is provided by Translink NI Railways: https://www.translink.co.uk/Services/NI-Railways/Routes--Timetables/All-Timetables/
It cannot be downloaded in bulk and is not provided in a machine readable format (only PDF). There was posted a freedom to information request on the What-do-they-know portal: https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/availability_of_timetable_statio but it was not successful (data could not be released).
Also a general problem is that both data providers are private entities and not an official government related source.
There is a community working on the open rail data and helping to make it easier to use with documentation: https://nrodwiki.rockshore.net/ List of Open Data Releases: https://nrodwiki.rockshore.net/index.php/OpenDataReleases","Yes","Yes","Peter Hicks","Peter Hicks","100"
"23fa2e00-ee11-4c44-b5e7-25e2de63f1bb","global","2014-11-05T08:32:18","2014","gh","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Added information to the entry. ","There is only one type of dataset for transport in Ghana - train. I could not find any information about buses. Data is not machine readable, not publicly licensed of updated on a regular basis, abhttps://www.fahrplancenter.com/GhanaTimings.html","Yes","No","Andrews Otoo","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"a8da971e-b2fb-4acd-8c78-86a5da81897c","global","2014-10-14T06:12:24","2014","fr","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://ressources.data.sncf.com/explore/?refine.theme=Horaires+et+itinéraires","GTFS",,"2012",,"SNCF","Yes","Yes","I agree with the revision : data are up to date and now published on a regular basis.","The data available is not complete, only Transilien, Intercités and TER lines are provided and not the main fast TGV lines. Also the licence under which it is released is an internal rewriting of the french ODbL with modifications that make it unsure whether it is actually OpenDefinition compliant.
*Revision: the data are updated on a weekly basis for Transilien and every two months for TER and Intercités. So the data is provided on a timely and up to date basis.*","Yes","No","anonymous","Pierre Chrzanowski","70"
"48e660f8-15ca-4264-b53b-8fb11dc9ba4f","global","2014-10-11T17:01:02","2014","ge","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.railway.ge/?web=1&action=page&p_id=479&lang=eng",,,,,"Georgian National Railway","Yes","Yes","Agree.","The schedule given above is a general schedule of all trains; it doesn't contain schedule information for arrival and departure times for all stations that a train stops at. This page allows users to see departure and arrival times for all stations, but it is not available in bulk; the starting/ending stations must be filled in individually:
https://www.railway.ge/samg/searchTrains.aspx?lang=en-US
A copyright notice specifying ""Copyright 2014 Georgian Railway. All Rights Reserved"" is at the bottom of most timetable pages, although some pages have no copyright notice at all.
Georgian Railway is a government-owned corporation in Georgia.","Yes","No","Derek Dohler","Mathias Huter","45"
"20030381-357a-4fc9-a1a7-111e2d572570","global","2014-10-29T16:45:50","2014","bg","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.sofiatraffic.bg/bg/transport/virtual-tables","HTML",,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission accepted with several amendments reflecting the current situation. Comments are aimed to give the needed nuance.","The data is mostly available for the capital Sofia. It's not in an open format, but there is a way to interface with the transportation company's website and is being actively used by several website offering route information and timetables. There are similar websites in other cities, but they mostly rely on static manually entered information on timetables and routes. There is a (mostly) crowdsourced) website allowing search of inter-city busses, but they don't offer data export. The state train company offers search for train routes, but also no export. The data could be scraped in some cases, but in others session information causes great difficulties. Whichever the website considered, the data is systematically the property of the institution that operates the website. It is unclear how other websites access this information but on the original websites, it is impossible to download the data in bulk and it is copyrighted by the respective institution.","Yes","No","Boyan Yurukov","Rayna St","20"
"01feaa75-5620-4ba6-be09-e5211cf72e2f","global","2014-10-30T19:52:11","2014","ec","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,"Not from the government, but from private bus companies, and not all of them have a website. In example: https://www.panamericana.ec/web/index.php/es/nuestras-rutas/rutas","Yes","Yes","The information provided is quite useful; however, I did edit this submission because the data comes from corporations, not the government.","Public transport services in Ecuador are privately managed. There are no national-level government operated public transport services. Trains are operated by the government, though these are used only for tourism services and not for public transportation. There are other city-level public transport services operated or commissioned by local governments, like Metrovía in Guayaquil and Trolebus in Quito. This question was answered considering privately operated national-level public transport services (interprovincial buses). Most timetables are available in printed form, and some bus companies have it published on their websites.","Yes","No","Eduardo Bejar","Mariel García M","0"
"4f12b3f4-9ded-4ba5-8e99-346c7a9a7bdc","global","2014-10-18T04:05:39","2014","cr","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.aresep.go.cr/index.php/inicio/mapas-de-rutas-de-autobuses",,,,,"Intendencia de Transporte ARESEP","Yes","Yes","Accepted submission, but edited to state there's no government data on timetables. ","There is scattered information about transportation and timetables. From the government, we only get information on routes – https://www.aresep.go.cr/index.php/inicio/mapas-de-rutas-de-autobuses
There is no national timetables managed by the government, but by each company that have a licensed route. There is information for the train in the Gran Area Metropolitanea (Great Metropolitan Area), but it might not represent the reality. To access this information go to www.incofer.go.cr It may not be up to date.
Each company may have online information about their service.
In many cases, information available might not be accurate to the reality. not available in one single URL
There are maps by a regulator agency, by route and in jpg. and not all routes have a map.","Yes","No","Ignacio Alfaro","Mariel García M","0"
"3da8bfea-811e-4490-b10c-de60c7f7f491","global","2014-11-12T06:50:49","2014","fi","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://developer.matka.fi/pages/en/home.php",,"https://portal.liikennevirasto.fi/sivu/www/f/aineistopalvelut/verkkopalvelut/avoimen_datan_kayttoehdot/avoimen_datan_lisenssi_eng",,,,"Yes","Yes","ok","No changes since 2013
See also the local public transport data from the Helsingi region at https://dev.hsl.fi/","Yes","Yes","anonymous","Antti Jogi Poikola","100"
"39c2aa08-6476-4b8a-9fb0-d3ebb4543558","global","2014-10-31T19:21:13","2014","se","timetables","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.trafiklab.se/api/gtfs-sverige","GTFS","https://www.trafiklab.se/api/gtfs-sverige/lisens",,,,"Yes","Yes","No public available since a key is required to access data. Licens regarded open although there are minor restrictions to the CC-BY license.","Available in GTFS format. License is a modification of CC-BY with some limitations on areas of use.. Unsure if this counts as open data.","Yes","No","Peter Krantz","Niels Erik Kaaber Rasmussen","95"
"cde9de5a-3d5f-4bb8-9c85-e077c8d0fddf","global","2014-10-17T15:52:18","2014","ko","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Because I know that the data doesnt exist.",,"Yes","No","Arianit Dobroshi","Besfort Guri","0"
"452ee6dd-c206-4d1a-acff-7cca5ba17024","global","2015-08-19T23:07:09","2015","bf","health","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Idriss TINTO","Idriss TINTO","0"
"928fe3ba-0c04-49da-b782-2a05b7e84815","global","2014-10-29T08:12:08","2014","bf","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://sotraco-bf.net/spip.php?rubrique11",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Yes, government do not operate national-level public transport services"," The government do not operate,and do not regulate any national-level public transport services.","Yes","No","anonymous","Idriss TINTO","0"
"f566eeb8-2594-4409-a0bc-aa2e3d925033","global","2014-10-26T17:16:50","2014","no","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure",,"Yes","https://labs.rutebok.no/","JSON, XML","https://data.norge.no/nlod/en",,,"Norsk Reiseinformasjon AS (NRI)","Yes","Yes","Disagree with the submitter on changing status from Yes to Unsure on whether data is available.
However, the entry points to transport timetables for the Oslo (capital) area. I changed it to point to the national transport timetable database which is open data and has an API. All providers of person-transport are required to export their data to this database.","NRI took over the responsibility of providing national travel data in 2013, and they're still in a process of getting more data (accessibility, realtime etc), more frequent updates, expanding their API etc.
All public and private companies providing personal transport are required to export data to NRI, and they as of 2014-11-19 have 214 companies in their database, according to their API.
Whether data is available in bulk is uncertain. This depends on the definition. I've been strict here, since it was not trivial to download the raw base data for all routes in Norway with the current API-documentation. You can however easily list all transport companies, the routes they provide, search to/from and get trip-results, query for further details on each journey etc.
Note1: the license is not prominently mentioned on the website. It is mentioned on the form you have to fill out to get an API-key.
Note2: many of the local providers have their own APIs with more functionality, real time data etc. Most notably labs.ruter.no
(Reviewer-comments, 2014)","Yes","Yes","Geirmund Knutsen","Bergheimivar L","90"
"485e3126-9fc1-4845-bb80-7c718aba939e","global","2014-10-30T10:23:18","2014","pk","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure",,"Yes","https://www.railways.gov.pk/gop/index.php?q=aHR0cDovLzE5Mi4xNjguNzAuMTM2L3JhaWx3YXlzd2ViL2ZybURldGFpbHMuYXNweD9vcHQ9bmV3cyZpZD0xMDk%3D","HTML",,,,"Ministry of Railways, Government of Pakistan.","Yes","Yes","Although the link is provided at the official website of Ministry of Railways but it is not working.","Link is not working and there is no alternative link at the moment.
No changes from 2013. ","Yes","No","Mujtaba Hussain","Nouman Nazim","45"
"56e3da94-34e8-4567-92a2-cb21096ccb46","global","2014-11-03T13:44:21","2014","uy","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://catalogodatos.gub.uy/dataset/horarios-interdepartamentales-de-omnibus_verano2014","CSV","https://datos.gub.uy/wps/wcm/connect/856cc1804db0463baa8bea01b72d8394/terminos-catalogodatos.pdf","2013","Buses timetable (summer 2014)","Ministerio de Transporte y Obras Públicas","Yes","Yes","Submitted information is accurate","Metadata also available as a text file in spanish which describes the csv files. For each column in the csv, a description is provided.","Yes","Yes","anonymous","Etcheverryorena L","100"
"9d70ad4f-7242-471c-a07d-cc0a9d72de10","global","2014-12-23T08:50:51","2014","ch","timetables","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.fahrplanfelder.ch/de/fahrplandaten/","HRDF (HAFAS timetable export)","https://www.fahrplanfelder.ch/fileadmin/fap_daten_test/141214_Nutzungsbed_Fahrpland_de.pdf",,,,"Yes","Yes","Changing according to civil society request. ","Public transportation in Switzerland is run by a private company (SBB/CFF/FFS) with government regulation (see [federal railroads law][1], in French). Open timetable data that is **not** supported by a Swiss transport agency can be found in an unofficial API: [transport.opendata.ch][2]
Since beginning of 2014, the SBB/CFF/FFS has started to published an export of the full timetable for Switzerland bus, train and other public transport modes on the Info+ system. This data is available for download after registration, and can be freely used and republished as long as the data is kept up to date and links are provided to the publisher. [geOps AG][3] also provides a GTFS feed of this data.
[1]: https://www.admin.ch/opc/fr/classified-compilation/19983388/index.html
[2]: https://transport.opendata.ch
[3]: https://gtfs.geops.ch/ ","Yes","No","Oleg Lavrovsky","Mor Rubinstein","95"
"d619ba64-664e-4096-a949-c01f5be4c101","global","2014-10-30T21:49:48","2014","us","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure",,"Yes","https://www.amtrak.com/train-schedules-timetables",,,,,"National Railroad Passenger Corporation (AMTRAK)","Yes","Yes","Open Licence changed from unsure to no, ""©2014 National Railroad Passenger Corporation""","National Railroad Passenger Corporation, doing business as Amtrak, is a publicly funded railroad service operated and managed as a for-profit corporation. Amtrak provides the most meaningful national-scale transportation timetables, as the United States has no national bus service that is publicly funded. For information on local transportation data, see: https://www.citygoround.org/agencies/us/?public=all
Additional transportation data is available from the US Department of Transportation at https://catalog.data.gov/dataset?organization=dot-gov and more at the Data.gov Safety community at https://safety.data.gov. This includes transportation venues, locations, safety records, on-time arrivals, etc. https://data.gov However this question is about national bus and train timetables which are harder to find. There is also a question as to whether in the US national bus and train are in fact government or privately run. ","Yes","No","Rebecca Williams - XFB","Katelyn Rogers","45"
"b6aeb5bd-84bd-47bc-8c18-43e89007ee15","global","2014-10-28T14:06:06","2014","gr","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","No data found."," ","Yes","No","Charalampos Bratsas","Andreas P","0"
"7865a208-da6b-411e-98e4-970a9874d912","global","2014-10-29T18:44:57","2014","th","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://home.transport.co.th/en/tcl-services/bus-schedule.html",,"https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/deed.th",,,"Transport Co.,Ltd","Yes","Yes","This dataset is available for bus transportable only, train, airplane are available through another sources which I've put in further information section.","Transport Co.,Ltd is Thai state enterprise that provide buses service between Bangkok to every region of Thailand included cross borders bus service.
There are no centralised data portal for all transportable mode, it still scattered based on responsible agencies. Additional sources for another mode of transportation are:
Train: https://www.railway.co.th/checktime/checktime.asp
Airplane: https://www.airportthai.co.th/main/th/real-time-flight-schedule
","Yes","No","Klaikong Vaidhyakarn","Patipat Susumpow","75"
"d082925b-9322-47f6-ad68-72505d17e9d1","global","2014-10-29T12:51:41","2014","bd","companies","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Data does exist, but not available to the public. ","The information for publicly quoted companies can be found on the websites of Dhaka Stock Exchange (DSE) (https://www.dsebd.org/company%20listing.php) and Chittagong Stock Exchange (CSE)(https://www.cse.com.bd/company_info_url.php). It is to be noted that DSE and CSE is fully under government control. It looks like relevant information for all companies is gathered on https://www.roc.gov.bd/ but cannot see how to access the information. Also application available but not any registered company list available in this website. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","20"
"ca2b30e7-681f-4f96-9513-14ff9ad78b12","global","2014-10-29T12:45:51","2014","bd","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.ecs.gov.bd/English/MenuTemplate1.php?Parameter_MenuID=19&ByDate=0&Year=",,,,,"Election Commission Bangladesh ","Yes","Yes","reviewed and updated the information.","Though it is mentioned in the site footer that the site is updated recently, but the last election result is not available there. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Nasir Khan","35"
"b4c22f0e-db8f-4823-9714-fe6a76ed560b","global","2013-10-08T15:03:35","2013","ye","timetables","Unsure","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"In the Official website of the Ministry of Transport: https://www.mot.gov.ye/ there's a link to the official website of the Instance in charge of Transport Management https://www.ltaa.gov.ye/mainltaa.php?action=sitescom which gives a list of transport companies like this one https://www.yemitco.com/contants.asp?CBT=1&SeIdN=1 but no transport timetables available. ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","0"
"ae150965-7b5a-468a-8dc4-8a20653d0c42","global","2013-10-08T15:49:03","2013","ye","map","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://www.moh.gov.ye/english/data.html",,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"Data needs specific software products to be accessed as mentioned in the website :
""You need ArcView or ArcCatalog to view the maps or access the data."" As these appear to be proprietary software, it was not possible to check if it's compliant with the data expected.","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","0"
"48d5638c-1e2e-452e-9992-fe6b16b72836","global","2013-10-07T11:10:29","2013","bh","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.bahrain.bh/pubportal/wps/portal/!ut/p/c5/hY5LDoJAEETPwgm6-Q1sGwgwCYzyU2BDJtEYjAIhBoXTCwdAq5aVV1VQw-pOTu1Nvtq-kw8ooWaNqTKukoHBoSAdeRqT7mqejgVb84o1bkChYUWItufbqDkm4wl6iNz8Q5-hRKPJ7vYQz68yWtwpvy_JHOf8E3tcE_l5ESI6Xk5p4RAdOzlOK1Nvrb82txx3RAgi7J9XyOQIFdTW7j_VghwqH4ZnMQ3hWxApyhem7CPJ/dl3/d3/L0lDU0dZcHBpZ3BSQ2dwUkNncFJBL29Ob2dBRUlZSWdCQUFJUkFDQUJSaEVBSUNGT1FZRGdwQ2tyQ0FFQUxSdEdWcXpyT1ZZQSEvNEMxYjhVQXBNa0VvaFNaTUpRaWt5VVNqRUEhIS83XzUxNkkxQTQwR09VQTMwSVJNQTNDMkQzMDE3LyUwX3JsdmlkLmpzcC9fcnZpcC8lME1PVEJ1c1NjaGVkdWxlYW5kUm91dGVJbmZvcm1hdGlvbi5qc3AvX3JhcC9wY19NT1RCdXNTY2hlZHVsZVZpZXcuZ29Ub1RyaXBEZXRhaWxzVmlldy90cmlwSURTZWxlY3RlZC82/",,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"The Ministry of Transportation has a link to a webpage that provides bus timetables and routes. This information is available both in Arabic and English (https://www.bahrain.bh/pubportal/wps/portal/!ut/p/c5/hY5JDoJAFETP4gn-Z2rYfiBKJ3SLDApsSCcaI5EhhLTK6cUDqFXLyqsqqGF1r_Ttqubb0Ks7lFCzxjEYN8jG3b4gC3kqyArM0MKCrXnFmmBHke3GiF649dD0HcYPGCJy5w99ghLtJmu9UbzmMl4CnbfL4SVy_hQhN2V-WqSMk_MxLXyipFeTXpn60_pr85PjFxGCjIbuApmaoILa_frPcCGHyoexK_QYPSTRZvMGvWOP0A!!/dl3/d3/L0lHSkovd0RNQU5rQUVnQSEhL1lCZncvZW4!/ ). Given the size of Bahrain, no trains exist. The website and the data it contains are are the Ministry's property, thus data is considered non-open.","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","35"
"3d50c8ab-5c23-48bd-8b85-71e453d5feb9","global","2014-10-22T08:34:17","2014","ma","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.oncf.ma/Pages/Accueil.aspx",,,,,"Tramway Casablanca, Tramway Rabat, ONDA (Office National des Aéroports), ONCF (national railway) and CTM (Compagnie de Transport au Maroc).","Yes","Yes","Submission complemented and fixed. Comment added to clarify details.","Data is partially available: train, tramway and plane schedules are posted on the official website of the respective websites (https://www.tram-way.ma/fr/ ; https://www.casatramway.ma/ ; https://www.onda.ma/ ; https://www.oncf.ma/Pages/Accueil.aspx ;
https://www.ctm.ma/). Data is not provided at all. The visitor can only send queries through a web interface. Each website (thus, institution) has its own copyright on each website.
Regarding whether information is provided on a timely and up-to-date basis: One would imagine so as these are frequently used services. Yet no indication is available to inform on when the last update was done.","Yes","No","Anass Beddi","Rayna St","35"
"ea96d178-2ce6-4f3b-a05e-3fa6c18f4094","global","2014-11-20T09:55:30","2014","tn","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.sncft.com.tn/index.php","HTML",,,,"SNCFT & SNTRI","Yes","Yes","Accepted with minor amendments, see comments for more details.","Train: data can be available via a search engine in HTML format https://www.sncft.com.tn/index.php
Bus: data can be available via a search engine in HTML format https://www.sntri.com.tn/html_fr/result_tarif_horaire_sntri.php
Data updates are not clearly indicated thus it is unknown whether data is provided on a timely and up-to-date basis.","Yes","No","Katelyn Rogers","Rayna St","35"
"50b88eba-dd19-4fcd-8cf3-0523a1372ccc","global","2014-11-27T12:40:19","2014","nl","timetables","Yes","Yes","No","No","Yes","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Changed to not publicly available. ","- There's a legal provision that says that if someone asks for the data the transport provider is obliged to give it (in Dutch: Besluit personenvervoer 2000, Hoofdstuk 1, Artikel 10.)
- There's a private entity '9292' which licenses out the data they've got from all the providers in a non-open way (current old entry)
- There's another, more community-oriented grassroots entity 'OpenOV' that is providing the data under CC-0 (proposed new entry).
Neither of these entries are officially valid for the Index, because they are not from a government source. So should technically be rejected. However, there is a legal provision that gives people the right to obtain the data, even though they don't provide it themselves","Yes","No","Stefan de Konink","Mor Rubinstein","35"
"05487503-ab6f-46e0-975b-d6798cc3599a","global","2013-10-07T15:42:54","2013","gg","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.gov.gg/buses","PDF",,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"outsourced public contract:
www.buses.gg ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","45"
"1826054d-adcd-47bf-975c-04ec26146a5d","global","2015-04-16T13:16:00","2015","tj","timetables","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission is correct and verified",,"Yes","No","Asomiddin Atoev","Daniel Dietrich","5"
"45b4d9b4-8668-4ed2-a327-83a8415124b9","global","2014-11-26T20:27:02","2014","om","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.nfc.om/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=88&Itemid=496",,,,,"National Ferries Company (NFC)","Yes","Yes","Submission accepted, please see comments for details and needed nuance.","The assessment was performed with data for the National Ferries Company data; the NFC is a government-owned company for sea transport between major cities in Oman. The data was marked as not up-to-date as the website explicitly states: ""Schedule is subject to change, for latest schedule & updates or any queries kindly contact NFC – Call Centre during office office hours on 800 72 000 or (968) 98111162."" Thus, there is no tangible reason to consider that the website provides timely and up-to-date information. Data is available as HTML tables only (static webpages per route). No information was identified regarding fares though.
The other systematic public transportation system available in Oman operated by the government is through the buses of the government-owned Oman National Transport Company. The website of ONTC ( https://www.ontcoman.com/ ) does not provide actual information on fares and routes (https://www.ontcoman.com/booking.php is under construction at the time of review). The available information is on the different services the ONTC provides (see https://www.ontcoman.com/services.php).","Yes","No","Rayna St","Rayna St","35"
"546a91da-5b89-4c23-8bda-7f2dc45d7d4e","global","2014-10-18T06:18:12","2014","np","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","True. Government data on public transport services are not openly available.","In Nepal, Time Table data for transportation are not available. Government don't directly manage land/terrestrial transportation for the public. We don't have sea transportation. But there is some timetable for long route transportation within the country which, however, is not maintained properly. ","Yes","No","Niroj Panta","Kshitiz Khanal","0"
"f12d1081-5912-4ba9-8ae5-8cc992f2b03b","global","2013-10-04T20:15:58","2013","je","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.gov.je/Travel/Buses/PublicBuses/Pages/RoutesTimetables.aspx","HTML",,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"no rail system
","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","45"
"ba0d3f7a-be60-4259-8758-93581249ab54","global","2014-11-13T06:54:29","2014","kr","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://openapi.tago.go.kr/openapi/service","JSON, XML","https://www.data.go.kr/#/L3B1YnIvcG90L2ZhcS9Jcm9zRmFxTGlzdCRAXjA0MW00NCRAXnNraXBSb3dzPTAkQF5tYXhSb3dzPTEwJEBec2VhcmNoQ29kZT0kQF5zZWFyY2hDbmQ9MCRAXnNlYXJjaFdyZD0=",,,"Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, and Transport","Yes","Yes","It looks good for now.","- National coverage transport data open api.
- The api provide data by xml and json (according to user gudie document, https://www.data.go.kr/#/L2NvbW0vY29tbW9uU2VhcmNoL29wZW5hcGkkQF4wMTJtMSRAXnB1YmxpY0RhdGFEZXRhaWxQaz11ZGRpOjU4ZDllMzIzLTYwMTEtNDVlOC04ZTI1LThmODZiNGEyNGFlMCRAXnNraXBSb3dzPTAkQF5tYXhSb3dzPTEw)
- It adopted open license (must give appropriate credit). by it's not clear which licese/terms is used.","Yes","Yes","Young-Je Lim","영택 홍","90"
"50fa46be-4b1e-49ad-b729-662f66372870","global","2015-07-22T07:58:06","2013","vg","emissions","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"It is uncertain if the data exists. ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","0"
"9d4615c3-47bb-46dd-b4e7-4a3cb8ccd79b","global","2015-07-22T07:58:06","2013","vg","map","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"It is uncertain if the data exists. ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","0"
"f1b72637-6a07-4cad-bd12-ecf434cfab71","global","2015-07-22T07:58:06","2013","vg","companies","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.bvifsc.vg/AreaofSupervision/RegistryofCorporateAffairs/tabid/182/Default.aspx","PDF",,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"information only available offline via the international search request form and a fee:
https://www.bvifsc.vg/AreaofSupervision/RegistryofCorporateAffairs/tabid/182/Default.aspx commercial online services are relatively expensive:
https://www.bvicompanysearches.com/searches-c10453.html ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","20"
"a236ee63-eea1-4bee-af69-17d1df091add","global","2015-07-22T07:58:06","2013","vg","statistics","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Yes","Unsure","No","No",,"No","https://www.dpu.gov.vg/index.php?pagename=Home&menuname=Home","HTML",,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"BVI Development Planning Unit - some basic facts in summary text but most download links are broken:
https://www.dpu.gov.vg/index.php?pagename=Home&menuname=Home
detailed statistics from the financial services regulator:
https://www.bvifsc.vg/en-us/publications/statisticalbulletin.aspx ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","15"
"ff11a328-c2d7-4aab-b8a8-7e642d2d8935","global","2015-07-22T07:58:06","2013","vg","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","No","Unsure","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"only summary and contact details online:
https://www.finance.gov.vg/AboutUs/Departments/BVIPostOffice.aspx
Tortola Central: VG1110, Tortola East: VG1120, Tortola West: VG1130, Anegada: VG1140, Virgin Gorda: VG1150, Jost Van Dyke: VG1160 ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","10"
"19bdf97a-2bff-4ebf-8e43-c7caef0ab93b","global","2015-07-22T07:58:06","2013","vg","elections","Yes","Yes","Unsure","No","Unsure","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"only summary and contact details online:
https://www.bvi.gov.vg/statutory-boards/office-supervisor-elections a local newspaper published election results:
https://www.bviplatinum.net/ELECTION/2011/ ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","10"
"3eb02a44-73a0-43ba-96e2-144e08aab455","global","2015-07-22T07:58:06","2013","vg","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"Lonely Planet:
None of the islands has public bus service.
Ferries are the primary mode of transportation between islands and a great way to meet locals. BVI Welcome (independent):
https://www.bviwelcome.com/ferries.php ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","0"
"7c00a17a-971e-4a59-b57c-3b7dfed240e9","global","2015-07-22T07:58:06","2013","vg","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://finance.gov.vg/Economy/MinistryofFinanceBudgetEstimate.aspx","PDF",,,,,"Yes","Yes",," ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","45"
"151b123d-8f11-4f37-aeb2-f6ee854da1d4","global","2015-07-22T07:58:06","2013","vg","spending","Yes","Yes","Unsure","No","Unsure","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"limited content on government website - annual budget estimates without actual costs or performance reporting ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","10"
"c9e17ab9-bdfc-432e-a278-5a284443124d","global","2015-07-22T07:58:06","2013","vg","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","No","No",,"No","https://finance.gov.vg/Economy/Legislation,PoliciesRegulations.aspx","PDF",,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"unsure about all legislation online
selected legislation - financial services:
https://finance.gov.vg/Economy/Legislation,PoliciesRegulations.aspx
selected legislation - financial services regulator:
https://www.bvifsc.vg/en-gb/legislationlibrary.aspx
","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","15"
"a580ee72-a8c9-40c6-b97e-db2462616aeb","global","2015-07-22T07:58:06","2013","mt","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://rocsupport.mfsa.com.mt/pages/Default.aspx","structured HTML",,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"webscraped by opencorporates.com ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","45"
"453b55cd-b0ab-42ad-b01d-c976de28a332","global","2014-11-26T00:52:01","2014","hu","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.kvvm.hu/olm",,,,,"Hungarian Air Quality Network ","Yes","Yes","Correct.","Data is structured HTML or PDF, per station, for any period up to 90 days in the past. If logged in, you can request for better machine-readable formats CSV/XLS. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Julia Keserű","45"
"df7eb7b5-b932-4eb5-a065-ad31f7dd6ac1","global","2014-11-21T11:50:36","2014","gh","map","Yes","Unsure","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Changed data source. ","Ghana has a land survey office, which is responsible for mapping, but no online. ","Yes","No","Jenny Molloy","Mor Rubinstein","5"
"2828708d-118a-4c0a-b66c-8c885a76ab78","global","2015-02-21T16:52:41","2015","by","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://zip.belpost.by/",,,,"HTML-based database of postcodes divided by region with search interface (not user-friendly)","Belarusian Post, part of Ministry of Communications and Informatisation","Yes","Yes","Accepting so that a new submission can be made to update this (whilst correct, it turns out this data does not have geocodes).","Belpost is government-owned organisation that is responsible for post. The organisation published a catalogue of postcodes: https://zip.belpost.by/.
It is aimed at users who simply search for a postcode but not for those who need to use these data professionally (there is no opportunity to download the postcodes in bulk).","Yes","No","Krystina Shveda","Rufus Pollock","45"
"60e5cb79-1f83-4efd-a612-82e755b89534","global","2014-12-31T19:53:31","2014","cy","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://www.cyprus.gov.cy/portal/portal.nsf/gwp.getCategory?OpenForm&access=0&SectionId=government&CategoryId=Legislations&SelectionId=none&print=0&lang=en","PDF, Word, Excel","https://www.cyprus.gov.cy/portal/portal.nsf/disclaimer_en?OpenForm&access=0&SectionId=citizen&CategoryId=none&SelectionId=home&lang=en",,,,"Yes","Yes",,"Found a page on the government website that shows Cypriot legislations and Government legal documents, sorted into thematic categories. Not sure the information provided is up to date.","Yes","Yes","anonymous","anonymous","90"
"db6c4b8d-d97c-44ad-ac4d-1c91a1d308bf","global","2014-12-04T09:20:44","2014","nz","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.kiwirailscenic.co.nz/long-distance-train-timetables",,,,,"KiwiRail, Intercity, Naked Bus, etc.","Yes","Yes","Information on national bus service included.","There are a lot of long-distance (national-level) coach services offered by private companies (Intercity, Naked Bus, for example). The NZ Transport Agency is the regulator for land transport and provides licenses for operating long-distance buses (https://www.nzta.govt.nz/commercial/passenger/types.html). Currently they don't provide any timetable data on long-distance transport, though. The long-distance bus companies provide timetables on their website, these are not unified in one database, though. Also, it is currently difficult to know, which long-distance coach services with regular timetables exist as there is no registry of all available services.
The national rail network is limited and there are no published data sets, just timetables. Data is provided in non-machine readable format - just HTML.
Metlink data covers Wellington region and is available in GTFS format at https://www.metlink.org.nz/customer-services/general-transit-feed-specification/
Auckland Transport data covers Auckland region and is available in GTFS format from https://at.govt.nz/bus-train-ferry/more-services/google-transit-feed/
","Yes","No","Daniela Mattern","Daniela Mattern","45"
"82c57120-4a09-4a01-9ee2-691e4f74830e","global","2014-12-03T18:50:32","2014","bd","postcodes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,"HTML",,,,,"Yes","Yes","Changed data since there is no geolocation","No mention of licensing so not open data
No geolocation","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"d0ae08b5-041b-4f4f-90de-46fc95b0b40c","global","2014-12-03T18:12:38","2014","rs","postcodes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Geolocation is not matching the dataset definition in the index. Changed accordingly. ","No explicit geospatial information is provided, alithough for each postcode there is a link to a proprietary GIS which displays post office on the map.
According to definition, no visible license means the information is non open.","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"89d54b33-80e0-4955-b0c8-39f5303bdbe4","global","2014-12-01T15:09:06","2014","vi","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Changed the data according to expert review","There are indications that expenditure (and revenue) are collected so the data exists, e.g. the legislative arm publishes aggregated expenditure data (quarterly report): https://www.legvi.org/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=529&Itemid=208 and the internal revenue bureau publishes revenues: https://www.vibir.gov/Collection.html but these are independent efforts it seems.","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"89534e4c-d168-4f2d-996c-59cedd9497c3","global","2014-12-01T13:31:12","2014","gh","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Changed expert review","There is a monthly aggregated data about spending and expenditure from the office of the accountant general. It is not detailed to per transaction data. ","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"aa6e5f62-fe55-4e75-964d-90f61ac45d9d","global","2014-12-01T13:28:26","2014","zm","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Changed according to expert review","The is a quarterly spending report on the Zambian Treasury website: https://www.mofnp.gov.zm/ but that's aggregated data, not transactional.
","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"a98cbbaa-ae2b-4121-9a9b-031a7d830092","global","2014-11-30T22:40:26","2014","rs","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Dataset was reviewed in experts review and was changed from 'unsure' to data exist but available, since the country should have this data as part of their procurement and spending mechanism","As part of the budget, it is possible to find data on total expenditure and expenditure for the current year. Data are related to individual sectors. There is no detailed transactions on a monthly basis.
https://www.trezor.gov.rs/uploads/file/Zakoni/Zakon%20o%20budzetu%20za%202013.pdf
Given there are no detailed monthly transactions available this dataset needs to be marked as not publicly available (but the data seems to be available and digital which is needed to produce the aggregated data).
","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"5eeef6b7-d9e4-4edb-a2d3-f4e83c2e00bd","global","2014-11-30T22:33:53","2014","nz","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.treasury.govt.nz/government/financialstatements/monthend/archive","Excel","https://www.treasury.govt.nz/aboutthissite/crowncopyright",,"Archive of Month End Financial Statements of the Government of New Zealand 2014 to 2000","The Treasury","Yes","Yes","After expert review we changed the data from not existed to exist but not available to the public. ","Data (in Excel format) not at transaction detail, but aggregated monthly for all of government at account item level. Annual figures also available. All individual government agencies also publish online their annual reports, typically in PDF format.","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"febffcc7-b0ff-4099-8302-31c4fc6a750d","global","2014-11-30T22:33:17","2014","bd","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","After expert review we changed the data from not existed to exist but not available to the public. ","A budget is declared every year in the national assembly. But stats regarding the efficiency of the implementation of the budget is not published that openly.
There are PDFs showing aggregate spend but no transactional level information. ","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"657e35cb-47ac-49a4-b7bf-916220fc1934","global","2014-11-30T22:26:18","2014","ht","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","After expert review we changed the data from not existed to exist but not available to the public. This is since there is aggregated data which is composed out of transactions, but these are not shown to the public. ","The Ministry of Economy and Finance provides with budget execution statements on a yearly basis but the report only contains aggregated data not transactional level ones.","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"aa284500-aa90-4157-96e1-625ea4d893e2","global","2013-10-08T14:35:24","2013","ye","spending","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://www.mof.gov.ye/budget/final-accounts.html","PDF",,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"Data about the Government Spending are available but only at high level (the same for Government Budget) that allows to compare what was expected and what really happens. But Government Spending detailed month by month seems to not be available. ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","0"
"7d7b6336-b0c7-4600-b17b-54e6c3c564c5","global","2014-11-30T14:34:03","2014","lt","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Experts review determine this is not transactional data. The submission was changed accordingly. ","The data is available and in a quite some detail, however, majority of it are PDFs and it is not on a transactional level: https://www.finmin.lt/web/finmin//auktualus_duomenys/biudzeto_pajamos/valstybes_biudzetas","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"71ba32e8-4014-41b9-9b42-49015095fca4","global","2014-11-27T18:33:38","2014","gh","legislation","Yes","Yes","No","No","Yes","No","No",,"Yes",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Added old submission","Ghana has a bill archive on the Parliament website - https://www.parliament.gh/publications/36/page/60
However, this archive doesn't contains all laws, but only bills from 2010 onward.","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","35"
"99bd6218-ba47-4c85-8ed3-588aef8307b1","global","2014-11-27T09:00:04","2014","vi","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://viewer.nationalmap.gov/viewer","SHP","https://www.usgs.gov/faq/categories/10154/3550",,"National Map Viewer","U.S. Geological Survey","Yes","Yes","Submissions accepted, although on the date of expert review (27th of Nov 2014) the map viewer and the license website both struggled to load properly. Although in the provided materials there is no evidence for the scale of the maps.","The U.S. Virgin Islands are an insular area of the United States of America and therefore get some services from the United States. The U.S. Geological Survey maintains a map of the islands and is for these purposes regarded as an official government source.
The government of U.S. Virgin Islands do not create, maintain nor publish maps on their own.","Yes","Yes","Daniela Mattern","Daniela Mattern","100"
"29a6ef39-0a01-4928-ac71-6efb407fc43a","global","2014-11-27T08:43:12","2014","ls","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.finance.gov.ls/news/background%20to%20the%202014-15%20budget%20speech.pdf",,,,"BACKGROUND TO THE 2014/15 BUDGET SPEECH","Ministry of Finance ","Yes","Yes","Updating data according to this review. ","Aggregated budget data for current fiscal year 2013/2014 are available in pdf format as part of the budget speech. For fiscal year 2014/2015, there is a document entitled Background to the budget speech containing some estimates and forecasts for revenues and expenditures.
","Yes","No","Pierre Chrzanowski","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"8519736b-71c4-4f5f-be7b-dacb341f8599","global","2014-11-27T07:59:26","2014","nz","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://data.linz.govt.nz/layers/category/topographic/nz-topo-50-data/","GeoTIFF,GeoJPEG,KML,Shapefile,FGDB,DWG,TAB,CSV","https://data.linz.govt.nz/license/attribution-3-0-new-zealand/",,"NZ Topo 50 Data Layers","Land Information New Zealand","Yes","Yes","Submission correct. Only changed the link to the dataset: the priorily linked dataset only represented the coastline of New Zealand.","NZ national map is available as both vector and raster data. Registration required. Some data download volume limits apply.","Yes","Yes","Daniela Mattern","Daniela Mattern","100"
"c1d99e19-3c1b-40d8-8784-998f8f2731db","global","2014-11-26T22:35:44","2014","ba","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://bhas.ba",,,,,"Agencija za statistiku","Yes","Yes","Minor revision + see comments.","The data is available as one-shot PDFs, therefore each file needs to be downloaded individually.","Yes","No","Rayna St","Rayna St","45"
"d3d065b1-13bd-42fa-9d4e-286b6caac94e","global","2014-11-26T22:32:46","2014","ba","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://bizreg.pravosudje.ba/pls/apex/f?p=183:20:1793782965566798",,,,,"Federalno ministarstvo pravde","Yes","Yes","Accepted (minor amendment + see comments for details).","The data seems solely accessible through a web-based search form. It is unclear how often it is updated. It does not seem possible to download the whole registry in bulk. No indication seems to exist on a possible fee to obtain either details or the whole registry, so the data was considered as accessible free of charge as basic information after the web-based query is available for free. The information is not openly licensed as the website seems to be the property of the institution.","Yes","No","Rayna St","Rayna St","45"
"1c0dd5f9-0b88-4647-92bd-c252e953cb3c","global","2014-11-26T15:21:46","2014","zw","spending","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Email has been sent to the Ministry for more information","There are no indication for the existence of the data in the Zimbabwean government. Searches through the finance office website and the government portal didn't show any indication to such data.
","Yes","No","Katelyn Rogers","Katelyn Rogers","0"
"5317860d-7dba-4f30-9386-f92b93c937f9","global","2014-11-26T13:57:14","2014","lt","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Unsure",,"Yes","https://oras.gamta.lt/cms/index",,,,"Years of air quality indicators","Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)","Yes","Yes","The data is available in quite some detail, but it is not accessible in open formats and in bulk. ","The data is fully available, but not in machine-readable formats. It is possible to request full datasets under the FOI legislation by filling FOI request. ","Yes","No","Karolis Granickas","Karolis Granickas","45"
"b72f4fe8-2f35-4470-9bc9-04895839f844","global","2014-11-26T03:06:23","2014","zm","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.mibs.gov.zm/?q=constitution",,,,,"Ministry of Information and Broadcasting","Yes","Yes","Accurate",,"Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Katelyn Rogers","45"
"42f1059f-2fde-4ec9-9c80-aaf06be897cb","global","2014-11-26T03:05:05","2014","zm","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Correct Analysis ","There is a zipcode system in Zambia, yet I couldn't find a public dataset of it.
","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Katelyn Rogers","0"
"46deee77-62ed-43f5-a591-545134f362bb","global","2014-11-26T03:04:06","2014","zm","map","Yes","No","Yes","No","No","No","No",,"Unsure",,,,,,"The Ministry of Lands ","Yes","Yes","Accurate and comprehensive ","The Ministry of Lands sales a national map on it's website. No digital copy was found. https://www.ministryoflands.gov.zm/index.php/services-and-fees","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Katelyn Rogers","10"
"e88e8a5d-1f95-4f6b-a704-81168d062310","global","2014-11-26T03:00:53","2014","zm","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Correct analysis","It seems that there is no ministry or government agency that has this data. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Katelyn Rogers","0"
"b6cd2099-926c-4c19-850e-8ef2bf72d755","global","2014-11-26T02:53:37","2014","zm","companies","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Accurate and comprehensive ","The Patents and Companies Registration Agency (PACRA) is a semi-autonomous executive agency of the Zambian Ministry of Commerce, Trade and Industry. Its principal functions are to operate a legal system for registration and protection of commercial and industrial property and to serve as a legal depository of the information tendered for registration.
Data is submitted to [PACRA online][1], yet the official [PACRA][2] website is not available, and it seems that the registry can not be accessed by the public.
[1]: https://www.onlinepacra.org.zm/pacranc/default.aspx?UR=https://www.pacra.org.zm/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=95&Itemid=136
[2]: https://www.pacra.org.zm/","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Katelyn Rogers","10"
"fd259d78-5ab6-49e1-97e5-9742f3a856a5","global","2014-11-26T02:42:12","2014","zm","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.elections.org.zm/",,,,,"ELECTORAL COMMISSION OF ZAMBIA","Yes","Yes","Analysis is correct ","The electoral committee of Zambia publish all major elections results on its website in PDF files on a timely basis. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Katelyn Rogers","55"
"1c340ddb-749e-4794-a155-16aa0d65952f","global","2014-11-26T00:53:43","2014","hu","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://ksh.hu","Excel",,,,"Hungarian Central Statistical Office","Yes","Yes","Correct."," No change from 2013","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Julia Keserű","70"
"52eeb226-d5aa-4509-965b-099433c0d7e1","global","2014-11-26T00:51:04","2014","hu","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://menetrendek.hu",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Correct","See also https://elvira.hu
[No change from 2013]","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Julia Keserű","45"
"c638410e-34da-4219-a2f5-be6d514d4cac","global","2014-11-26T00:49:47","2014","hu","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://loczy.mfgi.hu/flexviewer/atlasz200/",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Seems correct, I couldn`t find more info. "," More information on mapping in Hungary here: https://lazarus.elte.hu/gb/hunkarta/ica11/hungary2011.pdf
[no change from 2013]","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Julia Keserű","35"
"79cfa67f-c428-4ec1-9a4a-5fb6b5807935","global","2014-11-21T11:28:11","2014","gh","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.statsghana.gov.gh/ and some on https://data.gov.gh/","Excel",,,,"Ghana Statistical Service","Yes","Yes","Changed the license to not open. ","Reuse is allowed in policy but no specific license given.","Yes","No","Jenny Molloy","Mor Rubinstein","70"
"f0ba45db-1f2b-4dc4-ac7d-c7bfc1a07c18","global","2014-11-21T09:34:27","2014","zw","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Email has been sent to the Ministry for the Environment as well as the Global Environment Facility (financing the above mentioned project) ","While the missions statement of the ministry of environment shows that the office will create awareness to air pollution, no such data was found on the [website][1].
[1]: https://www.environment.gov.zw/index.php/en/poject-officers/persistent-organic-pollutants","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Katelyn Rogers","0"
"d1020a74-b45a-490a-9d8d-06dc48e219a7","global","2014-11-21T09:28:56","2014","zw","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Reasonable assumption about availability of data","According to wikipedia, there is not postcodes system in Zimbabwe. There is also no indication to it in the Zimbabwean post office [website.][1]
[1]: https://www.zimpost.co.zw/","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Katelyn Rogers","0"
"84ee81c0-819b-4292-941a-6e9137b0432c","global","2014-11-21T09:24:21","2014","zw","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.parlzim.gov.zw/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=3&Itemid=4",,,,,"Zimbabwean Parliament ","Yes","Yes","Accurate and comprehensive ","The Zimbabwean Parliament has a webpage with bills that are in discussion in this specific parliament, and not all the bills that exist. Bill statues are prepared by the Ministry of justice and are published on the [website][1]. It seems that it is not updated on a regular basis.
[1]: https://www.parlzim.gov.zw/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=27&Itemid=21","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Katelyn Rogers","35"
"1b918f2c-367c-4df6-bce8-0c2b1babf660","global","2014-11-21T09:17:31","2014","zw","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.zimstat.co.zw/",,,,"Zimbabwe National Statistics Agency (ZIMSTAT)",,"Yes","Yes","Accurate and comprehensive ","According to the Census and Statistics Act of 2007, Zimbabwean statistics is done by a corporate body - The Zimbabwe National Statistics Agency (ZIMSTAT).
The agency suppose to provide quarterly surveys, yet it seems that they can not sustain such reports and that most of the data is out dated.
Quarterly reports that do exist are in PDF format and do not give bulk information. There is a link to the [African development bank portal][1], but I couldn't find the information there.
[1]: https://zimbabwe.africadata.org/","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Katelyn Rogers","35"
"9db32e07-56a2-40ca-a8ff-f764d9f0cb29","global","2014-11-21T09:04:34","2014","zw","map","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Unsure","Yes",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Accurate and comprehensive ","The [website][1] of the surveyor general of Zimbabwe indicates that such maps exists in hard and soft copy and that they can be purchased. However, it is not clear if the soft copy is machine readable and how updated the maps are.
[1]: https://www.surveyorgeneral.gov.zw/","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Katelyn Rogers","20"
"2a2609c3-6ef3-4795-a35a-21944aaa5ca7","global","2014-11-20T12:30:22","2014","ls","emissions","Yes","Yes","No","No","Unsure","Unsure","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"According to the Department of Environment in the government of Lesotho, there is a data clearing house which monitor air pollutions.
However, it is not accessible online, and there is no information about how one can access the data. I tried to phone the department, but no one was able to help me.
(https://www.environment.gov.ls/)
Other background (no date stamp): https://unstats.un.org/unsd/ENVIRONMENT/envpdf/UNSD_UNEP_ECA%20Workshop/Lesotho.pdf","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Emma Beer","10"
"d0266a5a-5356-4e39-8ebf-4da7c6813897","global","2014-11-20T12:19:31","2014","zw","companies","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"The data is collected by the department of Deeds, companies and intellectual property of the Zimbabwean government (https://www.dcip.gov.zw/). There are forms on the site which can be downloaded for printing. There is also a project of Computerization which my indicate that the data is not in digital form. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Mor Rubinstein","5"
"80d32402-fb5c-455f-b6e8-c17c9efca992","global","2014-11-20T12:00:54","2014","zw","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.zec.gov.zw/2013-harmonised-election-report?download=22:zec-2013-harmonised-elections-report",,,,"Zimbabwe Electoral Commission ",,"Yes","Yes","Accurate and comprehensive ","Zimbabwe has a very comprehensive elections results report, yet it is not in a machine readable format. For more information see the Zimbabwe electoral commission website - https://www.zec.gov.zw/ ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Katelyn Rogers","55"
"816d85e1-a9c2-4e1c-8c72-96f05fbab633","global","2014-11-20T11:30:37","2014","ls","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","Unsure","Unsure","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"Lesotho has a computer system for government procurement and spending (https://www.finance.gov.ls/regulations/GOL_Procurement_System_Features.pdf). Therefore, we can assume that the data does exist and is in digital form. However, there is no specific document for monthly government spending (https://www.finance.gov.ls/reforms/procurements.php). https://www.finance.gov.ls/documents/budget_book.php","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Emma Beer","10"
"ea107c5a-f82c-4805-b4d5-b4ac417631eb","global","2014-11-19T23:51:29","2014","gh","companies","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Change data to exist. ","Data does exist in digital form through the [Registrar General][1] office. How ever, I couldn't find how to obtain and it was not online.
[1]: https://www.rgd.gov.gh/","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","10"
"e0e7e1d8-ebae-4419-a93b-9db96470f062","global","2014-11-19T23:46:10","2014","gh","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Double submission","There are no postcodes in Ghana.","Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","0"
"eb1b052b-6fc1-4de1-8c04-0fe5845f684b","global","2014-11-19T23:44:01","2014","gh","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.ec.gov.gh/",,,,,"Electoral Commission of Ghana","Yes","Yes","Data is accurate ",,"Yes","No","anonymous","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"da5191b6-fa59-4ec0-bc06-b549c6e96cdd","global","2014-11-19T17:43:49","2014","zw","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.zimtreasury.gov.zw/estimates-of-expenditure",,,,,"Ministry of Finance and Economic Development ","Yes","Yes","Changed link but all other information accurate ","The government of Zimbabwe publish every December an estimation of expenditure for the next calendar year on the treasury website. No license was found. ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Katelyn Rogers","55"
"82d3b297-dcad-40f6-80fa-646e2c89ae44","global","2014-11-19T17:07:11","2014","lt","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Unsure",,"Yes","https://www3.lrs.lt/dokpaieska/forma_l.htm",,,,"Document search - Seimas (Parliament) of the Republic of Lithuania ","Seimas (Parliament) of the Republic of Lithuania ","Yes","Yes","Vast majority of legislation is available in .doc formats. The Palrliament is currently implementing a new database and the website for its operations, which will allow for some access to legislative data. "," The legislation is available, however, mostly in .doc format ","Yes","No","Ploegerieke L","Karolis Granickas","45"
"bb9be459-9ed9-4baf-9081-1ff1d71db6df","global","2014-11-19T17:03:58","2014","lt","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure",,"Yes","https://osp.stat.gov.lt/viesos-duomenu-rinkmenos",,,,"Lithuanian Department of Statistics portal","Lithuanian Department of Statistics","Yes","Yes","There are only five categories of data that are in open formats. However, there is a massive lot of information that is available, however, not open. "," Massive lot of statistics is available online. However, most of statistics are not in machine-readable formats. ","Yes","No","Ploegerieke L","Karolis Granickas","45"
"cac970a5-27f3-475e-90b5-86491a3b5bb9","global","2014-11-19T16:48:12","2014","lt","companies","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Unsure","Yes",,"Unsure","https://www.registrucentras.lt/jar/",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The data is provided on a contract basis and with fee. There is no openly licenses data in open formats in bulk. ","Data is available only on commercial terms. Some basic information (max. 100 searches per day) is available freely: the full dataset on company register is only available at a cost.","Yes","No","Ploegerieke L","Karolis Granickas","20"
"f06d70d2-ca78-488f-a118-a4137f8fbb8b","global","2014-11-19T13:13:03","2014","zw","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.nrz.co.zw/",,,,"https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Railways_of_Zimbabwe","National Railways of Zimbabwe ","Yes","Yes","Data found and information added ","National Railways of Zimbabwe is the parastatal railway of Zimbabwe.
- Commuter Train Data available here:https://www.nrz.co.zw/index.php/passenger-services/commuter-trains
- Intercity Train data available here: https://www.nrz.co.zw/index.php/passenger-services/intercity-trains
Data is only available in PDF and there are separate PDFs for each individual line. It is unclear when this data was last updated ","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Katelyn Rogers","35"
"852fe054-2d2d-4972-890b-a65c56b0d965","global","2014-11-19T11:02:23","2014","vi","emissions","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I checked the 2014 submission and additional research did not yield any results to doubt its correctness.","According to the division of Environmental Control the data is collected on a weekly basis: https://dpnr.vi.gov/environmental-protection/air-pollution-control/ but it is not released to the general public except perhaps upon inquiry.","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Christian Villum","10"
"ceb10d8b-158b-4edc-a2bb-16e7ad80c479","global","2014-11-19T10:56:53","2014","vi","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I checked the 2014 submission and additional research did not yield any results to doubt its correctness.","The postcodes do exist and the U.S. Virgin Islands are serviced by the United States Postal Service (who use the code VI for domestic mail and zip codes in the 008xx series) according to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_Virgin_Islands#Transportation_and_communications
These zip codes are not maintained along with other zipcodes in by the U.S. Census Bureau like for the U.S. states. Websites of cabinet departments which might have this data are all inaccessible.","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Christian Villum","0"
"c2ee5f64-b4c9-437d-904b-b2589e35bb3c","global","2014-11-19T10:07:48","2014","vi","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.legvi.org/vilegsearch/",,,,,"Legislator of the Virgin Islands","Yes","Yes","I checked the 2014 submission and additional research did not yield any results to doubt its correctness.","The U.S. Virgin Islands are an insular area of the United States of America and as such are subject to federal legislation. However the U.S. Virgin Islands have a legislative authority similar to the states of the U.S.A and the legislation of that legislative body: https://www.legvi.org is what is used as basis, not the United States of America legislation.","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Christian Villum","35"
"12287a89-09bf-41a6-aa46-fc9d668718ec","global","2014-11-18T15:41:50","2014","vi","companies","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I checked the 2014 submission and additional research did not yield any results to doubt its correctness.","None found. Website of Department of Licensing & Consumer Affairs: https://dlca.vi.gov/ does not work. Internal Revenue Bureau does not have information and Economic Development Authority: https://www.usvieda.com/ does not include a list.","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Christian Villum","0"
"34c453ea-12fd-4bbb-9c6c-7429399d684d","global","2014-11-18T15:11:40","2014","vi","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://governordejongh.com/budget/index.html",,,,"FY 2015 BUDGET","US Virgin Islands/Governer John P. De Jongh, Jr.","Yes","Yes","I checked the 2014 submission and additional research did not yield any results to doubt its correctness. Added name of publisher and name of budget.","The buget is downloadable in full as a PDF document. The latest budget, for 2015, is available although the budget for 2014 is not.","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Christian Villum","55"
"b4da071c-c989-4539-9aae-83da471ba97a","global","2014-11-18T14:28:14","2014","vi","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I checked the 2014 submission and additional research did not yield any results to doubt its correctness.","The information does not seem to available in general. Something can be found on a tourist site: https://www.vinow.com/ which does give a hint at a time table for each island, e.g. for St. Croix: https://www.vinow.com/stcroix/getting_around_stx/
However this cannot be regarded as official information and furthermore the tourist site claims: ""The Bus System is not very reliable, if you are limited in time it is not recommendable.""
","Yes","No","Tryggvi Björgvinsson","Christian Villum","0"
"4909757e-09de-440e-b09e-d377907c5a6c","global","2014-11-09T18:04:38","2014","ba","map","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Accepted with minor corrections.","There is a mapping center in Bosnia and Herzegovina (https://www.fgu.com.ba), yet it is not an office of the national government, but of one of the entities. Therefore, the national government does not have this data. See more here - https://balkans.aljazeera.net/vijesti/geodetski-zavod-izmedu-bih-i-federacije","Yes","No","Mor Rubinstein","Stevan Gostojić","0"
"0e1c5e55-070c-44e5-bd93-443c3466bc74","global","2014-11-09T16:27:56","2014","rs","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.parlament.gov.rs/upload/documents/3472-12%20Lat.pdf","PDF",,,,"Narodna skupština Republike Srbije","Yes","Yes","After checking all the data are consistent.","The whole budget can be downloaded as a single pdf file, which means it is available in bulk.
No licese is available (although all laws should be in the public domain).","Yes","No","Stevan Gostojić","Bojana Dzulovic","55"
"38212069-3925-4e1c-96b9-297847aa3cc3","global","2014-11-09T16:18:43","2014","rs","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://w3.srbrail.rs/zsredvoznje/?lang=en",,,,,"Železnice Srbije","Yes","Yes","After checking all the data are consistent.","Only train timetable is available. There is no national level bus service operated or commissioned by the government. However, some municipal bus stations do have timetable available online:
Belgrade: https://www.bas.rs/redvoznje.aspx?lng=sl
Novi Sad: https://www.gspns.rs/red-voznje-medjumesni.php","Yes","No","Stevan Gostojić","Bojana Dzulovic","45"
"ba78d42a-99b2-49db-846f-3fa5501fd3c5","global","2014-11-09T16:10:32","2014","rs","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.rik.parlament.gov.rs/latinica/propisi_frames.htm","xls, html, pdf",,,,"Republička izborna komisija","Yes","Yes","After checking all the data are consistent.","Data available since 2002.","Yes","No","Stevan Gostojić","Bojana Dzulovic","70"
"9bbe4d44-6bd4-4a3d-8c89-db6da2e59a9f","global","2014-11-09T16:06:42","2014","rs","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://pretraga2.apr.gov.rs/ObjedinjenePretrage/Search/Search",,,,,"Agencija za privredne registre","Yes","Yes","After checking all the data are consistent.","No license can be found which makes it non-open.","Yes","No","Stevan Gostojić","Bojana Dzulovic","45"
"44064ef3-5377-4c9b-9b3d-b8aae4896cc1","global","2014-11-09T16:00:12","2014","rs","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.geosrbija.rs/rga/default.aspx?gui=1&lang=2",,,,,"Republički geodetski zavod","Yes","Yes","After checking all the data are consistent.",,"Yes","No","Stevan Gostojić","Bojana Dzulovic","35"
"3aefee81-b308-4088-ab39-602e8b26ee8d","global","2014-11-09T15:47:05","2014","rs","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://webrzs.stat.gov.rs/WebSite/Public/PageView.aspx?pKey=2","xls, xml, pdf",,,,"Republički zavod za statistiku","Yes","Yes","After checking all the data are consistent."," ","Yes","No","Stevan Gostojić","Bojana Dzulovic","60"
"8628b1a3-fab5-4bd7-9243-1a2e98232d0a","global","2014-11-09T15:43:01","2014","rs","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.sepa.gov.rs/ams/xajax_data/eas_kvalitet_vazduha_1.php",,,,,"Agencija za zaštitu životne sredine","Yes","Yes","After checking all the data are consistent.","No visible license means data is not open.","Yes","No","Stevan Gostojić","Bojana Dzulovic","45"
"a74c88d5-636d-4092-95f1-ac78aba98659","global","2014-11-09T15:22:04","2014","rs","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.parlament.gov.rs/akti/doneti-zakoni/doneti-zakoni.1033.html","PDF, DOC",,,,"Narodna skupština Republike Srbije","Yes","Yes","After checking all the data are consistent.","All national legislation enacted since 2001 can be retrieved by metadata and browsed by volume and number. The data is not machine readable (it is available in PDF and DOC format). No licence is visible (although the legislation should be in the public domain).
More comprehensive legislation set is available at https://pravno-informacioni-sistem.rs and https://bpp.uzzpro.gov.rs, but it also isn't machine readable.","Yes","No","Stevan Gostojić","Bojana Dzulovic","45"
"99b32ae6-c1f0-4627-8fe9-dd6aca7280de","global","2014-11-05T15:02:26","2014","hu","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://kereses.magyarorszag.hu/jogszabalykereso",,,,,"Portal of the Hungarian Government","Yes","Yes","Correct. "," ","Yes","No","Anna Orosz","Julia Keserű","45"
"d058f743-5783-4a95-a49f-2c822f7e256f","global","2014-11-05T14:59:21","2014","hu","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Correct. ","There is an Excel sheet of all postal codes published by Magyar Posta (Hungarian Post) at https://posta.hu/ugyfelszolgalat/iranyitoszam_kereso, but it doesn't contain lat/long co-ordinates.
","Yes","No","Anna Orosz","Julia Keserű","0"
"57c39bc1-0ea7-441b-b290-ed72eba989af","global","2014-11-05T14:57:58","2014","hu","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.e-cegjegyzek.hu",,,,,"Ministry of Justice","Yes","Yes","Correct. ","The following data is available on companies: name, registration numbers, address, branches, main activities, capital, VAT number and any ongoing liquidation or bankruptcy proceedings. ","Yes","No","Anna Orosz","Julia Keserű","45"
"cf74a79c-f7a9-44bb-8967-5bb215c95472","global","2014-11-05T14:50:37","2014","hu","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes"," https://www.valasztas.hu/ ","HTML",,,,"National Election Office","Yes","Yes","Correct.",,"Yes","No","Anna Orosz","Julia Keserű","60"
"e35f613b-5237-46a3-923b-ff7930cafd43","global","2014-11-05T14:47:44","2014","hu","spending","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Unsure","https://www.allamkincstar.gov.hu/kincstar/funkcionalis_merlegek","Excel",,,,"Hungarian State Treasury","Yes","Yes","Correct.","Until 2014, official budget documents were in the form of Budget Bills and acts, not available in a user-friendly format and which were difficult to interpret for the average citizen. Also, Budget Bills only talk about spending institutions and due to the frequent institutional reorganizations, it was difficult to track the spending dynamics over time by field/sector. By now the budget data are published on the Hungarian State Treasury's website in a slightly modified COFOG2 breakdown, which makes the interpretation of the budget data significantly easier.","Yes","No","Anna Orosz","Julia Keserű","60"
"3fb1477a-8b21-424c-b60b-ffaf652995b1","global","2014-11-05T14:39:30","2014","hu","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.allamkincstar.gov.hu/kincstar/funkcionalis_merlegek","Excel",,,,"Hungarian State Treasury","Yes","Yes","Correct.","Until 2014, official budget documents were in the form of Budget Bills and acts, not available in a user-friendly format and which were difficult to interpret for the average citizen. Also, Budget Bills only talk about spending institutions and due to the frequent institutional reorganizations, it was difficult to track the spending dynamics over time by field/sector. By now the budget data are published on the Hungarian State Treasury's website in a slightly modified COFOG2 breakdown, which makes the interpretation of the budget data significantly easier. ","Yes","No","Anna Orosz","Julia Keserű","70"
"aeb1e677-e84c-4122-a3ea-45cd57277965","global","2014-11-05T09:59:35","2014","gh","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.mofep.gov.gh/sites/default/files/budget/2014_Budget_Statement_0.pdf",,,,,"Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning","Yes","Yes","The data is only available in PDF. I updated the other categories from 'Unsure' to 'No'",,"Yes","No","Jerry Sam","Mor Rubinstein","45"
"988c5678-2430-48f4-856f-958508fb5b26","global","2014-10-31T11:21:48","2014","cy","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","No improvement since last year.","There is a link in the Department of Road Transport website for transportation information (https://www.mcw.gov.cy/mcw/rtd/rtd.nsf/rtd71_gr/rtd71_gr?OpenDocument), but this does not include any timetables. Any information on bus transportation can be found through private websites, not government ones.
","Yes","No","anonymous","Andreas P","0"
"86ff255b-a162-477f-8b3f-6a2586327688","global","2014-10-31T11:06:22","2014","cy","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.mcw.gov.cy/mcw/postal/dps.nsf/postcodeSearch_gr/postcodeSearch_gr?OpenForm",".pdf",,,,,"Yes","Yes","Same as before.","The data does not exist as per requirements of the Open Data Census. The data does exist in the form of street name, postcode and town/village name. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Andreas P","0"
"98b75826-4a27-4461-b9a4-7aba6eea8032","global","2014-10-31T01:48:24","2014","bd","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.railway.gov.bd/site/page/f8898018-00a5-4096-a803-8b533232e60c",,,,"Bangladesh Railway is the state-owned rail transport agency of Bangladesh. It operates and maintains the entire railway network of the country. BR is controlled by the Directorate General of Bangladesh Railway under the Ministry of Railways along with Bangladesh Railway Authority (BRA) and which works for policy guidance of BR.","Bangladesh Railway","Yes","Yes","All the mentioned information are correct and the official data source are valid.","Bus and Train services are maintained by different authorities in Bangladesh. The submission form should have the option to mention this information properly.","Yes","No","Daniela Mattern","Nasir Khan","55"
"3bcffb5a-3ebc-4ccd-845e-7014cfff2f5e","global","2014-10-30T17:27:16","2014","vi","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.vivote.gov/",,,,,"Office of the Supervisor of Elections","Yes","Yes","edemocracy trawl on website","2010, 2012 and pending 2014
","Yes","No","Graeme Jones","Graeme Jones","45"
"c34296bc-7e99-41c3-abe4-292bda3e84f7","global","2014-10-30T17:22:37","2014","vi","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.usviber.org/",,,,,"Bureau of Economic Research","Yes","Yes","initial content search -- statistics such as GDP, etc.","Includes GDP by USA Department of Commerce:
https://www.usviber.org/GTPVI2012.pdf
","Yes","No","Graeme Jones","Graeme Jones","45"
"bd59b9f2-3915-432b-b1e2-8b790144caf8","global","2014-10-30T17:06:34","2014","va","spending","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","initial search on financials","extensive trawl on relevant websites, description of relevant department but no search results on relevant keywords
","Yes","No","Graeme Jones","Graeme Jones","10"
"21c7b349-8ec7-49a2-8d32-80729009c088","global","2014-10-30T15:31:52","2014","ht","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Neither the Statistics & Informatics Institute (https://www.ihsi.ht/), nor the Ministry of Environment (https://www.mde-h.gouv.ht/) nor further governmental bodies have published this kind of data.","No evidence","Yes","No","Pierre Chrzanowski","Margo Thierry","0"
"68e40ca9-6577-40dc-b10b-cc9840f9da07","global","2014-10-30T15:28:48","2014","ht","postcodes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","When I reviewed this submission, the website https://www.postehaiti.gouv.ht/ was not working at all.
I could not find any database of postcodes from other governmental sources.","Postcodes are maintain by the Office Des Postes D'Haiti https://www.postehaiti.gouv.ht/ but it is unsure wether there is a digital georeferenced version","Yes","No","Pierre Chrzanowski","Margo Thierry","5"
"5e8c1d9c-75ad-420b-ad09-19de002cb5ca","global","2014-10-30T15:20:28","2014","ht","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.sdn.mefhaiti.gouv.ht/sdn_lois.php",,,,,"The Ministry of Economy and Finance","Yes","Yes","I modified the answer to ""Is the data provided on a timely and up to date basis?"" which was ""no"" and I replaced by ""Unsure"". I explained this choice adding a comment: Laws and statutes mentioned are up to date, meaning amendments are indicated on the initial law itself. But the data does not include all national laws or statutes, just a selection of them (especially none after 2008).","The data does not include all national laws and statutes, but a selection of them (especially none after 2008).
But each law is up to date, meaning that amendments are indicated in the initial law itself.","Yes","No","Pierre Chrzanowski","Margo Thierry","35"
"41b52c9c-db74-4d7f-9e03-304e2066e159","global","2014-10-30T15:12:48","2014","ht","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.ihsi.ht/",,,,,"Statistics & Informatics Institute (IHSI)","Yes","Yes","I removed the original URL https://www.ihsi.ht/tableau/POPULATION.pdf which is only about population data. I replaced it with https://www.ihsi.ht/ which is the main page of the Statistics & Informatics Institute where demographic and economic indicators can be found.
I translated the name of the publisher and add a comment about what is available on the URL I mentioned. The remaining answers are right.","Demographic and economic indicators can be found on the website of the Statistics & Informatics Institute (URL mentioned: https://www.ihsi.ht/). However, the site is not user-friendly, not all indicators can be downloaded (sometimes there are only data visualisations) and if so mostly in pdf.","Yes","No","Pierre Chrzanowski","Margo Thierry","35"
"31cd96c8-e6a0-4ccf-b72c-404eca2f781b","global","2014-10-30T14:35:56","2014","ht","map","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Maps visualisations made by the Statistics & Informatics Institute can be found here: https://www.ihsi.ht/carte_enemble_pays.htm but the georeferenced data is not visible and can not be downloaded.","In the aftermath of the 2010 earthquake, IGN France offered to support for the reconstruction of the country’s geographic reference information. But there is still no official map of the country. People rely on the OpenStreetMap version.","Yes","No","Pierre Chrzanowski","Margo Thierry","0"
"b22d807e-a3f1-4c55-8597-cb7842b867cd","global","2014-10-30T14:31:24","2014","ht","companies","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I neither could find the company register 2012 made by the Ministry of Trade and Industry. But other kind of economic data seem to be available on its website (internal trade:https://www.mci.gouv.ht/index.php?option=com_phocadownload&view=category&id=10&Itemid=90&lang=en; external trade: https://www.mci.gouv.ht/index.php?option=com_phocadownload&view=category&id=11%3Acommerce-exterieur&Itemid=194&lang=en). However, the number of datasets is extremly limited (7 at all) and not all of them can be opened.","The Ministry of Trade and Industry launched a census in 2012 to establish a register of companies but there is no evidence of the data.","Yes","No","Pierre Chrzanowski","Margo Thierry","0"
"eb014e31-f3f8-41dd-b813-32f74127339c","global","2014-10-30T14:27:19","2014","ht","elections","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I modified the comment, adding more information.","The Interim Electoral Council (Conseil Electoral provisoire, CEP) is the independant body responsible for the organisation of the national elections and publication of the results. However, its former website (https://cephaiti2010.org/) does not work anymore and no actual website is known.","Yes","No","Pierre Chrzanowski","Margo Thierry","0"
"8a8fd3d1-3088-4c83-aa22-85a6bbafcbe2","global","2014-10-30T14:17:48","2014","ht","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.mefhaiti.gouv.ht/Documents/PDF/Projet_de_Loi_de_Finances_2013-2014_signature.pdf",,,,,"Ministry of Economy & Finance","Yes","Yes","I translated the name of the publisher and added a title.",,"Yes","No","Pierre Chrzanowski","Margo Thierry","45"
"451697b4-e0fc-4360-8b75-831adab312e7","global","2014-10-30T14:16:07","2014","ht","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Indeed, I only found private transport companies.","The public transportation is mostly privately owned in Haiti.","Yes","No","Pierre Chrzanowski","Margo Thierry","0"
"6cc14f86-4133-4fc8-b2cc-f4f75da9e43e","global","2014-10-30T12:13:17","2014","lt","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.post.lt/lt/pagalba/pasto-kodu-paieska",,,,,"Lithuanian Post - www.post.lt","Yes","Yes","The state-owned company ""Lietuvos pastas"" allows to search for codes by address, but does not provide data in open formats, licenses and in bulk. "," There is only a possibility to search for a post code providing the address. No open datasets are available online. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Karolis Granickas","45"
"6d17e3bd-e464-4b60-a892-92f0d387ba17","global","2014-10-30T12:12:05","2014","lt","map","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The map is not found on governmental websites and is provided only by third parties. "," ","Yes","No","anonymous","Karolis Granickas","10"
"3898983d-66d2-417c-96ee-c745f6ef60e9","global","2014-10-30T12:09:58","2014","lt","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Unsure",,"Yes","https://www.2013.vrk.lt/2014_prezidento_rinkimai/output_lt/rinkimu_diena/index.html","mostly html tables",,,,"Chief Electoral Commission","Yes","Yes","The detailed data is available in a timely manner. However, it is not in bulk and in open formats. "," The data is available online mostly in html tables or already visualized on a map. The open datasets are not available. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Karolis Granickas","45"
"793f1960-8ae8-4606-b527-02a5905de803","global","2014-10-30T12:09:07","2014","lt","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Unsure",,"Yes","https://www.finmin.lt/web/finmin/2015_biudzetas",,,,,"Ministry of Finance","Yes","Yes","There are all documents in connection to the budget 2015, but majority of them are PDFs and the data is not in open formats and licenses. ","Presentation (visualizations) of data is mostly available as well as some Pdfs. However, open datasets are not available on the Governments websites. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Karolis Granickas","45"
"59e569e7-9ae3-4c57-a324-d3df5a479b54","global","2014-10-30T12:06:46","2014","lt","timetables","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","Unsure","Unsure",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","The data is not available in bulk an din open formats, licenses. However, it is being re-used by a third party, perhaps, based on a data supply agreement. ","The data is available, however, not from the Government. Re-users of the data (third party) created a tool (www.marsrutai.lt) that provides transport data in a user-friendly manner, but does not provide datasets and machine-readable formats. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Karolis Granickas","10"
"6ae41b9a-2ae2-43a6-a5d1-1516ae269618","global","2014-10-30T10:48:45","2014","sl","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Same conclusion ","No evidence pollution data exists. ","Yes","No","Pierre Chrzanowski","Katelyn Rogers","0"
"58f501de-16f1-438e-a865-8f97dee34d1c","global","2014-10-30T10:47:58","2014","sl","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","I arrived at the same conclusion ",,"Yes","No","Pierre Chrzanowski","Katelyn Rogers","0"
"32b75091-bc98-43b3-bf4d-b8bc19b619b5","global","2014-10-30T10:46:51","2014","sl","legislation","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Accurate and Comprehensive ","The government committed itself to release 20% of gazetted legislation data as open data as part of its Open Government Partnership's Action Plan.","Yes","No","Pierre Chrzanowski","Katelyn Rogers","5"
"3c29ef55-cc64-4754-b077-34a4cf345be8","global","2014-10-30T10:44:57","2014","sl","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.statistics.sl/economic_statistics_reports_2013/annual_economic_survey_report_2012.pdf",,,,,"Statistics Sierra Leone","Yes","Yes","Accurate and comprehensive ",,"Yes","No","Pierre Chrzanowski","Katelyn Rogers","35"
"f62655e6-052b-4cb8-a35f-c29e33b8f979","global","2014-10-30T10:39:59","2014","sl","map","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Arrived at same conclusion ","No up to date maps available from the government.","Yes","No","Pierre Chrzanowski","Katelyn Rogers","0"
"f070df45-f6c3-45c0-a1f4-ee168d4182d2","global","2014-10-30T10:37:29","2014","sl","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.nec-sierraleone.org/Presidential_Per_PollingStation.html",,,,,"National Electoral Commission Sierra Leone","Yes","Yes","Accurate and Comprehensive ","Presidential elections results are available at the level of polling stations.","Yes","No","Pierre Chrzanowski","Katelyn Rogers","45"
"5ce9ef75-b46f-4ffc-84df-6e4f93096224","global","2014-10-30T10:33:07","2014","sl","companies","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Evidence that the data exists was found, it remains unclear whether this is publicly available ","You can register a company online through the Office of the Administrator and Registar General's website so presumably the data is exists and is digital - https://www.oarg.gov.sl/","Yes","No","Pierre Chrzanowski","Katelyn Rogers","10"
"df63f2c5-a7fb-457b-bb0e-d71b1e5af852","global","2014-10-30T10:31:55","2014","sl","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","Unsure","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Accept ","The Ministry of Finance and Economic Development published Financial Spending Reports monthly for 2013 (see :https://mofed.gov.sl/linkingreports.htm). As such, it is safe to assume that if they have aggregate spending data, transactional spending data exists and is digital.","Yes","No","Pierre Chrzanowski","Katelyn Rogers","10"
"84d22362-74c2-471e-8821-0991f81d4f82","global","2014-10-30T10:30:49","2014","sl","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://mofed.gov.sl/annualbudgetrep.htm",,,,,"The Ministry of Finance and Economic Development","Yes","Yes","Accurate and Comprehensive ",,"Yes","No","Pierre Chrzanowski","Katelyn Rogers","45"
"7dd96d1f-fec4-4a59-ba47-bd37658439db","global","2014-10-30T10:29:02","2014","sl","timetables","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Accurate and Comprehensive ","There is no evidence that this data exists. The Ministry for Transport and Aviation does not appear to have a website; neither does the Sierra Leone Roads Transport Authority. Finally, the Sierra Leone Government Railway was closed in 1974. ","Yes","No","Pierre Chrzanowski","Katelyn Rogers","0"
"a700a47a-458e-4e60-9e66-dea5413b67bf","global","2014-10-29T12:59:55","2014","bd","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.moef.gov.bd/html/state_of_env/state_of_env.html","PDF",,,,"Ministry of Environment and Forest (MoEF) ","Yes","Yes","reviewed and updated.","The data is very backdated. It was last updated on 2001! There is a PDF report on air pollution. It is like an academic paper and there is no licence visible. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Nasir Khan","35"
"28396811-8422-4f3d-a3c4-efca4f785611","global","2014-10-29T12:57:25","2014","bd","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://bdlaws.minlaw.gov.bd/alp_index_update.php","html",,,,"Legislative and Parliamentary Affairs Division","Yes","Yes","reviewed","No mention of licensing, can't see option for bulk download nor of the data in anything apart from PDF or viewable on website (so, not machine readable)
","Yes","No","anonymous","Nasir Khan","35"
"5361e0bd-a8c5-4d10-9c8f-d9d3149a0a46","global","2014-10-29T12:55:36","2014","bd","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.bbs.gov.bd/home.aspx","PDF",,,,"Bangladesh Bureau of Statistics (BBS)","Yes","Yes","reviewed"," No licence specified","Yes","No","anonymous","Nasir Khan","55"
"444776a6-29b6-4568-a670-18bf3e44ff5a","global","2014-10-29T12:43:54","2014","bd","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.mof.gov.bd/en/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=183&Itemid=1#","pdf",,,,"Ministry of Finance ","Yes","Yes","All the mentioned information are correct and valid.","On https://www.mof.gov.bd/en/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=68&Itemid=1# can't find information on licensing; PDFs only so not machine readable; need to download many PDFs so not available in bulk . Various forms of information available including previous years from https://www.mof.gov.bd/en/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=235&Itemid=1","Yes","No","anonymous","Nasir Khan","45"
"570ee7eb-dbeb-4e2f-b2bb-b833cfc00080","global","2014-10-29T10:41:44","2014","zm","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://zambiamf.africadata.org/en/BulkDownload","CSV,Excel, .txt, .mdb, .dbf",,,,"Ministry of Finance ","Yes","Yes","Original submission was World Bank Data but similar data is available vis the Ministry of Finance's data portal ","
","Yes","No","anonymous","Katelyn Rogers","70"
"ffe048f0-9e10-46bc-a9f0-4b3f3f5ebe15","global","2014-10-29T10:26:40","2014","zm","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://zambiamf.africadata.org/en/DataSearch","https://zambiamf.africadata.org/en/ResourceCenter",,,,"Ministy of Finance ","Yes","Yes","Details added on how to find budget data on the portal. ","Budget data for 2014 is available here: https://zambiamf.africadata.org/en/ResourceCenter in PDFs by seraching ""Budget Yellow Books"" ","Yes","No","anonymous","Katelyn Rogers","70"
"cc781c81-b095-4b74-9977-a30b72946ea7","global","2014-10-29T08:01:36","2014","zm","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Comments added about rail services in Zambia ","Rail services in Zambia are operated by the Railway Systems of Zambia (RSZ) and TAZARA Railway, both are privately owned companies.
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zambia_Railways","Yes","No","Fatumata Kabemba","Katelyn Rogers","0"
"b2da6a78-f38f-4738-b5d5-b0c149c5d676","global","2014-10-27T23:04:00","2014","ls","map","Yes","Yes","No","Yes","No","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.laa.org.ls/index.php?option=com_k2&view=item&layout=item&id=2&Itemid=133",,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Largely correct submission, I only changed 'machine readable' from 'Yes' to 'No' (pdf-format).","Thematic maps are used to provide cartographical (or specific) information on various themes such as tourism, population percentage change or nature reserves. The maps are of scale 1:250 000 in hardcopies and digital formats.","Yes","No","Ciarán Staunton","Christian Villum","15"
"d9b385e2-79d5-4449-81dd-2b4d7dc89990","global","2014-10-27T22:55:47","2014","ls","companies","Yes","No","No","No","Unsure","No","Unsure",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"https://www.obfc.org.ls/business/
Contains summary statistics on 23100 companies registered in Lesotho but no data published","Yes","No","Ciarán Staunton","Emma Beer","5"
"2b11b946-487a-499b-b260-7264d3d49c0d","global","2014-10-27T22:48:23","2014","ls","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"No","https://www.bos.gov.ls/nada/index.php/home",,,,"National Data Catalogue","Bureau of Statistics","Yes","Yes","Submission largely correct, but changed 'openly licensed' from 'Unsure' to 'No' because no clear license is stated, and 'provided in timely manner' from 'Unsure' to 'No' since many of the sets date back to 2002-2003.","There are open files and licenced files.
Licensed files:
This approach involves a signed agreement between the National Data Archive and external trusted users, to permit them to access semi-anonymized data files. Licensing agreements are only entered into with bona fideusers when there is an appropriate sponsoring institution or referee. Users must be able to:
Demonstrate a need to access the data in order to fulfill a stated statistical or research purpose; and
Comply with the conditions set forth in a formal Microdata Access Agreement.
Those interested in accessing the data under license should fill our Licensed Dataset Request Form. Requests are evaluated by a our Microdata Release Panel. When the decision is made to grant access to the data, users will receive them through secure ftp server.","Yes","No","Ciarán Staunton","Christian Villum","45"
"e2f2b3bb-8e52-43ba-899b-17d3ac1908e4","global","2014-10-27T22:38:47","2014","ls","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.geopostcodes.com/Lesotho",,,,,"https://lso.geonamebase.com/","Yes","Yes","Changed submission drastically, because it was made based on third-party data (not from government source). After researching for gov source with no results (including the Lesotho Post website, https://lesothopost.org.ls/), I changed 'Does data exist' to 'No'.","There are non-government resources available only - for instance https://www.geopostcodes.com/Lesotho and https://lso.geonamebase.com/. Data seemingly does not exist.","Yes","No","Ciarán Staunton","Christian Villum","0"
"f0544bb1-a6e6-412e-8386-9f05da634098","global","2014-10-27T22:24:24","2014","ls","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.iec.org.ls/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=64&Itemid=11",,,,"2012 Elections Results by Constituency","Lesotho Electoral Commission","Yes","Yes","Submission largely correct, but I changed 'openly licensed' from 'Unsure' to 'No' because there is no clear license. Also changed the comment from simply being pasted content of https://www.iec.org.ls/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=22&Itemid=29 into being brief summary of the submission. ","Election data are available per constituency, but in pdf-format and without clear license. Latest update is 2012.","Yes","No","Ciarán Staunton","Christian Villum","45"
"cf00eb4f-571e-48aa-b4bd-64dfda135920","global","2014-10-27T22:02:14","2014","ls","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://www.lesotholii.org/search",,,,"Lesotho Legal Information Institute","https://www.lesotholii.org/indexpage/num_act","Yes","Yes","Submission largely correct, although I changed 'openly license' from 'Unsure' to 'No' since there is no visible license stated.","This information is not necessarily comprehensive, complete, accurate or up to date; sometimes linked to external sites over which LesLII has no control and for which LesLII assumes no responsibility; not professional or legal advice (if you need specific advice, you should always consult a suitably qualified professional).","Yes","No","Ciarán Staunton","Christian Villum","35"
"0a589f87-32dd-47f6-ad64-c122fdabb1b6","global","2014-10-27T13:06:51","2014","nz","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.legislation.govt.nz","HTML,PDF,XML","https://www.legislation.govt.nz/about.aspx#copyright",,,"Parlimentary Counsel Office","Yes","Yes","XML format a bonus but hard to find.","Legislation is available in machine readable format (XML) and in bulk (all publicly available legislation) here: https://www.legislation.govt.nz/subscribe ","Yes","Yes","Mark Heseltine","Alex Sadleir","100"
"e548bf0a-d84b-4e10-b92c-6d9038b91189","global","2014-10-27T13:01:06","2014","nz","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.stats.govt.nz/browse_for_stats.aspx","csv,Excel,SDMX","https://www.stats.govt.nz/about_us/about-this-site/copyright-terms-of-use.aspx",,,"Statistics New Zealand","Yes","Yes","Human readable overview with stat.nz machine readable data browsing tool"," A lot of data sets are available from the NZ.Stat interface at https://nzdotstat.stats.govt.nz/wbos/Index.aspx","Yes","Yes","Mark Heseltine","Alex Sadleir","100"
"dad32a82-26c4-4b92-8058-a2f42e6a612d","global","2014-10-27T12:47:39","2014","nz","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://www.mfe.govt.nz/more/environmental-reporting/air/air-domain-report-2014/data-and-supporting-information","Excel",,,"Data files used in 2014 Air domain report","Ministry for the Environment","Yes","Yes","Data available under Crown Copyright https://www.mfe.govt.nz/about-site/copyright","Air quality data is gathered by regional councils and aggregated by Ministry for the Environment annually. Some councils, such as ECAN, make realtime air quality data available (see https://data.ecan.govt.nz/Catalogue/Search?Query=&CollectionId=4 ).
The 2014 report ""includes data to 2012. Data for 2013 was not available for all our national indicators and case studies, or could not be collected, validated, and analysed in time to meet our publication schedule.""","Yes","No","Mark Heseltine","Alex Sadleir","60"
"cb328085-a396-4d33-8195-0004ddb79c59","global","2014-10-27T12:07:43","2014","nz","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure",,"Yes","https://www.business.govt.nz/businessdata","XML",,,,"business.govt.nz","Yes","Yes","Term of use didn't indicate any open license. "," Data available via web services. Registration required.
A human-readable web interface is also available at https://www.business.govt.nz/companies/app/ui/pages/companies/search
","Yes","No","Mark Heseltine","Mor Rubinstein","60"
"122441d8-b2a7-4fc4-9b74-6ea9e94ec09d","global","2014-10-27T11:45:49","2014","nz","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.treasury.govt.nz/budget/2014/data","Excel","https://www.treasury.govt.nz/aboutthissite/crowncopyright",,"Budget 2014 Data from the Estimates of Appropriations 2014/15","The Treasury","Yes","Yes","Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 New Zealand licence. "," ","Yes","Yes","Mark Heseltine","Alex Sadleir","100"
"c9ca391f-e9d4-4177-aebc-4e89685c7013","global","2014-10-27T11:39:00","2014","nz","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.electionresults.govt.nz/electionresults_2014/e9/html/statistics.html","CSV,HTML,Excel","https://www.electionresults.govt.nz/about.html",,"Votes for Registered Parties by Electorate","Electoral Commission","Yes","Yes","Reuse with attribution, csv format = thumbs up!","https://www.electionresults.govt.nz/about.html allows reuse with attribution, but this isn't obvious with the All Rights Reserved claim in the footer of the homepage. ","Yes","Yes","Mark Heseltine","Alex Sadleir","100"
"3d87585d-03a5-4a01-b1dd-e729660a6c38","global","2014-10-27T09:43:43","2014","ls","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"There are no timetables for public transport sector as the transport is informally operated. There are no passenger trains in Lesotho so there is no data for trains. ","Yes","No","anonymous","Emma Beer","0"
"748987b8-c043-4e13-b727-90e8acbc95e9","global","2014-10-19T10:10:57","2014","ba","emissions","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No","https://www.sllist.ba/glasnik/glavni%20meni2014.htm",,,,,"Private web dev/design company from Serbia","Yes","Yes","The submission is accepted. As far as the reviewer knows, the official data is not available.","Official data does not exist.","Yes","No","anonymous","Stevan Gostojić","0"
"db6cee01-b806-4790-ac2b-0fe78e46a09c","global","2014-10-19T09:42:27","2014","ba","timetables","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes","Submission accpted.","There are numerous web sites with information about municipal bus timetables (most outdated) as well as train timetables at the level of Federacija Bosne i Hercegovine and Republika Srpska. However, there is no centralized data supplied by the national government.","Yes","No","anonymous","Stevan Gostojić","0"
"6fcbc0bf-517f-4b92-8f89-9089fa59bccc","global","2014-04-14T09:58:27","2014","bt","timetables","Yes","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","Rufus Pollock","Rufus Pollock","5"
"f4300a2d-04e3-4d62-aa04-d448e7261889","global","2013-10-24T10:40:42","2013","gi","emissions","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"It is uncertain if the data exists. ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","0"
"e71e94ef-14f5-4ff9-a257-61cc5ae09e83","global","2013-10-24T10:39:54","2013","gi","map","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"It is uncertain if the data exists. ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","0"
"b5bb2a8e-0003-4a09-9dac-1ae42f63b7b0","global","2013-10-23T15:15:59","2013","mt","spending","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.nso.gov.mt/statdoc/document_view.aspx?id=3631&backurl=/themes/theme_page.aspx","Excel",,"2013",,,"Yes","Yes",,"Malta's national statistics office provides information related to the economic and financial status of the country. Quarterly accounts exist that provide information re monthly expenditure and revenue. ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","60"
"3841615e-d71d-47ad-b036-8c3ba69a819d","global","2013-10-23T14:42:53","2013","pl","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://ems.ms.gov.pl/krs/wyszukiwaniepodmiotu",,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"Business registry only available to query online (with Captcha).
PDF downloads of individual entries ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","35"
"ba44fd6e-cdc7-4dbb-8202-3d8b5f180121","global","2013-10-23T14:35:04","2013","pl","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.rozklad-pkp.pl/bin/query.exe/pn?",,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"Link to national rail service. Can't download and you will need written consent to use the data for anything else besides using the website according to Terms of Use (https://rozklad-pkp.pl/hafas-res/img/Regulamin.pdf). ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","35"
"7b1f9dff-3f11-4a77-8512-a770d33557ee","global","2013-10-23T14:20:30","2013","pl","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.dziennikustaw.gov.pl/Stronaglowna.aspx",,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"No copyright on laws; interpreted that as open license ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","75"
"cd4be8e7-5334-4037-890f-3df97fc2e1d0","global","2013-10-21T21:49:27","2013","pl","spending","Yes","Yes","No","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,,"Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","10"
"1b1bf654-cd45-44f1-8cf0-9919f3b8a016","global","2013-10-17T23:22:46","2013","mt","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://www.nso.gov.mt/statbase/data_table_catalogue.aspx","Excel",,"2013",,,"Yes","Yes",," ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","60"
"e764e437-4f72-4275-ba6f-04d7a45e6565","global","2013-10-17T23:16:57","2013","mt","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.arriva.com.mt","PDF",,"May 2012",,,"Yes","Yes",," ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","45"
"4bafa0f1-f2e7-440b-a6ad-9123aa35257f","global","2013-10-12T09:03:45","2013","mt","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.visitmalta.com/en/malta-maps","PDF",,,,,"Yes","Yes",," ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","55"
"2510c65f-3440-4277-81b3-48d978edb8b7","global","2013-10-12T08:55:03","2013","mt","emissions","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.enemalta.com.mt/emissions/","PDF",,,,,"Yes","Yes",," ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","45"
"8c3434bc-5fc4-4f3a-99d6-00a0c99e0531","global","2013-10-12T08:52:49","2013","mt","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.justiceservices.gov.mt/LOM.aspx?pageid=27&mode=chrono","PDF",,,,,"Yes","Yes",," ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","45"
"52c14aaf-8baa-45cc-b8e2-63010993a62e","global","2013-10-12T08:44:04","2013","mt","postcodes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://postcodes.maltapost.com/","HTML",,"2013",,,"Yes","Yes",," ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","45"
"31b1e378-f712-4135-9bd9-c30249ffa7b6","global","2013-10-12T08:32:34","2013","mt","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Yes",,"Yes","https://mfin.gov.mt/en/The-Budget/Pages/The-Budget-2013.aspx","PDF",,"2012",,,"Yes","Yes",," ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","55"
"e4df4401-bb86-4fcd-b5c3-ac13398c6af7","global","2013-10-12T08:24:27","2013","mt","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No",,"Yes","https://gov.mt/en/Government/Open%20Data/Electoral%20Commission/Pages/Open-Data-%28Beta%29-General-Elections-2013.aspx","Excel",,"2013",,,"Yes","Yes",," ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","60"
"47bd345d-2bdc-49ac-8547-f7c7de9071d5","global","2013-10-09T20:54:20","2013","ye","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"No","https://www.mof.gov.ye/issues/financial-statistics-issues.html","PDF",,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"Data about economics indicators is available in the official website of Ministry of Finances (https://www.mof.gov.ye/issues/financial-statistics-issues.html). Demographic indicators are available in the official website of Ministry of Public Health and Population (https://www.moh.gov.ye/arabic/reports_statistical.html). But these are not up to date (only 2003). ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","35"
"b67e74d9-1fde-4218-b546-5072b0766508","global","2013-10-09T20:50:30","2013","ye","elections","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"Seems that data is not available online in an official website.
Aggregate data at high level available in https://www.electionguide.org/countries/id/237/ (third party website).","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","5"
"4df54ff8-fddd-41ce-b9f6-1a08dc1e5e5d","global","2013-10-09T10:58:16","2013","gi","spending","Yes","Yes","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes",," ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","10"
"cf52ff48-929f-4d33-adc6-4bf19cf6113c","global","2013-10-09T10:56:19","2013","gi","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.gibraltar.gov.gi/public-finances","PDF; HTML",,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"https://www.gibraltar.gov.gi/public-finances summary:
https://www.gibraltar.gov.gi/images/stories/PDF/pressoffice/pressreleases/2013/442-2013.pdf budget 2013 address in parliament:
https://www.parliament.gi/chief-minister-s-budget-address-2013 ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","45"
"8ce9762c-f503-4925-8e05-6b2912420c4d","global","2013-10-09T10:36:41","2013","gi","timetables","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.gibraltarbuscompany.gi/routes.php","PDF",,,,,"Yes","Yes",," ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","45"
"ac0860cd-f8fc-4820-8f4f-cc5682bd7572","global","2013-10-09T10:34:33","2013","gi","postcodes","No","No","No","No","No","No","No",,"No",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"Gibraltar does not use a typical postcodes/zipcodes system ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","0"
"052eed50-d44b-4b04-9c7a-774cf8fb3ad7","global","2013-10-08T17:35:03","2013","ye","emissions","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"Impossible to find such data online. ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","0"
"1f4c32a6-64ca-460d-bf67-b23d3f8a0b5d","global","2013-10-08T17:34:23","2013","ye","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"Impossible to find such data online. ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","0"
"f5635262-623b-4789-bab7-b5a410ed6303","global","2013-10-08T14:05:42","2013","ye","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.mof.gov.ye/budget/general-budget.html","PDF",,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"Government Budgets at high level (from 2007 to the last one for 2014) are published in PDF format ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","45"
"303ff366-7821-4970-9c88-245e0ab29ad4","global","2013-10-08T13:44:34","2013","ye","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Unsure","https://www.moit.gov.ye/search/","HTML",,"Dec 2012",,,"Yes","Yes",,"Data available by a search request (arabic language) in HTML format. ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","35"
"120bd1c7-ef60-4971-b623-4d516d7ac75c","global","2013-10-05T16:26:22","2013","pl","budget","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"No","https://otwartedane.pl/72","CSV",,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"A lot of budget & spending datasets from 2007-2012. The application doesn't seem reliable, though - hangs and crashes a lot, only beta version available. Doesn't work well with Internet Explorer, suggest using Chrome to view. Link is to 2011 central budget. ","Yes","Yes","anonymous","anonymous","90"
"25e6d899-6cf9-4c7c-819f-257be2d29ca8","global","2013-10-04T23:43:11","2013","gi","companies","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.companieshouse.gi/namesearchauth.html","HTML",,,,,"Yes","Yes",," ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","30"
"b0014986-680c-4782-b48a-a5b79b517321","global","2013-10-04T23:35:10","2013","gi","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.parliament.gi/history/parliamentary-election-results","PDF",,,,,"Yes","Yes",," ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","45"
"7b264329-f4fa-4bc3-8649-918452806aca","global","2013-10-04T23:30:21","2013","gi","statistics","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.gibraltar.gov.gi/statistics","XLS; PDF",,,,,"Yes","Yes",," ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","45"
"8d4243ed-2bd8-48f6-afb0-7367b0d76ecc","global","2013-10-04T23:18:47","2013","gi","legislation","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","No","No",,"Yes","https://www.gibraltarlaws.gov.gi/search_form.php","PDF",,,,,"Yes","Yes",," ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","45"
"5300d32b-1565-439a-85f2-09c24d489762","global","2013-10-02T15:06:11","2013","pl","postcodes","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure","https://sejmometr.pl/kody_pocztowe","HTML",,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"The site https://sejmometr.pl/kody_pocztowe provides a paged, HTML list of (groups of) postal codes and the towns to which they relate. It does not provide the ""geolocation"" in terms of geospatial co-ordinates of individual postal codes as required in the definition. The site has an apparently open licence, but the data is not downloadable in bulk and is not (easily) machine readable. ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","0"
"3d72f8e2-95ed-498b-b745-ec6a29992506","global","2013-10-02T08:56:16","2013","pl","map","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Unsure",,"Yes","https://openstreetmap.org.pl/",,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"Opensource street map. ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","60"
"a86833df-1180-4b81-8b14-61f353e268e2","global","2013-10-02T08:41:17","2013","pl","emissions","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure","Unsure",,"Unsure",,,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"Very hard to find any relevant data released by the government. ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","0"
"79bdc7e8-f1fa-493e-8686-e4c506becce9","global","2013-10-02T08:07:10","2013","pl","statistics","Yes","Yes","Unsure","Unsure","Yes","Unsure","Yes",,"Yes","https://www.stat.gov.pl/gus",,,,,,"Yes","Yes",,"Not all data is open and publicly available but the website itself is a good resource. ","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","45"
"3d795f7d-6b6e-4a4d-82e1-a76e77d365b4","global","2013-10-02T07:56:28","2013","pl","elections","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes","Yes",,"Yes","https://pkw.gov.pl/",,,"Latest update in Sept, 2013",,,"Yes","Yes",," Very good source of open data, easy to navigate and process.","Yes","No","anonymous","anonymous","70"